Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
TOS No. 12 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on : 24-09-2026
Pronounced on : 30.10.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MRS.JUSTICE K. GOVINDARAJAN THILAKAVADI
TOS No. 12 of 2018
CNR:{HCMA014002912014}
and
Tr.CS NO. 563 of 2019
T.O.S.No.12 of 2018
Mrs.V.Suryakala
W/o.Dr.D.Vijayakumar
No.107, Big Maniyakara Street,
Chingleput-603 001.
..Petitioner
Vs
Mrs.K.Srividhya
W/o.Late Vivek Vijayakumar
Door No.49-717, Green Tulsi Apartments,
Visakhapatnam 530 016
Andhra Pradesh.
..Caveator
Tr.CS No. 563 of 2019
CNR:{HCMA011621462019}
Srividhya @ Kurella Srividhya
..Plaintiff
Vs
Suryakala
..Defendant
TOS No. 12 of 2018
The Testamentary Original Suit is filed under Sections 232, 255 & 276 of the
Indian Succession Act XXXIX of 1925 seeking the grant of Letters of
__________
Page1 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
Administration with the WILL in favour of the petitioner, the mother of the said
deceased Vivek Vijayakumar, having effect throughout the state of Tamilnadu
and limited to the properties mentioned in the Affidavit of Assets.
Tr. CS No. 563 of 2019
Plaint filed under Order VII Rule 1 of Civil Procedure Code praying to (i) pass
a Decree and Judgment declaring the settlement deed bearing document
No.1967/2013 dated 04/09/2013 executed in favour of the defendant with
respect to the suit property as null and void abinitio illegal improper and not
maintainable in law not binding upon the plaintiff, (ii) pass a decree and
judgment of partition by dividing the suit property into two equal share and by
allotting one such share in the suit property to the plaintiff by metes and bounds
and also appoint an Advocate Commissioner to divide the suit property, (iii)
pass permanent injunction restraining the defendant in any way encumbering or
alienating the suit property, (iv) direct the defendant to pay the cost of the suit to
the plaintiff and, (V) pass such other and further orders in the circumstances of
the case so as to render justice.
For Petitioner(s):
Mr. K.V. Babu
for Petitioner/Plaintiff in TOS No. 12/2018
Mr. K.V. Babu
for Mr. N. Ravi
for Sole Defendant in CS No. 563/2019
For Respondent(s):
Mr. M.Aravind Subramanyam,
Senior Advocate
for Ms. B. Jisha
Ms. A. Gayathri
Ms. U.S. Mrudubhashini
for Plaintiff in CS No. 563/2019
and for Sole Defendant in TOS No. 12/2018
__________
Page2 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
Common Judgement
This Testamentary Original Suit in TOS No.12 of 2018 arises out of O.P.
No.386 of 2017, filed by the plaintiff seeking grant of Letters of Administration
with the Will annexed in respect of the alleged last Will and testament of her
deceased son late Mr. Vivek Vijayakumar, dated 09.03.2014.
2. The connected Tr.C.S. No.563 of 2019 was originally instituted before
the learned Principal District Court, Chengalpattu, as O.S. No.33 of 2016 and
thereafter transferred to this Court. The plaintiff therein is the wife of the
deceased Vivek Vijayakumar, and defendant in TOS No. 12 of 2018. She seeks,
inter alia, a declaration that the settlement deed dated 04.09.2013 is null and
void and not binding upon her, and partition of the properties left behind by her
deceased husband.
3. The Case of the Plaintiff in T.O.S. No. 12 of 2018, in brief:
3.1. The plaintiff is the mother of Mr. V. Vivek Vijayakumar, who died
on 23.03.2014 at Apollo Speciality Hospital, Chennai. During his lifetime, he
ordinarily resided at No.107A, Big Maniyakara Street, Chengalpattu,
Kancheepuram District, and owned properties within the State of Tamil Nadu.
__________
Page3 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
3.2. The said Vivek Vijayakumar executed a Will dated 09.03.2014 at
Apollo Speciality Hospital, Chennai, in the presence of witnesses in favour of
the plaintiff. It is further stated that the testator spoke about the execution of the
Will in a videographed recording and that a forensic audio authentication report
was also obtained in connection with the same.
3.3. According to the plaintiff, the defendant, who is the wife of the
testator, left the matrimonial home after the testator underwent surgery and did
not return to take care of him. It is further alleged that she did not even attend
the funeral rites of her husband.
3.4. After the death of the testator on 23.03.2014, the defendant instituted
O.S. No. 33 of 2016 on the file of the Principal District Court, Chengalpattu,
seeking the reliefs of declaration and partition. Thereafter, the plaintiff was
constrained to initiate the present proceedings, originally filed as O.P. No. 386
of 2017 and subsequently converted into T.O.S. No. 12 of 2018 by order of this
Court dated 27.03.2018.
3.5. Since no executor was appointed under the Will, the plaintiff, being
the legatee thereunder, filed the petition seeking Letters of Administration with
__________
Page4 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
the Will annexed. In the above circumstances, the plaintiff prays that Letters of
Administration with the Will annexed be granted in her favour.
4. The defendant disputes the genuineness of the Will, contending that the
particulars relating to the date, place and time of its alleged execution, as well as
the witnesses thereto, appear to be concocted and fabricated. She further
contends that the very existence of the original Will is highly doubtful and
improbable. The exclusion of the defendant and the testator’s father, brother and
sister from the Will is also stated to give rise to serious suspicion regarding its
genuineness.
4.1. According to the defendant, she was attending to her husband at the
hospital before his death, whereas none of his other family members, including
the plaintiff, visited him. She further contends that, having been driven out of
the matrimonial home when her husband was seriously ill, she was compelled to
reside with her parents at Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh.
4.2. The defendant claims that, as the legally wedded wife of the testator,
she is entitled to a half share in the movable and immovable properties left
behind by him. Accordingly, she instituted a suit for declaration and partition.
She points out that there was no reference to the alleged Will dated 09.03.2014
__________
Page5 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
in the written statement filed in the partition suit and contends that the present
Testamentary Original Suit is an afterthought, instituted with the sole intention
of depriving her of her legitimate share in the estate.
4.3. The defendant further submits that the original petition, which was
subsequently converted into T.O.S. No. 12 of 2018, was filed only on
26.04.2017, more than three years after the alleged execution of the Will.
