Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE SRI P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA
WRIT PETITION NO.23124 OF 2018
(CNR.No. HBHC010490272018)
Reserved on: 13.07.2026
Pronounced on: 11 .11.2026
Uploaded on: 11 .11.2026
Between:
A Dhruva Kumar and others
…Petitioner
AND
The Union of India and others
…Respondents
ORDER: (As per the Hon’ble Sri Justice Narsing Rao Nandikonda)
This Writ Petition is filed challenging the order dated
09.01.2018 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal,
Hyderabad Bench, in O.A.No.37 of 2014, and the subsequent
order
dated
06.04.2018
passed
in
R.A.No.020/003/2018,
whereby the Original Application filed by the petitioners seeking
re-fixation of their pay on re-employment in the Employees'
Provident Fund Organization, by taking into consideration the
last pay drawn by them in the Defence Services, was dismissed.
2 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
2.
Heard Mr. K Sudhakar Reddy, learned counsel for the
petitioners; Ms. P Sarada, learned Standing Counsel appearing
for respondent Nos.1 & 2; Mr. S.N.Veernder Singh, learned
counsel appearing for respondent No.3; Mr. T Balaji, learned
Standing Counsel appearaing for respondent Nos.4, 5 and 6
learned counsel appearing for the respondents. Perused the
material available on record.
3. It is the case of the petitioners that they are ex-servicemen
who had served in the Indian Air Force and Indian Army for
about 18 to 20 years and retired from the Defence Services
before attaining the age of 55 years. Thereafter, they were
appointed as Social Security Assistants in the Employees'
Provident Fund Organization under the ex-servicemen quota
during the years 2006 to 2012. Petitioners Nos.1 to 7 retired
from the Defence Services after the year 2006 and were reemployed during the years 2010 to 2012, whereas petitioners
Nos.8 to 10 retired prior to the year 2006 and were re-employed
during the year 2006. It is their grievance that, notwithstanding
their previous service in the Armed Forces, their initial pay on
3 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
re-employment was fixed without extending the benefit of pay
protection by taking into consideration the last pay drawn by
them in the Defence Services.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the Central
Government issued the Central Civil Services (Fixation of Pay of
Re-employed
Pensioners)
Orders,
1986,
prescribing
the
procedure for fixation of pay of ex-servicemen upon their reemployment in civil posts. The said Orders were subsequently
amended by the Department of Personnel and Training through
Office
Memorandum
No.3/19/2009-Estt.(Pay-II),
dated
05.04.2010. It is contended that, under paragraph 4(d)(i) of the
said Orders, in the case of ex-servicemen who held posts below
Commissioned Officer rank in the Defence Forces and retired
before attaining the age of 55 years, the entire pension and
pension equivalent of retirement benefits are required to be
ignored
while
fixing
their
initial
pay
on
re-employment.
According to the petitioners, the respondents ought to have
taken into consideration their last drawn pay in the Defence
4 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
Services, together with the applicable pay elements, while fixing
their pay in the re-employed posts.
5. It is further submitted that the petitioners had submitted
several representations requesting re-fixation of their pay in
accordance with the aforesaid Orders and clarifications issued
by
the
Government
of
India.
Though
initially
certain
communications dated 11.06.2013 & 24.06.2013 were issued by
the respondents considering fixation of pay on the basis of the
last pay drawn certificates, the said benefit was subsequently
denied
through
communications
10.12.2013
and
respondents
have
provisions
and
11.12.2013.
It
erroneously
denied
the
dated
is
contended
interpreted
legitimate
26/28.11.2013,
that
the
entitlement
the
relevant
of
the
petitioners to pay protection.
