Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:SHC:24
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON‟BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.10 of 2025
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company Limited
versus
Respondents :
Dal Bahadur Thapa and Others
Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Rahul Rathi, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. Bhim Shankar Pradhan, Advocate and Mr. Nawang Tenzing
Bhutia, Advocate for the Respondents No.1, 3, 4 and 5.
Mr. Tarun Choudhary, Advocate for Respondents No.6 and 7 (through
VC).
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of hearing
:
06-04-2026
Date of pronouncement
:
06-04-2026
Judgment uploaded
:
06-04-2026
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Appellant impugns the Judgment, dated 30-09-2023,
of the Learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Namchi, Sikkim
(hereinafter, “MACT”), in MACT Case No.11 of 2020 (Dal Bahadur
Thapa and Others vs. The Branch Manager, Cholamandalam MS
General Insurance Co. Ltd. and Others), whereby the Appellant was
directed to pay a sum of ₹ 48,10,000/- (Rupees forty-eight lakhs and
ten thousand) only, with interest @ 9% to the Claimants, from the
date of filing of the Claim Petition, i.e., 28-12-2020.
2.
In brief, the case of the Claimants (Respondents No.1, 2,
3, 4 and 5 herein) is that the deceased Sagar Thapa, son of the
Respondents No.1 and 2 and the sibling of the Respondents No.3, 4
and 5, was driving a motorcycle at “Gangtok road”, from Ravangla,
2026:SHC:24
MAC App No.10 of 2025
The Branch Manager, Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company Limited
vs. Dal Bahadur Thapa and Others
South Sikkim. As the deceased rider slowed down his motorcycle on
account of the light traffic on the said road, the motorcycle was
struck from behind by a loaded Tipper truck, bearing registration
no.SK 04 D 0631, driven by the Respondent No.7, Krishna Pradhan.
It is alleged that the driver of the said truck was not only driving in a
rash and negligent manner, but was in a drunken state, while driving
the truck towards Namchi Bazaar. The truck dragged both the driver
of the motorcycle and the pillion rider to about 50 feet from the place
where the accident occurred, resulting in the death of the rider and
grievous injuries to the pillion rider.
The rider of the motorcycle, as
per the Respondents, was 29 years old at the time of the accident,
working as an ad hoc Post Graduate teacher at Victoria Cross Ganju
Lama Ravangla, Senior Secondary School, South Sikkim, earning a
monthly salary of ₹ 25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) only. All
the Claimants were solely dependent on the income of the deceased.
After the Appeal was filed before this Court, the name of
3.
the
Respondent No.2
was struck off from the array of the
Respondents, in terms of the Order dated 16-04-2025, as she had
passed away.
4.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant contends that firstly
the driver of the motorcycle did not have the requisite driving licence,
and was therefore not eligible to be drive. Secondly, the driver of the
offending truck was found to be in a drunken state as has been
proved by Exbt CW-12 relied on by the Respondents before the
MACT.
Hence, the Respondents are not at all entitled to the
compensation computed, in view of the foregoing shortcomings.
Even if the Respondents are found entitled to the compensation, the
Respondent No.6, the owner of the truck, would be liable to pay it as
2026:SHC:24
MAC App No.10 of 2025
The Branch Manager, Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company Limited
vs. Dal Bahadur Thapa and Others
the truck was being driven in breach of the conditions of the policy as
alcohol was found in the blood of the driver as proved by the forensic
report, Exbt CW-12.
5.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.1, 3, 4 and 5
submitted that there is sufficient evidence, i.e., Exbt CW-15, to show
that the victim was earning a monthly income of ₹ 25,000/- (Rupees
twenty five thousand) only. Exbt CW-12, which was not decimated
during the cross-examination by the Appellant, indicates that alcohol
was detected in the blood of the truck driver. This establishes that
he was in a drunken state and was also driving his vehicle rashly and
negligently. That, admittedly the driving licence of the deceased was
not furnished however this cannot be confused with the rash driving
of the driver to deprive the Respondents of compensation. To fortify
his submissions, reliance was placed on the decisions of the Supreme
Court in Sudhir Kumar Rana vs. Surinder Singh and Others1, where, in
similar circumstances the Supreme Court was of the view that if the
driver in accident was not driving rashly and negligently, the Court
failed to see as to how only because he was not having a licence, he
could be held to be guilty of contributory negligence.
