Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3488 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY SECOND DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION NO: 20103 OF 2025
Between
1. The Director General, Doordarshan, Doordarshan Bhavan, Copernicus Marg,
New Delhi- 110 001
2. The Director General (Administration), Doordarshan Bhavan, 5t11 floor,
Mandi house, New Delhi- 110001.
3. The Director, Doordarshan Kendraa, Ramantapur, Hyderabad.
4. The CEO, Prasar Bharathi, 2nd floor, PTI Building, Sansad Marg, New Delhi1 10 001.
and
5. The Union of lndia, Rep bv its Principal Secretary, Ministry of lnformation
110001.
Broadcasting, Room No 6'55, A Wing Shastri Bhivan, New Delhi-
..PETITIONERS
AND
1. The Central Administrative Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench, at Hyderabad
2. Prem Sagar, C/o. B. Ashok Rao_Age!: unknown, .Makeup. Asst Doordarshan,
H.No. g-16-9glSO lN2, PlotNo. 510, Street No.4, Kamakshipuram,
RamanthaPur, HYderabad.
( Rspondent no.1 is not necessary party in this Petition )
...RESPONDENTS
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an Order/writ in the nature of certiorari, to call for the records of
the orders passed in o.A. NO. 265 of 2016 vide orders dated 13.12.2024 by
central Administrative Tribunal- Hyderabad and set aside the sarne.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under section 151 cPC
in the affidavit fired in support
praying that in the circumstances
of the petition, the High court
stay a' further, proceedings in pursuance
2016 vide o"ders dated 13.'12.2024
Hyderabad perding disposat
COUNSEI fOr thEi PEtitiONErS:
'al
smt.p.KALYAN|
ORDER
265 0f
by central Administrative Tribunal_
No-1: SC FoR .ENTRAL
The Court made the following:
.,.
of orders passed in o.n. *o.
SRI K.L.N. RAGHAVENDRA
counsel for the, Respondent No.2:
L--,.
may be preased to
of the present writ petition.
counser for ther Respondent
stated
REDDY
GOVT
IN THE HIGH COT'RT F1OR THE STATE OF TELI\NGAIIA
AT IIYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSrICE SRI APARESIH KITIUAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION No.2O1O3 OF 2o25l
DATE: 22.OL.2O26
Between
The Director General, Doordarshan
and 4 others
....Petitioners
AND
The Central Administrative Tribunal
and another
..Respondents
ORDER
This Writ Petition assails the order dated L3.L2.2O24
passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) in
O.A.No.265 of 2A16, whereby the Tribunal allowed the said
application and directed the petitioners to regularise the
services of the second respondent with effect from 16.L2.2OO3,
together with all consequential and attendant benefits,
including pay fixation under successive Pay Commissions, grant
of Modified Assured Career Progression (MACP) benefits,
payment of interest at the rate of 9uh per annum in the event of
delay, and costs quantified at Rs.25,OOOl-.
2.
I{eard Sri K.L.N.Raghavendra Reddy, rearned counsel for
the p,:titioners and Smt. p.Kalyani, learned counsel for
respondent No.2 and perused the record.
3-
'l'he brief facts of the case are that the 2"d respondent was
initialllr engaged as a casual Make-up Assistant at Doordarshan
Kendrer, Hyderabad, in the year 1985. Subsequently, pursuant
to direr:tions issued by the courts, a Scheme for Regularisation
of casrral Artists was introduced in the year 1992 (for short the
schemt:J. As per the said scheme, regularisation was
permissible only against a duly sanctioned vacancy and subject
to the casual artist having rendered not less than 120 days of
work irr a calendar year.
4.
'l'he 2"d respondent was found to be other,,r,ise eligible
under the said scheme. However, at the relevant point of time,
no sanctioned vacancy in the other Backward classes (oBC)
category for the post of Make-up Assistant was available at
Doordarshan Kendra, Hyderabad.
5.
Irr the year 2OO3, the petitioners initiated a proposal to
shift a ,sanctioned vacancy from Doordarshan Kendra, Lucknow,
to Hyderabad for the purpose of considering the case of the
second respondent. The said vacancy, hou,ever, was subject
matter of a pending writ petition in w.p.No .2BTs of 2oo1 filed by
another casual employee before the Lucknow Bench of the
\
\
J
Allahabad High Court, which came to be disposed of only in
December,2Ol4.
