Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/8
GAHC010173792016
2026:GAU-AS:16768
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : MACApp./249/2016
MRS SAKIANA BIBI and ANR
W/O MD. BHABER ALI
2: MD. BHABER ALI
S/O LATE BHEBAI SK. BOTH THEM ARE R/O VILL. KODALDHOWA
P.O. and P.S. FAKIRAGRAM
DIST. KOKRAJHAR
ASSAM
VERSUS
ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD and 3 ORS
REPRESENTED DIVISIONAL MANAGER, BONGAIGAON DIVISION, P.O. and
P.S. BONGAIGAON, DIST. BONGAIGAON, ASSAM INSURER OF THE
VEHICLE BEARING REGD. NO. AS 17/B-2866 TRACTOR PIN NO.............
2:UNITED INDIA INS. CO. LTD.
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIVIONAL MANAGER
BONGAIGAON DIVISION
P.O. and P.S. BONGAIGAON
DIST. BONGAIGAON
ASSAM
3:LOKEN NATH
S/O LATE CHAITARAM NATH
R/O VILL. HELAGURI
P.O. BILASIPARA
DIST. DHUBRI
ASSAM.
4:MD. IFTIKAR RAHMAN
S/O KHORITULLA SK
Page No.# 2/8
R/O VILL. KODALDHOWA
P.O. and P.S. FAKIRAGRAM
DIST. KOKRAJHAR
BTC
ASSAM
PIN NO. .........
BEFORE
Hon’ble MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
Advocate for the Appellants
Advocates for the respondents
: Shri I.A. Talukdar.
: Shri S. Dutta (R-1)
Shri R. Goswami (R-2)
Shri A.T. Sarkar (R-4)
Date on which judgment is reserved
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:
03.11.2026
: 13.11.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the operative part of the judgment? : NA
Whether the full judgment has been pronounced? : Yes
Judgment & Order
The instant appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 has
been preferred in respect of a judgment dated 10.05.2016 passed by the
learned MACT, Kokrajhar in MAC Case No. 86/2014. By means of the appeal, the
appellants, who were the claimants before the learned Tribunal, are seeking
enhancement of the awarded amount.
2.
Before going into the grounds of appeal, it would be convenient if the facts
of the case are put in brief.
3.
As per the claim petition, on 01.01.2014 at about 1:40 P.M., the son of the
claimants (hereinafter interchangeably being used as appellants/claimants)-Siraj
Daula, was proceeding from Bangalipara towards Beltoli by the NH 31 as a
pillion rider of a vehicle (motorcycle) bearing registration no. AS-16/D-0231. A
Page No.# 3/8
rashly and negligently driven tractor bearing registration no.AS-17/B-2866 hit
the motorcycle from behind causing multiple grievous injuries to deceased. The
deceased was immediately shifted to the Bilasipara PHC for treatment and
thereafter, to the Lower Assam Hospital & Research Centre, Bongaigaon and
then to Guwahati, where he succumbed to the injuries on 06.01.2014. It may be
mentioned that the motorcyclist was also seriously injured in the accident.
4.
The claimants, who are the parents of the deceased had accordingly
instituted the claim. In the said proceeding, the Opposite Party nos. 1 and 2
(Oriental Insurance Company Limited) had contested the case. The learned
Tribunal framed the following issues:
1) Whether Siraj Daula succumbed to his injuries on 06.01.2014 for the
injury sustained on 01.01.2014 at about 1.40 pm when he was a pillion
rider in AS-16D/0231 he was hit by a rashly and negligently driven tractor
No. AS-17B/2866?
2) Whether the driver of the tractor was at fault?
3) Whether the claimant is entitled for compensation from the owner and
the insurer of the tractor and to what extent?
5.
The claimants had adduced evidence through 2 (two) nos. of witnesses.
PW1 is the claimant no. 1, who is the mother of the deceased and PW2 is the
person who had taken the deceased from the site of accident to the hospital.
The relevant documents are also proved.
6.
