Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/13
GAHC010174952016
2026:GAU-AS:3691
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : MFA/91/2016
THE UNION OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY THE GENERAL MANAGER, N.F. RAILWAY, MALIGAON,
ASSAM, GHY-11
VERSUS
M/S K.C. ENTERPRISE
KEDAR ROAD, GUWAHATI-1, ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MS.U NANDA, MR.D K DEY
Advocate for the Respondent : MR.K P MAHESWARI , MS.M SHARMA
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR SHARMA
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 26.02.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 13.03.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
: No
operative part of the judgment ?
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
Page No.# 2/13
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
(Sanjeev Kumar Sharma, J)
Heard Mr. D K Dey, learned counsel for the appellant and Ms. M Sharma,
learned counsel for the respondent.
2.
This is an appeal under Section 23 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act 1987,
preferred by NF Railways, challenging the judgment and award dated 10-05-2016
passed by the Learned Railway Claims Tribunal, Guwahati Bench, Guwahati in
Claim Application O.A No. 5/2010 (Old) & O.A No-I/Guwahati/2010/0005 (New).
3.
By the said judgment the learned Tribunal directed the Railway Authority to
make payment of compensation to the respondent for an amount of Rs. 2,52,611/(damage of 13150 kg of potatoes) to the claimant/respondent. The present
respondent, as the claimant, had preferred a claim application before the learned
Tribunal stating that the applicant/opposite party booked a trainload consignment
of 850 bags of potatoes (50 kg packing each) on 15.09.2009 under Invoice
Number 7760/Railway Receipt 212041708 from DKZ to NGC under trainload
condition in safe, sound and secure condition under railway risk rate after meeting
all legal and statutory inspections as per railway rules.
Page No.# 3/13
4.
The wagons containing the consignment were stranded at KIUL for about a
week. On being requested, CGS/NGC issued a telegraphic message dated
25.09.2009 for movement of the stranded wagons to the destination to avoid
damage to the potatoes. The applicant further averred that the consignment
reached destination after an abnormal delay and at the time of unloading, it was
found that the wagon doors were in an open condition, the wagon roof was leaky,
the wagon body was in a damaged condition and stacks of potatoes were in a wet
damaged/rotten condition and foul smell was emitting from them. On unloading, it
was found that 13,150 kg of potatoes were in a wet, damaged and rotten
condition. After proper inspection and verification, the respondent Railway
issued necessary short and damage certificates. It is also averred by the
applicant that despite serving notice along with the original Damage Delivery
Certificate and copy of Beejuck, the respondent did not pay any compensation.
As the damage was due to the negligence on the part of the respondent
Railway during railway transit, the respondent is liable to compensate the loss
sustained by the applicant along with interest and cost.
5.
The present appellant/respondent on receipt of notice contested the case
by filing a written statement and exhibited relevant documents. In their written
statement the Railway has contended that the consignment was booked by the
sender at the forwarding station under the remarks in the Railway Receipt
Page No.# 4/13
“wagon jointly examined found fit and water tight, train load condition complied
with loaded direct from truck/cart to wagon, loading not supervised by Railway
staff, bags not of uniform size, condition of contents not checked outer not
complained of, O.R”. The Railway further states that the Railway is not liable for
the alleged damage as the consignment was booked at owner’s risk rate under
Section 97 of the Railways Act.
6.
The present appellant/respondent also resisted the claim on certain other
technical grounds including the validity and sufficiency of the notice under
Section 106 of the Railways Act.
7.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the following issues were framed
for determination by the learned Tribunal:-
1.
Was there been a proper notice under Section 106 of the Railways
Act?
2.
Was there been any damage as contended by the applicant?
3.
Whether the respondent is liable to pay compensation? If so, to what
sum?
Page No.# 5/13
4.
8.
Reliefs and costs?
