The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. BOARD DIST. BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH) .....RESPONDENTS (BY MS. BHARATI LAKKAD, GOVT. ADVOCATE FOR THE STATE AND MS. CHITRALEKHA HARDIA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.7 ) …………………………………………………………………………………… This petition coming on for admission this day, the court passed the following: 1] This petition has been filed by the petitioner Vimala Convent Higher Secondary School Sanawad, District –Khargone under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, against the order dated 03.8.2023 passed in the Second Appeal by the Recognition Committee / the respondent No. 4 therein. 2] In brief, facts of the case are that the petitioner-School running since 1981 and has got the recognition as Higher Secondary School in the year 1999. Presently, the School has strength of around 225 students. The petitioner’s school is also being recognized from time to time since 1981, the documents regarding which have also been placed on record. On 15.12.2017, the Joint Director of the School Education has also issued the renewal certificate for the school from the year 2017 to 2024. However, the name and DISC Code of the school was deleted by the authorities from the portal of the respondents and when enquired about the same by the petitionerSchool, the District Education Officer, Khargone informed the petitioner-School that its recognition has been cancelled, and thus, 1:39:06 PM the petitioner applied before the …
11. Cancellation/suspension of recognition and forfeiture of security deposit.(1) The Divisional Joint Director shall have the powers to suspend the recognition of the school on the basis of an enquiry conducted, if standards, conditions and responsibilities prescribed under Rule 5 and Rule 9 as well as the directions and guidelines issued from time to time are prima facie not found to be complied with. After such suspension of recognition, it shall be mandatory to issue a Show Cause Notice to the Society/Trust within a period of 30 days. If such Show Cause Notice is not issued within the time prescribed, the suspension of recognition shall stand automatically withdrawn. (2) In case of issuing Show Cause Notice, if the Divisional Joint Director is not satisfied with the reply received from the Society/Trust, he/she may cancel the recognition of the school specifying the reasons thereof, after being given an opportunity to be heard to the concerned. (3) xxxxxxx. (emphasis supplied) 13] On due consideration of the rival submissions, on perusal of the of the documents filed by the rival parties, as also the aforesaid Rules of 2017 viz., Rule 11, it is apparent that the petitioner School’s recognition has been cancelled only because the petitioner has not produced the registered rent agreement. However, this Court is of 1:39:06 PM the considered opinion that it was incumbent upon the r…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUBODH ABHYANKAR
ON THE 19
th
OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 24320 of 2023
BETWEEN:VIMALA CONVENT HIGHER SECONDARY
SCHOOL
SANAWAD
DIST.
KHARGONE
THROUGH THE PRINCIPAL LUCKY K.O D/O
OUSEPH 74, DHAR KOTHI, OLD SEHORE,
ROBERT NURSING HOME, DIST. INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI NEERAJ KUMAR SONI, ADVOCATE)
AND
1. THE
STATE
OF
MADHYA
PRADESH
THROUGH
P.S.
SCHOOL
EDUCATION
DEPARTMENT VALLABH BHAVAN, DIST.
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2. THE
COMMISSIONER
LOK
SHIKSHAN
SANCHANALAYA M.P. SCHOOL EDUCATION
DEPARTMENT GAUTAM NAGAR NEAR
CHETAK
BRIDGE,
BHOPAL
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
3. THE
DIVISIONAL
JOINT
DIRECTOR
CHIMANBAGH INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
4. RECOGNITION
COMMITTEE
THROUGH
SECRETARY
SCHOOL
EDUCATION
DEPARTMENT GOVERNMENT OF MADHYA
PRADESH VALLABH BHAWAN, BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
5. DIRECTOR
/
COMMISSIONER
PUBLIC
INSTRUCTION
SCHOOL
EDUCATION
DEPARTMENT GAUTAM
NAGAR
NEAR
CHETAK BRIDGE, DIST. BHOPAL MADHYA
PRADESH (MADHYA PRADESH)
6. DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER SCHOOL
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/27/2024
1:39:06 PM
EDUCATION
DEPARTMENT
DIST.
KHARGONE (MADHYA PRADESH)
7. BOARD
OF
SECONDARY
EDUCATION
THROUGH SECRETARY SHIVAJI NAGAR
DIST. BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY MS. BHARATI LAKKAD, GOVT. ADVOCATE FOR THE STATE AND MS.
CHITRALEKHA HARDIA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.7 )
……………………………………………………………………………………
This petition coming on for admission this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
1]
This petition has been filed by the petitioner Vimala Convent
Higher Secondary School Sanawad, District –Khargone under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, against the order dated 03.8.2023
passed in the Second Appeal by the Recognition Committee / the
respondent No. 4 therein.
