Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OSA No. 473 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on
27.07.2026
Pronounced on
19.08.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE P. VELMURUGAN
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS.JUSTICE K. GOVINDARAJAN THILAKAVADI
OSA No. 473 of 2018
AND
CMP NO. 22510 OF 2018
Union Bank Of India
Rep By Its Chief Manager, No.152, Mount Road,
Chennai 600 002
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. Patanjali Foods Limited
Formerly Known As ( *)
Ruchi Soya Industries Limited,
Ruchi House, Royal Palms,
Survey No. 169,Aarey Milk Colony,
Near Mayur Nagar,
Goregaon (east),
Mumbai,Maharashtra,
India 400065
(r1 Amended As Per Order Of Court Dated
02.02.2026 Made In Cmp.2299 Of 2026 In Osa.
473 Of 2018 Cvkj And Kbj
2. P.Venkatesalu
Proprietor, Sri Balaji Enterprises, No.9,
M.G.Road, Kumaran Nagar, Padi, Madras
600 050
..Respondent(s)
Prayer: The Original Side Appeal is filed under Order 36 Rule 1 of the Original
Side Rules R/W Clause 15 of the Letter Patents Act, to set aside the judgment
and decree dated 28.06.2018 passed in C.S.No.132 of 2005.
__________
Page1 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
OSA No. 473 of 2018
For Appellant(s):
Mrs.Chira Sampath, Senior Advocate
for M/s.Nvs & Associates
of M/s.NVS & Associates
For Respondent(s):
MR.V.Raghavachari, Senior Counsel
Assisted by Ms.R.V. Gayatri
Mr.P.B.Ramanujam for R1
R-2 -No appearance
Judgment
(Judgment of the Court was delivered by K.Govindarajan Thilakavadi J.)
The Original Side Appeal is filed to set aside the judgment and decree
dated 28.06.2018 passed in C.S.No.132 of 2005.
Facts:
2.The Plaintiff is a supplier of Palmolein oil, carrying on business at
Chennai within the jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court. The 2nd Defendant
approached the Plaintiff with a request to supply specified quantities of
Palmolein oil on credit basis. Considering the nature of the transaction and the
credit facility sought, the Plaintiff insisted upon adequate security. Pursuant
thereto, the 2nd Defendant caused the 1 st Defendant Bank (Appellant herein) to
issue an irrevocable Bank Guarantee bearing No. 179/2001 dated 11.02.2002 in
favour of the Plaintiff. The said Bank Guarantee was valid for the period from
11.02.2002 to 10.02.2003 and secured the credit facility extended by the
Plaintiff, up to a maximum sum of Rs. 25,00,000/-, The guarantee constituted
an independent and binding obligation on the 1st Defendant Bank to honour its
__________
Page2 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
commitment upon invocation.
Acting on the strength of the said Bank
Guarantee and the assurances extended, the Plaintiff supplied Palmolein oil to
the 2nd Defendant from time to time and raised invoices in respect thereof. The
details of the invoices are set out below:
S.No.
Date
Amount
1.
08.04.2002
3,10,990/-
2.
08.04.2002
3,08,149/-
3.
12.04.2002
3,15,283/-
4.
12.04.2002
3,02,555/-
5.
13.04.2002
3,03,899/-
6.
13.04.2002
3,18,295/-
Total
Rs.18,59,171/-
Towards discharge of the amounts due under the aforesaid invoices, the
2nd Defendant issued cheques in favour of the Plaintiff. However, upon
presentation, all the said cheques were dishonoured and returned with
endorsements stating "Exceeds Arrangements" and "Insufficient Funds". In
view of the default committed by the 2nd Defendant, the Plaintiff invoked the
Bank Guarantee by approaching the 1st
Defendant Bank. The Plaintiff's
representatives submitted a covering letter along with the original Bank
Guarantee to the Branch Manager of the 1 st
Defendant Bank, one Mr.
