Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 321e ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF SEPTEMBER
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE TANGIRALA MADHAVI DEVI
WRIT PETITION NO:23323 OF 2026
Between:
Sunkari Saritha, W/o. Late. Mahesh, Aged about 44 yearc, Occ: House-Hold,
Rl/o. H.No.3-41 11, Laxrnipur Village, Manthani Mandal, Peddapalli- District.
... Petitioner
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Represented by lt's Principal Secretary, Home
Department. Office at, Secretariat Hyderabad.
2. The District Magistrate & Collector, Peddpalli District.
3. The Commissioner of Police, Ramagundam.
4. The Station House Officer, Kalva Srirampur Police Station.
5. The Executive Magistrate and Tahsildar, Kalva Srirampur Mandal.
... Respondents
Petition under Article 226 ol the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue writ more particularly one in the nature of a writ of CERTIORARIFIED
MANDAMUS under Article 226 of Constitution of lndia or any other appropriate Writ
or order or direction by call for the records relating to the Crime bearing No.21 of
2026 for the offence under section 194 BNSS Correspondence section 174 Cr.P.C.
on the file Kalava-srirampur police and declaring the respondent police final report
' before the respondent Tahsildar for requesting to close as suicidal death by
consuming Herbicide Poison due to depression caused by conflicts with her husband
and issue proceedings accordingly the action of closing, is illegal arbitrary and
violative of A(icles 14 and21 of constitution of lndia, consequently direct the
respondents to consider the petitioners representation dated.. 23-June-2O26,22-
June-2026, 23-03-2026 for DENOVO lnvestigation and initiate necessary penal
actions against respondents police and Tahsildar for misled the supra offence under
section 306, 498-4 IPC to 174 Cr.P.C and caused to closed the crime in the interest
of justice.
l.A. NO: 1OF 2026
Petition under Section '1 51 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to DIRECT
the respondents to consider the petitioners representation dated.. 23-June -2026, 22-
June-2026, 23-03-2026 for DENOVO lnvestigation and initiate necessary penal
actions against respondents polrce and Tahsiidar for misled the supra offence under
section 306 498-A IPC to 174 Cr.P.C and caused to closed the crime in the interest
of justice
Counsel for the Petitioner: Sri. M. Phanindra Bhargav
Counsel forthe Respondent Nos.1, 3 & 4: GP For Home
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 & 5: GP For Revenue
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR TIIE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT IIYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE TANGIRALA
MADHAVI DEVI
wRIT Plrrl't'ION NO.23323 0F 2026
(CNR No.HBHC010482002026)
DATED :09.09.2026
Betwcen
Sunkari Saritha
. Petitioner
;\Nt)
'lhe State o1-'[-elangar.ra" rcpresented by its
Principal Secretary, Home I)epartment,
Olfice at Secretariat, I lyderabad and othcrs
.. Respondents
ORDI]R
'l'his Writ Petition is filed secking a Writ of Mandamus to call fbr
recolds relating to Crimc No.2I of'1016 on lhc flle o1'Kaiavasrirarnpur
Police Station fbr thc ofl-cnce r-rnder Scction 194 ot' BNSS/Section 174
of Cr.P.C., and to declare the llnal report filed by the respondent police
belbre the respondcr.rt'l'ahsildar closing thc case as "suicidal death o1-thc
1N4D.J
\I P No.23123 0f 2026
deceased by cor-rsuming herbicide poison due to depression caused by
conflicts rvith her husband" and issuing proceedings accordingly, as
illegal. albitrar)' and liolative ol Articles 14 and 2 I of the Constitution
of India and consequctltl\ to direct the responclcnts to consider the
represcntations ol the petitioner dt.23.03.2026, 22.06.2026 and
13.06.1016 lor dc noro inrestigation and to pass such other older or
orders
2.
