Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 321s ]
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWELFTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI
WRIT PETITION NO: 21313 OF 2025
Between:
Syed Ahmed Mohiuddin alia Jeelani Pasha, S/o.Late Syed Shuiauddin Hussain alias
Khaleel Pasha Aged about 53 years, Occ. Hereditary Muthawalli, Sajjadanasheen,
R/o. H.No.12-2-710NA21A3, Flat No.103, 'lSt Floor Tulip Tower, Nan'itnagar, Near
77 7 Holel, Mehdipatnam, Hyderabad-1 3-TS
...PET!TIONER
AND
1 The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Minorities Welfare
Department, Secretariat Buildings, at Hyderabad
2 The Chairman, Telangana State Waqf Board, Haj Houz, Nampally,
Hyderabad
3 The Telangana State Waqf Board, Rep. by its Chief Executive Officer, Haj
Houz Building, Nampally, Hyderabad-TS
4. Mr.Syed Mohammed Siddiq Mahmoodi, S/o.Syed Mustafa Mahmood,
R/o. H. No. 1 4- 1 -494i 1, Darussalam X Road, Post Begumba zat, Hydeabad- 12-
TS
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, Order or Direction more particularly one in the nature of
Writ of Mandamus by declaring the action of the Official Respondent Nos.2 and 3
more particularly the Respondent No.2 in passing Resolution No.529 dt.26-10-
2024 in response to ltem No.4B of 9th Meeting of the Board in File
No.16lZ1/TlHYDl2024 by giving colourable exercise to his statutory powers
contrary to the proceedings and Reporti submitted by
his officiars and Respondent No.2 passed Resorution
the Respondent No_3 and
to incorporate the name of
the Respondent No.4 as tvruthawali of the waqf rnstitution
Dargah Ha ath
,'/iya. situated at Kishan Bagh, Bahadurpura, Hyderabad,
notified in A p Gazetle No 6-4 supprement to part-,
'r/lakki
namery Graveyard and
No.6'1 Sr.No.2245 with its attached properties on the
dt.09-02-1g89 at page
rights of being hereditary, by
ignoring the reports of the Respondent No.3 and his
subordinates and arso the
representation of this petrtioner dt.2g-12-201g requesting
to appoint him as
Muthawalli, as arbitrary, ex_facie illegal, discriminatory,
highhanded, and
dereliction of duty and giving colourable exercise
to his statutory powers
consequently may set-aside the said Resolution No
s29 dt.26- 10-2024 by
directing the Respondent Nos.2 and 3 to consider the
name of the petitioner in
the light of his Representation dt.28-r 2-2018 ro appoint
him as Muthawaili of the
aforesaid waqf rnstitution by incorporating his name to
transfer Towriath as being
hereditary, in the lnterest of Justrce.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
petition under section 15'1 cpc praying
that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court
may be pleased to
suspend the operatron of the Resorution No.52g dr26-10-2024
in response to
rtem No 48 0f gth tvreeting of the Board in Fire No.16/2
1fitHyDt2o24 passed by
the Respondent No 2 by directing the Respondent Nos.2
and 3 to consider the
petitioner
name of the
in the right of his Representation dt.2g-1
2-2018 to appoint
him as Muthawari of the waqf rnstitution namery
Graveyard and Dargah Hazrath
l\/akki Miya, situated at Kishan Bagh, Bahadurpura,
Hyderabad, notified in A.p.
Gazette No.6-4 suppremenl to part-ll dt.09- 02-1989
at page No.6.l S1.No.2245
with its attached properties by incorporating his name
to transfer Towriath as
being hereditary, in the rnterest of Justice, pending
disposar of the main writ
Petition.
lA NO: 2 oF 2025
Petition under section 15i cpc praying that in the
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High
circumstances stated in
Court may be pleased to
permit the Petitioner by ordering Newspaper publication in any Urdu newspaper
against unoff icial Respondent No. 4 in the interest of justice.
I
I
I
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI NAZIR AHMED KHAN
counsel for the Respondent No.1 : Gp FOR SOCIAL WELFARE
Counsel for the Respondent No.2&3: SRI FARHAN AZAM KHAN, SC FOR WAKF
Counsel for the Respondent No.4 :
The Court made the following: ORDER
-
IN I'HI] hIGTI COT-;R't I.-OR 1'IIE S'TATE OF'I'ELANGANA
,\1'II\'DT'RAB.\T)
THI- HONOT RABI-E Sivll' ., tJS'l'lC' Il T.MADFIAVI D0VI
r
w.P.NO.2r313 ()t'2025
DA'r'Er): 1J03.2026
Between
Sled Ahrrecl MohiLrddin ir .lcclani l)asha
Petitioner
Ancl
l-he Statc Lrl lclirrrcana.