Kamarudeen. Shockingly, instead of honouring the unconditional Bank
Guarantee, the Plaintiff's representatives were asked to wait outside the
Manager's cabin. After a prolonged wait of nearly two hours, they were
__________
Page3 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
informed that the Manager had left the premises. The Manager did not return to
the Bank for the next two days, and no response whatsoever was given to the
Plaintiff's request. It is submitted that the 1st Defendant Bank, being bound by
the terms of the Bank Guarantee, was legally obligated either to honour the
same or communicate its decision to dishonour the Guarantee, in accordance
with law. The complete inaction and evasive conduct on the part of the Bank is
arbitrary, unlawful, and contrary to settled banking principles. Left with no
alternative, the Plaintiff issued a legal notice dated 07.05.2002 to the 1 st
Defendant Bank and another notice dated 10.05.2002 to the 2nd Defendant
calling upon them to make payment. The 1 st Defendant Bank sent a reply dated
16.05.2002 containing false and untenable allegations, seeking to evade its
liability under the Bank Guarantee. In view of the unjustified refusal on the part
of the 1st
Defendant Bank, the Plaintiff was constrained to approach the
Banking Ombudsman by lodging a complaint on 21.05.2002.
3.While the said complaint was pending, the 2nd Defendant, at the instigation of
the 1st Defendant Bank, filed W. P. No. 30011 of 2002 before this Court. This
Court, by order dated 19.02.2003, disposed of the writ petition directing that the
2nd Defendant be given an opportunity to participate in the proceedings before
the Banking Ombudsman. Not satisfied with the same, the 2nd Defendant
preferred W.A. No. 1603 of 2003, which also came to be disposed of. The entire
sequence of events demonstrates a concerted attempt on the part of the
__________
Page4 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
Defendants to jointly delay and defeat the legitimate claim of the Plaintiff.
Infact, the complaint before the Banking Ombudsman pertained to the unilateral
and illegal cancellation of the Bank Guarantee by the 1 st Defendant Bank,
acting in collusion with the 2 nd
Defendant, to the grave prejudice of the
Plaintiff. The present suit has been instituted well within the period of limitation
and within the jurisdiction of this Court. The pendency of proceedings before
the Banking Ombudsman does not operate as a bar to the institution of the
present suit, which is one for recovery of money lawfully due. The Plaintiff has
sought recovery of a sum of Rs. 18,59,171/- towards the principal amount,
jointly and severally from the Defendants, by invoking the Bank Guarantee,
which is an irrevocable and unconditional instrument. The conduct of the 1 st
Defendant Bank in failing to honour the Bank Guarantee is arbitrary, illegal,
and indicative of collusion with the 2 nd Defendant. The Plaintiff had duly
supplied the goods, which were accepted by the 2nd Defendant without any
demur as to quality or quantity. The liability of the 2nd Defendant as the
principal debtor and the 1st Defendant Bank as guarantor is joint and several.
The Plaintiff is therefore entitled to recover the suit claim from both
Defendants. While the Plaintiff is also entitled to interest at the rate of 21% per
annum from May 2002, being the date of the last cheque issued by the 2nd
Defendant, till the date of realisation.
__________
Page5 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
4.The claim of the Plaintiff was resisted by the 1 st Defendant stating that
the 2nd Defendant is its constituent and had been availing various credit facilities
from it. One such facility, according to the 1 st Defendant, culminated in the
issuance of the subject Bank Guarantee for a maximum sum of Rs. 25,00,000/in favour of the Plaintiff, valid from 11.02.2002 to 10.02.2003. It is the case of
the 1st Defendant that though the Bank Guarantee was issued at the instance of
the 2nd Defendant, the Plaintiff had allegedly not confirmed its acceptance of the
same.
5.The 1st Defendant further states that on 02.05.2002, the 2nd Defendant
returned the original Bank Guarantee along with a covering letter dated
30.04.2002 requesting cancellation of the said guarantee and release of the
margin money. Acting upon such request, the 1st Defendant claims to have
cancelled the Bank Guarantee in the normal course of its business. The 1 st
Defendant categorically denies having received the original Bank Guarantee or
any invocation request from the Plaintiff. It disputes the Plaintiff's case that its
representatives approached the Bank for encashment of the guarantee upon
dishonour of the cheques issued by the 2 nd Defendant. The 1st Defendant also
denies the allegation that its Branch Manager, Mr. Kamarudeen, had received
the Bank Guarantee from the Plaintiff's representatives and thereafter failed to
act upon the same.
