Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
A.No.264 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 12-06-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE DR.JUSTICE A.D.MARIA CLETE
A No. 264 of 2026
in
C.S. No. 95 of 2025
The Madras Mahajana Saba
Represented by its General Secretary,
Mr.P.Chandrasekar, New NO.70, Old NO.833, 2nd
Floor, Mount Road, Chennai - 600 002.
..Applicant(s)
Vs
Mrs. T.T.P. Kadeeja
W/o.Late P.M. Abdul Nazar, H.Nu.Tech Heights
Apartments, No.11/6, Thambusamy Road, Kilpauk,
Chennai - 600 010.
..Respondent(s)
To Reject the Plaint in C.S.No.95 of 2025 under Order - VII Rule - 11
with exemplary cost.
For Applicant(s):
M/s. M.Sriram
Ramesh Venkatachalapathy
T.Sriram
For Respondent(s):
Mr.S.Thankasivan for R1.
ORDER
This application has been filed by the applicant/defendant under Order VII Rule
11(a) and (d) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, to reject the plaint in
1/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.No.264 of 2026
C.S.No.95 of 2025 on the ground that the plaint does not disclose any cause of
action and that the suit is barred by law.
2.
The respondent/plaintiff has filed the suit seeking, inter alia, a declaration
that she is entitled to renewal of the tenancy in respect of the suit schedule property
for a further period of 15 years from 01.12.2024, a mandatory injunction directing
the defendant to execute a deed of tenancy renewing the lease deed dated
11.12.1997, and a permanent injunction restraining the defendant from disturbing
her peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule property.
3.
According to the applicant/defendant, the original lease deed dated
11.12.1997 was for a fixed period. It is the case of the applicant that the lease
expired by efflux of time on 30.11.2024 and that the defendant had no intention to
extend the lease. The applicant has further stated that letters/notices were issued
prior to the expiry of the lease calling upon the plaintiff/respondent to deliver
vacant possession, and that thereafter the applicant initiated proceedings in
R.L.T.O.P.No.79 of 2025 before the Rent Court under the Tamil Nadu Regulation
of Rights and Responsibilities of Landlords and Tenants Act, 2017.
2/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.No.264 of 2026
4.
The principal contention of the applicant is that Clause 19 of the lease deed
does not create an automatic or unilateral right of renewal in favour of the lessee.
According to the applicant, the clause only contemplates renewal at the option of
both parties and on fresh terms and conditions. Therefore, in the absence of
consensus between both parties, the respondent/plaintiff cannot compel the
applicant/defendant to execute a fresh lease deed for another period of 15 years.
5.
It is further submitted by the applicant that the suit is framed only to
circumvent the statutory eviction proceedings initiated before the Rent Court. It is
also contended that after expiry of the lease, the plaintiff cannot seek a decree of
permanent injunction against the landlord so as to restrain the landlord from
asserting its lawful rights. The applicant has also raised objections regarding
valuation, court fee and the absence of a real cause of action.
6.
Per contra, the respondent/plaintiff has filed a counter affidavit resisting this
application. The respondent contends that the application under Order VII Rule 11
CPC is not maintainable and that, for deciding such an application, the Court must
look only into the averments contained in the plaint. According to the respondent,
3/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.No.264 of 2026
the defendant’s defence, written statement and disputed factual contentions cannot
be looked into at this stage.
7.
The respondent/plaintiff further contends that the suit has been filed to
enforce her contractual right under the registered lease deed dated 11.12.1997. It is
submitted that the building was constructed at the cost of the plaintiff’s husband,
that the lease was thereafter transferred in favour of the plaintiff under deed of
transfer of tenancy dated 24.06.2005, and that Clause 19 of the lease deed confers a
right of renewal for a further period of 15 years.
8.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondent/plaintiff relied upon the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vinod Infra Developers Ltd. v.
Mahaveer Lunia and Others, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1208, and submitted that
while considering an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the Court must
confine itself to the averments made in the plaint and should not enter into disputed
questions of fact or the defence of the defendant. It was further submitted that if
the plaint discloses triable issues, the plaint cannot be rejected at the threshold.
4/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.No.264 of 2026
9.
Placing reliance on the said judgment, learned counsel for the
respondent/plaintiff further contended that where the plaint discloses more than
one cause of action and even one cause of action survives, the plaint cannot be
rejected in its entirety. Reliance was also placed upon the principle noticed in
Central Bank of India v. Prabha Jain, as referred to in the said judgment, to
contend that the doctrine of severance cannot be applied to reject the entire plaint
merely because one of the reliefs is alleged to be untenable.
10.
Having heard the learned counsel appearing on either side, this Court has
also perused the plaint, the documents relied upon, the affidavit filed in support of
the present application, the counter affidavit and the written arguments.
11.
The scope of Order VII Rule 11 CPC is well settled. The Court has to
consider the averments in the plaint and the documents relied upon by the plaintiff.
At the same time, the plaint has to be read meaningfully and not merely formally.
If on such meaningful reading the plaint does not disclose a real cause of action, or
if the cause of action pleaded is illusory and created by clever drafting, the Court is
empowered to reject the plaint at the threshold.
5/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.No.264 of 2026
12.
In the present case, the foundation of the suit is Clause 19 of the lease deed
dated 11.12.1997. The said clause, as extracted in the pleadings and records, reads
to the effect that:
“The tenancy shall be renewed at the option of both the parties for a further period
of 15 years, on fresh terms and conditions that may be stipulated thereon.”
13.
A plain and meaningful reading of the said clause shows that renewal is not
automatic. The clause does not confer a unilateral right on the lessee to demand
renewal as a matter of course. The renewal contemplated under the said clause is
dependent upon the option of both parties and upon fresh terms and conditions
being stipulated.
