Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. A. 30/2025
The State of Tripura
represented by the Secretary, Home Department, Government of
Tripura.
----Appellant
Versus
Phayesha Begam, wife of late Abdul Mannan, resident of
Bejimara, Ward No.4, P.S. Sonamura, Sepahijala, Tripura
----Respondent
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, PP
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. J. Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Date of hearing
:
21.01.2026
Date of delivery
of Judgment & Order
:
28.01.2026
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
BEFORE
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT& ORDER
(Dr.T.Amarnath Goud, J)
Heard Mr. Raju Datta, learned Public Prosecutor, appearing for
the appellant-State of Tripura. Also heard Mr. J. Bhattacharjee, learned
counsel appearing for the respondent.
2.
The appellant-State, by means of filing the present appeal has
challenged the judgment and order dated 22.02.2024 passed by the learned
Special Judge (NDPS), Sepahijala Tripura, Sonamura, in connection with case
No. Special (NDPS) 82 of 2023, whereby the respondent has been acquitted
from the charge under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C)/25 of the NDPS Act.
3.
Facts leading to the present appeal are that, on the basis of a
secret information, on 28.06.2023, the informant conducted a joint raid and
search in the house of the accused-respondent and recovered 2 nos. of blue
colour plastic drum containing huge quantity (86 kgs.) of contraband articles
(dry ganja) stored in the house of the accused-respondent. A specific case was
registered against the accused-respondent. After completion of investigation,
charge sheet was submitted against the accused respondent under Sections
20(b)(ii)(C), 25 of the NDPS Act. Thereafter, learned Special Judge (NDPS),
Sonamura, took cognizance of the offence against the accused-respondent and
after supplying the prosecution papers, also framed charge against the
accused-respondent to which the accused-respondent pleaded not guilty and
claimed to be tried. Accordingly, trial commenced. During trial, prosecution
examined six witnesses out of nine witnesses and exhibited a document.
Subsequently, examination of the prosecution witnesses was closed and the
accused respondent was examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C. wherein he
denied all the incriminating materials brought against her and thereby the
learned trial Court by the impugned order acquitted the accused-respondent
from the charge leveled against her on the ground that the prosecution failed
to exhibit document to prove there was compliance of section 42(2) of NDPS
Act. It was also held that prosecution failed to prove seizure of the contraband
articles and also failed to prove chain of prosecution of contraband from the
time it was seized till forwarded for forensic examination. Being aggrieved,
the appellant has filed the present appeal challenging the impugned judgment
and order of acquittal.
4.
Mr. Raju Datta, learned PP appearing for the appellant-State, has
argued that the learned trial Court did not consider that the huge quantity of
contraband articles were recovered from the house of the accused-respondent
and the same relates to a grave offence under NDPS Act, but the learned trial
court acquitted the accused-respondent from the charges leveled against her.
Mr. Datta, learned PP has further submitted that there was no violation of
Section 41(2) or 42(2) of the NDPS Act, since learned trial Court did not
consider the communications made to the higher authority which were noted
down in GD Entries dated 28.06.2023 and also the authorization letter issued
in favour of the complainant. Learned PP has further submitted that the
learned trial court without giving any opportunity to the complainant to be
examined has disposed of the case in hurried manner. Learned PP has also
submitted that the learned trial court did not appreciate the deposition of PW-1
who was all alongwith the complainant during the entire search and seizure.
Learned PP has further submitted that the learned trial court did not consider
the settled principle of law that no accused can be acquitted from criminal
liability without facing proper trial and giving reasonable opportunity to the
prosecution agency. Mr. Datta, learned PP has further submitted that notices
were issued upon the witnesses but, without waiting for the service report,
learned trial court whimsically closed evidence of the prosecution witnesses
after examining only six witness without examining the complainant, most
erroneously acquitted the accused-respondent. Mr. Datta, learned PP has
further argued that many cases under NDPS Act exist where the accused
persons were acquitted without providing a proper opportunity to the
prosecution. Mr. Datta, learned PP has placed reliance upon the judgment and
order dated 30.07.2025 passed by this Court in Criminal Appeal No.4 of
2025, which deals with the similar circumstances, and urged for remanding
back the case for conducting fresh trial after setting aside the impugned order
dated 22.02.2024 by affording reasonable opportunity to rest of the
prosecution witnesses for their examination and cross-examination.
5.
On the other hand, Mr. J. Bhattacharjee, learned Counsel
appearing for the respondent-State has submitted that the learned trial court
has rightly closed the prosecution evidence since there was total failure on the
part of the prosecution to secure attendance of rest of the witnesses. Mr.
Bhattacharjee, learned counsel has further submitted that there was noncompliance of Section 41(2) and 42(2) of the NDPS Act on the part of the
prosecution. Learned counsel has further submitted that on verbal submission
of the prosecution, learned trial court has closed the prosecution evidence. Mr.
Datta, learned counsel has also stated the entire case is based on no evidence
and failure on the part of prosecution to comply Section 41(2) and 42(2) of
NDPS Act, hence urged to dismiss the appeal upholding the acquittal of the
respondent.
6.
We have gone through the case records and the orders contained
therein.
7.
The trial court took cognizance of offence on 18.10.2023 and
framed charge against the accused-respondent on 22.11.2023. After
commencement of trial, summon was issued upon the prosecution witnesses.