Neither party adduced any oral evidence. The applicant filed copies of the
Railway Receipt, the Message dated 25.09.2009 issued by CS/G/NGC, the
Open-cum-Assessment Delivery Report, the Record of Joint Survey of Open
Delivery (for Shortage and Damage), Notice dated 12.10.2009, original Sale
Invoice dated 15.09.2009 issued by R.S. Traders, original Bill dated 15.09.2009
issued
by
Nitin
Traders,
original
Acknowledgment
Letter
dated
16.10.2009/20.10.2009 issued by the Chief Claims Officer, N.F. Railway,
Amended Claim Letter dated 12.11.2009 and Affidavit dated 21.03.2012 of
Kusum More, Proprietor of M/s K.C. Enterprises, Guwahati, marked as exhibits
A1 to A10 respectively. On the other hand, the respondent filed copies of the
Delivery Deficiency Message, original Railway Receipt, copies of the Open-cumAssessment Delivery Report, the Forwarding Note, the Record of Joint Survey
of Open Delivery (for Shortage and Damage), Clause 1507 of the Indian
Railway Commercial Manual, typed copies of the Eastern Railway’s letter dated
11.10.1991, the Railway Board’s letter dated 25.05.1997 and the extract of
Railway Board’s D.O. No. 77-TCIII/49 dated 25.05.1977, marked as exhibits A1
to A9 respectively.
9.
The learned Tribunal, after considering the aforesaid documents, answered
Page No.# 6/13
all the issues in favour of the claimant/present respondent.
10. I have heard Mr. D.K. Dey, learned counsel for the N.F. Railway and Ms. M.
Sharma, learned counsel for the respondent.
11. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the appellant that the learned
Tribunal, while passing the impugned order, has failed to take into consideration
the remarks indicated in the Railway Receipt. It is submitted that the
consignment was booked by the sender at the forwarding station with the
remarks “wagon jointly examined found fit and water tight, trainload condition
complied with loaded direct from truck/cart to wagon, loading not supervised by
the railway staff, bags not of uniform size, condition of contents not checked by
railway staff, said to contain, packaging condition outer not complained of,
Original Receipt.”
12.
It is submitted that the learned Tribunal has failed to take into
consideration the law that has been laid down in the Railways Act, 1989. The
consignment was booked at owner’s risk rate under Section 65(2) and 97 of the
Railways Act. At the time of granting delivery, the consignor was required to
produce the sender’s original trade invoice but did not produce any such
document. As such, the appellant/respondent did not have the opportunity to
check or verify the consignment with the Railway Receipt.
Page No.# 7/13
13.
It is further submitted that the learned Tribunal, while passing the
impugned judgment, has failed to take into consideration the legal point that
the consignment was booked under the remark (RR). As per Section 65 and 97
of the Railways Act, 1989, relating to “said to contain” remarks on ‘RR’ as well
as non-supervision of loading by Railway staff, the burden of proof about the
number of bags, quality and quantity in proper loading lies on the consignor.
The burden of proving such negligence or misconduct shall lie on the consignor.
14. Learned counsel for the respondent, while taking the Court through the
impugned judgment, has referred to the findings of the learned Tribunal on issues
Nos. 2 & 4, wherein the learned Tribunal has referred to the exhibits, including an
attested copy of a message dated 25.09.2009, issued by the Railway Authority
stating as follows:-
“As shown in FOIS/NHC, a rake of Mixed Goods consisting 42 BCNA
wagon ex, DKZ to NGC and date of loading 15/09/09 is standing since
19.09.09 at your’s. Pleas arrange to send this rake onwards to NGC at the
earliest as the rake containing 6-7 wagons (Stated by Party) perishable item
(Potatoes) to avoid damage of the consignment.”
15. The learned Tribunal, on the basis of the letter, came to the conclusion that
Page No.# 8/13
the respondent had delivered the consignment at its destination after an abnormal
delay in transit despite full knowledge of the fact that the goods loaded were of a
perishable nature. The learned Tribunal also found that the fact that the
consignment was delivered in a damaged condition is confirmed by the Open-cumAssessment Delivery Report and the copy of the Record of Joint Survey of Open
Delivery Report (for Shortage and Damage), which were issued by the respondent
Railway and marked as Exhibits A3 and A4. The Delivery Deficiency Message
issued by CS/G/NGC, N.F Railway (Exhibit R1), also confirms the above fact.
