Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH AT
JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE RAJ MOHAN SINGH
ON THE 3rd OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION NO.20198 OF 2020
BETWEEN:SUDHIR KUMAR HUNDET S/O LATE SHRI
HARISHANKAR HUNDET, AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
OCCUPATION- RETD. GOVERNMENT SERVANT R/O
C-3, NIKHIL BUNGLOW, PHASE-III, HOSHANGABAD
ROAD, BHOPAL DISTRICT BHOPAL (MP)
....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI HEMANT KUMAR SHRIVASTAVA- SR.
ADVOCATE WITH MS. VARIDHI PATHAK-ADVOCATE)
AND
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
1.
MADHYA PRADESH MADHYA KSHETRA VIDYUT
VITARAN COMPANY LIMITED THROUGH ITS
MANAGING DIRECTOR, REGISTERED OFFICENISHTHA PARISHAR, GOVINDPURA BHOPAL
(MP)
2.
CHIEF
GENERAL
MANAGER,
MADHYA
PRADESH MADHYA KSHETRA VIDYUT VITRAN
COMPANY LIMITED, REGISTERED OFFICENISHTHA PARISAR, GOVINDPURA (MP)
3.
STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
THROUGH
PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY, GOVT. OF MADHYA
PRADESH, VB-2, VALLABH BHAWAN, ANNEX,
MANTRALAYA BHOPAL (MP)
....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SIDDHARTH SHARMA-ADVOCATE)
Reserved on
:
29-11-2023.
Pronounced on :
03-01-2024.
ORDER
The petitioner has assailed the order dated 15.10.2019
(Annexure P-1) passed by the respondent No.2 vide which the
pension of the petitioner has been withheld/forfeited on the ground
of his conviction in a corruption case.
2.
The petitioner is a retired employee of the Madhya
Pradesh Madhya Kshetra Vidyut Vitaran Company Ltd. (hereinafter
referred to as “MPMKVVCL”), which is an undertaking of the
Department of Energy, Government of Madhya Pradesh. During the
pendency of the criminal case, the petitioner was suspended vide
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
order dated 26.09.2015 passed by the respondent No.2. On
30.08.2017, the respondent No.2 directed the concerned authority to
provide provisional pension to the petitioner under Rule 64 of the
Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976 (hereinafter
referred to as ‘Rules, 1976”). On conviction of the petitioner, the
provisional pension was stopped and the pension was forfeited. The
petitioner has superannuated on 30.06.2017 and the conviction in
criminal case came to be recorded vide judgment dated 31.08.2019.
With the forfeiture of the pension, the respondents No.1 and 2 have
not paid any gratuity amount to the petitioner. Against the judgment
of conviction by the Special Judge under Prevention of Corruption
Act dated 31.08.2019, the petitioner has preferred a Criminal
Appeal No.7505/2019 before the High Court of Madhya Pradesh,
Principal Seat at Jabalpur. In the aforesaid criminal appeal, the
sentence of the petitioner has been suspended vide order dated
3.10.2019 during pendency of the appeal.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that
the criminal appeal is a statutory right of the petitioner under the
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, and therefore criminal appeal is
in continuation of judicial proceedings held before the Court of
Sessions, therefore for all intents and purposes, it has to be treated
as a pending judicial proceeding in relation to the charges levelled
against the petitioner under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) read with Section
13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (for brevity “PC
Act, 1988”), and therefore the petitioner is entitled to pension under
Rule 64 of the Rules, 1976. Vide the impugned order dated
15.10.2019 passed by the respondent No.2, it has been directed to
withhold the pension of the petitioner under Rule 8(1)(b) of the
Rules, 1976 on the basis of his conviction under the PC Act, 1988.
On the basis of aforesaid conviction recorded by the Special Judge
under the PC Act, 1988 on 31.8.2019, the respondent No.2/Chief
General Manager has been directed to withhold the provisional
pension provided to the petitioner vide order dated 30.08.2017. The
impugned order dated 15.10.2019 has been assailed on the strength
of Rule 64 and wrong application of Rule 8(1)(b) of the Rules,
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
1976. For ready reference, Rules 8 and 9 of the Rules, 1976 are
hereby reproduced as under:“8. Pension subject to future good conduct. - (1)
(a) Future good conduct shall be an implied
condition of every grant of pension and its
continuance under these rules.