__________
Page6 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
6.Further, it is contended that the said allegations are false and have been
introduced as an afterthought. According to the 1" Defendant, Mr. Kamarudeen
was not the final authority to decide claims under the Bank Guarantee, and that
the Bank's functioning is structured with multiple officials, including a Chief
Manager and other supervisory officials. It is further contended that the
Plaintiff's alleged attempt to invoke the Bank Guarantee is not genuine and
pertains to a non-existent or already cancelled instrument, and hence no liability
can arise thereunder. The 1st Defendant asserts that the Bank Guarantee was not
an irrevocable instrument and that its cancellation was effected in the ordinary
course of business upon the request of the 2nd Defendant. On the above
premises, the 1st Defendant contends that it was under no obligation to honour
any claim under the said Bank Guarantee and that there exists no cause of action
as against it. The 1st Defendant therefore seeks dismissal of the suit for the
reasons stated above.
7.Despite, summons served, the 2nd defendant remained absent and was
set ex-parte.
8.The issues framed by the learned Single Judge as hereunder:
1. Whether the 1st Defendant Bank, furnished irrevocable Bank
Guarantee bearing No. 179 of 2001 dated 11.02.2002, at the instance
and on behalf of the 2nd Defendant, in favor of the Plaintiff?
__________
Page7 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
2. Whether the 1st Defendant handed over the said original Bank
Guarantee to the 2nd Defendant, who subsequently requested the
Bank to cancel the said Bank Guarantee and accordingly, whether 1 st
Defendant cancelled it legally?
3. Whether the Plaintiff handed over the Bank Guarantee to the 1 st
Defendant for encashment as per law ?
4. Whether the Plaintiff, within the time stipulated in the Bank
Guarantee, exercised its option to enforce and encash the Bank
Guarantee?
5. Whether the cheques issued by the 2nd Defendant in favour of the
Plaintiff were all dishonoured on various dates and thereby paving
the way for invoking the said Bank Guarantee?
6. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to recover the suit amount of Rs.
29,00,306.75?
7. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to recover interest at the rate of
21% p.a. on Rs. 18,59,171/- from the date of Plaint till date of decree
and thereafter also at the same rate till the realization ?
8. To what relief is the Plaintiff entitled ?
8.During trial, the plaintiff examined the Manager as P.W.1 and marked
as Exibits EX.P.1 to P.24 and on the side of the defendants, 1st defendant Bank
__________
Page8 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
examine the Chief Manager Mrs.Rekha as D.W.1 and Manager Mr.Kamarudeen
as D.W2 and marked as Exs.D.1 to D.9.
9.Based on the pleadings, evidence and submissions made by the
respective counsel for the parties, the learned Single Judge decreed the suit with
costs.
10.Aggrieved by this, the present appeal is preferred.
11.For the sake of convenience the parties are referred as per the ranking
in the trial Court.
12.Mrs. Chitra Sampath, learned Senior counsel for the appellant/1st
defendant would submit that even though the bank guarantee was issued by the
1st defendant to the 2nd defendant, the same was not received by the plaintiff and
the plaintiff has failed to accept the same. No written communication
whatsoever from the plaintiff regarding the acceptance of the bank guarantee or
acknowledging the receipt of the same and the 1st defendant in view of the letter
of the 2nd defendant, acted as per the instructions of the 2 nd defendant and
accordingly cancelled the guarantee as per prevailing bank practice. Her further
contention is that as per Section 126 of the Contract Act, bank guarantee is a
contract to perform the promise and under Section 2(b) of the Contract Act,
__________
Page9 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
only when the proposal made by the 1 st defendant Bank is accepted, it becomes
promise and that when the plaintiff failed to accept the bank guarantee, it does
not constitute a binding contract. Hence, in the absence of acceptance on the
part of the plaintiff, there is no concluded contract between the plaintiff and the
1st defendant and the 1st defendant is not bound to honour the bank guarantee.
