Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 19th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 4096 of 2023
BETWEEN:ASHOK VERMA S/O SHRI MAHENDRA VERMA, AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: SERVICE SACHIVE R/O GRAM PANCHAYAT TEHSIL
DHARAMPURI DHAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI ANIRUDH SAXENA, ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH PRINCIPAL
VALLABH BHAWAN BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
SECRETARY
2.
COLLECTOR, DHAR DIST. DHAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER JILA PANCHAYAT, DHAR, (MADHYA
PRADESH)
4.
CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER JANPADH PANCHAYAT, DHARAMPURI,
DIST. DHAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SUDHANSHU VYAS, PANEL LAWYER)
WRIT PETITION No. 7711 of 2023
BETWEEN:THAWRIYA S/O SIGDAR BHEEL, AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS, VILLAGE
PATLAWAD, TEHSIL DHARAMPURI, (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI RAHUL YADAV, ADVOCATE)
AND
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
5:27:44 PM
-2-
1.
STATE OF M.P. COMMISSIONER PANCHAYAT RAJ SANCHANALAY,
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2. COLLECTOR DIST. DHAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
MUKHYA KARYAPALAN ADHIKARI, DIST. PANCHAYAT DHAR, DIST.
DHAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
MUKHYA
KARYAPALAN
ADHIKARI
JANPAD
DHARMANPURI, DIST. DHAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
PANCHAYAT
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SUDHANSHU VYAS, PANEL LAWYER)
This petition coming on for admission this day, the court passed
the following:
ORDER
Concerning the similitude in the controversy involved in the
present cases, with the joint request of the parties, these petitions are
finally heard and decided by this common order. Facts of W.P. No.4096
of 2023 are narrated hereunder.
01.
The petitioner has filed the present petition under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India being aggrieved by the order dated 07.02.2023
passed by the Chief Executive Officer, Janpad Panchayat, Dharampuri,
District – Dhar.
02.
Petitioner – Ashok Verma was appointed as Panchayatkarmai,
thereafter, he was notified as Panchayat Secretary. He was served with a
show-cause notice dated 24.08.2009 alleging sub-standard of works and
defects in valuation in respect of various work undertaken in the
Panchayat during the years 2005 – 06 & 2008 – 09. The aforesaid showcause notice was issued under the M.P. Panchayat Services (Conduct)
Rules, 1998 and Madhya Pradesh Gram Panchayat (Accounts) Rules,
1999.
03.
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
5:27:44 PM
The petitioner submitted a reply and the Collector vide order
-3-
dated 04.03.2010, directed to recover the amount of Rs.19,23,783/jointly from the Secretary and the Sarpanch. Being aggrieved by the
aforesaid order, the petitioner preferred an appeal before the
Commissioner. Vide order dated 29.11.2011, the matter was remitted
back to the Sub Divisional Officer for deciding it afresh after giving the
opportunity of hearing to the concerned parties. After remand, vide
order dated 12.09.2014, the Sub Divisional Officer examined all the
issues together and set aside all the recovery proceedings.
04.
After the aforesaid, the petitioner submitted a representation
dated 03.11.2014 seeking restoration of his status of Secretary. Vide
order dated 07.04.2015, his suspension was revoked and he was posted
as Secretary, Village – Semalda.
05.
It appears that a question was put before the Assembly of M.P.
in respect of financial irregularities, suspension and revocation against
the Sarpanch and Secretary. The Chief Executive Officer, Jila
Panchayat, Dhar vide letter dated 23.02.2016 sought an explanation
from the Chief Executive Officer, Janpad Panchayat, Dharampuri, Dhar
and also directed him to recover the disputed amount from Sarpanch,
Sachiv and employees within seven days and report back to him.
06.
The Chief Executive Officer, Janpad Panchayat quickly issued
notices dated 07.08.2020 to the petitioner, the then Sarpanch, the then
Sub Engineer, Assistant Engineer as to why the amount of
Rs.10,77,026/- be not recovered from them by registering a case under
Sections 40 & 92 of the Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Raj & Gram Swaraj
Adhiniyam, 1993.
07.
The petitioner submitted a reply stating that after the order was
passed by the Sub Divisional Officer, nothing remained in the matter
and he is discharging the duties efficiently and honestly, therefore, the
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
5:27:44 PM
-4-
case be closed. Without conducting any enquiry as contemplated in the
Panchayat Act and rules vide order dated 07.02.2023, the Chief
Executive Officer, Jila Panchayat, Dhar directed the petitioner to deposit
the amount of Rs.3,32,659/- @ Rs.8,000/- per month and also directed
to participate in the disciplinary proceedings. The Sarpanch and
engineers have also been directed to deposit a similar amount, they also
challenged by way of connected writ petition. Hence, the present
petition is before this Court.
08.