(b) The pension sanctioning authority may, by
order in writing withhold or withdraw a pension
or part thereof, whether permanently or for a
specified period, if the pensioner is convicted of a
serious crime or is found guilty of grave
misconduct:
Provided that no such order shall be passed
by an authority subordinate to the authority
competent at the time of retirement of the
pensioner, to make an appointment to the post
held by him immediately before his retirement
from service:
Provided further that where a part of
pension is withheld or withdrawn, the amount of
such pension shall not be reduced below [the
minimum pension as determined by the
Government from time to time].
(2) Where a pensioner is convicted of a serious
crime by a Court of law, action under clause (b) of
sub-rule (1) shall be taken in the light of the
judgement of the Court relating to such
conviction.
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
(3) In a case not falling under sub-rule (2), if the
authority referred to in sub-rule (1) considers that
the pensioner is prima facie guilty of grave
misconduct, it shall before passing an order under
sub-rule (1):(a) serve upon the pensioner a notice
specifying the action proposed to be taken
against him and the ground on which it is
proposed to be taken and calling upon him
to submit, within fifteen days of the receipt
of the notice or such further time not
exceeding fifteen days as may be allowed by
the pension sanctioning authority, such
representation as he may wish to make
against the proposal; and
(b)
take
into
consideration
the
representation, if any, submitted by the
pensioner under clause (a).
(4) Where the authority competent to pass an
order under sub-rule (1) is the Governor, the State
Public Service Commission shall be consulted
before the order is passed.
(5) An appeal against an order under sub-rule (1);
passed by any authority other than the Governor,
shall lie to the Governor and the Governor shall
in consultation with the State Public Service
Commission pass such order on the appeal as he
deems fit.
Explanation. - In this rule.-
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
(a) the expression "serious crime" includes a
crime involving an offence under the Official
Secrets Act 1923 (No. 19 of 1923);
(b) the expression "grave misconduct"
includes the communication or disclosure of
any secret official code or pass word or any
sketch, plan, model, article, note, document
or information such as is mentioned in
Section 5 of the Official Secrets Act, while
holding office under the government so as to
prejudicially affect the interests of the
general public, or the security of the
country.
[Note.- The Provisions of this rule shall also be
applicable to family pension payable under Rules
47 and 48. The authority competent to make an
appointment to the post held by the deceased
Government servant/ pensioner immediately
before the death or retirement from the service, as
the case may be, shall be the competent authority
to withhold or withdraw any part of family
pension.]
9. Right of Governor to withhold or withdraw
pension.- (1) The Governor reserves to himself the
right of withholding or withdrawing a pension or
part thereof, whether permanently or for a
specified period, and of ordering recovery from
pension of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss
caused to the Government if, in any departmental
or judicial proceeding, the pensioner is found
guilty of grave misconduct or negligence during
the period of his service, including service
rendered upon re-employment after retirement:
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
Provided that the State Public Service
Commission shall be consulted before any final
orders are passed:
Provided further that where a part of
pension is withheld or withdrawn, the amount of
such pension shall not be reduced below [the
minimum pension as determined by the
Government from time to time];
(2) (a) The departmental proceedings [xxx], if
instituted while the Government servant was in
service whether before his retirement or during his
re-employment, shall, after the final retirement of
the Government servant, be deemed to be
proceedings under this rule and shall be
continued and concluded by the authority by
which they were commenced, in the same manner
as if the Government servant had continued in
service:
Provided that where the departmental
proceedings are instituted by an authority
subordinate to the Governor, that authority shall
submit a report regarding its findings to the
Governor.
(b) The departmental proceedings, if not
instituted while the Government servant was in
service whether before his retirement or during his
re-employment:(i) shall not be instituted save with the
sanction of the Governor;
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
(ii) shall not be in respect of any event
which took place more than four years before such
institution; and
[(iii) shall be conducted by such authority
and in such place as the Government may direct
and in accordance with the procedure applicable
to departmental proceedings:
(a) in which an order of dismissal from
service could be made in relation to the
Government servant during his service in case it
is proposed to withhold or withdraw a pension or
part thereof whether permanently or for a
specified period; or
(b) in which an order of recovery from his
pay of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss
caused by him to the Government by negligence
or breach of orders could be made in relation to
the Government servant during his service if it is
proposed to order recovery from his pension of the
whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused to the
Government].