Further, she would submit that neither the plaintiff nor his employees ever
visited the branch office of the 1 st defendant and handed over the alleged bank
guarantee or letter of invocation. The evidence of D.W.2 would establish the
above fact and the same was not rebutted. Therefore, in the absence of
substantiating and proving the above facts, the onus could not have shifted on
the 1st defendant. She would further submit that the original bank guarantee
were in fact received only from the 2nd defendant who had handed over the
original bank guarantee along with the letter dated 30.04.2002 directing the 1 st
defendant to cancel the same.
13.Her further contention is that, a bank guarantee being an independent
contract between the bank and the beneficiary, there was not consensus ad idem
in view of the fact that the offer of the 1 st defendant never culminated into an
unequivocal acceptance on the part of the plaintiff. The plaintiff, therefore, did
not comply with the requirement of the 1st defendant that the plaintiff should
confirm the receipt of acceptance of the guarantee and that this fact is further
evident from the fact that the receipt of the bank guarantee was never proved by
__________
Page10 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
the plaintiff. While so, the learned Single Judge without considering the above
factors has arrived at the conclusion that the guarantee issued by a Bank will
have to be honoured, irrespective of any dispute between the beneficiary of the
guarantee and the party on whose behalf it was issued. Such a conclusion
completely disregarded the surrounding factual circumstances and crucial
evidence, including the well established principle that the initial burden of proof
always lay with the plaintiff. Hence, prayed for setting aside the judgement and
decree passed by the trial Court.
14.On the other hand, Mr.V.Raghavachari, learned Senior counsel for the
1st respondent /plaintiff would contend that the bank guarantee is irrevocable
guarantee and the 1st defendant bank undertook and promised to pay the amount
due from the 2nd defendant to the plaintiff subject to the guarantee amount as
stated above without any demur merely on demand from the plaintiff and the 2 nd
defendant is liable to pay a sum of Rs. 18,59,171/- towards supply of palmolein
and in order to discharge the above liability, the 2nd defendant had issued
separate cheques for each supply, totalling to a sum of Rs.18,59,171/- drawn in
the 1st defendant bank, but all the above cheques were returned on presentation
for collection with an endorsement “exceeds arrangements and insufficient
funds”. Since the 2nd defendant did not come forward to settle his liability, the
plaintiff has invoked the bank guarantee.
__________
Page11 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
15.He would further submit that the bank guarantee dated 11.02.2002
constitutes an unconditional and irrevocable financial instrument, creating an
independent and absolute obligation on the part of the 1st defendant bank to
honour its commitment in favour of the plaintiff upon invocation.
16.He would further submit that the Hon’ble Supreme Court in U.P.State
Co-operative Federation Ltd., Vs. Singh Consultants and Engineers (Private
Ltd.), reported in (1988) 1 SCC 174, has authoritatively held that a bank must
honour its guarantee free from interference, except in cases of established fraud
or irretrievable injustice of an exceptional nature and that this principle has been
consistently
reiterated
in
subsequent
decisions,
including
Svenska
Handelsbanken V. Indian Charge Chrome Ltd., reported in (1994) 1 SCC 502,
wherein the Court emphasised that the sanctity of bank guarantees underpins
commercial transactions, and any dilution of this principle would irreparably
damage commercial confidence. Further he would submit that, in Himadri
Chemicals Industries Ltd., Vs. Coal Tar Refining Co., reported in (2007) 8
SCC 110, the Hon’ble Supreme Court crystallised the governing principles by
holding that bank guarantees are independent contracts and must be honoured
strictly in terms thereof, save in narrowly defined exceptional circumstances.
17.In the present case, the 1st defendant bank has not even attempted to
bring its defence within the recognised exceptions to enforcement. In the
__________
Page12 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
absence of such exceptional circumstances, the refusal of the bank to honour the
guarantee is plainly contrary to the settled law and constitutes a breach of its
independent contractual obligation. His further submission is that the liability of
the 2nd defendant stands conclusively established. The 2 nd defendant has never
disputed the supply of goods nor raised any objections to the invoices. In such
circumstances, the learned counsel would submit that, the 1 st defendant Bank,
whose obligation is purely that of a guarantor, cannot be permitted to raise
objections that the principal debtor itself has not raised.
