The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. In the case of Babulal and Others (supra) it has been held by this Court as under :“2- The petitioners were appointed on the post of Cook, Caretaker and 'Aaya' under the advertisement issued by respondent No.3. They appeared before the selection committee and were appointed and posted in Government hospitals under the National Rural Health Mission. The appointment orders were issued on 2.6.2011 and since then they are working under Chief Medical & Health Officer Shajapur District. The petitioners were appointed on a contract basis which was extended from time to time by the respondents. Vide letter dated 4.4.2017, their services were transferred to “Rogi Kalyan Samiti” by way of a policy decision taken by the respondents, however, they were not agreed to such transfer. 3- According to the petitioners, they were selected by the National Health Mission (NHM) under the HR policy, 2017. Some of the similarly placed contractual employees had approached this by way of W.P. Nos. 5844/2017 and 17624/2017 in which interim order was passed restraining the respondents to change their service conditions. Finally, the writ petitions were disposed of vide order dated 2.4.2018 by directing NHM to continue the services of the petitioners till 31.3.2018 and thereafter would consider their cases for renewal in terms of executive instructions issued on 1.4.2015 as per HR policy of NHM. Some of th…
24. 2.2020 disposed of the writ appeal restraining the engagement of other contractual employees by way of outsourcing in place of existing contractual employees. 4- Now, vide order dated 13.8.2019 the Mission Director has directed all the Superintendents of Medical Colleges, CMHO, Civil Surgeons to take the services of Caretaker, Cook, Cleaning worker, Security Guard, Hospital Attendant, Sanitary Attendant, Driver, etc. by engaging outsource agencies and the existing staff working under the Rogi Kalyan Samiti be engaged through these agencies . In District Shajapur the outsourcing contract has been awarded to Kamthean Security Service who issued the letter to the petitioners and others directing them for joining on or before 20.2.2020. Hence, the petitioners have approached this Court by way of the present petition. 5- Shri Jitendra Verma, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that in order to overcome the orders passed by the co-ordinate Bench of this Court as well as the order passed by the Division Bench, the NHM has illegally decided for engagement of supporting staff by way of the outsourcing agency. Learned counsel submits that now the State Government has come up with the circular dated 5.6.2018 for the grant of 20% reservation to contractual employees who have worked for more than 5 years against the vacant post on a contract basis and now in order to deprive the pet…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRANAY VERMA
ON THE 3rd OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 26657 of 2019
BETWEEN:TRILOKCHANDRA
S/O
KAILASHCHANDRA
SISODIYA, AGED ABOUT 29 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
SERVICE 99/1, DAMDAMA KOTHI ROAD UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY - ADVOCATE)
AND
PUBLIC HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE
1. DEPARTMENT SECRETARY VALLABH BHAWAN
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
KSHETRIYA SANCHALAK SWASTH SEVAYE
2. UJJAIN SAMBHAG MADHAV NAGAR HOSPITAL
CAMPUS UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
CIVIL SURGEON SAH MUKHAY ASPATAL
ADHIKSHAK AVAM SACHIV ROGI KALYAN
3.
SAMITI DIST CHIKITSALAY, UJJAIN (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
( BY SHRI BHUWAN DESHMUKH – GOVT. ADVOCATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 1551 of 2020
BETWEEN:-
Signed by: NEERAJ
SARVATE
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:44:10
RAJESH S/O RATANLAL JAT, AGED ABOUT 38
1. YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE H.NO.6, DURGA
COLONY UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
DINESH S/O AATMA SOLANKI, AGED ABOUT 32
YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE R/O: GRAM
2.
HAKKANIPURA TEHSIL AND DIST UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
RAMESHWAR S/O DEVILAL BALECHA, AGED
ABOUT 38 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE R/O:
3.
H.N. 326, RAJIV NAGAR AAGAR ROAD, UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
SANDEEP S/O VISHRAMLAL, AGED ABOUT 23
YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE R/O: GRAM
4.