(3) No judicial proceeding, if not instituted while
the Government servant was in service, whether
before his retirement or during his re-employment,
shall be instituted in respect of a cause of action
which arose or in respect of an event which took
place, more than four years before such
institution.
(4) In the case of a Government servant who has
retired on attaining the age of superannuation or
otherwise and against whom any departmental or
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
judicial proceedings are instituted or where
departmental proceedings are continued under
sub-rule (2), a provisional pension and deathcum-retirement gratuity as provided in [Rule 64],
as the case may be, shall be sanctioned:
[Provided that where pension has already
been finally sanctioned to a Government servant
prior to institution of departmental proceedings,
the Governor may, by order in writing, withhold,
with effect from the date of institution of such
departmental proceedings fifty per cent of the
pension so sanctioned subject however that the
pension payable after such withholding is not
reduced to less than [the minimum pension as
determined by the Government from time to time]:
Provided further that where departmental
proceedings have been instituted prior to the 25th
October, 1978, the first proviso shall have effect
as it for the words "with effect from the date of
institution of such proceedings" the words "with
effect from a date not later than thirty days from
the date aforementioned," had been substituted:
Provided also that(a) If the departmental proceedings are not
completed within a period of one year from the
date of institution thereof, fifty per cent of the
pension withheld shall stand restored on the
expiration of the aforesaid period of one year;
(b) If the departmental proceedings are not
completed within a period of two years from the
date of institution the entire amount of pension so
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
withheld shall stand restored on the expiration of
the aforesaid period of two years; and
(c) If in the departmental proceedings final
order is passed to withhold or withdraw the
pension or any recovery is ordered, the order shall
be deemed to take effect from the date of the
institution of departmental proceedings and the
amount, of pension since withheld shall be
adjusted in terms of the final order subject to the
limit specified in sub-rule (5) of Rule 43].
(5) Where the Government decides not to withhold
or withdraw pension but orders recovery of
pecuniary loss from pension, the recovery shall
not be made at a rate exceeding one-third of the
pension admissible on the date of retirement of a
Government servant.
(6) For the purpose of this rule(a) departmental proceedings shall be deemed to
be instituted on the date on which the statement of
charges is issued to the Government servant or
pensioner, or if the Government servant has been
placed under suspension from an earlier date, on
such date; and
(b) judicial proceedings shall be deemed to
be instituted(i) in the case of criminal proceedings, on
the date on which the complaint or report of a
police officer, of which the Magistrate takes
cognizance, is made, and
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
(ii) in the case of civil proceedings, on the
date the plaint is presented in the Court.”
4.
Learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner
vehemently
contended that Rule 8(1)(b) of the Rules, 1976 has been wrongly
applied. Rule 8 of the Rules, 1976 relates to pension subject to
future good conduct. In order to apply Rule 8 of the Rules, 1976
nothing should be pending. Under Rule 9 of the aforesaid Rules,
1976, the Governor is an appropriate authority, who reserves the
right of withholding or withdrawing a pension or part thereof,
whether permanently or for a specified period, if in any
departmental or judicial proceeding, the pensioner is found guilty of
grave misconduct or negligence during the period of his service,
including service rendered upon re-employment after retirement.
Under 9(4) of the Rules, 1976, the Government servant who has
retired on attaining the age of superannuation or otherwise and
against whom any departmental or judicial proceedings are
instituted or where departmental proceedings are continued under
sub-rule (2), a provisional pension and death-cum-retirement
gratuity as provided in Rule 64, shall be sanctioned.
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
5.