The learned trial Court by its order dated 22.11.2023 fixed the calender for
examination of the witnesses on 15.12.2023, 16.12.2023, 18.12.2023 and
19.12.2023. On 15.12.2023 no witness turned up and service report upon the
complainant (PW-1) returned without service. On 16.12.2023 only three
witness turned up and on 18.12.2023, three witnesses were examined. On
19.12.2023 summon upon the complainant (PW-1) returned without service
and in respect of other two witnesses no service return has been received, and
subsequently, new calendar was fixed for PWs 1, 8 and 9 on 25.01.2024 and
on 25.01.2024 no witness turned up but service report upon the complainant
and another witness has returned and one message from OC Jampuijala, a
prosecution witness, has been received whereby it was intimated that the
prosecution witness is unable to appear as he is on leave. On 31.01.2024,
charge sheet has been filed. Accordingly, evidence was closed on 07.02.2024,
and on 19.02.2024 the accused-respondent was examined under Section 313
Cr.P.C. and fixed 21.02.2024 for argument and on 22.02.2024, the learned
trial court in exercise of power under Section 232 Cr.P.C. concluded the case
acquitting the accused from the charges leveled against her. For convenience,
the relevant orders passed by the learned trial court, are reproduced here-inbelow:
“22.11.2023
Custody accused Phayesha Begam is produced from J/C.
One bail petition is filed for the accused lady by her Ld. Defence Counsel Mr. K. Mandol. Ld. Special PP
Mr. M. Sen is present.
Accused copy supplied.
Upon hearing of parties and after considering the available materials in police report I find sufficient
grounds to frame charge against the accused lady u/s 20(b)(ii)(C)/25 of NDPS Act. However, no
ingredients are found available for framing charge u/s 29 of NDPS Act.
In the result charge are framed u/s 20(b)(ii)(C)/25 of NDPS Act to which accused pleads not guilty and
claims to be tried.
Upon hearing of both sides and on careful consideration of materials available in charge sheet bail
petition is rejected.
Accused is remanded to J/C till 15.12.2023.
Office is directed to issue summons upon the witnesses as per following schedule.
Ld. Special PP is also requested to take necessary steps to procure the attendance of witnesses as
because custody trial is going on.
Inform.
Fix 15.12.2023 for Pws(CSW-01)
Fix 16.12.2023 for Pws(CSW-2 to 4)
Fix 18.12.2023 for Ps(CSW-5 to 7)
Fix 19.12.2023 for Pws(CSW-8 & 9).”
“15.12.2023
Custody accused Phayesha Begam is produced from J/C.
No bail petition for the custody accused.
Ld. Counsel Mr. J. Bhattacharjee, S. Ghosh and K. Mandol are present before the court for the custody
accused.
Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen is present.
Today the case was fixed for prosecution witnesses.
No witness is present today.
Summons to the witness SI Jagabandhu Debnath has returned without service.
Accused is remanded to J/C till 15.12.2023.
To date fixed for Pws.”
“16.12.2023
Custody accused Phayesha Begam is produced from J/C.
One bail petition is filed for the accused.
Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen is present with 3 witnesses namely Insp. Manik Debnath, Michil Miah and Ripan
Miah.
All the aforesaid witnesses are examined as PW01, 02 & 03 respectively.
Heard both sides on the bail petition.
In course of hearing Ld. Defence Counsel Mr. J. Bhatthcharjee appearing for the accused strongly argued
for bail pointing out that by this time 3 witnesses have already been examined. According to Mr.
Bhattacharjee accused lady is in custody since 28.06.2023 i.e. almost for 6 months. According to him,
there is no scope for conclusion of trial immediately as because in present schedule in spite of process
issued by the court complainant has not appeared in court.
Thus, Mr. Bhattacharjee referring a decision of Hon’ble the High Court of Tripura in BA no.
72/2021(Mithun Das Vs. The State of Tripura); and also showing the order of this court dated 05.10.2023
in 2023KLC073(NDPS) urged for allowing bail atleast interim bail to the accused lady for fair ends of
justice.
On the other hand Ld. Special PP Mr. Sen has raised strong objection to the bail petition pointing out that
complainant has not yet been examined and sufficient evidences has come for which there is no scope to
allow the bail in view of rigors u/s 37 of NDPS Act.
Upon hearing of both sides I have carefully gone through the evidence, on record available materials in CS
and also considering the several orders of this court passed earlier while dealing with bail petition for the
accused lady I am unable to allow the bail petition holding that there is no scope at this stage for coming
into a definite conclusion that accused is not guilty and shall not commit any further similar offence if
released on bail.
In the result, the bail petition is rejected.
Accused is remanded to J/C till 18.12.2023.
To date fixed for Pws”.
“18.12.2023
Custody accused Phayesha Begam is produced from J/C.
One bail petition is filed for the accused.
Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen is present with 3 witnesses namely Diptanu Chakraborty, Delowar Hossain and
Sirin Akter.
All the aforesaid witnesses are examined as PW-04, 05 & 06 respectively and discharged.
Heard both sides on the bail petition.
Mr. J. Bhattacharjee, Ld. Advocate appearing for the accused lady strongly argued for allowing bail by
drawing attention of this court that by this time 6 witnesses have been examined and nothing has made
out from the evidence of prosecution witnesses to presume that she would be guilty on the evidence on
record.
Mr. Bhattacharjee further pointed out that from the evidence of one of the witness it was made out that
complainant is very much available at SNM PS but in spite of issuing summons upon him he has not
appeared to give his evidence in the court. Mr. Bhattacharjee also submits that for non examination of
complainant it would be difficult to examine the IO who is scheduled to be examined on 19.12.2023
under present calendar.
Therefore, considering the available evidence on record accused lady may be released on bail considering
the fact that since long i.e. from 28.06.2023 she is in custody and facing custody trial.
