Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/7
GAHC010177552024
2026:GAU-AS:3002
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/384/2025
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 2 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS, NEW
DELHI-110001.
2: DEPUTY INSPECTOR GENERAL
SECTOR HEAD QUARTER
SSB
TEZPUR
DIST.- SONITPUR
ASSAM.
3: THE COMMANDANT
33 BN
SSB
KEWTI
CHATTISGARH
VERSUS
VIKRAMJEET SINGH CHIB
SON OF BAJ SINGH CHIB, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- FLORA, POLICE
STATION- DOMANA, DIST- JAMMU, JAMMU AND KASHMIR.
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MS. B SARMA,
Advocate for the Respondent : , MR A HOSSAIN,MR. J I BORBHUIYA,A B T HAQUE
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE ASHUTOSH KUMAR
Page No.# 2/7
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE ARUN DEV CHOUDHURY
For the Appellant
: Ms. B. Sarma,
Central Govt. Counsel.
For the Respondents
: Mr. J. I. Borbhuiya,
Advocate.
Mr. L. Mohan, Advocate.
Date on which Judgment is
Reserved
:
NA
Date of pronouncement of
Judgment
:
25.02.2026
:
NA.
Whether the pronouncement
is of the operative part of the
Judgment
Whether the full Judgment has
been pronounced
:
Yes.
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
(A.D.Choudhury, J)
1.
We have heard Ms. B. Sarma, learned Central Govt. Counsel representing
the appellants. Also heard Mr. J. I. Borbhuiya, learned counsel for the
respondent.
2.
The intra-court appeal is directed against the Judgment and Order (CAV)
dated 14.12.2023, passed in WP(C) No.30/2015 by the learned Single Judge.
3.
Under the judgment impugned in the present appeal, the discharge of the
respondent from service in the Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB) was set aside, and
the appellants were directed to reinstate the respondent with back wages and
Page No.# 3/7
other consequential benefits.
4.
The learned Single Judge held that the dismissal from service is a
punishment under the Sashastra Seema Bal Act, 2007 (hereinafter referred to as
the Act, 2007) and such a punishment can be imposed under Section 53 of the
Act, 2007 in combination with the punishment prescribed under Section 51(C)
of the Act, 2007 only by a Force Court under Section 76 of the Act, 2007;
however, in case of the respondent, no such Force Court was constituted. It
was further held that there is no provision under the Act, 2007, which empowers
the Commandant to impose punishment of dismissal or removal based on a
show cause notice.
5.
The learned counsel for the appellant argues that the Commandant had
sanction and authority under Rule 26 of the Sashastra Seema Bal Rules, 2009
(hereinafter referred to as the Rules, 2009) read with Section 10 of the Act, 2007,
to discharge a member of the Force on the ground of unsuitability with a
further option to the member of the Force to resign from service. However, the
learned Single Judge has overlooked the aforesaid statutory position.
6.
The facts are largely undisputed.
7.
A show notice dated 27.12.2010 was issued to the respondent proposing
the imposition of the penalty of dismissal from service, based on his past
conduct and service record, concluding that he was not fit to be retained in
the Force. The Show Cause notice specifically mentioned the subject of the
notice to be “unsuitability for service”.
8.
The respondent submitted his written reply on 09.01.2011 to such show
cause notice.
9.
By order dated 28.02.2011, impugned in the writ petition, it was recorded
that considering the conduct of the petitioner, “led to his conviction” as to
render his further retention in government service undesirable, warranting
imposition of a major penalty.
Page No.# 4/7
10.
Accordingly, it was recorded that in exercise of power conferred by Rule 26
of the Rules, 2009, read with Section 10 of the Act, 2007, the petitioner is
discharged from service.
11.
The departmental appeal preferred by the respondent was also dismissed
on 29.04.2023.
12.
The principal issue that arises before our consideration is: (i) whether the
impugned order dated 28.02.2011 is a discharge simpliciter on the ground of
unsuitability under Rule 26 of the Rules, 2009 or (ii) whether, in substance, the
action amounts to punitive dismissal founded on misconduct, requiring
adjudication by a Force Court under the SSB Act, 2007.
13.
Section 51 of the Act, 2007, enumerates punishments, including dismissal
and removal from service. Section 53 of the Act, 2007, mandates that such
punishment be awarded only by a Force Court.
14.
Section 76 of the Act 2007 recognizes three kinds of Force Courts.
15.
The Act, 2007, does not confer any adjudicatory or punitive power of
dismissal from service upon a Commandant. However, Rule 26 of the Rules,
2009, empowers a Commanding Officer not below the rank of a Commandant
to terminate the service of an enrolled person on the grounds of unsuitability,
after informing and furnishing him with the particulars of all matters adverse to
him. The said Rule further mandates that the person against whom such a
termination is proposed be called upon to urge any reason he may wish to put
forward in favour of his retention in service.
16.
