Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
132521
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE SIXTH DAY OF JULY
THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
.I-WO
PRESENT
t'
I
TI-IE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREP,qLLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION NO: 18824 OF 2026
Between:
Vlshwa Sbmudra Engineering Private Limited, A company incorporated under the
provisions of the companies Act,having its registered office at 8th and 9th Floors,
Vamsiram Jyothi Velencia, Road No, 2, Andhra Pradesh Real Estate, Green Valley,
Banlara Hilis, Hyderabad, Telangana 500034, represented by its Authorized
Signatory, Sanjay NandaPurkar
,..PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. By its Principal Secretary, Transport, Roads and
Buildings Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad
2. The Transport Commissioner, Transport Department, Government of Telangana'
Hyderabad.
3. The Regional Transport Officer, lbrahimpatnam, Ranga Reddy District
4. The Assistant Motor Vehicle lnspector, o/o. Deputy Transport commissioner,
Ranga ReddY District,
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
be pleased
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may
particularly
one in. the
topleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or Direction, more
particularly
nature of writ of Mandamus, declaring the action of the respondents,
n"LponO"nt Nos. 3 and 4, in seizing and continuing_to d-etain the petitioners specialized
road rehabilitation equipment, namely wlRT GEN Cold Recycler Model wR-240
pursuant to
Ulaiing Engine Serial No. 79937981 and Machine Serial No 07WR.0208,
vlni"rE cr,6.x Report No.350741 dated 29.05.2026, and in insisting upon registration
RTanJ payment of liie tax despite the clariflcation contained in MoRTH Circular No.
1103617912016-lt4VL dated 13.07.2020, as illegal, arbitrary, without jurisdiction, contrary
to the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, violative of Articles 1a, 19(1)(g) and
300-4 of the Constitution of lndia, and consequently direct the respondents to forthwith
release tl-re petit oner's said Cold Recycler machine without insisting upon registration,
payment of life tax or any other motor vehicle tax, and not to interfere with its lawful use
for execution of road rehahrilitation works, and pass
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in llte circunrstances stated in the
affidlvit f ilel in s.rpport of the petition, the High Courl may tre pleasecl to dlrect the
Respon,Jent Nos,3 and 4 to forthwith relehse the pet!tioner's specialized road
rehabiiitation equipment, namely WIRTGEN Cold Recycler Model WR-240 bearing
Machine Serial No. 07WR,0208 and Engine Serial No. 79937981 , seized pursuant to
Vehicle Check Report No, 350741 dated 29.05.2026, without insisting upon registration
or payment of life tax, in terms of MoRTH Circular No. RT-1 1036/79/20'16-MVL dated
13.07.2020, pending disposal of the above Writ Petition, and pass
Counsel for the Petitione(s): Sri. Ravi G
Counsel for the Respondents: Gp For Transport
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN 1'!{E DIIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDER,ABAD
TtrON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PE TITION t{o.18824 a'F 2.f}26
DATE: 06 "o7.2426
i Eetwefrn:
Sri Vishwa Samudra Engineering Privdte Limited
.,. Petitioner
And
The State of Telangana and Others
...Respondents
ORDER
Heard Sri G.Ravi, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioner 'and learned Assistant
Government Pleader for Forests appearing on behalf of
the respondents.
roner
che
Cou
kin
Draver as under:
"...to issue an appropriate Writ Order or
Direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ
of Mandamus declaring the action of the
respondents particularly Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 in
seizing and continuing to detain the petitioners
sN.J
specialized road rehabilitation equipment namely
WIRTGEN Cold Rr:cycler Model WR-240 bearing
Engine Seria! l'lo. 79937981. and Machine Serial No.
07WR.020i3 pursuant to Vehicle Check Report No
350747, dated 29.05.2026 and in insisting upon
registratlon a nr: paynrent o1' life tax despite the
cl,arification co,ntai,rr=d in MoRl-ll Circular trlo.