2]
In brief, facts of the case are that the petitioner-School
running since 1981 and has got the recognition as Higher Secondary
School in the year 1999. Presently, the School has strength of around
225 students. The petitioner’s school is also being recognized from
time to time since 1981, the documents regarding which have also
been placed on record. On 15.12.2017, the Joint Director of the
School Education has also issued the renewal certificate for the
school from the year 2017 to 2024. However, the name and DISC
Code of the school was deleted by the authorities from the portal of
the respondents and when enquired about the same by the petitionerSchool, the District Education Officer, Khargone informed the
petitioner-School that its recognition has been cancelled, and thus,
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/27/2024
1:39:06 PM
the petitioner applied before the District Education Officer for
recognition of the School and the District Education also verified the
recommendation of the inspection committee, however, the Joint
Director of the School Education has rejected the recognition of the
petitioner School vide order dated 21.1.2023, on the grounds that the
registered documents of the school land/building were not clear and
the last year’s recognition certificate is not filed; e-payment’s
information is also not provided and the school’s play ground
information is also not made available. Against the aforesaid order
dated 21.1.2023, an appeal was also preferred by the petitionerSchool rectifying the defects for the documents required for the
purposes of the recognition, but the appeal was also rejected vide
order 28.4.2023 by the Appellate Authority-Secretary, Madhyamik
Shiksha Mandal, Bhopal on the ground that the objections have not
been cured. Against the aforesaid order dated 28.4.2023, a second
appeal was also preferred by the petitioner before the Recognition
Committee again apprising that they have already cured the defects,
but the Committee opined that the documents regarding the school’s
land, which the petitioner has produced, are only the notarized
documents and not the registered documents.
3]
Counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued before this
Court and it is submitted that the impugned orders are liable to be
quashed as the petitioner has not been given due opportunity of
hearing and despite curing the defects, the recognition of the school
has not been restored. Counsel has also submitted that the order also
runs contrary to rule 11 of Madhya Pradesh Recognition of
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/27/2024
1:39:06 PM
Secondary and Higher Secondary Schools Rules, 2017 (in short “the
Rules of 2017”), which have been made for renewal and recognition
of private Secondary and Higher Secondary Schools under S.27 of
the Madhya Pradesh Secondary Education Act, 1965.
It is also
submitted that the respondents could not have cancelled the
recognition of the petitioner School at the outset without following
rule 11 of the Rules of 2017, which clearly provides that firstly, the
respondent/Divisional Joint Director shall have the power to suspend
the recognition of the School, if the standard conditions and
responsibilities prescribed under Rules 5 & 9 as well as the directions
and guidelines issued from time to time are prima facie not found to
be complied with, and after such suspension of recognition, it shall
be mandatory to issue show notice to the society or the trust running
the school within a period of 30 days, and if such show cause notice
is not issued within the time prescribed, the suspension of the
recognition shall stand automatically withdrawn.
4]
Counsel has submitted that in the present case, admittedly,
neither the school’s recognition was first suspended nor 30 days’
notice was issued to the petitioner or the trust which is running the
school, which has prejudiced the valuable rights of the petitioner
school as provided under the Rules of 2017. Thus, it is submitted that
impugned order is liable to be set aside and the respondents be
directed to grant the renewal of recognition to the petitioner school as
High School and Higher Secondary School till 2024 and they be also
directed to open the portal to use DISC code to submit and to
participate in the procedure of admission of the students.
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/27/2024
1:39:06 PM
5]
Counsel has also submitted that this Court was also pleased to
pass an interim order on 23.9.2023 whereby the petitioner is
permitted to use the DISC code but, the portal has not been opened to
the petitioner school and the order has been violated by the
respondents, and hence, a separate contempt petition No.6266/2023
has also been preferred against the respondents.
6]
Counsel for the petitioner has also submitted that it is only
after the second appeal was rejected that the petitioner came to know
that the rent note of the school building was not registered, the
petitioner has already complied with the aforesaid direction and has
already got the rent agreement registered and has already submitted
the relevant documents vide its letter dated 14.9.2023, but the
respondents have not paid any heed to the aforesaid documents.
7]
On the other hand, the petition is opposed vehemently by the
counsel for respondents and separate replies have been filed by the
respondents No.1 to 6 and the respondent No.7.
8]
The Respondents No.1 to 6, who are the School Education
Department and the District Education Officer etc., have submitted
that they have raised a preliminary objection that the documents
submitted by the petitioner for recognition of the school did not
include the registered rent agreement (kirayanama)/possession of
land and the documents furnished by them were only the notarized
documents affixed on stamp of Rs.100/-, and the petitioner was also
afforded due opportunity of hearing before passing the order
however, the petitioner has not cured the defects, and thus, the
respondents had no option but to cancel its recognition.
