Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:THC:659-DB
TRHC010019452025
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. A. 53/2025
The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary, Home
Department, Government of Tripura;
…. Appellant
Versus
Jammu Baig, son of Rafiq Baig, resident of Bichli Guvadi,
Jilawada, P.S. Srinagar, District- Ajmer, Rajasthan.
----Respondent
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, PP
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate
Date of hearing & delivery
of Judgment & Order
:
13.05.2026
Date of delivery of judgment
& Order
:
20.05.2026
Whether fit for reporting
Yes
:
BEFORE
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(Dr.T.Amarnath Goud, J)
Heard Mr. Raju Datta, learned PP appearing for the
appellant-State. Also heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent.
2.
The judgment dated 19.05.2025, passed in Special
(NDPS) 64 of 2022 by the Special Judge, Court No.2, Khowai
District, has been assailed by the appellant-State by means of this
appeal, whereby the respondent had been acquitted from the
charge under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C)/25/29 of NDPS Act.
3.
Precisely stated, on 08.03.2022 while the complainant
of the case alongwith PS staffs were performing vehicle checking
duty at Salbagan on NH-08 Assam-Agartala road, at about 1145
Page 2
hours, they detained a vehicle bearing registration no. RJ-51-GA0392 (Multi Axle Trailer) coming from Teliamura to Ambassa
side, and on checking they found two boxes in hidden condition
under the trailer containing brown coloured packets of suspected
dry ganja, and thereby recovered 30 numbers of packets of dry
ganja weighing 292 kgs. in presence of O/C, Mungiakami PS and
SDPO, Teliamura, and thereafter the complainant seized those 30
numbers of packets of dry ganja, the truck alongwith its
documents by preparing seizure list and also arrested the
respondent and one Mukesh Sing, who are driver and co-driver.
Thereafter, a suo-moto complaint was lodged by the complainant
before
the
O/c,
Mungiakami
PS,
which
was
subsequently
registered as Mungiakami PS case No. 7 of 2022 dated
08.03.2022, under sections 20(b)(ii)(C)/25/29 of the NDPS Act,
and accordingly investigation was launched.
4.
On completion of investigation, charge sheet was
submitted
against
the
accused
respondent
under
Sections
20(b)(ii)(C)/25/29 of the NDPS Act. Thereafter, trial Court took
cognizance of the offence against the accused-respondent,
supplied the prosecution papers, also framed charge against the
accused-respondent to which the accused-respondent pleaded
not guilty and claimed to be tried. Accordingly, trial commenced.
During trial, prosecution examined ten witnesses and exhibited
some documents.
After closure of prosecution witnesses the
accused respondent was examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C.
wherein he denied all the incriminating materials brought against
him, and thereby learned trial Court by the impugned order
Page 3
acquitted the accused-respondent from the charges leveled
against him on the ground of non-production of Malkhana
Register and also on the ground of non-compliance of provisions
of sections 52A(2) and 57 of NDPS Act. It was also held that
prosecution failed to prove seizure of the contraband articles and
also failed to prove chain of prosecution of contraband from the
time it was seized till forwarded for forensic examination. Being
aggrieved, the appellant has filed the present appeal challenging
the impugned judgment and order of acquittal.
5.
Mr. Raju Datta, learned PP appearing for the appellant-
State, has submitted that the dry ganjas were seized under proper
seizure list and were deposited in the District NDPS godown under
Malkhana Register No.250 and subsequently were withdrawn and
redeposited in the NDPS godown under proper certification and,
thereby provisions of Section 52A(2) of the Act has been duly
complied with. He has further submitted that though the Malkhana
Register formed judicial part but the same could not be exhibited
since the IO of the concerned PS could not be examined, and the
trial court without affording opportunity to examine the IO closed
the evidence. Learned PP has also submitted that the IO of the
case also submitted detailed report under Section 57 of NDPS Act
to the SP, Khowai, which also could not be exhibited due to nonexamination of the IO. Learned PP has also submitted that the
prosecution has well established its case by adducing oral and
documentary evidence and mere non-exhibit of Malkhana register
cannot warrant acquittal of the accused-respondent. Learned PP
has also submitted that the contraband articles were seized by
Page 4
preparing seizure list under signature of the available witnesses.
