Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax,
Siliguri Commissionerate,
C.R. Buildings, Haren Mukherjee Road,
Hakimpara, Siliguri-734001.
…
Appellant
Versus
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and
Technological Science,
Tadong, Gangtok,
Sikkim-737102.
…
Respondent
WITH
Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax,
Siliguri Commissionerate,
C.R. Buildings, Haren Mukherjee Road,
Hakimpara, Siliguri-734001.
…
Appellant
Versus
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and
Technological Science,
Tadong, Gangtok,
Sikkim-737102.
…
Respondent
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CJ.
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, J.
For the Appellant :
Mr. B.K. Gupta, Advocate.
For the respondent :
Mr. Sameer Rohtagi, Ms. Bhoomija Verma and Mr.
Ugang Lepcha, Advocates.
Date of hearing
:
02.11.2019
Date of judgment
:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(Arup Kumar Goswami, CJ)
Tax Appeal No. 01 of 2017 is preferred under Section 35G of the Central
Excise Act, 1944 (for short, “the Act of 1944”) against the Order No.
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
76311/2016 dated 16.12.2016 passed by the Customs, Excise and Service
Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Eastern Zonal Bench, Kolkata in Appeal
No. ST/75010/2013 whereby, while allowing the appeal with consequential
reliefs, the Order-in-Original No. 11/COM/ST/SLG/12-13 dated 01.10.2012
passed by the Commissioner of Customs, Excise and Service Tax, Siliguri,
hereinafter referred to as Commissioner, was set aside.
2.
Tax Appeal No. 02 of 2017 is an appeal under Section 35G preferred
against the Order No. 75757/2016 dated 14.12.2016 passed by the CESTAT,
Eastern Zonal Bench, Kolkata in Appeal No. ST/76840/2016 whereby, while
allowing the appeal with consequential reliefs, the Order-in-Original No.
22/COMM/ST/SLG/16-17 dated 08.09.2016 passed by the Commissioner
was set aside.
3.
In both the appeals parties are same. The respondent in the appeals
had raised a preliminary objection to the maintainability of both the appeals
under Section 35G of the Act of 1944 by filing separate preliminary objections
to that effect on 20.09.2017.
4.
We have heard Mr. B.K. Gupta, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant in both the appeals and Mr. Sameer Rohtagi, learned counsel, who
also appear for the respondent in both the appeals on the maintainability of
the appeals under Section 35G of the Act of 1944.
5.
The respondent is a University set up under the Sikkim Manipal
University of Health, Medical and Technological Science Act, 1995, enacted
by the Sikkim State Legislature.
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
6.
For the purpose of proper appreciation we will take note of the basic
facts that gave rise to both the appeals as hereunder:
Tax Appeal No. 01 of 2017
7.
A show cause-cum-demand notice dated 07.03.2012 was issued to
Sikkim Manipal University, for short, „SMU‟, by the Commissioner, on the
allegation that SMU was found engaged in providing “franchise service” as
defined in sub-clause (zze) of clause (105) of Section 65 of the Finance Act,
1994 (for short, “the Act of 1994”) to different Learning Centres in
contravention of the provisions of Sections 66, 67, 68, 69 and 70 of the Act of
1994 read with Rules 4, 6 and 7 of Service Tax Rules, 1994, as amended, (for
short, “the Rules of 1994”) inasmuch as it failed to obtain service tax
registration for providing franchise service, which is a taxable service, and it
failed to discharge its due service tax liability inclusive of Education Cess and
Secondary & Higher Education Cess amounting to Rs.1,13,06,993/- only for
the period from April 2007 to February 2011.
8.
Though no reply was submitted by the respondent, the representative of
the respondent had availed the opportunity of personal hearing and had also
submitted written submissions.
9.
The Commissioner recorded a finding in the Order-in-Original dated
01.10.2012 that more than 860 Learning Centres were in operation as on
24.02.2011. SMU had collected registration fee, accreditation fee, affiliation
fee and inspection fee from different Learning Centres spread throughout the
country. It is also recorded that there was a relationship of „franchisor‟ and
„franchisee‟ in between SMU as „franchisor‟ and Learning Centres as
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
„franchisee‟ for the purpose of the Act of 1994. It was recorded that nonpayment of service tax did not appear to be bona fide and facts were
suppressed from the Department by not submitting statutory returns.