Mr. Bhattacharjee has also submits about the evidence on record where Pw-01 admits that fact of
receiving secret information was communicated to the Higher Authority by message which amounts to
non-compliance of mandatory provisions.
He has also verbally submits that earlier in some cases this court granted bail in NDPS cases after filing of
charge sheet and Hon’ble High Court has also granted bail in several cases in NDPS matters. Accordingly,
Mr. Bhattacharjee submits that accused lady may be released on bail on any condition.
On the other hand, Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen raised strong objection for granting bail pointing out that
evidence of complainant not yet been examined and court cannot grant bail unless conditions u/s 37 of
NDPS Act is satisfied. On going through the record it appears to me that on several occasions different
judgments of Hon’ble the Apex Court as well as High Court was referred by the Defence in course of bail
hearing and those were duly considered by this court.
Needless to say that under Section 37 of the NDPS Act court can grant bail only after satisfaction about
twin conditions as embodied in Section 37(1)(b)(ii) of the Act.
After going through the evidence on record and also considering the fact that complainant has not yet
been examined I am unable to come into a conclusion that accused lady is not guilty of charged offences
and that she is not likely to commit any offence while on bail.
In the result the bail petition is rejected.
Accused is further remanded to J/C till 19.12.2023.
To date fixed for Pws.”.
“19.12.2023
Custody accused Phayesha Begam is produced from J/C.
One bail petition is filed for the accused by Ld. Counsel Mr. K. Mandol.
Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen is present.
No witness turned up.
Received a message from Insp. Swarna Debbarma of SNM PS with information that she is unable to
attend before the court for deposition due to her illness.
Heard Ld. Special PP.
By this time 6 witnesses have been examined out of 9. Complainant as well as first IO and 2nd IO remains
to be examined.
Summons to the complainant returned without service.
No service return in respect of another witness also.
Issue fresh summons upon CSW no. 01, 08 & 09.
Heard both sides on the bail petition.
Mr. K. Mandol appearing for the custody accused submits for granting bail on any condition pointing out
that since 29.06.2023 accused lady is in custody and already 6 witnesses have been examined from where
it was made out that case is suffering from non-compliance of statutory provisions for which there is no
possibility of conviction. Further he pointed out that independent witnesses not supported the
prosecution case.
Therefore, in this situation accused may be released on bail with any condition.
On the other hand, Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen has raised strong objection by drawing attention of this
court that complainant as well as IOs have not yet been examined.
According to Mr. Sen, until and unless trial is concluded it cannot be ascertained that accused is not guilty
and shall not commit any offence while on bail.
Therefore, u/s 37 of the NDPS Act there is no scope for granting bail to the accused.
Upon hearing of both sides, I have carefully gone through the records and found that yesterday also bail
petition was rejected after hearing of both sides.
In fact, no new ground exists at this stage.
It is true that out of 9 witnesses already 6 witnesses have been examined but fact remains that
complainant has not yet been examined who is one of the most vital witnesses of this case.
Under the aforesaid circumstances and considering the available materials on record, I am of the firm
view that for non satisfaction of twin conditions u/s 37 of NDPS Act accused is not entitled to get bail.
In the result the bail petition is rejected.
Accused is further remanded to J/C till 25.01.2024.
Fix 25.01.2024 for Pws(CSW-01, 08 & 09).”
“31.01.2024
Record is put up today on special petition.
One bail petition is filed for the accused person namely Phayesha Begam by her Ld. Counsel Mr. K.
Mandol.
Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen is present. Charge sheet has been filed u/s 20(b)(ii)C)/25/29 of NDPS Act
against the accused person namely Phayesha Begam.
Heard both sides on the bail petition.
Ld. Counsel for the accused referred two judgments: i) Dilip Barman Vs. The State of Tripura in BA 20 of
2023; ii) Rajjak Khan Vs. State of Rajasthan in BA 20651/2021; iii) Tapash Debnath Vs. The State of of
Tripura. Ld. Counsel for the accused person submits that charge sheet has already been filed and there is
no prayer for custody trial from IO. Moreover, he submitted that 6 witnesses have already been
examined so there is no chance of hampering the remaining witnesses.
Ld. Special PP cited one judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court(2022 LiveLaw (SC) 613, N.V. RAMANA;
CJI., KRISHNA MURARI; J., HIMA KOHLI; J. in CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. 1001-1002 of 2022 ARISING OUT OF
PETITIONS FOR SPECIAL LEAVE TO APPEAL (CRL) NO. 6128-29 OF 2021 in the case of NARCOTICS CONTROL
BUREAU Vs. MOHIT AGGARWAL.
Relying upon the above judgment Ld. Special PP raised strong objection to the bail prayer and he also
submits that due to the rigors of Section 37 of NDPS Act the accused person should not be released on
bail.
I have perused the record and the judgment referred by the Ld. Special PP.
In the para 18 of the referred judgment it is stated that: “ In our opinion the narrow parameters of bail
available under section 37 of the Act, have not been satisfied in the facts of the instant case. At this stage,
it is not safe to conclude that the respondent has successfully demonstrated that there are reasonable
grounds to believe that he is no guilty of offence alleged against him, for him to have been admitted to
bail The length of the period of his custody or the fact that the charge sheet has been filed and the trial
has commenced are by themselves not considerations that can be treated as persuasive grounds relief to
the respondent under Section 37 of the NDPS Act.”
In view of the above fact this court is of the view that it is not safe to conclude that the respondent has
successfully demonstrated that there are reasonable grounds to believe that he is not guilty of offence
alleged against him, for him to have been admitted to bail. Also as per judgment of our Hon’ble Apex
Court as cited above the length of the period of his custody or the fact that the charge sheet has been
filed and the trial has commenced are by themselves not considerations that can be treated as persuasive
grounds relief to the respondent under Section 37 of the NDPS Act.
