Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT
OF MADHYA
PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUBODH ABHYANKAR
WRIT PETITION No. 19332 of 2021
BETWEEN:DEVI AHILYA NEW CLOTH MARKET CO.
LTD THR. MANAGING DIRECTOR SHRI
HANSRAJ JAIN 74, M.T. CLOTH MARKET
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
THR. THE SECRETARY VALLABH
BHAWAN
BHOPAL
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
JOINT
DIRECTOR
TOWN
AND
COUNTRY PLANNING A.B. ROAD,
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
INDORE MUNICIPAL COPORATION
THR
COMMISSIONER/BUILDING
OFFICER
ZONE
MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION
OFFICE
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE AND SHRI AMOL
SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.3/IMC)
WRIT PETITION No. 21216 of 2021
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
BETWEEN:1.
RAJKUMAR
RAJDEV
S/O
SHRI
GANESHOMAL,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 64,
KATJU COLONY (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
SMT. SARITA RAJDEO W/O SHRI
RAJKUMAR, AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 64, KATJU
COLONY (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION INDORE
COMMISSIONER/BUILDING
OFFICER
ZONE 13 MUNICIPAL CORPORATION
OFFICE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
JOINT
DIRECTOR
TOWN
COUNTRY PLANNING A.B.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
AND
ROAD
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMOL SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1/IMC AND SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 21400 of 2021
BETWEEN:SMT. MAYADEVI W/O SHRI MADHAVDAS
ASRANI OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 86, SOUTH
KATJU COLONY (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION
INDORE
COMMISSIONER/BUILDING
OFFICER
ZONE-13, MUNICIPAL CORPORATION
OFFICE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
JOINT
DIRECTOR
TOWN
COUNTRY PLANNING A.B.
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
AND
ROAD
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMOL SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1/IMC AND SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 21511 of 2021
BETWEEN:NEHA
W/O
SHRI
PRATIK
GOYAL
OCCUPATION:
BUSINESS
3/3,
SOUTH
TUKOGANJ, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION THRU.
COMMISSIONER/BUILDING
OFFICER
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
JOINT DIRECTOR DIRECTORATE OF
TOWN AND COUNTRY PLANNING A.B.
ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMOL SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1/IMC AND SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 21960 of 2021
BETWEEN:KRATIKA JAIN W/O SHRI BAHUBALI SETHI
OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 55, NEMINAGAR
JAIN COLONY (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION INDORE
THROUGH COMMISSIONER/BUILDING
OFFICER
ZONE-13,
MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION
OFFICE
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
JOINT
DIRECTOR
TOWN
COUNTRY PLANNING A.B.
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
AND
ROAD
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMOL SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1/IMC AND SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 23078 of 2021
BETWEEN:PRADIP KUMAR S/O SHRI RATANLAL
BANDI OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 21 M.T.
CLOTH MARKET (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION INDORE
COMMISSIONER/ BUILDING OFFICER
ZONE 13 MUNICIPAL CORPORATION
OFFICE INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
JOINT
DIRECTOR
TOWN
AND
COUNTRY PLANNING A.B. ROAD,
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMOL SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1/IMC AND SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 23082 of 2021
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
BETWEEN:VEER CHAND S/O SHRI BASANTILAL
MANAWAT OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 241,
M.T. CLOTH MARKET (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION INDORE
COMMISSIONER/ BUILDING OFFICER
ZONE
INDORE
MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
JOINT
DIRECTOR
TOWN
COUNTRY PLANNING A.B.
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
AND
ROAD
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMOL SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1/IMC AND SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 23887 of 2021
BETWEEN:GHANSHYAMDAS S/O SHRI MANGILAL
OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 382, CHHAPIHEDA
TEH. KHILCHIPUR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
1.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION INDORE
COMMISSIONER / BUILDING OFFICER
ZONE
INDORE
MUNICIAPL
CORPORATION (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
JOINT
DIRECTOR
TOWN
COUNTRY PLANNING A.B.
AND
ROAD
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMOL SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1/IMC AND SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 25737 of 2021
BETWEEN:DINESH CHHABADIA S/O SHRI PRABHUDAS
OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 177/8 M.T. CLOTH
MARKET (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION INDORE
THR. COMMISSIONER / BUILDING
OFFICER
ZONE
MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION
OFFICE
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
JOINT
DIRECTOR
TOWN
AND
COUNTRY PLANNING A.B. ROAD,
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMOL SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1/IMC AND SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 27114 of 2021
BETWEEN:ASHOK KUMAR S/O SHRI ARJUNDAS
WADHWANI OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 92,
M.T. CLOTH MARKET (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
AND
1.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION INDORE
THR.
COMMISSIONER/BUILDING
OFFICER
ZONE
MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION
OFFICE
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
JOINT
DIRECTOR
TOWN
COUNTRY PLANNING A.B.
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
AND
ROAD
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMOL SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1/IMC AND SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 27878 of 2021
BETWEEN:NILESH KUMAR S/O SANTOSH KUMAR JAIN
OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 25/8, YASHWANT
NIWAS ROAD, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION THRU.
COMMISSIONER/BUILDING
OFFICER
ZONE-13, MUNICIPAL CORPORATION
OFFICE INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
JOINT
DIRECTOR
TOWN
COUNTRY PLANNING A.B.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
AND
ROAD
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMOL SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1/IMC AND SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 28757 of 2021
BETWEEN:-
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
SURESH KUMAR LALWANI S/O SHRI
KASTURCHAND
JAIN
OCCUPATION:
BUSINESS 92, M.T. CLOTH MARKET
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION INDORE
THR.
COMMISSIONER/
BUILDING
OFFICER
ZONE
MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION
OFFICE
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
JOINT
DIRECTOR
TOWN
COUNTRY PLANNING A.B.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
AND
ROAD
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMOL SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1/IMC AND SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 929 of 2022
BETWEEN:DURGASHANKAR
SONI
S/O
SHRI
MOHANLAL SONI OCCUPATION: BUSINESS
27/1 LODHIPURA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
1.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION INDORE
THR.
COMMISSIONER/
BUILDING
OFFICER
ZONE
MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION
OFFICE
INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
JOINT
DIRECTOR
TOWN
AND
COUNTRY
PLANNING
AB
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
ROAD,
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMOL SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1/IMC AND SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 4824 of 2022
BETWEEN:ASHISH GARG S/O SHRI KALYANMAL
GARG OCCUPATION: BUSINESS R/O 22
PATEL NAGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI V.K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. VAISHALI JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION INDORE
COMMISSIONER/ BUILDING OFFICER
ZONE 13 MUNICIPAL CORPORATION
OFFICE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
JOINT
DIRECTOR
TOWN
COUNTRY PLANNING A.B.
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
AND
ROAD
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMOL SHRIVASTAVA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.1/IMC AND SHRI AMAY BAJAJ, P.L./G.A. FOR STATE)
…............................................................................................................
Reserved on
:
01.12.2023
Pronounced on
:
23.01.2024
…........................................................................................................
These petitions having been heard and reserved for orders,
coming on for pronouncement this day, the Court passed the following:
ORDER
Heard finally.
2]
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
This order shall also govern the disposal of the other connected
writ petitions as a common question of law is involved. For the sake
of convenience, the facts as narrated in W.P. No.19332 of 2021 are
being taken into consideration.
3]
This petition has been filed by Devi Ahilya New Cloth Market
Company Limited, a Company registered under Section 25 of the
Companies Act, 1956. The Company was registered on 28/02/1999 for
the purposes of developing a colony for its shareholders and members
and to sell the same to them.