Though the jurisdictional Service Tax Authority in the show cause-cumdemand notice had taken the amount received by SMU from Learned Centres
as accreditation fee/registration and inspection fee as taxable value and had
indicated service tax amount as Rs.1,13,06,993/-, on recalculation, the
Commissioner determined the total amount of service tax inclusive of
Education
Cess
and
Secondary
&
Higher
Education
Cess
to
be
Rs.1,01,51,705/-. Consequently, the Commissioner at paragraph 5.1 of the
Order-in-Original ordered as follows:
“5.1 In view of the above discussion and findings, I do hereby
order the following.
[A]
I confirm the demand of Service Tax including
Education Cess and Secondary & Higher Education Cess, to the
tune of Rs.1,01,51,705/- (Rupees one crore one lakh fifty one
thousand seven hundred five) only from the said noticee under
Section 73 (1) of the Finance Act, 1994.
[B]
Applicable interest for the relevant period is to be paid
by the said noticee in terms of Section 75 of the Finance Act,
1994.
[C]
I impose penalty of Rs.1,01,51,705/- (Rupees one crore
one lakh fifty one thousand seven hundred five) only on the said
noticee in terms of Section 78 of the Finance Act, 1994.”
10.
The CESTAT accepted the argument of the respondent that when the fee
charged by SMU and shared with Learning Centres is not subject to service
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
tax, amount in respect of accreditation fee cannot be brought under the net of
service tax.
Tax Appeal No. 02 of 2017
11.
A show cause-cum-demand notice dated 08.04.2016 was issued stating
that SMU had been collecting alumni fees along with admission fee at the
time of registration from their students and it had violated the provisions of
Section 68, 69 and 70 of the Act of 1994 read with Rules 4, 6 and 7 of the
Rules of 1994 inasmuch as SMU failed to obtain service tax registration and
it failed to pay service tax amounting to Rs.2,25,64,753/- for the period from
2011-12 to 2015-16 (up to September 2015) in respect of alumni fee so
collected by them which was taxable to service tax under the category of
„Business Auxiliary Services‟ for the period up to 30.06.2012 and thereafter
under „Other than Negative Services‟ for the period from 01.07.2012 under
Section 66B of the Act of 1994.
12.
The
respondent submitted reply and the
representative
of
the
respondent had availed the opportunity of personal hearing and had also
submitted written submissions.
13.
The Commissioner recorded a finding in the Order-in-Original dated
08.09.2016 that activity of the alumni services provided by SMU is not in
relation to furtherance of education and the same is for the benefit of the
former students and not for the existing students and accordingly, held that
taxability of alumni fees prior to 01.07.2012 will fall under sub-clause (6) of
the definition of „Business Auxiliary Services‟ and post 01.07.2012 under
„Other than Negative Service‟. It was also recorded that there was suppression
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
of facts with intention to evade payment of service tax. Consequently, the
Commissioner at paragraph 7 of the Order-in-Original ordered as follows:
“7.
Considering all the facts of the case, I pass the following
order:
i)
I confirm the demand of Service Tax and Cess
amounting to Rs.2,25,64,753.00 (Rupees two crores twenty five
lakhs sixty-four thousand seven hundred and fifty three) only, for
the period from 2011-12 to 2015-16 (upto September 2015), as
detailed in calculation sheet marked as Annexure-A enclosed with
the Show cause Notice, in terms of proviso to sub-section (1) of
Section 73(1) of the Finance Act 1994; read with sub-section(2) of
Section 73 of the Finance Act, 1994.
ii)
Interest at the appropriate rate as per Section 75 of the
said Act as applicable during the material period for delayed
payment of Service Tax including Education Cess and Secondary
& Higher Education Cess upon the entire demand as referred
above is also to be paid.
iii)
I impose penalty equal to the unpaid duty amount of
Rs.2,25,64,753.00 (Rupees two crores twenty five lakhs sixty-four
thousand seven hundred and fifty three) only, under Section 78 of
the said Act for failure to pay Service Tax in accordance with
provision 68 of the said Act. However, the Noticee can avail the
option of paying only 25% of such amount i.e. Rs.56,41,188.00
(Rupees fifty six lakhs forty one thousand one hundred and
eighty- eight) only, as „penalty‟, subject to fulfillment of the
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
conditions as prescribed under the 2nd and 3rd Proviso of Section
78(1) of the Finance Act, 1994.
iv)
I impose a penalty of Rs.10,000.00 (Rupees ten
thousand) only under Section 77(1)(a) of the said Act for failure to
take registration under the category of Business Auxiliary service
as provided under Section 69 of the said Act.
v)
I impose a penalty of Rs.10,000.00 (Rupees ten
thousand) only under Section 70 of the said Act read with Rule 7C
of the Service Tax Rules, 1994; for failure to submit statutory
returns in prescribed manner under the category of Business
Auxiliary Service.”