According to her, the existence of the Will was disclosed to her only after the
institution of the partition suit. She, therefore, disputes the genuineness, validity
and due execution of the Will.
4.4. It is further contended that the testator was capable of signing until
his death and that there was no necessity for him to affix his left thumb
impression, particularly when his right hand was not affected by any illness.
The defendant also points out that the left thumb impression appearing in the
settlement deed is horizontal, whereas the impression found in the disputed Will
is vertical, thereby raising further suspicion regarding its genuineness.
4.5. The defendant also highlights an apparent discrepancy in the
description of the place of execution, stating that the opening portion of the Will
__________
Page6 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
indicates that it was executed at Chengalpattu on 09.03.2014, whereas the
petition states that it was executed at Apollo Speciality Hospital, Chennai, in the
presence of witnesses. She further contends that no satisfactory explanation has
been offered for the delay of approximately three years in initiating proceedings
for the grant of Letters of Administration.
4.6. In the above circumstances, the defendant seriously disputes the
execution and genuineness of the Will and prays for the dismissal of the
Testamentary Original Suit.
5. On a consideration of the pleadings, this Court on 22.10.2021 framed
the following issues:
1. Whether the Will dated 09.03.2014, said to have been
executed by Vivek Vijayakumar, is true and valid;
2. Whether the testator was in sound disposing state of mind
at the time of execution of the Will;
3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to grant of letters of
administration with the Will annexed.
6. Since TOS No.12 of 2018 and Tr.C.S. No.563 of 2019 were tried
jointly and common evidence was recorded in Tr.C.S.No.563 of 2019, the
__________
Page7 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
evidence of the witnesses has been considered in the light of the pleadings and
evidence in both proceedings.
7. The plaintiff in Tr.C.S. No.563 of 2019 has examined herself as P.W.1
and marked P1 to P18. Her mother was examined as P.W.2. The defendant in
Tr.C.S. No.563 of 2019 has examined herself as D.W.1. D.W.2, Dr. K.K. Ram
Deepak, one of the attesting witnesses was examined in the connected
testamentary proceedings. Mrs. Yuvanthi was examined as D.W.3 and Dr. V.
Preetham, was examined as D.W.4. Exs. D6 to D9 were marked through D.W.1
and Exs. D13 and D14 were marked through D.W.3 and D.W.4 respectively.
Exs. D1 to D5 and D10 to D12 were marked in the course of cross examination.
8. Mr. K.V. Babu, learned counsel appearing for the plaintiff in TOS No.
12 of 2018 contends that the plaintiff is the mother of the late Vivek
Vijayakumar, who executed a Will dated 09.03.2014 in the presence of two
attesting witnesses, namely, Dr. R.Sabarathinam and Mr. K.K. Ram Deepak,
and in the presence of Advocate T.Chandran. The defendant is her daughter-inlaw / wife of late Vivek Vijayakumar and that their marriage was solemnised on
11.03.2012 at Chennai. It is stated that, at the relevant point of time, the
deceased was undergoing treatment at Apollo Speciality Hospital, Chennai, for
serious illness. It is further submitted that, though the Will contains a recital that
it was executed at Chengalpattu, the same was actually executed at Apollo
__________
Page8 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
Speciality Hospital, Chennai, and the recital regarding the place of execution
was only a typographical mistake.
8.1. He would further submit that, the deceased was unable to affix his
signature owing to weakness in his right hand and therefore, affixed his left
thumb impression in the presence of the attesting witnesses. He had also relied
upon the attestation of the document by an Advocate and Notary Public and also
upon an alleged audio recording of the deceased relating to the execution of the
Will and a forensic report concerning the said recording.
8.2. He further contends that the defendant, who is the wife of the
deceased, had left the matrimonial home and was not taking care of the
deceased during his illness and that the deceased, therefore, consciously chose
to bequeath his properties in favour of his mother. He would further contend
that, after the death of Vivek Vijayakumar on 23.03.2014, the plaintiff dealt
with the properties covered by the Will and obtained mutation of relevant
records.
According to the learned counsel, only after the defendant/wife
instituted O.S. No.33 of 2016, claiming a share in the estate of the deceased, did
the necessity arise to obtain Letters of Administration with the Will annexed.
He would further contend that the Court must place itself in the armchair of the
testator while examining the genuineness of the Will and the circumstances
surrounding its execution. He would submit that an oversight, typographical
__________
Page9 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
error or misunderstanding, if satisfactorily explained, cannot, by itself, form the
basis for an adverse judicial finding. He would also submit that there is no
period prescribed for filing petition for probate or Letters of Administration. In
support of his contention, he has relied upon the following decisions.
1. MANU/PR/0005/1913 before the Privy Council dated 10.12.2013
in Vencata Narayanasamy Appa Rao and Ors. vs. Parthasarathy
Appa Rao and others.
2. MANU/SC/0115/1958
(Civil Appeal No. 18/1995, decided on
13.11.1958) in the case of S. Venkatachala Iyengal vs. D.N.
Thimmajamma and others.
3. MANU/SC/1035/2023 (Civil Appeal No.3351/2014, decided on
21.09.2023) in the case of Meena Pradan and others vs. Kamala
Pradan and others.
4. MANU/SC/8061/2007 (Civil Appeal No.4882/2007, decided on
12.10.2007)
in the case of Savithri and others vs. Karthiyayini
Amma and others.
5. 2021 (SCC) Online TR1162 – In the Court of Tripura at
Agarthala (Division Bench) in the case of Soma Debbarama vs.
State of Tripura, decided on 23.03.2021.
6. S. Vatsala vs. K.S. Mohan and Others reported in 2016 (1) CTC
__________
Page10 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
9. On the other hand, Mr. M.Aravind Subramanyam, learned Senior Advocate
appearing for the defendant/wife in TOS No. 12 of 2018 would submit that, the
defendant is the widow of the deceased and that, there are several suspicious
circumstances surrounding the alleged Will. The learned counsel points out that
the document itself recites Chengalpattu as the place of execution, whereas, the
plaintiff now asserts that it was executed at Apollo Speciality Hospital,
Chennai.