Exhibits A3 and A4 show the quantum of damage as under:-
Damage Actual damage in Weight of
in bags percentage
sound bag
one Actual damage in
kg
106 bags 58%
50 kg
3074 kg
83 bags 70%
-do-
2905 kg
256 bags 40%
-do-
5120 kg
120 bags 45%
-do-
2700 kg
Total
13799 kg
-5% salvage value
689.95 kg
Page No.# 9/13
Total Wet Damage of Cement (in kg)
13109.05 kg
16. The learned counsel for the respondent has referred to Section 93 of the
Railways Act, 1989 which provides that a railway administration shall be
responsible for loss, destruction, damage or deterioration in transit or nondelivery of any consignment arising from any cause with the exception of certain
causes. Learned counsel has also referred to Section 97 which provides that
notwithstanding anything contained in Section 93, a railway administration shall
not be responsible for any loss, destruction etc. of any consignment carried at
owner’s risk rate, from whatever cause arising, except upon proof that such
loss, destruction, damage etc. was due to negligence or misconduct on its part
or on the part of any of its servants, subject to certain exceptions.
17. Further reference has also been made to Section 64 and 65 of the Railways
Act. Section 64 refers to the requirement of executing a forwarding note except
for exempted goods, whereas Section 65 provides for issuance of a Railway
Receipt in case where goods are loaded by a person, entrusting the goods to
the Railway on the completion of such loading and in other cases on the
acceptance of goods by it, which shall be prima facie evidence of the weight
Page No.# 10/13
and number of packages stated therein. It is submitted that the aforesaid
provision of Section 65 is applicable to cases of shortage, whereas the present is
a case of wet damage.
18. It is submitted on behalf of the respondent that the learned tribunal has taken
into consideration the railway boards D.O letter dated 24.09.1991 issued by the
Joint Director, Traffic Commercial (Claims), wherein it is stated as follows:-
“It is seen that all the seven pleas taken by the railway administration
to repudiate claims on damage by wet are such as cannot be sustained in a
Court of Law, Repudiation of claims on damage by wet on pleas such as
‘said to contain RR, loading directly from truck to wagon or loading not
supervised’ are relevant only in cases of shortage and not in case of
damage by wet. It has been clearly indicated to Zonal Railways vide letter
no. 77/TC III/49 dated 25.02.1977 that claims for damage by wet during
transit are payable unless it is proved by the Railway that the goods were
already in damaged condition at the time of booking.”
19. It was observed in the impugned judjment that in the case of Union of
India vs. Laduram, AIR 1974 Calcutta 207, that in order that the railway
administration may be absolved of its liability under Section 73, it is necessary
that in the forwarding note not only should there be a recording about the
Page No.# 11/13
defective or improper packing of the goods but also it should be further
recorded that as a result of such defective or improper packing the goods are
liable to damage, deterioration, leakage or wastage. It would, therefore, be
necessary to examine whether the fact of defective or improper packing and
the consequences thereof in the instant case have been recorded by the sender
or his agent in the forwarding note. A perusal of the Forwarding Note (Exhibit
R4) shows that no such adverse remark has been found recorded therein. The
Railway staff should have refused the booking of such consignment, if it were
defectively or improperly packed, since nobody prevented them from doing so.
20. In the instant case, it is an admitted position that the railway authorities
have issued the Open-cum-Assessment Delivery Report, which has been
exhibited as Exhibit A3, which clearly indicates that the goods in question were
received in a damaged condition both fully and partly and the perusal of the
Forwarding Note would also indicate that the total quantity of 850 bags had
been loaded, and moreover, there is no adverse entry regarding the condition of
the goods. Further, as per the Open-cum-Assessment Delivery Report (Exhibit
A3), the wagon was found in a leaky condition and the door was also found
partially open which also establishes negligence on the part of the Railways, and
therefore, by virtue of Section 97 of the Railways Act, referred to earlier, liability
Page No.# 12/13
for the damage has to be fastened on the Railways even assuming that the
goods were booked at owner’s risk rate.
21. Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, the reliance
placed by learned counsel for the appellant on the decision of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in Hari Sao & Anr. vs. State of Bihar, reported in (1969) 3 SCC 107
appears to be misplaced. In addition to what has been discussed above, the
circular of the Railway Board i.e., letter dated 24.09.1991, referred to earlier,
clearly negates the stand of the Railways, which may be relevant in case of
shortage but not in case of wet damage as in the present case.
22. Having regard to what has been discussed above, I do not find any
infirmity in the impugned judgment & award, and consequently the appeal is
found to be devoid on merit. It is dismissed accordingly.
23. Send back the records to the learned tribunal. The appellants are directed
to comply with the order of the Tribunal within a period of 45 days from today.
24. The appeal stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Page No.# 13/13
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review