4]
So far as the facts of the case are concerned, the petitioner
Company sought to develop a colony as New Cloth Market at village
Tejpur Gadbadi, Indore comprising of Survey Nos.117, 118/2, 119,
120/2, 121/2, 124/1/2, 125/2, 127/2, 128/2, 129/2, 130, 131, 132/1 and
133, in all admeasuring 46.30 acres. This land was reserved for
commercial purposes in the Master Plan.
5]
The case of the petitioner is that 1139 cloth traders of Indore
formed the aforesaid Company for the said purpose of developing a
colony, for which, the petitioner Company also purchased the
aforesaid lands through a registered sale deed dated 07/11/1990
having obtained various permissions and exemptions under the Urban
Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 and other permissions.
Subsequently, the petitioner Company also applied for the
development permission (Layout approval) which was firstly granted
on 02/03/1995 by respondent No.2, Joint Director Town and Country
Planning, which was subsequently amended/revised on 27/11/1997,
02/11/2000, 13/05/2004 and lastly on 01/02/2005 as per the prevailing
of MP Bhumi Vikas Niyam, 1984 (hereinafter referred to as the „Rules
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
of 1984‟) and Master Plan, 1991.
6]
It is the further the case of the petitioner that after obtaining the
relevant permission the petitioner applied for grant of development
permission from the respondent No.3 the Indore Municipal
Corporation, which was also granted on 02/01/2006 and thereafter, the
Company completed the development according to the sanctioned
layout plan by the Town and Country Planning Department. The
permission dated 02/01/2006 issued by the Indore Municipal
Corporation is also placed on record. Subsequent to that, the petitioner
Company also started allotting the plots to its members/shareholders
and executed registered sale deeds of almost all the plots in favour of
its members and the members are now applying individually for
sanction of building plans on their respective plots and huge number
of members have already constructed their buildings. Subsequently,
the petitioner also applied for transfer of the colony to the respondent
No.3 as required by law and the colony has already been handed over
to the respondent No.3 vide letter dated 15/11/2018.
7]
To the utter surprise of the petitioner, after having granted
several building permissions, respondent No.3 has started issuing
show cause notices to some of the members on the ground that their
plots are within the distance of 30 meters from the river, hence,
construction be stopped by them and why the building permission
granted to them be not revoked, and despite the reply being filed by
the plot holders, they are not permitted to complete their construction
as per the sanctioned building plan. Subsequently, on 19/06/2019
respondent No.3 Indore Municipal Corporation wrote a letter to the
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
respondent No.2 the Joint Director of Town and Country Planning,
Indore that about 48-50 plots are falling within 30 meters distance
from river and a distance of 30 meters from river has to be maintained
according to Bhumi Vikas Niyam, 2012 (hereinafter referred to as the
„Rules of 2012‟) and Master Plan, 2021. Hence, layout plan be
amended/revised. The petitioner also filed its objection to the said
letter on 01/08/2019 stating that since the layout plan has already been
sanctioned and even the development permission has already been
granted according to the Rules of 1984 and Master Plan 1991 and the
development was also done accordingly and the plots are allotted and
sold to the members,
some of whom have already raised their
construction after obtaining permissions, hence, the Rules of 2012 and
Master Plan 2021 shall not be applicable. The petitioner has also
placed on record the reply filed by the respondent No.2 Joint Director
Town and Country Planning dated 18/09/2019 to the reply sent by the
respondent No.3 Indore Municipal Corporation on 19/06/2019
clarifying the legal position that since the layout plan and
development permission were sanctioned at the time when the Rules
of 1984 and Master Plan 1991 were in force, hence, reference to the
Rules of 2012 and Master Plan 2021 cannot be made to seek
amendment in the layout plan. It was also mentioned that
amendment/revision of any sanctioned layout plan can only be done
under Section 29(3) of the Adhiniyam on the application of the
petitioner. This position was further reiterated in its letter dated
24/09/2019 by the Joint Director, Town and Country Planning sent to
the Director, however, despite the aforesaid stand taken by the Town
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
and Country Planning, respondent No.3 has kept the permissions and
applications on hold and has stopped accepting building permission
application. Hence, the petitioners, seeking intervention of respondent
No.1,
the
State
Administration
Government
and
through
Development
its
Secretary
Department
Urban
submitted
a
representation dated 20/01/2020 for issuance of the directions to the
respondent No.2 and 3, however, no directions have been issued on
the same. Thus, the respondent No.3 has continued to withhold the
applications vide its communication dated 14/03/2020 wherein, it is
informed that a request has been made to the Joint Director, Town and
Country Planning to revise the layout plan of Devi Ahilya New Cloth
Market and hence, no further building permission will be granted to
any plot of this colony till the new revised map is issued. The
petitioners have again sought the permissions for sanctioning the
building permissions but to no avail and subsequently, on 15/06/2021,
the Joint Director of Town and Country Planning has issued a notice
to the petitioner stating that their 48-50 plots are falling within the
distance of 30 meter from the river, hence, revised plan of the colony
be submitted to which, a reply was also sent by the petitioner on
01/07/2021, stating that the petitioner has been granted the
development permission vide order dated 01/02/2005, in accordance
with law as prevailing on that day including the Master Plan and the
plots have already been sold to the members of the petitioner
Company and also informed about the letters issued by the Municipal
Corporation in this behalf on 15/01/2021 and 19/06/2019, which have
been referred to in the notice dated 15/06/2021 by the Joint Director.
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
8]
Being aggrieved of the notice dated 15/06/2021 and other
notices dated 15/01/2021, 14/03/2020 (Annexure-P/13), 19.06.2019
(Annexure-P/8) passed by the respondent Nos.2 and 3, this petition
has been filed.
9]
Shri V.K.Jain, learned senior counsel for the petitioner has
drawn the attention of this Court to all the aforesaid documents and it
is submitted that the development permission (Layout plan) was
sanctioned by the respondent No.2, the Joint Director of Town and
Country Planning on
01/02/2005. Thereafter, the Municipal
Corporation has also granted development permission on 02/01/2006,
at that time, Rules of 1984 and Master Plan, 1991 were in force. It is
submitted that Rules of 1984 have been repealed by the new Rules of
2012, which came into force on 01/06/2012, whereas, the Master Plan,
2021 came into force on 01/01/2008 and Clause 6.3.11 of which
provides that if layout is sanctioned prior to commencement of Master
Plan-2021, the previously sanctioned development permission shall
continue to remain in force. Thus, it is submitted that the development
permission granted earlier is already saved by the subsequent Master
Plan of 2021, and the Master Plan of 2021 cannot be applied
retrospectively to disturb the earlier permissions granted by the Town
and Country Planning. It is also submitted that even Rule 105 of the
Rules of 2012 clearly provides that, the repeal shall not affect the
validity of the licences previously granted to the engineers, town
planners etc, the previous operation of said rules or anything done or
any action taken thereunder. Thus, it is submitted that the respondent
No.3 has clearly erred in withholding the building permission sought
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
by the respective plot owners and the letters dated 19.06.2019 and
14.03.2020 are liable to be quashed and the respondents be directed to
start granting building permissions to the respective plot owners of the
members of the petitioner Company who have filed the connected writ
petitions.
10]
On the other hand, the petition has been opposed by the
respondents, and the replies have also been filed by the respondent
No.1, 2 and respondent No.3 Indore Municipal Corporation, Indore, as
also the additional reply and rejoinder.
11]
In the reply filed by the respondent No.3 Indore Municipal
Corporation, they have referred to the decision rendered by the
National Green Tribunal, Central Zone, Bench Bhopal vide order
dated 19/07/2017 in the case of Kishore Samrite Vs. Union of India
in which following directions have been issued:“Learned counsel submits that the information is still
awaited. We direct that at present all building permissions
that may have been granted for allowing construction within
30 meters of the Full Tank Level (FTL) of all the lakes in the
State shall be put on hold. Copy of this order shall be sent to
that Chief Secretary, who in turn is directed to ensure the
compliance by the forwarding the appropriate directions to
the local authorities. Copy be also given to the Principal
Secretary, Urban Development Department for compliance.
