Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010179112026
2026:GAU-AS:13070
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 2433 OF 2026
Asmina Begum
W/o Muzamil Hoque
Resident of Devpukhuri,
Pauripota under Orang Police
Statioon, Dist- Udalguri, Assam
Accused/ Petitioner
-VersusThe State of Assam
Represented by P. P. Assam.
……. Respondent
–BEFORE–
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR SHARMA
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. B. M. Choudhury, learned Senior
Counsel assisted by Mr. U. Choudhury
learned counsel.
For the Respondent(s) : Mr. P. Borthakur, learned Addl.P.P,
Assam.
Date on which judgment
is reserved
: 02.09.2026.
Date of pronouncement
of judgment
: 09.09.2026.
Whether the pronouncement
is of the operative part
of the judgment ?
: No.
Whether the full judgment
has been pronounced
: Yes.
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. B. M. Choudhury, learned Senior Counsel
assisted by Mr. U. Choudhury, learned counsel for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. P. Borthakur, learned Additional
Public Prosecutor for the State.
2.
This is an application under Section 483 of BNSS, 2023
for granting bail to the petitioner, namely, Asmina Begum,
in connection with Teok P. S. Case No. 73/2026 under
Sections 21(c)/ 25/ 27A/ 29(1) of the NDPS Act.
3.
The brief facts of the case, are that on 23.07.2026, the
informant, WSI Baby Neog, In-charge of Lahdoigarh Out Post,
lodged an F.I.R. before the Officer-in-Charge of Teok Police
Station, alleging, inter alia, that on 22.07.2026, at about 3:30
P.M., reliable source information was received at Lahdoigarh
Out Post to the effect that a red-coloured Maruti Bolero motor
vehicle
bearing
Registration
No.
AS-01-DP-7060
was
transporting a large quantity of narcotic drugs concealed
inside sealed soap cases.
4.
The said information was duly entered and registered
vide Lahdoigarh O.P. GDE No. 439 dated 22.07.2026.
Pursuant thereto, a police team headed by senior police
officers proceeded towards Meleng Meteli and conducted naka
checking/searching. During the course of the operation, the
afore-noted suspected vehicle was intercepted and searched
in the presence of independent witnesses after observing the
mandatory legal formalities.
5.
During the search, 29 (twenty-nine) soap cases were
allegedly recovered from the vehicle, each containing
transparent polythene packets filled with a brown-coloured
powdery substance suspected to be heroin. The substance
was weighed on a digital weighing machine in the presence of
the independent witnesses and was found to weigh 434.38
grams. The recovered contraband was thereafter duly packed,
sealed, labelled and seized under a proper seizure memo. The
entire search and seizure proceedings were also videographed
and recorded through the e-Sakshya system.
6.
In addition to the aforesaid contraband, the police also
seized the afore-noted vehicle and two mobile phones along
with the SIM cards allegedly belonging to the arrested person.
Upon lodgement of the aforesaid FIR, the case was
registered.
7.
The only submission made by learned Senior Counsel on
behalf of the petitioner is that the petitioner being a lady was
arrested after sunset without obtaining the permission of the
magistrate as required under section 46(5) of the BNSS and
thereby the police has acted in violation of the aforesaid
statutory provisions and having regard to the same the arrest
of the petitioner has been rendered illegal and accordingly
she is entitled to bail. It is further submitted that the
petitioner was brought to Tiok police station on the night of
22.07.2026 and therefore she was taken into police custody
then itself and kept in the lockout of Tiok police station
throughout the night of 22.07.2026. Later on she was shown
to have been formally arrested at 11.30 a.m on 23.07.2026 at
Tiok police station. It is further submitted that the sunset at
Jorhat, the place of arrest, occurred at 6:06 p.m. on
22.07.2026, whereas the time of arrest has been stated as
6:30 p.m. on the same date in the bail application and also
during the submissions advanced by the learned Senior
Counsel. Thus, the stated time of arrest was after sunset. In
this regard reference has been made to the decision of the
co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Dr. Sangeeta Dutta Vs.
State of Assam and Anr. reported in 2025 SCC Online
GAU 4847.
8.
Countering
the
aforesaid
submissions,
learned
Additional PP has submitted that the provisions of section
43(5) of the BNSS are only directory in nature and noncompliance with the same would not result in rendering the
arrest
illegal.