6. Learned counsel further submits that the petitioners are
similarly situated to one G. Suryanarayana, who was reemployed
as
a
Lower
Division
Clerk in
the
respondent
Organization and whose pay was allegedly fixed by taking into
5 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
consideration the last pay drawn by him in the Armed Forces,
vide order dated 03.02.2000. It is contended that denial of
similar treatment to the petitioners amounts to discrimination
and is violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
Reliance is also placed on the orders passed in W.P.No.17408 of
1992 and connected matters, the decision of the Rajasthan High
Court in Union of India v. Mool Singh, and the judgments in
Director General of Posts and Others v. B. Ravindran and
another and ICAR v. Bidesh Singh and Others, in support of the
contention that the pay last drawn in the Defence Services ought
to be protected upon re-employment.
7. It is further contended that the Central Administrative
Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench, without properly appreciating the
provisions of the 1986 Orders, as amended by the Office
Memorandum dated 05.04.2010, dismissed O.A.No.37 of 2014
by order dated 09.01.2018. The Review Application filed by the
petitioners in R.A.No.020/003/2018 was also dismissed on
06.04.2018, observing that the grounds raised therein were
merely a repetition of the contentions already considered. It is,
6 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
therefore, submitted that the impugned orders are contrary to
the applicable rules and deserve to be set aside.
8. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos.2 to
6, referring to the counter affidavit, submits that the petitioners
were appointed in the Employees' Provident Fund Organisation
under the ex-servicemen quota by direct recruitment and their
initial pay was fixed strictly in accordance with the applicable
rules governing re-employed pensioners. It is submitted that the
petitioners admittedly held posts below Commissioned Officer
rank in the Defence Services and, therefore, their pay fixation is
governed by paragraph 4(d)(i) of the Central Civil Services
(Fixation of Pay of Re-employed Pensioners) Orders, 1986, as
amended by the Office Memorandum dated 05.04.2010.
9. Learned counsel submits that, under the aforesaid provisions,
though the entire pension and pension equivalent of retirement
benefits are to be ignored for the purpose of initial pay fixation,
the pay of re-employed ex-servicemen is required to be fixed at
the entry pay in the revised pay structure applicable to direct
7 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
recruits appointed to the corresponding civil posts on or after
01.01.2006. It is specifically contended that the said provisions
do not confer any right upon the petitioners to claim protection
of the last pay drawn by them in the Defence Services. The
respondents further contend that the benefit contemplated
under
paragraph
3(v)
of
the
Office
Memorandum
dated
05.04.2010 is applicable to a different category of re-employed
personnel and cannot be extended to the petitioners, who were
holding posts below Commissioned Officer rank at the time of
retirement.
10.
It
is
further
submitted
that,
upon
receipt
of
the
representations submitted by the petitioners, the matter was
referred to the Deputy Director (Audit), who examined the issue
and opined that the petitioners were not eligible for protection of
their last drawn pay. Thereafter, the Employees' Provident Fund
Organization,
Head
26.07.2017,
based
Office,
on
the
issued
clarifications
clarifications
issued
dated
by
the
Department of Personnel and Training, dated 04.07.2016 &
09.11.2016 reiterating that the initial pay of ex-servicemen who
8 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
held posts below Commissioned Officer rank and retired before
attaining the age of 55 years shall be fixed at the entry pay of
the re-employed post and that the relevant instructions do not
provide for protection of the last pay drawn in the Defence
Services.
11.
Learned
Administrative
counsel
further
Tribunal,
after
submits
that
considering
the
Central
the
relevant
provisions and the material placed before it, rightly dismissed
O.A.No.37 of 2014 by order dated 09.01.2018. The Tribunal
specifically
observed
that
merely
because
certain
other
employees were granted the benefit of re-fixation of pay on the
basis of their last drawn pay, the petitioners cannot claim
similar relief contrary to the applicable instructions, as an
illegality committed in one case cannot be perpetuated in other
cases.
The
Review
Application
was
also
dismissed
on
06.04.2018, as the petitioners failed to establish any error
apparent on the face of the record. It is, therefore, contended
that the impugned orders do not suffer from any illegality or
9 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
perversity warranting interference by this Court under Article
226 of the Constitution of India.
