Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA
WRIT PETITION No.25112 of 2021
(CNR No.HBHC010404452021)
Date of Order: 11.11.2026
Reserved on : 23.09.2026
Pronounced on : 11.11.2026
Uploaded on : 12.11.2026
Between:
M/s. Tecumseh Products India Private Limited.
…Petitioner
AND
Income Tax Officer, National Faceless Assessment Centre,
Room No. 401, 2nd Floor, E-Ramp, Jawahar Lal Nehru Stadium,
Delhi – 110003 and 3 Others.
…Respondents
ORDER: (per Hon’ble the Acting Chief Justice P.Sam Koshy)
Heard Mr. Harpreet Singh Ajmani, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of Mr. G. Narendra Chetty, learned counsel for the petitioner;
and Ms. J. Sunitha, learned Senior Standing Counsel for Income Tax
Department appearing on behalf of the respondents.
2.
The instant Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India has been filed by the petitioner challenging the impugned Final
Assessment
Order
bearing
DIN
ITBA/AST/S/143(3)/2021-
22/1035556860(1), dated 14.09.2021, passed by respondent No.1
under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B of the Income Tax Act,
1961 (for short the ‘Act’) to be illegal, nullity and void ab initio, as it
has been passed in non-compliance with the provisions of section
144C of the Act, whereby the Final Assessment Order was passed
without complying with Section 144C which mandates a draft
assessment order to be passed before the final assessment order.
3.
The facts of the case are that the petitioner was a private
limited company incorporated under the provisions of the Companies
Act, 1956 and was engaged in the business of manufacture of
hermetically sealed compressors in India, which were widely used in
air
conditioners,
applications.
petitioner
refrigerators
and
commercial
refrigeration
Engineering solutions were also provided by the
through
Computer
Aided
Designing,
Engineering
and
Manufacturing (for short ‘CADEM’). For the assessment year 2018-19,
a revised return of income was filed by the petitioner on 30.11.2018,
declaring NIL total income after setting off the current year losses
amounting to Rs.14,31,785/-.
4.
The case of the petitioner was selected for scrutiny under the
Computer Aided Scrutiny Selection system (for short ‘CASS’) and a
notice under Section 143(2) of the Act was issued on 22.09.2020.
Subsequently, a notice along with a questionnaire was issued under
Section 142(1) of the Act on 26.11.2020. In response to the notice
under Section 142(1), a reply was filed by the petitioner vide letters
dated 10.12.2020 and 28.12.2020, and all the preliminary documents
were placed on record.
5.
A reference was thereafter made under Section 92CA of the Act
to the Transfer Pricing Officer (for short ‘TPO’) on 01.03.2021, for
determination of the Arm’s Length Price (for short ‘ALP’) of the
international transactions entered into by the petitioner with its
Associated Enterprises (for short ‘AEs’).
A notice under Section
92CA(2) was issued by the TPO to the petitioner on 29.03.2021,
calling upon the petitioner to file the documents maintained in terms
of Section 92D(3) of the Act.
notice
on
25.07.2021,
The TPO then issued a show cause
rejecting
the
transfer
pricing
analysis
undertaken by the petitioner and requesting further explanations. An
order was passed by the TPO under Section 92CA(3) of the Act on
31.07.2021
proposing
Rs.65,78,92,738/-
on
a
transfer
account
of
pricing
the
adjustment
following
transactions:
(i) Sale and Manufacture of Goods: Rs.63,92,95,748/-.
(ii) Interest on ECBs: Rs.34,82,917/-;
(iii) Business Support Services: Rs.40,13,628.
(iv) Interest on Trade Receivables: Rs.1,11,00,445/-.
of
international
It was clearly mentioned in the said order that the respondent
No.1 was mandatorily required to follow the provisions of Section
144C of the Act before passing the final order.
6.
In compliance with the provisions of Section 144B of the Act, a
show cause notice proposing variation on account of the Transfer
Pricing adjustments was issued to the petitioner on 01.09.2021.
In
the meanwhile, a rectification application dated 03.09.2021 was filed
by the petitioner under Section 154 of the Act before the TPO
requesting rectification of mistakes apparent from the record. On the
same day, a reply to the show cause notice dated 01.09.2021 was
also filed by the petitioner, wherein reliance was placed on the
submissions made before the TPO to dispute the variation to the
returned income on account of the Transfer Pricing adjustments.
Without prejudice to the above, respondent No.1 was also requested
to consider the rectified amounts in terms of the rectification
application
filed
before
the
TPO
for
the
purpose
of
making
adjustments.
7.