The learned Tribunal adopted the multiplier of 11 by referring to the age of
claimant no. 1, who was 51 years of age. Since the monthly income of the
deceased was not proved, the Tribunal took a notional income of Rs.3,000/- per
month and on that basis, awarded compensation of Rs.3,88,112/- (Rupees
Page No.# 4/8
Three Lakhs Eighty Eight thousand One Hundred Twelve) only together with the
interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing the case. The Award, however,
was passed against opposite party no. 3 - Laken Nath - the driver of the tractor.
The learned Tribunal further observed that the tractor, being primarily meant for
agricultural purposes, was covered by an insurance policy issued for that
purpose alone and at that time of the accident, the tractor was not being used
for agricultural purposes.
7.
Being aggrieved by the adequacy of the Award, the instant appeal has
been preferred.
8.
I have heard Shri I.A. Talukdar, learned counsel for the appellants. I have
also heard Shri S. Dutta, learned counsel for the respondent no.1, Shri R.
Goswami, learned counsel for the respondent no.2 and Shri A.T. Sarkar, learned
counsel for the respondent no. 4.
9.
Shri Talukdar, the learned counsel for the appellants, has submitted that
the compensation is wholly inadequate. He submits that although a sum of
Rs.66,112/- (Rupees Sixty Six Thousand One Hundred and Twelve) only has
been granted under the head of medical expenses, the actual medical expenses
incurred were about Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees One Lakh) only. He further submits
that no compensation has been granted under the Head of “Love and Affection”.
10.
Shri Talukdar, the learned counsel has also invited the attention of the
Court to the fact that in respect of the motorcycle rider, a separate case was
instituted in which the same Tribunal had granted an award to be paid by the
insurance company of the tractor. In the instant case, however, the liability has
been fastened on the owner of the tractor without any reasons, which, he
submits, would itself render the release of the amount a difficult task. He
Page No.# 5/8
further submits that the conventional Heads, namely Loss of Estate, Loss of
Consortium and other Heads have not been properly taken into consideration by
the learned Tribunal. He submits that the impugned award requires interference
and is liable to be enhanced.
11.
Per Contra, Shri Dutta, the learned counsel for respondent no. 1 has
submitted that there is no error in the evaluation or assessment of the medical
expenses. He submits that medical vouchers and bills were proven only to the
extent of Rs. 66,112/- (Rupees Sixty Six Thousand One Hundred and Twelve)
only and that the learned Tribunal accordingly granted the amount.
12.
The learned counsel, however fairly submits that certain aspects laid
down by a Five Judge Bench in the landmark decision in National Insurance
Co. Ltd v. Pranay Sethi [2017 (16) SCC 680] do not appear to have been
taken in consideration by the learned Tribunal. He has also not disputed the
factual position that, so far as the owner of the motorcycle is concerned, the
same Tribunal had granted an Award payable by the Insurance Company of the
Tractor.
13.
Shri Goswami, the learned counsel for respondent no. 2 has submitted
that the conventional Head as laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Pranay Sethi (supra) do not appear to have been taken in consideration by the
Tribunal.
14.
Shri Sarkar, the learned counsel for respondent no. 4 submits that he has
no role in the adjudication of the present appeal.
15.
It may be mentioned that respondent no. 3 has chosen not to contest the
appeal.
16.
The learned Tribunal has taken the monthly income of the deceased as
Page No.# 6/8
Rs.3,000/- (Rupees Three Thousand) only as there was no proof of income. In
the view of this Court, such an approach cannot be said to be unreasonable.
The calculations made by the learned Tribunal, however do not appear to be in
consonance laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Pranay
Sethi (supra). Future income is required to be taken as 40%, whereas it has
been taken at 50%. The funeral expenses, which are prescribed at Rs. 15,000/with an addition @ 10% has been given as Rs. 25,000/-. No amount has been
given on the Head - Loss of Estate which has been prescribed to be Rs.
15,000/- with enhancement of 10% every 3 years. No amount has been given
under the Head- Loss of Consortium which is Rs.40,000/- per head with a
similar enhancement of 10% every 3 years.
17.
