Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
- : 1 :W.P. No.128/2024
IN THE HIGH COURTOF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 9th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 128 of 2024
BETWEEN:SULTANA BEGAM W/O SHRI N.U QURESHI T-GOYAL COMPLEX NEAR
IBP PETROL PUMP, BAIRASIYA ROAD, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(SHRI SHASHANK SHARMA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER.)
AND
STATE OF M.P. THROUGH PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF
EDUCATION VALLABH BHAWAN, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
COMMISSIONER LOK SHIKSHAN SANCHANALAYA GAUTAM NAGAR
2.
HOUSING BOARD COLONY BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
JOINT DIRECTOR LOK SHIKSHAN UJJAIN DIVISION SETHI NAGAR
3.
UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER DUSHHERA MAIDAN BEHIND
4.
GIRLS COLLEGE SETHI NAGAR UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
1.
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI KUSHAL GOYAL, LEARNED DY. ADVOCATE GENERAL FOR THE
RESPONDENTS/STATE ON ADVANCE COPY.)
This petition coming on for hearing this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
1.
The petitioner has filed the present petition seeking direction to the
respondents to complete the inquiry against Mr. Ikrar Hussain S/o. Salim
Khan working as Middle School Teacher posted in Middle School Kadai,
- : 2 :W.P. No.128/2024
Tehsil Tarana, District Ujjain.
2.
According to the petitioner, during service, third child of Ikrar
Hussain born on 2.6.2019, therefore, he has incurred disqualification to
continue on the said post.
3.
Firstly, the petitioner is a social worker and not an aspirant to the
post of Samvida Shala Shikshak; secondly, the relief is sought against Ikrar
Hussain who has not been impleaded as party in this petition. Therefore,
the petition suffers from misjoinder of parties.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that Ikrar Hussain was
appointed
under
the
M.P.
Panchayat
Samvida
Shalla
Shikshak
(Employment and Conditions of Contract) Rules, 2005 in which, Schedule
II prescribes disqualification for the said post. Clause (9) says that he or
she has more than two living children, one of them was born on 26.1.2001
or thereafter, he or she will be become disqualified. In support of his
contention, he has placed reliance over the judgment of the apex Court in
the case of Mehsana District Central Cooperative Bank Ltd. V/s. State of
Gujarat : (2004) 2 SCC 463 in which it has been held that if the
complainant has brought to the knowledge of the authorities the inaction of
the respondents and the respondents fail to perform their statutory
obligations, the High Court should entertain such petition.
5.
The aforesaid qualification and disqualification provided in
Schedule II applies at the time of appointment under rule 6 (4), (8) and not
a misconduct during service. Even otherwise, the Rules of 2005 have been
replaced by M.P. M.P. School Education Service (Teaching Cadre), Service
Conditions and Recruitment Rules, 2018 in which also the disqualification
about the third child is only in respect of selection and not misconduct
during the service. In the case of Ayaaubkhan Noorkhan Pathan V/s.
- : 3 :W.P. No.128/2024
State of Maharashtra : (2013) 4 SCC 465 the apex Court has considered
the locus standi of a person aggrieved to file the petition under Article 226
of the Constitution of India in respect of appointment and the castecertificate and held that the petition is not maintainable. Para 18 to 23 of
the said judgment are reproduced below :
“18. As respondent no.5 does not belong to the Scheduled
Tribes category, the garb adopted by him, of serving the cause of
Scheduled Tribes candidates who might have been deprived of their
legitimate right to be considered for the post, must be considered by
this Court in order to determine whether respondent no. 5, is in fact,
in a legitimate position to lay any claim before any forum,
whatsoever.
19. This Court in Ravi Yashwant Bhoir v. District Collector,
Rajgad & Ors., (2012) 4 SCC 407, held as under:
“58. Shri Chintaman Raghunath Gharat, ex-President was the
complainant, thus, at the most, he could lead evidence as a witness.
He could not claim the status of an adversarial litigant. The
complainant cannot be the party to the lis. A legal right is an
averment of entitlement arising out of law. In fact, it is a benefit
conferred upon a person by the rule of law. Thus, a person who
suffers from legal injury can only challenge the act or omission.
There may be some harm or loss that may not be wrongful in the eye
of the law because it may not result in injury to a legal right or
legally protected interest of the complainant but juridically harm of
this description is called damnum sine injuria.
