Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND RAMESH PHADKE
ON THE 4th OF JULY, 2023
WRIT PETITION No. 2061 of 2022
BETWEEN:MANIRAM RAJAK S/O LATE SHRI PALUA, AGED68 YEARS, OCCUPATION: RETIRED EMPLOYEE
R/O BHEEM NAGAR COLONY, NEAR KALIMATA
MANDIR DABRA DISTRICT GWALIOR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI S.N. SETH- ADVOCATE)
AND
1. THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY PWD VALLABH
BHAWAN BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2. THE CHIEF ENGINEER PUBLIC HEALTH
ENGINEERING
DEPARTMENT,
PWD
THATIPUR, GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
3. THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PUBLIC WORKS
DEPARTMENT DIVISION NO. 2 GWALIOR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
4. THE ASSISTANT ENGINEER PUBLIC WORKS
DEPARTMENT
SUBDIVISION
DABRA
DISTRICT GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
5. THE TREASURY OFFICER, TREASURY AND
ACCOUNTS GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SOHIT MISHRA- GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This petition coming on for hearing this day, Hon'ble
Shri Justice Milind Ramesh Phadke passed the following:
ORDER
1.
The present petition under Article 226/227 of the
Constitution of India has not been preferred against any
particular order, but had been preferred against the inaction on
the part of the respondents, whereby though the petitioner is
entitled for grant of 7th Pay Scale, it had not yet been finalized.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that the petitioner was initially
appointed on 08.07.1976 on the post of Beldar as daily rated
employee and accordingly, his service book was prepared from
the date of his appointment. The petitioner had continuously
worked in the respondent department which is clear from the
service book of the petitioner and on 08.12.1989 the petitioner
was given the work as work charged and contingency paid
employee on the post of Chawkidar in the respondent
department which is also mentioned in the service book of the
petitioner.
3.
At the time of retirement, the services of the petitioner as
daily rated employee since 08.07.1976 till 07.12.1989 were not
counted for pensionary purposes, which is contrary to the Rules
12 and 13 of the M.P. Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976 and
also against the settled provisions of law in view of judgment
passed by this Court in W.P. No.16652/2016, the present petition
came to be filed. In the petition it was averred that before
superannuating the benefit of 7th Pay Commission was also not
extended to the petitioner though from the service book it was
clear that on 08.12.1996 the benefit of 5 th Pay Commission was
extended to the petitioner and later from 01.01.2006, the benefit
of 6th Pay Commission was also extended and because of that
the petitioner is receiving a meager amount of pension. It was
further
averred
therein
that
since
the
petitioner
got
superannuated on 31.12.2016, the benefit of 7 th Pay Commission
which was applicable since 01.01.2016 was required to be
extended to the petitioner. Since the said benefit was not
extended, therefore, representations were moved by him and
since no action was taken upon them, a complaint was made to
the Collector, District Gwalior in Jan Sunvayi No.5651/2016 on
13.12.2016, wherein respondent no.3 took a note of the
complaint and reported the matter to the Collector and a copy
thereof was also forwarded to the petitioner with an intimation
that the matter has been sent for consideration to respondent
no.2, but till date no reply has been received by the petitioner
neither the entitlement of the petitioner has been rejected nor has
been considered. In the petition it was also averred that the
Finance Department of the State Government vide policy dated
21.09.2016 has extended the benefit of time scale pay to the
work charged and contingency paid employee in view of the
circular of the State Government from 01.01.2016 and due to the
circular dated 21.09.2016 the petitioner became entitled for time
scale pay which was also not extended to the petitioner.
4.
In that regard, a detailed representation was again
submitted by the petitioner to the respondent/authorities but till
date the said benefit has also not been extended nor finalized. In
spite of the representations moved by the petitioners they have
not been dealt with till date as provided under Rule 12 of Rules
of 1976, neither the Kramonnati first, second and third has been
extended to the petitioner nor the benefit of the 7th Pay
Commission has been extended to him. Thus, the present
petition has been filed.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued
that from the policy of the State Government with regard to
grant of benefit of time pay scale to the work-charged and
contingency paid employees, it is apparently clear that the
petitioner was entitled for the benefit of time scale pay since
1.1.2016 as the petitioner has worked for more than 30 years,
likewise he was also entitled for first, second and third time
scale pay but in spite of his entitlement the benefit has not been
extended to the petitioner which is per se illegal.
6.