Companies of this order shall be reported by the learned
counsel for the State on the next date of hearing.
Let the matter be listed on 23rd August, 2017.”
12]
Thus, it is stated that the Municipal Corporation is duty bound
to comply with the order passed by the National Green Tribunal and
in this regard Directorate of Urban Administration and Development,
M.P. vide its order dated 25/09/2017 has also issued directions to all
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
the Commissioners of the Municipal Corporation to comply with the
directions of the National Green Tribunal and in pursuance thereto, the
respondent No.3 has written a letter dated 19/06/2019 (Annexure-P/8)
to the petitioner, which is under challenge in this petition.
Subsequently, another letter dated 15/01/2021 has also been issued by
the respondent No.3 to the petitioner directing the petitioner to change
the layout plan. Thus, it is submitted that the aforesaid letters have
been issued by the respondent No.3 in compliance with the orders
passed by the NGT and Directorate of Urban Administration and
Development M.P. Thus, no case for interference is made out as the
respondent No.3 has rightly stopped granting building permissions in
the petitioner‟s colony, which if granted, would be in breach of the
order passed by the NGT, and in line with the aforesaid stand, the
respondent No.2 has also written a letter to the petitioner on
15/06/2021, which is also under challenge in this petition. Thus, it is
submitted that 48-50 plots which are falling within the 30-meter
distance from the river Saraswati cannot be granted permission as the
change in the layout plan taking into account the 30 meter range,
would affect the entire colony. It is also submitted that the petitioner
had obtained the development permission from the respondent No.2
by declaring the river as „Nala’, which is a material suppression of
fact.
13]
Counsel appearing for the respondent No.3 has also submitted
that Clause (b) of Sub Rule 1 of Rule 105 of the Rules of 2012
provides that any application submitted under the repealed Rules,
pending at the commencement of these Rules shall be continued and
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
disposed of in accordance with the provisions of these Rules i.e., M.P.
Bhumi Vikas Rules, 2012. Thus, it is submitted that since in the Rules
of 2012 and the Master Plan of 2021 no construction can be made
within 30 meter distance from the river, the respondent No.3 has
rightly rejected the applications filed by the respective plot owners for
construction on their plots.
14]
In rejoinder to the aforesaid reply, the petitioner has reiterated
its claim that it was accorded the layout plan way back on 02/01/2006,
and thereafter, building permission has also been granted by the
respondent No.3 vide order dated 25/06/2011, and has also relied upon
Rule 50(b) of Rules of 1984, which provides that construction cannot
be made if the site is within the distance of 9 meter of highest
watermark and in case of a major water force nearby, 15m from the
defined boundary of water source, whichever is more. Reliance is also
placed on Clause 6.15.3 of the Indore Development Plan 2021 (Master
Plan) which came into force on 01/01/2008. Reliance is also placed on
Sections 72 and 73 of the Madhya Pradesh Nagar Tatha Gram Nivesh
Adhiniyam, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as the „Adhiniyam of 1973‟),
which provide for the power of the State Government of supervision,
control and to give directions. Counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that as per the clarification issued by the State Government vide letter
dated 03/04/2012 (Annexure-P/17), it is clearly opined that the Master
Plan 2021 has come into force on 01/01/2008, and prior to that all the
development permissions which have been granted by the Town And
Country Planning would hold good for the purposes of giving
construction permission by the Municipal Corporation. Thus, it is
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
submitted that the aforesaid letter has been issued by the State
Government while exercising its powers under Sections 73 and 74 of
the Adhiniyam.
15]
It is also stated that so far as the order dated 19/07/2017 passed
by the NGT is concerned, it does not relate to the Adhiniyam of 1973
and M.P. Bhumi Vikas Niyam and the development plan sanctioned
thereunder, and otherwise also, it is in respect of lakes only and not
the rivers. It is also submitted that in the said case the final order has
also been passed on 13/12/2021, but the same would not have any
bearing on the outcome of the present case as the sanction was already
granted much prior to even the interim order dated 19/07/2017 passed
by the NGT. It is also submitted that the contention of the respondent
No.3 that the petitioner has made a false representation that the said
river is a nala, is also misconceived and incorrect as it is common
knowledge that the aforesaid river has been referred to as nala in the
city of Indore. It is further submitted that reliance on Master Plan
2021 cannot be placed by the respondents to deny the permission to
the members of the petitioner Company. It is also submitted that there
is no provision in the Adhiniyam or Rules to compel any person to
amend the layout plan and in the present case when not only the entire
development has been completed, but the same has also been certified,
and the plots have already been sold to various members of the
petitioner Company running into more than 1100 plots, and since the
project has already been handed over to the respondent No.3 Indore
Municipal Corporation, it is practically impossible for the petitioner to
amend/revise the layout plan. Thus, it is submitted that the reply filed
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
by the Municipal Corporation be rejected and the petition be allowed.
16]
In their reply to the petition, the respondent No.2 Town and
Country Planning has reiterated what is stated by the respondent No.1
State. It is also stated that the respondent Nos.1 and 2 are not the
competent authority to grant building permission to the petitioner as it
is the respondent No.3, who is the competent authority in the matter of
grant of building permission. It is also submitted that the petitioner
could have applied for modification/amendment of the layout plan as
provided under Section 29(3) of the Adhiniyam of 1973.
17]
An additional reply dated 13/12/2022 has also been filed by the
respondent No.3 Municipal Corporation contending that the Municipal
Corporation has put on hold the building permissions by invoking
Rule 25 of the Madhya Pradesh Bhumi Vikas Rules and have recalled
and revoked such building permissions granted within 30 meter of
FTL in accordance with the order passed by the NGT. It is also
submitted that the building permissions have already been refused to
three plot holders namely Jagdish Kasat, Pankaj Parmar, Vandana
Parmar and Shri Mohit Chandwani.
18]
Yet another additional reply has also been filed by the
respondent No.3 on 07/01/2023 by referring to a letter issued in the
month of February 2005 to submit that the development permission
and building permissions are two independent permissions from two
independent authorities, and the final sanction of the construction of
building has to be obtained separately and the grant of development
permission by respondent No.2 does not ipso facto entail an absolute
right to the petitioner to construct the building in the absence of
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
building sanction, it is also stated that the Building Officer has
committed no error in asking the petitioner to revise their applications
in terms of the applicable laws namely, the Rules of 2012 and
Development Plan of 2021. It is also submitted that the writ petition
against the notice issued under Rules 25 of the Rules of 2012 is also
not maintainable as no jurisdictional error has been committed by the
respondent No.3 in issuing the aforesaid letter and apart from that, an
alternative remedy of appeal under Rule 25(A) of the Rules of 2012
and Section 31 of Adhiniyam of 1973 is available to the petitioner and
thereafter, a revision under Section 32 is also available to the State
Government.
19]
Shri Amol Shrivastava, learned counsel for the respondent No.3
IMC has also banked upon an order passed by this Court at Jabalpur in
the case of Ashish Kumar Vs. State of M.P. reported as (2015) 2
MPLJ 540, which according to Shri Shrivastava, squarely covers the
issue involved in this case as in the said decision, this Court, in no
uncertain terms has held that building plan in a development area must
be sanctioned by the Municipal authority only as per the Rules of
2012. Attention of this Court has also been drawn to paras 31, 36 and
37 of the aforesaid judgement. Thus, it is submitted that on this
ground only, this petition is liable to be dismissed.