14.
The CESTAT recorded a finding that SMU had collected some money in
the name of alumni fee but without providing any service and so, when no
service is provided then applicability of service tax is not in question.
15.
Mr. B.K. Gupta, learned counsel for the appellant submits that
taxability of accreditation fee is not an issue in Tax Appeal No. 01 of 2017. It
is further submitted that CESTAT was wholly wrong in holding that the
decision rendered by CESTAT, New Delhi in the case of Punjab Technical
University vs. Commissioner of Central Excise and Service Tax, reported
in MANU/CE/ 0655/2015, is not applicable to the facts of Tax Appeal No. 01
of 2017 though the ratio of the above case applies in all fours to the facts of
the case. CESTAT did not pass any order regarding the rate or value of the
service, or its classification regarding its taxability, he contends. Since orders
of the CESTAT in both the appeals is not in relation to the determination of
any question having a relation to the rate of duty for service tax for the
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
purpose of assessment, the appeals are maintainable before this Court. He
has placed reliance on the judgment dated 05.09.2019 of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of Customs, Bangalore-1 vs.
M/s Motorola India Ltd., passed in Civil Appeal No.10083 of 2011.
16.
Mr. Sameer Rohtagi, learned counsel for the respondent submits that
having regard to the Orders-in-Original and the Orders passed by the
CESTAT, it is evident that determination of taxability of accreditation fee as
received by the respondent University as well as alumni fee is an issue in the
appeals. Substantial questions of law, as formulated by the appellant in both
the appeals, also bear out the same. It is submitted that what is meant by the
term “determination of any question having a relation to the rate of duty of
excise or to the value of goods for the purposes of assessment” had fallen for
consideration before the High Court of Delhi in the case of Commissioner of
Service Tax vs. Ernst & Young Pvt. Ltd., reported in MANU/DE/0539/2014
and the High Court of Delhi had held that determination of any question
relating to rate of tax would directly and proximately involve the question as
to whether the activity falls within the charging section and service tax is
leviable on the said activity. It is submitted that after the aforesaid judgment
was delivered on 25.02.2014, sub-Section (2) of Section 35L was inserted by
the Finance (No.2) Act, 2014 making it clear that determination of any
question having a relation to the rate of duty shall include the determination
of taxability or excisability of the goods or service for the purpose of
assessment and therefore, these appeals are not maintainable before this
Court. He also places reliance in the case of Navin Chemicals Mfg. and
Trading
Co.
Ltd.
vs.
Collector
of
Customs,
reported
in
MANU/
SC/0571/1993. It is also submitted by Mr. Rohtagi that the Special Leave
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
Petition filed by the Revenue against the decision in Ernst & Young Pvt. Ltd.
(supra) was dismissed as withdrawn by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court by an
order dated 19.01.2015.
17.
We have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties
and have perused the material on record.
18.
Whether or not the CESTAT was correct in not following the decision
rendered by CESTAT, Principal Bench, New Delhi, in Punjab Technical
University (supra) is a question that will take us to examine the issue on
merits.
When
we
are
considering
a
preliminary
objection
regarding
maintainability of the appeals before this Court, we deem it appropriate not to
examine the correctness or otherwise of the order of the CESTAT dated
16.12.2016 at this stage.
19.
Section 83 of the Finance Act, 1994 provides, amongst others, that
Section 35G and Section 35L of the Act of 1944, as in force from time to time,
shall apply, so far as may be, in relation to service tax as they apply in
relation to a duty of excise and therefore, Section 35G as well as 35L are
applicable for the purpose of preferring an appeal in relation to service tax.
20.
The key to the question posed with regard to maintainability of the
appeals lies on the meaning to be ascribed to the expression „determination of
any question having a relation to the rate of duty of excise or to the value of
goods for purposes of assessment‟, which expression finds place in Section
35G as well as in Section 35L of the Act of 1944.
21.
Section 35G (1) of the Act of 1944, which is relevant for our purpose, is
reproduced herein below:
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
“35G. Appeal to High Court. - (1) An appeal shall lie to the High
Court from every order passed in appeal by the Appellate Tribunal
on or after the 1st day of July, 2003 (not being an order relating,
among other things, to the determination of any question having a
relation to the rate of duty of excise or to the value of goods for
purposes of assessment), if the High Court is satisfied that the
case involves a substantial question of law.”