It was further argued that though as per the Pension Rules
of 1976 the period of service the petitioner has worked as daily
rated employee is required to be counted so far as pensionary
benefits are concerned, but the same has not been counted due to
which the petitioner is suffering daily loss in terms of pension.
7.
It was further argued that it is apparent from the service
book of the petitioner that the petitioner was initially appointed
as Beldar on 08.07.1976 and got the status of work-charged and
contingency employee on 08.12.1989 and hence the said period
from 1976 to 1989 was required to be counted for the
pensionary benefits as per the provisions contained in Rules 12
and 13 of the Rules of 1976 but since the same has not been
calculated the action of the respondents thereof is per se illegal.
8.
It was lastly argued that from the circulars issued by the
State Government the benefit of recommendations of Seventh
Pay Commission was required to be extended from 01.01.2016
as the petitioner stood retired w.e.f 31.12.2016 and though the
benefit of 5th and 6th pay commission has been extended to the
petitioner which is reflected from the service book, it was
incumbent upon the respondents to have extended the benefit of
seventh pay commission also w.e.f. 01.01.2016 and as it has not
been extended, the action of the respondents in that regard is
also illegal. To bolster his submission, reliance has been placed
on the matter of Chandrakanta w/o Manaklalji Sharma vs.
State of M.P. and others, 2007(2) MPLJ 339 and also in the
matter of Gaurishankar Pandey vs. State of M.P. And Ors
passed in W.P. No.16652/2016 on 4th of October, 2017.
9.
On the other hand, learned Government Advocate Shri
Sohit Mishra vehemently opposed the prayer made by counsel
for the petitioner and submitted that the petitioner is trying to
mislead this Court on the basis of facts and norms that he is
entitled to get the benefit of seventh pay commission as well as
the benefit of first, second and third time scale pay but the true
fact is that the petitioner is not entitled to seek any relief as
prayed by him. It was further argued that the petitioner is trying
to demonstrate that he was entitled to get the third time pay scale
for the period of his service as work-charged and contingency
paid employee whereas the work-charged and contingency paid
employees are not entitled to get the benefit of third time pay
scale. It was further argued that it is not denied that the
petitioner had received the benefit of fifth and sixth pay
commission
and
now
since
provision
of
up-gradation
(Kramonnati) has been abolished and new time scale has been
given to the employee and the petitioner has already been given
the time scale pay as per the norms, he is not entitled to any
benefit thereof. Thus, it was submitted that the petitioner being
sans merits deserves to be dismissed.
10.
Heard the counsel for the parties and perused the record.
11.
Three-fold reliefs which are being claimed by the
petitioner viz.:
(i)
Counting of his past services for the
pensionary benefits;
(ii)
Extending the benefit of seventh pay
commission w.e.f. 01.01.2016;
(iii)
Grant of first and second time scale
of pay as per the policy of the State
government.
12.
So far as the counting of the past services of the petitioner
is concerned, it is an admitted fact that the petitioner was
appointed on 08.07.1976 on the post of Beldar as daily rated
employee and thereupon on 08.12.1989, the petitioner was given
the status of work-charged and contingency paid employee on
the post of Chowkidar.
13.
Rule 12 (2) of the Rules of 1976 is relevant for
consideration of aforesaid aspect, which reads as under:
“12. Commencement of qualifying service:2. Subject to the provision of these
rules
qualifying
service
of
a
Government Servant shall commence
from the date he takes charge of the
post to which he is first appointed
either substantively or in officiating
or temporary capacity.”
14.
Rule 12 (2) of the Rules of 1976, provides for counting of
the qualifying service of a government servant which
commences from the date he takes charge of the post to which
he was first appointed either substantially or in officiating or
temporary capacity. From the record, it is apparent that since
1976 till 1989 the petitioner has worked as a daily rated
employee till he was given the status of work-charged and
contingency paid employee on the post of Chowkidar and
thereafter he stood retired after attaining the age of
superannuation on 31.12.2016, thus, the petitioner had already
spent approximately around 40 years in service out of which he
had worked as a daily rated employee for 13 years. This Court in
the case of Chandrakanta w/o Manaklalji Sharma (supra)
has observed in paragraphs 11(a), and 12 to 17 as under:
“11A. Learned counsel appearing for the parties
have agreed that the pension and gratuity of the
petitioner shall be regulated, as per M.P. Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 1976. Chapter III, which
starts from Rule 12, and deals the qualifying
service, and Rule 13 which deals with the
condition subject to which service qualifies; the
relevant extract of those rules are reproduced
herein below:12. Commencement of qualifying
service.
