Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CS No. 310 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 20-08-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MRS.JUSTICE K.GOVINDARAJAN THILAKAVADI
CS No. 310 of 2025
AND
A.No. 3352 of 2026,
A.No. 755 of 2026, A.No. 1029 of 2026,
OA.No. 625 of 2026, A NO. 2842 OF 2026
1. V.R. Jaganathan
S/o.C.Ramasawamy,
President, Indian National Trade Union
Congress(TN Branch)
19, T.N.Chinnasamy Avenue,
Rangammal Koil Street,
Peelamedu,
Coimbatore-641004
2. Indian National Trade Union Congress
Rep by P.Srinivasan Secretary, INTUC
Residing at 46/1, 3rd Main Road,
Baba Nagar, Villivakkam, Chennai-600049
..Plaintiff(s)
Vs
1. M. Pannerselvam
S/o.Munuswamy,
No.179/80, Adam Sahib Street,
Royapuram,
Chennai-600013
2. A.Kalyanaraman
Care of M.Paneerselvam,
No.179/80, Adam Sahib Street,
Royapuram,
Chennai-600013
3. S.Lingamoorthy
__________Page 1 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80, Adam
Sahib Street, Royapuram, Chennai-600013
4. M.Arumugam
Care of M.Pannerselvam , No.179/80, Adam
Sahib Street, Royapuram, Chennai-600013
5. M.Nandhakumar
Care of M.Pannerselvam ,
No.179/80, Adam Sahib Street,
Royapuram, Chennai-600013
6. D.Dhanasekar
Care of M.Pannerselvam ,
No.179/80, Adam Sahib Street, Royapuram,
Chennai-600013
7. J.Mathiyalagan
Care of M.Pannerselvam , No.179/80, Adam
Sahib Street, Royapuram, Chennai-600013
8. T.Rajasekaran
Care of M.Pannerselvam ,
No.179/80, Adam Sahib Street,
Royapuram,
Chennai-600013
9. K.Gunasekaran
Care of M.Pannerselvam ,
No.179/80, Adam Sahib Street, Royapuram,
Chennai-600013
10.K.S.ThusalimanCare of M. Pannerselvam
No.179/80, Adam Sahib Street, Royapuram,
Chennai-600013
..Defendant(s)
A.No. 2842 of 2026
1. A.Kalyanaraman
Care of M.Paneerselvam, No.179/80, Adam
Sahib Street, Royapuram, Chennai-600013
2. S.Lingamoorthy
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80, Adam
Sahib Street, Royapuram, Chennai-600013
3. M.Arumugam
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80, Adam
__________Page 2 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
Sahib Street, Royapuram, Chennai-600013
4. M.Nandhakumar
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80, Adam
Sahib Street, Royapuram, Chennai-600013
5. D.Dhanasekar
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80, Adam
Sahib Street, Royapuram, Chennai-600013
6. J.Mathiyalagan
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80, Adam
Sahib Street, Royapuram, Chennai-600013
7. T.Rajasekaran
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80, Adam
Sahib Street, Royapuram, Chennai-600013
8. K.Gunasekaran
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80, Adam
Sahib Street, Royapuram, Chennai-600013
9. K.S.Thusaliman
Care of M.Pannerselvam, No.179/80, Adam
Sahib Street, Royapuram, Chennai-600013
..Applicant(s)
Vs
1. V.R. Jaganathan
S/o.C.Ramasawamy, President, Indian National
Trade Union Congress(TN Branch) 19,
T.N.Chinnasamy Avenue, Rangammal Koil
Street, Peelamedu, Coimbatore-641004
2. Indian National Trade Union Congress
Rep by P.Srinivasan Secretary, INTUC
Residing at 46/1, 3rd Main Road, Baba Nagar,
Villivakkam, Chennai-600049
..Respondent(s)
CS No. 310 of 2025
Prayer: The suit has been filed under Order IV Rule 1 of O.S. Rules and Order
VII Rule 1 of CPC:
i) For Declaration declaring that the election conducted by the defendants
on 16.11.2025 as null and void in the eyes of law and not binding on the
__________Page 3 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
plaintiff’s union;
ii) For consequential permanent injunction restraining the defendants,
their men, agents, anyone claiming under them from interfering with or
disturbing the functioning of the Working Committee under the presidentship of
the 1st plaintiff;
iii) Directing the defendants to pay the cost of the suit.