Mr. Datta, learned PP has further submitted that there was no
violation of Section 52A(2) or 42 or 57 of the NDPS Act. Learned
PP has also submitted that the learned trial court did not
appreciate the deposition of PW-9. He has also submitted that the
seizure list was duly proved by the witnesses during trial. Learned
PP has further submitted that the learned trial court did not
consider the settled principle of law that no accused can be
acquitted from criminal liability without facing proper trial and
giving reasonable opportunity to the prosecution agency. Mr.
Datta, learned PP has further submitted that learned trial court
whimsically closed evidence without examining the complainant
enabling the prosecution to exhibit the documents, and most
erroneously
acquitted
the
accused-respondent.
On
to
his
submission, Mr. Datta, learned PP has placed reliance upon
judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in Bharat Aambale vs. State of
Chhattisgarh, reported in (2025)8 SCC 452, paras 37 and 38;
Kailas vs. State of Maharashtra, reported in 2025 SCC OnLine
SC 1977, which deal of procedural provisions under Section 52A
of the Act. Mr. Datta, learned PP has also referred to a judgment
rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in State of Rajasthan vs.
Sahi Ram, reported in (2019) 10 SCC 649, para 18, wherein it
deals with the possibility and feasibility of production of the seized
articles before the court.
6.
To refute the submission of learned PP, Mr. lodh,
learned Counsel appearing for the respondent-accused has
submitted that the learned trial court has rightly closed the
Page 5
prosecution evidence since there was total failure on the part of
the prosecution to secure attendance of the I.O. Mr. Lodh,
learned counsel has placed his argument in the following folds:
(i)
malkhana register attached with the Memo of Appeal is full
up of lacuna under prescription of law and the same was never
produced before the trial court, hence the appellate court has no
jurisdiction to look into the Xerox copy which was submitted by
the appellant alongwith the memo of appeal; (ii) the prosecution
did not file any application for adducing any additional evidence;
(iii) chain of custody of the contraband seized articles has not
been established and there is serious discrepancy is depositing
and re-depositing the same and also under whose custody the
seized contraband articles were lying during performing the
procedural aspects has no evidence thereby discarding the link;
(iv) additional evidence cannot be taken by the appellate court if
the same was not produced in trial court during trial; (v) serious
non-compliance of Section 52A(2) and 42 of the NDPS Act; Mr.
Lodh, learned counsel has also stated the entire case is based on
no evidence and failure on the part of prosecution to comply
Section 52A(2) and 42 of NDPS Act, hence urged to dismiss the
appeal upholding the acquittal of the respondent. In support of
his submission, Mr. Lodh has placed reliance upon Central
Bureau of Investigation vs. Shyam Bihari & ors., reported in
(2023) 8 SCC 197, para 27; Mohammed Khalid & anr. Vs.
State of Telengana reported in (2024)5 SCC 393, paras 23,
25; Karnajit Das vs. State of Tripura [Crl.A(J) 29 of 2023,
Page 6
decided on 30.07.2024]; Crl.L.P. 4 of 2024 [ Ebadul Islam
vs. Rajjib Hossain @ Rajib & ors., decided on 22.04.2024]
7.
We have gone through the case records and the orders
contained therein.
8.