12. In support of the aforesaid submissions, learned counsel for
the respondents places reliance on the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Union of India and Others v. Anil Prasad,
reported in 2022 LiveLaw (SC) 513, decided on 20.05.2022 in
Civil Appeal No.4073 of 2022, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme
Court considered the question whether an employee who had
served in the Armed Forces would, upon re-employment in
Government service, be entitled to fixation of pay at par with the
last pay drawn by him in the Armed Forces. The Hon'ble
Supreme Court, while interpreting paragraph 8 of the Central
Civil Services (Fixation of Pay of Re-employed Pensioners)
Orders, 1986, held that the last drawn pay in the Armed Forces
cannot, as a matter of right, be claimed as the pay to be fixed
upon re-employment in a civil post.
13. The relevant observations of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
paragraph Nos.5.1, 5.3 and 5.4 are extracted hereunder:
10 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
Paragraph 5.1 — Relevant question considered by the
Supreme Court:
Whether on re-employment in Government service, a
former Armed Forces employee is entitled to pay at par
with his last drawn Armed Forces pay.
Paragraph 5.3 — Relevant observations:
The Hon'ble Supreme Court explained that paragraph 8
provides for advance increments corresponding to
completed years of Armed Forces service, calculated with
reference to the pay scale of the civil post. The pay so
determined cannot exceed the basic pay last drawn in the
Armed Forces. It further clarified that the last drawn pay
operates as a ceiling and does not confer an independent
right to pay protection.
Paragraph 5.4 — Relevant observations:
The Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the fixation of pay in
the case before it was in accordance with paragraph 8 of
the 1986 Orders and that the provision does not entitle a
retired Armed Forces employee to automatic fixation of
basic pay at par with the last pay drawn in military
service. Accordingly, the contrary judgment of the High
Court was set aside.
14. Placing reliance on the aforesaid judgment, learned counsel
for the respondents submits that the law laid down by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court makes it clear that an ex-serviceman,
merely by virtue of having drawn a higher pay in the Defence
Services, cannot claim fixation of his pay at the same level upon
11 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
re-employment in a civil post. It is submitted that the
petitioners' claim for protection of the last pay drawn in the
Defence Services is contrary to the applicable provisions
governing pay fixation and, therefore, the Tribunal was justified
in rejecting their claim. Learned counsel accordingly prays for
dismissal of the Writ Petition.
15. Having heard learned counsel appearing for the respective
parties and upon perusal of the material available on record, the
question that arises for consideration before this Court is
whether the petitioners, who are ex-servicemen re-employed as
Social Security Assistants in the Employees' Provident Fund
Organization, are entitled to fixation of their initial pay by taking
into consideration the last pay drawn by them in the Defence
Services and whether the orders passed by the Central
Administrative Tribunal warrant interference by this Court.
16. Admittedly, the petitioners had served in the Indian Air
Force and Indian Army and retired from the Defence Services
before attaining the age of 55 years. Subsequently, they were
12 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
appointed as Social Security Assistants in the respondent
Organization under the ex-servicemen quota. It is also not in
dispute that the petitioners held posts below Commissioned
Officer rank at the time of their retirement from the Defence
Services. Therefore, their entitlement to fixation of pay upon reemployment is required to be examined in the light of the
Central
Civil
Pensioners)
Services
Orders,
(Fixation
1986,
as
of
Pay
of
amended
by
Re-employed
the
Office
Memorandum dated 05.04.2010.
17. The principal contention of the petitioners is that, since the
entire pension and pension equivalent of retirement benefits are
required to be ignored while fixing their initial pay, they are
entitled to protection of the last pay drawn by them in the
Defence Services. However, the said contention cannot be
accepted. Merely because the pension and pensionary benefits
are required to be ignored for the purpose of initial pay fixation,
the same would not automatically confer any right upon the
petitioners to claim fixation of pay at par with the last pay drawn
by them in the Defence Services. The entitlement to pay
13 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
protection must necessarily flow from the applicable rules and
instructions governing their re-employment.