RTLl036/l'9/2016-l\4vt-, dated 1 3.07.2020 as illegal,
arbitrary, w'ithor.rt iuri:;dictiorr contrary to the
provisioi'rs of 1'h,:: l,'lotr:r yehicles Act 1988 violative
of Articles 14, 19(1)(g) a:d 300-A ol' the
Constitution of India and consequently direct the
respondents to forthwith release the petitioners said
Cold Recycler machine without insisting upon
registration payment of Iife tax or any other motor
vehiclr: ta;< ar:ii nct tcr interFere with its Ia\/ful use
for execut;or of road rehabilitation works and
IJdss....
The case of the Detitio ner in brief as oer the
averments made in the a ffidavit filed bv the oetitioner
in suooort of the pres ent Writ Petition is as under:-
The petitioner is a reputed infrastructure company
engaged in execution of Government road projects. The
petitioner had purchased a WIRTGEN Cold Recycler Model WR-
240 (Machine Serial No.07WR.020B; Engine Serial No.
79937981) from WIRTGEN India Private Limited for exclusive
use in road rehabilitation and soil stabilization works, While
executing an HRDCL road rehabilitation project near
Tukkuguda, Ranga Reddy District, the machinery was
J
SN,J
intercepted on 29.05.2026 by the officials of the 4th
respondent, who issued Vehicle Check Report No' 350741
alleging non-payment of life tax and absence of a valid driving
licence, and seized the dquipment. Thereafter, the petitioner
had submitted representatic'ns relying upon MoRTH Circular
l
No. FLT-11dr36 /79/2.0t6-Nlvl dated 13.07.2020, whiclr clatil"ies
that Cold Recyclers are not "motor vehicles" requiring
registration or life tax. On 03.06.2026, the 3rd respondent
acknowledged the representation and directed verification of
the machinery's eligibility under the said Circular' Thereafter,
the petitioner submitted a further representation by email
dated 08.06.2026 to the 2nd respondent seeking withdrawal
of the Vehicle Stop Notice and release of the machinery'
Despite the binding Central Government clarification and
pending verification, the respondents continued to detain the
equipment, disrupting the ongoing public infrastructure
project, causing substantial financial loss' Hence, the
petitioner had approached this court by filing the present Writ
Petition.
PER USED T E RECO D:-
,
SN,J
Ttre ins
cti
!'eoort vide Lr.No.Nill / RRD / 2026, dater!
soondent No.3 is extracted
03.06.2026 is:lued bv the
hereundef:-
In the reference 1't cited B.Swathi ApIVI RR Dis;t has
,:hecked and seized the vehicle bearirig chassis nurnber
)'99379fi! for the irregularities noticed in the VCR.
:
Ir the rel'err3nce 2nd cited the reg;steieC owner of the
vehicle has approached this office with a request to release
the vehicle with reference to MoRTH notification No.RT-
17036/79/2016-MVL, dated 13.07.2020 without collection oF
life tax by treating the vehicle as construction equipment
rnacirine which is not required registration arid not comes
under ivloror Vehicle Act.
-f
he copy of the notification is enclosed herewith.
Therefore B. Swathi AMVI RR Dist is requested to inspect
the vehicle once again and submit a detailed report with
regard to class of vehicle for taking further necessary action.
Further it is also requested to verify whether the above
said vehicle fit under the notification issued by the MoRTH.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION :DISCUSSION:5
n
a
u
ear
onb half
-f
t e
f
lt
h
wln
subrliesLons:-
i)
The petitioner is a reputed infrastructure company
engaged tn
the execution of major road and infrastructure
SN,J
projects across India and is presently undertaking various
roads rehabilitation and development works in the State of
Telangana pursuant to Government contracts.
ii)
For the execution of such specializecl works, the
petit;oner utllized a WIRTGENI
! old 'Fiec,r'cler Model WR-240,
bearing machine Serial No.07WR.0208 and Engine Serial
No.79937981, which is a special purpose road rehabilitation
and construction equipment designed exclusively for cold
recycling and soll stabilization operations.
