Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/23
GAHC010151912026
2026:GAU-AS:16711
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Bail Appln./2064/2026
MD. MUJAFER HUSSAIN AND ANR
S/O - ABDUL HAKIM R/O - MOIJANG LAMKHAI, PS THOUBAL, DISTRICT
THOUBAL, MANIPUR
2: MD ACHOUBA
S/O - KAYAM UDDIN R/O - KEIRAO MAKTING MAKHA LEIKAI
PS IRILBONG
DISTRICT - IMPHAL EAST
MANIPU
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY THE LEARNED PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, ASSAM,
GUWAHATI.
Advocate for the Petitioner
: S KAUR, N NEOG,L BANIK
Advocate for the Respondent : PP, ASSAM,
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR SHARMA
ORDER
13.11.2026
Heard Mr. N.J. Dutta, learned counsel for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. M.P.
Goswami, learned Addl. PP for the State.
Page No.# 2/23
2.
This is an application filed under Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, praying for grant of bail in respect of the
accused/petitioners namely i) Md. Mujafer Hussain and ii) Md. Achouba in
connection with NDPS Case No. 104/2025 vide Dillai P.S. Case No. 40/2025 and
punishable under Sections 21(c)/25/29 of NDPS Act, 1985 pending before the
learned Sessions Special Judge, Karbi Anglong, Diphu.
3.
The two earlier bail applications, being Bail Application No. 2718 of 2025
and Bail Application No. 3667 of 2025, were rejected by this Court by orders
dated 17.10.2025 and 11.12.2025, respectively.
4.
The case of the petitioners is that on 31.07.2025, Munmi Chutia lodged a
written FIR at Dillai PS to the effect that on 30.07.2025, while conducting
routine Naka checking at NH 29 DillaiTiniali at about 10 P.M, one white Swift
vehicle bearing registration No. WB02AG 9632 which was moving towards Manja
from Dimapur side was signalled to stop. Accordingly, the driver of the vehicle
stopped for checking and while checking, it was suspected that there might be
some narcotics concealed inside the vehicle. Then, the matter was informed to
SSP, Karbi Anglong and SDPO Bokajan gave authorization to WSI (P) Munmi
Chutia for conducting search and seizure of narcotic psychotropic's substances if
found. After sometime, DYSP (P) Shri Arup Baishya, APS and staff arrived at the
Naka checking and in the presence of DYSP and Independent witnesses, the
vehicle was searched thoroughly. During the search, two packets of muddy
colour powdery substance suspected to be morphine were recovered weighting
total of 2.127 Kg which was kept concealed in between the fuel tank and upper
body inside one torn tube. The recovered substances were tested with the help
of DDT kit and found positive for morphine. After that recovered substances
Page No.# 3/23
were seized, packed and sealed in the presence of independent witnesses and
the driver and accompanied persons were apprehended namely 1. Achouba, son
of Kayam Uddin, resident of KeitaoMakhtingLeikai, P.S. Irilbung, District Imphal
East, Manipur and 2. Md. Mujafer Hussain, son of Abdul Hakim, resident of
Moijing Lamkhai, P.S. and District Thoubal, Manipur.
5.
The petitioners were produced before the Court of Judicial Magistrate First
Class, Bokajan, Assam on 31.07.2025 and forwarded to judicial custody and
since that day, they are in judicial custody.
6.
Mr. N.J. Dutta, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the instant
bail application has been preferred after rejection of the earlier two applications
on two additional grounds i.e., violation of Section 42 and Section 50 of the
NDPS Act.
7.
With reference to Section 42 of the NDPS Act, learned counsel for the
petitioners, by filing an additional affidavit, has referred to the search and
seizure list annexed thereto, wherein the date and time of seizure has been
shown as 30.07.2025 at 11:22 PM. However, referring to the Authorization
Letter under Section 41(2) of the NDPS Act issued by the Sub-Divisional Police
Officer, Balijan Sub-Division, Karbi Anglong, Assam, it has been pointed out that
the same was issued on 31.07.2025. This itself shows that the search of the
vehicle was carried out without any prior authorization, and therefore, the
provisions of Section 42 of the NDPS Act have been violated, which entitles the
petitioners to bail.
8.