20]
In rebuttal, Shri V.K.Jain, learned sr. counsel for the petitioner
has submitted that the aforesaid judgement is clearly distinguishable
and is not applicable under the facts and circumstances of the case as
in the aforesaid case, the issue which was involved was of FAR as the
petitioner therein was claiming the FAR under the old Rules of 1984
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
whereas, the respondents‟ contention was that the Rules of 2012
would be applicable. Counsel has also submitted that even in the
aforesaid decision, this Court has clearly held that there are three fold
applications to be made, (i) for grant of permission from the
development authority, (ii) grant of license or permission from the
colonizer‟s authority and (iii) an application for grant of building
permission. It is also submitted that the first two applications were
required for permission to enable the petitioners to apply for grant of
building permission and, therefore, if such permissions were granted
by the competent Authority under the relevant Rules, which were in
force at the relevant time, the petitioners can make the application
before the Municipal Corporation for the purposes of grant of building
sanction which has to be decided as per the prevailing Rules only. It is
also submitted that in the said decision it has further been described
that mere grant of development permission will not automatically
become an absolute right for building sanction. Since the two aspects
are differently dealt with under the different provision of the
Development Rules, the building sanction was also to be granted
keeping in view the Development Rules which were in vogue,
therefore, though the application of the petitioners was made prior to
coming into force of the Development Rules, 2012, but incidentally
the same has remained pending and not decided till the Development
Rules, 2012 were brought in force and, therefore, the said application
was to be considered only and only under the provision of the
Development Rules, 2012. Thus, it is submitted that when the
development permission was granted to the petitioner under the Rules
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
of 1984 and as per the Master Plan, 1991, although the respondents
were required to consider the building permissions on the basis of the
provisions of the Rules of 2012, they were not authorized to
reconsider the development permission already granted to the
petitioner in respect of the development of the colony under the Rules
of 1984. Shri Jain has also submitted that so far as the building
permission is concerned, the same has to be considered under the
Rules of 2012 only and in that case, the respondents are entitled to
implement the rules on 2012. Thus, it is submitted that the petition
deserves to be allowed.
21]
Heard counsel for the parties and perused the record.
22]
From the record it is apparent that in the case at hand, the
interpretation of the Rules of 1984 as also the Rules of 2012 is
involved in the light of the provisions of the Adhiniyam of 1973.
Thus, at this stage it would be apt to refer to the relevant rules of the
provisions as aforesaid.
23]
For the purpose of this petition, Rules 2(5), 2(56) and 50(b) of
the Rules of 1984 are relevant, which read as under:“2(5). “Authority having jurisdiction” (hereinafter referred to
in these rules as “Authority” in relation to development and
building activities means –
(a)
For
permission
for The Director of Town and
development of land in Country Planning or any
planning
area
and other officer authorised by
non planning area authorized
him in this behalf.
(i) making of any material
change in land includes subdivision of land use of land in
terms of occupancy.
(ii) the Corporate development
inclusive of group housing
projects. (iii) any type of
building, including height of
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
building etc.
(iv) development of land,
construction/alteration,
demolition of building in area
beyond Municipal area but
within planning area.
(b)
For
permission
for Such Municipal Corporation
construction/alteration,
or Municipal Council, as the
demolition of building in case may be or such other
planning
area
and authority
or
officer
non planning area - 13
authorized by or under the
(i) In any area falling within the relevant Municipal Law to
local a Municipal Corporation grant such permission.
or Municipality and over which Such
Special
Area
Special Area Development Development Authority or
Authority has no jurisdiction.
such other officer of the
(ii) In any area over which a Authority as may be
Special Area Development authorised by such authority
Authority has jurisdiction.
in this behalf.
xxxxxxxx
2(56). “Sanctioned plan” means the set of plans and
specifications submitted under the rules in connection with a
building and duly approved and sanctioned by the Authority.
xxxxxxxxx
50. Requirements of Site.- No piece of land shall be used as a
site for the construction of building(a) xxxx
(b) if the site is within a distance of 9 metres of the highest
water mark and if there be major water course nearby the
distance of the plot from the same shall be 9 metres from
average high flood mark or 15 metres from the defined
boundary of water course, whichever is more;”
24]
So far as the Rules of 2012 are concerned, Rules 3, 4 and 13
read as under:“3. Applicability of the rules. – (1) Where land is to be
developed or redeveloped into sub-divisions, plots or colonies,
the rules shall apply to all such development and modifications
if any therein.
(2) Where a building is erected, the rules shall apply to the
design and construction of the building.
(3) Where the whole or any part of the building is demolished,
the rules shall apply to any remaining part and to the work
involved in demolition.
(4) Where a building is to be altered the rules shall apply to the
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
whole building whether existing or new, except that the rules
shall apply only to part if that part is completely self-contained
with respect to facilities and safety measures.
(5) Where the occupancy of a building is to be changed, the rules
shall apply to all parts of the building affected by the change.
4. Existing building.- Nothing is these rules shall require the
demolition, alteration or abandonment of a building existing on
the date on which the relevant provisions of these rules come
into force nor prevent continuance of the use or occupancy of an
existing building unless in the opinion of the Authority, such
building or portion thereon constitute a hazard to the safety of
the adjacent property or to the safety of the occupants of the
building itself.
xxxxxxxx
13. Development/Building permission issued prior to these
rules.- Any permission, sanction or approval given or order
passed or any action taken or anything done in respect of the
matters covered by these rules under any law or rule in force
immediately before the commencement of these rules shall be
governed in accordance with the provisions of law or rules under
which such sanction or approval was given order was passed or
any action was taken or anything was done, as if these rules have
not come into force : Provided that at the time of application for
renewal of such permission fresh sanction under these rules shall
be required for that part of the work which had not started and
the same may be granted.”
25]
Sections 2(f), 13(3), 24, 72, 73 and 74 of the Adhiniyam of
1973 reads as under:“2(f) “development” with its grammatical variations means the
carrying out of a building, engineering, mining or other
operation in, or over or under land, or the making of any
material change in any building or land or in the use of either,
and includes sub- division of any land.
xxxxxxx
13. Planning area. –
(1) xxxxxxx
(2) xxxxxxx
[(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Madhya Pradesh
Municipal Corporation Act, 1956 (No. 23 of 1956), the Madhya
Pradesh Municipalities Act, 1961 (No. 37 of 1961) or the
Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993 (No. 1 of
1994), the Municipal Corporation, Municipal Council or the
Nagar Panchayat or a Panchayat, as the case may be, shall, in
relation to the planning areas, from the date of the notification
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
issued under sub-section (1), cease to exercise the powers,
perform the functions and discharge the duties which the State
Government or the Director is competent to exercise, perform
and discharge under this Act.]
Xxxxxx
72. State Government's power of supervision and control. The State Government shall have power of superintendence and
control over the acts and proceedings of the officers appointed
under Section 3 and the authorities constituted under this Act.
Xxxx
74. Power of Government to review plans etc., for ensuring
conformity. - Notwithstanding anything contained in any other
enactment for the time being in force, the State Government
may, with a view to ascertaining that no repugnancy exists or
arises with the provisions of this Act or the rules made
thereunder, review the town improvement schemes, building
plans or any permission for construction sanctioned or given by
any authority under development plans, sanctioned under any
enactment for the time being in force and may revoke, vary, or
modify any scheme, plan, permission or sanction in order to
bring such scheme, plan, permission or sanction in conformity
with the provisions of this Act :
Provided that no order under this section shall be made
without giving a reasonable opportunity of being heard to the
persons affected thereby.”
26]
Section 426 of the Municipal Corporation Act reads as under:“426. Rules for inspection of institution and works of
Corporation The Government may make rules authorising
inspection under this Act by servants of the Government, of
Institutions and works which are under the Management and
control of the Corporation and regulating such inspection.