–
(1)
Except
for
compensation gratuity, a Government
servant’s service does not qualify till
he has completed 18 years of age,
provided that nothing contained in
this clause shall apply in the case of
persons who were in service on the
date of commencement of these rules
and in whose case a lower age limit
has been prescribed.
(2) Subject to the provisions of these
rules,
qualifying
service
of
a
Government servant shall commence
from the date he takes charge of the
post to which he is first appointed
either
substantively
or
in
an
officiating or temporary capacity.
13. Conditions subject to which
service qualifies.- (1) The service of a
Government servant shall not qualify
unless his duties and pay are
regulated by the Government, or
under conditions determined by the
Government.
(2) For the purposes of sub-rule (1),
the
expression
“service”
means
service against a post under the
Government
and
paid
by
the
Government from the consolidated
Fund of the State which has not been
declared as non-pensionable.”
12. On perusal of the sub-rule (2) of Rule 12, it is
apparent that subject to the provisions of the
Pension Rules, the qualifying service of the
employee shall commence from the date, on she/he
takes charge of the post to which she/he is first
appointed either substantively or in an officiating
or temporary capacity. Rule 13 specifies that
unless the duties and pay of the employee
concerned is regulated by the Government it shall
not qualify the service rendered by such employee.
The word qualifying service has been defined
under rule 3(p) of the Pension Rules which is
reproduced as under :“3(p) “Qualifying Service” means the
period between the date of joining
pensionable service under the State
Government and retirement therefrom
which shall be taken into account for
purpose of the pension and gratuity
admissible under these rules and
includes the period which qualifies
under any other order or rule for the
time being in force;”
13. However, on reading of the aforesaid rules, it
is apparent that the date of joining to a post on
which the employee is first appointed, either
substantively or officiating or temporarily and
takes over the charge on that post and retired
therefrom shall be, the period of service on that
post, and the date of taking over the charge till
attaining the age of superannuation be treated as
qualifying service. Under Rule 13(1) it is clarified
that the service of the employee shall not qualify
unless duties and pay of the Government servant
is regulated by the Government under the
conditions determined by them. Sub clause (2) of
Rule 13 clarifies the word service for the purpose
of Rule 13(1), by which it is apparent that if the
service rendered against a post under the Gov.
and paid salary from the consolidated fund of
Govt., which is not declared as non-pensionable to
be treated as service of the Govt. In view of
reading of the aforesaid rules, it is apparent that
qualifying service has been defined under clause
3(p) of the Pension Rules. Rule 12(2) of these
rules
indicates
the
commencement
of
the
qualifying service and Rule 13(1)(2) explains that
service against the post paid from consolidated
fund, not declared as non-pensionable, shall be
qualified
service,
only
with
the
rider
of
regularization of pay and duties by the Govt.
14. In the facts of the present case and as per the
return submitted by the Govt., it is apparent that
the petitioner was appointed temporarily as
Teacher though on a fix pay of Rs.100/-. On the
date of appointment petitioner was possessing the
requisite qualification of the post of Assistant
Teacher. She has taken over the Teacher by joining
her duties on 10-1-1974 and remain continued on
such post till attaining the age of superannuation.
She has performed the work attached to the post of
Teacher. The payment of the salary either of fixed
pay or in the regular scale of the pay was allowed
to her from the consolidated fund of the Govt. was
not declared as non-pensionable. The order of
regulation of pay was passed by the Govt. on 282-1989 extending such benefit with effect from 61-1989. However, it is apparent that, her pay has
also been regulated by the Govt.
15. The argument of the Dy. Govt. Advocate Shri
Joshi is only confined, that the services rendered
by the petitioner in between 10-1-1974 to 5-11989 she had received fix pay, however, such
period shall not be counted under the qualifying
service, to the Govt. servant. The service may
qualify, only with effect from the date from which
the pay is regulated by the Govt., under the
conditions as determined by them under Rule
13(1); this argument is of no substance. Because
Rule 12(2) of the Pension Rules deals with the
commencement of the qualifying service, whereby
it is apparent that the commencement of the
qualifying service shall be with effect from the
date on which he/she takes the charge of the post
to which he/she is first appointed. Thereafter Rule
13(1) specifies the conditions subject to which the
service qualifies. Wherein, it is mentioned that the
service shall not qualify under his duties and pay
are regulated. Sub-rule (2) deals with the service,
whereby it is apparent that if the payment is made
to the employee from the consolidated fund of the
Govt. which is not declared as non-pensionable.