In support of his aforesaid contention, learned counsel for the petitioner
Page No.# 4/23
has relied upon a decision of a Coordinate Bench of this Court in Abdul
Khalique v. State of Assam [GHHC010276042023] in connection with Bail
Appln./4465/2023, wherein by order dated 04.04.2024, the petitioner therein
was granted bail on the ground of violation of Section 42 by holding due
compliance with the same to be mandatory. In this regard, the learned
Coordinate Bench had relied upon the decision of the Apex Court in the case of
Sarija Banu Alias Janarthani Alias Janani &Anr. v. State through
Inspector of Police, reported in (2004) 12 SCC 266, wherein it was held as
follows:
“7. It is pertinent to note that in the bail application of the appellants, it
was alleged, that there was serious violation of Section 42 of the NDPS
Act. In the impugned order nothing is stated about the alleged violation of
Section 42, and it is observed that it was not necessary to consider such
violation at this stage. The compliance with Section 42 is mandatory and t
hat is a relevant fact which should have engaged the attention of the
Court while considering the bail application.”
9.
It is further submitted by the learned counsel that since the search was
carried out between sunset and sunrise, it was required of the police officer to
record the grounds of his belief for proceeding without authorisation or search
warrant and to communicate the same to his superior officer as per Proviso to
Section 42(2) of the ND&PS act, which he failed to do. In this regard, learned
counsel has relied upon Karnail Singh vs. State of Haryana reported in
(2009) 8 SCC 539.
10.
As regards compliance with Section 50 of the NDPS Act is concerned,
learned counsel has drawn the attention of the Court to the FIR wherein it has
been stated that for conducting personal search of the petitioners, option was
Page No.# 5/23
given whether they would like to be taken before a Magistrate or a Gazetted
Officer for conducting their personal search, or whether they would allow the
police to conduct their personal search on the spot; and that the personal
search of the petitioners was conducted in the presence of Shri Arup Baishya,
APS, Deputy Superintendent of Police, through H.G. Raju Timung, and during
their personal search, some mobile handsets, driving license, etc., were
recovered. Although no recovery of drugs was made upon such personal search,
the same having been recovered from their vehicle, it was nevertheless
incumbent upon the police to have strictly complied with the provisions of
Section 50 of the NDPS Act once the police proceed to conduct a personal
search of the accused.
11.
It is contended that the petitioners, besides being given the option to be
searched in the presence of a Magistrate or a Gazetted Officer, they were also
given a third option to be searched before the police, which has been held to be
illegal and not in accordance with Section 50 of the NDPS Act.
12.
In support of his aforesaid contentions, learned counsel has relied upon
the decision of the Apex Court in State of Rajasthan v. Parmanand &Anr.,
(2014) 5 SCC 345, as well as State of Himachal Pradesh v. Surat Singh,
2026 INSC 240. The sum and substance of the decision in Parmanand (supra)
is that regardless of the fact that no recovery of any contraband is made upon
personal search of the accused and the alleged recovery is made from any bag
being carried by the accused, compliance with Section 50 NDPS Act was
mandatory.
13.
Finally, it has been urged that the petitioner has spent more than a year
Page No.# 6/23
behind bars, and although the trial is underway since the last two months, no
witnesses have turned up, and therefore, also the petitioner is entitled to be
granted bail because of long incarceration.
14.
Per contra, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor submits that Section
42 of the NDPS Act would not be attracted in the facts of the present case
inasmuch as this is a case of chance recovery. As is evident from the FIR itself,
there was no prior information available with the informant and the recovery
was made in the course of routine naka checking. Therefore, since the recovery
was made while it was in transit, it is Section 43 of the NDPS Act that would be
applicable, and therefore, alleged non-compliance with Section 42 of the NDPS
Act is of no consequence.
15.