426.A. Removal of difficulties.-- If any difficulty arises in
giving effect to the provisions of this Act, the State
Government may, by order, do anything not inconsistent
with the provisions of this Act which appears to it to be
necessary or expedient for the purpose of removing the
difficulty.
426. B. Delegation of powers.-- The State Government may, by
notification delegate to any officer subordinate to it all or any of
the powers conferred upon it by or under this Act except the
power under section 422.”
27]
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
So far as the decision rendered by the Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court in the case of Ashish Kumar (Supra) is concerned, it is also
necessary to refer to the relevant paras of the said decision as on the
face of it, it appears that it provides that building plan in a
development area shall only be sanctioned by a Municipal authority
and it has to be as per the Development rules of 2012. The relevant
paras of the same read as under:“14 : The Scheme of the Rules are required to be examined and the
object of the said Rules are also to be considered first to ascertain
whether any change in the Development Rules is required to be taken
into consideration by the Building Sanction Authority or not. For the
said purposes the authorities, the fields, objects and reasons of the Rules
are required to be examined. The provisions were made under the
Development Rules, 1984, for grant of such sanction only, therefore, the
Rules of 1984 were made for the purposes of fulfilling the objects of the
Act of 1973, as is clear from the provisions of Section 85 of the Act of
1973. Since the development plans were to be approved under Rule 27
of the Rules of 12 1984, permission was required to be granted for the
said purposes. The definition as was provided under the Rules is also to
be kept in the mind. The definition as laid down under Rule 2(5), 2(29)
and 2(56) are relevant for consideration of the controversy involved in
the present case, therefore, the same are reproduced :“2(5). “Authority having jurisdiction” (hereinafter referred to
in these rules as “Authority” in relation to development and
building activities means –
(a)
For
permission
for The Director of Town and
development of land in Country Planning or any
planning
area
and other officer authorised by
non planning area authorized
him in this behalf.
(i) making of any material
change in land includes subdivision of land use of land in
terms of occupancy.
(ii) the Corporate development
inclusive of group housing
projects. (iii) any type of
building, including height of
building etc.
(iv) development of land,
construction/alteration,
demolition of building in area
beyond Municipal area but
within planning area.
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
(b)
For
permission
for Such Municipal Corporation
construction/alteration,
or Municipal Council, as the
demolition of building in case may be or such other
planning
area
and authority
or
officer
non planning area - 13
authorized by or under the
(i) In any area falling within the relevant Municipal Law to
local a Municipal Corporation grant such permission.
or Municipality and over which Such
Special
Area
Special Area Development Development Authority or
Authority has no jurisdiction.
such other officer of the
(ii) In any area over which a Authority as may be
Special Area Development authorised by such authority
Authority has jurisdiction.
in this behalf.
2(29). “Floor Area Ratio” means the ratio of the permissible
total of built up area in a building on all floors to the total plot
area of the land in question. (The ratio stipulates the maximum
of built quantity and no variations or exceptions shall be
allowed, except as specifically provided. The built up area as
stated would construe the total built up area on all floors with the
exception of lift wells, service ducts, machine room for lifts,
water tanks, covered parking areas, one entrance lobby/foyer on
ground floor, corridors, arcades, lobbies, mumptee, staircases but
inclusive of covered projections exceeding the limits prescribed
under Rule 58.
2(56). “Sanctioned plan” means the set of plans and
specifications submitted under the rules in connection with a
building and duly approved and sanctioned by the Authority.”
15 : The Development Rules, 1984, were made under the same powers
which have been exercised by the State Government for making of the
Development Rules, 2012. Therefore, if the definitions mentioned in the
said Development Rules, 2012 are examined, virtually the same
definitions have been incorporated in the new Rules only with the
change of serial number. The definition of 'Authority' having
jurisdiction as was given in Rule 2(5) 14 of the Development Rules,
1984, is reproduced at the same place at the same serial number in the
Development Rules, 2012. The definition of FAR given in Rule 2(29) of
the Development Rules, 1984 is separately given under Rule 2(30) of
the Development Rules, 2012, which reads thus :“2(30). “Floor Area Ratio” (FAR) means the ratio of total
built up area in a building on all floors to the total plot-area
of the land in question. The built up area shall mean the total
built up area on all floors excluding the area under lift wells,
service ducts, machine room for lifts, water tanks, escalator,
lift lobby, fire escapes, ramps, reftise chutes and service
ducts, mezzanine floor, balcony (upto a width of 1.20 mtrs)
parking areas, parking floors, mechanized parking areas,
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
porch, service floors, podiums, private garage (not exceeding
25 sq. mtrs.), servant quarter (not exceeding 25 sq. mtrs.),
basement subject to the provision of rule 76, corridors,
arcades, lobbies, mumptee, staircases, entrance lobby or
foyer atrium which is not used for commercial, activity,
pump room and two watchmen hut each not exceeding 6 sq
meters, but shall include covered projections exceeding the
limits prescribed under rule 58.
Provided that in commercial use premises, the area of
foyer(s) or entrance lobby (s) located on the ground floor
which exceeds 20% of permissible ground coverage shall be
counted in the FAR.
Note : If the built form below the ground or reference
level is used as habitable accommodation because of the
existing topography such area may be permitted as habitable
area and shall be counted in the Floor Area Ratio.”
16 : A comparison of these two definitions will show that barring for
some changes in excluding the areas of construction, much or less the
definition of the FAR was the same. Lastly, the definition of
“Sanctioned Plan” 15 as prescribed in Rule 2(56) of the Development
Rules, 1984, is the same and there is virtually no change in the said
definition except that the same is now provided under Rule 2(61) of the
Development Rules, 2012. The change in the concept of FAR was with
certain objects and for that reasons, when there was a change made in
the definition, the concept of the FAR was changed and, accordingly, the
limit of the said area is also prescribed differently.
17 : From the definition of authority given under Rule 2(5) of the
Development Rules, it is clear that separate applications are required to
be made for the purposes of grant of permission to develop the land and
an application for grant of building permission. The authorities are
distinctly prescribed for grant of such permission and sanction
specifically. The application for grant of approval of a plan to construct
a building is required to be made before the development authority,
which is required to be considered by the Director of Town and Country
Planning and permission is required to be granted in terms of the
relevant provision of the Rules referred to herein above. Once the
permission is granted, the intending builder/person interested in making
the construction is required to apply to the Municipal Corporation or the
Municipal Council as the case may be for grant of building permission,
under the relevant Municipal Laws read with the relevant Development
Rules. For the said purposes, the relevant provisions of Rules and their
effect and operation are required to be examined.
18 : Since permission was granted to the petitioners at the time when the
Development Rules, 1984 were in 16 vogue, it would be appropriate to
examine whether an absolute permission was granted to the petitioners
by the Development Authority or not. Part-III of the Development
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
Rules, 1984 deals with Permission and Inspection. Rule 14 of
Development Rules, 1984 prescribes that no person shall carry out any
development or erect, re-erect or make alterations or demolish any
building or cause the same to be done without obtaining a prior
permission in writing in this regard from the Authority. Here the word
“Authority” is to be examined in terms of the definition prescribed in
the very same Rules. As has been explained herein above, the definition
specifically prescribes different authorities having different jurisdiction
to deal with the subject matters prescribed in the Rules. It will not be out
of place to mention here that Authority having jurisdiction is
specifically referred as a word “Authority” in the entire Scheme of the
Development Rules, 1984 as is clear from the definition of Authority
having jurisdiction given under Rule 2(5) of the aforesaid Development
Rules. Therefore, for the purposes of permission for development of
land in planning area and non-planning area, the Director of Town and
Country Planning or any other Officer authorised by him in that behalf
was the Authority to grant such permission. For permission for
construction/alteration, demolition of a building in planning area and
non-planning area if it falls within the Municipal Corporation, the
Municipal Corporation was the authorised Authority under the
Development Rules, 1984 to grant such permission.