Simultaneously, the Chief Executive Officer vide letter dated
15.02.2023 requested the SHO, Police Station – Dhamnod to issue a
warrant of arrest against the petitioner under Sections 75 & 76 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 and vide order dated 09.05.2023, the
petitioner was informed that recovery has been started from his salary @
Rs.8,000/- per month. The petitioner has brought these documents by
way of amendment. Vide order dated 20.02.2023, this Court has stayed
the letter dated 15.02.2023, thereafter, recovery against Secretary &
Sarpanch has been stayed by way of the interim order.
09.
The respondents filed a reply raising objection in respect of the
maintainability of the writ petition as the petitioner is having alternative
and efficacious remedy of appeal under the provisions of the M.P.
Panchayat (Appeal & Revision) Rules, 1995. It is submitted that before
passing the recovery order, a show-cause notice was given to the
petitioner. It is further submitted that the Chief Executive Officer, Jila
Panchayat vide letter dated 09.04.2015, directed the Chief Executive
Officer, Janpad Panchayat to enquire into the irregularities of the affairs
of Gram Panchayat – Patlawad. Thereafter, vide order dated 04.07.2016,
the Chief Executive Officer appointed 03 Members' Committee to
conduct a fresh enquiry. The petitioner was called and heard by the
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
5:27:44 PM
-5-
Enquiry Team on 05.12.2016. After considering the defence, the enquiry
report was submitted on 20.12.2016 which is filed as Annexure-R/4 and
as per the report, Ashok Verma, Secretary and the then Sapanch,
Thavariya Sigdar (petitioner in W.P. No.7711 of 2023) were directed to
deposit amount of Rs.3,32,659/- each and Dhanesh Shukla, Sub
Engineer and Amit Kumar Kothari were directed to deposit
Rs.2,05,854/- each to make total recovery of Rs.10,77,026/-. Hence, the
petition is liable to be dismissed.
10.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and
perused the record.
11.
Under the Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Raj & Gram Swaraj
Adhiniyam and rules framed thereunder, the authorities have been
prescribed / authorized to conduct the proceedings under Sections 40, 89
& 92 of the Panchayat Act against the employees and office bearers of
Gram Panchayat, Janpad Panchayat and Jila Panchayat.
12.
Under Section 40 of the Madhya Pradesh Panchayat & Gram
Swaraj Adhiniyam, the Sarpanch is liable to be removed from the post
with further disqualification to contest the election for six years,
therefore, repeatedly this Court has held that the proceedings under
Section 40 of the Adhiniyam should be conducted like a regular trial by
framing issues, recording of evidence and giving complete opportunity
of hearing to the office bearers.
13.
So far as the proceedings under Sections 89 & 92 of the Madhya
Pradesh Panchayat Raj & Gram Swaraj Adhiniyam are concerned, these
are the proceedings by which the amount / dues payable to the Gram
Panchayat are liable to be recovered from the office bearers as well as
employees, apart from the disciplinary action under the Service Rules,
hence, such enquiry cannot be handed over to a team, the prescribed
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
5:27:44 PM
-6-
authority is empowered under the Act and rules to do the enquiry.
14.
In the present case, initially, the proceedings were initiated in
the year 2006 and the Collector passed the final order dated 04.03.2010
which was challenged by the petitioner before the Commissioner by
way of appeal. Vide order dated 29.11.2011, the order of the Collector
was set aside and the matter was remanded back to the Sub Divisional
Officer, Revenue for further adjudication. Vide order dated 12.09.2014,
the Sub Divisional Officer found discrepancies in the report submitted
by the Enquiry Committee and set aside the proposed recovery of
Rs.19,23,783/-. The relevant content of the said order is reproduced
below:“esjs }kjk izdj.k esa mYysf[kr rF;ksa] lfpo }kjk izLrqr tokc] U;k; n`"Vkar]
lfpo ds dk;Zdky esa fd;s x;s dk;Z dh tkap gsrq xfBr rdfudh ny }kjk
izLrqr rduhdh izfrosnu ,oa layXu eki iqfLrdkavksa] iapk;r }kjk fd;s x;s dk;kZs
ds mi;ksfxrk izek.k&i= ,oa dk;Z iw.kZrk izek.k i= dk voyksdu fd;k x;kA
mijksDr foospuk ds vk/kkj ij eSa bl fu"d"kZ ij igqpk gwW fd& ftyk Lrj ls
xfBr tkap ny }kjk vius tkap izfrosnu esa ,drjQk dk;Zokgh djrs gq, ftu
dk;ksZ dh iw.kZrk izek.k&i= tkjh gks pqds gS] mudk iqu% ewY;kadu dj varj dh
jkf'k fudkyh xbZ gSA lkFk gh ;g Hkh ik;k fd ftu dk;ksZ ds iw.kZrk izek.k&i=
iwoZ esa tkjh gksus ds i'pkr ewY;kadu ckn iw.kZrk izek.k&i= tkjh fd;s x;s gS]
mUgs iqu% ekSds ds eku ls ewY;kadu dj varj dh jkf'k fudkyh x;h gSA lkFk gh
mDr tkap ny }kjk ljiap@lfpo dh vuqifLFkfr esa tkap fd;k tkuk ik;k
tkrk gS vksj u gh xzke iapk;r dk fjdkMZ voyksdu fd;k x;k vkSj u gh