6.
Thereafter, in a special drive undertaken in the year 2015,
the 2nd respondent \r,as regularised prospectively with effect
from 03.06.2015 along w,ith 232 other similarly placed casual
artists. Aggrieved by the non-grant of
retrospective
regularisation from the year 2OO3 or an earlier date, the 2"d
respondent approached the Tribunal by filing O.A.No.265 of
20t6.
7.
The Tribunal, by the impugned order dated 13.12.2024,
allowed the application and issued directions for retrospective
regularisation with consequential benefits.
8.
Questioning the legality and correctness of the said order,
the petitioners have preferred the present writ petition.
9.
The learned counsel for the petitioners has contended:
i. That the directions issued by the Tribunal for
retrospective regularisation are contrary to the law laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Secretary, Sto,te of Karno,takq. and, others u.
Umadeui and othersr, wherein it has been categorically
held that regularisation cannot be ordered dehors the
constitutional scheme of recruitment and in the absence
of a duly sanctioned vacancy.
'lzooo;4 scc r
I
ii. That the Scheme itself mandated that regularisation
could be effected only against an existing sanctioned
vacancy. According to the petitioners, no sanctioned
vacancy in the OBC category for the post of Make_up
Assistant was available at Doordarshan Kendra,
Hyderabad, till the year 2OL4-IS.
iii That although a proposal was initiated in the year 2o03
to shift a sanctioned vacancy from Doordarshan Kendra,
Lucknow, to Hyderabad for considering the case of the
2nd respondent, the said proposal could not be
implemented on account of the pendency of W.p.No .2g75
of 2OO1 before the Allahabad High Court, which was
beyond the control of the petitioners.
iv. That the Tribunal failecl to consider rhe Office
Memorandum dated 11.06.2010 issued b_y the
Department of Personnel and Training, '*,hich clarifies
that casual service cannot be reckoned for seniority or
other service benefits.
v. That at the time of the 2"d respondent's regurarisation in
the year 2015, the 2nd respondent had furnished a
written declaration undertaking that he would not claim
any benefits for the period prior to the date of
regularisation. Despite the same, the Tribunal
erroneously directed grant of retrospective benefits. The
,
I
E
said declaration is extracted hereunder for ready
il
E
{
:
reference:
t
;;
:l
(iil I also declare that I am wilting to be posted
anywhere in India in the euent ts considered for mg
regular appointment under Regularisation Scheme of
Doordarshan 1992 & 1994 against the uacancies
auailable at the Kendras other than the one ulten I
was tnitiallg engaged as casual and worked prior to
31.12.1991.
(iu) **"*t'
(u) I solemnly declare that I wtll not clatm seniority and
other conseEtent benefits whatsoeuer from the date of
mg initial engagement and all the in-seruice benefits
would accrue to me from the date of mg regular
appointment.
vi. That the direction to grant arrears of pay from the year
2003 amounts to payment of wages lor a period during
which the 2"d respondent was neither appointed against
a regular post nor discharging duties in a regular
capacity, which is impermissible in law.
vii. That the award of costs quantified at t{s.25,O00/- was
assailed as unwarranted, in the absence of any wilful
delay or malafid.e conduct on the part of the petitioners.
10. The learned counsel for the 2,d respondent supported the
impugned order of the Tribunal and contended:
i. That the petitioners themselves had approved the
proposal for shifting of a sanctioned vacancy from
Doordarshan Kendra, Lucknow, to Hyderabad as early as
16.12.2003, which clearly demonstrates that a vacancy
,/
/
/
\^.aS available for the purpose of regularising
the services
of the second resPondent'
T'hat the pendency of the writ petition before the
to
Allahabad High Court was merely cited as a reason
1l
indelinitelypostponeregularisation,andthatthesaidwrit
petition ultimately came to be dismissed' thereby
removing any impediment to regularisation'
,lhat the petitioners had regularised juniors and other
lll
similarly situated casual artists from earlier dates,
while
denying similar treatment to the second respondent'
which amounts to hostile discrimination and violation of
Articlesl4andl6ofthcConstitutionoflndia.
tv
That the 2.d respondent had rendered continuous service
for more than three decades, which' according to learned
counsel, gave rise to a legitimate expectation of
regularisationfromthedatehebecameeligibleunderthe
scheme.
v
Thattheundertakingfurnishedatthetimeof
regularisationin2o|s,,.l,asobtainedunderCompulsion
and cannot operate as a waiver of statutory or
constitutionalrights,andthattheTribunalrightly
exerciseditsequitablejurisdictionandgrantedreliefin
favour of the 2rd respondent in the interest of
\
\
justice.