In support of his aforesaid contention, learned Additional Public
Prosecutor has referred to a decision of a Coordinate Bench of this Court in
Kumarjit Deb v. State of Assam [GHHC010194222024] in connection
with Bail Appln. 1737/2024 wherein the learned Coordinate Bench in the
aforesaid decision has held as follows:
“20. Though, in view of the observations made by the Apex Court in the
case of “Boota Singh and Ors –Vs- State of Haryana” (supra), this Court is of
the opinion that a private (Wagon-R) car may not be regarded as a “public
place” within the meaning of section 43 of the NDPS Act, 1985. However, the
submissions made by the learned Additional Public Prosecutor to the effect that
the seizure was made while the contraband was in transit is relevant and if the
seizure is made in transit, the seizure would be regarded as a seizure made
under Section 43 of the NDPS Act, 1985 and in that event, in light of the
observations of the Apex Court in the case of “State of Haryana –Vs- Jarnail
Singh and Ors.”, the procedural requirement contemplated by the proviso to
Page No.# 7/23
Section 42 of the NDPS Act, need not to be followed.
21.
Regarding the submission of the learned senior counsel for the
petitioner that the word “transit” appearing in Section 43 of the NDPS Act, 1985
cannot be read on a standalone basis and it has to be read along with the word
“any public place”, I am unable to persuade myself. In the Section 43 of the
NDPS Act, 1985, the legislature has used the word “or” in between the word
“any public place” and “in transit”. It has not used the word “and” between said
phrases. The word “or” is a disjunctive word and where a statutory provision is
clear and unambiguous the word “or” cannot be read as “and” by applying the
principle of reading down.
22. The word “transit” has been defined in the Black Laws Dictionary
(11th edition) as “the transportation of goods or person from one place to
another”. If we take that meaning of the word transit in this case, it would
appear that in the instant case, the contraband was carried from Badarpur to
Patharkhandi and it was seized at Karimganj Bypass Road at National Highway
near Karimganj Bypass Road while the contraband was “in transit”.
23. Thus, even if the seizure from a Maruti Wagon-R car in the instant
case may not be regarded as a seizure at “a public place”, however, as the
contraband was seized while it was in transit, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the seizure in this case appears to have been made under Section
43 of the NDPS Act, 1985. Hence, as per the observations made by the Apex
Court in the case of “State of Haryana –Vs- Jarnail Singh and Ors.”(supra), there
may not be any requirement of complying with the procedural safeguards as
provided in Section 42 of the NDPS Act, 1985.”
16. Learned Additional Public Prosecutor has also contended that even if for the
sake of argument Section 42 of the NDPS Act is assumed to be attracted, that is
a question to be decided at the time of trial; and in this regard, reliance has
been placed on the decision of the three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court in
Union of India through Narcotic Control Bureau Versus Md. Nawaz
Khan in Criminal Appeal No. 1043 of 2021, decided on 22.09.2021,
Page No.# 8/23
wherein it has been held as follows:
“28. Further, it was held that the issue of whether there was compliance of the
procedure laid down under Section 42 of the NDPS Act is a question of fact. The
decision in Karnail Singh (supra) was recently followed by this Court in Boota
Singh v. State of Haryana 2021 SCC OnLine SC 32429.
17.
It was further observed that in the complaint that was filed on 16 October
2019 it is alleged that at about 1400 hours on 26 March 2019, information was
received that between 1500-1700 hours on the same day, the three accused
persons would be reaching Uttar Pradesh. The complaint states that the
information was immediately reduced to writing. Therefore, the contention that
Section 42 of the NDPS Act was not complied with is prima facie misplaced. The
question is one that should be raised in the course of the trial.”
18.
It is submitted that the decision in Md. Nawaz Khan (Supra), being that of
a three-Judge Bench, would override the decision in Sarija Banu (supra), which
was a decision of a two-Judge Bench.
19.
As regards violation of Section 50 of the NDPS Act, it is submitted that
Section 50 clearly provides the options of the accused being searched before a
Magistrate or a Gazetted Officer, and if the accused so prefers, before the police
officer himself, and therefore there is no violation of the said provision and
moreover, since no recovery was made from the person of the petitioners,
Section 50 NDPS Act, is clearly inapplicable. Furthermore, the trial of the case is
proceeding satisfactorily and there is no inordinate delay warranting the release
of the petitioners on bail, particularly having regard to the fact that a huge
Page No.# 9/23
quantity of contraband was recovered from the petitioners and no satisfaction
as required under Section 37 of the NDPS Act can be said to be warranted.
20.
I have given my anxious consideration to the rival submissions.
21.