10. The learned counsel further contends that, the deceased was suffering
from serious illness and was under treatment at the relevant time and that the
Will excludes not merely the defendant / wife but also the father, brother and
sister of the deceased, thereby, conferring the entire benefit upon the plaintiff,
who is the mother of the deceased. He has also pointed out the alleged
contradiction between the recital in the Will that the deceased was unable to
sign owing to weakness in his right hand and the recital in another portion of the
Will that he had “signed and executed” the document. The learned counsel
disputes the necessity for obtaining a left thumb impression and contends that
the deceased was capable of signing.
Reliance is also placed upon the
difference allegedly noticed between the thumb impression found in the earlier
settlement deed and that found in the alleged Will.
__________
Page11 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
10.1. Another important circumstance relied upon by the defendant is that
she had instituted O.S. No.33 of 2016 seeking partition and challenging the
settlement deed dated 04.09.2013, whereas the plaintiff in her written statement
and additional written statement in the said suit, did not disclose the existence of
the alleged Will dated 09.03.2014. It is therefore contended that the Will
surfaced only subsequently, after the defendant asserted her claim to a share in
the estate, and that the Will is an afterthought intended to defeat the defendant’s
claim.
11. Points for consideration in TOS No. 12 of 2018:
Since the relief in the testamentary proceedings depends upon the validity
of the alleged Will, issues 1 to 3 have to be considered together.
12. It is settled law that the propounder of a Will has to establish that the
Will was duly executed by the testator and attested in accordance with Section
63 of the Indian Succession Act. Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act requires
the execution of such a document to be proved by examining at least one
attesting witness, where such witness is available.
12.1. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Lakshmi vs. Gopi & others in SLP
No.9510 of 2023 (Civil Appeal No.9006 of 2026), has held as follows:
__________
Page12 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
“11. In this context let us deal, albeit briefly, with what a Court is
required to do when it is confronted with the question of
genuineness of the Will. It has to be proved like any other
document except for additional requirements under ISA. To
restate, the Civil Court had refused to accept the Will and the
High Court as the First Appellate Court was to decide on both
questions of fact and law. The requirements below are in the light
of Section 67, 68 of the Evidence Act 1872 and Section(s) 59 and
63 of ISA.
(1) Since the proving of the Will is necessarily an event after the
death of the testator there is a certain level of sanctity that is
attached to the same;
(2) If the will has been signed by the testator, the same has to be
established according to Section 67 IEA with recourse to Section
45 and 47 thereof, if required;
(3) The will in order for it to be proved to be the last will of
testator, has to be attested in accordance with IEA Section 63 ISA
either by signing/affixing his mark or signed by a third party upon
his direction and in his presence in which situation not one but
two attesting witnesses would be required to be examined;
(4) The testator must be of sound mind within the meaning of
Section 59 of ISA and it has to be proved accordingly;
__________
Page13 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
(5) At least one attesting witness has to be examined in court to
prove its execution;
(6) Three questions need to be asked by the Court and the answer
so produced should be to the satisfaction of a prudent mind.
Mathematical precision is not to be looked for. They are: (a) has
the testator signed the Will?; (b) Did he/she understand the
nature?; and (c) the effect of the dispositions in the Will; and (d)
Did he /she put his/her signature on the Will knowing what it
contained?
12.2. The Hon’ble Supreme Court had also made reference to the
judgments in
(i) H. Venkatachala Iyengal v. B.N. Thimmajamma reported in 1958
SCC OnLine SC 31
(ii) Meena Pradhan v. Kamla Pradhan reported in (2023) 9 SCC 734
(iii) Parvathi Nairthi (Dead) and Ors v. Laxmi Nairthy (dead)
through Lrs and ors. Reported in 2026 INSC 521
12.3. In H. Venkatachala Iyengar vs. B.N. Thimmajamma (cited supra)
the Hon’ble Supreme Court explained that the propounder has to establish that
the Will was signed by the testator; that the testator was in a sound and
disposing state of mind; that he understood the nature and effect of the
__________
Page14 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
dispositions; and that he executed the document of his own free will. Where
suspicious circumstances surrounded the Will, the propounder has the additional
burden of removing such suspicion by satisfactory evidence.
12.4. Therefore, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has repeatedly held that,
where suspicious circumstances exist, the burden upon the propounder becomes
heavier. Suspicious circumstances may include the physical or mental condition
of the testator, the participation of persons interested in the execution of the
Will, an unnatural or improbable disposition, exclusion of a natural heir,
discrepancies regarding the execution and other circumstances which give rise
to legitimate doubt regarding the genuineness of the testamentary disposition.
12.5. At the same time, the mere presence of a suspicious circumstance
does not automatically render a Will invalid. The question is whether the
propounder has satisfactorily explained the circumstances so as to remove the
legitimate doubt in the mind of the Court.
12.6. In the present case, the plaintiff has examined one of the attesting
witnesses (D.W.2) who has spoken about the execution of the Will. The
evidence of the attesting witness, therefore, cannot be brushed aside merely on
the ground that the other attesting witness had not been examined. To that
extent, the statutory requirement regarding proof of execution by an attesting
__________
Page15 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
witness has been substantially addressed. However, the Court is required to
consider whether the evidence of the attesting witness is sufficient to dispel the
other circumstances surrounding the execution. The fact that the testator affixed
his thumb impression instead of signing the document is not, by itself,
suspicious. The Will itself contains an explanation that the right hand of the
testator has become weak. The thumb impression appearing on the document
may also be that of the testator. Likewise, the mere fact that the Will was
executed while the testator was undergoing medical treatment cannot, by itself,
invalidate the Will.
12.7. The difficulty arises from the cumulative effect of the surrounding
circumstances, which are enumerated as follows:
1. The medical condition of the testator;
2. The discrepancy regarding the place of execution;
3. Effect of the Truth Lab report.
It is not in dispute that the testator was suffering from a serious illness and had
undergone treatment for cancer. The evidence placed before the Court indicates
that the testator had undergone surgery, Chemotherapy and Radiotherapy and
that his health had considerably deteriorated by the time of the alleged
execution of the Will. However, this Court is not inclined to presume that a
person suffering from cancer is necessarily incapable of making a Will.
Undoubtedly, a person suffering from a serious physical ailment may very well
__________
Page16 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
possess full testamentary capacity.