Hence, the bail prayer is rejected.
To date fixed(07.02.2024).”
“07.02.2024
Custody accused Phayesha Begam is produced from J/C.
One bail petition is filed for the accused by his Ld. Advocate Mr. K. Mandol.
Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen is present.
Perused the record.
Heard both sides on the bail petition.
Ld. Special PP raised strong objection in rigors of Section 37 of NDPS Act.
It appears that on 31.01.2024 the bail prayer was rejected.
No new ground exits today.
Due to rigors u/s 37 of NDPS Act I am no inclined to allow the bail prayer in favour of the accused.
Hence, the bail prayer is rejected.
Accused Phayesha Begam is further remanded to J/C till 19.02.2024.
The case is pending at the stage of prosecution witnesses and already 6 witnesses have been examined
out of 9 witnesses.
So, on verbal submission of Ld Special PP the evidence of prosecution witnesses is hereby closed.
Accused Phayesha Begam is directed to furnish bail bond in compliance of Section 437A of Cr.P.C.
Fix 19.02.2024 for examination of accused person u/s 313 of Cr.P.C./ furnishing of bail bond in
compliance of Section 437A of Cr.P.C.”
“19.02.2024
Custody accused Phayesha Begam is produced from J/C.
Ld. Defence Counsel Mr. K. Mandol is present on behalf of the accused lady. Ld. Special PP Mr. M. Sen
is present.
Today the case was fixed for examination of accused person u/s 313 of Cr.P.C.
Accused lady was examined u/s 313 of Cr.P.C. to which she denied all the evidences of prosecution
witnesses and also declined to adduce any witness on her behalf.
Accused lady has furnished bail bond in compliance of Section 437A of Cr.P.C. which is checked, found
correct, verified and accepted.
Fix 21.02.2024 for argument.
Accused lady is further remanded to J/C till 21.02.2024.”
“22.02.2024
Accused person namely Phayesha Begam is present by filing hazira with her Ld. Defence
counsel Mr. K. Mondal.
Ld. PP Mr. M. Sen is present for the State by filing hazira.
The day it was fixed for Judgment.
Accordingly, Judgment is delivered in the open court in a separate sheets of paper which is kept
with the case record.
The operative part of the Judgment runs as follows:
“In the result, the accused namely Phayesha Begamis hereby acquitted from the charges
under Sections 20(b) (ii) ( C) /25 of NDPS Act, 1985 as framed against her and she is set at liberty at once.
Her previous surety, if any, stands discharged.
Sonamura Police Court shall dispose the seized alamats, if any, after observing
all formalities on expiry of period of appeal.
Thus, the case is disposed of on contest.
Make necessary entry in the CIS.”
8.
A court cannot automatically acquit an accused under the NDPS
Act merely because the witnesses did not turn up. Courts have the power to
compel the attendance of witnesses using various provisions of the Criminal
Procedure Code. The court must assess the entire evidence presented and
determine if the prosecution has proven its case beyond a reasonable doubt,
even in the absence of certain witnesses.
9.
This court in Criminal Appeal 4 of 2025 has relatably dealt with
similar and identical issue-in-question, raised in this appeal, wherein in paras
16 to 22 of the said judgment, this court has observed thus:
“[16] To deal with the case, this court thinks it apposite to extract herein below Sections 67, 87, 230
and 242 of Cr.PC.
67. Service of summons outside local limits: When a Court desires that a summons issued by it shall
be served at any place outside its local jurisdiction, it shall ordinarily send summons in duplicate to
a Magistrate within whose local jurisdiction the person summoned resides, or is, to be there served.
87. Issue of warrant in lieu of, or in addition to, summonsA Court may, in any case in which it is empowered by this Code to issue a summons for the
appearance of any person, issue, after recording its reasons in writing, a warrant for his arrest –
(a) if either before the issue of such summons, or after the issue of the same but before the time
fixed for his appearance, the Court has reason to believe that he has absconded or will not obey the
summons;
(b) if at such time he fails to appear and the summons is proved to have been duly served in time to
admit of his appearing in accordance therewith and no reasonable excuse is offered for such failure.
230. Date for prosecution evidence. –
If the accused refuses to plead, or does not plead, or claims to be tried or is not convicted under
Section 229, the Judge shall fix a date for the examination of witnesses, and may, on the
application of the prosecution, issue any process for compelling the attendance of any witness or
the production of any document or other thing.
242. Evidence for prosecution
(1)If the accused refuses to plead or does not plead, or claims to be tried or the Magistrate does not
convict the accused under section 241 the Magistrate shall fix a date for the examination of
witnesses.
(2)The Magistrate may, on the application of the prosecution, issue a summons to any of its
witnesses directing him to attend or to produce any document or other thing,
(3)On the date so fixed, the Magistrate shall proceed to take all such evidence as may be produced
in support of the prosecution;
Provided that the Magistrate may permit the cross-examination of any witness to be deferred
until any other witness or witnesses have been examined or recall any witness for further cross
examination.
[17] The learned Public Prosecutor's submission regarding the alarming number of 145 acquittals in
NDPS cases without proper opportunity to the prosecution and the subsequent resignations of public
prosecutors further underscores the systemic issues at play, which warrant immediate rectification to
uphold the integrity of the judicial process. The cases pertaining to 2022 were disposed of in 2024 in a
hurried manner, which was not warranted.