Hence, the
compensation awarded to the said driver in accident was allowed by
the Supreme Court. This case was relied on again by the Supreme
Court in Dinesh Kumar J. alias Dinesh J. vs. National Insurance Company
Limited and Others .
That, the parents of the deceased were
dependant on the income of the deceased as also his sibling, who
were students at the time of the accident.
Judgment warrants no interference.
(2008) 12 SCC 436
(2018) 1 SCC 750
Hence, the impugned
2026:SHC:24
MAC App No.10 of 2025
The Branch Manager, Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company Limited
Learned
6.
Counsel
for
the
vs. Dal Bahadur Thapa and Others
Respondents
No.6
and
contended that as the owner of the vehicle had taken a driving test of
the driver and the driver was found to be competent to drive the
vehicle, as held by the Supreme Court in a plethora of Judgments,
the owner is not required to make a roving enquiry with regard to the
licence of the driver if he shows it to the owner and the owner finds it
valid.
As the vehicle was insured with the Appellant Insurance
Company, it is the Appellant who was liable to pay the compensation,
if any.
7.
I have heard Learned Counsel for the parties. I have also
perused the impugned Judgment, the pleadings, evidence and all
documents on record.
8.
Learned MACT after due consideration of the Claimants‟
case vide the impugned Judgment granted compensation as reflected
hereinabove.
9.
In a similar set of facts and circumstances, the Supreme
Court in Sudhir Kumar Rana (supra) held as follows;
“9. If a person drives a vehicle without a licence,
he commits an offence. The same, by itself, in our
opinion, may not lead to a finding of negligence as
regards the accident. It has been held by the courts
below that it was the driver of the mini truck who was
driving rashly and negligently. It is one thing to say that
the appellant was not possessing any licence but no
finding of fact has been arrived at that he was driving
the two-wheeler rashly and negligently. If he was not
driving rashly and negligently which contributed to the
accident, we fail to see as to how, only because he was
not having a licence, he would be held to be guilty of
contributory negligence.
10. The matter might have been different if by
reason of his rash and negligent driving, the accident
had taken place.”
This was followed by the Supreme Court in the latter decision of
Dinesh Kumar (supra).
2026:SHC:24
MAC App No.10 of 2025
The Branch Manager, Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company Limited
10.
vs. Dal Bahadur Thapa and Others
Consequently, bearing in mind the aforementioned views
of the Supreme Court, it stands to reason that although the rider of
the motorcycle had no licence, he was admittedly not the person
driving rashly or negligently nor was he under the influence of any
mind altering substance. He had slowed down his motorcycle on
account of the traffic. It was the truck which was driven by
Respondent No.7 in a rash and negligent manner as evidently he was
under the influence of alcohol. The truck struck the motorcycle from
behind and dragged the deceased and the pillion rider for a distance
of 50 feet leading to the death of the deceased and injuries to the
pillion rider.
In fine, it concludes that the driver of the motorcycle
was not responsible for the accident which snuffed out his life.
11.
Consequently,
I
find
no
error
compensation by the Learned MACT.
in
the
granting
of
It was argued by Learned
Counsel for the Appellant that the deduction ought to be 50% in
consideration of the expenses which the deceased would have
incurred towards maintaining himself had he been alive. In Sarla
Verma (Smt) and Others vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another
the
Supreme Court has held that the deduction would be 1/4th where the
dependents of the deceased are four to six. Considering the number
of dependents on the deceased, the deduction would be 1/4th instead
of 1/3rd. Further, the argument of Learned Counsel for the Appellant
that the owner is vicariously liable to pay the compensation has no
legs to stand in view of the fact that the vehicle was duly insured with
the Appellant Insurance Company.