12.8. Nevertheless, where the Will is alleged to have been executed
shortly before the death, while the testator was in a hospital and in a seriously
debilitated condition, the Court must examine with care whether the propounder
has satisfactorily established that the testator understood the nature and
consequences of the testamentary disposition. The evidence of the attesting
witness establishes his presence and his perception of the execution. But the
evidence must be examined along with the other surrounding circumstances and
not in isolation.
12.9. A significant circumstance is the discrepancy concerning the place
of execution. Further, the learned counsel for the plaintiff has submitted that the
Will was executed at Apollo Speciality Hospital, Chennai and that under
Section 57(a) of the Indian Succession Act, the relevant provisions concerning
testamentary succession apply to Wills executed by a Hindu within the ordinary
original civil jurisdiction of the High Court of Madras. Section 213 requires the
grant of probate or Letters of Administration in cases falling within the classes
specified in Section 57. The Madras High Court has consistently recognised the
significance of Section 57 and 213 in testamentary proceedings. Therefore, the
plaintiff's case that the Will was executed at Chennai provides a legitimate basis
for invoking the testamentary jurisdiction of this Court. Further, he would
__________
Page17 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
submit that the reference to Chengalpattu in the Will, having been satisfactorily
explained in the circumstances of the present case does not deprive this Court of
jurisdiction.
12.10. Admittedly, the Will contains a recital indicating Chengalpattu as
the place of execution. The plaintiff, however, specifically contends that the
Will was executed at Apollo Speciality Hospital, Chennai. This is not merely a
trivial discrepancy because the very place at which the testamentary document
was allegedly executed becomes relevant in determining the circumstances in
which the testator executed the document. The plaintiff contends that, the video
recording establishes that the execution took place in the hospital. Even
assuming that the video recording is genuine and that the recording was made in
the hospital, the authenticity of the video does not, by itself, establish the
validity of the testamentary disposition. Ex.D9 is the Truth Lab report. The
report, as relied upon the plaintiff, opines that the audio and video recording did
not contain signs of morphing and that the recording was authentic. The Will
itself contains a recital showing Chengalpattu as the place of execution. The
plaintiff, however, specifically pleads that the Will was actually executed at
Apollo Speciality Hospital, Chennai and that the recital of Chengalpattu was
only a typographical mistake. This circumstance undoubtedly requires
examination because the place of execution is specifically stated in the
document. The document itself and the case now put forward by the plaintiff are
__________
Page18 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
materially different regarding the place where the will was executed. The
explanation that the recital was a mere typographical mistake cannot be
accepted merely because it has been asserted.
12.11. The place of execution is not an insignificant clerical detail in the
present case. It assumes considerable importance because the jurisdiction of this
Court is also sought to be founded upon the assertion that the Will was executed
within the original jurisdiction of this Court. If the Will itself records
Chengalpattu as the place of execution, and the plaintiff seeks to overcome that
recital by asserting that the Will was actually executed at Apollo Hospital, the
burden lies heavily upon the plaintiff to establish the latter fact by clear and
convincing evidence.
12.12. The plaintiff has not produced sufficiently cogent evidence
explaining how such a material recital came to be incorrectly incorporated in the
Will. This Court therefore finds that the discrepancy regarding the place of
execution remains an unexplained suspicious circumstance.
12.13. The next circumstance concerns the manner in which the Will was
executed. It is not in dispute that the Will bears the left thumb impression of the
deceased. The defendant has specifically contended that the testator was capable
of signing and that there was no satisfactory explanation as to why he did not
__________
Page19 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
sign the Will. The plaintiff's case is that the hand of the testator had become
weak and that he was unable to sign and therefore affixed his thumb impression.
There is no satisfactory contemporaneous medical evidence specifically
establishing that on 09.03.2014, the testator was physically incapable of signing
the document. This Court is not holding that affixing a thumb impression is
legally impermissible. It is undoubtedly permissible. The question here is, why,
in the peculiar circumstances of this case, did the testator adopt that mode of
execution. When the Will is already surrounded by other circumstances
requiring explanation, the unexplained departure from the normal mode of
signature assumes significance. The defendant has also pointed out the
difference in the appearance of the thumb impression between the earlier
settlement deed and the Will. Though this circumstance alone may not establish
forgery, it adds to the requirement for satisfactory proof. The plaintiff has failed
to remove the doubt surrounding this circumstance.
12.14. Further, the medical records establish that the testator was
suffering from a serious and ultimately fatal illness. He has been admitted to
Apollo Hospital, Chennai on 21.02.2014 and died on 23.03.2014. The Will is
alleged to have been executed on 09.03.2014, when he was undergoing
treatment. It is true that illness by itself does not render a person incapable of
making a Will. However, in the present case, the testator was admittedly
suffering from a grave medical condition shortly before his death. Therefore,
__________
Page20 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
the propounder was required to establish by cogent evidence that,
notwithstanding his condition, the testator was fully conscious of the nature and
effect of the disposition and voluntarily executed the Will. The evidence relied
upon by the plaintiff does not satisfactorily remove all the doubts created by the
surrounding circumstances.
12.15. Further, the Will excludes the defendant who is the wife of the
deceased. The father, brother and sister of the testator are also stated to have
been excluded. Exclusion of natural heirs is not, by itself, a ground to reject a
Will. A testator is entitled to dispose of his property according to his own
wishes. However, where the Will substantially excludes the natural heirs and
confers the estate upon another person, such circumstance assumes significance
when considered with other suspicious circumstances.
12.16. In the present case, the Will contains allegations concerning the
conduct of the defendant and the matrimonial relationship. The defendant has
categorically denied those allegations and has given a materially different
account of the matrimonial circumstances. This Court is not required in this
testamentary proceeding to determine the matrimonial disputes between the
parties. But the fact remains that the plaintiff has not established by independent
and convincing evidence that the testator, while in a critical state of health,
__________
Page21 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
voluntarily chose to exclude his wife for the reasons stated in the Will. The
exclusion of the wife, therefore, becomes a relevant circumstance when
considered cumulatively with the other circumstances surrounding execution.