As per allegation, the recovery of the commercial quantity of contraband
was made from the private vehicle of the petitioners who were travelling
therein. Although it has been held by the Apex Court in Boota Singh (supra) that
a private vehicle cannot be regarded as a public conveyance for the purpose of
Section 43, as explained by the learned Coordinate Bench of this Court in
Kumarjit Deb (supra), the recovery having been made upon search of the
private vehicle while in transit, Section 43 of the NDPS Act must be held to be
applicable, and in this regard, I am in complete agreement with the view of the
learned Coordinate Bench. Further to that, I also find sufficient force in the
submission of learned Additional Public Prosecutor that since the recovery was
not made on the basis of any prior information or personal knowledge of the
informant, the provisions of Section 42 would not be attracted as it is a case of
chance recovery. The Hon’ble Apex Court in Karnail Singh (Supra) has held:
“26.The material difference between the provisions of Sections 42
and 43 of the NDPS Act is that Section 42 requires recording of
reasons for belief and for taking down of information received in
writing with regard to the commission of an offence before conducting
search and seizure, Section 43 does not contain any such provision
and as such while acting under Section 43 of the Act, the empowered
officer has the power of seizure of the article, etc. and arrest of a
person who is found to be in possession of any narcotic drug or
Page No.# 10/23
psychotropic substance in a public place where such possession
appears to him to be unlawful.”
22.
As already discussed, even if the vehicle in transit was a private one,
Section 43 would be attracted when the recovery is made while the vehicle is in
transit and Karnail Singh (Supra) does not hold to the contrary.
23.
In State of Punjab vs. Balbir Singh, the Apex Court held:
“25. The question considered above arise frequently before the
trial courts. Therefore we find it necessary to set out our conclusions
which are as follows :
(1) If a police officer without any prior information as contemplated
under the provisions of the NDPS Act makes a search or arrests a
person in the normal course of investigation into an offence or
suspected offences as provided under the provisions of CrPC and when
such search is completed at that stage Section 50 of the NDPS Act
would not be attracted and the question of complying with the
requirements thereunder would not arise.
If during such search or arrest there is a chance recovery of any
narcotic drug or psychotropic substance then the police officer, who is
not empowered, should inform the empowered officer who should
thereafter proceed in accordance with the provisions of the NDPS Act.
If he happens to be an empowered officer also, then from that stage
onwards, he should carry out the investigation in accordance with the
other provisions of the NDPS Act.
(2-A)
(5) On prior information the empowered officer or authorised officer
while acting under Sections 41(2) or 42 should comply with the
provisions of Section 50 before the search of the person is made and
such person should be informed that if he so requires, he shall be
produced before a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate as provided
thereunder. It is obligatory on the part of such officer to inform the
Page No.# 11/23
person to be searched. Failure to inform the person to be searched
and if such person so requires, failure to take him to the Gazetted
Officer or the Magistrate, would amount to non-compliance of Section
50 which is mandatory and thus it would affect the prosecution case
and vitiate the trial. After being so informed whether such person
opted for such a course or not would be a question of fact.
24.
The same principle would be applicable to Section 42 of the ND&PS Act as
well.
25.
It is also to be noticed that although the written authorization is dated
31.07.2025, it is stated in the FIR that authorization over phone was given to
the informant on 30.07.2025 itself and a perusal of Section 41(2) of the NDPS
Act does not seem to insist on written authorization. Be that as it may, in view
of the aforesaid finding regarding non-applicability of Section 42 of the NDPS
Act to the facts of the present case, I do not find force in the submission of
learned counsel for the petitioners in this regard.
26.
We may now take up the contention regarding violation of Section 50 of
the NDPS Act. It is not in dispute that no recovery was made from the personal
search of the petitioners and the alleged recovery was made from the vehicle in
which they were travelling. The law in this regard as laid down by the Hon’ble
Apex Court may therefore be discussed at length.
27.