18.He would further contend that a bank guarantee, once issued in favour
of a beneficiary and expressed to be irrevocable, cannot be unilaterally
cancelled by the issuing bank during its subsistence, particularly at the instance
of the principal debtor, without notice to the plaintiff. It is further submitted that
the original bank guarantee was submitted to the bank at the time of invocation.
Though the 1st defendant bank denied such receipt, the same cannot defeat the
plaintiff’s claim when the foundational facts of issuance and terms are admitted.
Further, the guarantee being unconditional does not prescribe any rigid format
for invocation, nor does it make its enforceability contingent upon formal
acceptance by the beneficiary. The law is well settled that once a guarantee is
issued and communicated to the beneficiary, it becomes enforceable according
to its terms and that the liability of the 1st defendant bank as guarantor is coextensive with that of the principal debtor, subject to the terms of the guarantee.
__________
Page13 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
19.He would further contend that the invoices issued by the plaintiff
expressly stipulate that delayed payments would attract interest at the rate of
21% per annum. Having contributed to the delay, the bank cannot now seek to
avoid the contractual rate of interest.
20.The learned Single Judge has, upon a detailed appreciations of
pleadings, oral evidence, and documentary material, arrived at well reasoned
findings, warrants any interference by this Court.
21.Heard on both sides and records perused.
22.This original side appeal is directed against the judgment and decree
passed by the learned Single Judge decreeing the suit filed by the plaintiff, the
1st respondent herein against the appellant - bank and the 2nd respondent/2nd
defendant for recovery of the amount covered by the bank guarantee.
23.The plaintiff is engaged in the business of supplying palmolein. The
2nd defendant purchased palmolein from the plaintiff on credit basis. As security
for the
credit facility extended by the plaintiff to the 2 nd defendant, at the
request of the 2nd defendant, the appellant - bank issued a bank guarantee in
favour of the plaintiff for a maximum sum of Rs.25,00,000/-.
__________
Page14 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
24.The bank guarantee was valid for a period of one year, namely, from
11.02.2002 to 10.02.2003. The material terms of the guarantee contemplated
payment by the bank upon demand, not withstanding any dispute between the
plaintiff and the 2nd defendant.
25.The plaintiff continued to supply goods to the 2 nd defendant relying
upon the security afforded by the bank guarantee. Subsequently, the cheques
issued towards payment were dishonoured with the endorsement “exceeds
arrangement” and “ insufficient funds”. The plaintiff therefore approached the
bank on 30.04.2002 and, according to the plaintiff, submitted a covering letter
expressing its intention to invoke the bank guarantee and handed over the
original bank guarantee to the branch manager, one Kamarudeen.
26.It is the plaintiff’s further case that the branch manager left the bank
without responding to the request. The plaintiff thereafter issued notices dated
07.05.2002 to the defendant. The plaintiff also lodged a complaint before the
Banking Ombudsman on 21.05.2002 alleging unilateral cancellation of the bank
guarantee by the bank in collusion with the 2nd defendant.
27.To the contrary, the appellant – bank denied that the plaintiff had
invoked the bank guarantee on 30.04.2002. It was contended that the plaintiff
__________
Page15 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
had never confirmed acceptance of the bank guarantee and that, in any event,
the original bank guarantee had been handed over by the 2 nd defendant to the
bank on 30.04.2002 along with a covering letter, requesting cancellation of the
guarantee.
28.The bank has specifically denied receipt of the original bank guarantee
from the plaintiff and denied that any request for invocation had been made by
the plaintiff.
29.It was further contended that the guarantee was not irrevocable and
that, by the time the plaintiff purportedly sought to invoke it, there
was
no
subsisting bank guarantee. According to the bank, the plaintiff therefore had no
cause of action against the bank.
30.The 2nd defendant, though duly served with suit summons, remained
absent and was set ex-parte.
Points for consideration:
1.Whether the plaintiff established a valid invocation of the bank
guarantee on 30.04.2002?
2.Whether the alleged cancellation of the bank guarantee at the
__________
Page16 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
instance of the 2nd defendant was effective against the plaintiff?
3. Whether the appellant – bank was justified in refusing to honour
the guarantee?
4.Whether the judgment and decree of the learned Single Judge
require interference?