tuin iapk;r ls mDr fuekZ.k dk;ksZ dh tkudkjh yh xbZ vkSj euekus rjhds ls
varj dh jkf'k fudkyh xbZ gSA ,d vU; rf; ;g fd jkf'k :i;s 8]36]557@&
dk Hkqxrku uxn fd;k x;k] fdUrq mlds fcy Ogkmpj Hkh xzke iapk;r }kjk
izLrqr fd;s x;s gSA mDr fcyksa ls Ø; dh xbZ jkf'k ls xzke iapk;r ds tks dk;Z
fufeZr gq, gs] ftlesa ,d rjQ rks fd;s x;s dk;ksZ dk ewY;kadu fd;k tk jgk gS
vkSj nwljh rjQ mldh olwyh Hkh dh tk jgh gS] tks U;k;fgr esa ugh gSA ;fn
ny }kjk xzke iapk;r ds fjdkMZ ,oa vkosndx.kksa dks le{k esa lquokbZ dj]
fu"d"kZ fudkyrs rks ;g fLFkfr mRiUu ugh gksrhA lkFk gh nksf"k;ksa ds :i esa
mi;a=h] ys[kkf/kdkjh] ljiap ,oa lfpo dks lkewfgd :i ls ekuk gS] fdUrq
izdj.k esa ek= lfpo ds fo:) dk;Zokgh dj] olwyh fudkyh xbZ gS tks fu;e
fo:) gksdj] fujLr dh tkrh gSA”
15.
Now the said order has attained finality because after that order,
the suspension of the petitioner was revoked on 07.04.2015 and he was
permitted to work as Secretary.
16.
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
5:27:44 PM
Only on the basis of question Nos.349 raised before the
-7-
Assembly, the Chief Executive Officer Zila Panchayat shown his
displeasure in this matter and straightway directed Chief Executive
Officer, Janpad Panchayat to initiate the process for recovery of money
from the petitioner and others and informed him within seven days. A
Four Members' Committee was constituted by the Chief Executive
Officer Janpad Panchayat. The Committee gave an opportunity to the
petitioner and others and submitted a report that the amount of
Rs.10,77,026/- is liable to be recovered from the four officers named
above. In the Panchayat Raj & Gram Swaraj Adhiniyam, there is no
such provision for constitution of the Committee and conduction of an
enquiry. There could be a preliminary enquiry before issuance of any
show-cause notice or initiation of proceedings under Sections 40, 89 &
92 of the Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Raj & Gram Swaraj Adhiniyam,
1993. After submission of the preliminary report, the case is liable to be
registered under Section 89 of the Adhiniyam for recovery of any
amount from the concerned persons. However, in the present case, after
obtaining the report, no proceedings were initiated under Section 89 and
straightway the recovery order was issued which is unsustainable in the
eyes of the law.
17.
Chief Executive Officers of Zila Panchayat and Janpad
Panchayat are senior officers of the State services. The Madhya Pradesh
Panchayat Raj & Gram Swaraj Adhiniyam, 1993 & Rules made
thereunder have been in force in the State of Madhya Pradesh for the
last 50 years. All the Chief Executive Officers are supposed to know the
procedure to be followed under the Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Raj &
Gram Swaraj Adhiniyam, 1993 & Rules, despite that they are acting in
an arbitrary manner, especially in the matter of removal of Sarpanch and
recovery against the office bearers. In Writ Petitions and writ appeals
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
5:27:44 PM
-8-
where these types of orders are challenged, every time this High Court is
required to entertain the writ petition and quash such types of illegal
orders. It is high time now these officers are liable to be trained so that
they can properly exercise the quasi judicial power conferred to them
under the Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Raj & Gram Swaraj Adhiniyam,
1993. The State Government should organize training programs for
them so that the unnecessary burden on the High Court can be avoided.
On every occasion, this Court cannot entertain the writ petition
challenging the order passed in flagrant violation of the Madhya Pradesh
Panchayat Raj & Gram Swaraj Adhiniyam,1993.
18.
Once the order has attained finality after the order of Sub
Divisional Officer, which was not challenged either by Panchayat or by
the State Government the de novo enquiry cannot be initiated merely
because a question was raised before the Assembly. Under the pressure
of a higher officer, a Committee was constituted, the report was obtained
and recovery was started. Under the threat of registration of FIR, the
Chief Executive Officer tried to recover the amount from them. This is
nothing but a misuse of authority by the Chief Executive Officers.
Accordingly, the impugned orders in the writ petitions are set aside.
19.
With the aforesaid, both the Writ Petitions stand allowed with a
cost of Rs.10,000 – 10,000/- which shall be payable to the petitioners by
the then Chief Executive Officer of Zila Panchayat who issued the
impugned order.
Let a copy of this order be kept in the connected petition also.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Ravi
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
5:27:44 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review