The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. Accordingly, we set aside the orders passed by the learned Single Judge and the Division Bench of the High Court and direct that the case of the Appellant be reconsidered by the concerned Respondents in accordance with the Circular No.14-GR of 1990 dated 6th March, 1990, for the purpose of granting retrospective effect to the promotion already granted to him on 19th August, 2000, and if such retrospective effect is given, to consider such other benefits that he may, thereafter, become entitled to in accordance with law. The said exercise should be completed within three months from the date of communication of this order." 6 . This in view of the aforesaid, the petition deserves to be and is accordingly allowed. The impugned order dated 31/7/2020 (Annexure P/11) passed by the respondent No.2 is hereby set aside and the respondents are directed to grant out-of-turn promotion to the petitioner retrospectively with all consequential benefit forthwith in accordance with law, within a period of 3 months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
7. The petition is accordingly, allowed and disposed off. C.c. as per rules.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRANAY VERMA
ON THE 12th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 23675 of 2021
BETWEEN:VINOD KUMAR DIXIT S/O SHRI P N DIXIT, AGED ABOUT
54 YEARS, OCCUPATION: GOVT. SERVICE 59, S.F. HIG
VIJAY NAGAR, INDROE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI VIVEK SHARAN - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY VALLABH
BHAWAN
BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE POLICE
HEADQUARTERS BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
INSPECTOR
GENERAL OF POLICE INDORE
RANGE INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI ANENDRA SINGH PARIHAR - P.L. FOR STATE)
This petition coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the
following:
ORDER
1. With the consent of the parties heard finally.
2 . By this petition preferred under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the petitioner has prayed for the following relief(s):Signature Not Verified
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 1/12/2024
4:51:06 PM
"(i) That, the Hon'ble Court be pleased to allow the petition
by quashing the impugned order dated 31/7/2020.
(ii) To, direct the respondent to grant the Seniority to the
petitioner w.e.f. 4.4.2006 on the post of Inspector.
(iii) To, direct the respondent to grant all consequential
benefits to the petitioner forthwith.
(iv) Any other relief, which the Hon'ble Court deems fit in the
facts and circumstances of the case, be granted to the petitioners."
3 . At the outset learned counsel for the petitioner has brought to the
notice of this Court an order dated 6/12/2016 passed by the Principal Seat of
this Court at Jabalpur in W.P. No.14141/2012 ( Niranjan Sharma V/s. State
of M.P. & Ors. ) and has submitted that the present matter is squarely covered
by the said decision.
4 . The aforesaid contention has not been denied by the learned counsel
for the respondents/State.
5. In Niranjan Sharma (supra) it has been held by this Court as under
:10. Having considered the submissions made on behalf of
the parties and the material on record, as also the judgments of the
learned Single Judge and the Division bench of the High Court, it
does appear that the circumstances prevailing within the town of
Charare Sharif and in Chadoora were different during the
disturbance and the decision to grant out-of-turn promotion to
Shaikh Hamidulla, who was the Station House Officer, Charare
Sharif, during those fateful days was fully justified.
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 1/12/2024
4:51:06 PM
11. In the absence of any glaring discrepancy or bias in the
decision making process, ordinarily the Court does not normally
take upon itself the task of making a subjective assessment of an
officer's performance in relation to matters of promotion and that
too of the nature contemplated in the present case. However, at the
same time, the Court is also entitled to consider the materials
placed before it in order to arrive at a conclusion as to whether an
injustice has been caused t the concerned officer. In the present
case, both the Superintendent and Senior Superintendent of Police,
Budgam District, had a chance to observe the Appellant's
performance on the ground on 10th and 11th of May, 1995, when
the incident was actually taking place and they have recommended
that the appellant should be given out-of -turn promotion. The
Director General of Police has also recognized the exemplary
performance of the appellant. All such recommendations seemed to
suggest that the performance of the appellant merited special
consideration. Of course, the appellant has already been promoted
to the post of Inspector on 19th August, 2000, and the only
question which now survives is whether such promotion should be
given retrospective effect from the date on which Shaikh Hamidulla
and Sub-Inspector Sonaullah were given such promotion.
12. While considering the appellant's claim for out-of-turn
promotion or accelarated promotion in the Writ Petiton filed by
him, the learned Single Judge took special note of the condition,
procedure and norms which provided that out-of-turn promotion
would be considered only for consistently exceptional performance
on the anti-militancy front. The learned Judge took not of the fact
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 1/12/2024
4:51:06 PM
that except for two episodes, which, in any event, were performed
in the usual course of duties, the same did not constitute any
consistent exceptional performance. The said view was endorsed by
the Division Bench while dismissing the Letters Patent Appeal filed
by the appellant herein.