[18] In light of the fundamental principle that a fair trial is paramount to ensuring justice, this Court
notes with concern the Trial Court's premature closure of the prosecution's evidence. The Apex
Court's pronouncements are unequivocal Shailendra Kumar (supra) mandates the trial court's
imperative duty to secure the presence of the Investigating Officer and other crucial witnesses, even
resorting to coercive measures like warrants, to prevent the frustration of justice. This critical
responsibility was evidently not discharged in the present case, as the prosecution was denied the
opportunity to present its full evidence. For ready reference, the same is extracted herein below:
9. In our view, in a murder trial it is sordid and repulsive matter that without informing the police
station officer-in-charge, the matters are proceeded by the Court and by the APP and tried to be
disposed of as if the prosecution has not led any evidence. From the facts stated above, it appears
that accused wants to frustrate the prosecution by unjustified means and it appears that by one
way or the other the Addl. Sessions Judge as well as the APP have not taken any interest in
discharge of their duties. It was the duty of the Sessions Judge to issue summons to the
investigating officer if he failed to remain present at the time of trial of the case. The presence of
investigating officer at the time of trial is must. It is his duty to keep the witnesses present. If there
is failure on part of any witness to remain present, it is the duty of the Court to take appropriate
action including issuance of bailable/non-bailable warrants as the case may be. It should be well
understood that prosecution cannot be frustrated by such methods and victims of the crime cannot
be left in lurch.
[19] Further, the decision to terminate the trial due to the mere lapse of time stands contrary to the
dictum in P. Ramachandra Rao (supra), which firmly establishes that no rigid outer limit can be
prescribed for the conclusion of criminal proceedings, particularly if such termination stifles the
prosecution's ability to prove its case. The Trial Court's role, as clarified in Mina Lalita Baruwa (supra),
is not that of a silent spectator; rather, it has an active duty to ensure all relevant evidence is brought
forth and to intervene when necessary. This inherent judicial responsibility was not upheld. For ready
reference, the same is extracted herein below:
19. In criminal jurisprudence, while the offence is against the society, it is the unfortunate victim
who is the actual sufferer and therefore, it is imperative for the State and the prosecution to ensure
that no stone is left unturned. It is also the equal, if not more, the duty and responsibility of the
Court to be alive and alert in the course of trial of a criminal case and ensure that the evidence
recorded in accordance with law reflect every bit of vital information placed before it. It can also be
said that in that process the Court should be conscious of its responsibility and at times when the
prosecution either deliberately or inadvertently omit to bring forth a notable piece of evidence or a
conspicuous statement of any witness with a view to either support or prejudice the case of any
party, should not hesitate to interject and prompt the prosecution side to clarify the position or act
on its own and get the record of proceedings straight. Neither the prosecution nor the Court should
remain a silent spectator in such situations. Like in the present case where there is a wrong
statement made by a witness contrary to his own record and the prosecution failed to note the
situation at that moment or later when it was brought to light and whereafter also the prosecution
remained silent, the Court should have acted promptly and taken necessary steps to rectify the
situation appropriately. The whole scheme of the Code of Criminal Procedure envisages foolproof
system in dealing with a crime alleged against the accused and thereby ensure that the guilty does
not escape and innocent is not punished. It is with the above background, we feel that the present
issue involved in the case on hand should be dealt with.
[20] Moreover, the principle from Prodyut Kumar Baidya (supra) reinforces the court's obligation to
secure witness presence once summons are served. For ready reference, the same extracted herein
below:
4. Heard the submissions of the ld. Advocates appearing for the parties. Considered the materials
on record. From the impugned order it appears that the Sub-Postmaster, Katihar Post Office and
Head of Post-Office were served with the summons and they received the same. In spite of receipt
of the summons, the SubPostmaster, Katihar Post Office failed and neglected to appear before the
Court in answer to the summons. The ld. Magistrate sought to have taken steps according to law
for securing the presence' of the witnesses before him. Instead of doing the same, he simply
avoided it saying that the matter is a quasi-civil in nature and it is duty of the person who cited
them as witnesses to secure his presence before the Court. The part that is to be performed by the
party who cites a witness is to deposit the requisite and if on his prayer the summons are issued
then it becomes the duty of the court to secure the presence of that witnesses if the summons are
served upon that witness as the fiat of the court has not been complied with. In the instant case,
upon the prayer of the party summons were issued and served upon the witnesses but they ignored
the summons and failed to appear before the court. In such circumstances, the court is to take steps
for securing their presence before the court as contemplated under the Cr. P.C. The ld. Magistrate
is, accordingly, directed to take appropriate steps to secure the presence of the said witnesses
before the court and for that he may consider the exercise of his power under Section 87 of the
Cr. P.C. 1973.
[21] The cumulative effect of these judicial pronouncements leads this Court to conclude that the
Trial Court's actions constitute a clear deviation from established norms, resulting in a miscarriage of
justice that warrants the setting aside of the impugned judgment.
[22] This Court must remind the trial court of its powers and duties under the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973, as well as the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985. Section 67 of
the NDPS Act deals with the power to call for information, which is often a critical piece of evidence.
The trial court's duty to secure the presence of the witnesses who can testify to such information is
thus integral to the prosecution's case. Under Section 242 of the Cr.P.C., the court is to proceed to
hear the prosecution and take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution.