12.17. Further, the defendant had instituted proceedings for declaration
and partition after the death of the testator. It is an admitted circumstance that
the alleged Will was not disclosed in the written statement originally filed in the
partition proceedings. The plaintiff seeks to explain this by contending that the
properties covered by the Will were not originally included in the schedule to
the partition. This explanation is not wholly satisfactory. If the plaintiff was in
possession of the alleged Will from 2014 onwards and the Will purported to
govern the devolution of the properties of the deceased, the existence of such a
document would be a material fact in any litigation concerning the estate of the
deceased. The subsequent production of the Will assumes importance because
the testamentary proceeding was instituted only after the partition litigation had
commenced. This circumstance, by itself, may not prove fabrication. But, it
cannot be ignored when the Court is required to decide whether the propounder
has dispelled all legitimate suspicion.
12.18. It is to be noted that, the testator died on 23.03.2014. The original
petition was filed only on 26.04.2017. The learned counsel for the plaintiff
relies upon the judgements of this Court, including S. Vatsala vs. K.S. Mohan
__________
Page22 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
(cited supra) to contend that Article 137 of the Limitation Act does not, by
itself, bar testamentary proceedings and that a Will creates a continuing right.
There can be no quarrel with the proposition that mere delay does not
automatically invalidate a Will. However, the issue before this Court is not
merely whether the proceeding is barred by limitation. The issue is whether the
delay, when considered together with the other circumstances, has been
satisfactorily explained.
12.19. In the present case, the delay assumes significance because:
a) The Will is said to have been executed shortly before the death of the
testator;
b) The testator died within a fortnight thereafter;
c) The Will contains a disputed recital as to the place of execution;
d) The testator’s thumb impression rather than the signature is relied
upon;
e) The Will excludes the wife and other natural heirs;
f) The defendant subsequently instituted partition proceedings;
g) The Will was not disclosed in the original pleadings in those
proceedings; and
h) The testamentary proceeding was instituted only thereafter.
__________
Page23 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
12.20. Therefore, the proposition relied upon may be correct as a general
statement of law in the appropriate factual setting. However, the question of
limitation is not determinative of the present Testamentary proceedings. Even
assuming that, the testamentary suit is not barred by limitation, the plaintiff
must independently establish the genuineness and due execution of the Will.
Therefore, the decisions relied upon by the learned counsel for the plaintiff on
limitation do not advance the plaintiff’s case on the principal issue of
testamentary validity. Further, the delay is not being treated as an independent
statutory bar. It is considered as one of the surrounding circumstances which the
propounder was required to explain. The explanation offered is insufficient.
12.21. The plaintiff has relied upon the videographic recording and the
forensic report marked as Exhibit D9. The expert has opined that the recording
did not contain signs of morphing and that it was authentic. This Court has no
reason to reject the expert opinion in so far as it relates to the technical
authenticity of the recording. However, the scope of such expert opinion must
be properly understood. This Court accepts that the report may establish that the
recording was not shown to have been digitally manipulated. However, absence
of morphing is not equivalent to proof of valid execution of the Will. The expert
was concerned with whether the audio video recording has been tampered with,
morphed or manipulated. The expert was not called upon to determine whether
the testator possessed testamentary capacity in law, whether he understood the
__________
Page24 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
contents of the Will, whether he voluntarily approved every disposition
contained therein, or whether, the document was free from undue influence. Nor
can a forensic opinion regarding the integrity of an electronic recording
establish the circumstances in which the Will itself was prepared, explained,
executed and attested. At the highest, the recording may corroborate that a
particular conversation or incident was recorded. It does not, by itself, remove
the other suspicious circumstances surrounding the Will. Therefore, authenticity
of the video recording cannot be equated with proof of the validity of the Will.
12.22. Likewise, the evidence of D.W.4 regarding the making of the
video cannot substitute the statutory proof of due execution and the
propounder's obligation to dispel legitimate suspicion. The plaintiff contends
that the video and other evidence establish that the testator was in a sound
disposing state of mind. This Court is unable to accept this contention in the
absence of sufficiently convincing evidence. The question is not merely whether
the testator could speak or answer questions. The testator must have understood
the nature of the document, the extent of the property dealt with, and the
persons whose interests were being affected. The evidence must therefore be
assessed against the background of his serious illness, the unusual mode of
execution, the disputed place of execution and the exclusion of his wife.
__________
Page25 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
12.23. The learned counsel for the plaintiff placed considerable reliance
upon the answers given by the defendant in the cross examination. It is true that
the defendant has admitted that she was not present at the hospital on
09.03.2014 and that she cannot speak from personal knowledge as to the precise
circumstances in which the Will was executed. The defendant has also admitted
that she had seen the video recording and has not obtained an independent
expert opinion to establish that the recording was manipulated. However, the
fact that the defendant was not present at the alleged execution cannot, by itself,
prove the Will. The burden does not shift to the defendant merely because she is
unable to establish that the Will is fabricated. The initial burden remains upon
the propounder to establish the Will and to remove legitimate suspicious
circumstances surrounding its execution.
12.24. This Court is required to examine the evidence of the propounder
as a whole and determine whether the propounder has succeeded in satisfying
the judicial conscience of the Court. The relationship between the testator and
the plaintiff is itself a material circumstance. The defendant, in the connected
partition proceedings, has made several serious allegations concerning the
conduct and character of the deceased during the matrimonial relationship. She
had also admitted that she was not with the testator on 09.03.2014 and that she
was at her parents house at that time. She had also admitted that she did not
return to the hospital thereafter. These circumstances, standing alone, would not
__________
Page26 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
invalidate a Will. A spouse living separately may nevertheless be a beneficiary
under a Will. However, when the Will is alleged to have been executed in the
final stage of the testator’s illness, this Court has to examine the circumstances
with greater care, particularly, when the Will materially alters the normal course
of succession.
12.25. The defendant is the widow of the testator and is a natural heir
under the applicable law. The alleged Will substantially affect the defendant’s
statutory entitlement. The exclusion of a natural heir is not, by itself, a ground
for rejecting a Will. A testator is free to depart from intestate succession. But,
where the disposition is challenged and the circumstances surrounding its
execution are questioned, the reason for such exclusion becomes relevant. The
propounder must therefore satisfactorily establish that the disposition was the
free and conscious act of the testator. The Will itself gives reasons for the
disposition. However, the Court must be satisfied not merely with the existence
of reasons in the document but with the circumstances in which those reasons
came to be recorded and the testamentary document brought into existence.
12.26. This Court has also viewed the video recording relied upon by the
plaintiff. The recording may show the testator speaking about the Will and the
reasons for affixing his thumb impression.