_1/
11. We have taken note of the respective contentions urged
and the material on record.
Consideration bv this Court
L2. In the present case the Tribunal proceeded on the premise
that the communication dated L6.12.2OO3, whereby a proposal
was initiated to shift a sanctioned vacancy from Doordarshan
Kendra, Lucknow, to Hyderabad, conferred an enforceable right
upon the 2"d respondent to claim regularisation with effect from
the said date. Such an assumption, in our considered view, is
legally unsustainable.
13. The Apex Court in Stqte of Haryana u. Subash
Chander Marutq.ha2 has held that the mere existence of a
vacancy, or even a proposal to create, fill, or transfer a vacancy,
does not vest any indefeasible right in an employee to seek
appointment or regularisation against the same.
L4. [t is pertinent to note that even assuming that a vacancy
was proposed to be shifted in the year 20O3, the record reveals
that the said vacancy was subject to the outcome of pending
litigation before the Allahabad High Court in W.P. No. 2875 of
2OOl. Until the said litigation attained linality in December,
2014, the vacancy remained legally encumbered and
unavailable for regularisation. In such circumstances, no
'gez+1 3 scc 22o
-{
enforr:eable right could have accrued in favour of the 2rd
respo:edent prior to 2015.
15. The Hon'ble Supreme court in tlntad.eui's case (supra 1),
has authoritatively held that regularisation is not a rnode of
appointment andthat courts cannot direct regularisation in the
absence of sanctioned posts or
in derogation of the
constitutional scheme of public employment.
16. It is to be noted that the Scheme itself reflects compliance
',nith the principles enunciated in tlmadeui's case (supra l),
inasnruch as it restricts regularisation strictly to available
sanctioned vacancies. The direction issued by the Tribunal to
grant re trospectivc regularisation from 2oo3, despite the
admitted absence of a clear and unencumbered vacancy at
Hyderabad during the relevant period, effectively results in
creation of a backdated vacancy, which is impermissible in law.
17. Further, a material aspect which has not received due
consileration by the Tribunal is the decraration-cumunde::taking furnished by the 2nd respondent while seeking
regul;rrisation under the special drive undertaken between 2ol2
and 2015. By the said undertaking, the 2"d respondent
expressly acknowledged that his regularisation would be
prostr)ective, that he would be placed junior to all regularly
appointed employees, and that he would not claim seniority or
other consequential benelits from the date of his initial
engagement.
18. Such an undertaking cannot be treated as a mere
formality. Having consciously accepted regularisation on the
said terms and availed the benelit thereof, the 2"d respondent is
estopped from resiling from the conditions voluntarily agreed to
by him. Therefore, the Doctrine of Estoppel squarely applies,
and the Tribunal erred in disregarding the legal effect of the said
undertaking.
19. It is to be noted that the Oflice Memorandum dated
11.06.201O issued by the Department of Personnel and Training
categorically clarifies that casual service shall not be reckoned
for seniority or other service benefits. This position was
reiterated in the regularisation order issued in favour of the 2"4
respondent in 2015. The said portion of the Oflice Memorandum
is extracted hereunder for ready reference:
1. In the matter regarding regularization of casual Artists as
per Regularization Scheme of 1992 & 1994, it has been
clarified bg DOP&T uide letter dated 1lth June, 2010, "that
the seruices rendered bg the Producfion Asststanfs on
casual basis would not count for the purpose of their
senioritg in that grade. Theg will not be entitled to any
consequential benefits and senioritg from the date of initial
booktng as casual artist".
20. Further the Tribunal's direction to grant seniority and
attendant financial benelits from the year 2OO3 runs contrary to
the said clarification, the governing scheme, and the express
terms of regularisation accepted by the 2nd respondent.
l0
2L. While the long and continuous association of the 2nd
respondent with the establishment may evoke sympathetic
consider:rtion, Equitable principles cannot override binding
Constitutional mandates, statutory schemes, and voluntary
undertakings. Legitimate expectation, howsoever genuine,
cannot b,: elevated to a legal right in the absence of compliance
with the iloverning rules and availability of a sanctioned post.