In
support
of
the
submission
learned
counsel has referred to a decision of the High Court of
Tripura, i.e., Anawora Begam vs. the State of Tripura in
Bail Application No. 137 of 2025 decided on 16.03.2026,
wherein the decisions of various high courts on this point
have been discussed and ultimately the said provision was
held to be in directory and it was held that non-compliance of
section 46(4) of the Cr.P.C corresponding to section 43(5) of
the BNSS would not confer an indivisible right upon the
accused to be released on bail on the same ground in every
case. At this stage it would be appropriate to reproduce
section 43(5) of the BNSS which reads as follows:
“43(5) Save in exceptional circumstances, no woman shall
be arrested after sunset and before sunrise, and where such
exceptional circumstances exist, the woman police officer
shall, by making a written report, obtain the prior
permission of the Judicial Magistrate of the first class within
whose local jurisdiction the offence is committed or the
arrest is to be made.”
9.
The word used herein is "arrest", whereas section
42(1)(d) of the NDPS Act provides for detention, search,
arrest etc. The said section reads as follows:
“42 (1)(d) detain and search, and, if he thinks proper,
arrest any person whom he has reason to believe to
have committed any offence punishable under this
Act:
[Provided that in respect of holder of a licence
for
manufacture
of
manufactured drugs or
psychotropic substances or controlled substances
granted under this Act or any rule or order made
thereunder, such power shall be exercised by an
officer not below the rank of sub-inspector:
Provided further that] if such officer has reason
to believe that a search warrant or authorisation
cannot be obtained without affording opportunity for
the concealment of evidence or facility for the escape
of an offender, he may enter and search such
building, conveyance or enclosed place at any time
between sunset and sunrise after recording the
grounds of his belief.”
10. From the above, it appears that the aforesaid provision
of the NDPS Act contemplates two forms of detention: first,
detention simpliciter, during which the petitioner is not
formally arrested and no memorandum of arrest is prepared;
and second, detention followed by formal arrest at a
subsequent stage, after the concerned officer arrives at the
requisite satisfaction or otherwise deems it appropriate to
formally arrest the accused.
11. The Hon’ble Apex Court had the occasion to consider
the
meaning
and
scope
of
the
expression
“arrest”
in Niranjan Singh & Anr. v. Prabhakar Rajaram Kharote
& Ors., reported in (1980) 2 SCC 559. In the said decision,
the Hon’ble Apex Court held that a person who is under the
control of the Court or is in the physical hold of an officer
exercising coercive authority is considered to be in custody for
the purposes of Section 439 of the Cr.P.C. Relevant paragraph
of the aforesaid judgment reads as under:
“7. When is a person in custody, within the meaning
of Section 439 CrPC? When he is in duress either
because he is held by the investigating agency or
other police or allied authority or is under the control
of the court having been remanded by judicial order,
or having offered himself to the court's jurisdiction and
submitted to its orders by physical presence. No
lexical dexterity nor precedential profusion is needed
to come to the realistic conclusion that he who is
under the control of the court or is in the physical hold
of an officer with coercive power is in custody for the
purpose of Section 439. This word is of elastic
semantics but its core meaning is that the law has
taken
control
of
the
person.
The
equivocatory
quibblings and hide-and-seek niceties sometimes
heard in court that the police have taken a man into
informal custody but not arrested him, have detained
him for interrogation but not taken him into formal
custody and other like terminological dubieties are
unfair evasions of the straightforwardness of the law.
We need not dilate on this shady facet here because
we are satisfied that the accused did physically
submit before the Sessions Judge and the jurisdiction
to grant bail thus arose.”
12. Relevant paragraphs of the judgment of the Tripura
High Court in Anawora Begam (Supra) reads as under:
“6) (i) Directorate of Enforcement vs. Subhash
Sharma, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 240 wherein an
LOC was issued by the Directorate of Enforcement to
the Bureau of Immigration and said Bureau of
Immigration detained the accused of said case at IGI
Airport on 4th March, 2022 and thereafter, physical
custody of the accused was handed over by Bureau of
Immigration at 11.00 hours on 5th March, 2022 to the
Directorate of Enforcement but his arrest was shown
at 1.15 hours on 6th March, 2022. Hon'ble Supreme
Court observed that the accused was not produced
before the nearest Magistrate within 24 hours from
11:00 am on 5th March, 2022 and therefore, held that
arrest of the accused was illegal as a result of
violation of Article 22(2) of the Constitution. In said
case, time of detention was not computed from 01.15
hours of 6th March, 2022 which was shown in the
arrest memo as time of arrest.
(iii) Dr. Sangeeta Dutta vs. State of Assam, rep.
by the Special PP, Assam and another, 2025 SCC
OnLine Gau 4847- In this case, allegation of the
accused was that she was actually arrested at 1:00
am in the night of 06.05.2023 but her formal arrest
was shown at 11:00 am on the following day and
such arrest was effected without obtaining prior
permission of any Judicial Magistrate. Further
grievance was also that ground of arrest was not
communicated to her or to her near relatives as
required under Sections 50 and 50A of Cr.P.C.