The contraband articles were seized on 08.03.2022
from the possession of the respondent-accused and another and
the same contains signatures of PW 3, 6 and 7 and they have
proved their signature during the course of their deposition. In
course of investigation, on the same day, the IO prepared the
inventory of the seized articles and alongwith the seized articles
and the arrested accused persons returned to the PS and lodged
the suo moto complaint, and thereafter on 09.03.2022 as per
Court’s order produced the seized articles before the court on
11.03.2022,
and
for
correctness
of
the
inventory
took
photograph in presence of learned JM, 1 st class, Khowai, and
sealed the packets in brown colour packets with proper gala
infront of the learned JM, 1 st class keeping Exhibit A and B, as
representative sample in yellow colour packets under proper gala
and seal of learned JM, 1st class, Khowai. Thereafter, the
contraband articles wrapped in packets were deposited in District
NDPS store for safe custody until disposal order from learned
court. On 15.03.2022 through forwarding letter issued by SDPO,
Teliamura, the same were sent to SFSL, Narsinghar, for
examination and opinion and on 20.05.2022 received the SFSL
report. Subsequently, upon prayer of the I.O., learned Special
Judge(NDPS) by its order dated 08.06.2022 directed the I.O. to
dispose of the remaining seized contraband items through Drug
Page 7
Disposal Committee as per provision of Section 52A of the Act,
and on 21.06.2022, the I.O. made prayer before the Chairman ,
State Drug Disposal Committee for such disposal. After disposal,
the Chairman, State Drug Disposal Committee, issued certificate
of destruction dated 10.08.2022. Thus, to substantiate the
applicability of Section 52-A of NDPS Act, in the instant
case, relevant sub-sections of Section
52-A
of
the
Act
are
reproduced hereinbelow:
“52A. Disposal of seized narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances.-- [(1) The Central
Government may, having regard to the hazardous nature, vulnerability to theft, substitution,
constraint of proper storage space or any other relevant consideration, in respect of any
narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled substances or conveyances, by notification
in the Official Gazette, specify such narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled
substances or conveyance or class of narcotic drugs, class of psychotropic substances, class of
controlled substances or conveyances, which shall, as soon as may be after their seizure, be
disposed of by such officer and in such manner as that Government may, from time to time,
determine after following the procedure hereinafter specified.]
(2) Where any [narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled substances or conveyances]
has been seized and forwarded to the officer-in-charge of the nearest police station or to the
officer empowered under section 53, the officer referred to in sub-section (1) shall prepare an
inventory of such [narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled substances or
conveyances] containing such details relating to their description, quality, quantity, mode of
packing, marks, numbers or such other identifying particulars of the [narcotic drugs,
psychotropic substances, controlled substances] or conveyances or the packing in which they
are packed, country of origin and other particulars as the officer referred to in sub-section (1)
may consider relevant to the identity of the [narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances,
controlled substances or conveyances] in any proceedings under this Act and make an
application, to any Magistrate for the purpose of-(a) certifying the correctness of the inventory so prepared; or
(b) taking, in the presence of such magistrate, photographs of [such drugs, substances or
conveyances] and certifying such photographs as true; or
(c) allowing to draw representative samples of such drugs or substances, in the presence of
such magistrate and certifying the correctness of any list of samples so drawn.
(3) Where an application is made under sub-section (2), the Magistrate shall, as soon as may
be, allow the application.
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of 1972) or the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974), every court trying an offence under this Act, shall
treat the inventory, the photographs of [narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled
substances or conveyances] and any list of samples drawn under sub-section (2) and certified
by the Magistrate, as primary evidence in respect of such offence.]”
The purpose of Section 52A of the Act, provides a
mechanism for disposal of seized narcotic substances before the
conclusion of the trial because storing large quantities of such
substances poses risks like theft, deterioration, and hazards to
safety, and in procedure, it allows authorized officers to prepare
an
inventory,
take
photographs,
and
draw
representative
Page 8
samples of the
seized substances in the presence
of a
Magistrate. These certified documents and samples are then
admissible as primary evidence, allowing the bulk substance to
be disposed of safely.
Further, prior to search and seizure, the O/C PS intimated
the matter to his superior i.e. SP, Khowai and SDPO, Khowai,
and the letter dated 08.03.2022 issued by the O/C, Mungiakami
PS to the SP, Khowai District also reveals that immediately the
matter was informed to the superior of the O/C PS. For better
appreciation, the letter dated 08.03.2022 is reproduced below:
“The Superintendent of Police (C/S)
Khowai District Tripura
Reference.- Mungiakami P.S G.D.Entry No-12, date- 08/03/2022.