18. A perusal of the counter affidavit filed by respondent Nos.2
to 6 would disclose that the respondents have specifically
explained the manner in which the initial pay of the petitioners
was fixed. As per the Office Memorandum dated 05.04.2010, in
the case of ex-servicemen who held posts below Commissioned
Officer rank and retired before attaining the age of 55 years, the
entire pension and pension equivalent of retirement benefits
shall be ignored. However, the initial pay on re-employment
shall be fixed at the entry pay in the revised pay structure of the
re-employed post, as applicable to direct recruits appointed on
or after 01.01.2006. The said provision does not contemplate
protection of the last pay drawn by such ex-servicemen in the
Defence Services.
19. It is pertinent to note that the respondents, upon receipt of
the representations submitted by the petitioners, referred the
matter to the Deputy Director (Audit), who, after examining the
14 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
applicable provisions, opined that the petitioners were not
entitled to pay protection. The Employees' Provident Fund
Organization, Head Office, also issued clarifications dated
26.07.2017,
based
on
the
clarifications
issued
by
the
Department of Personnel and Training, reiterating that the initial
pay of re-employed ex-servicemen who held posts below
Commissioned Officer rank shall be fixed in accordance with the
entry pay applicable to the re-employed post. Therefore, the
action of the respondents in fixing the initial pay of the
petitioners in accordance with the aforesaid instructions cannot
be termed illegal or arbitrary.
20. At this juncture, it is relevant to refer to the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India and Others v. Anil
Prasad, reported in 2022 LiveLaw (SC) 513, relied upon by
learned counsel for the respondents. In the said judgment, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, while interpreting paragraph 8 of the
Central
Civil
Services
(Fixation
of
Pay
of
Re-employed
Pensioners) Orders, 1986, considered the question whether an
employee who had served in the Armed Forces would, upon re-
15 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
employment in Government service, be entitled to fixation of pay
at par with the last pay drawn by him in the Armed Forces. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court categorically held that the last drawn
pay in the Armed Forces cannot be claimed as a matter of right
upon re-employment in a civil post and that the fixation of pay
must be in accordance with the applicable provisions governing
the re-employed post.
21. The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in the aforesaid judgment,
further clarified that the reference to the last drawn pay in the
Armed Forces under paragraph 8 of the 1986 Orders is only for
the purpose of ensuring that the pay computed upon reemployment does not exceed the basic pay last drawn in the
Armed Forces. It was specifically held that such a provision does
not confer any right upon a retired Armed Forces employee to
claim protection of the last drawn pay. The Hon'ble Supreme
Court accordingly set aside the judgment of the Delhi High
Court, which had directed fixation of pay at par with the last pay
drawn by the employee in the Armed Forces.
16 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
22. Though the aforesaid judgment was rendered in the context
of paragraph 8 of the 1986 Orders, relating to Emergency
Commissioned
Officers
and
Short
Service
Commissioned
Officers, the principle laid down therein, namely, that protection
of the last drawn pay upon re-employment cannot be claimed as
a matter of right in the absence of a specific provision, is
relevant to the issue involved in the present Writ Petition. In the
case on hand, the petitioners admittedly held posts below
Commissioned Officer rank and their pay fixation is governed by
the specific provisions applicable to such category of exservicemen. The respondents have demonstrated that the
relevant instructions provide for fixation of initial pay at the
entry level of the re-employed post and do not provide for
automatic protection of the last pay drawn in the Defence
Services.
Therefore,
the
claim
of
the
petitioners
is
not
sustainable.