iii)
The said equipment was lawfully purchased by the
petitioner under a valid Tax Invoice issued by WIRTGEN India
Private Limited. It is specialized ionstruction equipment used
at project sites and shifted from one location to another only
for the purpose of execution of road works'
iv)
While the said machinery was engaged in the execution
of road rehabilitation works near Tukkuguda in Ranga Reddy
District, the officials of the 4th respondent intercepted and
checked the machinery on 29.05 '2026 and issued Vehicle
Check Report No.350741 alleging that the machinery was
operating in the State of Telangana without payment of life
SN,J
tax and that the driver was not possessing a valid driving
licence.
v)
vide Lr.Nil/lilRD/2025, dated .30.06.2026, the 3'd
respondent directed for verification of the machinery's
eligibility acting upon rhe representation of the petitioner.
vi)
Thereafter, the petitioner had submitted a further
representation throuEh e-mail to the 2"d respondent, dated
08.06.2026 enclosing al the relevant documents, including
the Circular No.RT-11036 /79/2016-MV L, dated 13.07.2020
issued by the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways,
Government of India, Nelv Delhi, seeking withdrawal of the
vehicle stop notice and tl-re release of the machinery.
vii) The said Circular dated 13.07.2020 clearly clarifies about
the subject equipment and further as per Clause (3) of the
said Circular
Cold Recyclers and soil Stabilizers are not
covered under the definition of a Motor Vehicle under the
Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 and further clause (5) of the said
Circular clearly states that registration should not be sought
sN.J
for road builcJing and rehabilitation equipment, including
wheeled Cold Recycle machines
viii) Seizing of the subject equipment is illegal and crlntrary
to the MoRTH Circular No.RT-11036/79/2076-MVL, dated
13.07.2020t and thJrefore, the petitioner sought imrpediate
release of the subject equipment which does not fall under
the purview of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
ix) The representation of the petitioner, dated 15'06.2026
addressed to the 2nd respondent though acknowledged on
t6.06.2026, did not lead to any progress for conduct of any
enquiry for release of the subject machinery to the petitioner
herein. The' said action of the respondent is illegjl and
arbitrary.
Base n
on th
coun sel aooe rrno on
h
n
aforesai d submi sions, le rned
ehalf of the oetiti oner cont ends
nt t
r h
Lear ed Assi tant Go vernment
Tran Dolt aD Deartno
f
Pleader
for
on behal f of the resDon ents
sN,l
p!a1:es reliance on the material documents filed bv the
.LeuliqEeI_trt--Ss DDort of the orese n t writ oetition. In
pArticulaL_.
dated 03,
2026 issuecl bv the 3''d re s roondent hnd
u-r,r2-Lr.!-rylHl!!: s:-lq
$.@IE
:
-
i
i) A detailed inspection report had been called for in the
subject issue by requesting one Officer B.Swathi, AMVi, Ranga
,R.:cd y District to inspect the subject vehicle or ce again Ernd
subrnit a detailed report with regard to class r:f vehicle and
verify whether the said vehicle fits under the notification
issued by the MoRTH.
ii)
Though the said proceedings, dated 03.06.2026 was
issued by the respondent No.3, no action had been initiated as
on date and the subject equipment had not been inspected so
far is the specific grievance oF the petitioner.
Based on the aforesa id submissions, learned
Assistant Government Pleader for Transoort aooearino
on behalf of the resDondent s contends that aDDroDriate
orders mav be oassed for conduct of insoection of the
subiect vehicle.
sN,J
Clause Nos.4 & 5 of the Circul ar Vide
7.
1103 t79t20L6 -MVl-. dat
Mlni
rv of Roa
O.RT-
13.O7.20 O lssued b v the
Tra nsoor t and Hitrtt wavs, Tra sDort
I
l
tsharnl an. 1 Parli
ment Str
New De llri are extr acted
hereuncler
3. The issue had been discussed in the 56th meeting of the
CMVR-TSC wherein it was opined that cold milling machine,
cold recycler and soil stabilizers are not covered under the
definition of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 and that the type
approval of the machine is also not nrade.