Subject:- Information on violation of NDPS Act as per regulation U/S-42(2) of NDPS Act,1975
Sir,
With reference to the above, I have the honour to report before your kind honour that,
on 08.03.2022 at 1145 hrs Si Rathindra Debbarma informed to this P.S over mobile phone
that during vehicle checkong at salbagan on NH 8 road found some brouwn colour packets
are contain in two hidden box of one vehicle B/Regd. No RJ51-GA-0392 (Multi Axel Trailer),
Which is suspected to be dry Ganja, the vehicle was coming from teliamura side towards
Ambassa. Said officers also requested to visit the spot for taking legal action. Accordingly the
matter noted in G.D vide Mungiakami P.S G.D. Entry No. 12, dated-08/03/2022. And the
matter also infromed to SP(KHW) and SDPO TLM through mobile phone for permiss ion to
conduct search as per law and also requested to SDPO TLM to come at Spot for taking lawful
action of this information.
This is for favour of your kind information and thus oblige.
Yours faithfully
Sd/Officer-in-charge
Mungiakami Police Station
Khowai District Tripura”
Further, from the extract of GD Entry No. 12, dated
08.03.2022, it is also
revealed that PW-10, SI
Ratindra
Debbarma prior to search and seizure, brought the matter to
the knowledge of his superior i.e. SP, Khowai and SDPO,
Khowai, and the said GD No. 12 is extracted hereunder:
“This time SI Rathindra Debbarma informed to this P.S over mobile phone that during vehicle checking
at Salbagan on NH 8 road found some brown colour packets are contain in two hidden box of one
vehicle B/Regd. No RJ51-GA-0392 (Multi Axel Trailer), which is suspected to be dry Ganja. The vehicle is
coming from Teliamura Side towards Ambassa. Said officers also requested to visit the spot for taking
legal action. Accordingly the matter noted in G.D and also informed to SP(KHW) and SDPO TLM through
mobile phone for permission to conduct search as per law and also requested to SDPO TLM to come at
Spot for taking lawful action of this information. Noted in G.D.
Sd/
Duty Officer
Date 08/03/2022”
Page 9
9.
In the case in hand, it is seen that the seized NDPS
items were recovered from the conscious possession of the
respondents, inventory was drawn on the same date and
correctness of the inventory was done by taking photograph in
presence of learned JM, 1st class, Khowai and thereafter the
same was wrapped under gala and seal of learned JM, 1 st class
and deposited in District NDPS store for safe custody until
disposal order from learned court. Letter dated 09.03.2022
issued by the O/C PS also reveals that he has written letter to
the Incharge of the District NDPS Store requesting him to
arrange for depositing the seized packets of dry ganjas in the
Store for safe custody. Vide letter dated 11.03.2022, the O/C PS
requested the Incharge of District NDPS Store to allow him to
take out the brown coloured packets containing dry ganjas for
drawing samplex and correctness of the inventory before the JM,
1st class against MR no. 250.
Thereafter, upon communication
the same was sent to SFSL and after collection of report through
order of learned JM 1st class, the said contraband items were
disposed of by State Drug Disposal Committee following issuance
of certificate of destruction. Order dated 08.06.2022 passed by
the learned trial Court also shows that there was a prayer for
destruction of the contraband articles made by PW-10 and the
said prayer was allowed by the learned trial court. Therefore, the
foundational facts are established that raises an issue as regards
the non-compliance of Section 52A of the NDPS Act.
Page 10
10.