Brief facts leading to the filing of the present Writ Petition are
Lhat thc petitioncr is the mother ol tlrc deceased Kondeti Reeshma. It is
subrnitted that thc pctitionet 's daughtcr Kondeti l{eeshrna was married
to one Sri Koteslit,ar thrcc r e ars ago and lhey rr crc blcssed with a baby
girl Shrc; anr,'i rvho is t* o le ars old. [t is subrnitted that the petitioner
receivcd infbrmation that hel daughter was admitted in Government
hospital at Peddapalli and later shifted to Hyderabad and she went there
and lbund that her tlaughtel rras in unconscious condition and since her
condition was critical in I']cddapalli. she was shifted to Yashoda
llospital. Secunc]c.rabad tbr adr. anced trcatrxent. Horvevcr, due to high
cost., hcr daughtcr- * as r.oadntittcd in Cover.nrnent tlospital. peddapalli
on 17.02.2026. br-rr on rhe sarxc day. her daughter died while undergoing
T\4D.J
treatment
W.P. No.23321 o12026
It is subrnitted that thcr-calicr, the petitioner has lodged a
cornplaint with the police on 18.02.2026 infbnning about the suspicious
circumstances under which her daughter has died. lt is submitted that
since the petitioner was illiterate, her cornplaint was drafted and scripted
by a police constable without explaining about the contents ol the
complaint. The petitioner had complained that her son-in-law has caused
her daughter to commil- suicide but tl're respondent police rrisinterpreted
the complaint and closed the case and aggrieved thereby, the petitioner
addressed a letter to the rcspondent police on 22.03.2026 stating that the
petitioner purchased a washing machinc and gavc it to hcr son-in-Jaw,
but thereafier also her daughter was harassed lor additional dowrT as she
gave birth to a baby girl and the petitioner gave Rs. 1,00,000/-, but her
son-in-law and his family werc not satisfled and I-ur-ther harassed hcr
daughter and the petitioner paid a sum ol Rs.3,00,000/- on 08.02.2026
and even then, they were not satist-led and the petitioner has also held a
local panchayat u,ith villagc clders ar.rd tl'rcrcalicr, the petitioner's
daughter was taken homc by her husband, but on 16.02.2026 the
petitioner got inlormation through her son-in-law that her daughter
consuped grass pesticide and he has tal<en his wife to Government
Hospital. Peddapalli and thercalier shilted to Yashoda Hospital,
I N4 D.J
\\.P No.23123 of2026
Secundcrabad lbr bcttcr LrcatntenL and that the petitioner had gone
direcrly to Yashoda Flospital. Secunderabad and thereafter was shifted to
Peddapalli Govemrrent hospital where the doctors have dcclared that
the petitioner's daughter died on 18.02.2026. She complained that it was
her son-in-lan' rvho harassed the pctitioner's daughter mentally and
physically. due to which she consutned pesticide conlntit suicide. It is
sLrbrnittccl that thc police Lhlcatctrccl thc pctitioncr not to rclcal to
anyone about the complaint as that u,ould put her lile in peril and that
the policc har,c nol even seizcd thc deccased's phone and without any'
intirnation to thc peLitioncr, the respondcnt police requested thc
lahsildar to close the case as 'suicidal death by' consuming herbicide
poison due to dcpression caused by conflicts rvith her husband' and to
I:]SL]C
n rrrc ced in s
s accordirtglr
It is sr-rbrrrtLcd that th. pctitioner has
addrcssed a letter to the Coutrissioner o1- Police, Ramagundatn on
23,06.1026 and also to thc
-l-ahsildar.
Kalavasriratllpul on 22.06.2026 to
rcopcn the crinrc arrd conduct irrr cstigaLion about tl-re harassment mete d
out to her daughter'. but thc respondents havc not responded, but instead,
have threatencd thc pe titioner to r.r ithdraw the complaint
3.
I MI],J
W.l' No.2llli ol l016
Learned counscl tbr thc pclitioner placcd reliance upon the
judgrtrent of the Hon'ble Suprernc Courl in the case of Vinay Tyagi Vs.
Irshad Ali @ Deepak and othersr and also relied upon the judgment olthe [{on'ble Suprcrre Court in thc casc of Anant 'I'hanur Karmuse Vs.
State of Maharashtra and others2 on the power of the Constitutional
Court for direction of de novo and rc- inr,'estigat ion.
4.