59. The complainant has to establish that he has been deprived
of or denied of a legal right and he has sustained injury to any legally
protected interest. In case he has no legal peg for a justiciable claim
to hang on, he cannot be heard as a party in a lis. A fanciful or
sentimental grievance may not be sufficient to confer a locus standi
to sue upon the individual. There must be injuria or a legal grievance
which can be appreciated and not a stat pro ratione voluntas reasons
i.e. a claim devoid of reasons.
60. Under the garb of being a necessary party, a person cannot
be permitted to make a case as that of general public interest. A
person having a remote interest cannot be permitted to become a
party in the lis, as the person who wants to become a party in a case,
has to establish that he has a proprietary right which has been or is
threatened to be violated, for the reason that a legal injury creates a
remedial right in the injured person. A person cannot be heard as a
- : 4 :W.P. No.128/2024
party unless he answers the description of aggrieved party.”
20. A similar view has been re-iterated by this Court in K.
Manjusree v. State of Andhra Pradesh & Anr., (2008) 3 SCC 512,
wherein it was held that, the applicant before the High Court could
not challenge the appointment of a person as she was in no way
aggrieved, for she herself could not have been selected by adopting
either method. Morever, the appointment cannot be challenged at a
belated stage and, hence, the petition should have been rejected by
the High Court, on the grounds of delay and non-maintainability
alone.
21. In Balbir Kaur & Anr. v. Uttar Pradesh Secondary
Education services Selection Board, Allahabad & Ors., (2008) 12
SCC 1, it has been held that a violation of the equality clauses,
enshrined in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution, or discrimination
in any form, can be alleged, provided that, the writ petitioner
demonstrates a certain appreciable disadvantage qua other similarly
situated persons. While dealing with the similar issue, this Court in
Raju Ramsingh Vasave v. Mahesh Deorao Bhivapurkar, (2008) 9
SCC 54 held:
“45. We must now deal with the question of locus standi. A
special leave petition ordinarily would not have been entertained at
the instance of the appellant. Validity of appointment or otherwise on
the basis of a caste certificate granted by a committee is ordinarily a
matter between the employer and the employee. This Court,
however, when a question is raised, can take cognizance of a matter
of such grave importance suo motu. It may not treat the special leave
petition as a public interest litigation, but, as a public law litigation.
It is, in a proceeding of that nature, permissible for the court to make
a detailed enquiry with regard to the broader aspects of the matter
although it was initiated at the instance of a person having a private
interest. A deeper scrutiny can be made so as to enable the court to
find out as to whether a party to a lis is guilty of commission of fraud
on the Constitution. If such an enquiry subserves the greater public
interest and has a far-reaching effect on the society, in our opinion,
this Court will not shirk its responsibilities from doing so.” (See also:
Manohar Joshi v. State of Maharashtra & Ors., (2012) 3 SCC 619
22. In Vinoy Kumar v. State of U.P., AIR 2001 SC 1739, this
Court held:
“Even in cases filed in public interest, the court can exercise
the writ jurisdiction at the instance of a third party only when it is
shown that the legal wrong or legal injury or illegal burden is
threatened and such person or determined class of person is by
reason of poverty, helplessness or disability or socially or
- : 5 :W.P. No.128/2024
economically disadvantaged position, unable to approach the court
for relief.”
23. Thus, from the above it is evident that under ordinary
circumstances, a third person, having no concern with the case at
hand, cannot claim to have any locus-standi to raise any grievance
whatsoever. However, in the exceptional circumstances as referred to
above, if the actual persons aggrieved, because of ignorance,
illiteracy, inarticulation or poverty, are unable to approach the court,
and a person, who has no personal agenda, or object, in relation to
which, he can grind his own axe, approaches the court, then the court
may examine the issue and in exceptional circumstances, even if his
bonafides are doubted, but the issue raised by him, in the opinion of
the court, requires consideration, the court may proceed suo-motu, in
such respect.”
In view of the above, the facts of the case in Mehsana District Central
Cooperative Bank (supra) are altogether different to the facts of the case in
hand. It was not the service matter and in the service matter, the locus is
important.
6.
With the aforesaid, this petition being absolutely misconceived
deserves to be and is hereby dismissed.
( VIVEK RUSIA )
JUDGE
Alok/-
Date: 2024.01.10 10:18:59 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review