In Ranjan Kumar Chadha vs. State of Himachal Pradesh reported in
2023 SCC OnLine SC 1262, reference was made to the three-Judge Bench
decision of the Apex Court in State of Himachal Pradesh vs. Pawan Kumar
reported in (2005) 4 SCC 350, and it was observed as follows:
Page No.# 12/23
“96. What is most important to note in Pawan Kumar (supra) is that the
search was not only of the bag, but also of the person of the accused, however,
the contraband was recovered only from the bag and not from the person of the
accused therein. What we are trying to highlight is that although in Pawan
Kumar (supra) the search was of the accused as well as the bag, yet since the
recovery of the contraband was only from the bag, this Court took the view that
Section 50 would have no application.
101. Pawan Kumar (supra) was also relied upon in Jarnail Singh
v. State of Punjab reported in (2011) 3 SCC 521. In the said case,
opium was recovered from a bag which the accused was carrying.
Section 50 was held to be not applicable as accused was not
searched. It was held that:“16. This apart, it is accepted that the narcotic/opium, i.e., 1 kg. and
750 grams was recovered from the bag (thaili) which was being
carried by the appellant. In such circumstances, Section 50 would
not be applicable. The aforesaid Section can be invoked only in
cases where the drug/narcotic/NDPS substance is recovered as a
consequence of the body search of the accused. In case, the
recovery of the narcotic is made from a container being carried by
the individual, the provisions of Section 50 would not be attracted.”
102. In Suresh v. State of Madhya Pradesh reported in
(2013) 1 SCC 550, illicit articles were recovered from the
polythene bags placed in a vehicle found to be in the
possession of the accused person upon their personal
search. This Court held that though the requirement of
Page No.# 13/23
Section 50 was not complied with qua the personal search
of the accused, yet the provision was inapplicable qua the
recovery made from the vehicle. Therefore, this Court gave
a restricted interpretation to Section 50 and held as under:“19. Though a portion of the contraband (opium) was recovered
from the vehicle for which Section 50 is not applicable, if we exclude
the quantity recovered from the vehicle, the remaining would not
come within the mischief of “commercial quantity” for imposition of
such conviction and sentence. Taking note of the length of period in
prison and continuing as on date and in view of non-compliance with
sub-section (1) of Section 50 in respect of recovery of contraband
from the appellants, we set aside the conviction and sentence
imposed on them by the trial court and confirmed by the High
Court.”
105. However, in Dilip v. State of M.P. reported in (2007) 1
SCC 450, a contrary view was taken to that of Pawan Kumar
(supra). In the said case, Section 50 was not complied with
while conducting the search of the person and drugs were
recovered from the accused’s scooter. This Court while
acquitting the accused held that the recovery made from the
scooter ought to be inadmissible. It is pertinent to note that
in this case the judgement in Pawan Kumar (supra) was not
looked into. The Court held as under:“12. Before seizure of the contraband from the scooter, personal
search of appellants had been carried out and, admittedly, even at
Page No.# 14/23
that time the provisions of Section 50 of the Act, although required
in law, had not been complied with.
xxxx
15. Indisputably, however, effect of a search carried out in violation
of the provisions of law would have a bearing on the credibility of
the evidence of the official witnesses, which would of course be
considered on the facts and circumstances of each case.
16. In this case, the provisions of Section 50 might not have been
required to be complied with so far as the search of scooter is
concerned, but, keeping in view the fact that the persons of the
appellants were also searched, it was obligatory on the part of PW
10 to comply with the said provisions. It was not done.”
106. The decision of Dilip (supra) was relied upon in Union
of India v. Shah Alam reported in (2009) 16 SCC 644,
wherein packets of heroin were recovered from the
accused’s shoulder bag. This Court rejected the argument of
the State that Section 50 was not applicable as no further
recoveries were made from the person of the accused after
the recovery from the bag. Accordingly, the recovery was
held to be in violation of Section 50 and the accused’s
acquittal was upheld. It was held that:“15. The legal proposition advanced by Mr. Terdal, based on the
distinction between search of someone's person and the baggage
carried by him/her is unexceptionable but his submission is not
Page No.# 15/23
supported by the facts of this case. We have carefully gone through
the records of this case. From the evidence of the complainant, PW
1 and the seizure memo (fard baramdegi) Ext Ka-2 it is evident that
the two respondents were subjected to a body search in course of
which packets of heroin were found in the shoulder bags carried by
them and were recovered from there.
