Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND RAMESH PHADKE
ON THE 8th OF SEPTEMBER, 2023
WRIT PETITION No. 29192 of 2022
BETWEEN:DHIRAJ KUMAR SHARMA S/O SHRI MUKESH KUMAR
SHARMA, AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
SERVICE PRESENTLY POSTED AS MARKETING
EXECUTIVE MP STATE TOURISM DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION
REGIONAL
OFFICE
GWALIOR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY MS. SMIRITI SHARMA- ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TOURISM DEPARTMENT
GOVT OF MP VALLABH BHAWAN BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
M.P.
STATE
TOURISM
DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION LTD THROUGH ITS MANAGING
D IR ECTOR , PARYATAN BHAWAN BHADBADA
ROAD BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
GENERAL MANAGER (ADMINISTRATION) M.P.
STATE TOURISM DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
PARYATAN BHAWAN BHADBADA ROAD, BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
REGIONAL MANAGER M.P. STATE TOURISM
DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION, REGIONAL
OFFICE GANDHI ROAD, GWALIOR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI TEJ SINGH MAHADIK- ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.4 )
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 24-01-2024
05:32:55 PM
This petition coming on for hearing this day, th e court passed the
following:
ORDER
Present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India has been
directed against the order dated 08.12.2022 passed by respondent No.3
whereby the petitioner who was working as Marketing Executive, M.P. State
Tourism Development Corporation, Bhopal, was ordered to be transferred in
the office of M.P. State Tourism Corporation, Lucknow. The said order was
assailed on the ground that petitioner is a contractual employee and his transfer
is not permissible under the law. The petitioner is further aggrieved by the illegal
and arbitrary action on the part of the respondents in not considering his case
for regularization whereas the petitioner was appointed after following due
process of law and has rendered more than 11 years of satisfactory service.
The petitioner is also aggrieved by arbitrary and discriminatory action of the
respondents in reducing his pay and treating him differently from the similarly
situated employees alleging it to be arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of
Articles 14, 16, 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India.
2.Short facts leading to the present controversy are that petitioner is
presently holding the post of Marketing Executive (Contract) and has been
posted in Madhya Pradesh State Tourism Development Corporation Ltd.,
Regional Office, Gandhi Road, Gwalior. The petitioner was appointed on the
aforesaid post in pursuance of his application submitted in regard to
advertisement issued by respondent No.2/Corporation inviting applications for
eligible candidates for certain vacant posts including the vacant post of
Marketing Executive. The petitioner was invited for interview and after following
due process of law vide order dated 11.02.2011 the petitioner was appointed on
the aforesaid post. After his appointment, vide order dated 25.02.2011, the
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 24-01-2024
05:32:55 PM
petitioner was directed to join at Regional Office Gwalior and in pursuance
thereof, the petitioner joined his services at Regional Office, Gwalior, on
26.02.2011 and since then the petitioner is discharging his duties in the said
office. Although in the advertisement, the respondent had fixed an honorarium
of Rs.15,000/- per month for the post of Marketing Executive, but later on while
issuing appointment order the honorarium was fixed at Rs.3,000/- per month.
Initially the appointment of petitioner was made only for a year, however, he
continued with the respondents and as on date he is working with the
respondent/Corporation. Subsequently in the year 2013 the honorarium of
similarly situated persons has been increased from Rs.15,000/- per month to
Rs.25,000/- per month, whereas the salary of petitioner was increased to
Rs.18,000/-. In such circumstances, the petitioner moved representations dated
20.1.2014 and 10.2.2014.
3.The said representations were considered and vide order dated
19.11.2015 the respondents enhanced the pay of petitioner at par with similarly
situated employees extending the benefit of increased salary w.e.f 17.02.2015.