Thus, it is apparent that the commencement of the
qualifying service starts from the date on which
the employees takes the charge of the post and
receives payment from the consolidated fund of the
State Govt., which has not been declared as nonpensionable. Thereafter Rule 13(1) deals that
under which condition the service of a Govt.
servant shall be treated as qualifying service. In
the present case the commencement of the service
of the petitioner has been started on 10-1-1974
and the salary has been received by her from
consolidated fund which has not been declared as
non-pensionable. The pay has been qualified by
the regulating the same as per the order of the
competent
authority
in
the
regular
scale,
therefore, the period of the service with effect from
10-1-1974 to 5-1-1989 deserves to be counted as
qualifying service, under Rules 12(20 and 13(1)
and (2) of M.P. Civil Services Pension Rules,
1976.
16. The aforesaid interpretation of Rules 12 and
13 finds support from the various judgments of
this Court in the case of Madhukant Yadu, Hariom
Soni, Jagdish Prowal and Vibha Mathur (supra),
whereby this Court has held that if the Assistant
Teachers appointed on the fix pay, are entitled to
get regular scale of the pay and increment since
the date of appointment. If the ratio of the
aforesaid judgments is made applicable in the
facts of the present case then petitioner was
entitled to get regular scale of pay since the date
of initial appointment, which was not allowed to
her by the Govt. arbitrarily. However, taking into
consideration this aspect, and in view of the
discussion made hereinabove the service rendered
by the petitioner on a fix pay of Rs.100/- or
Rs.300/- shall be treated as qualifying service for
the purpose to grant her, the benefit of pension
and other retiral dues.
17.
In view of the discussion made hereinabove
and on perusal of Rule 12, 13, 3(p), 43 and 44 of
the Pension Rules, and in the facts of the present
case the entire period rendered by the petitioner
from
10-1-1974
till
attaining
the
age
of
superannuation i.e. 30-9-1997, deserves to be
counted as qualifying service. However, in the
light of Rule 43 and 44 of the Pension Rules of
1976 because the petitioner has rendered the
services for more than ten years, hence, she is
entitled for pension and gratuity after its redetermination..”
Thus, so far as the rendering of total services by the
petitioner is concerned, it is an admitted fact that he had already
served for 13 years as daily rated employee in a temporary
capacity and there is no clarification from the State that the
salary of the petitioner was not being given from the
consolidated funds of the State.
14.
The Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the matter of
Gaurishankar Pandey (supra) after relying on the case of
similarly situated person Sudama Prasad Pandey, had also relied
on the decision of Division Bench passed in WA No.682/2009
wherein it had been held that since the petitioner has already
worked as daily rated employee, then it cannot be said that the
aforesaid services of the petitioner shall not be included in the
qualifying service and while allowing the petition had directed
the respondents to consider and settle the claim of the petitioner
and decide the entitlement with regard to retiral dues in light of
decision in the case of Sudama Prasad Pandey within a period of
three months.
15.
So far as the benefit of the third time pay-scale to the
petitioner in the light of the circular dated 21.09.2016 w.e.f.
01.01.2016 is concerned, the circular dated 21.09.2016
specifically mentions that the benefit of the third time pay-scale
scheme had been extended for the employees who are drawing
their salary from the head of work charged contingency fund and
had been made effective since 01.01.2016 and admittedly since
the petitioner stood retired on 31.12.2016 he was entitled for the
extension of the said benefit, subject
to this eligibility and
denial thereof without any reason appears to be not justified.
16.
So also the extension of benefit of the 7 th Pay Commission
to the petitioner which according to the petitioner was required
to be extended to him from 01.01.2016 and has not been
rebutted by the respondents in specific terms is required to be
considered as it is not the case of the respondents that he was
not entitled at all rather the contentions of the respondents are
that since he stood retired and had taken all the benefits of
service as per the norms the benefit of 7 th Pay Commission
cannot be extended to him appears to be not reasonable.
17.
Accordingly, the petition stands allowed and the
respondents are directed to count the past services of the
petitioner from 1976 till 1989 during which the petitioner has
worked as a daily rated employee for the purpose of pensionary
benefits and issue fresh PPO and also to consider the case of the
petitioner for grant of time pay scale in the light of the circular
dated 21.09.2016 and the extention of benefit of 7 th Pay
Commission.
18.
Let this exercise be done within a period of three months
from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
19.
With the aforesaid, the petition stands allowed and
disposed of.
20.
CC as per rules/directions.
(Milind Ramesh Phadke)
Judge
chandni/CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
2023.09.29
15:33:58
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review