The petitioner
was
denied the remedy of
disputing the
assessment order by raising objections before the Dispute Resolution
Panel (for short ‘DRP’) as provided for under Section 144C of the Act,
as the option of filing objections before the DRP was not available on
the e-proceedings portal of the Income Tax Department.
The only
option visible on the said portal was to file an appeal before the
Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), which, according to the
petitioner further corroborated that the impugned order had been
passed in contravention of Section 144C of the Act and was a final
assessment order.
Reliance was also placed by the petitioner, in
support of this contention, on the assessment framed for the
assessment year 2017-18 wherein a draft assessment order had been
passed.
8.
The objections raised by the petitioner to the proposed
adjustments were rejected, and the Final Assessment Order was
passed on 14.09.2021 by respondent No.1 under Section 143(3) read
with Section 144B of the Act for the assessment year 2018-19, in
complete disregard of the procedure contained in Section 144C of the
Act.
Aggrieved, the petitioner challenged the legality and validity of
the impugned Final Assessment Order dated 14.09.2021 by way of the
present Writ Petition.
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the procedure
of framing an assessment under Section 144C read with section 144B
of the Act is to be mandatorily followed and at the first instance a
“draft order” has to be passed in case of an “eligible assessee” in
terms of section 144C(1) read with section 144C(15)(b) and 144B of
the Act. It is pertinent to mention that Section 144C(15)(b) of the Act
defines an “eligible assessee” to be:
i.
Any person in whose case the variation referred to sub-section
(1) to section 144C of the Act arises as a consequence of an
order of the TPO; and
ii.
Any foreign company and the final assessment order dated
14.09.2021 passed under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B
of the Act without passing a “draft order” in terms of Section
144C(1) of the Act is illegal, bad in law a nullity.
10.
Learned counsel for petitioner further submitted that the factum
of the impugned order being a “final assessment order” and not a
“draft order” is further corroborated from the fact that it was passed
under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B of the Act (as sated in
the assessment order), and the notice of demand under Section 156 of
the Act has been issued and directions have been given in the
impugned assessment order to also initiate penalty proceedings
separately.
Further, it is also evident from the screenshot of
Department's online portal which depicts that the petitioner only has
an option to file an appeal before the Commissioner of Income tax
(Appeals) and resultantly, the vested right of the petitioner to get the
assessment framed in terms of Section 144C read with Section 144B
of the Act is abrogated.
Therefore, the impugned assessment order
dated 14.09.2021 and the consequential notices are unsustainable in
law, illegal and a nullity.
11.
Learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the decision of
the Bombay High Court in the case of SHL (India) (P) Ltd. vs. CIT1
wherein it was held that the Assessing Officer cannot straightaway
pass a final assessment order without issuing a draft assessment order
under Section 144C(1), even in the case of remand of proceedings and
that such an omission is not a mere irregularity, but an incurable
illegality, which cannot be saved by Section 292B of the Act.
12.
On the other hand, the learned Senior Standing Counsel for
Income Tax Department relied upon the decision of the Delhi High
Court in the case of Interglobe Enterprises (P) Ltd. vs. NFAC2
wherein it was held that since there existed a statutory remedy
available for the petitioner; the Writ Petition was not maintainable for
the present case.
13.
Having heard the contentions put forth on either side and on
perusal of records, the question that falls for our consideration is
whether the Final Assessment Order dated 14.09.2021 passed by
respondent No.1 under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B of the
Act without first forwarding a draft assessment order to the petitioner
under Section 144C(1) of the Act where the proposed variation arose
from the order of the Transfer Pricing Officer under Section 92CA(3) is
without jurisdiction and a nullity and whether the availability of an
(2021) 3 HCC (Bom) 99
(2023) 450 ITR 126
appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) bars this
Court from entertaining the Writ Petition.
14.
Section 144C of the Act lays down a special procedure for a
class of assessees described as eligible assessees.
The Assessing
Officer must in the first instance forward a draft of the proposed order
of assessment to an eligible assessee if he proposes a variation in the
returned income or loss that is prejudicial to the assessee. An eligible
assessee under Section 144C(15)(b) includes any person in whose
case the variation arises as a consequence of the order of the Transfer
Pricing Officer under Section 92CA(3).
The petitioner falls in that
class.
15.
The draft order starts a process that the Act sets out in a fixed
order.
The eligible assessee may either accept the draft or raise
objections before the DRP and before the Assessing Officer. The Panel
is a body of senior officers of the Department that is independent of
the Assessing Officer.
It issues directions on the objections and the
Assessing Officer then completes the assessment in conformity with
those directions. The assessee thus gets the benefit of a review by a
collegiate authority before any final order is made against it. That is a
substantive right and not a procedural nicety.