Section 57 of the NDPS Act mandates that any officer
making an arrest or seizure under the Act must submit a full
report of all the particulars of the arrest or seizure to their
immediate official superior within 48 hours. On 08.03.2022, after
search and seizure, the OC P/s arrested the accused-respondent
and taken into custody. Thereafter, after reaching the PS, a suomoto complaint was lodged. On the next day i.e. on 09.03.2022,
the OC P/S submitted a detailed report as per section 57 of the
NDPS Act before the Superintendent of Police, Khowai, which
clearly reveals that the OC P/S has complied the provision of
Section 57 of the Act. Section 57 of the NDPS Act, reads as
follows:
“57. Report of arrest and seizure.—
Whenever any person makes any arrest or seizure, under this Act, he shall, within forty-eight
hours next after such arrest or seizure, make a full report of all the particulars of such arrest or
seizure to his immediate official superior.”
11.
Regarding non-production of Malkhana register before
the trial court during a trial is not necessarily fatal to the
prosecution's case. On close scrutiny of the record, it appears
that neither the seized articles nor the remaining of the samples
has been produced before the Trial Court. Now the question that
emerges is when there is legal evidence available on record of
the recovery of contraband articles from the possession of the
respondent which, on chemical examination, found to be ganja,
and which has also not been rebutted by the respondent by
cogent evidence, except stating that they had been falsely been
implicated in this case, whether the same is unsustainable in law
on the ground that recovered articles have not been produced in
the Court. In view of this court, regarding safeguard of the seized
Page 11
item, viewing chance of tampering and also whether the
recovered and sealed item reached to the chemical laboratory,
from the materials available on record, this court do not find any
such infirmity. To add, if Malkhana register has not been
produced in the Court, it will not make any difference because
after drawing samples before the JM, 1st Class the same were
kept intact under seal and gala, the same were sent to SFSL after
affixing seal, and SFSL received the samples intact and the same
will reveal from Order dated 11.03.2022 passed by the learned
trial court. In these circumstances, it is apparent that there was
no opportunity to tamper with the impression of seal. That apart,
the report of SFSL dated 25.04.2022 also shows that the yellow
coloured parcel they received was sealed with 08 wax seals with
impression of SDPO, Teliamura. On 08.03.2022 the IO alongwith
PW-1, 2, 3, 6, 7, 8, 10 seized the vehicle and the contraband
articles. Thereafter, PWs 3,6,7,8 and 10 put their signatures on
the seizure list and the same were exhibited during trial on
confirmation by the said PWs. PW-1 stated that after seizure, the
seized items were taken to PS. PW 5 was in-charge of District
NDPS godown in whose presence the packets were produced
before the court and were again deposited to the godown. PW-8
during cross-examination stated that he has sent the samples to
SFSL on 15.03.2022. PW-9 in his deposition stated that on
11.03.2022 the contraband items were withdrawn under MR No.
250 and was again deposited to NDPS godown. PW-10 is the
complainant of the suo-moto complaint. The defense during trial
failed to discard the prosecution evidence except mere denial.
Page 12
The I.O. of the case prepared inventory and for correctness
drawn sample and taken photographs and kept the same in
godown for safe custody, thereafter, sent the sample to SFSL
through SDPO, collected the report, prayed for pre-trial disposal
of the contraband items and as per order of learned court
arranged for disposal of the same and thereby produced the
certificate of destruction. The IO has investigated the case in
detail and submitted his charge-sheet which in all circumstances
establishes the link from seizing to destruction, thus, no link has
been found missing or doubtful in the case of the prosecution.
Further, from the cross examination put to the prosecution
witnesses, it has been found that the defence has not challenged
the authenticity of depositing of the case property with the
Malkhana to none of the witness of the prosecution, so
examined. The prosecution has proved that the seized items
remained safe and un-tampered from the moment of seizure
until they reached the forensic laboratory.
The contraband
articles were seized by the police during vehicle checking.
Following the seizure, the necessary formalities were observed,
and the samples of the contraband were drawn, sealed, and sent
to the SFSL for examination, which confirmed the substance as
ganja, and the same has well been proved by the prosecution
witnesses and documents relied therein. In view of all this, this
Court is of the opinion that non-production of Malkhana register
in the Court is in no way fatal to the prosecution case and the
respondent is not entitled to have any benefit of this lacuna.
