Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3252 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY FIFTH DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION NO: 19181 OF 2026
Between:
The Wanaparthy District Paddy Rice Millers Association, Sy.No. 182,
Mirasipally village, Kothakota Mandal, Wanaparthy District, Rep., by its
president P. ParameshwarareddY
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Represented by its Ex- Officio Secretary to
Government, Consumer affairs, Food & Civil supplies Department, Civil
suppl ies bhavan, Erramanzil, Somaj ig uda,F{yderabad, Telangana.
2. The Telangana State Civil supplies Corporation, Represented by its Vice
Chairman/Managing Director, TSCSCL, Civil Supplies Bhavan, Erramanzil,
Somajiguda, Hyderabad, Telangana State
3. The Commissioner of Civil supplies, Civil supplies Bhavan, Erramanzil,
Somajiguda, Hyderabad, Telangana State.
4. The District Collector, Wanaparthy district, Wanaparthy.
5. The Addl. District collector, wanaparthy District, wanaparthy.
6. The District Manager, Telangana State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd
(TSCSCL), Wanaparthy District, Wanaparthy.
...RESPONDENTS
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to
issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ
of Mandamus, declaring the action of the Sth respondent in demanding the members
of the petitioner association rice millers to pay Rs.2236.81 per quintal by issuing
individual demand notices of auctioned paddy of Rabi 2022-23 though the said paddy
!va7
was sold in the public auction at Rs.1814 per quintal on 25.01 .2024 which was not
lifted by the auction purchasers for the want of quality, now after lapse of three years
paddy being the pershiable commodity as totally become unfit for human consumption
apart from other facts and circumstances which clearly establishes on face of the
record that the aforesaid auction paddy will not cosUworth Rs 1200 per quintal,
whereas demanding aforesaid unreasonable amount is without application of mind in
arbitrary manner in violation of Article 14,19 (t)(g) and2l of the Constitution of lndia
and consequently dire<:t the respondents to fix the reasonable price at Rs.12001- per
quintal by consideringl the detailed representation dt.06.06.2026 submitted with
documentary evidence by the petitioner.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Se:ction 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in suppol of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to forthwith
direct respondents tc consider the representation of the petitioner association
dt.06.06.2026 and pasr; appropriate orders by fixing the reasonable price for rabi 202223 paddy by objectively considering the total facts scenario along with documentary
evidence submitted by the petitioner association.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI K. RATHANGA PANI REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent No.1,3,4 & 5: GP FOR CML SUPPLIES
Counsel for the Resp,endsnt No.2 & 6: SRI K. DEVENDER,
SC FOR CIVIL SUPPLIES CORPORATION
The Court made the lbllowing: ORDER
--J
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION No.19181 OF 2O26
DATE: 25.O6.2026
Between :
The Wanaparthy District Paddy
Rice Millers Association, Sy.No. 182,
Mirasipally Village, Kothakota Mandal,
Wanaparthy District rep. by its President
P. Parameshwarareddy.
Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana,
Rep. by its Ex-Officio Secretary to
Government, Consumer Affairs, Food
and Civil Supplies Department,
Civil supplies Bhavan, Erram anzil,
Somajiguda, Hyderabad, Telangana
and 5 others
Respondents
ORDER
Heard Sri K. Rathanga Pani Reddy, learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner, learned
Assistant Government Pleader for Civil Supplies,
appearing on behalf of respondent Nos.l, 3, 4 and 5
and Sri K. Devender, learned Standing Counsel for
-
SN,J
W.P. No.19181 of 2026
Civil Supplies Corporation, appearing on behalf of
respondent No.2.
2.
The D,etitioner aDDroa ched the Court seekino
prayer as urrder:
"...to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more
particula rly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus,
declaring the actlon of the 5th respondent In demanding
the merrbers of the petitioner association rice millers
to pay Rs.2236.81 per quintal by issuing individual
demand notices of auctioned paddy of Rabi 2022-23
though l:he said paddy was sold in the public auction at
Rs.1814 per quintal on 25.O1.2O24 which was not lifted
by the aruction purchasers for the want of quality, now
after lapse of three years paddy being the perishable
commodity as totally become unfit for human
consumftion apart from other facts and circumstances
which clearly establishes on face of the record that the
aforesaid auction paddy will not cost/worth Rs.1200
per (luintal, whereas demanding aforesaid
unreasc nable amount is without application of mind in
arbitrar/ manner in violation of Articles 1a, 19 (f) (g)
and 21 of the Constitution of India and consequently
direct the respondents to fix the reasonable price at
Rs.120()/- per quintal by considering the detailed
representation dt.06.06.2026 submitted with
docume:ntary evidence by the petitioner and pass...".