Point Nos.1 to 4
31.The law relating to bank guarantees is well settled. A bank guarantee
constitutes an independent contract between the bank and the beneficiary. In
U.P.Co-operative Federation Ltd., Vs. Singh Consultants and Engineers (P)
Ltd., reported in (1988) 1 SCC 174, the Hon’ble Supreme Court emphasis the
independent nature of the bank’s obligation and held that an irrevocable bank
guarantee ordinarily has to be honoured in accordance with its terms.
32.The Hon’ble Supreme Court has repeatedly reiterated that in
commercial transaction, the bank is not concerned with disputes between the
beneficiary and the person at whose instance the guarantee was issued. The
bank must honour an unconditional guarantee when a demand is made in
accordance with its terms. The recognised exceptions are cases of established
fraud going to the very foundation of the guarantee and cases of irretrievable
injustice. The Hon’ble Supreme Court also emphasised, that the terms of the
__________
Page17 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
bank guarantee are of paramount importance and that invocation must be in
accordance with those terms. The bank and beneficiary are bound by the
independent contract constituted by the guarantee.
33.The appellant’s principal defence is that there was no invocation at all.
34.This contention has to be examined on the evidence. The guarantee
was admittedly valid from 11.02.2002 to 10.02.2003. The plaintiff ‘s case is that
on 30.04.2002, upon dishonour of the cheques issued by the 2 nd defendant, it
approached the appellant – bank and made a demand under the guarantee. The
date is significant. The alleged demand was made nearly 9 months before expiry
of the guarantee. The plaintiff has also relied upon the subsequent notice dated
07.05.2002 and the complaint made before the Banking Ombudsman on
21.05.2002. These subsequent contemporaneous documents lend support to the
plaintiff’s case that it had, in fact, attempted to invoke the guarantee on
30.04.2002.
35.The appellant – bank, on the other hand, as relied upon the alleged
letter of the 2nd defendant dated 30.04.2002 requesting cancellation of the
guarantee. The learned Senior Counsel for the Appellant – Bank would contend
that, P.W.1 in his evidence has stated that the original bank guarantee was with
the plaintiff, but the same was filed only by the appellant – bank before this
__________
Page18 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
Court, which would demonstrate that the plaintiff never received the bank
guarantee as pleaded by the plaintiff and that it was only the 2 nd defendant who
handed over the original bank guarantee to the appellant – bank for cancellation.
Further, the Chief Manager of the appellant – bank was not examined by the
plaintiff, to establish the alleged incident that took place on 30.04.2002. Hence,
the plaintiff cannot invoke the guarantee and claim the amount of bank
guarantee, when the initial obligation always rest upon the plaintiff to
conclusively establish before this Court that they had in fact received the
guarantee and handed over the same to the appellant-bank on 30.04.2002.
36.This contention of the appellant – bank regarding non production of
the original bank guarantee is devoid of merits. In fact, the bank guarantee
marked as Ex.D2 was addressed only to the plaintiff. No copy was marked to
the 2nd defendant. In such circumstances, the appellant-bank has to establish
that how the original of Ex.D2 was produced by the 2nd defendant, which the
appellant - bank failed to do so. In this regard, the principles of preponderance
of probabilities applies. Only if the plaintiff ‘s case is appreciated to the effect
that the document in Ex.D2 was handed over to the 1 st defendant Bank Manager
(Mr.Kamarudeen - D.W.2) along with the letter dated 30.04.2002 by the
plaintiff , the question of the original finding its place with the appellant – bank
through the 1st defendant’s hand becomes apparent.
__________
Page19 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
37.Further, the evidence of D.W.2 Mr. Kamarudeen, recorded on
03.04.2013, strengthens the plaintiff’s case, wherein he has stated in
unambiguous terms which is extracted as hereunder:
“ The letter dated 30.04.2002 from the 2nd defendant was allegedly
received on 02.05.2002.
There is no entry in the inward Tapal Register (Ex.D.3) evidencing such
receipt by the Chief Manager.
The endorsement received 02.05.2002 was made by D.W.2 himself
He further endorsed instructions to cancel the bank guarantee and
transfer amounts between accounts.