14.
The plaint itself proceeds on the footing that the plaintiff sought renewal and
that the defendant did not execute the renewal deed. Therefore, even according to
the plaint, there was no concluded agreement between both parties for renewal of
the lease after 30.11.2024. Once the lease has expired and the landlord has not
agreed for renewal, the plaintiff cannot seek a decree compelling the landlord to
execute a fresh lease deed for a further period of 15 years.
6/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.No.264 of 2026
15.
The prayer for mandatory injunction directing the defendant to execute a
deed of tenancy is, in substance, a prayer to compel the creation of a fresh tenancy.
Such a relief cannot be granted in the absence of an enforceable concluded
contract. The plaint does not disclose any legally enforceable right in favour of the
plaintiff to compel the defendant to enter into a fresh lease arrangement.
16.
The judgment relied upon by the respondent/plaintiff in Vinod Infra
Developers Ltd. v. Mahaveer Lunia and Others, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1208,
undoubtedly reiterates the settled principle that at the stage of Order VII Rule 11
CPC, the Court must primarily examine the plaint and the documents relied upon
therein, and that disputed questions of fact are ordinarily not to be adjudicated at
that stage. However, the said judgment does not assist the respondent/plaintiff in
the facts of the present case.
17.
In the present suit, this Court is not rejecting the plaint on the basis of the
defence raised by the defendant or on the basis of disputed questions of fact. Even
on a reading of the plaint and the lease clause relied upon by the plaintiff, the right
claimed by the plaintiff is not an automatic or unilateral right of renewal. Clause 19
itself makes renewal dependent upon the option of both parties and upon fresh
7/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.No.264 of 2026
terms. Therefore, the plaint does not disclose an enforceable legal right to compel
the defendant/landlord to execute a fresh lease deed for a further period of 15
years.
18.
The contention based on Central Bank of India v. Prabha Jain, as referred
to in Vinod Infra Developers Ltd., that if one cause of action survives the plaint
cannot be rejected in its entirety, also does not advance the case of the
respondent/plaintiff. In the present case, all the reliefs claimed in the plaint are
founded upon the same alleged right of renewal under Clause 19. The relief of
declaration, the relief of mandatory injunction and the relief of permanent
injunction are not independent or severable causes of action. They are all
consequential upon the alleged right of renewal. Once the alleged right of renewal
is found to be unenforceable on the face of the plaint and the document relied
upon, no independent surviving cause of action remains.
19.
The plaintiff has also sought permanent injunction restraining the defendant
from disturbing her possession and enjoyment of the suit property. The said prayer
is consequential to the main relief of renewal. A tenant whose lease has admittedly
expired cannot seek a perpetual injunction against the landlord in such a manner as
8/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.No.264 of 2026
to prevent the landlord from asserting its rights in accordance with law. The
landlord has already initiated statutory proceedings before the Rent Court in
R.L.T.O.P.No.79 of 2025. The plaintiff cannot, by filing the present suit, indirectly
obstruct or nullify the statutory proceedings initiated under the special enactment.
20.
The respondent/plaintiff has contended that the construction was put up at the
cost of her husband and that substantial expenditure was incurred for developing
and maintaining the property. These averments may form part of the background of
the transaction. However, they do not create a present enforceable right to compel
renewal of lease contrary to the express language of Clause 19. At the highest,
these facts may explain why the plaintiff desired renewal. They do not create a
legal right to obtain a mandatory decree for renewal.
21.
The contention that the defendant had participated in the suit proceedings and
that interim orders had earlier been passed does not bar consideration of an
application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC. The power under Order VII Rule 11
CPC can be exercised at any stage of the proceedings, provided the conditions
under the said provision are satisfied.
9/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.No.264 of 2026
22.
The earlier interim orders passed in the interlocutory applications cannot be
treated as finally deciding the maintainability of the suit. An order of interim
protection is granted on a prima facie consideration and does not preclude the
Court from considering whether the plaint discloses a cause of action or whether
the suit is barred by law.
23.
It is also relevant to note that the applicant/defendant has already initiated
proceedings under the Tamil Nadu Regulation of Rights and Responsibilities of
Landlords and Tenants Act, 2017. The dispute relating to occupation after expiry
of tenancy, continuation in possession and eviction is within the domain of the
statutory forum constituted under the said Act. The present suit, as framed, would
have the effect of interfering with the adjudication of the landlord-tenant dispute
before the Rent Court. However, it is also submitted that the eviction was ordered
on 18.04.2026 and the applicant is taking steps to file execution petition.
24.
This Court is therefore of the view that the plaint is liable to be rejected
under Order VII Rule 11(a) CPC for want of real cause of action. It is also noticed
that the plaint is valued and court fee paid under section 25(d) and 27(c) of Tamil
10/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.No.264 of 2026
Nadu court fee and suits valuation Act 1955 instead of section42 (c) of Tamil Nadu
court fee and suits valuation Act 1955.
25.
On a meaningful reading of the plaint and the lease clause relied upon by the
plaintiff, this Court finds that the plaint does not disclose a real cause of action for
the reliefs sought. The plaintiff seeks to convert a clause requiring the option of
both parties into a unilateral right of compulsory renewal. Such a reading is
contrary to the language of Clause 19.
26.
In the result this application is allowed. The plaint in C.S.No.95 of 2025 is
rejected under Order VII Rule 11(a) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. No
costs. Consequently, connected applications, if any, are closed.
12-06-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
AY
11/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.No.264 of 2026
DR.A.D.MARIA CLETE, J.
AY
A No. 264 of 2026
in
C.S. No. 95 of 2025
12-06-2026
12/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review