Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CNR No. SKHC01-000205-2024
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. MUHAMED MUSTAQUE,
CHIEF JUSTICE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------MAC App No.26 of 2024
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited,
Near Police Headquarters,
NH 10, Gangtok, Sikkim.
... Appellant
versus
1.
Hasmukh Pannalal Punamiya,
S/o Late Pannalal Punamiya,
Aged about 50 years
2.
Mahipal Pannalal Punamiya,
S/o Late Pannalal Punamiya,
Aged about 49 years
3.
Chitralekha Jitendra Jain,
D/o Late Pannalal Punamiya,
Aged about 43 years
All are permanent resident of
Thane West, Maharashtra, 400601.
4.
Kanahiya Singh,
R/o Dikchu,
Mangan, Sikkim.
...Respondents
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Madan Kumar Sundas, Ms. Anita Limboo and Ms. Priyanka Subba,
Advocates for the Appellant.
Mr. Rahul Rathi and Ms. Rupal Agarwal, Advocates for the Respondent
Nos.1 to 3.
Mr. Nirmal Thapa, Advocate on behalf of Mr. Sushant Subba, Advocate
for the Respondent No.4.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Judgment Reserved on
: 06.08.2026
Judgment Pronounced on
: 10.08.2026
Judgment Uploaded on
: 10.08.2026
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.26 of 2024
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs. Hasmukh Pannalal Punamiya and Others
JUDGMENT
(A. Muhamed Mustaque, C.J.)
1.
This appeal was preferred by the insurer, National Insurance
Company Limited. The Appellant is aggrieved by a Judgment of the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Gangtok, dated 12-08-2024, in a Claim
Petition filed under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
2.
By the impugned judgment, the Learned Tribunal ordered the
insurer to pay compensation of ₹ 85,59,880/- (Rupees eighty-five lakhs,
fifty-nine thousand, eight hundred and eighty only) together with
interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of filing of the claim
petition to the Respondents-Claimants.
3.
The Respondent-Claimants are siblings who claimed compensation
as dependents of their sister-in-law.
4.
The facts in brief, necessary for the disposal of this Appeal, are
that the deceased sister-in-law, Toran Suresh Punamiya, was married to
the younger brother of the Claimants, namely, Suresh Punamiya. Two
children were born out of wedlock. Claimants’ brother, Suresh Punamiya
and his wife, Toran Suresh Punamiya, along with two minor children,
who were the permanent residents of Maharashtra, had visited Sikkim
as tourists. During their visit, they hired a vehicle which was insured by
the Appellant-Insurer. It appears that while travelling to Lachung, North
Sikkim, the vehicle met with an accident and fell approximately 700 feet
off the cliff, resulting in their instantaneous death.
5.
The Claimants thereafter instituted claim proceedings seeking
compensation for the loss. The Claimants, by separate proceedings,
were found entitled to the compensation – consequent upon the death
of their brother and his two minor children. It was submitted at the Bar
Page 2
MAC App. No.26 of 2024
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs. Hasmukh Pannalal Punamiya and Others
that the said claim for compensation was allowed but is presently
challenged before the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
6.
The Insurer has preferred the present Appeal essentially on two
grounds. Firstly, that the Claimants are not dependent on the income of
the
deceased
sister-in-law
and
therefore,
the
Tribunal
erred
in
calculating compensation under the head of loss of dependency. That
the Claimants are grown-up adults and the claims based on being
dependent is a far-fetched fact, and all the Claimants are independent
and possessed of their own sources of income. Secondly, that the
business run by the deceased sister-in-law along with her husband was
inherited by the Claimants after their demise and therefore there was no
actual loss of dependency and that such claim has no foundation.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant has placed reliance upon Sarla Verma
and Others vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another , National Insurance
Co. Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi and Others , Amrit Bhanu Shali and Others vs. NIC
Ltd. and Others , Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. P. Sathyavathamma and
Others , Shashikala and Others vs. Gangalakshmamma and Another , Rani
Gupta and Others vs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. and Others , Sadhana
Tomar and Others
vs. Ashok Kushwaha and Others7, Manjuri Bera vs.
