Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 4th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 4846 of 2023
BETWEEN:SUDHAKAR KHIRE S/O SHRI NAGESHWAR KHIRE OCCUPATION:
RETIRED EMPLOYEE, R/O 77 PRAKASH NAGAR, DHAR, DISTRICT
DHAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI GURDEEP SINGH DANG, ADVOCATE.)
AND
GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEE GRAH NIRAMAN SAHKARI SANSTHA,
PRAKASH NAGAR, DHAR THROUGH ITS SECRETARY COMMUNITY
HALL OFFICE, PRAKASH NAGAR COLONY, DISTRICT DHAR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SANJAY P.JOSHI, ADVOCATE.)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This petition coming on for orders this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
The petitioner has filed the present challenging the order
dated 31.01.2023 passed by Madhya Pradesh Cooperative Tribunal,
Bhopal in Second Appeal No.79/2020 whereby the order passed by the
Deputy Registrar and Joint Registrar have been set aside by remitting
the matter back to the Dy. Registrar for fresh adjudication.
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
-2-
Despite the opportunity granted on 18.08.2023 for filing a reply
respondent No.1 has not filed any reply.
02.
The petitioner is a citizen of India and a retired Government
employee. The respondent is a registered Housing Society of
Government employee. The respondent society was allotted land by the
State Government for the development of the Housing Society for its
members. According to the petitioner, the respondent Society allotted
plot No.160 to him and he deposited Rs.61,150/- for which receipt
No.1703 was issued. Out of Rs.61,150/- the petitioner paid Rs.56,000/for the plot admeasuring 20 x 40 sq. ft. @ Rs.70/- per Sq.ft. and
Rs.3,000/- for draining charges, Rs.50/- for membership fees, Rs.1,500/for Sahyog Rashi, Rs.500/- for Ansh Poonji and Rs.100/- for Bhubharak.
03.
The petitioner made a repeated request for allotment of the
plot. Vide letter dated 18.11.2008, the respondent Society demanded the
receipts and other documents from the petitioner which he submitted on
02.12.2008. Thereafter, vide letter dated 30.01.2009, the respondent
Society denied the allotment and registration of the plot to the petitioner
without assigning any reason.
04.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid action, the petitioner filed a suit
under Section 64 of the M.P. Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 (for
brevity “Act of 1960”) before the Deputy Registrar (Cooperative), Dhar
which was registered as case No.E/01/2009-10. The respondent Society
filed the written statement. Vide order dated 08.06.2018, the Deputy
Registrar passed the order in favour of the petitioner directing the
respondent Society to register plot No.160 in favour of the petitioner.
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
-3-
05.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid order, the respondent Society
filed an appeal under Section 78 (1) of the Act of 1960 before the Joint
Registrar Cooperative. Vide order dated 18.11.2020, the Joint Registrar
after examining all the documents and evidence that came on record,
dismissed the appeal and affirmed the order of the Deputy Registrar.
06.
Thereafter,
the
respondent
Society
approached
the
M.P.
Cooperative Tribunal, Bhopal by way of Second Appeal No.79/2020.
Vide impugned order dated 31.01.2023, the learned Tribunal has set
aside both the orders and remanded the case to the Deputy Registrar to
adjudicate afresh after framing the issues hence, this petition before this
Court.
07.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the learned
Tribunal erred by not considering that the respondent society had raised
a similar dispute with respect to neighbouring plots No.159 & 161
belonging to the members Shri Rajesh Dwivedi and Shri Mahesh Nikam
respectively. They both approached the Deputy Registrar and after the
order passed by the Deputy Registrar, the Society allotted the plots to
them in compliance with orders dated 04.08.2005 and 29.04.2000
respectively. Therefore, the petitioner is also entitled to claim the parity
as the respondent society is permitted to discriminate between similarly
situated persons/ members. It is further submitted by learned counsel
that although the issues were not framed but the Deputy Registrar and
Joint Registrar duly considered all the facts and evidence that came on
record and passed the reasoned orders. Hence, the learned cooperative
Tribunal has wrongly remanded the matter back to the Deputy Registrar
which would take another 10 years to conclude the matter. In support of
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
-4-
his contention, learned counsel placed reliance on a judgment passed by
the Apex Court in the case of Arvind Kumar Jaiswal (D) Thr. LR. V/s
Devendra Prasad Jaiswal Varun in SLP (C) No.9172 of 2020.
08.
Per contra Shri Sanjay P. Joshi, learned counsel for the
respondent contends that the Deputy Registrar has not considered
various other issues like a limitation, the entitlement of the petitioner,
non-availability of the plot while deciding the case. On all these
objections taken by the respondent, the issues were liable to be framed,
without framing issues the proceeding under Section 64 of the Act of
1960 cannot be decided as a suit therefore, the learned Tribunal has
rightly remanded the matte back for fresh adjudication after framing the
issues. No fresh evidence is required to be recorded, only the issues
were required to be framed to adjudicate the matter hence, no
interference is called for, and the petition is liable to be dismissed.
10.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused
the order passed by the Deputy Registrar dated 08.06.2018 and Joint
Registrar dated 18.11.2020.