38.Further, the defence sought to be raised by the appellant – bank that
Ex.P.2 guarantee, stood cancelled at the instance of the 2 nd defendant is wholly
untenable both in fact and in law.
39.The alleged cancellation requires close scrutiny. The bank guarantee
was issued in favour of the plaintiff as security for the credit facility extended
by the plaintiff to the 2nd defendant. The plaintiff was the beneficiary under the
guarantee. Once the guarantee was issued in favour of the plaintiff and the
plaintiff had acquired the right to invoke it in accordance with its terms, the 2 nd
defendant could not, without the consent of the beneficiary, unilaterally
extinguish that right by merely requesting the appellant – bank to cancel the
bank guarantee.
__________
Page20 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
40.In fact, the conduct of the Appellant – Bank is further exposed through
its own evidence. The Chief Manager of the bank, examined as D.W.1 on
07.01.2013, categorically admitted which is extracted as hereunder:
“There is no record to show that the plaintiff was informed either
before or after cancellation of the bank guarantee”
41.This admission is fatal to the bank’s defence. It unequivocally
establishes that the alleged cancellation of the bank guarantee was effected
unilaterally, without any notice whatsoever to the bank, the beneficiary of the
under the bank guarantee. Such an act is not merely irregular, it is illegal and
void. The cumulative effect of the oral and documentary evidence leads to an
irresistible conclusion that there was collusion between the officials of the
appellant-bank and the 2nd defendant, resulting in the wrongful cancellation of a
valid and subsisting bank guarantee. Further, the appellant – bank has asserted
a positive fact, namely, that the original bank guarantee was returned by the 2 nd
defendant along with the letter dated 30.04.2002 requesting cancellation of the
bank guarantee. The 2nd defendant, who alone would have had direct knowledge
of such alleged surrender, chose not to contest the suit. If the appellant – bank
had in fact received the original guarantee from the 2 nd defendant and cancelled
it on 30.04.2002, it was incumbent upon the appellant – bank to establish the
circumstances in which such cancellation took place and, more importantly, to
__________
Page21 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
establish that the plaintiff’s right as beneficiary had not already been invoked or
that the plaintiff had consented to such cancellation. No convincing evidence
has been brought before us to establish that the plaintiff consented to
cancellation of the guarantee.
42.The appellant – bank, however, cannot rely merely upon the alleged
request of the 2nd defendant when the plaintiff, the beneficiary, has specifically
asserted that it invoked the guarantee on the same date. Further, the appellant bank cannot place itself in a position where, on the one hand, it holds out a
guarantee to the beneficiary and induces the beneficiary to act upon the security,
while, on the other hand, permits the constituent to withdraw or cancel that
security without notice to the beneficiary. The very commercial purpose of bank
guarantee would be defeated if the constituent could privately cancel the
guarantee after the beneficiary had acted upon it and had become entitled to
invoke it.
43.Much emphasis has been placed upon the appellant’s bank contention
that the plaintiff did not confirm acceptance of the guarantee and that the
original instrument was subsequently surrendered.
44.We are unable to accept that contention in the manner suggested.
__________
Page22 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
45.The plaintiff’s case is not founded merely upon an unaccepted offer of
a guarantee. The guarantee was actually issued by the bank in favour of the
plaintiff, and the plaintiff thereafter supplied goods to the 2 nd defendant on
credit relying upon the security. The subsequent conduct of the plaintiff,
particularly the immediate approach to the bank after dishonour of the cheques,
the notice dated 07.05.2002 and complaint before the Ombudsman, is consistent
with the existence of an operative guarantee and an attempt to enforce it.
46.The appellant – bank also contended that the guarantee was
irrevocable. The nomenclature used in the document is not decisive. What is
relevant is the substantive obligation undertaken by the Bank. If the terms of the
guarantee stipulate that the bank shall pay upon demand and notwithstanding
any dispute between the beneficiary and the constituent, the bank’s obligation is
independent and cannot be avoided by reference to dispute arising out of the
underlying transaction.
47.The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Hindustan Construction Co. Ltd., Vs.