However, on very next day i.e. vide order dated 20.11.2015 the respondents
confined the benefits of aforesaid increase w.e.f 1.11.2015 without assigning
any reason. Vide circular dated 5.6.2018 State of M.P. through General
Administration Department has framed a policy extending certain benefits to the
contract employees, but even though the petitioner was fulfilling the conditions
of the policy, the respondents neither extended the benefits of salary nor
considered case of the petitioner for regularization on equivalent post of
Manager and Tourism Officer, whereas respondents have made regular
appointments on the aforesaid posts.
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 24-01-2024
05:32:55 PM
4.It was further contended that during period of outbreak of Covid-19
Pandemic and its lock-down the respondents paid salary of 15 days and 22
days instead of 30 days to the employees of the Corporation. However, on
representations the retained salary of other employees was reimbursed, but
remaining salary of the petitioner of that period has not been paid to him. Vide
order dated 6.5.2022 while extending the contract period the respondents gave
an increase of 10% on total emoluments. Thus, in a way the respondents have
reduced the total emoluments which is totally illegal and arbitrary.
5.In the aforesaid regard, the petitioner submitted a representation for
extending the benefit of GAD policy dated 5.6.2018, but respondents instead of
extending the aforesaid benefit, not only reduced the pay of the petitioner, but
vide impugned order Annexure P/1 transferred him from Gwalior to Lucknow.
Being aggrieved with the aforesaid, present petition has been filed.
6.Learned counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued that action
on the part of the respondents in passing the impugned order Annexure P/1 and
further not extending the benefits of GAD circular dated 5.6.2018 and further
reducing the pay and emoluments of petitioner for no fault on his part is
absolutely illegal, arbitrary and violative of Article 14 & 16 of the Constitution
of India.
7. Learned counsel further contended that the petitioner is not holding
any transferable post and he is only a contract employee as such his transfer is
not permissible in the eyes of law, but without taking into consideration the
aforesaid facts vide order Annexure P-1 the petitioner has been transferred from
Gwalior to Lucknow.
8.It was further contended that as per condition No.4 of the appointment
dated 11.2.2011 the petitioner being a contract employee could not enjoy
Signature Notorder
Verified
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 24-01-2024
05:32:55 PM
any financial or administrative powers, but vide impugned order the petitioner
has been made in-charge of the Marketing Office Lucknow which would include
the financial and administrative powers which he could not exercise, thus, the
impugned order being contrary to the condition of appointment order, is not
sustainable in the eyes of law.
9.It was further contended that respondents have utterly failed to extend
the benefit of the policy of GAD dated 5.6.2018 though the petitioner has made
several representations
and
apart
from that,
they
have
fixed
his
honorarium/salary contrary to the conditions of advertisement and subsequently
has increased the salary of similarly situated persons, but the said benefit was
denied to the petitioner and recently respondents have granted only 10%
increase in honorarium, whereas right from beginning they were required to pay
annual increase of 10% on the total emoluments, meaning thereby the
respondents have reduced the salary of petitioner without assigning any reason
and without providing any opportunity of hearing. Thus the said action of the
respondents is arbitrary and discriminatory.
10.Lastly it was contended that even though petitioner has rendered more
than 11 years of satisfactory service and his initial appointment was made after
following due procedure of law, the case of the petitioner has not been
considered for regularization, which is pe rse illegal. To bolster the submission,
reliance was placed in the case of M.P. State Tourism Development
Corporation Ltd & Anr. Vs. The Municipal Corporation Gwalior & Anr.
in W.P.No.1588/2017 on 26.3.1998 and in the case of Mahesh Chandra Dixit
vs. State of M.P. in W.P.No.27026/2019 decided on 12.01.2023. Thus it was
prayed that impugned transfer order be quashed, that respondents be directed
to consider his case for regularization and proper increase be made in the
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 24-01-2024
05:32:55 PM
emoluments which are being paid to the petitioner.