16. The facts of the case in hand are very close to another decision
of this Court in Dilip and Anr. v. State of M.P. where it was observed
in paragraphs 12, 15 and 16 as under: …
17. On the facts of the case we find that the alleged recovery
of heroin from the respondents was made in complete
violation of the provisions of Section 50 of the Act.”
107. A similar view was taken by a Division Bench of this Court in
Parmanand (supra). This Court was called upon to consider
whether Section 50 ought to apply when the search of the person
and his bag is carried out. This Court held that if the bag is
searched without searching the accused, then Section 50 would
have no application. However, as a corollary it was held that if
the bag carried by the accused is searched along with his search,
then Section 50 would be applicable. The relevant portion is as
under:“15. Thus, if merely a bag carried by a person is searched without there
being any search of his person, Section 50 of the NDPS Act will have no
application. But if the bag carried by him is searched and his person is
Page No.# 16/23
also searched, Section 50 of the NDPS Act will have application. In this
case, Respondent 1 Parmanand's bag was searched. From the bag, opium
was recovered. His personal search was also carried out. Personal search
of Respondent 2 Surajmal was also conducted. Therefore, in light of
judgments of this Court mentioned in the preceding paragraphs, Section
50 of the NDPS Act will have application.”
108. Parmanand (supra) was relied upon by a threeJudge Bench
in SK. Raju (supra).
109. Thus, one view which originated from Dilip (supra) and
relied upon in SK. Raju (supra) implied that if a person is
searched and along with him or her, his or her bag is also
searched, then the benefit of Section 50 should be extended
while conducting the personal search of the accused.
110. However, it is pertinent to note that although Pawan Kumar
(supra) has been referred to and considered in SK. Raju (supra)
yet, the Court in SK. Raju (supra) overlooked the fact that in
Pawan Kumar (supra) also the search was not only of the person
of the accused but also of his bag. Even in such circumstances,
the larger Bench in Pawan Kumar (supra) took the view that
Section 50 would not apply if nothing incriminating is recovered
from the person of the accused. Thus, there is an apparent
conflict between the two decisions. Section 50 not applicable
when recovery made from bag, conveyance, etc.
111. A three-Judge Bench in the State of Punjab v. Baljinder Singh
Page No.# 17/23
reported in (2019) 10 SCC 473 considered the question:“8. … If a person found to be in possession of a vehicle containing
contraband is subjected to personal search, which may not be in conformity
with the requirements under Section 50 of the Act; but the search of the vehicle
results in recovery of contraband material, which stands proved independently;
would the accused be entitled to benefit of acquittal on the ground of noncompliance of Section 50 of the Act even in respect of material found in the
search of the vehicle?”
113. The Court went on to hold that Section 50 would be applicable
only to the personal searches and not to the searches of vehicles or
bags. This was in line with the ratio laid down in Pawan Kumar (supra)
and Baldev Singh (supra). This Court held that:“15. As regards applicability of the requirements under Section 50 of the
Act are concerned, it is well settled that the mandate of Section 50 of the Act is
confined to “personal search” and not to search of a vehicle or a container or
premises.
16. The conclusion (3) as recorded by the Constitution Bench in Para 57 of
its judgment in Baldev Singh clearly states that the conviction may not be based
“only” on the basis of possession of an illicit article recovered from personal
search in violation of the requirements under Section 50 of the Act but if there
be other evidence on record, such material can certainly be looked into.
114. It is pertinent to note here that in Baljinder Singh (supra) the
decision of SK. Raju (supra) was not looked into, however, the
decision in the case of Dilip (supra) was considered and held to be not
Page No.# 18/23
laying down the correct law on the ground that it did not consider the
decision of Baldev Singh (supra). This Court held that:“18. The decision of this Court in Dilip’s case, however, has not adverted
to the distinction as discussed hereinabove and proceeded to confer advantage
upon the accused even in respect of recovery from the vehicle, on the ground
that the requirements of Section 50 relating to personal search were not
complied with. In our view, the decision of this Court in said judgment in Dilip’s
case is not correct and is opposed to the law laid down by this Court in Baldev
Singh and other judgments.”