Representcd br itr l)rincipal Sccr-ctarr.
Minorities \\'el lirrc I )epartrncut.
Sccretariat Builcliuq: at I Ir clerabad ancl Thrcc Others
Respondcuts
OIIDER
ln this u riL [)etition. tlre pctittonor is secking a writ ol rrandarnus
dcclaring thc actiou ol'the lc:pondcnts No.l ancl 3 in passine lLesolution
No.529. rlatcd 16. l0 l()ll iu rcsponsc to ILcrtr No.zl8 ul gtr' I\{ccting ol
thc Boarul in lrilc No. l6 /.1 I I IYI) 102;+- incorporatrne the namc of thc
respondcnt No.-1 ls Vlutltarr alli ol' tht. Waql' lnstitution narnclr
(iravel,ard arrd [).rrqah llrLu r-ath N,lakki \,liva. norille(l in A.P.Gazette
No.6-A. SLrpple rrent to l)urt-ll dntcci (t9.02.1989 aL l,age No.6 l.
S1.No.22.15 s,ith irs atLachcd proper-ries on rhc rights of boing hercditarr
bl ignorine the rcports of thc rcsponclcnt No.l and his sllbordinatcs and
\
TMD'J
w.P.No. 21373 oJ 2025
also the reprcsentation ol the petitioncr datcd 28.12.2018 rcquesting to
appoint hirn as Muthau'alli. as illegal. arbitrary, discrirninatory and
giving colourablc exercisc to his stattltor)' pori,ers and consequently, to
set aside thc said [{csolution No.529, datcd 26.10.2024 and direct the
respondents No.2 and 3 to cottsidcr the representation of the petitioner
dated 28.12.2018 fbr appointment as Muthawalli of the aforesaid Waql
lnstitution and to pass such other order or orders in the interest ol
.iusticc.
2.
Bricl taots leading to the fiting ol the present writ pctition
are that the petitioner claims that his father Mr.Khaleel Pasha was the
notilled Muthas'alli of the subject Waqf Institution, notified in
A.P.Gazcue No.6-A. supplemcnt to Part-Il, dated 09.02.1989 at page
No.6l. St.r'\o.21.15. \\ith its attached properties and that the petitioner
used to accotnpanr his [ather in all dcy to day activities aud rvas also
looking alter thc religious duties of the Waql Institution lt is stated that
the petirioner also used to couduct Urs and rnonthly [ratiha lt is
subrnittcd that alier thc death ol his father, the petitioner made several
representations requcsting the rcspondents No.2 and 3 to appoint him as
Muthawalli of the subject Waql Institution by incorporating his name in
place of his fathcr having obtained the copy ofthe succession and also
I
I
TMD,J
w.P.No. 21313 of 2O2s
NC)C fiom legal heirs ol his latlier. {t is statctl that responclent No.4 and
his lirther. u'ith an cril int!'ution'o Lrsru'l] the:rril \\'aql lnstitution. have
also llled an applicirtion lirr
'l'os
liathship aud used poliLical in0ucnce
and though respondent No.2 conductcd an euquirv bl'appointing Waqf
[]oard offrcials to glYc status rcport al)(l that thc r(jpurl \\ils givcn in
far,our of the petitioncr. but in its 9'r' []oarcl l\4cctine iu Iter.n No.48,
respondent No.2 has passed a Resolution No.529. dated 26.10.2024.
appointing respondcnl No. 1 as \,lutltau alli Lrntlcr Scction 12 ol fhe Waql-
Act. 199-5. b1' gl\ rng colorrrablc crelcisc t() his statutor\ porvcrs. It is
stated that alicr coming to knou about thc intpur:.ned ltcsolution dated
26.10.2024. thc pelitioner had soLrqht inlbmration undcr RTI Act b1,
fllins an application datcd 0l.ll.l0l-l unri :incc the rcspondent No.4
rvas interf-ering into the adrniuistration ol lllc \\'a11f'Irrstitution though he
was not 1,et appointccl as Muthatalli. hc hiLd rcquested rcspondent No.3
to take the sub.icct \\'aqt IustiLLrLiun unclcl iiis dircct rtrarras.crnent undcr
Section 6j of' the \\'aql' ,\cL. 1995. but no action rr,as taken by
respondent No.2. Ar erring that the pctitioncr has no other ell-cctive
alternativc romcdl . this ririt pe tition has bcen tilcd
3.
