The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Consequently, the petition fails and accordingly, dismissed. No order as to costs. (Nandita Dubey) Judge. jk . is,
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
WP No.18068/2017
(Shaligram Dubey vs. State of M.P. and others)
JABALPUR, DATED : 23.08.2021.
Shri
H.K.Upadhyay,
Advocate
for
the
petitioner.
Ms. Sonali Paroche, Panel Lawyer for the
respondents/State.
Heard finally.
This
petition
under
Article
of
the
Constitution of India takes exception to the order
dated
26.09.2016
passed
by
no.1/Director
General
of
Headquarter,
Bhopal,
whereby
respondent
Police,
Police
petitioner's
representation seeking out of turn promotion, was
rejected.
2.
The facts, as culled out from the pleadings
reveals that in the year 2001 the petitioner was
posted at Balaghat at “A” Company Police Station,
Rupjhar
as
Gunman
to
Addl.Supdt.of
Police,
Balaghat/respondent no.4. On 06.10.2002. A truck
loaded with dynamite destined
for Malajkhand
Copper Mines was looted by nexalites at Udd Valley
Bahir Road. On receiving this information, a police
party headed by respondent no.4, including the
petitioner and other four persons reached the spot.
After
some
time,
other
police
personnel
also
arrived at the spot and by joint efforts about 8
tons of dynamite was recovered. According to the
petitioner, he was promised by the respondent
no.4 that he would be adequately awarded for the
bravery shown by him. Much to his dismay, 19
police personnel were promoted out of turn in the
same year i.e.2002, but petitioner was neither
promoted nor offered any reward. Distressed by
this
discrimination,
petitioner
made
various
representations to the authorities, but in vain. He,
therefore,
filed
WP
No.11628/2016
(Shaligram
Dubey vs.
State of M.P. and others) wherein vide
order dated 20.07.2016, a direction was given to
respondent
However,
no.1
the
to
decide
his
representation.
representation
of
petitioner
was
rejected vide the impugned order on the grounds
that :- (i) The name of petitioner is not reflected
in the daily police book of the date on which police
party went to the spot of crime; (ii) name of
petitioner was neither sent to PHQ with other
names nor recommended by his superior officers;
(iii)
Police
regulation
70-A
Regulations
(hereinafter
referred
of
M.P.Police
to
as
“the
Regulations”) for out of turn promotion has been
deleted
vide
11.09.2012.
Gazette
Notification
dated
3.
Referring
(Annexure
to
P/8)
letter
dated
28.08.2017
obtained
under
Right
to
Information Act, it is urged by learned counsel for
the
petitioner
that
petitioner
was
serving
as
Gunman to respondent no.4, and, therefore, there
is
no
entry
in
the
police
duty
diary.The
photographs filed as Annexure P/7 also confirms
the presence of petitioner at the crime scene. It is
submitted that respondent no.4 sent the name of
the petitioner for Gallantry award to the Supdt. of
Police, Balaghat who did not send it any further to
Police Headquarter. It is urged that 25 police
persons were given out of turn promotion, but
petitioner,
though
on
same
footing,
has
been
selectively excluded with mala fide intent.
4.
Per contra, Ms. Sonali Paroche, learned PL
appearing for respondent no.1 to 3 submitted that
out of turn promotion for act of bravery is not a
matter of legal right, but it is the discretion of the
competent authority.
Petitioner's representation
has been rejected since his name was not found in
the Aamad Rawangi Register of the concerned
police station comprising team of police personnel
who had recovered the huge quantity of dynamite
nor his name was recommended by his superiors.
It is further submitted that Regulation 70-A of the
Regulations which was inserted vide notification
dated
10.06.1987
has
been
deleted
notification no.392 dated 11.09.2012.
vide
Under such
circumstances, petitioner is not entitled for any
relief.
5.
Respondent no.4 in para 4 of his reply filed
along with his affidavit submitted that petitioner
was a part of his team but has denied making any
promise or assurance to the petitioner.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused the record.
7.
In view of reply filed along with affidavit of
respondent no.4 and photographs (Annexure P/7),
undisputedly, petitioner was a part of the team,
other members of which were given out of turn
promotion and reward for the act of bravery.
The
claim of the petitioner was resisted on the ground
that
his
name
was
not
found
in
the
Aamad
Rawangi Register, however from Annexure P/8,
dated 28.08.2017, it is evident that petitioner
never got his Aamad Rawangi Register noted in the
police diary.
It is pertinent to note that this
document is not denied by the respondents.