Sub Rule 2 of Rule 26 of the Rules, 2009, also empowers the Commanding
Officer not below the rank of Commandant to call upon the enrolled person to
retire or resign, and, on his refusal, the enrolled person may be compulsorily
retired or discharged from service.
17.
Thus, Rule 26 of the Rules, 2009, provides for administrative discharge on the
ground of unsuitability; therefore, such discharge cannot be termed punitive,
Page No.# 5/7
nor does it require a finding of guilt. It is based on an overall assessment of
suitability for retention in a disciplined force.
18.
As recorded hereinabove, the Rule further empowers the authority to advise
retirement or resignation of the enrolled to protect his financial interests. The
mere fact that such advise was given does not convert the action into a
disciplinary proceeding.
19.
The decisive test for determining whether the action is punitive in substance
is to examine the foundation of the termination, i.e., whether it is founded on
misconduct or, if so, whether the misconduct is only a motive.
20.
The Show Cause dated 27.12.2010, though it contains the expression
“dismissal from service”, must be read in its entirety and in the perspective
warranted in the facts of the case. The substance of the notice was to call
upon the respondent to explain why, in view of his overall conduct and service
record enumerated in the Notice, he be not discharged from service. The
reference to dismissal in the notice cannot override the statutory source of
power invoked.
21.
Beyond that, it is a mandate under Rule 26(1) of the Rules’ 2009 to provide
the adverse materials to the enrolled person.
22.
In the given facts of the present case, more particularly, under the mandate
of Rule 26 of the Rules, 2009, the past misconduct can at best be the motive,
not the foundation of the impugned discharge.
23.
The final order dated 28.02.2011 expressly records that it is passed under Rule
26 of the Rules, 2009, read with Section 10 of the Act, 2007 and directs
“discharge from service”. Although the order contains the word “convicted”, it
does not purport to record a conviction by a Force Court as contemplated
under the Act, 2007. Therefore, the reference to the word “convicted” cannot
override the statutory power invoked, particularly when no charge sheet was
filed, no Force Court was convened, and no punishment under Section 51 of
the Act, 2007 was imposed.
Page No.# 6/7
24.
Further, the operative portion of the impugned order does not impose
dismissal as a statutory punishment but orders administrative discharge. The
stray use of the expression “convicted”, when read contextually, cannot alter
the essential character of the action.
25.
The appellant, by filing an affidavit, brought on record the fact that the
respondent was given an opportunity as required under Rule 26 of the Rules,
2009 to tender his resignation; however, he refused to resign. Such a stand
taken in the affidavit before the learned Single Judge was not denied by the
respondents.
26.
In the given facts, the consideration required was as to whether the
authority exercised punitive jurisdiction under Section 51 of the Act, read with
Section 53 of the Act, or administrative jurisdiction under Rule 26 of the Rules,
2009.
27.
The absence of a Force Court, the absence of formal charges, and the
invocation of Rule 26 of the Rules, 2009, clearly demonstrate that the power
exercised was administrative.
28.
In disciplined forces like the SSB, assessment of suitability is statutorily
permitted and prescribed under Rule 26 of the Rules, 2009; such an assessment
necessarily involves an evaluation of conduct and service record. Such an
evaluation does not ipso facto amount to a finding of guilt.
29.
The learned Single Judge, with respect, erred in equating discharge under
Rule 26 of the Rules, 2009, with dismissal under Section 51 of the Act, 2007, and
proceeded on the assumption that any discharge necessarily attracts the
jurisdiction of the Force Court, overlooking the distinction between punitive
dismissal and administrative severance.
30.
The Commandant, being the competent authority, was mandated to
consider and evaluate the conduct and service record as part of the material
in forming an opinion regarding suitability. The statutory scheme emphasizes
reliance on such material for administrative discharge. The learned Single judge
Page No.# 7/7
failed to consider this aspect of the matter and conflated the source material
with the source of power.
31.
An additional aspect that merits consideration is the lapse of more than a
decade between the date of discharge on 28.02.2011 and the direction of
reinstatement. In matters concerning uniformed & disciplined services,
reinstatement after prolonged separation has significant implications for
operational
efficiency,
beyond
seniority
and
other
factors.
Therefore,
reinstatement with backwages after such a time lapse should not generally be
an automatic consequence and requires careful balancing of equities, which
was not undertaken.
32.
In view of the reasons recorded hereinabove, we are satisfied that the
impugned action was taken by the Commandant in exercise of power under
Rule 26 of the Rules 2009, read with Section 10 of the Act, 2007, and such an
action constitutes administrative discharge on the ground of unsuitability, not
punitive. Therefore, the absence of a Force Court does not vitiate the action.
33.
The appeal is accordingly allowed. The Judgment and Order (CAV) dated
14.12.2023 passed in WP(C) No.30/2015 by the learned Single Judge is set aside.
The Administrative power of discharge of the appellant is sustained and
restored.
34.
No order as to cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
CHIEF JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review