State of Bihar, reported in (1999) 8 SCC 436 reiterated that the bank must
honour the guarantee according to its terms and that the underlying dispute
ordinarily has no relevance to the bank’ s obligation.
__________
Page23 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
48.Likewise, in Himadri Chemicals Industries Ltd. Vs. Coal Tar
Refining Co., reported in (2007) 8 SCC 110, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
reiterated that the Courts should be slow to interfere with unconditional bank
guarantees and that the bank’s obligation is to be determined from the terms of
the guarantee.
49.As rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for the plaintiff, the
bank cannot impose conditions or requirements which are not contemplated by
the terms of the guarantee itself. The defence that the plaintiff did not ‘accept’
the guarantee or comply with certain alleged procedural requirements has no
legal basis. The guarantee being unconditional, does not prescribe any rigid
format for invocation, nor does it make its enforceability contingent upon
formal acceptance by the beneficiary. The law is well settled that once a
guarantee
is issued and communicated to the beneficiary, it becomes
enforceable according to its terms. The bank cannot, by way of subsequent
interpretation, introduce new condition or dilute its obligation.
50.The present case is not that where the plaintiff seeks an injunction
restraining the bank from honouring a guarantee. Nor it is a case were the bank
seeks protection against an invocation founded upon an extraneous or fraudulent
demand. The plaintiff claims that it invoked the guarantee during its validity
and that the bank wrongfully refused to honour it. The bank’s obligation
__________
Page24 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
therefore has to be examined on the terms of the guarantee and on the question
whether a valid demand was made.
51.Indisputedly, the plaintiff has duly and validly invoked the bank
guarantee within the period of its validity. The plaintiff has placed on record
comprehensive documentary evidence establishing supply of goods, issuance
and dishonour of cheques, and invocation of the bank guarantee. These
documents have not been effectively rebutted by the defendants. The appellant
bank has not discharged its burden of disproving the plaintiff’s claim nor has it
produced any cogent evidence to support its own defence.
52.Further, the invoices issued by the plaintiff expressly stipulate that
delayed payment would attract interest at the rate of 21% per annum. This term
forms part of the contractual arrangements between the plaintiff and the 2 nd
defendant. Once the bank has undertaken to guarantee payment obligations
arising from that very transaction, it cannot selectively honour only the principal
amount while disclaiming liability for agreed interest. As rightly pointed out by
the learned Senior Counsel for the plaintiff, the obligation under the bank
guarantee must be read in a commercially meaningful manner so as to give full
effect to the underlying transaction. Therefore, the contention by the learned
Senior Counsel for the appellant – bank that the interest rate of 21% per annum
is usurious is wholly unsustainable.
__________
Page25 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
53.The learned Single Judge has considered the oral and documentary
evidence and arrived at the conclusion that the plaintiff has established its
entitlement against the appellant bank under the bank guarantee.
54.We find that the said conclusion is neither perverse nor contrary to the
settled principles governing bank guarantee. The appellant - bank, having issued
the guarantee in favour of the plaintiff and having undertaken to pay upon
demand in accordance with its terms, cannot escape its liability by relying upon
a unilateral request for cancellation allegedly made by its constituent,
particularly when the beneficiary had already invoked the guarantee and had
acted upon it.
55.In the result, the original side appeal is dismissed. The judgement and
decree of the learned Single Judge are confirmed. There shall be no order as to
costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition is closed.
(P.V.,J.) (K.G.T.,J.)
19-08-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
VSN
__________
Page26 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
1. Patanjali Foods Limited
Formerly Known As
Ruchi Soya Industries Limited,
Ruchi House, Royal Palms,
Survey No. 169,Aarey Milk Colony,
Near Mayur Nagar,
Goregaon (east),
Mumbai,Maharashtra,
India 400065
2. P.Venkatesalu
Proprietor, Sri Balaji Enterprises, No.9, M.G.Road, Kumaran Nagar,
Padi, Madras 600 050
__________
Page27 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 473 of 2018
P.VELMURUGAN J.
AND
K.GOVINDARAJAN THILAKAVADI J.
VSN
Pre-delivery judgment made in
OSA No. 473 of 2018
and
CMP NO. 22510 OF 2018
19-08-2026
__________
Page28 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review