The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. We therefore find no jurisdictional error and no perversity in the order of the Tribunal. Accordingly, the Writ Petition stands dismissed at the admission stage and the impugned order passed by the Tribunal is upheld. The question framed in the preceding paragraph stands answered in favour of the respondent and against the Department.
22. As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending if any, shall stand closed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA
WRIT PETITION No.26054 of 2025
(CNR No.HBHC010509512025)
Date of Order : 11.11.2026
Reserved on: 24.08.2026
Pronounced on: 11.11.2026
Uploaded on: 12.11.2026
Between:
Union of India, represented by its Secretary to Government of India,
Ministry of Defence, South Block, New Delhi -110011 and 3 others.
…Petitioners
AND
Ex. Sep. Sk. Samulla.
…Respondent
ORDER: (per Hon’ble the Acting Chief Justice P.Sam Koshy)
Heard Mr. Arvind Kumar Kata, learned Senior Standing Counsel
for Central Government appearing on behalf of the petitioners; and
Mr. S. Govinda Rao, learned counsel for the respondents.
2.
The instant Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India has been filed by the petitioner challenging the order dated
03.03.2022, passed by Armed Forces Tribunal, Regional Bench,
Chennai, Circuit Bench at Hyderabad (for short the ‘Tribunal’) in O.A.
No.78 of 2020 along with M.A.No.76 of 2020.
3.
Vide the impugned order, the Tribunal held that the respondent
is eligible for pensionary benefits and condoned the shortfall of service
of one year.
4.
The facts of the case are that the respondent herein, who was
the applicant before the Tribunal, was enrolled in the Indian Army on
05.07.2000 and was invalided out of service on 19.01.2010 under
Rule 13(3) III of the Army Rules, 1954, after rendering 9 years, 6
months and 15 days of service.
The Invaliding Medical Board, duly
constituted at the Command Hospital, Northern Command, assessed
the
disability
of
the
respondent
namely
“Alcohol
Dependence
Syndrome” on 29.12.2009 as neither attributable to nor aggravated
by military service, and there being no connection between the service
and the disability. The disability was assessed at 11 to 14%, and the
net assessment for disability pension was accordingly held to be not
applicable.
5.
The claim of the respondent for disability pension was thereafter
adjudicated by the Army authority namely the Officer In-charge, Army
Medical Corps Record Services, in the light of the existing medical and
administrative provisions, and it was decided that the respondent was
not entitled to disability pension. This decision was rendered by the
competent authority on 18.08.2010. No appeal was preferred by the
respondent against the said decision, and he approached the Tribunal
directly.
6.
The claim of the respondent for invalid gratuity was, however,
admitted and Invalid Gratuity, DCRG and MOC were sanctioned vide
letter No.G/3/85/84/3-11, dated 24.03.2011.
years, an application dated
27.09.2014
After a lapse of 10
was
preferred by the
respondent, which was suitably replied to by respondent No.4 vide
letter dated 22.01.2015. A total amount of Rs.28,66,777/- was paid
to the respondent towards the benefits. According to the Department,
2 issues arose for determination: first, whether the respondent was
eligible for invalid pension, having been invalided out; and second,
whether the respondent was entitled to pensionary benefits after
condonation of the shortfall in pensionary service, since he had
rendered more than 9 years, 6 months and 15 days of qualifying
service before being invalided out of service on medical grounds.
7.
On the first issue, the Tribunal held that the respondent was
clearly not eligible for disability pension since the Medical Board had
declared the invaliding disease “Alcohol Dependence Syndrome”,
assessed at 11 to 14%, to be neither attributable to nor aggravated by
military service. The Tribunal held that there was no infirmity in the
proceedings and no reason to interfere with the findings of the Medical
Board.
Reliance was placed on the extant provisions of Regulation
117 of the Pension Regulations for the Army, 1961 which deal with
individuals invalided out on account of indulgence in drugs and drink.
It was further held by the Tribunal that it was a settled proposition of
law that, where the Medical Board had assessed the disability at 11%
to 14% as neither attributable to nor aggravated by military service
and unconnected with it, the Tribunal ought not to have allowed the
claim of the respondent.
The Department also stated that the High
Court and the Hon’ble Supreme Court had held time and again that
the Courts do not have the necessary medical expertise to assess
disability and must therefore maintain restraint in matters of medical
assessment.
8.
The Tribunal was accordingly stated not to have been justified
in interfering with a medical assessment that had been made by
following due process of law.
9.
Aggrieved
by
the
same,
the
Department
challenged
the
impugned order by way of the present Writ Petition.
10.
Learned Senior Standing Counsel for the Central Government
submitted that the respondent is not eligible for disability pension, as
the Medical Board has declared the Invaliding Disease ‘Alcohol
Dependence Syndrome’ 11-14% and not attributable nor aggravated
by Military Service. There is no infirmity in the proceedings nor any
reason to interfere in the findings of the Medical Board by virtue of
Regulation 117 of Pension Regulations for the Army, 1961 regarding
‘Individuals Invalided’ out on account of Indulgence in Drugs & Drinks.
11.
Learned Senior Standing Counsel for the Central Government
further submitted that it is a settled preposition of law that when the
Medical Board assessed the relief at 11% to 14%, it cannot be
attributable nor aggravated by military service and it is not connected
to military service. Therefore, the Tribunal ought not to have allowed
the claim of the respondent.
12.
