The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Accordingly, this Court finds that no illegality or perversity appears to have been committed by Additional Commissioner and Board of Revenue in setting aside the order passed by SDO on 04.07.2003.
16. The petition being sans merits is hereby dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND RAMESH PHADKE
ON THE 10th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 5412 of 2007
BETWEEN:STATE OF M.P. THROUGH EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, DAM
AND SAFETY DIVISION, GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI S.S. KUSHWAH - ADVOCATE)
AND
L.D. HOTEL PVT. LTD. THROUGH MANAGING
DIRECTOR, DEVRAJ GARG S/O SHRI LAXMANDAS
GARG, R/O BASANT BIHAR COLONY, LASHKAR,
GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI YOGESH CHATURVEDI - ADVOCATE)
This petition coming on for hearing this day, th e court passed the
following:
ORDER
The present petition under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India
has been directed against the order dated 12th March, 2007 passed by Board of
Revenue in Revision No. 321-PBR/2005 whereby the order dated 04.02.2004
passed by Additional Commissioner, Gwalior Division, Gwalior in case No.
199/2002-2003 was affirmed and the order of diversion dated 31.10.2002
passed by Sub-Divisional Officer, Gwalior was set-aside.
2. The short facts of the case are that the present petitioner who is the
owner of land bearing survey Nos. 557 admeasuring 0.021 hectare, survey
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 12-01-2024
05:34:09 PM
No.558 admeasuring 0.052 hectare, survey No.559 admeasuring 0.105 hectare,
survey No.560 admeasuring 0.021 hectare total 21375 sq. ft. situated at village
Ramtapura Patwari Halka No. 39 applied for diversion of the aforesaid lands
from agricultural to residential purpose.
3. The Sub-Divisional Officer before whom the application was moved
registered the aforesaid matter at No.6/2002-2003 under Section 172(i) M.P.
Land Revenue Code, 1959 and after detailed scrutiny allowed the said
application and vide order dated 31.10.2002 permission for diversion was
granted to the petitioner with certain conditions. One of the conditions of the
order for diversion was that the aforesaid permission was granted subject to
construction on the disputed land leaving 30 meters area from the middle of
Swarn Rekha Nala and leaving 20 meters area from the road side.
4. Since the very purpose for which lands were diverted was not carried
out by the petitioner, therefore, alleging that because of the said non-compliance
public nuisance is being created which amounted to violation of terms and
conditions of the diversion order and therefore a show cause notice dated
03.06.2003 was issued to the petitioner. The crux of the show cause notice was
that on the spot, activities of public nuisance are being carried out which is
detrimental to the public health and safety and also imbalance of environment is
being caused and since under the sanction plan for Swarn Rekha Nala, the entire
land of the petitioner is coming, therefore, why not the permission for diversion
granted to the petitioner be cancelled ?
5. In response to the aforesaid show cause notice, a reply was submitted
by the petitioner and after appreciating the contents of reply on 04.07.2003, the
Sub-Divisional Officer cancelled the diversion order dated 31.10.2002 on the
ground that no construction was raised by the petitioner even after diversion of
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 12-01-2024
05:34:09 PM
the land.
6. The said order was challenged by the petitioner in appeal (though a
revision was preferred but the same was treated as an appeal) which was
allowed and while allowing the appeal, it was held that no condition appended
to the order of diversion appears to have been flouted, therefore, the permission
cancelled vide impugned order dated 04.07.2003 cannot be sustained.
7. The said order of appeal was thereupon unsuccessfully challenged by
the State Government before the Board of Revenue in revision. The revision
preferred on behalf of the petitioner/State was dismissed vide impugned order
dated 12.03.2007 and the order passed by the Additional Commissioner,
Gwalior Division was affirmed on similar lines. Aggrieved by the aforesaid
order passed by the Board of Revenue, the present petition has been preferred.
8. Learned counsel for the petitioner has tried to support the order
passed by Sub-Divisional Officer whereby the order of diversion was cancelled
on the ground that due to non-adherence of the condition of raising
construction over the land in question by the petitioner in pursuance to the
order of diversion for residential purposes, situation of public nuisance over the
said land was reported which amounted to violation of condition as contained in
the order of diversion.
9. It was further submitted that admittedly no development/construction
after passing of the order of diversion was carried out by the petitioner because
of which, the land became hotspot of public nuisance which became detrimental
for public health and safety as well as since the land in question came within the
purview of sanctioned plan for restructuring of Swarn Rekha Nala, therefore, it
was incumbent upon the authorities to cancel the diversion permission, which
was rightly cancelled and ignoring this aspect, learned Additional Commissioner
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 12-01-2024
05:34:09 PM
as well Board of Revenue had set-aside the order of Sub-Divisional Officer
cancelling the diversion permission which are per se illegal and therefore
deserves to be set-aside.
1 0 . Per contra, Shri Chatruvedi appearing for respondent while
supporting the order impugned herein contends that as per the diversion order
dated 31.10.2002, certain conditions were appended in Para 5 but none of the
conditions was pleaded or proved to have been violated. Thus, the order
passed by Sub-Divisional Officer cancelling diversion permission was per se
illegal and therefore, was rightly set-aside by the Additional Commissioner and
the Board of Revenue.
