The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. In view of the above and that various High Courts as well this Court has recently observed that the notice issued to a dead person for reopening of assessment of a dead person is null and void, this Court holds that the notice and all consequential proceedings arising therefrom in the name of the deceased assessee are not sustainable.
16. Consequently, the impugned notice dated 08.04.2022 passed in case No. ITBA/AST/F/148_1/2022-23/23/1042654010 (1) as well as order u/S 148A(d) of the Act of 1961 dated 07.04.2022 for the assessment year 20152016 are quashed and all actions in furtherance thereto are prohibited. However, liberty is given to the respondent to reinitiate proceedings against the petitioner/legal heir of deceased Shri Kamal Kumar Saxena, if so advised.
17. Petition is therefore allowed. No order as to cost.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA
ON THE 22nd OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 24807 of 2023
BETWEEN:URMILA SAXENA W/O LATE SHRI KAMAL KUMAR
S A X E N A 160, MAHARSHI VED VYAS COLONY,
GAUSHALA ROAD, RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI ARUN DWIVEDI, ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
CENTRAL BOARD OF DIRECT TAXES THROUGH
ITS
CHAIRMAN
MINISTRY OF FINANCE
(DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE) NORTH BLOCK,
NEW DELHI (DELHI)
2.
PRINCIPAL CHIEF COMMISSIONER OF INCOME
TAX INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT MITRA NIWAS
ROAD, RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
THE INCOME TAX OFFICER (ITO1) INCOME TAX
DEPARTM ENT MITRA NIWAS ROAD, RATLAM
(MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
THE NATIONAL FACELESS ASSESSMENT CENTRE
THROUGH PR. CHIEF COMMISSIONER OF
INCOME TAX 2ND FLOOR, JAWAHARLAL NEHRU
STADIUM NEW DELHI (DELHI)
.....RESPONDENTS
(MS. VEENA MANDLIK, ADVOCATE)
This petition coming on for admission this day, Justice Sushrut Arvind
Dharmadhikari passed the following:
ORDER
Signed by: VATAN
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:26:41 PM
Heard finally with the consent of parties.
T h e present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
challenges the notice under Section 148A(b) of the Income Tax Act, 1961
(referred to as 'the Act of 1961' hereinafter) for the assessment year 2015-16
dated
08.04.2022
issued
in
case
No. ITBA/AST/F/148_1/2022-
23/23/1042654010 (1) [Annexure P-4], as well as order u/S 148A(d) of the Act
of
dated
07.04.2022
[Annexure
P-3]
passed
in
case
No. ITBA/AST/F/148_1/2022-23/23/1042633569 (1) for the assessment year
2015-16.
2. Brief facts of the case are that, the petitioner is an old widow and legal
heir of Lt. Shri Kamal Kumar Saxena (Deceased Assessee) who has filed this
writ petition praying for the issuance of a writ of Certiorari and Mandamus to
quash the impugned Re-Assessment Proceedings for A.Y. 2015-16 initiated by
way of issuance of Notice u/S 148A(b) of the Act Annexure (P/2), Order u/S
148A(d) of the Act (Annexure P/3) and subsequent impugned Notice u/S 148
of the Act (Annexure P/4) all being issued in the name of petitioner's deceased
husband Lt. Shri Kamal Kumar Saxena. The impugned re-assessment
proceedings are being challenged on the ground that entire re-assessment
proceedings started from issuance of notice u/S 148A(b) of the Act on the dead
person and culminating into notice u/S 148 of the Act are being initiated against
a dead person, therefore the impugned proceedings are bad in law, wholly
without jurisdiction and void ab initio. That the petitioner is the wife and legal
heir of the deceased Lt. Shri Kamal Kumar Saxena, who had died on
09/11/2020 and this fact is not disputed by the respondent authorities. The
petitioner is an old and ailing home-maker and is living with the support of her
own saving. Hence the present petition is filed.
Signed by: VATAN
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:26:41 PM
3 . Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that an essential
condition to issue notice u/S 148 of the Act of 1961 is that the notice be issued
to the person who is alive and the same cannot be issued to a dead person. He
further submitted that the deceased husband of the petitioner had passed away
on 09.11.2020, as is evident from his death certificate. The settled legal principle
in such cases is that a notice issued in the name of the dead person is
unenforceable in law. Keeping this legal position in mind, coupled with the fact
that the petitioner had already intimated about the death of her husband Lt. Shri
Kamal Kumar Saxena, the Revenue is and would not be justified at all in
contending that they having the knowledge about the death of the petitioner's
husband, are entitled to plead that the impugned notice under Section 148 is not
defective.
4 . It is further submitted that where petitioner-legal heir of assesseedeceased had supplied death certificate of assessee to concerned officer within
a short period after his/her demise, impugned reopening notice issued
subsequently under Section 148 of the Act of 1961 in the name of the deceased
was illegal and thus liable to be set aside as held in the case of Smt. Madhuben
Kantilal Patel Vs. Union of India reported in [2023]148 taxmann.com
202(Gujarat).
5 . He further placed reliance on the case of J. Kishorekumar V.
Income Tax Officer reported in [2022] 139 taxmann.com 47 (Madras)
wherein it has been held as under:
"Where petitioner, legal representative challenged impugned
notice issued under Section 148 on the ground that notice had
been issued in name of his deceased father, revenue was to be
Signed by: VATAN
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:26:41 PM
directed to issue appropriate notice to petitioner under Section 148
of the Act of 1961 as a legal representative."
6.