Learned Senior Standing Counsel for the Central Government
also contended that the Courts do not have the necessary medical
expertise to assess the disability and as such must maintain restraint
in medical assessment.
Hence, the Tribunal is not justified in
interfering with medical assessment, which has been done by following
due process of law.
13.
Having heard the learned Senior Standing Counsel for the
Central Government at the stage of admission and on a perusal of
records, the question that falls for our determination is “whether the
impugned order passed by the Tribunal which holds the respondent
eligible for invalid pension and the pensionary benefits that follow and
condones the shortfall in his qualifying service, calls for interference
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India in view of the finding of
the Invaliding Medical Board that his disability is neither attributable to
nor aggravated by military service and the rule of judicial restraint in
the matters of medical assessment?”
14.
The present Writ Petition is taken up and disposed of at the
admission stage.
This Court has jurisdiction under Article 226 to
examine the orders of the Armed Forces Tribunal, but the jurisdiction
is supervisory. It does not make this Court a second appellate forum.
It is exercised where the Tribunal has acted without jurisdiction or has
committed a patent error of law or has reached to a conclusion that is
perverse.
The Department must show that the Tribunal ignored a
statutory provision or misapplied a binding precedent or arrived at a
result that no reasonable adjudicator could reach. A different view of
the matter is not a ground for interference.
15.
We have perused the order of the Tribunal which examined the
pleadings and the record at length and has relied extensively on
various judgments and applied them to facts that are not in dispute.
The respondent was enrolled in the Indian Army on 05.07.2000 and
was invalided out of service on 19.01.2010 under Rule 13(3) III of the
Army Rules, 1954 after rendering 9 years 6 months and 15 days of
service. The Invaliding Medical Board had found him medically unfit.
The Army itself sanctioned Invalid Gratuity DCRG and MOC to him by
letter dated 24.03.2011. On these facts the Tribunal held that he is
eligible for invalid pension and condoned the shortfall in his qualifying
service. An order that rests on authority and on admitted facts is not
one that we can fault merely because the Department wishes for a
different outcome.
16.
The Department relied on the finding of the Invaliding Medical
Board that Alcohol Dependence Syndrome assessed at 11 to 14% is
neither attributable to nor aggravated by military service.
The
contention of the learned Senior Standing Counsel for the Central
Government is that this finding bars the claim. We do not accept that
the finding has this effect. Attributability to or aggravation by service
is the test for disability pension which is a compensatory benefit that
depends on the cause of disability and the extent of the disablement.
Invalid pension is a different benefit which is meant for a person who
is invalided out on medical grounds and who has the qualifying service
that the pension scheme requires.
The finding of non-attributability
answers the first question and does not answer the second.
17.
The Department’s own affidavit shows the mismatch. The first
issue is stated by them to be whether the respondent is eligible for
invalid pension having been invalided out.
The answer they give is
that the respondent is not eligible for disability pension because the
disability is not attributable to service. That answer is addressed to a
different benefit.
The second issue which the Department frames is
whether the respondent is entitled to pensionary benefits after
condonation of the shortfall in pensionary service.
The Department
thus acknowledge that the real controversy concerns the qualifying
service and not the attributability of the disease.
18.
The Department relied on Regulation 117 of the Pension
Regulations for the Army, 1961 which as they describe it deals with
individuals invalided out on account of indulgence in drugs and drink.
The Department has not shown that the regulation takes away invalid
pension from a person who has otherwise qualified for it. They have
also not shown any finding that the respondent was discharged for
misconduct. He was invalided out on medical grounds and the Army
sanctioned the benefits that follow ‘invalidment’.
A regulation that
defeats a pensionary benefit must be read strictly and cannot be
extended by implication to a case that is not clearly within its terms.
19.
This Bench accepts the principle that Courts and Tribunals do
not possess medical expertise and must be slow to disturb the
assessment of a duly constituted medical board.
This Bench applied
that principle. Neither the Tribunal nor this Court has substituted its
own medical opinion. The finding of the Invaliding Medical Board on
the
nature
undisturbed.
of
the
disease
and
its
non-attributability
stands
What the Tribunal decided is the legal consequence of
that finding for a person who has been invalided out with a little less
than 10 years of service. That is a question of interpretation of the
pension regulations and of the application of precedent. It lies within
the competence of the Tribunal.
The rule of restraint concerns
medical assessment and does not shield the legal consequences from
review.
20.
The respondent rendered 9 years 6 months and 15 days of
service.
He did not leave of his own accord.
His service ended
because the Army found him medically unfit. The shortfall is marginal
when compared with the period of 10 years. Pension is not a bounty
granted at the pleasure of the State. It is a benefit earned by service.
A rule on qualifying service must be applied with that purpose in mind.
The condonation of a small shortfall in the case of a person whose
service was cut short by the employer’s own medical finding is
consistent with the object of the scheme.
The Department has not
pointed to any provision that bars condonation in such a case. It has
also not shown that the Tribunal exercised the power arbitrarily. Its
own formulation of the second issue recognises that condonation is a
known step.
21.
We therefore find no jurisdictional error and no perversity in the
order of the Tribunal. Accordingly, the Writ Petition stands dismissed
at the admission stage and the impugned order passed by the Tribunal
is upheld.
The question framed in the preceding paragraph stands
answered in favour of the respondent and against the Department.
22.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending if any, shall stand
closed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
________________
P. SAM KOSHY, ACJ
__________________________
NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA, J
Date: 11.11.2026
GSD
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review