Learnctl counsel appcaring lbr Lhc ltctilionct has drarvn thc
attention of this CorLrt to the (i) represcutation ot'thc petitioner dated
TMD,J
w.P.No. 21313 oJ 2O2S
28.12.2018. which r.r.as stated to have becn
reccived by the WaqlBoard
on 08.10.202-l as per the endorsemenr ol receipt;
Inspector Audiror ol rhe Waql' Board dated
(ii) the report ol the
21.10.2024; (iii) the
representation of r-cspondcnr No..1. datcd 12.12.2017;
and also (iv) the
representation of' thc pctitioncr reccivcd on 07.03.2025,
Institution under its direct nlanagelnent under Section
lor taking the
65 of the Waqf
Act, t995 and againsr rhc Resorution No.i29, dated 26.r0.2024.
He has
relerred to thc cop\ ol the A.p.Gazctte No.6_A. Hyderabad.
09.02.1989. uherein rhc narnc ol the petitioner,s
father Khaleel pasha
Sahab. residcnt .r' -[ ro.p []azar'. *,as rnentioned as
the Muthawa i ot'
Waqf' [nstitution i.e.. (irar elards. Bagh_c-Makki Miyan.
Bahadurpura. AttapLir. at.ca to an cxtent 29,323.g
datecl
behind
square yards at Serial
No.2245. I Ie also ref'crrcd ro rhc Mcrno d,ated 24.07 .201 g
the pctitioncr as ri ell as respondent No.4 calting for
addressed to
the documents to
substalltiate thcir clairn or er the subject propcrty and also
05.10.202.+. requir.ing thc Inspector Auditor of the Waqf
Metno dated
to conduct an
inquirl,and subnrit it fhctrral reporr_
4.
[_carrred corrnsel appearing Ibr the respondent No.4
has
flled a counter al'fldar. it siating that thc subject Waqf property rvas
devotional gill b1, one Burhan Shah. S/o.Bande Ali Shah
a
on 21.1 Shaban
TMD,J
W.P.No. 21313 of 2025
1315 Hiiri. exprcssll' lor the rraintenance and scrvicc of llazrat Makki
Milan Sahatr's [)argah and (ilarc_rarcl and tlrcrclirrc. fiorn the inccprion
it has bccn trcated as \\1at1[ ltroper-tr. dcclicatccl lirr rclieious and
charitable purposes and not a self'-acquircrl propert\ liahle to partition
and upon the demisc of Hazrat Sl,ed Mahnrood Ali Shah 'rr. Makki
Mivan Sahab. the subjcct laud sood crcltLdecl liont clil.ision ol'tarni11,
propcfiics as it was dedicated Ibr sen'ice t() thc saint. I{e has shown the
table shou,ing the succcssion basccl on lincagc and serr'ice and according
Lo the same. thc initial Muthau alli \\ ils onc Sr ccl Nloharnmcd Masood
'ir) Mi1'an Mohantnrcd Sahab. the cldcr son ol th. sitiltt and thcr.r it was
S1'ed Moharnrned Siddiq Mahrloodi frr' Klrlja l,asha Sahab. rhe third son
and lrom hirn it u,as fallcn olt Slecl Shu jauclclin llLrssaini ,@ Khaleel
Pasha Sahab. rvho rvas thc qrandsou ol'(lutuhrrrltlin Sahab and later
Syed Mustala Mahmood .1i Yousuf'I)asha Sahalr. son ol'Kha.la pasha
Saliab rvas appointed as Muthau,alli and aticr hir:r his clder son i.e..