5.
It is requested not to seek the reglstration of Road
Building and Rehabilitation equipment (wheeled cold milling
machini, wheeled soil stabilizers machine, wheeled cold
recycler equipment machine etc.) as these special purpose
construction equipment and HEMM such as Dumpers,
Payloaders, Shovels, Drill Master, Bulldozers, Motor Grader
and Rock breakers as special purpose mining equipment and
further that they are transported from one location to another
through carriage on another vehicles, and do not ply on road
the mselves.
8.
A bare perusal of the above referred Clauses of the
Circular No.RT-1 1O3 6 t 7 9 I 2O16-MVL, dated L3.O7'2O2O
issued by the Minastry of Road Transport and Highways,
Government of India, New Delhi, clearly clarifies about
the subject equipment and further as per Clause (3) of
the said Circular , Cold Recyclers and soil Stabilizers are
not covered under the definition of a Motor Vehicle
l0
SN,J
runder the Motor Vehicl,e Acts, 198E and further clause
(5) of the said Circular clearly states that registration
should not be sought for the said road building and
rehahititation eolrrriprflerit, incldrdirrg wheeled Cold
Recycle machines.
I
In the iudqment of the A
x Court reoorted in 2O26
LawSuit(SC)8l, dated OB.0 L.2O26 in Ultratech Cement
Ltd. Vs. State of Gu iara{t & Ors, anc lin oarticular Dara
Nos.17, 18 & 55 are e)l;relte.d-reICglld-g
17. The primary submission on behalf of the appellants is that
Entry 57 of List II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution
of India permits taxation only of vehicles "suitable for use on
roads", therefore, vehicles not used in public places or public
roads or not suitable fo5 use on roads are outside the purview
of the definition of "motor vehicles" and are not chargeable to
road tax. Secondly, it has been submitted that the
manufacturer's specifications and the certificates of the
experts on record clearly demonstrate that the vehicles in
question are off-road vehicles. The certificates and
contentions have not been refuted by the State and the Court
has simply ignored them by saying that the expert certificates
and manufacturer's specifications are not material.
18. It has also been contended that the Ministry of Road
Transport and Highways (MoRTH) vide circular dated
13.07.2020 expressly states that such vehicles as used by the
appellants are "off-road equipment" and they do not qualify to
be "motor vehicles" which may require registration.
55. In view of the aforesaid discussion specially considering
the pleadings and the material on record, we are of the
conclusive opinion that the vehicles used by the appellants are
sN,l
of special types, precisely construction equipment
which are suitable and are meant for use for
vehicles
vehicles
operation and use within the industrial area/factory premises/
defined enclosed premises and are not meant for use on roads
or public roads. They are off-road equipments and as such
stand excluded not onty from the purview of the "motor
vehicle" as def ined underl Section 2 (28) of the Act but also
from tax as Entry 57 of List II of the Seventh Schedule of the
Conrtiirtion only authorizes taxation of vehicles suitable for
use on roadp orlly. lhey are not even chargeable to rgad tax
in vielv of Schedule I to Section 3 (1) of the Gujarat Tax'Act
which do not prescribes any tax for such kind of vehicles i'e',
construction equipment vehicles. However, if any such kind of
vehicles are found using roads, they would not be free front
the rigors of Section 2 (28) of the Act and Section 3 of the
GujarJt Tax Act and may also be subject to proceedings for
seizure and penalty in accordance with the law.
Releva nt Dar aqraohs of the
bove sa id iudq ent
x f
a
use
rt
Tr
Min
its
r
v hi
t.e
7.2
d
tru
I
h
Hi
s
RTH
re
a
ha
me
hicl
thereu der a
bvt E ADD la nts
t
ne
ha
n
o
"off-r oad
r
vehi cles" w ich mav reoulre reoistr tion.