11. It was further submitted that from bare perusal of the show cause
notice dated 03.06.2003, it is evident that the same was issued on the pretext of
commission of public nuisance on the spot which had created danger to the
public health and safety and was also creating imbalance to the environment
coupled with the fact that the said permission was against the sanctioned plan
for restructuring of Swarn Rekha Nala, whereas the order passed by SubDivisional Officer dated 04.07.2003 was on the ground that since as per the
condition mentioned in the diversion permission, neither the construction was
raised nor any development was carried out by the petitioner, therefore, the said
diversion permission was required to be cancelled and accordingly, was
cancelled which was impermissible as no opportunity to rebut so far as this
aspect was concerned with regard to development or construction was
provided or even the said order itself was per se illegal. Thus, supporting the
impugned order, it was prayed that the present petition being devoid of any
substance deserves to be dismissed.
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 12-01-2024
05:34:09 PM
12. After hearing the rival contentions and going through the entire record
of the petition, this Court finds that in clause 5 of the diversion order dated
31.10.2002 certain conditions were provided upon which
the permission
dwelled with which for ready reference is reproduced below:-
5- izdj.k esa layXu leLr vfHkys[k dk ijh{k.k fd;k x;kA ;g ekuk
x;k fd vkjksfir 'krksZ ds lkFk iz'uk/khu Hkwfe ij Mk;olZu dh vuqefr
iznku dh tk ldrh gSA vr% vkosnd dh fuEu 'krksZa ds lkFk iz'uk/khu
Hkwfe ij vkoklh; mi;ksx gsrq Mk;olZu dh vuqefr iznku dh tkrh gSA
1- vkosnd v/kh{kd Hkw&vfHkys[k Mk;olZu dh x.kuk vqulkj ifjofrZr
Hkw&jktLo rFkk izhfe;e 'kkldh; dks"k esa tek djus gsrq ikcUn gSA
2- LFky ij vkoklh; mi;ksx gsrq Mk;olZu dh vuqefr nh tk jgh gSA
fuekZ.k Lo.kZ js[kk ukyk ds e/; ls 30 ehVj rFkk ekxZ ds e/; ls 20 ehVj
NksM dj djuk gksxkA
3- LFky ij yksd U;wlsal dh xfrfof/k oftZr gSA rFkk lkekftd LokLF;
,oa lqj{kk rFkk i;kZoj.k larqyu dks cuk;s j[kus dh ftEesnkjh vkosnd dh
gksxhA
4- vkosnd ds fy;s e/;izns'k uxj rFkk xzke fuos'k vf/kfu;e 1973 rFkk
e-iz- Hkw fodkl fuxe 1984 ds izko/kkuksa dk ikyu djuk vfuok;Z gksxkA
5- vkosnd vU; lacaf/kr foHkkxksa ls Hkh fuekZ.k iwoZ vko';d vuqefr;kWa izkIr
djsaA
6- Hkwfe ds LoRo ds laca/k esa dksbZ fookn mRiUu gksus ij mldh ftEesnkjh
vkosnd dh gksxhA
mijksDr 'krksZa dk mYya?ku djus ij nh x;h Mk;olZu dh vuqefr fujLr
dh tk ldsxhA ch uksfVl tkjh gksA ch&9 esa vey gksA
In none of the conditions as mentioned above, there was any time limit
given for carrying out any development or raising any construction over the land
in question. In sub-clause (3) of Clause 5, it was mentioned that on the spot any
activity relating to public nuisance is prohibited and it is the responsibility of the
respondent to cater to the public health, safety and to keep environment balance
intact.
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 12-01-2024
05:34:09 PM
13. From bare perusal of the show cause notice dated 03.06.2003, it is
not reflected that any allegation with regard to any public nuisance created by
the petitioner itself, has been alleged. Learned Government Advocate has tried
to canvas that due to inaction on the part of the respondent in not developing or
raising any construction over the land, public nuisance is being done by some
other person which has caused danger to the public health and safety which
appears to be not correct and thus, it cannot be said that conditions of
diversion order has been flouted.
14. Further it is also seen that the show cause notice was issued alleging
public nuisance which was detrimental to the public health and safety and also
that the layout sanctioned for Swarn Rekha Nala is covering the entire land and
reply in that regard was sought from the respondent but the order dated
04.07.2003 passed by Sub-Divisional Officer was on different ground that
neither development has been carried out nor any construction has been raised
on the land in question, thus, without giving any opportunity to rebut the said
ground the order of Sub-Divisional Officer appears to be faulty and illegal.
15. Accordingly, this Court finds that no illegality or perversity appears
to have been committed by Additional Commissioner and Board of Revenue in
setting aside the order passed by SDO on 04.07.2003.
16. The petition being sans merits is hereby dismissed.
(MILIND RAMESH PHADKE)
JUDGE
ojha
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 12-01-2024
05:34:09 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review