That is certainly a relevant
circumstance. But the existence of a video in which the testator speaks cannot
__________
Page27 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
dispense with the legal requirement of proving testamentary capacity and
removal of suspicious circumstances.
The crucial question is not merely
whether the testator was capable of speaking or answering questions but
whether he possessed sufficient mental capacity to understand the nature of his
act, the extent of the property disposed of, the persons who might ordinarily
have claims upon his estate and the consequences of the disposition. The
medical evidence and the surrounding circumstances have to be assessed from
that perspective.
12.27. Further, the Will is stated to have been executed in the presence of
Advocate T. Chandran. It is unfortunate that the said Advocate is no longer
alive, as evidenced by Ex.D14. Had the Advocate who was allegedly present at
the time of execution been available, his evidence could have been of
considerable assistance in determining the circumstance in which the Will was
prepared and executed. His absence is not attributable to the plaintiff and
cannot, by itself, be treated as a suspicious circumstance. Nevertheless, in a
case where the Will is otherwise surrounded by circumstances requiring
explanation, the absence of a material witness who was allegedly present at the
execution necessarily leaves one aspect of the evidence uncorroborated.
12.28. The evidence of the attesting witness (D.W. 2) has been carefully
considered. He has spoken about the execution of the Will, the affixing of the
__________
Page28 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
thumb impression and the presence of other attesting witness. His evidence
establishes an important part of the plaintiff’s case. However, the attesting
witness’s statement that the testator was in a sound state of mind is not
conclusive. This Court has independently assessed the totality of the evidence.
The statutory requirement of attestation and the judicial requirement of removal
of suspicious circumstances operate in different fields. Therefore, even after
accepting the evidence of D.W.2 regarding physical act of execution, it has to
be determined whether the plaintiff has satisfactorily removed the other
circumstances which legitimately arise from the evidence.
12.29. This Court is not considering any single circumstance in isolation.
The
following
circumstances
assume
significance
when
considered
cumulatively;
1. The testator was suffering from an advance and serious illness and
died shortly thereafter.
2. The Will was allegedly executed during the period of his
hospitalisation.
3. There is discrepancy between the place of execution recited in the
Will and the place asserted by the propounder.
4. The natural heir, namely the wife, is excluded or materially
affected by the testamentary disposition.
5. The defendant was admittedly not present at the alleged execution.
__________
Page29 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
6. The principal Advocate said to have been present at the execution
is no longer available for examination.
7. The video recording, though found technically authentic, does not
by itself, establish testamentary capacity or absence of undue
influence.
8. The medical condition of the testator was sufficiently serious to
require careful scrutiny of his testamentary capacity.
9. The circumstances in which the document came into existence have
not been established with such clarity as would completely dispel the
legitimate doubts arising from the record.
This Court reiterates that none of these circumstances, individually, is sufficient
to invalidate a Will. The question is whether, taken together, the plaintiff has
discharged the heavier burden cast upon a propounder in a case involving
suspicious circumstance. On a careful consideration of the entire evidence, this
Court is unable to hold that the suspicious circumstances surrounding the
subject Will has been satisfactorily removed.
12.30. The plaintiff has sought to explain the non disclosure of the Will in
the Written Statement filed in the partition suit on the ground that the property
covered by the Will was not the subject matter of the Original Partition Suit.
The explanation may have some relevance while considering the conduct of the
__________
Page30 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
parties. However, it does not by itself either prove or disprove the Will. This
Court therefore, does not rest its conclusion upon the alleged non disclosure.
12.31. The learned counsel for the plaintiff has relied upon several
decisions relating to the following propositions:
a) the Court should examine the Will from the perspective of the
testator;
b) an attesting witness satisfying Section 63 of the Indian Succession
Act and Section 68 of the Evidence Act is sufficient to establish
formal execution;
c) minor discrepancies or typographical errors should not invalidate
an otherwise genuine document;
d) modern technology, including video recording and expert analysis,
can be relied upon to establish authenticity of electronic material;
e) delay in seeking testamentary relief does not, by itself, constitute a
suspicious circumstance; and
f) testamentary proceedings may stand on a different footing from
ordinary suits for the purpose of limitation.
12.32. There can be no quarrel with these propositions. However, none
of these authorities lays down that once one attesting witness enters the witness
__________
Page31 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
box, every suspicious circumstance surrounding the Will automatically
disappears. Likewise, a judgment concerning a typographical or clerical error
cannot be applied to a discrepancy concerning the very place of execution when
that circumstance forms part of the overall challenge to the Will. A minor error
can be ignored where satisfactorily explained and where the surrounding
evidence leaves no genuine doubt. The question here is not the typographical
error in isolation but its evidentiary significance when considered along with the
other circumstances. Similarly, decisions recognising the evidentiary value of
video recordings or electronic material cannot be applied to hold that a
technically genuine recording conclusively proves testamentary capacity. Each
testamentary case must ultimately turn upon its own facts and the evidence
adduced before the Court.
12.33. Further, the plaintiff contended that once the execution and
attestation were spoken to by the witnesses, the burden shifted upon the
defendant to establish forgery or fabrication. This submission cannot be
accepted in the manner advanced. The initial and continuing burden upon the
propounder is to establish the Will and, where suspicious circumstances exist, to
satisfy the conscience of the Court that the Will represents the genuine and free
testamentary intention of the deceased. The caveator is not required, in every
case, to affirmatively establish the precise manner in which the Will was
__________
Page32 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
fabricated. The failure of the defendant to prove a positive act of forgery does
not relieve the propounder of the obligation to remove legitimate suspicion.
12.34. In the present case, the plaintiff seeks Letters of Administration
with the Will annexed in respect of the alleged Will dated 09.03.2014. The
central question is not merely whether the testator affixed his thumb impression
or whether one attesting witness has spoken to the execution of the document.
The real question is whether the plaintiff has established that the Will represents
the free, conscious and voluntary testamentary intention of the deceased,
executed while possessing a sound and disposing state of mind, and free from
suspicious circumstances. The testator’s serious illness, the circumstances of
hospital execution, the material effect of the disposition upon a natural heir, and
the limitations of the evidence relied upon to establish testamentary capacity
must be considered together. The question is whether the plaintiff has
satisfactorily explained the cumulative effect of these circumstances.