A.No. 2842 of 2026
To transpose the Applicants/Defendants 2 to 10 as Plaintiffs 3 to 11 in
C.S.No.310 of 2025 and to permit the Applicants to continue and prosecute the
above suit.
O.A.No.625 of 2026
To grant an ad interim injunction restraining the 2 nd Respondent herein/2nd
Plaintiff, Indian National Trade Union Congress (Central INTUC) its President,
Secretary, Office Bearers, men, agents and all persons claiming under or
through it, from in any manner acting upon, proceeding with, giving effect to or
taking up for consideration the Show Cause Notice dated 10/06/2026, including
by placing the same before or deliberating upon or taking any decision pursuant
thereto at the Working Committee Meeting of INTUC proposed to be held on
28/06/2026 or any adjourned or subsequent date and thereby restraining the
Respondents 1 and 2 herein/Plaintiffs, their men and agents from suspending,
dissolving, superseding or interfering with the Working Committee of TNINTUC elected on 16/11/2025 under the Presidentship of the 1 st Defendant, or
from constituting any Ad-hoc Committee in its place, pending disposal of the
above suit.
For Plaintiff(s):
Mr.M.S.Krishnan,
__________Page 4 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
Senior Advocate
for Mr.K.Roopesh
for Sarvabhavman Associates
For Defendant(s):
Mr.A.K.Sriram for
Mr.D.Ravichander for D1
M/S. K.S.Kamakshi for D2 to
D10
ORDER
The plaintiffs have filed a memo seeking permission to withdraw the suit
unconditionally. The said memo is opposed by the 1st defendant.
2.The brief facts necessary for consideration of the memo are as follows:
The plaintiffs instituted the suit questioning the validity of the elections
conducted to the Tamil Nadu INTUC Working Committee on 16.11.2025 and
sought a declaration that the said election conducted by the defendants is null
and void. It is contended that the apex body of the Trade Union subsequently
took cognizance of the irregularities prevailing in the Organization and took
appropriate steps in accordance with the Constitution of the Organization. The
apex body of the Trade Union Organization, in exercise of the powers conferred
upon it under the Constitution of the Organization, appointed an Ad-hoc
Committee. Consequently, the alleged elected Committee has been replaced by
__________Page 5 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
the said Ad-hoc Committee, and the subject matter of the suit has thereby
become infructuous. In view of the subsequent developments, the plaintiffs filed
the present memo seeking unconditional withdrawal of the present suit.
3.Pursuant thereto, the defendants 2 to 10 filed a transposition
application, numbered as A.No.2842 of 2026, in which the plaintiffs have filed
their counter statement.
4.The 1st defendant filed a reply to the said memo stating that the
plaintiffs, who challenged the elections conducted to the Tamil Nadu INTUC
Working Committee held on 16.11.2025, had got their interim application in
O.A.No.1201 of 2025 dismissed by this Court vide order dated 26.02.2026. This
Court, while considering the interim relief sought by the plaintiffs, noticed, inter
alia, that other members elected in the elections held on 16.11.2025 had not
been impleaded and that the application suffered from the defect of non-joinder
of necessary parties. It was also observed that the validity of the election was a
matter which would have to be adjudicated at the stage of trial.
__________Page 6 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
5.It is the further case of the 1st defendant that notwithstanding the
aforesaid proceedings, the 2nd plaintiff issued a show cause notice calling upon
the 1st defendant to show cause as to why action should not be taken against him
in relation to the conduct of the elections held on 16.11.2025 and further as to
why an Ad-hoc Committee should not be appointed in the place of the existing
Working Committee of Tamil Nadu INTUC. The said notice was served upon
the 1st defendant on 17.06.2026.
6.Immediately thereafter, the 1st defendant instituted O.A.No.625 of 2026
seeking appropriate injunctive relief, which was posted for hearing on
24.06.2026. According to the 1st defendant, with a view to render the said
proceedings infructuous, the plaintiffs filed the memo stating that an amicable
settlement was in progress. The 1st defendant disputes the existence of any such
settlement and contends that the withdrawal is an abuse of the process of the
Court.
7.More importantly, the 1st defendant has already filed a written statement
containing a counter claim. By way of the counter claim, the 1 st defendant seeks,
inter alia, a declaration that he is the duly elected President of the Tamil Nadu
__________Page 7 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
INTUC Working Committee, a declaration that the show cause notice dated
10.06.2026 is null and void, and a consequential permanent injunction
restraining the plaintiffs from interfering with his peaceful functioning as
President of the Tamil Nadu INTUC Working Committee.