This Court has also found that the learned Tribunal has erred in taking the
multiplier as 11 by considering the age of the mother. However, it is the age of
the deceased which is material and the deceased being aged about 29 years,
the correct multiplier would be 17.
18.
In view of the aforesaid discussions which are based on the principles laid
down for ascertaining a reasonable and fair compensation, the following
emerges which is put in a tabular form:
(i) Monthly Income
Rs.3,000/-
(ii) Future Prospect 40%
Rs.1,200/-
(iii) Yearly Income = (i + ii) x 12
Rs. 50,400/-
(iv) Deduction by 50% as deceased was
a bachelor
Rs.25,200/-
(v) Compensation Rs. 25,200/- x 17
Rs.4,28,400/-
(vi) Funeral Expenses Rs.15,000/- +
Rs.4,500/-
Rs.19,500/-
Page No.# 7/8
(vii) Medical Expenses
Rs.66,112/-
(viii) Loss of Estate Rs.15,000/- +
Rs.4,500/-
Rs.19,500/-
(ix) Loss of Consortium Rs.40,000/- x 2
= Rs.80,000/- + (10% every 3 years
after 2017) Rs.24,000/-
Rs.1,04,000/-
TOTAL
Rs.6,37,512/-
19.
So far as the rate of interest is concerned, while the Tribunal has granted
6% per annum, judicial precedent would require such interest to be given @ of
9% per annum. In this regard, this Court would take aid from certain
observations and opinion expressed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case
of Puttamma and Others v. K.L. Narayana Reddy and Another reported
in (2013) 15 SCC45 which are as follows:
“59. This Court in Kaushnuma Begum v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. &
Ors. (2001) 2 SCC 9 noticed that the Nationalized Banks are granting
interest @ 9% on fixed deposit for one year and held as follows:
“24. Now, we have to fix up the rate of interest. Section 171 of the
MV Act empowers the Tribunal to direct that “in addition to the
amount of compensation simple interest shall also be paid at such
rate and from such date not earlier than the date of making the
claim as may be specified in this behalf”. Earlier, 12% was found to
be the reasonable rate of simple interest. With a change in economy
and the policy of Reserve Bank of India the interest rate has been
lowered. The nationalised banks are now granting interest at the
rate of 9% on fixed deposits for one year. We, therefore, direct that
the compensation amount fixed hereinbefore shall bear interest at
the rate of 9% per annum from the date of the claim made by the
appellants. ...
60. ...
61. In Supe Dei v. National Insurance Co. Ltd.&Anr. (2009) 4 SCC 513 this
Page No.# 8/8
Court held that proper interest would be 9% per annum.”
There is another aspect of the matter. Vide the impugned judgment, the
compensation has been directed to be paid by the owner of the offending
vehicle i.e., the tractor. This Court has however been apprised that so far as the
claim instituted by the motorcyclist in the same case is concerned, the liability
has been saddled with the Oriental Insurance Company. In fact, the judgment
itself dated 05.12.2015 has been enclosed as Annexure 4 of the memo of
appeal. This Court is of the opinion that on the same accident when the liability
has been saddled with the Insurance Company and there being no dispute that
there was a valid insurance cover of the tractor in question, the mere fact that
the accident had happened on the road and not on the agricultural field cannot
be a reason to saddle the owner of the tractor.
20.
The appeal accordingly succeeds. The appellants would be entitled to the
compensation of Rs.6,37,512/- (Rupees Six Lakh Thirty Seven Thousand Five
Hundred and Twelve) only along with interest @9% per annum from the date of
institution of the claim petition. However, since vide the impugned Award, the
liability was saddled not on the Insurance Company, such interest would be
payable from the date of institution of the claim petition till the date of the
Award. The total compensation be deposited by the respondent no.1 – Oriental
Insurance Company Limited either in the Registry of this Court or before the
learned Motor Accident Claim Tribunal, Kokrajhar within a period of 45 days
from today. The same would be released to the claimants thereafter on being
duly identified by their learned counsel.
21.
Sent back the records.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review