This
Court is of the view that the plaintiff has failed to do so. Notwithstanding the
evidence of one attesting witness and the technical authenticity of the video
recording, the plaintiff has not discharged the heavier burden required in a case
involving suspicious circumstances. Further, sitting in the testator’s arm chair,
does not mean accepting the Will merely because the dispositions are legally
possible. It requires the Court to examine whether, considering the testator’s
circumstances, the document represents his free and conscious intention.
__________
Page33 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
12.35. Merely because some formal requirements of execution have been
established, this Court cannot grant Letters of Administration, when the
genuineness of the testamentary intention remains surrounded by legitimate and
unexplained doubt.
13. In view of the findings recorded above, the plaintiff in TOS No. 12 of
2018 is not entitled to grant of Letters of Administration with the Will dated
09.03.2014 annexed thereto.
14. Tr. C.S. No.563 of 2019
14.1. The case of the plaintiff in brief:
14.2. The plaintiff is the wife of late Mr. Vivek Vijayakumar.
The
defendant is the mother of the deceased. The marriage between the plaintiff and
the deceased was solemnised on 11.03.2012 at Chennai. According to the
plaintiff, after the marriage, she came to know that her husband was addicted to
alcohol and drugs and was suffering from serious health ailments. He was
subsequently
diagnosed
with
colon
cancer
and
underwent
surgery,
chemotherapy and radiotherapy. Ultimately he died on 23.03.2014.
__________
Page34 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
14.3. The plaintiff alleges that, taking advantage of the serious illness and
condition of her husband, the defendant and her family members obtained a
settlement deed dated 04.09.2013 in favour of the defendant in respect of the
property jointly purchased in the name of the deceased and the defendant.
According to the plaintiff, the deceased was not in a fit state of mind to execute
the settlement deed and the same was brought about by fraud, coercion and
undue influence.
14.4. The plaintiff further claims that, upon the death of her husband, she
became entitled to his share in the properties and, therefore, instituted the suit
seeking a declaration that the settlement deed dated 04.09.2013 is invalid and
not binding upon her and for partition and separate possession of her alleged
share.
14.5. The second item of property was subsequently brought into the suit
schedule by way of amendment pursuant to the order dated 20.10.2017 in I.A.
No.948 of 2017.
15. On the other hand, the defendant had denied the allegations made by
the plaintiff. According to the defendant, the deceased was hale and healthy
and voluntarily executed the settlement deed dated 04.09.2013 in her favour out
of natural love and affection. It is her specific case that the deceased personally
__________
Page35 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
appeared before the Sub Registrar, Chengalpattu, presented the document,
admitted its execution and completed the registration formalities.
15.1. The defendant further contends that the plaintiff has not pleaded or
established any specific act of fraud, coercion or undue influence and that the
registered settlement deed cannot be invalidated merely on the basis of the
deceased’s subsequent illness. The defendant also contends that the suit is not
maintainable as a suit for partition, since the plaintiff has deliberately omitted
several properties belonging to the deceased from the suit schedule. It is further
contended that, the plaintiff is not in possession of the suit property and,
therefore, the Court fee paid under Section 37(2) of the Tamil Nadu Court Fees
and Suits Valuations Act, 1955, is incorrect.
16. The following issues have been framed in CS No.563 of 2019:
1. Whether the settlement deed dated 04.09.2013 is null and void
and not binding on the plaintiff;
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to half share in the suit
property;
3. Whether the plaintiff is in joint possession of the property;
4. Whether the Court Fee paid is proper;
5. To what other reliefs the parties are entitled to?
__________
Page36 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
Issue No. 1:
17. The foundation of the plaintiff’s claim is that the settlement deed
dated 04.09.2013, marked as Ex.P1, executed by her husband in favour of the
defendant is invalid and consequently the plaintiff is entitled to succeed to the
share which, according to her, continue to remain with her deceased husband.
Ex.P1 is a registered settlement deed dated 04.09.2013. The document contains
the signature / execution particulars of the settlor. The registration endorsement
contains the photographs and left thumb impression of the deceased.
The
endorsement also records the presentation and admission of the document for
registration.
17.1. The plaintiff does not dispute that the photographs appearing in the
registration endorsement is that of her husband. In cross examination, she has
also admitted that the thumb impression appearing in the registration
endorsement is that of her husband. She has further admitted that the
registration endorsement records that the document was presented by her
husband and admitted by him for registration.
17.2. The significant question, therefore, is whether the plaintiff has
established that, notwithstanding the execution and registration of Ex.P1, the
document was brought about by fraud, coercion, undue influence or incapacity
of the executant. The plaintiff has stated in her evidence that her husband was
__________
Page37 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
suffering from cancer and that, on account of his medical condition, he was not
in a position to execute the settlement deed. However, the mere fact that the
executant was suffering from cancer or had undergone treatment does not, by
itself, establish that he lacked the mental capacity to execute a document.
17.3. The burden was upon the plaintiff to establish the circumstances
which would render Ex.P1 invalid. Though in the cross examination P.W.1 was
specifically asked whether the settlement deed had been obtained by fraud or
coercion, she stated that it was so. However, she was unable to set out any
specific act or circumstance constituting such fraud or coercion. More
importantly, P.W.1 has admitted that she was at the residence at Chengalpattu
on the relevant date. She has also admitted that she was unaware of the exact
circumstances of the execution. She has not stated who accompanied her
husband to the Sub Registrar’s Office, what transpired there or in what manner
the defendant exercised any coercion or undue influence upon him.
17.4. The plaintiff has also admitted that she did not specifically use the
expressions “fraud” or “coercion” in the plaint or in her proof affidavit. Merely
describing the transaction as a “sham transaction” is not sufficient to establish
fraud or coercion unless the material particulars constituting such fraud or
coercion are pleaded and proved. This Court also cannot lose sight of the fact
that Ex.P1 was not a document brought into existence privately or an
__________
Page38 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
unregistered document. The document was presented for registration before the
competent Sub Registrar. The registration endorsement records the appearance
and admission of the executant. His photograph and thumb impression form part
of the registration record. The plaintiff has not examined any person who was
present before the Sub Registrar to establish that the deceased was incapable of
understanding the nature of transaction or that the document was executed
against his free will.