8.Mr.M.S.Krishnan, learned Senior Counsel for the plaintiffs submitted
that due to the subsequent developments, the very subject matter of the suit has
become infructuous and that there is no useful purpose in continuing the suit.
He would further contend that, when a memo is filed by the plaintiff for
withdrawal of the suit, no option is left to the Court except to record the memo
and dismiss the suit as withdrawn and relied upon the judgment reported in
2010 SCC Online Madras 5794. His further contention is that, while making a
prayer to withdraw the suit under Order XXIII Rule 1(1), the plaintiff does not
ask for any leave to file a fresh suit on the same subject matter. A mere
withdrawal of the suit without asking for anything more can, therefore, be
always permitted. The defendant has no right to compel the plaintiff to
prosecute the suit by opposing the withdrawal of the suit sought by the plaintiff
except to claim the costs for filing a suit against him and relied upon the
judgment reported in (2018) 12 Supreme Court Cases 584. He would further
__________Page 8 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
contend that from a perusal of the Rule and the ratio laid down in Vasantha
Ammal Vs. V.P.Dhanaraj and Others, reported in 1990 (1) LW 209, a
defendant has a right to transpose himself as a plaintiff must have a substantial
question to be decided and it has to be tested whether such substantial question
has to be decided against any other defendants, and the defendant seeking
transposition must have an identity of interest along with the plaintiff as against
other defendants. Further, it has to be tested whether the withdrawal or
abandonment by the plaintiff of the suit results in some vested right of the
defendant getting defeated. The learned Senior Counsel would submit that,
applying the above tests, in the present suit the defendants who seek to
transpose themselves as plaintiffs do not have any substantial question to be
decided against any other defendants in the suit and do not have any identity of
interest along with the plaintiff as against other defendants and therefore, the
withdrawal of the suit by the plaintiff do not result in defeating any right of the
above defendants. Hence, submitted that the application filed by the defendants
who seek transposition as plaintiffs is liable to be rejected. To support his
contention, he has relied upon the judgments reported in 2006 SCC Online
MAD 913 and (2020) 14 Supreme Court Cases 1.
__________Page 9 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
9.On the other hand, Mr.A.K.Sriram, learned Counsel for the 1 st
defendant would submit that the counter claim is designed to avoid multiplicity
of proceedings. The learned counsel would submit that no time limit for filing a
counter claim is explicitly provided for and that the only limitation as to accrual
of cause of action is provided for. Therefore, even counter claim filed after
submission of the written statement is permissible and the Court has
discretionary power to consider such belated counter claim. To support his
contention, he has relied upon the judgment reported in (2020) 2 Supreme
Court Cases 394.
10.Heard on both sides and records perused.
11.The question that arises for consideration is:
Whether the plaintiffs can be permitted to withdraw the suit?
12.Order XXIII Rule 1(1) CPC recognises the right of a plaintiff to
abandon his suit or part of his claim. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has
repeatedly held that an unconditional abandonment of a suit ordinarily
constitutes an unqualified right of the plaintiff and the Court cannot ordinarily
compel a plaintiff to continue prosecuting a claim which he does not wish to
__________Page 10 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
pursue. However, the position becomes materially different once a defendant
has raised a valid counter claim. Order VIII Rule 6-A(2) CPC provides that a
counter claim shall have the same effect as a cross suit so as to enable the Court
to pronounce a final judgment both on the original claim and on the counter
claim. Rule 6-A(4) provides that the counter claim shall be treated as a plaint
and governed by the Rules applicable to plaints.
13.Most significantly, Order VIII Rule 6-D provides:
“If in any case in which the defendant sets up a counter
claim, the suit of the plaintiff is stayed, discontinued or
dismissed, the counter claim may nevertheless be
proceeded with.”
14.The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rajni Rani Vs. Khairati Lal, reported
in (2015) 2 SCC 682, has authoritatively explained the effect of these
provisions. The Hon’ble Supreme Court held that a counter claim is in the
nature of a cross suit and, by statutory command, even if the original suit is
dismissed, the counter claim remains alive for adjudication. The object of the
provision is to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and to enable the Court to
adjudicate both claims in the same proceeding.