22. In regard to the imposition of costs by the Tribunal on the
ground of administrative delay, it is to be noted that the delay in
rcgularisation was substantially occasioned by pendency of
litigation beyond the control of the petitioners. In the absence of
any finding of mala ftde or deliberate inaction, the imposition of
costs wa:i unwarranted and calls for interference.
23.
Subsequent to the conclusion of hearing, learned counsel
for 2"d rt:spondent, by way of mentioning, placed on record the
order in O.A.Nos.729 of 2018 and T2S of 2ol9s and
judgments rendered in Dharam Singh and others u. State of
U.P and' othersa, Rajkaran Singh and. others u. tlnion of
India and otherss, S.D. Jagaprakash and others a. (Inion of
India a,nd others6, and Centro,l Inland Water Transpor.t,
Cotporation Ltd. a. Brojo Nath Gangulgz which she sought to
3 Central Fdministrative Tribunal,
Cuttack Bench, Cuttack in
O. A. Nos. 2(i O / OO 129 / 20 1 8&T 25 I 20 I 9 dated 26.O9.2025
4 AIR 2025 SC 3897
5' ArR 2024 SC 4321
6 SLP (C) Itlos. 19539- 19540 of 2021
7 AIR 198€, SC 1571
\
\
dated 29.04.2025
lt
rely upon. The said judgments have also been taken into
consideration by this court to ensure a complete and
comprehensive adjudication of the issues involved. In this
regard, this court finds that the reliance placed by the 2,d
respondent on the following cases does not advance the cause of
respondent No.2 employee for the following reasons:
i. In O.A.lVos. 129 of 2Ot8 and 725 of 2Ot9 (supra 3/, the
cAT, cuttack Bench recorded a categorical finding that a
specilic, identilied and unencumbered vacancy stood
created in favour of the applicants pursuant to an office
Memorandum dated 10.11.1995, whereby two sanctioned
posts were expressly diverted "with immediate effect" for
the sole purpose of regularizing the services of the named
individuals. The vacancy, thus, was found to be real,
available, and attributable to the applicants from the said
date, and the prolonged delay in issuing formal orders of
regularization was held to be purely administrative and
unjustified.
In stark contrast, the communication dated
16.12-2oo3 was merely a proposal to shift a vacancy from
Lucknow to Hyderabad. The said vacancy was not
available, being subject to adjudication in w.p.No.2g7s of
2ool pending before the Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad
High court, which constituted a clear legal impediment
t2
until its disposal in December 2014. The resulting delay,
therefore, cannot be attributed to administrative inaction
or arbitrariness, but arose from circumstances beyond the
control of the appellants, there being
final or
exe,lutable order akin to the Oflice Memorandum dated
1O. I 1. 1995 prior to the special drive of 2015.
Further, unlike in O.A.No.l29 of 2018, the present
ma[ter is distinguished by a written undertaking dated
09.11 .2012 furnished by the 2"d respondent, whereby he
unr:quivocally waived any claim to seniority or
cor:.sequential benefits prior to his regular appointment,
giving rise to estoppel against retrospective ciaims; a
determinative factor absent in the Cuttack proceedings.
In the light of the above reasons, the CAT, Cuttack
orcer, which turned on its own peculiar facts, cannot be
tre,eted as a precedent governing the present controversy.
In Dharam Singh (supra 4), the Hon'ble Supreme Court
was concerned with daily-wage employees discharging
perennial and core ministerial functions of a statutory
bo,1y, where the employer itself had repeatedly sought
sarrction of posts acknowledging a continuing
administrative necessity. The Court found the State's
relusal to create posts to be arbitrary, there being no legal
impediment to such creation. The present case stands on
\
\
\
l3
a different footing artogether, as the engagement
Ill
of the 2nd
respondent was under a specific scheme governing
casuar
artists, and the alleged vacancy itself was
legally
encumbered by pending litigation. Thus,
no finding of
arbitrariness in the employer's conduct can
be drawn.