With reference to the aforesaid rules, learned counsel
for the petitioner vehemently submitted that the Rules 8 and 9 of the
Rules, 1976 are operating in different fields. During the pendency of
the judicial proceedings, the petitioner shall be treated on deemed
extension as Government servant till appeal is pending, and
therefore on the strength of Rules 9(4) and 64 of the Rules, 1976, he
is entitled for provisional pension and no such forfeiture of pension
can be ordered under Rule 8 of the Rules, 1976. Rule 64 (c) of the
Rules, 1976, damage/penalty, if any ordered in judicial proceeding,
is to be deducted and no interest is to be paid in view of the
amendment in Rule 64 and the said aspect is subject to the
discretion of the Court. No gratuity shall be paid to the Government
servant until the conclusion of the departmental or judicial
proceedings and issue of final orders thereon. Learned counsel for
the petitioner with reference to the facts on record submitted that
Rule 9 of the aforesaid Rules ought to have been applied in the
instant case, as at the time of superannuation of the petitioner, the
judicial proceeding/criminal trial was pending and conviction was
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
recorded only after the superannuation of the petitioner on
31.8.2019, therefore the competent authority was the Governor to
pass any order in consonance with the requirement of Rule 9 of the
Rules, 1976.
6.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents
submitted that at the time of retirement of the petitioner, the
petitioner was facing a criminal trial for the offences under the PC
Act, 1988. The petitioner has been convicted after his retirement.
Rule 8(1)(b) of the Rules, 1976 is very clear that the pension
sanctioning authority may by an order in writing withhold or
withdraw a pension or part thereof, whether permanently or for a
specified period, if the pensioner is convicted of a serious crime or
is found guilty of grave misconduct. Rule 9 of the Rules, 1976 can
be pressed into service for withholding or withdrawing the pension
when the Government servant has caused any pecuniary loss to the
Government or an order for recovery can be passed in the
departmental or judicial proceeding when the petitioner is found
guilty of grave misconduct or negligence during the period of his
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
service, including service rendered upon re-employment after
retirement. Rule 9 of the aforesaid Rules makes it abundantly clear
that the power can be exercised when misconduct is proved during
the departmental or judicial proceeding causing pecuniary loss to
the Government and such order of recovery from the pension can be
ordered by the Governor, withholding the pension wholly or partly.
In the instant case, Rule 8 of the Rules, 1976 would be applicable,
which clearly deals with the situation when the pensioner is
convicted of a serious crime by a Court of competent jurisdiction,
therefore, the pension can be withheld or withdrawn permanently or
for a specified period. The aforesaid Rule also provides that future
good conduct shall be an implied condition of every grant of
pension and its continuance under these rules.
7.
It is a settled principle of law that even if a wrong
provision is quoted by an authority, exercising the powers for which
the authority is competent, the order is not vitiated on account of
wrong mentioning of the provision on the strength of ratio of Kedar
Shashikant Deshpande and others Vs. Bhor Municipal Council
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
and others, (2011) 2 SCC 654 and N. Mani Vs. Sangeetha
Theatre and others, (2004) 12 SCC 278.
8.
The larger Bench of this Court in Writ Petition
No.16549/2016 (Lal Saheb Bairagi Vs. State of M.P and others)
has held that after conviction of the pensioner, if the competent
authority withholds or withdraws the pension wholly or in part
thereof, no prior notice is required to be issued. The observations
made by the Larger Bench while dealing with Rule 8 of the
aforesaid Rules are to be effect that it is a settled principle of law
that the payment of pension to a pensioner is regulated by the
provisions of the Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Pension) Rules,
1976 and the same has been made statutorily subject to future good
conduct of the pensioner.
9.
From perusal of the Rule 8 of the Rules, 1976 as
reproduced in the preceding part of the order, it is clear that the
pension sanctioning authority may by an order in writing withhold
or withdraw a pension or part thereof, if the pensioner is convicted
of a serious crime or is found guilty of grave misconduct. The
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
pension can be withheld or withdrawn permanently or for a
specified period. Rule 8(2) of the Rules, 1976 deals with the cases
of pensioner, who has been convicted in a criminal case, while Rule
8(3) of the Rules, 1976 deals with the cases of pensioner found
guilty of grave misconduct. From perusal of the provisions of Rule
8(3) of the Rules, 1976, it is clear that the said provision prescribes
that where an authority considers a pensioner prima facie guilty of
grave misconduct, it shall, before passing an order under sub-rule
(1) of Rule 8 of the Rules, 1976, serve upon the pensioner a notice
specifying the action proposed to be taken against him, and the
ground on which the action is proposed to be taken, call upon him to
submit a representation within fifteen days or any further time that
is extended by the authority, take into consideration the
representation filed by the pensioner and thereafter pass an order.