17.5. The execution of a registered instrument cannot be discarded merely
because the executant subsequently died of a serious disease. There must be
cogent evidence connecting the illness with lack of testamentary or contractual
capacity at the relevant point of time. No such evidence has been established in
the present case. It is also relevant that the settlement was made in favour of the
defendant, who is admittedly the mother of the deceased. The property covered
by Ex.P1 had itself been purchased jointly in the names of the deceased and the
defendant. The defendant was, therefore, already a co-owner of the property.
The transaction, viewed in that background, cannot by itself be characterised as
an unnatural transaction.
17.6. The contention of the plaintiff that the deceased was suffering from
cancer in September 2013 also cannot, by itself, invalidate the transaction. The
medical records may establish the nature of his illness, but they do not, in the
__________
Page39 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
absence of medical or other cogent evidence, establish that on 04.09.2013 he
lacked the capacity to understand the nature and effect of the settlement deed.
17.7. This Court is therefore unable to accept the contention that Ex.P1
was executed by the deceased without knowledge or consent or that it was
procured by fraud, coercion or undue influence. A registered document carries a
presumption arising from the regularity of the official act of registration, but
such presumption is not conclusive. Nevertheless, in the present case, the
plaintiff has failed to produce evidence sufficient to rebut the evidentiary value
of the registered instrument.
Issue Nos. 2 to 5:
18. The learned counsel for the defendant has relied upon the decision in
Gandhi vs. Swaminatha Gounder, 2006 (1) CTC 267 and would submit that,
in her cross examination, P.W.1 has admitted that the affidavit of assets filed in
the connected testamentary proceedings contained particulars of several
properties. She has further admitted that even after becoming aware of those
properties, she did not take steps to incorporate them in the present suit. The
suit, even after amendment, contains only two items of property. A suit for
partition ordinarily ought to encompass the entire estate available for partition
between the parties. A plaintiff cannot seek partition of only some of the
__________
Page40 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
properties forming part of the common estate while leaving out other properties,
unless the case falls within a legally recognised exception or there is a
satisfactory explanation for such exclusion. In the present case, the plaintiff has
not established any such exception. Her explanation that she was unaware of
the other properties cannot survive in view of her own admission that she
subsequently became aware of the properties but nevertheless did not amend the
plaint. The decisions relied upon by the learned counsel for the defendant on
the principle relating to partial partition support the proposition that, where
several properties forming part of the estate are available for partition, omission
of such properties without justification renders the suit defective.
18.1. His further submission is that the plaintiff has not established that
the properties omitted from the suit are either not available for partition or that
there exists any legally sustainable reason for excluding them. Consequently,
the plaintiff cannot seek a decree for partition in respect of the two items alone.
For both these reasons, namely, failure to establish invalidity of Ex.P1 and the
maintainability of the suit as a partial partition, the plaintiff is not entitled to the
relief of declaration or partition.
18.2. The learned counsel for the defendant has relied upon the decision
in Gandhi Vs Swaminatha Gounder, 2006 (1) CTC 267, in support of the
proposition concerning non inclusion of properties in a partition suit. The
__________
Page41 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
principle in Gandhi case has to be applied on the facts of the particular case.
The decision dealt with a situation where an admitted item of family property
had been omitted from the partition suit. A suit for partial partition is
discouraged to prevent a multiplicity of proceedings.
18.3. In the present case, the properties to which plaintiff claims title as
heir must first be identified as properties forming part of the estate of Vivek
Vijayakumar. In the present case, TOS and Tr.CS were tried jointly and this
Court effectively has cognizance of the entire dispute surrounding the
deceased's estate. Because both suits were tried jointly, the evidence regarding
the estate, shares, and status of the family members is already before this Court.
Once the Court dismisses the testamentary suit and finds the Will invalid, the
assets designated in that Will do not disappear or belong exclusively to the
propounder of the Will. Instead, they become part of the general estate available
for distribution among all legal heirs according to the applicable succession law.
Therefore, the properties covered under the failed Will fall back into the estate
of the deceased as intestate property. Courts generally lean towards a liberal
approach to amendments in joint trials so that all properties of the deceased are
partitioned in a single decree, avoiding future litigation. Hence, the omission of
the properties initially is rarely fatal to the entire partition suit when the Will
fails during the joint trial.
__________
Page42 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
18.4. Therefore, the plaintiff, being the widow of the deceased, is entitled
to the statutory share in the estate of the deceased in the absence of a valid Will.
The mother of the deceased is also a Class 1 heir. Accordingly, in respect of the
properties which are established to have belonged to the deceased on the date of
his death and which are not otherwise excluded by a valid prior transfer, the
plaintiff and the defendant are each entitled to one half share.
18.5. Further, in a suit for partition, the plaintiff need not establish actual
physical possession in the manner required in a suit for recovery of exclusive
possession where there is no legally established ouster. In the absence of clear
and cogent evidence of ouster, possession of one co-sharer is ordinarily
referable to the possession of all co-sharers. Therefore, the contention raised on
the side of the defendant that the plaintiff is not in joint possession of the
property and improper Court fee has been paid is unsustainable.
19. In the result:
(i) TOS No. 12 of 2018 is dismissed. The plaintiff is not entitled to
Letters of Administration with the Will annexed in respect of the alleged Will
dated 09.03.2014.
(ii) Tr.CS No. 563 of 2019 is partly decreed, holding that, in the absence
of a valid Will, the plaintiff, being the widow of late Vivek Vijayakumar, is
entitled to one half share in the properties which are proved to have formed part
__________
Page43 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
of the estate of the deceased on the date of his death. The said property shall be
included in the estate and dealt with in accordance with the preliminary decree.
(iii) A preliminary decree for partition shall be drawn accordingly, and an
Advocate Commissioner shall thereafter be appointed for division by metes and
bounds, if necessary.
(iv) The relief seeking declaration that the settlement deed dated
04.09.2013 is null and void stands rejected.
(v) The relief of permanent injunction shall operate only to the extent
necessary to preserve the properties forming part of the estate pending
completion of the partition proceedings.
(vi) There shall be no order as to costs.
30-10-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
BGA/mar
__________
Page44 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
TOS No. 12 of 2018
K.GOVINDARAJAN THILAKAVADI J.
BGA/mar
Pre-delivery Common Judgment in
TOS No. 12 of 2018
and
CS NO. 563 of 2019
30-10-2026
__________
Page45 of 45
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review