-7
SN,J
W.P. No.19181 of 2025
3.
The case of the oetitioner, in brief, as oer the
averments made in the affidavit filed bv the petitioner
in suooort of the present Writ Petition is as under:The writ petition is filed challenging the action of the
respondent authorities in demanding Rs.2,236.81 per
quintal from the members of the petitioner association
towards auctioned paddy pertaining to Rabi 2022-23,
despite the fact that the same paddy had earlier been
auctioned at Rs.1,814 per quintal on 22.02.2024 and was
not lifted by the successful bidder. The petitioner contends
that the paddy has remained in storage for nearly three
years, being a perishable commodity, and has substantially
deteriorated in quality, rendering it unfit for human
consumption.
It is the specific case of the petitioner that the
respondent authorities failed to take timely delivery of the
paddy despite repeated requests from the rice millers,
resulting in deterioration due to prolonged storage, heavy
rains, reduction in moisture content, insect damage and
natural wear and tear. The petitioner further submits that
-
SN,J
W.P. No.19181 of 2026
the respondents have fixed the impugned price without any
scientific assessment, expert opinion or consultation with
the stakehol<lers, while ignoring the expenditure incurred by
the rice mill,3rs towards storage, unloading, transportation
and preservertion of the paddy. It is also contended that the
fixation of the price at Rs.2,236.81 per quintal amounts to
unjust enrichment by the State, particularly when even
good-quality paddy supplied for ethanol production was sold
at a much lower effective price.
The potitioner, therefore, seeks issuance of a writ of
Mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in
demanding 11s.2,236.81 per quintal as illegal, arbitrary and
unconstitutional, and consequently prays for a direction to
the respondents to fix a reasonable value of Rs.1,200 per
quintal after considering the detailed representation dated
06.06.2026.
PERUSED I
.HE
R CORD:
DISC USSI( )N AND CONCLUSION
SN,J
W.P. No.19181 of 2026
(i) In pursuance to the notice dated 03.06,2026
communicated to the petitioner association i.e. Wanaparthy
District Paddy Rice Millers Association, Mirasipally Village,
Kothakota Mandal, Wanaparthy District, Wanaparthy, the
petitioner submitted a detailed representation dated
06.06.2026 to the respondents herein which had even been
acknowledged by the office of the District Collector,
Wanaparthy and also the Telangana State Civil Supplies
Corporation Ltd., but in spite of the receipt of the said
representation made by the petitioner association, there had
been no action as on date. Vide the said notice dated
03.06.2026 issued individually to the Rice Millers in the
District Wanaparthy, the said Rice Millers individually had
been called upon to remit certain amounts within a period of
90 days without fail and the said notice further stipulated
that in case of non-payment of said amount within 90 days,
the Telangana State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd., would
proceed to recover an amount of Rs.2,44t,90 per Quintal
SN,J
W.P. No.19181 of 2025
along with ,25% penarty and r20/o interest.
against the interests of the Rice Millers
The notice is
and an unilateral
decision determining the amounts in crear
principles o. natural justice had
vioration of
been taken against the
individual Rice Millers, Though petitioner
submitted rr-.presentation on 06.06.2026
association
itself, in response
to the said notice, dated 03.06.2026, the respondents
are
silent in the matter. The State is bound
to act upon the
same, but failed to discharge its duty in
considering the
grievance o = the petitioner association
as put forth vide
petitioner's representation to the respondents
permission t,l the rice millers to pay
@ Rs.12OOl_ per quintal
and the said action of the respondents is illegal,
5.
seeking
arbitrary.
The learned counsel appearing on behalf
petitioner in support of the petitioner,s
placed reli:rnce on the Judgment of
of the
submissions,
the Apex Court
SN,J
w.P. No.19181 of 2026
dated 13.o4.2005 reported in (2o05) 276 ITR 225
passed in A.P. Wine Dealers Association and Others
Vs. Deputy Director of Income Tax (Investigation) in
particular para No.18 and also the recent Judgment of
the Apex Court dated 2L.O3.2O23 reported in (2O23)
18 SCC 1 passed in Orissa Administrative Tribunal Bar
Association Vs. Union of India and Others in particular
para Nos.36 to 39 and put forth the specific plea that
petitioner Association is a society registered under
Societies Registration Act, 1860 and hence as per
Section 6 ofthe said act is authorized to sue and to be
sued and hence petitioner Association is entitled to
approach the High Court ventilating the common
cause and the common grievances of the Members of
the Association.
ti
w.P. No.1e181 of 2l#C
(i)
Though notice dated 03.06.2026
been communicated to the petitioner
had been inrJividually served on
(ii)
admittedly had
association, the same
to the Rice Millers.
l-he petitioner submitted reply
dated 06.06.2026
to the Tel€rngana State Civil Supplies
Corporation Ltd.,
Wanaparthy in response to the
communicated to the petitioner
notice dated 03.06.2026
association
(iii) The detailed representation dated
of the petitioner Association addressed
No.3 would le duly considered in
06.06.2026
to the responclent
accordance to law, within
a reasonable period.