This is the stage where the prosecution is to be given a fair and complete opportunity. Furthermore,
Section 230 of the Cr.P.C. expressly mandates the judge to fix a date for the examination of witnesses
and to issue process for compelling their attendance upon the prosecution's application. Finally,
Section 87 of the Cr.P.C. provides the necessary legal mechanism, allowing the court to issue a
warrant for a person's arrest in addition to, or in lieu of, a summons, if there is reason to believe the
person has absconded or will not obey the summons, or fails to appear despite due service. The trial
court's inaction in utilizing these statutory powers to ensure a full and fair trial for the State led to a
miscarriage of justice that cannot be sustained.”
10.
From the record it is evident that after receiving the information,
the complainant (PW-1) on the date itself i.e. on 28.06.2023 entered the
information into GD vide GDE No. 14 and thereafter he intimated the matter
to his superior and the sought for permission and authorization from his
superior and the same was also entered into GDE No. 15, dated 28.06.2023
and on the same date itself, authorization was received from the SDPO,
Sonamura for conducting raid and the same was also reflected in the GDE No.
16, dated 28.06.2023 and thereafter, the complainant alongwith staffs of the
PS left for search and raid on the same date i.e. on 28.06.2023 and the same
was also entered into GDE vide No. 18 dated 28.06.2023. On 28.06.2023,
after receipt of the information from the complainant, the SDPO, Sonamura
vide authorization letter dated 28.06.2023 authorized the complainant to cause
search and seize the contraband articles. Thereafter, on 29.06.2023, the
Inspector of Sonamura PS submitted a detailed report under Section 57 of the
NDPS Act to the Superintendent of Police, Bishramganj, convening the search
and seizure wherein it was also intimated that if police presence was delayed,
then the contraband articles would be transported/smuggled in a short period.
For convenience, the GDEs, the authorization letter and the detail report under
Section 57 of NDPS Act, are extracted hereunder:
“GDE No. 14, dated 28.06.2023
This time SI Jagabandhu Debnath received an information from secret source that huge quantity of Ganja are
stocked in the house of one Phayesha Begam(53) W/O Lt.Abdul Mannan of Bejimara, Ward No04, PS SNM. The
information presumed to be true.”
“GDE No. 15, dated 28.06.2023
This time SI Jagabandhu Debnath communicate with SP(C/S)SPJ and SDPO(SNM) regarding the information
received which refers to SNM PS GDE no14, dated 28/06/2023 and intimated for necessary permission and
authorization for taking legal action.”
“GDE No. 16, dated 28.06.2023
This time received authorization from SDPO(SNM) to proceed for conducting raid on the basis of information
received which refers to SNM PS GDE no14, dated 28/06/2023.”
“GDE No. 18, dated 28.06.2023
This time Inspr. Manik Debnath, OC SNM PS, SI Jagabandhu Debnath, WC 11637 Sirin Akter with ps staff a/w TSR
staff left PS to verify the information which refers to SNM PS GDE no14, dated 28/06/2023 after receiving
authorization from higher authority search and raid in the dwelling house of one Phayesha Begam (53) W/O
Lt.Abdul Mannan of Bejimara, Ward No-04, PS SNM and warrant could not be obtained as the raid was to be
conducted very urgently to avoid concealing of evidences.”
“Authorization Letter, dated 28.06.2023
(Authorization to search premises U/S 41(2) of the NDPS Act.1985)
To SI Jagabandhu Debnath
Of Sonamura Police Station.
(Through OC Sonamura Police Station)
Whereas from the information laid before me by SI Jagabandhu Debnath of Sonamura PS that on
28.06.2023 at 1140 hrs he received an information from his reliable source over telephone that huge quantity of
Ganja are kept and concealed in the dwelling house premises of one Smti. Phayesha Begam (53) W/O Lt. Abdul
Mannan of Bejimara, ward No. 04, PS Sonamura And requested to moved at spot ie Bejimara for taking further
course of action as per Law. It transpired that an offence in respect of Narcotic Drugs/Psychotropic
Substances/Controlled Substances has been committed in contravention of the provisions of the NDPS Act 1985
and that there is reasonable belief that such substances and other articles, things, documents which may provide
evidence of the contravention of the Act and of holding illegally acquired property which are liable to
seizure/forfeiture under Chapter VA of the Act are kept and concealed in the at Bejimara, in his dweling house
premises said Smti. Phayesha Begam under the Control and Occupation, now therefore, by virtue of powers
vested in under Section 41(2) of the NDPS Act, 1985, you are hereby authorized to search the aforesaid place by
day or by night and seize such Substances, articles, things, documents and inform the undersigned about the
result of the search and action taken in respect of Substance, articles, things, documents recovered there from..”
Valid for 01(one) day.
Issued on 28.06.2023.”
“Detailed report dated 29.06.2023 U/s 57 of NDPS Act
To
The Superintendent of Police
Bishramganj, Sepahijala Tripura
Reference:- Sonamura PS case no 2023 SNM 087 Date-28/06/2023 U/S-20(b)(ii)(C)/25/29 of NDPS Act 1985.
Subject:- Submission of details report U/S-57 of NDPS act.
Sir,
With reference to the cited above I have the honour to inform you that on 28/06/2023 at 1140 hrs the
complt. of the case namely Jagabandhu Debnath sub-inspector of police received an information from secret
source that a huge quantity of suspected to be dry cannabis are kept and concealed in the dwelling house of one
smt. Phayesha Begam (53) W/O Lt. Abdul Mannan of Bejimara ward no- 04 PS- Sonamura Dist. Sepahijala and
requested for police present at spot i.e. Bejimara ward no. 04 for taking further course of action as per law
immediately, if police presence is delayed then contraband items will be transported/ smuggled very shortly. The
matter is reflected in GD vide SNM PS GDE no -14 dated-28/06/2023 and conveyed the matter to OC PS and
SDPO SNM and originated a letter of intimation to SP(C/S) Sepahijala Tripura and for authorization noted in GDE
no-15 dated-28/06/2023 and obtained written permission from SDPO SNM noted in GDE no 16 dated28/06/2023. after prior permission from superior authority SI Jagabandju Debnath along with women constable
no-11637 Sirin Akter, spo-109 Delowar Hossain, NK no.97050181 Uttam Kumar Das of 11-BN TSR, Pathaliaghat
and other TSR staff rifle men 01010521 Kamal Debbarma, Rifle men no. 02010522 Gour Sundar Roy, Riflemen no.