13. Neither the learned Single Judge nor the Division Bench
of the High Court appears to have given proper attention to the
Circular No.14-GR of 1990 dated 6.3.1990, in relation to the
recommendations which had been made by the Superintendent and
the Senior Superintendent of Police, Budgam District. However,
the final assessment for giving out-of-turn promotion lay with
Director General of Police and in his judgment a cash reward of
Rs.2,000/- was felt to be appropriate in recognition of the
exemplary services rendered by the appellant.
14. However, from the materials on record it is quite clear
that the claim of the appellant is covered by the policy decision of
the Government contained in Circular No.14-GR of 1990 dated
6th March, 1990, which provided an incentive to all Government
employees to give their best performance of duties in the service of
the people and in meeting the challenge of the anti-national forces
to disturb the law and order situation in the State. It is only
subsequently that on 6th January, 2000, that a Government Order
No.Home-3(P) of 2000 was published by the State in its Home
Department regarding the procedure for out-of-turn promotion in
the Police Department. It is in the said circular that it has been
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 1/12/2024
4:51:06 PM
indicated that out-of-turn promotion could be considered only for
consistently exceptional performance on the anti-militancy front
and that the recommendations of the Director General of Police,
along with the dossier of the concerned employee, along with other
formalities and the extent of deviation from the seniority rule, would
have to be placed before the Home Department Select Committee
for consideration and recommendation which would then be
placed before the Chief Minister with the prior approval of the
Minister of State, Home Department.
15. The aforesaid circular dated 6th January, 2000, directly
links up out-of-turn promotion with the concept of consistently
exceptional performance on the anti-militancy front, which did not
figure in the earlier Circular No.14-GR of 1990 dated 6th March,
1990. Both the learned Single Judge and the Division Bench
appear to have overlooked the difference in the two different
circulars and the decision of the learned Single Judge is based on
the later Circular dated 6th January, 2000, while the Appellant's
claim is under the earlier Circular of 6th March, 1990, in relation
to incidents which had taken place prior to the promulgation of
the Government Order dated 6th January, 2000.
16. In fact, in the Supplementary Affidavit filed on behalf of
the State of Jammu and Kashmir on 3rd August, 2010, the said
two circulars have been referred to and it has been submitted that
the Circular of 6th January, 2000, had been issued in continuation
and in addition to the Circular dated 6th March, 1990. It has also
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 1/12/2024
4:51:06 PM
been stated that since the Circular dated 6th January, 2010, was
issued subsequent to the circular issued in the year 1990, cases
which have occurred after the issuance of the 2000 Circular would
be subject to the same. It has been categorically stated that the case
of the Appellant belongs to the period prior to the issuance of the
2000 Circular and, therefore, he would be governed by the 1990
Circular. Of course, it has also been submitted that the said
Circular dated 6th March, 1990, does not confer any legal right
on the Appellant nor does it cast any obligation on the State of
Jammu and Kashmir, since it was only an internal guideline which
authorized the State Government to grant out-of-turn promotion in
cases where the officials of the Jammu and Kashmir Police display
exemplary bravery and courage in confronting terrorists, militants
and insurgents. In the said affidavit it has been sought to be
justified that the case of the Appellant did not merit out-of-turn
promotion and he deserved a cash reward which had been duly
awarded to him.
17. It is clear that the Respondent State of Jammu and
Kashmir is also alive to the fact that the claim of the Appellant has
to be considered in the light of the earlier Circular dated 6th
March, 1990, and not by the subsequent Circular dated 6th
January, 2000.
18. In these circumstances, we are of the view that the
Appellant's claim for out-of-turn promotion, on the basis of the
facts disclosed, require reconsideration in the light of the Circular
dated 6th March, 1990, and not the Circular dated 6th January,
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 1/12/2024
4:51:06 PM
2000, as has been sought to be done in his case.
19.
Accordingly, we set aside the orders passed by the
learned Single Judge and the Division Bench of the High Court
and direct that the case of the Appellant be reconsidered by the
concerned Respondents in accordance with the Circular No.14-GR
of 1990 dated 6th March, 1990, for the purpose of granting
retrospective effect to the promotion already granted to him on 19th
August, 2000, and if such retrospective effect is given, to consider
such other benefits that he may, thereafter, become entitled to in
accordance with law. The said
exercise should be completed
within three months from the date of communication of this order."
6 . This in view of the aforesaid, the petition deserves to be and is
accordingly allowed. The impugned order dated 31/7/2020 (Annexure P/11)
passed by the respondent No.2 is hereby set aside and the respondents are
directed to grant out-of-turn promotion to the petitioner retrospectively with all
consequential benefit forthwith in accordance with law, within a period of 3
months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
7. The petition is accordingly, allowed and disposed off.
C.c. as per rules.
(PRANAY VERMA)
JUDGE
SS/-
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 1/12/2024
4:51:06 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review