KUNDIKHEDA , TEHSIL MAHIDPUR DIST UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
ARPIT S/O BALARAM, AGED ABOUT 23 YEARS,
5. OCCUPATION: SERVICE R/O: GRAM NAIKHEDI
DIST UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
GAJENDRA S/O CHANDERLAL RATHORE, AGED
ABOUT 21 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE R/O:
6.
GRAM NAYAKHEDI DIST UJJAIN (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY - ADVOCATE)
AND
PUBLIC HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE
1. SECRETRY VALLABH BHAWAN BHOPAL (MADHYA
PRADESH)
MISSION
DIRECTOR
NATIONAL
HEALTH
2. MISSION 8,ARERA HILS ,JAIL ROAD BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
CIVIL CERGEN SAH MUKHYA HOSPITAL
3. ADHIKSHAK EVAM SACHIV ROGI KALYAN
SAMITI DISTRICT CHIKITSALAY UJJAIN. (M.P.).
.....RESPONDENTS
( RESPONDENT/STATE BY SHRI BHUWAN DESHMUKH - GOVT.
ADVOCATE AND RESPONDENT NO.2 BY SHRI
ROMESH DAVE - ADVOCATE)
Signed by: NEERAJ
SARVATE
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:44:10
WRIT PETITION No. 11311 of 2020
BETWEEN:INDIRA SHARMA W/O RAMESH SHARMA, AGED
1. ABOUT 40 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE 40,
INDORE GATE UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
JYOTI BAMNIYA W/O MADANLAL, AGED ABOUT
2. 42 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE 462, DHANCHA
BHAWAN (MADHYA PRADESH)
KIRAN BILALDIYA W/O VINOD, AGED ABOUT 40
3. YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE 19/1, KAMAL
COLONY (MADHYA PRADESH)
SEEMA VERMA W/O KAMAL VERMA, AGED
4. ABOUT 40 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE 35,
PRITI NAGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
SEEMA KANDARE W/O RAKESH, AGED ABOUT 40
5. YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE KANCHAN BIHAR
COLONY, NEELGANGA (MADHYA PRADESH)
SANTOSH SISODIYA D/O KANHAIYALAL, AGED
6. ABOUT 23 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE 19,
JANSAPURA K.D. GATE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY - ADVOCATE)
AND
PUBLIC HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE
1. DEPARTMENT SECRETARY VALLABH BHAWAN
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
MISSION SANCHALAK NATIONAL HEALTH
2. MISSION 8, ARERA HILLS, JAIL ROAD (MADHYA
PRADESH)
CIVIL
SERGEON
AND
CHIEF
HOSPITAL
SUPRIENTENDENT AND
SECRETARY ROGI
3.
KALYAN SAMITI DISTRICT HOSPITAL UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
( RESPONDENT/STATE BY SHRI BHUWAN DESHMUKH – GOVT.
ADVOCATE AND RESPONDENT NO.2 BY SHRI ROMESH DAVE ADVOCATE)
Signed by: NEERAJ
SARVATE
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:44:10
WRIT PETITION No. 5736 of 2021
BETWEEN:SMT. RADHA W/O PRAKASH PARMAR, AGED
ABOUT 35 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE
1.
GULMOHAL COLONY MAXI ROAD (MADHYA
PRADESH)
ANIL S/O NIRBHAYSINGH, AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS,
2. OCCUPATION: SERVICE NEHRU NAGAR NAGJHRI
UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
SMT. MALTI W/O RAJESH SUNERIYA, AGED
ABOUT 37 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE HOUSE
3.
NO. 2, GALI NO. 3 NIJATPUR IMLI WALI GALI
UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
SHERU S/O KISHORE KAUSHAL, AGED ABOUT 21
YEARS,
OCCUPATION:
SERVICE
GRAM
4.
HARSODAN MAKSI ROAD. UJJAIN (MADHYA
PRADESH)
PRAKASH S/O DULAJI PARMAR, AGED ABOUT 40
YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE GULMOHAR
5.