He also placed reliance on the case of Krishnaawtar Kabra Vs.
Income Tax Officer reported in [2022] 140 taxmann.com 432(Gujarat)
[29.03.2023] where it has been held that reopening notice u/S 148 issued upon
deceased assessee was void ab intio and therefore consequential proceedings
and orders passed thereon were without any jurisdiction and where to be
quashed and set aside.
7.
Learned counsel for the respondent/Income Tax Department by
placing reliance on the various judgments of the Apex Court as well as the High
Court submitted that petition against order u/S 148A(d)/Notice u/S 148 of the
Act of 1961 for initiation of reassessment proceedings is not tenable as all such
objection have to be raised before the Assessing Officer as it is not a final
adjudication of the matter where no further statutory remedy against the
adjudication order is available.[Salil Gulati Vs. ACIT(2023(455 ITR 29 (SC)
, Ajay Gupta Vs. ITO 454 ITR 794 (SC) (2023), Seema Gupta Vs ITO
455 ITR 504 2023(SC) , Anshul Jain Vs. PCIT Specal Leave to
Appeal(C) No. 14823/2022, Harinder Singh Bedi Vs. UOI(MP) W.P. NO.
22734/2022,
and
Amit
Homes
Pvt.
Ltd.
V/S
DCIT
W.P.
NO.15244/2023(M.P.)]
8 . She further submits that the question of going into the veracity and
genuineness of material/evidence forming the opinion of the Assessing Officer
suggesting that income of petitioner has escaped assessment ought not be gone
into while exercising writ jurisdiction under Article 226 or Supervisory
jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. On all these grounds
Signed by: VATAN
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:26:41 PM
the present petition deserves to be dismissed at the admission stage itself.
However, petitioner would be at liberty to avail the statutory remedy under the
Income Tax Act in accordance with law.
9. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
10. The issue which falls for consideration of this Court is as to whether
the impugned notice under Section 148 of the Act of 1961 is issued in the name
of dead person i.e. Shri Kamal Kumar Saxena is enforceable in law. The fact
that Shri Kamal Kumar Saxena died on 09.11.2020 is not disputed. The notice
issued in the name of the dead person is unenforceable in the eyes of law.
11. It has been observed by the Delhi High Court in the case of Savita
Kapila Vs. Asstt. CIT reported in [2020]118taxmann.com46/273 Taxman
148/426 IRT 502/108 CCH 0049 DelHC] as under:
"In the absence of a statutory provision it is difficult to cast a
duty upon the legal representatives to intimate the factum of death
of an assessee to the income tax department."
"Consequently, the legal heirs are under no statutory obligation
to intimate the death of the assessee to the revenue."
12. The Madras High Court in the case of Alamelu Verappan(supra)
has observed as under:
"Nothing has been placed before this Court by the Revenue
to show that there is a statutory obligation on the part of the legal
representatives of the deceased assessee to immediately intimate the
death of the assessee to take steps to cancel the PAN registration."
13. Similar view has been taken by the High Court of Mumbai in Sumit
Signed by: VATAN
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:26:41 PM
Balkrishna Gupta Vs. Asstt. CIT[2019] 103 taxmann.com 188/262
Taxman 61/414 ITR 292/104 CCH 0379 MumHC] wherein it has been
observed as under:
"7. The issue of a notice under Section 148 of the Act is a
foundation for reopening of assessment. The sine qua non for
acquiring jurisdiction to reopen an assessment is that such notice
should be issued in the name of the correct person. This
requirement of issuing notice to a correct person and not to a dead
person is not a merely a procedural requirement but is a condition
precedent to the impugned notice being valid in law. Thus, a notice
which has been issued in the name of the dead person is also not
protected either by provisions of Section 292B or 292BB of the Act.
This is so as the requirement of issuing a notice in the name of
correct person is the foundational requirement to acquire
jurisdiction to reopen the assessment. This is evident from Section
148 of the Act, which requires that before a proceeding can be
taken up for reassessment, a notice must be served upon the
assessee. The assessee on whom the notice must be sent must be a
living person i.e. legal heir of the deceased assessee, for the same to
be responded. This in fact is the intent and purpose of the Act.
Therefore, Section 292B of the Act cannot be invoked to correct a
foundational/substantial error as it is meant so as to meet the
jurisdictional requirement."
14. In view of the above, reopening notice under Section 148 of the Act,
Signed by: VATAN
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:26:41 PM
1961 issued in the name of a dead assessee is null and void being without
jurisdiction. Recently, this Court in the order dated 23.11.2023 passed in W.P.
No. 9697/2022 has also held that notice and all consequential proceedings
arising therefrom in the name of deceased assessee are not sustainable.
15. In view of the above and that various High Courts as well this Court
has recently observed that the notice issued to a dead person for reopening of
assessment of a dead person is null and void, this Court holds that the notice
and all consequential proceedings arising therefrom in the name of the deceased
assessee are not sustainable.
16. Consequently, the impugned notice dated 08.04.2022 passed in case
No. ITBA/AST/F/148_1/2022-23/23/1042654010 (1) as well as order u/S
148A(d) of the Act of 1961 dated 07.04.2022 for the assessment year 20152016 are quashed and all actions in furtherance thereto are prohibited. However,
liberty is given to the respondent to reinitiate proceedings against the
petitioner/legal heir of deceased Shri Kamal Kumar Saxena, if so advised.
17. Petition is therefore allowed. No order as to cost.
(S. A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
Vatan
Signed by: VATAN
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:26:41 PM
(DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review