10. TAKING INTO CONSIDERATION:
a)
The aforesaid facts and circumstances of the case,
SN,J
b)
The subnrissions made by the learned counsel
;lppearing onr behalf of the petitioner and lealnerl
,\ssistant Government Pleader for Transport appearing
on trehalf of t[le respondents.
c)
I-herr contents of the
Cincular Vide I{o.R'1rI
LLO36/79/2O16-MVL, dated 13.07.2O2O issued by the
Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, Transport
flihau/an, ]. Irarliament Street, Neu"' fielhi (rreferred to
anrl extracted above)
d)
The contents of the inspection report vide
proceedings Lr.No.Nill/RRDl2026, dated 03.O6.2026
issued by the respondent No.3 (referred to and
extracted above) requesting the inspection of the
srlbject vehicle and for submission of detailed report on
the subject issue.
e) The fact that the subject machinery had been seized
on 29.05.2026, vide Vehicle Check Report No.35O741
on the ground that the machinery was operating in the
State of Telangana without payment of life tax and on
the ground of holding invalid driving licence ,
l3
SN,J
f) The judEment of the Apex Court reported in 2O26
LawSuit(SC) 81 (referred to and extracted above)
g)
The discussion and conclusiorr as arrived at
I
paragraph Nos. 5 to 9 of this order,
t$ di
The wn
vide
issu
roceedin os Lr.No .NitI/RRD t2026,
h
the reouest
of the
o
m n
n
thp
iFe
s d
n
ated
r
a
n
Detitione r
for re lease of the
oetitioner's equipment namelv WIRTGEN Cold Recvcler
Mod twR-24
993798 and
bea rinq Enoine S erial No.
ine Seri I No. O7 wR.o208 seized, oursua tto
Mac
Vehi le Chec KR
4l
No
.20
d
dulv considerinq the reoresentation of the oetitioner'
nd
2 2
n
here in, seeki o examr ation of the Circu Iar quidelin es,
n
n
h
se the v hicle be rino Cha sis Numb er 7993798L,
rel
serz d vide VCR No.3
r
n
c
o7L. da ted 29.O .2(J26 ot the
s
r
r
a
ln
A
t4
SN,J
d. Vs. State of
in Ul ratech C eme
ve
r
oa
refer
Or
ar
Clause Nos. (3) & J5'! of the Circular Vide No'RT-
Cou r t iudqme nt
,.103 6t79/20L6,-N Vil-, CI ated I.3. dt.zozo issued bv the
hwa
.Ei-nisttv-pf -BBgsl--li E
r ferre
anrl
New D elhi
r cted a bove) and take a de isio ll
ont he subiect issue and Dass apD ropriate detailed
speakinq order, rn a ordance to law, in con form itv
les of natural ustice bv orovid in oan
er and
o DDort nitv of pe rsonal hearinq t otheD
r
wt h
ul
co
n
icat
d c
n
h
n
sub
tssue to the Detitione r, Howeve r, there shall be no order
as to costs.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this Writ
Petition, sha ll stand closed
SD/. A.H.S.GOWRI SHANKAR
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR,
//TRUE COrY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
and
Principal secretary' Transport' Roads
its
By
Rep.
Telangana,
of
State
I The
l-lyderabacl
auitO'ngs Department Secretariat
Telarrg{na'
iru"uoou Deoart'nent' Government of
2 The Transport Con',,ltsionel'
Hyderabad.
3. The Regional Transport fficer, lbrahimpatnam, Ranga Reddy District
4. The Assistant Motor Vehicle lnspector, o/o. Deputy Transport Commissioner,
Ranga Reddy District,
5. One CC to SRl, RAVI G ACvocate IOPUC]
6. Two CCs to GP FOR TRANSPORT High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad [OUT]
7. Two CD Copies
YY
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED: 061A71242.6
tr'
ORDER
q
WP.hlo.18824 ctf 20?6
o
LL
eo
? TE
v
"S5
$s'
l/otH + f ft
ptSlrc-rimG' cF lHg \,']lzlt t)Gt\T'iolu
(c"\l/)
Fri+h Gll
..\
\s
\c2r-
Xtt'
*
+
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review