COLONY MAKSI ROAD. BYPASS (MADHYA
PRADESH)
SHANTABAI W/O NIRBHAYSINGH RATHORE,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE
6.
NEHRU NAGAR. NAGJHARI UJJAIN (MADHYA
PRADESH)
HARIOM PRAJAPAT S/O JAGDISH, AGED ABOUT 24
7. YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE JAYSINGH PURA.
UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
( RESPONDENT/STATE BY SHRI BHUWAN DESHMUKH – GOVT.
ADVOCATE AND RESPONDENT NO.2 BY SHRI ROMESH DAVE ADVOCATE)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THR.
1. SECRETARY VALLABH BHAWAN BHOPAL (M.P.)
(MADHYA PRADESH)
MISSION
SANCHALAK
RASTRIYA
SWASTH
2. MISSION 8, ARERA HILLS. JAIL ROAD. BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
Signed by: NEERAJ
SARVATE
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:44:10
CIVIL SURGEON SAH MUKHYA HOSPITAL
3. ADHIKSHAK AVM SACHIV ROGI KALYAN SAMITI
JILA CHIKITSALAY UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
( RESPONDENT/STATE BY SHRI BHUWAN DESHMUKH - GOVT.
ADVOCATE AND RESPONDENT NO.2 BY SHRI ROMESH DAVE ADVOCATE)
These petitions coming on for admission this day, the court
passed the following:
ORDER
1.
With the consent of learned counsel for the parties the matters are
finally heard.
2.
As the controversy involved in all these petitions is identical they
have been heard together and are being disposed off by this common
order.
3.
The petitioners have filed the present petitions being aggrieved
by order dated 13.08.2019/13.07.2020 passed by the respondents. The
petitioners were appointed as Cook, Care Taker and Aaya under the
advertisement issued by respondent No.2. They appeared before the
Selection Committee and were appointed and posted in Government
hospital under the National Rural Health Mission. The appointment
orders were issued in the year 2013 and since then they are working
under the Chief Medical and Health Officer, Ujjain. The petitioners
were appointed on a contractual basis which contract was extended
from time to time by the respondents. Vide letter dated 01.08.2017 their
services were transferred to "Rogi Kalyan Samiti" by way of policy
Signed by: NEERAJ
SARVATE
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:44:10
decision taken by the respondent but they did not agree to such transfer.
4.
According to the petitioners they were selected by the National
Health Mission (NHA) under the HR policy 2017. Some of the
similarly placed contractual employees had approached this Court by
way of W.P. No.5844/2017 and W.P. No.17624/2017 in which interim
orders were passed restraining the respondents to change their service
conditions. Finally the Writ Petitions were disposed off vide order dated
02.04.2018 by directing NHM
to continue the services of the
petitioners till 31.03.2018 and thereafter would consider their cases for
renewal in terms of executive instructions issued on 01.04.2015 as per
HR policy of NHM. Some of the employees approached the Principal
Bench of this Court in which interim protection was granted against
which the State Government preferred Writ Appeal No.588/2017 which
was disposed off by order dated 24.02.2020 restraining the engagement
of other contractual employees by way of outsourcing in place of
existing contractual employees.
5.
Now by order dated 13.08.2019 the Mission Director has directed
all the Superintendents of Medical Colleges, CMHO Civil Surgeon to
take the services of Care Taker, Cook, Cleaner, Worker, Security
Guards, Hospital Attendants, Senitory Attendants, Driver etc. by
engaging outsourcing agencies and the existing staff working under the
Rogi Kalyan Samiti be engaged through these agencies. The
outsourcing contract has been awarded
to a certain service who has
issued letters to the petitioners and the other directing them to join.
Hence the petitioners have approached this Court by way of the present
Signed by: NEERAJ
SARVATE
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:44:10
petition.
6.