11.Per contra, learned counsel for respondent No.4 has raised a
preliminarily objection with regard to maintainability of present petition on the
ground that respondents No.2 and 3 against whom the writ petition has been
preferred are Managing Director and General Manager of M.P. State Tourism
Development Corporation Ltd.
which is a Company registered under the
provisions of Companies Act, therefore, present writ petition is not maintainable
against a Company registered under the Companies Act and deserves to be
dismissed as not maintainable. To bolster his submission, reliance was placed in
the case of The Praga Tools Corporation vs. Shri C.A. Imanual and
others, (1969) 1 SCC 585.
12.Heard counsel for the parties and perused the record.
13.The preliminary objection which has been raised by learned counsel
for respondent No.4 is that a writ under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
is not maintainable against a Company incorporated under the Companies Act.
This Court first deems it fit to deal with the said issue.
14.It is well settled that a company registered under the Companies Act
does not have any statutory duty or function to perform and it is well
understood that a mandamus lies to secure the performance of a public or
statutory duty in the performance of which the one who applies for it has a
sufficient legal interest, though Article 226 of the Constitution of India provides
that the Court shall have power to issue to any person or authority orders and
writs including writs in the nature of habeas corpus, mandamus etc., or any of
them for the enforcement of any of the rights conferred by Part III of the
Constitution and for any other purpose, but since the Company incorporated
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 24-01-2024
05:32:55 PM
under the Companies Act does not perform any statutory duty or function, the
order of transfer or grievance with regard to any other personal relief is
essentially of a private character, and therefore, no such application can be
maintained to secure performance of obligations owed by a company towards
its employees or to resolve any private dispute. Therefore, the condition
precedent for the issue of writ of mandamus is that there is one, claiming it a
legal right to the performance of a legal duty by one, against whom it is
sought.
An order of mandamus is, in form, a command directed to a
person, corporation or an inferior tribunal requiring him or them to do a
particular thing therein specified which appertains to his or their office and is
in the nature of a public duty. It is however not necessary that the person or
authority on whom the statutory duty is imposed need be a public official or
an official body. A mandamus can be issued, for instance, to an official
of a society to compel him to carry out the terms of the statute under which
the society is
constituted or
governed
and
also
to
companies
or
corporations to carry out duties placed on them by the statutes authorizing
their undertakings. A mandamus would also lie against a company constituted
by a statute for the purposes of fulfilling public responsibilities.
15.The respondents herein being a non-statutory body and one incorporated
under the Companies Act, there was neither a statutory nor a public duty
imposed on it by a statute in respect of which enforcement could be sought
by means of a mandamus nor was there in its employees any corresponding
right for enforcement of any such statutory or public duty.
16.So far as the judgment cited by learned counsel for the petitioner in the
matter of M.P. State Tourism Development Corporation ltd. (supra) is
concerned, the same dealt with the issue with regard to payment of urban
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 24-01-2024
05:32:55 PM
development and education cess by the M.P. State Tourism Development
Corporation under the provisions of Madhya Pradesh Municipal Corporation
Act, 1956 wherein the issue was altogether different and exemption from
payment of the aforesaid tax was sought on the ground that land on which the
building of the Corporation was situated was owned by the State Government,
therefore, they are exempted from the property tax. Therein the status of M.P.
State Tourism Development Corporation as a Company was not in question nor
was considered. So far as reliance placed in the matter of Mahesh Chandra
Dixit (supra) is concerned, this Court in the said matter had analyzed the age
of superannuation of the employees of the Corporation under the bye-law 21 of
the Company and since the said bye-law provides for implementation of the
rules and regulations as framed by the State Government to the employees of
the Corporation, in that context, it was held that the age of superannuation of
the employees would be 62 years. In the aforesaid judgment also the question
of maintainability of the writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India for implementation of private rights was not under consideration.
Therefore, the same is also not applicable in the present case.
17.Thus, this Court has no hesitation in holding that present petition for
issuance of writ of mandamus against the respondents is not maintainable.
18.Accordingly, the petition fails and is hereby dismissed declining its
admission. As the writ petition has been dismissed on the point of
maintainability itself, the merits of the matter has not been gone into.
ms/Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 24-01-2024
05:32:55 PM
(MILIND RAMESH PHADKE)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review