23. Insofar as the contention of the petitioners that one G.
Suryanarayana,
who
was
similarly
re-employed
in
the
respondent Organization, was extended the benefit of pay
17 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
protection is concerned, the respondents have specifically stated
in their counter affidavit that the pay fixation of the said
employee was governed by the rules prevailing at the relevant
point of time, which are not applicable to the petitioners. Even
otherwise, merely because a particular benefit was extended to
another
employee,
the
petitioners
cannot
claim
similar
treatment unless they establish their entitlement under the
applicable rules. It is a settled principle of law that Article 14 of
the Constitution of India does not envisage negative equality and
that an illegality or irregularity committed in one case cannot be
perpetuated by extending the same benefit to other employees
contrary to the governing rules.
24. It is also pertinent to observe that the Central Administrative
Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench, while dismissing O.A.No.37 of 2014
by order dated 09.01.2018, had considered the relevant
provisions and the contentions advanced by the petitioners. The
Tribunal specifically observed that the respondents had acted in
accordance with the instructions contained in the Office
Memorandum dated 05.04.2010 and that merely because
18 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
certain other employees were granted re-fixation of pay on the
basis of the last pay drawn, the petitioners cannot claim similar
relief. The Tribunal further observed that even if any illegality
had been committed in some other cases, the same cannot be a
ground to direct the respondents to perpetuate such illegality.
25. This Court is in agreement with the findings recorded by the
Tribunal. The petitioners have not been able to demonstrate that
the fixation of their initial pay by the respondents is contrary to
any mandatory provision of the applicable rules. On the
contrary, the material placed on record would disclose that the
respondents have fixed the pay of the petitioners in accordance
with the instructions governing the re-employment of exservicemen who held posts below Commissioned Officer rank.
The contention that the petitioners are entitled to protection of
the last pay drawn by them in the Defence Services, merely
because their pensionary benefits are required to be ignored, is
devoid of merit.
19 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
26.
Insofar
as
the
R.A.No.020/003/2018
order
dated
06.04.2018
is
concerned,
the
passed
Tribunal
in
has
specifically observed that the Review Application was nothing
but a repetition of the contentions already raised and considered
in the Original Application. It is well settled that the scope of
review is limited and a Review Application cannot be treated as
an appeal in disguise for re-appreciation of the entire matter. In
the absence of any error apparent on the face of the record, the
Tribunal was justified in dismissing the Review Application.
27. It is well settled that, while exercising jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, this Court would not
ordinarily interfere with the findings recorded by the Central
Administrative Tribunal unless such findings are demonstrated
to be perverse, arbitrary or contrary to the applicable provisions
of law. In the present case, the Tribunal, upon due consideration
of the material available on record and the relevant rules
governing fixation of pay of re-employed ex-servicemen, has
rejected the claim of the petitioners by assigning cogent reasons.
This Court does not find any jurisdictional error, illegality or
20 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
perversity in the findings recorded by the Tribunal warranting
interference.
28. In view of the aforesaid discussion and having regard to the
law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India
and Others v. Anil Prasad (supra), this Court is of the considered
opinion that the petitioners have failed to establish any legally
enforceable right to claim fixation of their initial pay at par with
the last pay drawn by them in the Defence Services. The action
of the respondents in fixing the initial pay of the petitioners in
accordance with the applicable rules and instructions cannot be
found fault with. The Tribunal has rightly dismissed the Original
Application as well as the Review Application. Therefore, this
Court does not find any merit in the Writ Petition warranting
interference with the impugned orders.
29. Accordingly, the Writ Petition is dismissed, confirming the
order dated 09.01.2018 passed by the Central Administrative
Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench, in O.A.No.37 of 2014 and the
21 of 21
HACJ & NNR,J
WP_23124_2018
subsequent
order
dated
06.04.2018
passed
in
R.A.No.020/003/2018. There shall be no order as to costs.
30.
Consequently, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in
this Writ Petition shall stand closed.
__________________________
P. SAM KOSHY, ACJ
________________________________________________
JUSTICE NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA
Date: 11.11.2026.
aqs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review