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. and Another
emphasising that compensation
under the head of loss of dependency depends upon proof of actual
financial dependency to be determined on the evidence, and not merely
by the Claimant's relationship with the deceased. That the Claimants
(2009) 6 SCC 121.
(2017) 16 SCC 680.
(2012) 11 SCC 738.
2009 SCC Online AP 758.
(2015) 9 SCC 150.
(2009) 13 SCC 498.
(2025) SCC Online SC 554.
(2007) 10 SCC 643.
Page 3
MAC App. No.26 of 2024
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs. Hasmukh Pannalal Punamiya and Others
have failed to establish that they were financially dependent upon the
deceased.
7.
Per contra, Learned Counsel for the Respondents-Claimants
submits that the Claimants were entirely dependent upon the income
generated from the business jointly run by the deceased and her
husband, which constituted the sole source of livelihood for the
members of the joint family and that they are not carrying on any
business at present. It is further submitted that the Appellant neither
adduced any evidence to establish that the business had been inherited
or continued by the Claimants nor produced any evidence to contradict
the specific claim of dependency made by the Claimants. Learned
Counsel for the Respondents has relied upon Gujarat State Road Transport
Corporation,
Ahmedabad
vs.
Ramanbhai
Prabhathbhai
and
Another ,
Custodian of Branches of BANCO National Ultramarino vs. Nalini Bai Naique
,
Montford Brothers of St. Gabriel and Another vs. United India Insurance and
Another
, N. Jayasree and Ors. vs. Cholamandalam MS General Insurance
Company Limited
, Sadhana Tomar (supra), Seema Rani and Others vs.
The Oriental Insurance Company Limited and Other
and The Branch
Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Hasmukh Pannalal Punamiya and
Others
contending that the term "legal representative" under Section
166 of the Motor Vehicles Act is to be interpreted broadly and liberally,
that a person who suffers on account of the death of the victim may
maintain a claim even if not a legal heir in the strict sense.
8.
The legal argument raised by the Learned Counsel for the
Appellant is that, being siblings-in-law of the deceased, the Claimants
(1987) 3 SCC 234.
1989 Supp(2) SCC 275.
(2014) 3 SCC 394.
(2022) 14 SCC 712.
2025 SCC OnLine SC 283.
2026:SHC:13.
Page 4
MAC App. No.26 of 2024
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs. Hasmukh Pannalal Punamiya and Others
cannot be regarded as dependents of their sister-in-law. It is argued
that determination of compensation must strictly conform to the
principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court under Section 166 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. It is submitted by Learned Counsel for
the Appellant that, at best, the Claimants may be entitled only to
compensation under the conventional or non-pecuniary heads and not
towards loss of dependency.
9.
As far as the maintainability of the Claim Petition under Section
166 of the Motor Vehicles Act is concerned, it is well settled that legal
representative of the deceased may maintain an application for
compensation and that such person need not necessarily be a legal
heir.
10.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that, in the present
case, the Claimants would also succeed to the estate of the deceased
under Section 15 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, there being no
surviving members in the immediate family of the deceased. It is
submitted that upon the mother's death, her children would ordinarily
succeed to her estate, and upon the subsequent demise of the children,
the Claimants, being their natural legal heirs, would succeed to their
estate in accordance with Section 15 of the Hindu Succession Act,
1956.
11.
This
Court
may
not
have
much
dispute
regarding
the
maintainability of the Claim Petition. The claimants, no doubt, fall within
the expression of “legal representatives”. The question is whether the
claimants can be treated as dependents of the deceased sister-in-law.
There is no hard and fast rule for defining the expression “dependent”.