10.
It is, however, apparent from a bare perusal of the first
few words of Rule 8(3) of the Rules, 1976 that the aforesaid
procedure prescribed for passing order against the pensioner in case
where he is prima facie guilty of grave misconduct, has no
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
applicability to the case falling under Rule 8(2) of the Rules, 1976,
which deals with the action to be taken against a pensioner
convicted by a criminal Court of competent jurisdiction. The
provisions of Rule 8(3) of the Rules, 1976 shall apply only to those
cases, which do not fall under sub-rule (2) of Rule 8 of the Rules,
which makes it clear that the category of cases under Rule 8(2) of
the Rules, 1976 is that where the action has been taken in the light
of the judgment of the Criminal Court in which the pensioner is
convicted of a serious offence by a Criminal Court of competent
jurisdiction and while taking such an action, the procedure
prescribed under Rule 8(3) of the Rules of 1976, would not apply as
the same has been expressly excluded by the opening words of Rule
8(3) of the Rules of 1976. Rule 8(2) of the Rules of 1976, does not
contemplate giving of an opportunity of hearing when the pension is
withheld or withdrawn on account of conviction in a serious
offence.
11.
The interpretation of the Rules is apparent. A bare
perusal and reading thereof would indicate that the language of Rule
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
8(3) of the Rules of 1976 is simple and unambiguous and it leads to
no other interpretation or conclusion. In view of the clear and
unambiguous language used in the provisions of Rule 8(3) of the
Rules of 1976, which incidentally was neither considered nor
brought to the notice of the Full Bench in the case of Ram Sewak
Mishra Vs. State of M.P. and another. The principles of natural
justice cannot be read into Rule 8(2) of the Rules of 1976, as they
are statutorily and expressly excluded by the opening words of Rule
8(3) of the Rules of 1976.
12.
The ratio of the larger Bench in Lal Saheb Bairagi’s
case (supra) has been summed up in paragraphs No.10 to 18. For
ready reference, the aforesaid paragraphs are reproduced here as
under:“10. A perusal of Rule 8 of the Rules of 1976,
makes it further clear that the category of cases
that fall under Rule 8(2) of the Rules of 1976, are
those cases in which action has been taken in the
light of the judgment of the Court where the
pensioner is convicted of a serious crime by a
Court of law and that while taking such action,
the elaborate procedure prescribed under Rule
8(3) of the Rules of 1976, would not apply as the
same has been expressly excluded by the opening
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
words of Rule 8(3) of the Rules of 1976. Rule 8(2)
of the Rules of 1976, does not contemplate giving
of an opportunity of hearing when the pension is
withheld or withdrawn on account of conviction of
a serious crime.
11. The aforesaid aspect and interpretation of the
Rules is apparent from a bare perusal and reading
of the Rules. The language of Rule 8(3) of the
Rules of 1976, is simple, unambiguous and clear
and leads to no other interpretation, meaning or
conclusion.
12. In view of the clear and unambiguous
language of the provisions of Rule 8(3) of the
Rules of 1976, which incidentally was neither
considered nor brought to the notice of the Full
Bench in the case of Ram Sewak Mishra vs. State
of M.P. and another (supra), it is held that the
principles of natural justice cannot be read into
Rule 8(2) of the Rules of 1976, as they are
statutorily and expressly excluded by the opening
words of Rule 8(3) of the Rules of 1976.
13. The principles of natural justice or holding of
an enquiry is neither a universal principle of
justice nor inflexible dogma. The principles of
natural justice are not incapable of exclusion in a
given situation. For example, Article 311(2) of the
Constitution, which essentially embodies the
concept of natural justice, itself contemplates that
there may be situations which warrant or permit
the non- applicability of the principles underlying
Article 311(2) of the Constitution. Reference may
be made to the second proviso to Article 311 of the
Constitution. The Supreme Court in Union of
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
India vs Tulsiram Patel AIR 1985 SC 1416 =
(1985)3 SCC 398 had in terms of Art 311 ruled
that not only, can the principles of natural justice
be modified but in exceptional cases they can even
be excluded.