[-earned Assistant (iovcrnntenI Pleadcr lbr Horne. on written
instructions. subrnitted that on receipt of the representation of the
petrtloner on 23.06.2026. thc Comrnissioncr of Police. vrde letter'
dt.23.06.2026 directed the Circle lnspecror ol- Police, Sulthanabad to
conduct an enquiry inlo the allegations rradc by thc pctitioner and
subnrit a detailed report and accordingly, detailed enqLriry was
conducted and thc cnquirl. rr.porl \\ as subnrittcd whercir.r it ,,ras statcd
that the allegations rnade by thc petitioner were not supponed by the
con tern poraneous record. It was stated that inrmedialell, alter. the death
of her daughter', i.e., on 18.02.2026, rhe petitioner herself subrnitted a
wfl tten complaint before the Sub-lnspector of Police, Kalvasrirampur
rCt'itttinal Appcal Nos.20J0-201lol
dr.ll ll.l0l2
10ll . r\ ny oUt ol Sl.P(('rl.)Nos9l85-t)l116rrj l009
Crirninal Appcal \o li ol l0l.l clr.ll.0l lUll
I \1D..1
\\' I'. N o.l-1i Ii oil0l()
Police Station stirtirlg thirt hcr claughtcr had cornmitted suicide br
consunring he|hrcidcigrass poison due to stotrach pain and she lrad no
suspicion re.earclin!. rhc dcath ol'her daughter and that on re-qistration o1
thc vu'riltcr-r conrl.rlulrt. a casc itl ('rinre No,l I ol'1016 urrdcr Scction l9:1
of tINSS u as tcsistet ed artd statutory enqr-ri11 rvas conducted. It is
subrritred thal thc police hare collected and eramined the relevant
rura[criril couctrnittLl thc dcath and on thc basis ol- such evidence, thc
casc \\ as reli'r'retl as -suiciclal clcath. Ile strbnlits tlrat sLtbseqr-rent
rcprcseutation ntatlc br Lhe pctitioncr l'ras onil t() reopen the tnatter bv
intl()dLlcin,s alLcqatiorts rihich tct'c llot part ol hcr original complaint.
ri hich *c-rc nol cotttclttpolatlcoLls Lo her oliginal \ et's lor
5.
(
l-he .lahsildar. Sriratlpttr Mandal. Peddapalli District
rcsIondcnt \ tr.5 lulso has Illcd writren instrLrctions and he sublxitted
I
that it rvas thc opinion of thc panchas that the deceased has expired due
to c()nsIr11pti(-] r o1' Lrnlinori n fcsticidc arrd the rt' was no doubt in the
carrsc Lr1'death ot'thc dcccasccl arrd the rclirre. the llnal report submittcd
b) rcsl..ondent \ o J rr a: accc1.rt.'ti
6.
On a qLrer'1 1r'ont this ('ourt as to the authority of the Executive
\laqisrlarc'i a lt s iltll
r
Ut ace cJrtirrt the final rcporl
of the suiciclal death.
W.P No ljili
I MI),J
0t t0l6
the learned Assistant Government pleader lbr Home has relied upon thc
provisions of Section 174 of Cr.P.C. (corresponding Section 194 ol
BNSS) u,here the -lahsildar/Fixccutivc Magistrate has power or authority
to receive and act upon the police linallclosure reporl.
7,
Lcarned counscl lbr thc peLitioncr. howcvcr.. has solrght
a
direction to the respondcnt police to r.cinrcstigate thc lnattcr
8.
This court has fbund that rhe issue of ar-rthority ol the Executive
Magistrate in accepting the finar repofl or suicidal death has lauen ror
considcration befbre thc Madurai ucnch o1- lvladr.as t.ligh court in the.
case o1' Manohari vs. -rhc District Superintendent of porice,
Sivagangai District and othersj and thc IIigh (.'ourr. aficr taking into
consideration the pror,'isiorrs of Sccti.n I 74 of Cr.p.c., has observed tha[
the final repofl therein was fired belbrc RDO, Thanjavur.under Section
174 ol Cr.P.C. and has obsen,ecl that such a procedure is completely.
in
violation of the guidelincs issued b' thc Cou11. It was observed that thc
report has to be filed bcfore the Judiciar Magistratc and not befbre
thc
Executivc Magistrate. 'rhe court thcrcrbrc set aside thc final report
and
directed reinvestigation into thL- nrattcl
C{1. OP (MD) Nos t55lj of l0t8 and
.
| 76t ot t0 t, irnd I 1802 of 20 t8 dr. t7.09.2018
I }1D.J
{l
9.