06111317 Ajoy Debbarma all are 11 BN TSR and accompanied by OC Sonamura PS Manik Debnath Inspector of
police along with other PS staff and with investigation kit left PS for Bejimara ward no. 04 noted in GD vides no18 dated-28/06/2023. On arrival at Bejimara ward no. 04, the complt. called two local people for remain
presence at the time of pre-search, search memo, he prepared search memo and conducted raid and search in
the house of alleged owner namely smt. Phayesha Begam (53) W/O Lt. Abdul Mannan of Bejimara ward no. 04
PS- Sonamura Dist. Sepahijala and during search the complt. found 2(two) no's blue colour plastic drams inside
containing suspected to be dry ganja(cannabis) which is kept in her(AP) dwelling house and during search the
complt also found available the house owner namely smt. Phayesha Begam(53) W/O Lt. Abdul Mannan of
Bejimara ward no. 04 PS- Sonamura dist. Sepahijala, thereafter the complt. have recovered this contrabands
drams, on measuring it is found that total weighing approx-86(eighty six) kg suspected to be dry ganja including
drams out of which exhibits marked "A" containing 42 kg, exhibits marked "B" containing 44 kg after preparing
proper seizure list in presence of independence witnesses and presence of OC Sonamura PS Manik Debnath, who
is acting as gazette officer, after that he detained the alleged house owner smt. Phayesha Begam(53) W/O Lt.
Abdul Mannan of Bejimara ward no. 04 PS. Sonamura dist. Sepahijala on being found available and brought to PS
after completion of seizure, the complt. taken over the custody of seized articles on arrival at PS the complt.
handed over the seized articles to OC Malkhana of SNM PS which is taken into the custody and kept at Malkhana
vide SNM PS MR no. 400/23 dated 28/06/2023.
On returned at PS SI Jagabandhu Debnath lodged a Suo-Moto complain to the O/C Sonamura PS against
smt. Phayesha Begam (53) W/O Lt. Abdul Mannan of Bejimara ward no. 04,PS-SNM for taking. necessary action
as per provision of Law
On the basis of Suo muto complain of the complainant registered the instant case and OC PS endorsed to
me for its investigation.
This is for favour of your kind information and perusal please.”
10.
Section 41 of the NDPS Act, reads as follows:“41. Power to issue warrant and authorisation.- (1) A Metropolitan Magistrate or a Magistrate of the first class
or any Magistrate of the second class specially empowered by the State Government in this behalf, may issue
a warrant for the arrest of any person whom he has reason to believe to have committed any offence
punishable under Chapter IV, or for the search, whether by day or by night, of any building, conveyance or
place in which he has reason to believe any narcotic drug or psychotropic substance in respect of which an
offence punishable under Chapter IV has been committed or any document or other article which may furnish
evidence of the commission of such offence is kept or concealed.
(2) Any such officer of gazetted rank of the departments of central excise, narcotics, customs, revenue
intelligence or any other department of the Central Government or of the Border Security Force as is
empowered in this behalf by general or special order by the Central Government, or any such officer of the
revenue, drugs control, excise, police or any other department of a State Government as is empowered in this
behalf by general or special order of the State Government, if he has reason to believe from personal
knowledge or information given by any person and taken in writing that any person has committed an offence
punishable under Chapter IV or that any narcotic drug, or psychotropic substance in respect of which any
offence punishable under Chapter IV has been committed or any document or other article which may furnish
evidence of the commission of such offence has been kept or concealed in any building, conveyance or place,
may authorise any officer subordinate to him but superior in rank to a peon, sepoy, or a constable, to arrest
such a person or search a building, conveyance or place whether by day or by night or himself arrest a person
or search a building, conveyance or place.
(3) The officer to whom a warrant under sub-section (1) is addressed and the officer who authorised the arrest
or search or the officer who is so authorised under sub- section (2) shall have all the powers of an officer
acting under section 42.
Section 42 of the NDPS Act, provides:42. Power of entry, search, seizure and arrest without warrant or authorisation. (1) Any such officer (being an
officer superior in rank to a peon, sepoy or constable) of the departments of central excise, narcotics, customs,
revenue intelligence or any other department of the Central Government or of the Border Security Force as is
empowered in this behalf by general or special order by the Central Government, or any such officer (being an
officer superior in rank to a peon, sepoy or constable) of the revenue, drugs control, excise, police or any other
department of a State Government as is empowered in this behalf by general or special order of the State
Government, if he has reason to believe from personal knowledge or information given by any person and
taken down in writing, that any narcotic drug, or psychotropic substance, in respect of which an offence
punishable under Chapter IV has been committed or any document or other article which may furnish
evidence of the commission of such offence is kept or concealed in any building, conveyance or enclosed
place, may, between sunrise and sunset
(a) enter into and search any such building, conveyance or place;
(b) in case of resistance, break open any door and remove any obstacle to such entry;
(c) such drug or substance and all materials used in the manufacture thereof and any other article and any
animal or conveyance which he has reason to believe to be liable to confiscation under this Act and any
document or other article which he has reason to believe may furnish evidence of the commission of any
offence punishable under Chapter IV relating to such drug or substance; and
(d) detain and search, and, if he thinks proper, arrest any person whom he has reason to believe to have
committed any offence punishable under Chapter IV relating to such drug or substance:
Provided that if such officer has reason to believe that a search warrant or authorisation cannot be obtained
without affording opportunity for the concealment of evidence or facility for the escape of an offender, he
may enter and search such building, conveyance or enclosed place at any time between sun set and sun rise
after recording the grounds of his belief.