Gauhati High Court in this case on consideration of
the materials placed in said case held that Section 50
of Cr.P.C. was not complied with by the arresting
authority and therefore, violation of fundamental
rights guaranteed under Articles 21 and 22(1) gives a
strong cause or reason to the accused applicant to be
enlarged on bail. The High Court also observed in this
case that Section 50A, Cr.P.C. was also violated. It
was also further held that no permission from Judicial
Magistrate First Class was obtained before effecting
the arrest. The time of arrest in said case was also
treated to be 1:00 am on 06.05.2023. On that score,
the High Court further held that the arrest became
illegal for violation of provision of Section 46(4) of
Cr.P.C. and that violation of such statutory provision
gave the accused applicant to argue for bail as the
same had violated fundamental right of life and
liberty guaranteed under Articles 21 and 22(1) of the
Constitution of India.”
13. What follows from the above decisions, clearly, is that
the crucial factor is the point of time from which the petitioner
was no longer a free agent to move as he or she pleased.
That point evidently commences from the time the petitioner
is detained by an authority with coercive powers regardless of
whether any formal arrest has been made or not. In other
words the accused gets taken into custody which is nothing
but an another form of arrest without however following the
formalities like issuance of memorandum of arrest under
section 36 of the BNSS and other statutory notices under
section 47/48 of the BNSS. Therefore, for the purposes
of determining whether the petitioner was arrested before or
after sunset would be the point of time when she was under
effective detention. It is not disputed that the petitioner after
the apprehension of the vehicle was under the effective
custody of the police and was no longer free to move as she
pleased and her freedom of movement stood effectively
curtailed. Section 42(1)(d) of the NDPS Act makes it
abundantly clear that the authorized officer may firstly detain
a suspect and after being satisfied regarding the necessity of
arrest would make the formal arrest. This is so because in
case the search, pursuant to the detention yields no fruitful
result, the authorized officer would perhaps have no option
but to release the said suspect. But in the event that the
authorized officer deems it proper to make the formal arrest,
the point of time from which the arrest commences would
relate back to the point of time at which the suspect was first
detained. That much is evident from a reading of the
decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Niranjan Singh
(supra) as well as Subhash Sharma (supra). In the case of
Dr. Sangeeta Dutta (supra) cited on behalf of the
petitioner, the court had held the time of effective detention
of the petitioner during the midnight hours as the time of
arrest for the purpose of determining the question of violation
of the provisions of section 46(4) of the Cr.P.C/ 43(5) of the
BNSS, although she was shown to have been formally
arrested much later.
14. A perusal of the case record reveals that the date and
time of seizure has been recorded in the seizure list on
22.07.2026 at 6:05 p.m. Therefore, the detention of the
petitioner must necessarily have taken place sometime prior
to 6:05 p.m. on 22.07.2026, since the search and seizure
contemplated under Section 42(1)(d) of the NDPS Act is
preceded by the detention of the person concerned. Such
detention,
for
the
purposes
of
determining
the
commencement of the period of custody, is liable to be
treated as the time of arrest within the meaning of Section 46
read with Section 43(5) of the BNSS, or Section 46(4) of the
Cr.P.C., as the case may be. Consequently, the period of 24
hours prescribed for production of the arrestee before the
nearest Magistrate under Article 22(2) of the Constitution of
India would commence from the time of such detention,
excluding only the time necessarily required for travelling
from the place of arrest to the Court.
15. By the own submission of the learned Senior Counsel
for the petitioner, which fact has also been verified by this
Court, the time of sunset on 22.07.2026 was subsequent to
6:05/ 6:06 p.m., when the arrest of the petitioner was
effected. In view of the discussion hereinabove, it is,
therefore, evident that the petitioner was arrested before
sunset on 22.07.2026.
16. Therefore on the perusal of the factual aspects of the
case as revealed in the case diary as well as the contentions
on behalf of the petitioner herself, there appears to be no
force in the contentions of learned senior counsel for the
petitioner. In other words since the petitioner is found to have
been arrested before sunset, there is no scope for application
of section 43(5) of the BNSS mandating the permission of a
magistrate before the arrest of a woman is affected after
sunset.
17. Furthermore on a perusal of the material available in
the case diary, it prima facie appears that a commercial
quantity of contraband drugs were recovered from the
conscious possession of the petitioner and therefore the bar
imposed by section 37 of the NDPS Act is clearly attracted.
18. In view of the above the prayer for bail stands rejected
and the petition stands dismissed.
19. Send back the case diary.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review