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/27/2024
1:39:06 PM
9]
Counsel for the respondents No.1 to 6 has also submitted that
Rule 5(2)(C) of the Rules of 2017 clearly provides that it is
mandatory that the land either on rent or in possession thereof,
should be duly registered and such registered documents are required
to be duly verified by the concerned institution, and since the
petitioner was not in possession of any registered document, its
second appeal has also been rejected.
10]
In its reply, the respondent No.7 has also reiterated what the
respondents No.1 to 6 have stated. It is also submitted that the
provisional recognition which was given to the petitioner was also a
conditional one as the petitioner was required to comply with all the
conditions of rule 11 of the Rules of 2017. Thus, it is submitted that
the petition being devoid of merit is liable to be dismissed.
11]
Heard the counsel for the parties and perused the record.
12]
For the purposes of deciding the dispute between the parties, it
would be necessary to refer to the relevant provisions of the rules of
5 and 11 of the Rules of 2017 read as follows:5. Parameters for Recognition:- (1) The
Societies/Trusts shall be eligible for getting
recognition for Private High School/Higher
Secondary Schools registered under the
Central or Madhya Pradesh Firms and Society
Act or Central or Madhya Pradesh Public
Trust Act.
(2) Land and Building(a) The Society/Trust, intending to run
a High School, or/and Higher
Secondary School must have minimum
one acre land and constructed area
should be as per the standards Specified
in National Building Code.
(b) xxxxx.
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/27/2024
1:39:06 PM
(c) In case of rented land or building the
documents must be legally registered and
the attested copy of these documents
should be attached with the application
form.
(d) to (f).xxxxxx
11. Cancellation/suspension of recognition
and forfeiture of security deposit.(1) The Divisional Joint Director
shall have the powers to suspend the
recognition of the school on the basis
of an enquiry conducted, if
standards,
conditions
and
responsibilities prescribed under
Rule 5 and Rule 9 as well as the
directions and guidelines issued
from time to time are prima facie not
found to be complied with. After
such suspension of recognition, it
shall be mandatory to issue a Show
Cause Notice to the Society/Trust
within a period of 30 days. If such
Show Cause Notice is not issued
within the time prescribed, the
suspension of recognition shall stand
automatically withdrawn.
(2) In case of issuing Show Cause
Notice, if the Divisional Joint
Director is not satisfied with the
reply
received
from
the
Society/Trust, he/she may cancel the
recognition of the school specifying
the reasons thereof, after being given
an opportunity to be heard to the
concerned.
(3) xxxxxxx.
(emphasis supplied)
13]
On due consideration of the rival submissions, on perusal of
the of the documents filed by the rival parties, as also the aforesaid
Rules of 2017 viz., Rule 11, it is apparent that the petitioner School’s
recognition has been cancelled only because the petitioner has not
produced the registered rent agreement. However, this Court is of
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/27/2024
1:39:06 PM
the considered opinion that it was incumbent upon the respondents to
comply with the Rule 11 of the Rules of 2017 before such
cancellation, which clearly provides that if standards, conditions and
responsibilities as well as the directions and guidelines issued from
time to time are prima facie not found to be complied with, then the
recognition can be suspended, and thereafter, it shall be mandatory to
issue a Show Cause Notice to the Society/Trust within a period of 30
days, and in case of issuance of Show Cause Notice, if the Divisional
Joint Director is not satisfied with the reply received from the
Society/Trust, he/she may cancel the recognition of the school
specifying the reasons thereof, after being given an opportunity to be
heard to the concerned. However, a bare perusal of the record clearly
reveals that although no such show cause notice was ever issued to
the petitioner/school, but its recognition was straight away cancelled
citing non-compliance of the Rules of 2017.
14]
In such circumstances, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the respondents themselves are guilty of not complying with the
mandatory provisions of the Rules of 2017 and it is rather surprising
the way this petition is contested by them. Thus, the cancellation of
the recognition of the petitioner/school cannot be sustained in the
eyes of law and both the appellate authorities have also not cared to
see that the Rule 11 of the Rules 2017 has not been complied with by
the competent authority.
15]
In view of the same, the impugned order dated 03.8.2023
being bad in law is hereby quashed and the respondents are directed
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/27/2024
1:39:06 PM
to restore the petitioner/school’s recognition with immediate effect
and enable it to access the its name and DISC Code and all other
facilities which are available to a recognized school be also extended
to it. However, liberty is reserved to the respondents to proceed
against the school in accordance with law as prescribed under rule 11
of the Rules of 2017.
16]
With the aforesaid, the Writ Petition stands allowed and
disposed of.
(SUBODH ABHYANKAR)
JUDGE
moni
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/27/2024
1:39:06 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review