16.
Section 144C(1) opens with a non-obstante clause and applies
notwithstanding anything to the contrary in the Act.
It therefore
overrides the general power to make an assessment under Section
143(3) in cases that fall within its scope. The Bombay High Court in
SHL (India) (P) Ltd. (supra) has noticed the same feature of the
provision and held as under:
“24. The decision of the Delhi High Court in JCB India Ltd. v. CIT
[JOB India Ltd. v. CIT, 2017 SCC OnLine Del 10424] also reemphasises that the assessing officer cannot straight away pass a
final assessment order without issuing a draft assessment order
under
Section
144-C(1),
even
in
the
case
of
remand
of
proceedings and that such an omission is not a mere irregularity,
but an incurable illegality, which cannot be saved by Section 292-B
of the IT Act. Paras 17, 18, 19 and 20 of the said decision are
relevant and the same are quoted as under:
“17. The court is unable to agree with the submissions
made on behalf of the Revenue by Mr Jain. Section
144-G(1) of the Act is unambiguous. It requires the AO
to pass a draft assessment order after receipt of the
report from the TPO. There is nothing in the wording of
Section
144-C(1)
which
would
indicate
that
this
requirement of passing a draft assessment order does
not arise where the exercise had been undertaken by
the TPO on remand to it, of the said issue, by the ITAT.
18. It was then contended by Mr Jain that the
assessment order passed by the AO should not be
declared to be invalid because of the failure to first pass
a draft assessment order under Section 144-C of the
Act. In this regard, reference is made to Section 292-B
of the Act.
19. As already noted, the final assessment order of the
AO stood vitiated not on account of mere irregularity
but since it was an incurable illegality: Section 292-B of
the Act would not protect such an order. This has been
explained
by
this
Court
in
CIT
v.
Citi
Financial
Consumer Finance India (P) Ltd. [CIT v. Citi Financial
Consumer Finance India (P) Ltd., 2015 SCC OnLine Del
14678] where it was held:
‘Section 292-B of the Act cannot be read to confer
jurisdiction on the AO where none exists. The said
section only protects return of income, assessment,
notice,
summons
or
other
proceedings
from
any
mistake in such return of income, assessment notices,
summons or other proceedings, provided the same are
in substance and in effect in conformity with the intent
of purposes of the Act.’
20. The court further observed that Section 292-B of
the Act cannot save an order not passed in accordance
with the provisions of the Act. As the court explained,
‘the issue involved is not about a mistake in the said
order but the power of the AO to pass the order’.”
26. In our view, the following principles emerge from the above
discussion:
(i) That the procedure prescribed under Section 144-C of the IT
Act is a mandatory procedure and not directory.
(ii) Failure to follow the procedure under Section 144-C(1)
would be a jurisdictional error and not merely procedural error
or irregularity.
(iii) Therefore, Section 292-B of the IT Act cannot save an
order passed in breach of the provisions of Section 144-C(1),
the same being an incurable illegality.
27. It is important to note that Section 144-C(1) is a non obstante
provision, which requires its compliance irrespective of the other
provisions that may be contained in the IT Act. There is no dispute
that petitioner is an eligible assessee and also there is no dispute
as to the applicability of Section 144-C. It is also not in dispute
that the final assessment order has been passed without the draft
assessment order as contemplated under Section 144-C(1) of the
IT Act. The assessing officer ought to have in the first instance
forwarded a draft of the proposed order of assessment to
petitioner, as there was a proposed variation prejudicial to the
interest of the assessee. This important step has been completely
omitted by the respondent taking away a very necessary right of
petitioner to file objections to the proposed variation with the DRP
and the assessing officer, which in our view, strikes to the root of
the procedure contemplated by Section 144-C.
28. Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of this case, we
are of the view that the failure on the part of the assessing officer
to follow the procedure under Section 144-C(1) is not a merely
procedural or inadvertent error, but a breach of a mandatory
provision. We are also not impressed with the arguments of the
Revenue that the assessing officer was under pressure of two
charges, as there were timelines to adhere to, since the said
timelines from time to time have been extended, the most recent
one being to 30-9-2021. The Revenue ought to have appreciated
that the requirement under Section 144-C(1) to first pass a draft
assessment order and to provide a copy thereof to the assessee is
a mandatory requirement which gave substantive right to the
assessee to object to any variation, that is prejudicial to it. In this
case, the order under Section 92-CA(3) of the IT Act, proposed to
make an adjustment of Rs 10,74,54,337 to the arm's length price
considered as nil “by petitioner and to that extent the said
adjustment was evidently prejudicial to the interest of petitioner
depriving petitioner of this valuable right to raise objection before
DRP would be denial of substantive rights to the assessee, for
which, in our view, the assessing officer has no power under the
statute, as the provision clearly mandates the assessing officer to
pass and furnish a draft assessment order in the first instance in
such a case. The legislature, in our view, has intended to give an
important opportunity to petitioner, who is an eligible assessee,
which in our view, has been taken away. In our view, failure to
follow
the
procedure
under
Section
144-C(1)
would
be
a
jurisdictional error and not merely procedural error or a mere
irregularity. The assessment order has not been passed in
accordance with the provisions of Section 144-C of the IT Act. This
is not an issue, which involves a mistake in the said order, but it
involves the power of the assessing officer to pass the order. By
not following the procedure laid down in Section 144-C(1) to pass
and furnish a draft assessment order to petitioner and directly
passing a final assessment order and without giving petitioner an
opportunity to raise objections before the DRP, there is a complete
contravention of Section 144-C, the assessing officer having
wrongly assumed jurisdiction to straight away pass the final order.
This is not a mere irregularity but an incurable illegality Even the
provisions of Section 292-B of the IT Act would not protect such an
order as Section 292-B of the IT Act cannot be read to confer
jurisdiction on the assessing officer, where none exists. The
Supreme Court decision in CIT v. M. PiraiChoodi [CIT v. M.
PiraiChoodi, (2010) 15 SCC 283 : (2011) 334 ITR 262] referred to
in the Revenue's reply is also not applicable to the issue at hand as
that was a case where the assessee was not given an opportunity
to cross-examine the witness concerned and which assessee also
had a statutory appellate remedy which the assessee had failed to
avail of, whereas there is no such right available to petitioner in
this case. In fact, petitioner has lost a substantive right due to the
failure of the respondents to pass and forward a draft assessment
order in the first instance on a variance, prejudicial to the interest
of petitioner. In our view, this is clearly a case of jurisdictional
error. The final assessment order passed by the assessing officer
stands vitiated on account of lack of jurisdiction, which is incurable
and deserves to be set aside as void ab initio.”
17.
Section 144B regulates the manner in which assessments are
conducted under the faceless scheme.
It does not displace Section
144C. The two provisions deal with different matters. A show cause
notice proposing a variation under the faceless scheme is not a draft
order
under
Section
144C(1)
and
does
not
carry
the
same
consequences. After a show cause notice the assessee is left with the
statutory appeal against the final order.
After a draft order the
assessee has the additional forum of the DRP. The show cause notice
dated 01.09.2021 therefore cannot stand in for the draft order that
Section 144C(1) requires.
18.
The order of the TPO itself recorded that the Assessing Officer
was mandatorily required to follow Section 144C before passing the
final order.
The Revenue was thus told by its own officer in plain
terms what procedure had to be followed.
Respondent No.1
nevertheless issued a show cause notice on 01.09.2021 and received
the petitioner’s reply on 03.09.2021 and thereafter passed the Final
Assessment Order on 14.09.2021 under Section 143(3) read with
Section 144B. No draft order was ever forwarded to the petitioner.
19.
Several features of the impugned order show that it is a final
assessment order and was never meant to be a draft. It was passed
under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B as stated on its face. A
notice of demand under Section 156 was issued along with it. It also
directed that penalty proceedings be initiated separately.
None of
these steps is taken in a draft order. The Revenue has not explained
how an order carrying them can be treated as anything other than
final.
20.
The petitioner also points out that the e-proceedings portal
offered it no facility to file objections before the Dispute Resolution
Panel
and
showed
only
the
option
of
an
appeal
before
the
Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals). The portal thus treated the
order as a final one. This is consistent with our reading. We also note
that for the assessment year 2017-18 the same Department framed
the assessment by first passing a draft order.
No reason has been
offered for adopting a different procedure for the next year in a case
of the same kind.
A statutory right cannot be lost because of the
manner in which a portal is configured.
The petitioner cannot be
faulted for failing to raise objections before the Panel when no draft
order was ever served on it. The loss of that forum is the direct result
of the omission of the Department.
21.
In the case of SHL (India) (P) Ltd. (supra), the Bombay High
Court considered the effect of passing a final assessment order
without a draft order. It held that the procedure under Section 144C
is mandatory and not directory. It held that a failure to follow Section
144C(1) is a jurisdictional error and not a mere procedural irregularity.