14. The Rule 8(2) enables the authority to exercise
power under Rule 8(1)(b) upon conviction of
serious crime in the light of the Judgment of the
criminal court. While doing so, it must consider
whether his conduct which has led to his
conviction was such as warrants the
withholding/withdrawing of pension. For that
purpose it will have to peruse then judgment of the
criminal court and consider all the facts and
circumstances of the case. This, however, has to
be done by it ex parte and by itself and without
hearing the concerned pensioner reason of the
exclusionary effect of the starting words of Rule
8(3) upon exercise of powers under Rule 8(2) of
the 1976 Rules.
15. In view of the law laid down by the Supreme
Court in the case of Tulsiram (supra), which is
fully applicable to the present case as well, the
authority must, however, bear in mind that a
conviction on a criminal charge does not
automatically entail withdrawal or withholding of
pension. This can be done in the light of the
judgment of the Court relating to such conviction.
No direction for taking action in the judgment of
the criminal Court is necessary or required for
taking action under Rule 8(2) of the Rules of
1976. This authoritative judgment of the Supreme
Court was completely overlooked by the learned
Single Bench while deciding Dau Ram
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
Maheshwar case(supra) on the basis of decision
of Chhatisgarh High Court. The majority view in
Ram Sewak Mishra(supra) wrongly did not apply
the decision of Tulsi Ram Patel (supra) to the
Rules of 1976. On the other hand the earlier Full
Bench in Laxmi Narayan Hayaran v. State of M.P.
reported in 2004(4) MPLJ 555 after considering
the relevant case law including Tulsi Ram Patel
(supra), correctly held that no prior hearing is
required before passing an order under Rule 8(2)
of 1976 Rules consequent upon conviction.
16. The upshot of the whole discussion is that the
decision of the Single Bench as well as the Full
Bench in Ram Sewak v. State of M.P.(supra) does
not lay down the correct law, while the earlier
Full Bench decision in Laxmi Narayan Hayaran v.
State of M.P. (supra) lays down the correct law.
17. The answer to the questions referred to this
Larger Bench is given accordingly by clearly
stating that:(i) The principles of natural justice are
specifically and expressly excluded and have no
application to the cases falling under Rule 8(2) of
1976 Rules in view of the opening words of Rule
8(3) of the Rules of 1976, therefore, when an
action is taken against the pensioner under Rule
8(2) of the Rules of 1976, no notice is required to
be issued to the pensioner nor can he insists upon
prior opportunity of representation on the strength
of the principles of Natural Justice.
(ii) The decision of the Full Bench in the case of
Ram Sewak Mishra (supra) and the decision in the
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
case of Dau Ram Maheshwar (supra) are hereby
over- ruled.
(iii) It is held that the authority is not required to
issue notice or afford prior opportunity of
representation before passing the order under
Rule 8(2) of the Pension Rules of 1976, in respect
of a pensioner who has been convicted in the
criminal cases. However, the power of the
authority to take action under the Rules would be
subject to the guidelines as stated by the Supreme
Court in the case of Tulsiram Patel (supra) and
reiterated by this Bench in the preceding
paragraphs of this judgment.
18. The Reference made to the Larger Bench is
answered accordingly. The petition may now be
placed before the appropriate Bench as per Rules
and Roster, for further orders.”
13.
The Division Bench of this Court in the case of
Gyaneshwar Choudhary and others Vs. State of Madhya
Pradesh and others (Writ Appeal No.1710/2022 decided on
05/01/2023) has also observed that on conviction of a pensioner, he
is not entitled to get pension and if order is passed by the authority
under Rule 8 of the Rules 1976 withdrawing pension, the same
cannot be faulted with. The Division Bench has also taken note of
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
the view expressed by the larger Bench in Lal Saheb Bairagi’s case
(supra).