(emphasis supplied by us)
22.
Section 35G provides that an appeal shall lie to the High Court from
every order passed in appeal by the Appellate Tribunal on or after the 1st day
of July, 2003 except an order relating, among other things, to determination
of any question having a relation to the rate of duty of excise or to the value of
goods for the purpose of assessment, if the High Court is satisfied that the
case involves a substantial question of law. Thus, an appeal against an order
relating to determination of any question having a relation to the duty of
excise or to the value of goods for the purpose of assessment will not be
maintainable before the High Court.
23.
It will also be relevant to take note of Section 35L of the Act of 1944 and
therefore, the same is reproduced hereunder for better appreciation.
“35L. Appeal to Supreme Court.—An appeal shall lie to the
Supreme Court from—
(a)
any judgment of the High Court delivered—
(i)
in an appeal made under section 35G; or
(ii)
on a reference made under section 35G by the
Appellate Tribunal before the 1st day of July, 2003;
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
(iii)
on a reference made under section 35H,
in any case which, on its own motion or on an oral
application made by or on behalf of the party
aggrieved, immediately after passing of the judgment,
the High Court certifies to be a fit one for appeal to the
Supreme Court; or
(b)
any order passed before the establishment of the National
Tax Tribunal] by the Appellate Tribunal relating, among
other things, to the determination of any question having a
relation to the rate of duty of excise or to the value of goods
for purposes of assessment.
(emphasis supplied by us)
(2)
For the purpose of this Chapter, the determination of any
question having a relation to the rate of duty shall include the
determination of taxability or excisability of goods for the purpose
of assessment.”
24.
A perusal of Section 35L (b) goes to show that an appeal against any
order passed by the CESTAT relating, among other things, to the
determination of any question having a relation to the rate of duty of excise or
to the value of goods for purposes of assessment shall lie directly to the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court. Such order, as is noticed earlier, is not made
appellable to the High Court, as Section 35G specifically excludes such an
order from being a subject matter of an appeal before the High Court.
25.
In Navin Chemicals Mfg. and Trading Co. Ltd. (supra), the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court observed that the phrase “relation to” is, ordinarily of wide
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
import but in the context of its use in the expression in Section 129-C of the
Customs Act, 1962, it must be read as meaning a direct and proximate
relationship to the rate of duty and to the value of goods for the purpose of
assessment. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court, while considering Section 129-D of
the Customs Act, 1962, at paragraph 11, had observed as follows:
“11. It will be seen that Sub-section 5 uses the said expression
'determination of any question having a relation to the rate of duty or to
the value of goods for the purposes of assessment' and the Explanation
thereto provides a definition of it 'for the purposes of this sub-section'. The
Explanation says that the expression includes the determination of a
question relating to the rate of duty; to the valuation of goods for purposes
of assessment; to the classification of goods under the Tariff and whether
or not they are covered by an exemption notification; and whether the
value of goods for purposes of assessment should be enhanced or
reduced having regard to certain matters that the said Act provides for.
Although this Explanation expressly confines the definition of the said
expression to Sub-section 5 of Section 129-D, it is proper that the said
expression used in the other parts of the said Act should be interpreted
similarly. The statutory definition accords with the meaning we have
given to the said expression above. Questions relating to the rate of duty
and to the value of goods for purposes of assessment are questions that
squarely fall within the meaning of the said expression. A dispute as to
the classification of goods and as to whether or not they are covered by
an exemption notification relates directly and proximately to the rate of
duty applicable thereto for purposes of assessment. Whether the value of
goods for purposes of assessment is required to be increased or
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
decreased is a question that relates directly and proximately to the value
of goods for purposes of assessment. The statutory definition of the said
expression indicates that it has to be read to limit its application to cases
where, for the purposes of assessment, questions arise directly and
proximately as to the rate of duty or the value of the goods.”
26.
A perusal of the judgment of the High Court of Delhi in Ernst & Young
Pvt. Ltd. (supra) goes to show that a contention was advanced by the
Revenue that the expression „rate of duty‟ or „value of service‟ should be
construed in a narrow manner limiting it to the rate of duty payable on the
service chargeable to tax or the valuation of the service which is chargeable to
tax and that the same will not encompass the question as to whether the
activity is a taxable service under the charging section. It was also contended
that when the question relates to excisability or levy of tax, the same does not
amount to a dispute about the rate of tax. The High Court of Delhi held that
determination of any question relating to rate of tax would necessarily directly
and proximately involve the question, which is, whether the activity falls
within the charging section and service tax is leviable on the said activity. It
was further held that the said determination is integral and an important
injunct to the question of rate of tax. In case service tax is not to be levied or
imposed and cannot be imposed under the charging section, no tax would be
payable. Accordingly, it was held the words „rate of tax‟ in relation to rate of
tax would include the question whether or not the activity is excisable to tax
under a particular or specific provision.