(2) Where an officer takes down any information in writing under sub-section (1) or records grounds for his
belief under the proviso thereto he shall forthwith send a copy thereof to his immediate official superior.
Here it is also necessary to read Section 50 of the NDPS Act, which is
extracted here-in-below:
“50. Conditions under which search of persons shall be conducted.—
(1)When any officer duly authorised under section 42 is about to search any person under the provisions of
section 41, section 42 or section 43, he shall, if such person so requires, take such person without unnecessary
delay to the nearest Gazette Officer of any of the departments mentioned in section 42 or to the nearest
Magistrate.
(2)If such requisition is made, the officer may detain the person until he can bring him before the Gazetted
Officer or the Magistrate referred to in subsection (1).
(3)The Gazette Officer or the Magistrate before whom any such person is brought shall, if he sees no reasonable
ground for search, forthwith discharge the person but otherwise shall direct that search be made.
(4)No female shall be searched by anyone excepting a female.
(5)When an officer duly authorised under section 42 has reason to believe that it is not possible to take the
person to be searched to the nearest Gazetted Officer or Magistrate without the possibility of the person to be
searched parting with possession of any narcotic drug or psychotropic substance, or controlled substance or
article or document, he may, instead of taking such person to the nearest Gazette Officer or Magistrate, proceed
to search the person as provided under section 100 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974).
(6)After a search is conducted under sub-section (5), the officer shall record the reasons for such belief which
necessitated such search and within seventy-two hours send a copy thereof to his immediate official superior”.
From the above, it is clear that it is not mandatory for the superior
officer to be physically present at the scene of a raid and search, provided that
the legal requirements regarding authorization and information are fulfilled.
Intimation to the superior officer can satisfy the requirements. Here in this
case, immediately after getting the secret information, the complainant
conveyed the matter to his superior and sought for authorizing him to conduct
the search and raid subsequent to which he was authorized thereby, and the
communications were also recorded in the GD books, as mentioned
hereinabove. It is also seen that on receipt of information, GD was made and
on apprehension of the contraband articles being transported, the complainant
opted for authorization from his superior by making GD which was accorded
and in pursuance thereof, the search party apprehended the accused and
recovered the contraband from her and the custody of the contraband from the
time of recovery to the time, it reached the trial Court stands sufficiently
explained. The samples have been taken and requisite seals have been affixed.
It is clear that the samples which were taken from the seized contraband had
been sent for analysis and the test report has confirmed that what was seized
was contraband. Thus, all the mandatory provisions of N.D.P.S. Act, required
in this case, have been complied with. Further, from the seizure memo, it is
confirmed that the contraband articles were seized from the possession of the
accused-respondent. Further, the charge-sheet also reveals that the house from
where the contraband articles were recovered belongs to the accusedrespondent. Further, it was the complainant himself to prove the prosecution
papers in the trial, but the same cannot be exhibited since the complainant was
not afforded with reasonable opportunity to depose as witness before the
learned trial court. The complainant was the most vital witness in the case but,
facts remain, he was not afforded opportunity to depose before the learned
court and without his examination, the evidence was closed. To ensure
appearance of a witness, the court uses legal mechanisms by rendering
summon upon the witness and if the witness fails to appear after being served
with a summons, the court can issue a bailable or non-bailable warrant to
compel his/her attendance, but, the learned trial court refrains itself from
adopting such procedure rather closed the evidence without securing evidence
of the vital witness (complainant).
11.
When a court has previously dealt with a similar issue, the legal
principle of precedent generally requires that the same law be applied to
ensure consistency and predictability in the legal system. In light of the
precedents cited, the Court held that the trial court had committed error in law
in acquitting the accused-respondent without securing evidence of the
prosecution witness. Thus, the impugned judgment and order passed by the
learned trial Court is a miscarriage of justice and the same cannot sustain.
12.
In fine, the impugned judgment and order dated 22.02.2024
passed by the learned Special Judge(NDPS), Sepahijala District, Sonamura, in
case No. Special(NDPS) 82 of 2023, is hereby set-aside. Accordingly, the
matter is remanded back to the learned Special Judge(NDPS), Sepahijala
District, Sonamura, with a direction to conduct a fresh trial by calling upon
rest of the prosecution witnesses. However, it is made clear that reasonable
opportunity shall be afforded to the prosecution witnesses. It is further made
clear that after closure of evidences of all the prosecution witnesses, learned
Court below shall deliver its judgment afresh. The entire exercise shall be
completed expeditiously.
The appeal stands allowed to the extent as indicated above.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed.
13.
The accused-respondent is directed to surrender before the
learned trial Court on or before 10.02.2026. Upon his surrender, the learned
trial Court may consider bail application, if so, filed by her, in accordance
with law. It is needless to observe that, in the event the accused- respondent is
on bail pending trial, the benefit shall be extended to her.
S.DATTA PURKAYASTHA,J
SAIKAT KAR
DR.T. AMARNATH GOUD,J
KAR
Date: 2026.01.29 01:12:21
-08'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review