19 : From a perusal of Sub-rule (2) of Rule 14 of Development Rules,
1984, it is clear that this Rule specifically prescribes that permission for
development and in addition a permission for building shall be
necessary for commencement of building activities involving
development of land as a composite building Scheme. Sub-rule (3) of
Rule 14 of the Development Rules, 1984, specifically prescribes that for
construction for ground floor tenaments, with walls of non-combustible
material on plots not exceeding 50 square metres in site and service
schemes on plinth of 30 centimetres above ground level and with a
living room of not less than 7.5 square metres, no building permission
shall be required. Similarly, under rule 17 of the Development Rules,
1984, various provisions were made with respect to the preparation of
development plan which nowhere prescribes the standard of
construction of building, the total built up area, the FAR which is to be
maintained and all other necessary requirements of a building plan.
However, provisions of such a Rule make it clear that a tentative
building plan is to be prepared and is required to be placed before the
Development Authority for the purposes of considering whether the
development of the land is to be permitted for the purposes and object of
making a building as suggested in the building plan or not. Nothing
more is prescribed under the said Rule, with respect to the building
permission or the building plan.
xxxxxxxxxx
22 : The distinction in granting the permission to develop with the
approval of the plan and grant of actual building permission is to be kept
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
in mind in terms of the provisions made under Rule 21(4) of the
Development Rules, 1984. It is also to be seen that the developer after
obtaining permission of development is required to obtain 19 building
permission and then to keep such documents available at site before
starting the construction. The entire Scheme of the Rules as prescribed
in Part-IV deals with the development of the area and not with the
building plan which is specifically dealt with in Part-V for which the
competent authority to grant sanction would be only the local Municipal
Authority in terms of the Municipal Laws as prescribed in the definition
2(5) of the Development Rules, 1984.
Xxxxxxxxxxxxx
28 : In view of this, now it has to be examined whether any absolute
right had accrued to the petitioners in terms of the permission letter
dated 18.3.2011 or not. What would be the effect of the repeal of the
Development Rules, 1984 and whether only because said permission
was protected under the Development Rules, 2012, the building sanction
authority was required to grant building permission in terms of the
permission granted by the Development Authority. As has been
contended by the learned Senior counsel for petitioners, the effect of
repeal is required to be examined in terms of the provisions of General
Clauses Act, 1897 (hereinafter referred to as the Act of 1897 for
brevity). For the said purposes, the provision of Section 6 and 29 of the
Act of 1897 are relevant therefore, the same are reproduced thus :“6. Effect of repeal.- Where this Act, or any [Central Act]
or Regulation made after the commencement of this Act,
repeals any enactment hitherto made or hereafter to be
made, then, unless a different intention appears, the repeal
shall not –
(a) revive anything not in force or existing at the
time at which the repeal takes effect; or
(b) affect the previous operation of any enactment
so repealed or anything duly done or suffered
thereunder; or
(c) affect any right, privilege, obligation or liability
acquired, accrued or incurred under any enactment
so repealed; or
(d) affect any penalty, forfeiture or punishment
incurred in respect of any offence committed
against any enactment so repealed; or
(e) affect any investigation, legal proceeding or
remedy in respect of any such right, privilege,
obligation, liability, penalty forfeiture or
punishment as aforesaid, and any such
investigation, legal proceeding or remedy may be
instituted, continued or enforced, and any such
penalty, forfeiture or punishment may be imposed
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
as if the repealing Act or Regulation had not been
passed.”
“29. Saving for previous enactments, rules and byelaws.- The provisions of this Act respecting the
construction of Acts, Regulations, rules or bye-laws made
after the commencement of this Act shall not affect the
construction of any Act, Regulation, rule or bye-law made
before the commencement of this Act, although the Act,
Regulation, rule or bye-law is continued or amended by
an Act, Regulation, rule or bye-law made after the
commencement of this Act.”
29 : A plain and simple meaning of these provisions would be that in
case any Rules which were in vogue on earlier occasion and certain acts
have been done under the said Rules, are subsequently repealed, the act
done or the right accrued under the said Rules while the same were in
vogue would not be taken away unless specifically provided in the new
Rules or Act. For this reason, now the provisions of the Development
Rules, 2012, and specially the provisions of Repeal and Savings are
required to be examined. Rules 13 of the Development Rules, 2012,
prescribed the Savings. The same is reproduced as a whole:“13. Development/Building permission issued prior to
these rules.- Any permission, sanction or approval given
or order passed or any action taken or anything done in
respect of the matters covered by these rules under any
law or rule in force immediately before the
commencement of these rules shall be governed in
accordance with the provisions of law or rules under
which such sanction or approval was given order was
passed or any action was taken or anything was done, as if
these rules have not come into force :
Provided that at the time of application for renewal of
such permission fresh sanction under these rules shall be
required for that part of the work which had not started
and the same may be granted.”
30 : Similarly, Rule 105 of Development Rules, 2012 prescribes Repeal
and Saving, which reads thus :105. Repeal and Savings.-(1) The Madhya Pradesh
Bhoomi Vikas Rules, 1984 and the amendments made
therein, from time to time, hereby stand repealed,
provided that,
(a) such repeal shall not affect the validity of the licences
previously granted to engineers, town-planners etc, the
previous operation of the said rules, or anything done, or
any action taken, thereunder;
(b) any application submitted under the repealed rules,
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
pending at the commencement of these rules shall be
continued and disposed of in accordance with the
provisions of these rules i.e. Madhya Pradesh Bhumi
Vikas Rules, 2012;
(c) nothing in these rules shall be construed as depriving
any person to whom these rules apply of any right of
appeal which had accrued to him under the rules hereby
repealed.”
31 : The plain and simple reading of Rule 13 of Development Rules,
2012, leaves no room to doubt that all previous sanction granted under
the Development Rules, 1984, would remain in operation even when the
Rules are repealed and any right accrued under the said sanction would
not be jeopardised only because of coming into force of the
Development Rules, 2012. Similarly, the first part of Rule 105
prescribes that the repeal of the Development Rules, 1984, shall not
affect the validity of the licences previously granted to the engineers,
town planners, etc. and the previous operation of the said Rules, or
anything done, or any action taken thereunder. Probably this will not be
required to be interpreted as all acts done, orders passed under the
Development Rules, 1984 are protected by this clause. The other part of
this deals with safeguarding the appeals or any other proceedings,
instituted under the Development Rules, 1984. The said part is also not
materially important. The only clause which according to the
respondents is applicable in the present case is sub-clause (b) of sub-rule
(1) of Rule 105. This deals with making of the applications at the time
when the Development Rules, 1984 were in vogue which could not be
decided and were pending when the Development Rules, 2012 were
brought in force. The specific condition mentioned in this clause is that
all such applications shall be continued and disposed of in accordance
with the provisions of these Rules i.e. M.P. Bhoomi Vikas Rules, 2012.
This particular provision made in Rule 105 is, therefore, an express
provision of the intention of Rule Making Authority. Whether the
applications were made before coming into force of the Development
Rules, 2012, or not was immaterial. The fact which was to be taken note
of was whether the application was decided prior to coming into force
of the Development Rules, 2012 or not. Of course this provision would
be applicable to such application for grant of permission of development
made before the Development Authorities, and which were not decided.