Learned counsel for the respondents has at the outset drawn
attention of this Court to the order dated 20.08.2020 passed by the
Gwalior Bench of this Court in W.P. No.11482/2020(S) Hariom and
Others V/s. State of M.P. and Others and order dated 01.04.2023
passed by this Bench in W.P. No.22341/2019 (Babulal and Others
V/s. Public Health and Family Welfare Department and Others)
stating that the controversy as raised in these petitions has already been
settled in the aforesaid decisions by this Court. On a perusal of the
aforesaid orders it is apparent as noon day that the controversy as raised
by the petitioners in these petitions has already been settled in the
aforesaid decisions. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that
against the said order a Writ Appeal has been filed and is awaiting final
adjudication. However he has not been able to provide the number of
the Writ Appeal nor has contended that any interim order has been
passed therein. Thus the aforesaid orders continue to be binding upon
this Court.
7.
In the case of Babulal and Others (supra) it has been held by
this Court as under :“2- The petitioners were appointed on the post of Cook,
Caretaker and 'Aaya' under the advertisement issued by
respondent No.3. They appeared before the selection committee
and were appointed and posted in Government hospitals under
the National Rural Health Mission. The appointment orders were
issued on 2.6.2011 and since then they are working under Chief
Signed by: NEERAJ
SARVATE
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:44:10
Medical & Health Officer Shajapur District. The petitioners were
appointed on a contract basis which was extended from time to
time by the respondents. Vide letter dated 4.4.2017, their services
were transferred to “Rogi Kalyan Samiti” by way of a policy
decision taken by the respondents, however, they were not agreed
to such transfer.
3- According to the petitioners, they were selected by the
National Health Mission (NHM) under the HR policy, 2017.
Some of the similarly placed contractual employees had
approached this by way of W.P. Nos. 5844/2017 and 17624/2017
in which interim order was passed restraining the respondents to
change their service conditions. Finally, the writ petitions were
disposed of vide order dated 2.4.2018 by directing NHM to
continue the services of the petitioners till 31.3.2018 and
thereafter would consider their cases for renewal in terms of
executive instructions issued on 1.4.2015 as per HR policy of
NHM. Some of the employees approached the Principal Bench of
this Court in which interim protection was granted against
which the State Government preferred Writ Appeal No.
588/2017. The Division Bench of this Court vide order dated
24.2.2020 disposed of the writ appeal restraining the
engagement of other contractual employees by way of
outsourcing in place of existing contractual employees.
4- Now, vide order dated 13.8.2019 the Mission Director
has directed all the Superintendents of Medical Colleges,
CMHO, Civil Surgeons to take the services of Caretaker, Cook,
Cleaning worker, Security Guard, Hospital Attendant, Sanitary
Signed by: NEERAJ
SARVATE
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:44:10
Attendant, Driver, etc. by engaging outsource agencies and the
existing staff working under the Rogi Kalyan Samiti be engaged
through these agencies . In District Shajapur the outsourcing
contract has been awarded to Kamthean Security Service who
issued the letter to the petitioners and others directing them for
joining on or before 20.2.2020. Hence, the petitioners have
approached this Court by way of the present petition.
5- Shri Jitendra Verma, learned counsel for the
petitioners submits that in order to overcome the orders passed
by the co-ordinate Bench of this Court as well as the order
passed by the Division Bench, the NHM has illegally decided for
engagement of supporting staff by way of the outsourcing
agency. Learned counsel submits that now the State Government
has come up with the circular dated 5.6.2018 for the grant of
20% reservation to contractual employees who have worked for
more than 5 years against the vacant post on a contract basis
and now in order to deprive the petitioners of claiming 20%
reservation the respondents have illegally come introduced this
outsourcing policy.
6- The respondent, NHM has filed an application seeking
the dismissal of the writ petition in the light of the order passed
by the Gwalior Bench of this Court in W.P. No.11482/2020 (S)
(Hariom V/s. State of M.P.) on 20.8.2020 whereby all the issues
raised by the petitioners therein have been answered while
dismissing the writ petition.