11.
Both the aforesaid authorities have duly considered the
claim of the petitioner and the objection taken by the respondent. After
appreciating the evidence it was concurrently held that the petitioner
was a member of the Society who was allotted the plot No. 160
thereafter he deposited the amount of Rs.61,150/- despite that the plot
has not been registered in his name. The Registrar has also considered
allotment of plots No.159 & 161 to Shri Rajesh Dwivedi and Shri
Mahesh Nikam. Therefore, the issues between the parties were very
limited and were considered based on the pleadings and the evidence
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
-5-
that came on record. The Deputy Registrar was already required to
examine whether the petitioner was a member of the Society and
deposited the cost of the plot alongwith other charges after the allotment
of the plot No.160. Only the learned Registry was required to be
executed between the parties, therefore, there was no such complex
issue involved in this case for which the matter was liable to be
remanded back.
11.
The learned Tribunal has held that the provisions of Section
67(3) of the Act of 1960 have not been followed. The proceedings under
Section 64 of the Act of 1960 before the Deputy Registrar are summary
proceedings. Section 67(3) of the Act of 1960 nowhere mandates the
framing of the issues before deciding the dispute like a regular civil suit.
Though the issues were not framed the dispute between the parties has
rightly been adjudicated by the Deputy Registrar as well as Joint
Registrar.
12.
The Apex Court in the case of Arvind Kumar Jaiswal
(supra) has held that the order of remand prolongs and delays the
litigation hence, the appellant Court should not pass a remand order
unless finds that retrial is required or evidence on record is not sufficient
to dispose of the matter. It is further held that even the lower Court has
omitted to frame the issues or has failed to determine any question of
fact which in the opinion of the appellate Court is essential. Where the
evidence has already been adduced and the decision can be rendered on
appreciation of such evidence. The order of Arvind Kumar Jaiswal
(supra) is reproduced below:
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
-6Leave granted.
In our opinion, the impugned judgment of the High
Court remanding the case to the trial court by relying upon
Section 33 and order XX of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
(the 'Code'), overlooks the provisions of Rule 23, 23A, 24 and
25 of Order XLI of the Code.
An order of remand prolongs and delays the litigation
and hence, should not be passed unless the appellate court
finds that a re-trial is required, or the evidence on record is not
sufficient to dispose of the matter for reasons like lack of
adequate opportunity of leading evidence to a party, where
there had been no trial of the dispute or there is no complete or
effectual adjudication of the proceedings, and the party
complaining has suffered material prejudice on that account.
Where evidence has already been adduced and a decision can
be rendered on appreciation of such evidence, an order of
remand should not be passed remitting the matter to the lower
court, even if the lower court has omitted to frame issue(s)
and/or has failed to determine any question of fact, which, in
the opinion of the appellate court, is essential. The first
appellate court, if required, can also direct the trial court to
record evidence and finding on a particular aspect/issue in
terms of Rule 25 to Order XLI, which then can be taken on
record for deciding the case by the appellate court.
In the present case, the High Court, as the first appellate
court, which is also a court of fact and law, has passed an order
of remand observing that the judgment of the trial court was, in
its opinion, not written as per the mandate of Section 33 and
Rule 4(2) and 5 of Order XX of the Code, as the discussion
and reasoning on certain aspects was not detailed and
elaborate.
This is not a case where the evidence is not adduced
and on record. In fact, the first portion of the judgment of the
High Court elaborately records the contention of the parties
and the facts and evidence relied by the parties.
In view of the aforesaid, we allow the present appeal, and set
aside the impugned judgment and restore the first appeal to its
original number before the High Court, to be decided on merits
and in accordance with law, as per the provision of order XLI
of the Code. As the appeal has been pending for a considerable
time, the High court would decide the appeal expeditiously as
possible.
We clarify that we have not expressed any opinion on
merits of the of case. There would be no order as to costs.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
-7-
13.
Shri Sanjay P. Joshi, learned counsel for the respondent
submits that the issue of limitation was also raised before the Deputy
Registrar which has not been decided. The issue of limitation was raised
by way of application under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC which was
rejected against which no appeal or revision was filed thereafter, the
respondent contested the matter on merit.
14.
Even otherwise, the respondent has failed to distinguish the
case of the petitioner from the case of Shri Rajesh Dwivedi and Shri
Mahesh Nikam in whose favour the Deputy Registrar and Joint
Registrar passed the order and thereafter, the respondent Society
registered a sale-deed. The respondent has not filed any document to
show that the plot No.161 is not vacant and is allotted to someone else.
Even if the same has been allotted for which the petitioner cannot be
held responsible.
15.
During pendency of the petition, the Society was required to
keep the said plot vacant as the same was allotted to the petitioner
hence, the order of the Tribunal is set-aside the respondent is directed to
comply with the order passed by the Deputy Registrar dated 08.06.2018
and the Joint Registrar dated 18.11.2020 within a period of 60 days from
the date of production of a certified copy of this order.
16.
In view of the above, the Writ Petition is finally allowed
with the cost of Rs. 10,000.00 payable to the petitioner.
Certified copy, as per rules.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Divyansh
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review