The applications which were considered and decided were not to be
treated as pending applications.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
36 : As has been explained herein above, there were three fold
applications to be made, (i) for grant of permission from the
Development Authority, (ii) grant of licence or permission from the
Colinizer Authority, and (iii) an application for grant of building
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
permission. The two applications were required for permission to enable
the petitioners to apply for grant of building permission and, therefore,
if such permission were granted by the competent Authority under the
relevant Rules, which were in force at the relevant time, the petitioners
could have made the application before the Municipal Corporation for
the purposes of grant of building sanction, but as has been pointed out,
the said building sanction was also to be granted under the relevant
provisions of the Development Rules read with provisions of the Act of
1956. It has further been described that mere grant of development
permission will not automatically become an absolute right for building
sanction. Since the two aspects are differently dealt with under the
different provision of the Development Rules, the building sanction was
also to be granted keeping in view the Development Rules which were
in vogue. Therefore, though the application of the petitioners was made
prior to coming into force of the Development Rules, 2012, but
incidentally the same has remained pending and not decided till the
Development Rules, 2012 were brought in force and, therefore, the said
application was to be considered only and only under the provision of
the Development Rules, 2012. These findings are required to be
recorded in terms of the law already laid down by the Apex Court in the
cases of J.S. Yadav (supra) and Andhra Pradesh Dairy Development
Corporation Federation (supra). A vested right only, available to the
petitioners was not to be denied. The law as has been discussed by the
Apex Court in that respect in the case of J.S. Yadav (supra) in
paragraphs 20, 21 and 22, explains this, which reads thus :“20. "The word 'vested' is defined in Black's Law
Dictionary (6th Edition) at page 1563, as vested; fixed;
accrued; settled; absolute; complete. Having the character
or given the rights of absolute ownership; not contingent;
not subject to be defeated by a condition precedent.' Rights
are 'vested' when right to enjoyment, present or prospective,
has become property of some particular person or 15
persons as present interest; mere expectancy of future
benefits, or contingent interest in property founded on
anticipated continuance of existing laws, does not constitute
vested rights. In Webster's Comprehensive Dictionary
(International Edition) at page 1397, 'vested' is defined as
(law held by a tenure subject to no contingency; complete;
established by law as a permanent right; vested interest."
(See: Mosammat Bibi Sayeeda & Ors. etc. v. State of Bihar
& Ors. etc., AIR 1996 SC 1936).
21. The word "vest" is normally used where an immediate
fixed right in present or future enjoyment in respect of a
property is created. With the long usage the said word
"vest" has also acquired a meaning as "an absolute or
indefeasible right". It had a "legitimate" or "settled
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
expectation" to obtain right to enjoy the property etc. Such
"settled expectation" can be rendered impossible of
fulfilment due to change in law by the Legislature. Besides
this, such a "settled expectation" or the so-called "vested
right" cannot be countenanced against public interest and
convenience which are sought to be served by amendment
of the law. (Vide: Howrah Municipal Corpn. & Ors. v.
Ganges Rope Co. Ltd. & Ors., (2004) 1 SCC 663).
22. Thus, "vested right" is a right independent of any
contingency. Such a right can arise from a contract, statute
or by operation of law. A vested right can be taken away
only if the law specifically or by necessary implication
provide for such a course.”
37 : Therefore, it has to be held that no vested right had accrued to the
petitioners to claim grant of building sanction only under the provisions
of the Development Rules, 1984. In fact, there was no absolute right
accrued to the petitioners to claim such building permission even when
the Development Rules, 1984 were in vogue and if under the
circumstances, the building sanction authority was of the opinion that
the petitioners were not to be granted the FAR of 2.5, a sanction could
have been granted for a lesser FAR. That being so, the entire contentions
raised by learned Senior counsel for the 36 petitioners that a vested right
has been taken away by the respondent Municipal Corporation by
passing the order impugned cannot be accepted. This is further to be
seen from the provisions of the Rules prescribed in Part-III of the
Development Rules where specific provisions are made in Sub-Rule (2)
of Rule 14 of Development Rules, 1984 as also Rule 12(3) of
Development Rules, 2012 that both the permission for development and
in addition, a permission for building shall be necessary for
commencement of the building activities. The development permission
was depending on grant of building sanction, as a composite plan was
made by the petitioners for development and building.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
28]
A perusal of the aforesaid decision rendered by the co-ordinate
Bench of this Court clearly reveals that in the said case the issue of
grant of FAR which the petitioner was claiming under the old
Development Rules. This judgement does not suggest that even the
development permission and the grant of license or permission from
the colonizer authority would also have to be reviewed, which have
been granted as per the old Rules of 1984 and the Master Plan 1991,
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
while considering an application for grant of building permission
which was filed under the Rule of 1984, and is to be decided as per
the Development Rules of 2012. What this Court has held is that an
application for building permission which was filed as per the Rules
of 1984 has to be decided as per the Development Rules of 2012 only,
which is the mandate of clause (b) of Sub Rule 1 of Rule 105 of the
Rules of 2012. Thus, the aforesaid decision cannot be pressed into
service to hold that even the development permission and the
colonizer permissions are not valid after the Development Rules of
2012 came into force. Thus, the aforesaid decision is clearly
distinguishable and has only limited application in the facts and
circumstances of the case regarding those applications for building
permission which were either filed prior to commencement of the
Development Rules of 2012 or have been filed subsequent thereto.
29]
A perusal of the record also reveals that on 09.05.2022, this
Court has also passed an interim order in favour of the petitioners to
carry out the construction activities in respect of those plots which are
not disputed. The aforesaid order reads as under:“Heard on the question of admission.
Counsel for the petitioners has sought the interim reliefs, however, he
is pressing for the interim relief No.(iii) only, which is reproduced as
under:“(iii) the Respondent No.3 may kindly be directed at least
to grant building permissions to the plots, having no
concerned with the present controversy.”
Counsel for the petitioners has submitted that the controversy
involved in the case is in respect of the plots situated in the vicinity of
30 meters area of the river Saraswati, as has been directed by the
National Green Tribunal ((hereinafter referred as the“NGT”) in its order
dated 19.7.2017, which has also been filed along with the reply by the
respondent No.3 / Indore Municipal Corporation, Indore and thereafter,
the State Government has also passed the order for compliance of the
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
aforesaid order passed by the NGT.
Counsel has further submitted that the petitioner, (in W.P.
No.19332/2021) is a registered company and various plots have been
sold to the share holders as per the sanctioned map in the year 2005, and
thereafter the order of NGT has been passed directing the State
Government to ensure that there should be no construction within 30
meters of Full Tank Level (FTL) all the lakes in the State. It is further
submitted that obeying the aforesaid order, the petitioners are also not
inclined to make any construction within vicinity of 30 meters of bank
of the river Saraswati as this issue is under challenge before this Court
only and any future construction on this strap would be governed by the
final order passed in this petition, however, in the sanctioned map, there
are other 1100 odd plots also involved which have nothing to do with
the present controversy. Thus, it is submitted that the aforesaid plot
holders be allowed to carry out the construction and other activities in
respect of the plots which do not come within 30 meters limit of the
river.
Shri Manoj Munshi, counsel appearing for the respondent No.3/
Indore Municipal Corporation, Indore has opposed the prayer and it is
submitted that as per the NGT's order as also the order passed by the
State Government, the Municipal Corporation is the duty bound to
comply with the same and in such circumstances, no construction can be
made until the final disposal of this petition.
On due consideration of the rival submissions and on perusal for the
documents filed on record, it is found that so far as the NJT's order is
concerned, the same reads as under:“Learned counsel submits that the information is still
awaited. We direct that at present all building
permissions that may have been granted for allowing
construction within 30 meters of the Full Tank Level
(FTL) of all the lakes in the State shall be put on hold.
Copy of this order shall be sent to the Chief Secretary,
who in turn is directed to ensure the compliance by the
forwarding the appropriate directions to the local
authorities. Copy be also given to the Principal Secretary,
Urban Development Department for compliance.