Page 13
12.
Section 42 of the NDPS Act, empowers specific central
and state government officers to enter, search, seize, and arrest
individuals involved in drug-related offenses without a warrant.
Section 42(1) of the NDPS Act empowers authorized officers to
conduct
searches,
seizures,
and
arrests
in
buildings,
conveyances, or enclosed spaces without a warrant. Crucially, if
the officer acts on prior information, they must record it in
writing and forward it to a superior official. Section 42(2) of the
NDPS Act, 1985 is a crucial procedural safeguard. It mandates
that whenever an empowered officer records prior information or
grounds for belief about a drug-related offense, they must send a
written copy of this information to their immediate superior
officer within 72 hours. Turning to the facts of the case, the I.O.
was not examined in trial. However, on 08.03.2022, SI Rathindra
Debbarma alongwith staffs left the PS for vehicle checking by
Mungiakami PS GDE No. 11, and while on checking they detained
a vehicle bearing registration no.RJ51-GA-0392 and on spot
checking they found two box hidden under the trailer suspected
to be dry ganja. Then and there he informed O/C, PS and SDPO
over mobile and requested them to come to the spot for taking
lawful action which refers to Mukgiakami PS GDE No. 12, dated
08.03.2022. On reaching, they conducted search into the vehicle
and recovered 292 kgs. of dry ganjas packed in 30 packets and
in presence of witnesses seized the same by preparing seizure
list. The information was received when the officer was not in the
police station, but while he was on patrol duty and when the
information calls for immediate action, without any delay he
Page 14
recorded the information in writing and forthwith informed the
same to the official superior. Thereafter, the search and seizure
was made following the mandates of NDPS Act. Subsequently, a
detailed report was sent to SP, Khowai on 09.03.2022.
13.
PW-2, Goutam Debbarma, is IO of the case, and non-
examination of the IO made the seizure lists and the malkhana
register unproved. IO of the case is most crucial witness to prove
both the seizure list and the malkhana register. His testimony
establishes the "chain of custody," which proves that seized
evidence was safely stored and never tampered with before
reaching court. Since the IO failed to depose before the trial court,
the respondent has been acquitted from the case. A court cannot
automatically acquit an accused under the NDPS Act merely
because the witnesses did not turn up. Courts have the power to
compel the attendance of witnesses using various provisions of the
Criminal Procedure Code. The court must assess the entire
evidence presented and determine if the prosecution has proven
its case beyond a reasonable doubt, even in the absence of certain
witnesses. To ensure appearance of a witness, the court uses legal
mechanisms by rendering summon upon the witness and if the
witness fails to appear after being served with a summons, the
court can issue a bailable or non-bailable warrant to compel
his/her attendance, but, the learned trial court refrains itself from
adopting such procedure rather closed the evidence without
securing evidence of the vital witnesses. It is primarily the
prosecution’s responsibility to file an application for securing the
evidence of its witnesses, but the court possesses overriding
Page 15
powers to summon any witness on its own, if the evidence is
essential for justice, but in this case, the trial court did not take
any step for securing evidence of the vital witness (IO). This Court
is of the view that the trial court had committed error in law in
acquitting the accused-respondent without securing evidence of
rest of the prosecution witnesses.
14.
As per Section 57 of the Act, the OC P/S made a
detailed report of arrest and seizure to his superior on 09.03.2022
i.e. within 48 hours. As per Section 52(A) of the N.D.P.S. Act
before disposal of seized psychotropic substances, an inventory
has been prepared and an application was made to the Magistrate
for the purpose of certifying the correctness of the inventory, in
presence of Magistrate, photographs of such drugs was taken and
thereby certification of correctness was drawn, and thereafter, on
approval of Magistrate, disposal of the seized narcotic items was
done by Disposal committee following completion of chain of
custody. Thus, provision of Section 52(A) and 57 of the Act has
been complied with.
15.