It held further that Section 292B cannot save an order passed in
breach of Section 144C(1) because the breach is an incurable
illegality. It also observed that the omission strikes at the root of the
procedure by taking away the right of the assessee to object before
the Panel.
22.
The Revenue relied on the case of Interglobe Enterprises (P)
Ltd. (supra) for the proposition that the petitioner has an alternative
statutory remedy and that the writ petition is not maintainable. The
rule of alternative remedy is a rule of discretion and not one of
jurisdiction.
It yields
where
the impugned action is
without
jurisdiction or in breach of natural justice or in violation of a
mandatory
statutory
procedure.
The
relevant
paragraphs
are
reproduced below for ready reference:
“7. Since in the present case no prior show-cause notice as well as
draft assessment order had been issued and no hearing had been
given before passing the impugned assessment order, there is a
blatant violation of principles of natural justice as well as
mandatory procedure prescribed in "Faceless Assessment Scheme"
and stipulated in section 144B of the Act.
8. It is also settled law that an alternative statutory remedy does
not operate as a bar to maintainability of a writ petition where the
proceeding is carried out in violation of principles of natural justice
- like in the present case.
9. Keeping in view the aforesaid facts and mandate of law, the
impugned assessment order dated April 9, 2021 and notice of
demand for the assessment year 2018-19 are set aside and the
matter is remanded back to the Assessing Officer, who shall issue
a draft assessment order and grant an opportunity of hearing to
the petitioner by way of video conferencing and thereafter pass a
reasoned order in accordance with law. With the aforesaid
direction, the present writ petition along with pending application
stands disposed of.
23.
The decision of Interglobe (supra) placed before us does not
support the Revenue.
The Delhi High Court there found a blatant
violation of natural justice and of the mandatory procedure of the
faceless scheme because no draft order had been issued and no
hearing had been granted.
It held in terms that an alternative
statutory remedy is no bar to a Writ Petition where the proceeding is
carried out in violation of principles of natural justice.
It then set
aside the assessment order and the notice of demand and remanded
the matter to the Assessing Officer to issue a draft assessment order
and grant a hearing.
The decision therefore supports the petitioner
and also indicates the course that is appropriate here.
24.
An appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) is
a remedy against a final assessment order validly made. It is not a
substitute for the very procedure that the Act prescribes in its place.
The petitioner would have to give up the forum of the Panel to which it
is entitled before the final order and would be left with an appeal
against an order that should never have been made in that form.
25.
We also place our reliance on the decision of this Court in the
case of Principal Commissioner of Income Tax-2, Hyderabad vs.
M/s. Hyundai Motor India Engineering Pvt. Ltd.3 wherein the
petitioner was granted relief on similar lines as in the present case. In
paragraph No.18 of the said judgment, it was held as under:
“18.Given the aforesaid legal position as it stands, as is required
under Section 144-C of the Act and also taking note of the
contents of the operative part of the so called assessment order, in
I.T.T.A. No.29 of 2023, dated 11.09.2023
the considered opinion of this Bench leads to the only conclusion of
the order being a final assessment order, more particularly, when
the authority concerned has also ordered and directed for initiation
of penalty
proceedings simultaneously along with the draft
assessment order. Hence, this Bench has no hesitation in reaching
to the conclusion that the findings arrived at by the Tribunal while
allowing the appeal of the respondent/assessee was proper, legal
and justified. That the present appeal thus being devoid of merits,
deserves tobe and is accordingly, rejected. There shall be no order
as to costs.
26.
Therefore, the Final Assessment Order dated 14.09.2021 was
passed without the draft order that Section 144C(1) of the Act
requires and it is without jurisdiction and cannot be sustained. We do
not examine the merits of the Transfer Pricing adjustment of
Rs.65,78,92,738/- or the other contentions raised by the petitioner in
relation to it.
Those will be open for consideration before the Panel
after a draft order is passed.
The proper course is to restore the
proceedings to the stage that followed the order of the TPO.
The
order under Section 92CA(3) is not challenged before us. The defect
lies in what the Assessing Officer did afterwards.
A remand to that
stage will allow the statutory scheme to take its course.
27.
For the foregoing reasons the Writ Petition stands allowed.
The Final Assessment Order bearing dated 14.09.2021, passed by
respondent No.1, under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B of the
Act for the assessment year 2018-19 is set aside. The notice of
demand under Section 156 of the Act and the directions for initiation
of penalty proceedings issued with it also stand set aside.
28.
The question of law framed is answered in favour of the
petitioner and against the Revenue.
29.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending if any, shall stand
closed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
________________
P. SAM KOSHY, ACJ
__________________________
NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA, J
Date: 11.11.2026
GSD
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review