12.
In
conclusion,
the
total
compensation
for
Respondents No.1, 3, 4 and 5 is computed accordingly as follows;
(2009) 6 SCC 121
the
2026:SHC:24
MAC App No.10 of 2025
The Branch Manager, Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company Limited
vs. Dal Bahadur Thapa and Others
₹
3,00,000.00
₹
1,20,000.00
₹
4,20,000.00
₹
1,05,000.00
Net yearly income
₹
3,15,000.00
Multiplier to be adopted „17‟ (₹ 3,15,000/- x 17)
[The age of the deceased at the time of death was „29‟ and
the relevant multiplier in terms of Paragraph 42 of Sarla
Verma (supra) is „17‟]
₹
53,55,000.00
Add Funeral Expenses
(+)
[in terms of Paragraphs 52 & 59.8 of Pranay Sethi (supra),
10% enhanced every three years, hence 10% of
₹ 15,000/- = ₹ 1,500/- + ₹ 15,000/- = ₹ 16,500/and 10% of ₹ 16,500/- = ₹ 1,650/- + ₹ 16,500/- =
₹ 18,150/-, as the accident occurred on 25-01-2019]
₹
18,150.00
Add Loss of Estate
(+)
[in terms of Paragraph 52 & 59.8 of Pranay Sethi (supra),
10% enhanced every three years, hence 10% of ₹ 15,000/= ₹ 1,500/- + ₹ 15,000/- = ₹ 16,500/- and 10% of
₹ 16,500/- = ₹ 1,650/- + ₹ 16,500/- = ₹ 18,150/-, as the
accident occurred on 25-01-2019]
₹
18,150.00
Add Loss of Filial Consortium
(+)
[₹ 40,000/- each payable to Respondents No.1, 3, 4 and 5
(Claimants), in terms of Paragraph 21.3 and 24 of Magma
General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Nanu Ram : (2018) 18 SCC
130 and in terms of Paragraphs 52 & 59.8 of Pranay Sethi
(supra), 10% enhanced every three years, hence 10% of
₹ 1,60,000/- = ₹ 16,000/- + ₹ 1,60,000/- = ₹ 1,76,000/and 10% of ₹ 1,76,000/- = ₹ 17,600/- + ₹ 1,76,000/- =
₹ 1,93,600/-, as the accident occurred on 25-01-2019]
₹
1,93,600.00
Annual income of the deceased
Add 40% of ₹ 3,00,000/- as Future Prospects
[in terms of Paragraph 59.4 of National Insurance
Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and Others :
(2017) 16 SCC 680]
(+)
Less 1/4 of ₹ 4,20,000/[in terms of Paragraph 30 of Sarla Verma (supra)]
(-)
th
Total = ₹ 55,84,900.00
(Rupees fifty five lakhs, eighty four thousand and nine hundred) only.
13.
The impugned Judgment of the Learned MACT is upheld,
however the award is modified as stated hereinabove.
14.
The Appellant-Insurance Company is directed to pay the
above compensation amount of ₹ 55,84,900/- (Rupees fifty five lakhs,
eighty four thousand and nine hundred) only, with interest @ 9% per
annum, to the Respondent-Claimants within one month from today,
failing which, it shall pay simple interest @ 12% per annum, from the
date of filing of the Claim Petition, i.e., 28-12-2020, till full
realisation.
15.
Amounts, if any, already paid by the Appellant-Insurance
Company to the Respondents-Claimants, shall be duly deducted from
the compensation granted today.
2026:SHC:24
MAC App No.10 of 2025
The Branch Manager, Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company Limited
vs. Dal Bahadur Thapa and Others
16.
Appeal disposed of accordingly.
17.
No order as to costs.
18.
Copy of this Judgment along with original records, if any,
be remitted forthwith to the Learned MACT.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
06-04-2026
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds/sdl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review