rcspondcut No.,l lras bccn appointcd as \{Lttharrirlli. [Jricl historv as tct
hor.r it has dcvolr.ed ou tltc ltctitioncr ancl his prcclcccssor lras also
mcntioned in the counter allldar it. It is statcd rhat thc
llcritioner-'s lathcr
has scrved as Mutharvalli and Sal.jadah-nas hecn tiorn I 98_5 to 20 t7 and
ir.r thc ycar 201 7. o*,ing to old asc and ill-hc-altlt. hc clcclured responrient
I
I
TMD,J
w.P.No 21373 of2O2s
and that a fbrmal deed to
No.4. his elder son. as thc tllth successor
record that succession was prcpared
and executed by his father' attested
by Mashayaqeen. lilema' disciplcs and
documcnts vncrc subnriLtcd to
tbllorvers and all the relevant
the rcspondent No'J for recording his
name as Muthaii'alli antl alicr takillg
the same into consideration only'
as the Muthawalti
respondcnt No.4 has been appointcd
needs no interf-erence Alorrg
and therefore' it
rr ith the counter affidavit' he has
copies of the photographq 35 "vell
filed the
as the press clippings to demonstrate
that he rvas the onc uho rl,'as discharging
the rcligious functions as
and theretbre' he prayed lor
Muthawalli ol the sub.iect Waql'propertl
lt is lurrher starecl
dismissal ol thc rr rit pctilion
appointment of Mutharr alli' therc
that against the
is an alternativc remedy for thc
petitioner be iore thc Waq | 1 ribunal
ancl on this ground also' the
writ
petition is liable to be disurisscd'
5.
I [e placed tcliancc tlporl thc
it then was in W.P Nos 4;17 I and 5()12
clecision of A P't]igh Court as
of l0l3' dated 25 06'2013' in the
caseofP.BandagiSahVs.llntlltraProdeshstuleWaqlfBoard.rvherein
it rvas held that therc exists atr cfticacious'
Waql Tribunal [irr reclrcssal ol- disputes
also the decision ol tho Division Bcnch
t
specdy' alternative rernedy
conccrning Waql properties
ol
and
ol this Court in W A'No 827 of
-rMD,J
w P.No. 213 13 of 2O2s
2024. dated 12.02..2025. holding thar the peritioncr has ro
approach rhc
Waqf Tribunal in respect olthc disputes relarine to \\,aq1.
6.
IJal in{l rcqard to Lhc ri\.al c()ntcrlti()ns urrtl tlrc tlltcrial
record. this Court frnds that the issue as to rrhetrrcr thc pctitionr:r
successor of the carlier notil-ied Muthav'alli is a qucsti.n
rras rhe
of lact and it
,eccls co,sideration [r' a fact Iinding arrth.rit,r anci in tlris
case. thc
waql' fribunar. l hc pctitioner has nor hccn abrc tu puinr Uur
irre_plularitv in passing ol'the Rcsolution No..i29. clatcd
on
an\
16. I0.2021. The
lcgalit) or otller\vise ot'said ResoluLi., ca, ,rulr bc dcciclcrl b_r.thc
Tribunal as held in the case o[' p.BundugiSa6 (cirec] srrpra)
\tr,,aq1.
ancl also
dccision oldivision bench ot this C,uurr in \\ .A.Nu.tI7 oI.2()24.
7.
ln vicrr thereol. this Cour.t ts not inclinccl lo !_\prcss an),
opi,io, ou rnorits. a.d is arso not ircrine rr r. i,Ler.rer c rr irh Rcsorurion
No.529. dated 26.10.2024 at this stagc. l he rctirrc. rhe * r-ir pctiti.n
disrnisscd w,ith libertl, to rhe petitioncr to challcnse rhc
Rcsolution befbrc thc waql' r'r-ibrrnar. .fhcr-c srrari bc rri, .rtrcr
8.
Misoellaneous
petition. sha Il stand closcd.
is
sub-jcct.
as to cosls.
pctitiolls. i1'anr. ltcrrtlins irr rhis rv.it
SD/.C. IiEEPIKA
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
i
,TRUE COPY//
I
iI
SECTION OFFICER
To,
\
l One CC to SRI NAZIR AHMED KHAN, Advocate. [OPUC]
2 fwo CCs to GP FOR SOCIAL WELFARE, High Court for the State of
I
I
Telangana. [OUT]
3. One CC to SRI FARHAN AZAI\I KHAN, SC FOR WAKF BOARD IOPUCI
I
4. Two CD Copies
BSK
BS
I
I
I
{ry
HIGH COURT
DATED:1 210312026
(v
lri-.,7.,a-*\
' C. t\.
i
{
2 3 lltti ,,i1n
I
t
ORDER
WP.No.21313 of 2025
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
//.- ) \
l.l
)
\_'
2b
AL
Dr t F-.'i-t'c\l ,f rt
-tr
.c)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review