\\.P. \o llSll ol 1016
Il rlas noticcrl that r Coordinatc l]ench of this Court also. in the
casc ot ll.,fava L-axmi Vs. 'fhc State of Telangana rep. b!' its Prl,
Secrctary for Honrc{ cousidcrcd thc said.judgrnent ol the Madras t Iigh
( oLr t ,rnd has oh.cr'\ crl thaL Scction 17.1 o1- ('r.l).('. docs not envisagc
filing o1' t-rnal rep,rrt bcf ore Lxecr-rtir c Magistratc. l his Courl also has
directerl Lhe poliL c to lllc rhc final report bcfbre tlrc jurisdictional
Maqislratc of ['irsl ( ]ass Lrnder Scction 173(l) ot- Cr.l',C., i.e.. Section
193(l) ot'llNSS
10. Irr vieq ol'tlrcsc .juderrcnts and also on perusal of the conrplaint
gircn lrr tlrc prt ti,rne r rrncl also tlrc llnal rcporl. this ( ourt llnds that thc
rcsponilcnt policc harr' not con(lLrctcd thc investigation oroperly and not
eren ol,tained the \,ll ( lronr Lhc hospital uhele thc dcceased died. but
harc lllcd linal r'.'port as suiciclal clcath. l'he lrndinpls of the police
appeal to be not in cor]lbrrnitr rt ith ant' evidence on lecord and as held
in tlrc above ,:lecisions. the final rcporl cannot be llled befbre the
lixccutir r' N'lag stratr'. htrt the s{llIe has to bc fl lcd belole thc
jurisdicLional .lLrilie rll \llgistratc ol'I'irst ('lass. In thrs casc. admittcdly.
thc dcceased died rrithin sc\en \cars o1'hcr nralriage and the pror isions
\\ lr \(\ r--< (,f:(r i .lt .() rr
fMD-.I
W.l' No.2li2i o12026
ol- Sub-section (3) ol' Secrion ir94 ot' BNSS would apply and the
respondents have not conducted the enquiry as per the provisions of
Section 194 ol BNSS. I"or thc sakc of rcadr, rc|ercrcc. Section 194 olBNSS is cxtracted as under
',5. 191. Police to enquirc und report
on suicide. etc, ( l) When
tha ollic'cr in thurga o/ u poliLt .\t(rtion or .sonc other polic.c o[/icer
specicrlly cmpot,ererl h.y,thc Stutc (jot.ernnrunt in rhut behulf rec.eivt.t
informotbn that a pcrson h{t.\ Lommitted.\uit.itla. or has been ki ed tty
urutlhcr rtr by un unimul or b1 ntuchiner.t. or b1, un ac.t.itlenl, or htts
cliecl untlcr cir(um.\lon(a.t rtti.sing tt t.cu.s0nuhla .su.s:1.tit,ion th(tl
.\onc
olher ltarson hus cttmmi ccl un o//cnt.a ht .shalt intmccliutall. gita
inlintulion lhctto/ lo tht ntttrtst l..rtc.ttlit,c .\l(t,gi.\lr(tle ttttl.trtrarctl
lo
hold inquc,sl.:. untl. tttla.ss othrnr i.:t, tltt.at.tcd h.t. ut.4 r.trlc tttula b.t. tht
Slatt Goyarnntcnt, or.by un).Kentrul rtt .:1tcc.iul order rtf th( Di.\lriL.l
or Sub-divi.sionol Magi.\trote. .shttll proceetl to the plocc tt.here Ihe
hodl ct/ .suth tle ttu.satl ptt.:ott i.s ttnLl tlttrt in th(, pt.(.\e nL.r of t\t
o ()t.
more respec,tttble inhahtt(tnts,tl tht. nr ighh,, tthoLtcl. ,;h,tll ntuke
un
investigalbn. and drar up Lt t.(porl ol the uplturent cuu:c
of tlauth.
describing such yt ounds, frttc.tura.s. ttruisa.s und olher murk.s
o/. inlury
tts mcry be /ound on tha hotlv. Lrttt./ .strtting in \ hut nlunncr.
or h.t, v,hrtt
ttct:tpon or inslrU lf t /i/ utt.tt tttc.lt tL k.\ (tpp(ut. tt)
h(i.1, bc(tl
i
n/l it'te d.
()) Iha rapot t rhttil hc-:tynt,tl h) .strt.h l;ttlit.t ttf/it.ar trntl olhcr
l)crsott.\. ot b) so tnunl o/ thtn u.: c.onL,ur thcretn. ttncl .shatt he
lorwurdetl to the Dittt.iL,t ,\,lugi.\tt Lttc or rha .\trh-diyis.iorurl \lugi.strutc
trithin ty cnt.r'-fbtt hout .:.