In Rajkaran Singh (supra S) the employees, though
labelled as tempof?ry, were found to be
fulry assimilated
into the regurar governmental structure, drawing
regular
pay scales, increments, promotions and aflowances
decades, thereby warranting parity in substance
form. The 2"d respondent herein, by contrast,
service benefits prior to his regularization
lv
over
remained a
casual artist governed by the Lgg2 scheme,
integration into a regular cadre or parity
for
without
in pay and
in 2015.
The decision in S.D. Jagaprakash (supra
entirely on the mandatory application of
6) turned
Rule 17 of the
ccS (Pension) Rures, Lgr2, which entitled a regurarized
employee to count prior contractual service
The present case does not arise under
for pension.
the said statutory
rule' but under a specific administrative scheme,
further distinguished by the 2nd respondent,s
and is
express
written waiver of retrospective claims. Thus,
the ratio of
Jagapralcash's case cannot be mechanicalry
extended to
.ffi!
\l
override the terms of the scheme
and the binding
un<Iertaking.
v
In centrar Inland' water Transport corporation
Ltd..
(sulrra 7) it dealt with the varidity
of an unconscionabre
sen'ice rule permitting arbitrary
termination without
cause or hearing, and the consequent
Artir:les 12 and 14 of the constitution
and Section 23 of
the Contract Act. Ho,w,ever, the present
relare to termination or oppressive
application of
case does not
contractuar terms, but
concerns service jurisprudence on
regurarization against
sanctioned vacancies and the effect
of a voluntary waiver
of rer:rospective claims. The 2na respondent
subjr:cted to arbitrary termination;
regularized in accordance with the
herein was not
,iil
rather, he was
i
ii
ii
appricabre scheme and
thereafter sought retrospective regularization
conse'quentiar benefits despite the
ri
',
and
absence of a crear
vacancy and in the face of a binding
waiver. Thus, the
said judgment affords no support to
the second
respondent's claim.
24'
Upon carefur consideration, this court
the reliance placed by the 2nd respondent
judgments does not advance
I
is of the view that
I
on the aforesaid
:
!
the cause of the 2.d respondent,
the same ar: distinguishable on facts,
as
i
:
circumstances, and the
\
i
I
t
I
I
I,
j
I
l5
context in which they were rendered; and therefore have no
application to the facts of the present case.
Conclusion
25. For the foregoing reasons, this court is of the considered
view that the order passed by the Tribunar is legally
unsustainable. The Tribunal erred in proceeding on the
assumption that a proposal for transfer of a vacancy confers a
vested right to regularisation. The Tribunal also failed to accord
due weight to the binding undertaking furnished by the 2na
respondent, and issued directions contrary to the settled
principles governing public employment. The impugned
directions are contrary to the applicable regularisation scheme
and the clarifications governing reckoning of casual service and,
therefore, cannot be sustained.
26. Accordingly, this writ petition is allowed setting aside the
order dated 13.12.2024 passed by the Tribunal, in o.A.No.265
of 2016. No order as to costs.
As a sequel, the miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall
stand closed
SD/
//TRUE COPY/'
. JAWAHAR REDDY
ANT REGISTRAR
SECTION OFFICER
I
To,
I
1. The Director General, Doordarshan, Doordarshan Bhavan, copernicus
Marg'
2. The Director General (Administration), Doordarshan Bhavan' 5t11
floor'
New Delhi- 110 001
Mandi house, New Delhi- 1 10001'
3. The Director, Doordarshan Kendraa, Ramantapur' Hyderabad'
a The CtrO Prasar Bharathi, 2nd floor, PTI Building, Sansad Marg' New Delhi-
fi
' ::.
.!,
'4
{
*
:
I
5. The Un on of lndia, Bgp b-V_ its Principal Secretary, Ministry of lnformaton anct
Broadcasting, Room No. 655, A Wing Shastri Bhivan, trtew Oettri- t tOOO1.
6. The cerrtralAdministrative Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench, at Hyderabad
7. One CC: to SC FOR CENTRAL GOVERNIv|ENT [OPUC]
8. one cc to sRl K.L.N RAGHAVENDRA REDDY, Advocate topucl
9. One CC to SRI P.KALYAN|, Advocate [OpUC]
10.Two CD Copies
PMK
BS
v,
I
,
HIGH COURT
DATED:2:.210112026
E
I^
\
(_f
0 6 lllAfr 2026
*
ORDER
WP.No.20103 of 2A2S
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
3 3
c!
I\
*
ParcH
I
,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review