118. In Than Kunwar v. State of Haryana reported in (2020) 5 SCC
260, this Court took a different view. In the said case, the personal
search of the accused did not lead to any recovery. However, upon
conducting the search of the bag, opium was recovered. This Court
acknowledged the divergent views and noted that the decision of SK.
Raju (supra) was not considered while deciding Baljinder Singh
(supra). However, the latter was applied and was read to be in line
with Baldev Singh (supra). It was held that:“22. Having regard to the judgment by the three-Judge Bench, which
directly dealt with this issue, viz., the correctness of the view in Dilip (supra)
reliance placed by the appellant on para 16 may not be available. As already
noticed, we are not oblivious of the observation which has been made in the
other three-Judge Bench judgment of this Court in SK. Raju (supra), which it
appears, was not brought to the notice to the Bench which decided the case
later in Baljinder Singh (supra). We notice however that the later decision draws
inspiration from the Constitution Bench decision in Baldev Singh (supra). We
Page No.# 19/23
also notice that this is not a case where anything was recovered on the alleged
personal search. The recovery was effected from the bag for which it is settled
law that compliance with Section 50 of the Act is not required.”
119. Baljinder Singh (supra) was followed by this Court in Kallu Khan
v. State of Rajasthan reported in 2021 SCC OnLine 1223, wherein the
search and seizure was made from the accused’s motorcycle. This
Court while holding that the search cannot be said to be vitiated on
account of noncompliance of Section 50 as the same only applies to a
search of a person, held as under:“15. Simultaneously, the arguments advanced by the appellant regarding
non-compliance of Section 50 of NDPS Act is bereft of any merit because no
recovery of contraband from the person of the accused has been made to which
compliance of the provision of Section 50 NDPS Act has to follow mandatorily. In
the present case, in the search of motor cycle at public place, the seizure of
contraband was made, as revealed. Therefore, compliance of Section 50 does
not attract in the present case. It is settled in the case of Vijaysinh (supra) that
in the case of personal search only, the provisions of Section 50 of the Act is
required to be complied with but not in the case of vehicle as in the present
case, following the judgments of Surinder Kumar (supra) and Baljinder Singh
(supra). Considering the facts of this case, the argument of noncompliance of
Section 50 of NDPS Act advanced by the counsel is hereby repelled.”
120. Similarly, in a recent judgement, this Court in Dayalu Kashyap v.
State of Chhattisgarh reported in (2022) 12 SCC 398, held that an
extended view of Section 50 cannot be given to include a polythene
bag containing narcotics being carried by the accused. This Court
Page No.# 20/23
rejected the argument that as three options were given to the accused
to get himself searched from the officer which was in violation of
Section 50, the search conducted, even of the polythene bag, ought to
be vitiated. It was held as under:“4. The learned counsel submits that the option given to the appellant to
take a third choice other than what is prescribed as the two choices under subsection (1) of Section 50 of the Act is something which goes contrary to the
mandate of the law and in a way affects the protection provided by the said
section to the accused. To support his contention, he has relied upon the
judgment of State of Rajasthan v. Parmanand [State of Rajasthan v. Parmanand,
(2014) 5 SCC 345], more specifically, SCC para 19. The judgment in turn, relied
upon a Constitution Bench judgment of this Court in State of Punjab v. Baldev
Singh [State of Punjab v. Baldev Singh, (1999) 6 SCC 172] to conclude that if a
search is made by an empowered officer on prior information without informing
the person of his right that he has to be taken before a Gazetted Officer or a
Magistrate for search and in case he so opts, failure to take his search
accordingly would render the recovery of the illicit article suspicious and vitiate
the conviction and sentence of the accused where the conviction has been
recorded only on the basis of possession of illicit articles recovered from his
person. The third option stated to be given to the accused to get himself
searched from the Officer concerned not being part of the statute, the same
could not have been offered to the appellant and thus, the recovery from him is
vitiated.
5. In the conspectus of the facts of the case, we find that the recovery
was in a polythene bag which was being carried on a kanwad. The recovery was
Page No.# 21/23
not in person. The learned counsel seeks to expand the scope of the
observations made by seeking to contend that if the personal search is vitiated
by violation of Section 50 of the NDPS Act, the recovery made otherwise also
would stand vitiated and thus, cannot be relied upon. We cannot give such an
extended view as is sought to be contended by the learned counsel for the
appellant.”