Dependency is essentially a question of fact and must be determined
based on the evidence available in each case. The Hon'ble Supreme
Page 5
MAC App. No.26 of 2024
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs. Hasmukh Pannalal Punamiya and Others
Court in Montford Brothers of St. Gabriel (supra), held that the religious
congregation was the legal representative of the deceased, as it
represented his estate. The Court recognized that the institution could
suffer a loss from the death of its member. Likewise, in The Branch
Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited vs. Sa-Ngor Chotshog
Centre and Another
, a learned Single Judge of this Court recognised a
Buddhist monastic institution as the legal representative of the deceased
monk. In Fr. Jose Anthanatt vs. Cholamandalam Insurance Co. Ltd.16, the
Kerala High Court held that a Monastery was entitled to pursue the
claim where the deceased priest had bequeathed all his assets to the
Monastery by his Last Will. Similarly, in Shri S.B. Shivamurthy Shivachary
Hiremutt v. Shabir Ahamed and others
, the Karnataka High Court held
that a Mutt, qualified as the legal representative of the deceased and
the claim for compensation, including under the head of loss of
dependency. Therefore, the concept of dependency must be understood
in the context of the relationship between the deceased, the claimant
and the nature of financial support actually received.
12.
In the present case, there are specific pleadings in the claim
petition, duly supported by the evidence, that the Claimants were
financially dependent upon the income earned by the deceased and her
husband. They have produced Income Tax Returns of the deceased to
establish that the business run by the deceased and her husband
constituted the sole source of the income. This factual aspect was not
effectively contested before the Tribunal. There was no effective crossexamination on the question of dependency nor did the Appellant
adduce any evidence to establish that the Claimants possessed an
independent source of income. In the absence of such rebuttal evidence,
2019 SCC OnLine Sikk 31.
2026:KER:3645.
2026:KHC-K:2871-DB.
Page 6
MAC App. No.26 of 2024
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs. Hasmukh Pannalal Punamiya and Others
the Court will have to incline towards accepting the plea of dependency,
particularly in view of the evidence that the business was being
conducted by the deceased and her husband for the benefit of the joint
family. Equally, no evidence was adduced to show that the business had
continued to be operated by the Claimants after the demise of the
deceased. In such circumstances, the computation of loss of dependency
was made in accordance with the principles laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court, and no substantial challenge has been raised before this
Court regarding the calculation of the compensation amount.
13.
This present case, however, could have had a different dimension
in the matter of claim. Assuming that the Appellant's contention
regarding dependency were to be accepted, an interesting question
would still arise with respect to the devolution of the right to claim
compensation. In this context, it would be apposite to refer to Section
21 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, which reads as follows:
“21. Presumption in cases of simultaneous deaths.—
Where two persons have died in circumstances rendering
it uncertain whether either of them, and if so which,
survived the other, then for all purposes affecting
succession to property, it shall be presumed, until the
contrary is proved, that the younger survived the elder.”
14.
Applying the statutory presumption contained in Section 21 of the
Hindu Succession Act, if the deceased mother is presumed to have
predeceased her children, the children would have become entitled to
succeed to her estate, including any claim arising out of her death.
Since the children also lost their lives in the same accident, and are
presumed to have survived the deceased mother, they would, in turn,
have been entitled to claim compensation arising from her death. Upon
their subsequent demise, the Claimants, being their natural legal heirs
under the applicable provisions of the Hindu Succession Act, would have
succeeded to their estate. Viewed from that perspective, the Claimants
Page 7
MAC App. No.26 of 2024
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs. Hasmukh Pannalal Punamiya and Others
could arguably have become entitled to an even higher amount of
compensation than that awarded in the present proceedings.
15.
Even when the matter is examined from the aforesaid perspective,
I find no reason to interfere with the well-considered Judgment passed
by the Learned Tribunal.
16.
Consequently, the Appeal fails and is accordingly dismissed.
17.
There shall be no order as to costs.
18.
Records of the Learned Tribunal be remitted forthwith.
Chief Justice
Approved for reporting: Yes
ds/ami
Page 8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review