8.
Regulation
70-A
of
the
Regulations
is
reproduced as under :“ 70-A
Notwithstanding
anything
contained in Regulation 70, a Constable may
be promoted to the rank of Head Constable
by
the
Supdt.of
Police
with
the
prior
approval of the Director General of Police
and
a
Head
Assistant
Constable
to
the
Sub-Inspector
by
the
rank
of
Deputy
Inspector General of Police with the prior
approval of Director General of Police if he
has
distinguished
operations,
law
himself
and
in
order
anti
dacoit
situations
of
shooting competitions or in some other field
of
duty
or
who
has
been
awarded
the
President's Police Medal for Gallantry or for
meritorious/distinguished
services,
considers
for
him
suitable
if
he
promotion.
Similarly the Inspector General of Police may
promote an Assistant Sub-Inspector to the
rank of Sub-Inspector and a Sub-Inspector
to
the
rank
of
an
Inspector
on
similar
grounds if found suitable for promotion and
subject to the prior approval of the Director
General of Police.
The number of Officers
promoted under this Regulation shall not
exceed 10 per cent.”
9.
Admittedly,
of
the
of
turn
promotion/reward in the year 2002 itself.
The
petitioner
have
other
team
members
been
granted
out
petitioner's claim for promotion is based on the
concept of equity and equability. However, the
petitioner has knocked the door of the Court only
in the year 2016.
It is clear from the documents
on record that cause of action has arisen to the
petitioner in the year 2002 itself when his other
team members were promoted out of turn, and in
view of Regulation 70-A of the Regulations, his
name was not considered. Though the respondents
have not denied that petitioner has been making
repeated
regarding
representations
his
representations
to
the
claim,but
could
not
respondents
mere
justify
his
making
belated
approach.
10. In State of T.N.vs.
Seshachalam (2007)
10 SCC 137, Hon'ble the Supreme Court while
testing the equality clause on the bedrock of delay
and laches pertaining to grant of service benefits
has observed thus :“16.............. filing
of
representations
alone
would not save the period of limitation. Delay
or laches is a relevant factor for a court of law
to determine the question as to whether the
claim
made
by
an
applicant
deserves
consideration. Delay and/or laches on the part
of a government servant may deprive him of
the benefit which had been given to others.
Article 14 of the Constitution of India would
not, in a situation of that nature, be attracted
as it is well known that law leans in favour of
those who are alert and vigilant.
11. Though
there
is
no
period
of
limitation
provided for filing a writ petition under Article 226
of the Constitution of India, yet a writ petition
ordinarily should be filed within a reasonable time.
In this case, the petitioner first approached this
Court in the year 2016 i.e. after more than a
decade.
12. In P.S.Sadasivaswamy vs. State of Tamil
Nadu reported in (1975) Vol.1 SCC 152, Hon'ble
the Supreme Court held thus :-
“ 2 ............. A person aggrieved by an order of
promoting
a
junior
over
his
head
should
approach the Court at least within six months or
at the most a year of such promotion.
It is not
that there is any period of limitation for the
Courts to exercise their powers under Article 226
nor is it that there can never be a case where
the Courts cannot interfere in a matter after the
passage of a certain length of time. But it would
be a sound and wise exercise of discretion for
the
Courts
to
refuse
to
exercise
their
extraordinary powers under Article 226 in the
case
of
persons
who
do
not
approach
it
expeditiously for relief and who stand by and
allow things to happen and then approach the
Court to put forward stale claims and try to
unsettle settled matters.”
13. In S.S.Balu vs.
State of Kerala reported
in (2009) 2 SCC 479, it has been held by the
Supreme Court thus :-
“ 17. It is also well settled principle of law that
“delay defeats equity”. It is now trite law that
where the writ petitioner approaches the High
Court after a long delay, reliefs prayed for may
be denied to them on the ground of delay and
laches irrespective of the fact that they are
similarly situated to the other candidates who
obtain benefit of a judgment...........”
14.
Grant of out of turn promotion is not a
fundamental
right.
Grant
of
such
relief
while
remaining oblivious to the factum of delay and
laches is contrary to the settled principle. What is
urged by learned counsel for the petitioner is that
the petitioner be treated equally with his other
team members.
But equality has to be claimed at
the right juncture and not after expiry of a decade.
15. Consequently,
the
petition
fails
and
accordingly, dismissed. No order as to costs.
(Nandita Dubey)
Judge.
jk .
Date: 2021.09.22 14:45:32 +05'30'
is,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review