27.
In the Memo of Appeal of Tax Appeal No. 01 of 2017, the appellant has,
amongst others, framed the following substantial questions of law:
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
“A.
xxxxxxxxxxxxx
B.
Whether the respondent is liable to pay service tax or not?
C.
xxxxxxxxxxxxx”
By filing an affidavit dated 12.03.2018, the appellant has framed the
following substantial questions of law, which are as follows:
“I.
Whether the respondent University is liable to pay service
tax on “Accreditation Fees” received by it from its Learning
Centres under Sections 65(47) & (48) of Finance Act, 1994.
II.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx.”
Subsequently, another affidavit dated 26.08.2019 was filed framing the
following substantial questions of law:
“(I)
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
(II)
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
(III)
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
(IV)
Whether the Hon‟ble Tribunal is justified in setting aside the
Order-in-Original without appreciating the fact that service
rendered by the party falls under the purview of Sub Section
(47) and (48) of Section 65 of the Finance Act 1994 as per
which they were liable to pay service tax and were also
required to get registered for paying tax and filing returns?
(V)
28.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx”
Similarly, in Tax Appeal No. 02 of 2017, the appellant has framed the
following substantial questions of law:
“A.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
B.
Whether M/s Sikkim Manipal University has failed to obtain
Service Tax Registration and failed to pay Service Tax
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
amounting to Rs.2,25,64,753/- only for the period from
2011-12 to 2015-16 (up to September 2015) in respect of
alumni fee collected by them at the time of registration from
their students which was taxable to Service Tax under the
category of “Business Auxiliary Services” for the period up to
30.06.2012 and thereafter under “Other than Negative
Services” for the period from 01.07.2012 under Section 66B
of the Finance Act, 1994.
C.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx”
Subsequently, another affidavit dated 12.03.2018 was filed framing the
following substantial questions of law:
“I.
Whether the respondent University is liable to pay service
tax on “Alumni Fees” received by it from its students under
Section 65(19) & Section 66 D (i) of Finance Act, 1994.
II.
29.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx”
Having regard to the nature of the Orders-in-Original as well as the
orders of CESTAT, it is evident that determination of the question as to
whether service tax demand on the accreditation fees received by the
respondent as also on alumni fees collected can stand to be levied by the
Department or not arise in these appeals. The substantial questions of law
framed by the appellant, as noted herein above, also demonstrate that the
question as to whether the respondent is liable to pay service tax on
accreditation fee and alumni fee as collected by SMU very much arises in the
appeals.
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
30.
In M/s Motorola India Ltd. (supra), the question that arose for
consideration was as to whether an appeal from CESTAT, involving an issue
regarding violation of conditions contained in the customs exemption
notification would lie before the High Court under the provisions of Section
130 of the Customs Act, 1962 or to the Hon‟ble Supreme Court under the
provisions of Section 130E of the Customs Act, 1962. It is noticeable that
Section 130E does not have a provision like Section 35L (2) of the Act of
1944.
31.
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court, on the facts of the case, held that neither
any question with regard to determination of rate of duty nor a question
relating to valuation of goods for the purpose of assessment arose in the case
and that the only question that had arisen was as to whether the assessee
had breached conditions which are imposed by the notification for getting
exemption from payment of customs duty or not.
32.
While respectfully following the decision of High Court of Delhi in Ernst
& Young Pvt. Ltd. (supra), we also note that Sub-Section (2) of Section 35L,
which was inserted by the Finance (No.2) Act, 2014 with effect from
06.08.2014, makes it abundantly clear that the determination of any
question having relation to the rate of duty shall include determination of
taxability or excisability of goods for the purpose of assessment.
33.
In view of our discussions above, we are of the considered opinion that
these appeals before this Court are not maintainable under Section 35G of
the Act of 1944.
Tax App. No. 01 of 2017 with Tax App. No. 02 of 2017
The Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Siliguri
vs.
Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical and Technological Science.
34.
Preliminary objection of the respondent having been upheld, the
appeals are disposed of as not maintainable.
Judge
Approved for Reporting: Yes
jk/
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review