Shri Romesh Dave, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent, NHM submits that this writ petition is also liable to
Signed by: NEERAJ
SARVATE
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:44:10
be dismissed in the light of the order passed by the Gwalior
Bench in the case of Hariom (supra).
7- Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that
against the said order, a writ appeal has been filed and is
awaiting final adjudication.
Appreciations & Conclusion
8- In the case of Hariom (supra), the validity of the
impugned order dated 13.8.2019 was challenged by the
petitioners therein, who were appointed to the posts of
Caretaker, Cook and Sweeper by the NHM in the Gwalior
region. The order passed in the case of Sahma Maravi
(W.P. No.21775/2019) has been considered in the light of
orders passed by the apex Court in the case of Ram Kumar
Yadav and Uma Devi. The operative part of the order
passed in the case of Hariom (supra) is reproduced below :
“From para 2 of order dated 1-5-2018 passed
in W.P. No. 5697 of 2017, it is clear that the
respondents had decided to outsource the services of
class III and IV employees for better management of
health services at every District and therefore, it was
decided to transfer the existing employees to the Rogi
Kalyan Samiti. Thus it is clear that the respondents
did not decide to stop renewing the contractual
employment of the support staff, but they had decided
to transfer the contract employees to Rogi Kalyan
Samiti, therefore, the petitioners had a right to submit
Signed by: NEERAJ
SARVATE
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:44:10
that they donot want to work under Rogi Kalyan
Samiti.
However, in the present case, now the
respondent no.2 has decided to outsource the
employment of support staff through private agencies.
Once, the respondents have decided not to renew any
contractual employment and has decided that now
onwards they would employ the support staff through
outsourced agency, then the petitioner could not point
out that how such a decision of the respondents is
violative of Constitutional or Statutory rights of the
petitioners.
Further, it is the case of the Petitioners, that the
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Govt. of India
has taken a decision to outsource the employment of
support staff and accordingly, has also allocated the
fund of Rs. 2520.00 lacs, then this Court cannot look
into the decision of the Ministry of Health and Family
Welfare, Govt. of India for the simple reason, that
neither the Union of India through Ministry of Health
and Family Welfare, has been made a party to the
petition, nor the decision of the Govt. of India has
been put to challenge. Further, in absence of any
right, the petitioners also cannot dictate that the
respondent no.2 must employ the support staff in any
particular manner.
Further, as per the provisions of Section 4 of
Signed by: NEERAJ
SARVATE
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:44:10
M.P. Contractual Appointment of Civil Post Rules,
2017 (In short Rules, 2017), it is clear that a
contractual appointment can be made for a period of
one year subject to further renewal however, in view of
Section 11 (1) of Rules, 2017, the maximum term of
contractual appointment would be 5 years only.
Thus, the petitioners cannot claim that once
they have been given appointment on contractual
basis for a period of one year and the said contractual
appointment was renewed either by written order or
by verbal order, therefore, they are entitled to continue
in the said capacity, till they attain the age of
superannuation. Further, the respondents have taken
care of the interest of the existing support staff and
therefore, in the impugned order dated 13-8-2019
(Annexure P/3), it has been directed that preference
would be given to the existing employees.
So far as the interim orders passed in other
cases is concerned, the Counsel for the petitioners
could not point out that the interim order passed in
another case has binding force as a precedent.
Accordingly, this Court is of the considered
opinion, that since, the petitioners have failed to
establish any right to either continue to work on
contractual basis or for regularization, therefore, it is
incorrect to say that by taking a decision to outsource
the employment of support staff, the respondent no.2
Signed by: NEERAJ
SARVATE
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:44:10
has changed the service conditions of the petitioners.
Ex Consequenti, the petition fails and is hereby
Dismissed.”
8.
Thus in view of the authoritative pronouncement by this Court in
the case of Hariom (supra) and Babulal & Others (supra), the
petitions are found to be devoid of any merits and are accordingly
dismissed.
(PRANAY VERMA)
JUDGE
ns
Signed by: NEERAJ
SARVATE
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:44:10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review