14.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in Civil Appeal Nos.7437-
7438 of 2021 (The Secretary Local Self Government Department
and others etc. Vs. K. Chandaran Etc.) has held that after
conviction, the employee is not entitled to claim pension though
his/her criminal appeal against the conviction is pending before the
Court of law. In 2002 (5) MPHT 11 (Ram Ratan Tiwari Vs. State
of MP and others), WP No.18341/2023 (Badelal Pathak Vs.
State of MP and others, decided on 5.9.2023) and WP
No.17664/2022 (Rama Shankar Tiwari Vs. State of MP and
others, decided on 7.12.2023), it has been held that the criminal
appeal is not a continuation of criminal trial. When a person is
convicted for the offence under the PC Act, then stay of conviction
cannot be granted in a routine manner. When there is no stay of
conviction, then disqualifications attached to the conviction must
follow. In the instant case the conviction of the petitioner has not
been stayed, and only sentence part of order has been stayed and the
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
petitioner will remain a convicted person until and unless his
conviction is set aside in the pending appeal in accordance with law.
15.
From bare perusal of Rule 64 of the Rules, 1976, it is
clear that the provisional pension shall be drawn on establishment
pay bill and paid to retired Government servant by the competent
authority during the period commencing from the date of retirement
to the date on which upon conclusion of departmental or judicial
proceedings, final orders are passed by the competent authority. If
the pensioner is found to have been convicted and sentenced for a
serious offence, then the pension can be forfeited after stopping the
payment of provisional pension. Thus it is clear from Rule 64(1)(b)
of the Rules, 1976 that the aforesaid provision is applicable only
when the trial is pending, where an element of innocence is attached
to the accused. Once the trial is concluded or resulted in conviction
of the accused/pensioner, then merely because an appeal against
such conviction is pending where conviction has not been stayed, it
cannot be said that the judicial proceedings have not come to an end
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
for the simple reason that the pensioner has to face the
disqualification attached to the conviction.
16.
So far as non-payment of gratuity is concerned, Section
4(6) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 can be appreciated, which
prescribes that notwithstanding anything contained in sub-Section
(1), the gratuity of an employee, whose services have been
terminated for any act, willful omission or negligence causing any
damage or loss to, or destruction of, property belonging to the
employer, shall be forfeited to the extent of the damage or loss so
caused. The gratuity payable to an employee may be wholly or
partially forfeited, if the services of such employee have been
terminated for his riotous or disorderly conduct or any other act of
violence on his part, or if the services of such employee have been
terminated for any act which constitutes an offence involving moral
turpitude, provided that such offence is committed by him in the
course of his employment.
17.
In case of termination/dismissal of service of an
employee on account of conviction in a criminal trial, conduct
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
leading to conviction has to be seen. It is not necessary to terminate
or dismiss the employee in every case where he or she has been
convicted in a criminal case, but if an employee/pensioner is
convicted for an offence involves moral turpitude, defect in
character and the accusation had embarrassed him/her in discharge
of public duty, then he or she has to be terminated or dismissed,
thereby forfeiting pension and gratuity. It is only the conduct
leading to conviction has to be adhered to while dismissing the
employee.
18.
The assertions made by the learned counsel for the
petitioner on the basis of judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Shribhagwati Prasad Tiwari Vs. Union of India and
others, reported in 2004 SCC Online MP 760, are not applicable
to the present case. On conviction in a corruption case, the petitioner
is found to have committed grave misconduct, which involves moral
turpitude and defect in character and in such like situation even
Article 311(2) of the Constitution of India could have been resorted
to.
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
19.
For the reasons recorded hereinabove, I do not find any
merit in the instant writ petition. The writ petition is accordingly
dismissed with no order as to costs. If the petitioner is ultimately
acquitted in the pending criminal appeal, thereafter he may seek his
legal remedy in accordance with law. If the amount under the head
of GIS, GPF and Leave Encashment has not been paid to the
petitioner, then the petitioner may approach the competent authority
for redressal of his grievance, as these components would remain
unfettered and would not be forfeited except the pension and
gratuity.
(Raj Mohan Singh)
Judge
03/01/2024
Ansari
Signed by: MANZOOR
AHMED
Signing time: 1/3/2024
5:24:41 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review