124. While interpreting a provision, the Court only interprets the law and cannot
legislate it. If a provision of law is misused and subjected to the abuse of
process of law, it is for the legislature to amend, modify or repeal it, if deemed
necessary. (See : Rishabh Agro Industries Ltd. v. P.N.B. Capital Services Ltd.,
(2000) 5 SCC 515). The legislative casus omissus should not be supplied by
judicial interpretative process. The language of Section 50 of the NDPS Act is
plain and unambiguous. There is no scope of reading something into it as was
done in many decisions of this Court which we have referred to in our
judgment.
126. As such, there is no direct conflict between SK. Raju (supra) and Baljinder
Singh (supra). It is pertinent to note that in SK. Raju (supra) the contraband
was recovered from the bag which the accused was carrying, whereas in
Baljinder Singh (supra) the contraband was recovered from the vehicle. This
makes a lot of difference even while applying the concept of any object being
“inextricably linked to the person”. Parmanand (supra) relied upon the judgment
in Dilip (supra) while taking the view that if both, the person of the accused as
well as the bag is searched and the contraband is ultimately recovered from the
bag, then it is as good as the search of a person and, therefore, Section 50
would be applicable. However, it is pertinent to note that Dilip (supra) has not
Page No.# 22/23
taken into consideration Pawan Kumar (supra) which is of a larger Bench. It is
also pertinent to note that although in Parmanand (supra) the Court looked into
Pawan Kumar (supra), yet ultimately it followed Dilip (supra) and took the view
that if the bag carried by the accused is searched and his person is also
searched, Section 50 of the NDPS Act will have application. This is something
travelling beyond what has been stated by the large Bench in Pawan Kumar
(supra). Baljinder Singh (supra), on the other hand, says that Dilip (supra) does
not lay down a good law.”
28.
It is also to be noted that the decision of the three-Judge Bench in
Pawan Kumar (supra) was rendered prior in point of time of the decision of
the three-Judge Bench in SK Raju (supra) and, as observed in Than Kunwar
(supra), the decision in Baljinder Singh (supra) draws inspiration from the
unanimous five-Judge Bench decision in Baldev Singh (supra).
29.
In the light of the above exposition of the law, I am of the view that the
provisions of Section 50 of the NDPS Act are not attracted in a situation where a
search is carried out of the person of the accused as well as of any bag carried
by him or found in his possession, and the recovery of any contraband is made
only from the bag. Accordingly, there is no necessity for compliance with the
provisions of Section 50 of the NDPS Act.
30.
At this stage, it would be apt to note that in the earlier two bail
applications preferred by the petitioners, the aforesaid two grounds, though
could have been taken, were not pleaded or canvassed. Sections 42 and 50 of
the NDPS Act are statutory safeguards but do not enjoy the status of
fundamental rights or even constitutional rights. A fundamental/constitutional
Page No.# 23/23
right may be enshrined in the statute, for example, Article 22(1) of the
Constitution of India finding reflection in Section 47 of the BNSS. There is, of
course, no gainsaying the fact that all statutory provisions must conform to the
constitutional provisions, but it would be quite different to suggest that all
statutory safeguards are to be equated with one constitutional right or the
other. Therefore, it appears that it is otherwise also not open for the petitioners
to take up pleas of the present nature by submitting consecutive bail
applications when the same could have been taken up in the earlier
applications. This is necessary to note as multiplicity of litigation is against
public policy.
31. As regards the contention regarding prolonged incarceration, it appears that
the petitioners have spent about 1 year 3 months behind bars, but from the
record, it appears that the trial is progressing satisfactorily. Out of eight chargesheet listed witnesses, four witnesses have already been examined, the last
having been examined on 09.09.2026. There are bound to be days when for
various reasons, witnesses do not appear, which is why perhaps no witnesses
have been examined for the last two months, but in the facts and
circumstances, there does not appear to be any inordinate delay in the progress
of the trial warranting consideration of release of the petitioners on that ground
alone. In other words, there does not appear to be sufficient reason to form a
view that the right of the petitioners to a speedy trial has been violated.
32.
In view of the above discussion, the prayer for bail stands rejected and
the petition stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review