Takino into consideration
(a) l'he aforesaid facts and circumstances
of
the case,
(b) T'he submissions made by the learned
counsel app,earing on behalf of the petitioner,
Assistant (;overnment pteader for
appearing on behalf of respondent
learned
Civit Suppties,
Nos.l, 3, 4 and 5
and Sri K. Devender, tearned Standing
Counsel for
-
I
SN,J
W.P. No.19181 of 2026
Civil Supplies Corporation, appearing on behalf of
respondent No.2.
(c) The observations in the Apex Court
Judgment dated 13.04.2OO5 reported in (2005) 276
ITR 225 passed in A.P. Wine Dealers Association and
Others Vs. Deputy Director of Income Tax
(Investigation) in particular para No.18 and also the
recent Judgment of the Apex Court dated 21.O3.2O23
reported in (2023) 18 SCC 1 passed in Orissa
Administrative Tribunal Bar Association Vs. Union of
India and Others in particular para Nos.36 to 39.
(d) The fact that petitioner Association
submitted a detailed representation dated
06.06.2026, setting out its objections and
explanations in response to the notice dated
03.06.2026 communicated to the petitioner
Association. The fact that though the said
representation was duly received and acknowledged
by the office of respondent No.4. However, despite
such acknowledgment, no reasoned order or
s N,l
W.P. No.19181 of 2026
communication had been issued by the respondents
to the petitioner Association considering the contents
of the petitioner,s representation dated 06.06.2026
till date.
(e) 'l'he discussion and conctusion as arrived at
paragraph l{os.4 to 6 of the present order,
fl toe titio nis dis os
n
re ore
si
nta ion da
o6.o5. 202
r
ta
rce da
fu rnis ed
the
h
n
d 03.O5 ,2026 iss ued bvt he
resDon dent No .5 to the
iti oner Ass ocia tion, wit tn
eriod of
f
h
of the or der rna ccord an
ori ncioles
d
n
resDonse to t en
a
of da recti qt he
of
na tu ral
tol win con form itv w ith
lu stice
bv
o
vid ino
oooortunity of De rsona lhe nno toa lco cer ned a
an
nd
a
communicaite the decision to the oetitioner.
fn so far as the sub issi
rn
o
r
s
a
byt he
SN,]
W.P. No.19181 of 2026
l
'l
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this Writ
Petition, shall stand closed. ,
,
r
A
ASSTSTANT REGISTRAR
,,TRUE COPY'/
SECTION OFFICER
To,
I
t
State of Telangana' Consumer
. The Ex- Officio Secretary to Government, The
Civil supplies bhavan' Erramanzil'
Food and Civil supplies Department,
"tf"ir",
Somajigud4, HYderabad, Telangana'
by its Vice
ii"ngani state iirit .r-ppti". Corporation, Represented
z.
- itr"
Erramanzil'
ctrairmanlilanaging Director, ibcscr-, diyil Suppties Bhavan'
Telangana StaQ. ..
Somajiguda, Hyderabad,'ci;ii
s-upplies, civil supplies Bhavan, Erramanzil,
of
3. The commissioner
Somajiguda, Hyderabad, Telangana State'...
4. The D'dtrict Colbctor, Wanaparthy district, Wanaparthy'
S. fne ROAI. District Collector,'Wanaparthy District'.Wanaparthy'
Ltd
6. The District t,tanager,- iLianiaita Siate Civil Supplies Corporation
(TSCSCL), Wanaparthv District, WanaDarthv'
!tE7
7. One CC to SRI t(. RATHANGA PAN| ie ooV, Advocate TOPUCI
8. One CC to SRI K. DEVENDER, SC FOR CIVIL SUPPLIES CORPORATION
loPUCl
9. Two CCs to GP FOR CIVIL SUPPLIES, High Court for the State of Telangana,
at Hyderabad [CIUT]
10.Two CD Copies
BN
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2510612026
rE
.s
o,
ttl
ORDER
WP.No.19181 of 2026
u
o
s
s
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WTHOUT COSTS
t
o
u
\
c Hgl$ t
q
,
.?
{
J
)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review