Further, in the present case, PW-10 alongwith PS staffs
while were on vehicle checking duty vide Mungiakami PS GDE No
11 detained a vehicle and on checking at the spot found two boxes
hidden under trailer suspected to be dry ganja and then and there
he detained the driver and co-driver of the vehicle and conveyed
the information to his immediate superior i.e. the SDPO, Teliamura
and O/C, Mungiakami PS, Goutam Debbarma (IO of the case)
requesting them to come to the spot immediately for taking lawful
action and the same refers to Mungiakami PS GDE No. 12, and
Page 16
thereafter the proceeding for search, seizure and arrest continued.
Had they not done so immediately, the opportunity of seizure and
arrest of the respondent-accused would have been lost. On these
facts, this Court finds that no inference could be drawn that there
has been violation of Section 42 of Act."
16.
From the aforesaid decisions, it is revealed that if the
seizure of the material is otherwise proved on record and is not
even doubted or disputed, the Malkhana record need not be placed
before the court. From the evidence of PW-5 and PW-9 it is
revealed that the seized contraband articles were deposited,
withdrawn and re-deposited following proper safeguard. The fact
that the samples taken from and out of contraband material was
kept intact and was done in presence of the Magistrate, and when
the samples were submitted for forensic examination the seals
were intact, thus, the essential ingredients constituting an offence
are made out.
17.
However, another notable fact that comes to our notice
is that after recovery and seizure of the alleged contraband items,
all
those items
were produced
before the learned Judicial
Magistrate, 1st Class, Khowai, after preparation of an inventory by
the OC, Mungiakami PS and the inventory, photographs and list of
samples of seized items were also certified by the learned Judicial
Magistrate, 1st Class, Khowai. But, those documents are lying in
the record and the prosecution did not take any steps during the
trial to prove those documents into evidence though as per Section
52-A, those documents are to be treated as primary evidence.
Even the Investigating Officer did not cite the said Judicial
Page 17
Magistrate, 1st Class, Khowai, as a witness of the case. In such a
serious nature of offences, it is quite unfortunate that proper steps
were not taken from the side of the Investigating Officer and the
prosecution to prove all these documents into evidence. We,
therefore, feel that the prosecution should get an opportunity to
prove such documents into evidence after complying with the due
procedure of law for due administration of justice. Even the
learned Special Judge also missed that aspect though he had the
ample authority, as discussed earlier, to summon the required
witness to prove those documents.
18.
In fine, the impugned judgment dated 19.05.2025
passed by the learned Special Judge Court No.2, Khowai, Tripura,
in case No. Special (NDPS) 64 of 2022, is hereby set-aside.
Accordingly, the matter is remanded back to the learned Special
Judge(NDPS), Khowai, Tripura, with a direction to conduct a fresh
trial by calling upon rest of the prosecution witnesses. However, it
is made clear that reasonable opportunity shall be afforded to the
prosecution witnesses to depose before the court and take on
record the un-exhibited documents. The prosecution will also be at
liberty to file necessary application for summoning the concerned
witnesses to prove said inventory, photographs and list of samples
as certified by Judicial Magistrate and of course, defense will have
the liberty to adduce rebuttal evidence, if any, on that point. It is
further made clear that after closure of evidences of all the
prosecution witnesses, learned Court below shall deliver its
judgment
afresh.
expeditiously.
The
entire
exercise
shall
be
completed
Page 18
The appeal stands allowed to the extent as indicated
above, and the matter is remanded back to the Trial Court by
setting aside the impugned judgment. Pending application(s), if
any, also stands disposed.
19.
The accused-respondent is directed to surrender before
the learned trial Court on or before 15.06.2026. Upon his
surrender,
the
learned
trial
Court
may
consider
the
bail
application, on such terms and conditions as the accused/ convict
was released after the trial court judgment, the balance of
convenience is in favour of the accused/convict.
S.DATTA PURKAYASTHA,J
SAIKAT KAR
DR.T. AMARNATH GOUD,J
SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2026.05.20
18:13:27 -04'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review