__________Page 11 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
15.Therefore, the objection of the 1st defendant that the plaintiffs have no
right whatsoever to withdraw the original suit cannot, in the absolute sense, be
accepted. The plaintiffs, as dominus litis, are entitled to abandon their own
claim. But such abandonment cannot operate to extinguish or defeat the
independent counter claim of the 1st defendant. Further, the 1st defendant has not
merely raised a defence in the written statement. He has sought substantive and
affirmative reliefs by way of counter claim, namely, a declaration regarding his
election as President, a declaration concerning the validity of the show cause
notice and a consequential permanent injunction. Such reliefs constitute
independent claims requiring adjudication. Consequently, even if the plaintiffs’
suit is permitted to be withdrawn, the counter claim cannot be treated as having
automatically disappeared. It has to be proceeded with as an independent cross
suit in accordance with Order VIII Rules 6-A to 6-G CPC. Further, the
proposition in Ashok Kumar Kalra Vs. Wing CDR Surendra Agnihotri,
reported in (2020) 2 SCC 394, decided by a three-Judge Bench, concerns Order
VIII Rule 6-A CPC and the stage at which a counter claim may be introduced.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court held that Order VIII Rule 6-A CPC does not
absolutely require
a
counter
claim
to be filed along with the written
__________Page 12 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
statement. A counter claim may, in an appropriate case, be permitted even after
filing of the written statement. Further, it is held that there is no specific time
limit for filing of a counter claim in Rule 6-A. Therefore, the contention made
by the learned Senior Counsel for the plaintiffs that the counter claim is not
filed along with the written statement and the same is filed belatedly cannot be
accepted.
16.It is therefore held that the plaintiffs are entitled to withdraw the
original suit under Order XXIII Rule 1 CPC. However, such withdrawal shall
have no effect whatsoever upon the counter claim of the 1 st defendant. The 1st
defendant shall be entitled to prosecute the same in accordance with law and the
plaintiffs shall be entitled to file their defence to the counter claim, if not
already filed.
17.The Court also makes it clear that this order does not express any
opinion on the validity of the elections held on 16.11.2025, the validity of the
show cause notice dated 10.06.2026. All such questions are left open for
adjudication in the counter claim, subject to its maintainability and the
pleadings and evidence of the parties.
__________Page 13 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
Application No.2842 of 2026
18.The defendants 2 to 10 have filed the above application for
transposing themselves as plaintiffs in the present suit and to permit them to
continue and prosecute the suit. Such application can be entertained only when
the defendant seeking transposition possesses an identical interest to that of the
plaintiff and seeks adjudication of a substantial question against the remaining
defendants.
19.In the present case, the suit has been instituted by the plaintiffs seeking
a declaration that the election allegedly conducted on 16.11.2025 is null and
void and not binding upon the plaintiff’s union. The defendants 2 to 10 in the
suit, admittedly, constituted the Election Committee and Credentials Committee
responsible for conducting the said election held on 16.11.2025. Therefore, the
above defendants are directly interested in sustaining and defending the validity
of the very election which is under challenge in the suit. In such circumstances,
their interest is fundamentally opposed to that of the plaintiff, and by no stretch
of imagination it can be contended that their interest is aligned with that of the
plaintiff so as to warrant their transposition as plaintiffs. Hence, the above
application is liable to be dismissed.
__________Page 14 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
20.In the result,
(a) the memo filed by the plaintiffs seeking unconditional withdrawal of
the suit is recorded and the civil suit is dismissed as withdrawn, without
granting liberty to institute a fresh suit on the same subject matter.
(b) the counter claim shall survive independently and shall proceed with
in accordance with Order VIII Rules 6-A to 6-G CPC.
(c) the plaintiffs shall be entitled to contest the counter claim in
accordance with law.
(d) the Application No.2842 of 2026 is dismissed.
(e) the status quo in O.A.No.625 of 2026 is extended till 27.08.2026.
(f) connected applications in A.No.755 of 2026 and A.No.1029 of 2026
are closed. There shall be no order as to costs.
20-08-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
VSN
__________Page 15 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CS No. 310 of 2025
K.GOVINDARAJAN THILAKAVADI J.
VSN
CS No. 310 of 2025
and
A NO. 3352 OF 2026,A NO. 755 OF 2026,
A NO. 1029 OF 2026,
OA NO. 625 OF 2026,A NO. 2842 OF 2026
20-08-2026
__________Page 16 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review