Companies of this order shall be reported by the
learned counsel for the State on the next date of hearing.
Let the matter be listed on 23rd August, 2017.”
(emphasis supplied in original)
On perusal of the aforesaid order, this Court finds that the dispute is
purely in respect of the plots which are situated within the vicinity of 30
meters of the bank of Saraswati river. However, so far as the other 1100
odd plots are concerned, they are not situated within the aforesaid area
and in such circumstances, to restrain them from further construction
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
work would be onours to them as the plots have been sold by the
petitioner to the respective plot holders in the year 2005 itself and all the
development activities have already been complete. In view of the same,
it is directed that till the final disposal of this petition, the petitioner or
any other person shall not construct or carry out any activity within the
vicinity of 30 meters area of the bank of Saraswati river as has been
directed by the respondent No.2 to the petitioner. However, so far as the
other plots are concerned, they are excluded from the order passed by
the NGT and as such, the Respondent No.3 is directed to grant building
permissions to the plot owners in accordance with law and allow them
to carry out other development activities pursuant thereto.
Let the matter be listed in the week commencing 01/8/2022.
Signed copy of the order be kept in Writ Petition No.19332/2021 and
the copy whereof be placed in the other connected
W.P.Nos.21216/2021,21400/2021,21511/2021,21960/2021,23078/2021,
23082/2021, 23887/2021, 25737/2021, 27114/2021, 27878/2021,
28757/2021, 00929/2022, 04824/2022.”
30] Thus, it is apparent that this court has already directed the
respondents to allow the building permission of those plot owners of
the colony whose plots are outside the 30-meter perimeter from river
Saraswati, meaning thereby, the layout plan of the colony is not to be
disturbed as it has been sanctioned by the competent authority in
accordance with law.
31]
Now, coming to the merits of the case, it is found that the
petitioner Company was constituted under Section 25 of the
Companies Act for the purpose of providing plots to its shareholders
on „no profit no loss‟ basis and was not constituted to earn any profits.
It is also found that in pursuance of their objective, the petitioner have
also purchased a huge piece of land ad-measuring 46.30 acres at
Village Tejpur, Gadbadi bearing Survey Numbers as aforesaid and
also obtained the development permission (layout sanction) for New
Cloth Market from respondent No.2, which were granted in a phased
manner on 02/09/1995, 27/11/1997, 02/11/2000, 13/11/2004 and lastly
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
on 01/02/2005 as per the prevailing Rules of 1984, and based on the
aforesaid sanction, the Municipal Corporation also granted its
development permission on 01/02/2006, vide Annexure P/3. A careful
reading of the aforesaid documents and the provisions cited above
would lead this Court to believe that the respondent No.3 cannot seek
the review of the plan and ask the petitioner or the respondent No.2 to
issue a fresh plan as per the Rules of 2012, and if the respondent
No.3‟s contentions are to be accepted, it would frustrate the very
purpose of Rule 105 of the Rules of 2012, which clearly provides that,
„the repeal shall not affect the validity of the licences previously
granted to the engineers, town planners etc, the previous operation of
said rules or anything done or any action taken thereunder shall not
be affected’.
32]
Thus, this Court finds force in the submissions as advanced by
Shri Jain, senior counsel appearing for the petitioner that the
respondent No.3 cannot be permitted to interfere with the sanction of
plan earlier granted to the petitioner under the Rules of 1984 as the
earlier orders passed by the respondent No.2 are already saved by
Rule 105 of the Rules of 2012. This Court is also of the considered
opinion that while considering the separate applications of the plot
owners for building permission, the respondent No.3 is required to
follow the Rules of 2012 as also provisions of the Municipal
Corporation Act, which are in respect of control and powers of the
State Government.
33]
So far as the final order dated 13/12/2021, passed by the
National Green Tribunal is concerned, counsel for the petitioner has
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
submitted that the aforesaid order was passed in respect of the seven
water bodies of the Balaghat city and although, certain other
observations have also been made by the Green Tribunal, hence those
observations could not be made applicable on the parties involved in
the present petition.
34]
On perusal of the said order passed by the Green Tribunal,
reference may be had to its paras 15, 18 and 19 which read as under:“15. At the outset, we make it clear that this Tribunal is not a
forum to go into correctness or otherwise of the decisions already
taken in any other judicial proceedings. Thus, scope of proceedings
before this Tribunal is to deal with the environmental issues. With
regard to individual issues, without expressing any opinion in these
proceedings, it is made clear that any party is free to take remedies
in accordance with law.
xxxxxx
18.
In view of above, as far as issue to protection of water
bodies generally is concerned, the same stands concluded and the
authorities in the State of MP may deal with the matter in
accordance with the said directions. Needless to say that in the
light of judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in M.K.
Balakrishnan and Ors. vs. Union of India, M.C. Mehta v. Kamal
Nath & Ors. and Hinch Lal Tiwari v. Kamala Devi, the State
Authorities are under obligation to protect the water bodies. Water
becoming contaminated cannot be a ground to change the land use
and destroy such water body.
19.
The application will stand disposed of accordingly with a
direction that the compliance of environmental norms for
protection of water bodies may be monitored in every district by
the District Magistrate at regular intervals which may also be
monitored by the Chief Secretary of the State in accordance with
the directions of this Tribunal on the subject quoted above. Since
any decision of the State Authorities has to be compliant with the
Central Environmental Laws on the subject, inter alia, Air Act,
Water Act, Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 and Rules/Orders
framed thereunder, including Wetland Rules, any earlier decision
including decision with regard to change of land use or master plan
may be liable to be revisited in the light thereof.
20.
Since we have not found it viable to go into individual
violations simultaneously with the larger general issue of
protection of water bodies, any individual surviving grievance is
left open to be gone into independently in any independent
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
proceeding in respect of such individual issue by setting out such
individual grievance, impleading concerned individual party and
giving the date of cause of action to determine whether the matter
is within the prescribed limitation as per NGT Act.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
35]
Counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, has submitted
that even in the final order passed by the Green Tribunal, a general
direction has been issued to the authorities and to every District
Magistrate to ensure proper monitoring of the water bodies for their
protection and any earlier decision including decision with regard to
change of land use or Master Plan, may be liable to be revisited in the
light of the aforesaid order.
36]
Having considered the aforesaid submissions as well, this Court
is of the considered opinion that the aforesaid decision of the NGT
would not be applicable in the facts and circumstances of the case
where all the requisite permissions under the law were already
obtained by the petitioners under the provisions of M.P. Bhoomi Vikas
Niyam, 1984 and the Master Plan, 1991 whereas, the respondents are
applying the provisions of M.P. Bhoomi Vikas Niyam, 2012 and
Master Plan, 2021 to reject the building permission of the petitioners.
Admittedly, neither the land use has been changed, nor the Master
Plan has been revisited so far as the land in question is concerned, and
as this Court has already held that the decision rendered by the coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Ashish Kumar (supra) is
distinguishable, the petitioners are entitled to obtain the building
permission in accordance with law, as the building permission cannot
be denied on the basis of the Rules of 2012 that the plot is within the
30 meters from the water body. This Court is also of the considered
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
opinion that while deciding the application for building construction,
the respondents may resort to the subsequent rules for the purposes of
FAR etc, but the permission itself cannot be rejected altogether, citing
the provisions of subsequent Rules or the new Master Plan. In view of
the same, the petition stands allowed and the impugned orders dated
19/06/2019, 14/03/2020, 15/01/2021 and 15/06/2021 are hereby
quashed.
37]
Let a copy of this order be kept in other connected writ
petitions.
38]
With the aforesaid, the petitions are allowed and disposed of.
(SUBODH ABHYANKAR)
JUDGE
Bahar
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:36:26 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review