(3) tl'hen-
t \.1D..1
\!.I'] \o l'i rll o1 2026
r0
ti' I lt,
,,,1i,', strlc /r/(, h\ u touttttt tt ithin vyen |eur.\ o/
(ii) tlt Lu\(' t rldtcs to lhc cleuth of o \omon,,r,ilhin set'an t,aur'.s
t)f lrcr tLl t ,tyt !n ut .t tittttnt.stttn(e s roising Lt reasonthle srtspicittn
lltdl \()ntt tth(t lt('t:t)u tontntilttl ttn offt,nct itt tclulion lo .strL.h
t
/ /, / //?(, ((/\L /arr/1d\
tlt tltttlt ()/ Lt \t()ntutl tithin :atvn
t(t'.\ t)i ltt'i Dtttt t'itt!t, ittttl
ttlutire ol thc tronrun hus mudt'tt
rLqtttsr itt tltt: bLittl/
rtr
/r , /ii('r I i' ttrt: LloLtl)l rt,grrttling lhc (t t\( ol tlettlh. ot'
t\'t tliL Dolitt rtllitct lt)r ut1.\ othtr rcoson t.on.sitlcr.s it
trltdicnl 'o to do.
1,.. 1i',111 '71f 1 rt t() \uLh ttrltt ur lhL, .\tutc C()\(rnntcnt md.r
/)1
('\./rl)(' i rlti' I'Llr,til /ot \\Lu Ll tlt( brtl), yitlt u \.ta\ lo il,\ fuinq
(\uItinatl 11 1lp
,1r,,tt ( ivil .\trr',qt0n. rtr otht'r' tltruiilictl ntulitttl
))t,t\ott ttl)i,o.ntt'tl i ; titt, ht'lttlt h.,, tltt' .\lutt,(iott't ntttttt. il lht, :lLttt'of
tl,t,\t(dlttLt intl tlu' tli'ltttlLL, u(lutil ol ils Itt'trtq ro lottr,tt dctl yilhottl
, rr
t r I 7 t r I r /
i Ii ,r
I /ir.'ifr
r
t t t I it,' loliott lt! \fu.qrrtrtttt x ut t cnlt)\t trctl to itoltl inqtt:ts
,ttrDrl.\. ,rtij l)i\/rtLt \lttri.\tt(rtc rtt' .\u b-tliyi.; irtnu l :\,lugistrute urul tu|,
other l,,rr.tttt )(, \l(ttt\tlttlt,s1ts1i11ll.1 cmpo\t(tcd in thi.s bchal./ ht lhc
\/L//( (ir),( t' i;1r)l ttr t,,, l)t:t
I
l.
tt \ltt,gi.ttrUtt,
Irr vieu ol' Lhc ab()\e. thc tlnal reporl rssued bv the respondent
p()li( !' I(r rlrc r.sr)()ir(r!-,rr I .rrrsiicla. irr (-r'irrc N..r
KaiarasrirarnpLrr l)olic,-. Srurion. l)crJrlapaili
I of 20r6 on thc flc of
I)istr.ict rs set aside \\'ith a
TI\4D.J
W P. No.23323 o12026
lt
direction to the respondent police to conduct investigation afresh based
on Lhe representations ol- the petitioner and take action strictly ln
accordance with law
12. The Writ Petition is accordingly allowed' No order as to costs
Pending uriscellaneous petitions, if any' in this Writ Petition shall
13.
stand c losed
^,3l#i'.iffI3BiH[
G
//TRUE COPY//
SECTTON OFFICER
To,
Secretariat Hyderabad'
Department Office at'
Home
Secretary'
1. The Principal
State of Telangana'
District
and Collector' Peddpalli
Magiskate
District
2. The
;;.issioner of Police' Ramasundam
.
Kalva Srirampur Pol'rceStation'
Officer'
House
4. The Station
Srirampur Mandal'
and tunt"O"r.' Kalva
tvtagistra;
5. The Executive
BHARGAV, AdVOCAIE TOPUC]
PHANIN;RA
M
at
SRI.
tO
CC
6. OnE
for the State of Telangana'
7. Two CCs to GP FoR";;"l'l;" ''nn "o'n
or reransana' at
Hish court ror the state
; ;;
- Tl1"3::iioo'J'.o* REVEN,E,
HYderabad IOUTI
9, Two CD CoPies
PSR
l.
,,W
.
HIGH COURT
CC TODAY
DATED: 0910912026
ORDER
os
WP.No.23323 ot 2026
o
o
1 H e s TA 14:
I StP 2026
* ).ss,
PARTY ALLOWING
THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
(;
Q21r\
1ci
1b
'n: cH
Co
*
z
-ai+
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review