Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-'!
[ 348e ]
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE SIXTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TVVENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION NO: 2675 OF 2004
Between:
State Bank of lndia, rep., by its K. Srirama [Vlurthy, Chief Manager IDPL
Colony Branch, IDPL Colony, Hyderabad.
C.T. is amended as per C.O. dt. 03.01 .2023 vide l.A.No.1/2022 in
W.P.No.267512004
...PETITIONER
AND
The Commercial Tax Officer, Ferozguda Circle, Ferozguda, Hyderabad.
The Deputy Commercial Officer, Jeedimetla Circle, Jeedimetla, Hyderabad
The Sub-Registrar, tMedchal, Ranga Reddy District.,
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, order or direction, particularly a writ in the nature of
mandamus, declaring the notice of sale in Form No.7, under Section 36 of
R.R.District Act, 1864 issued dated 30.1.2004 by the 2nd respondent herein is
illegal and without jurisdiction.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2004(WPMP. NO: 3531 OF 2004)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the 1st respondent herein to issue clearance certificates in respect of the
properties sold by the petitioner herein and consequently direct the 3rd
respondent herein to register the sale deed in respect of plot Nos.68,69,70,71,
72,73,74,75,76 and 7T in Sy.Nos.311 and 312, rDA,
ft/landal' R'R'District as and when presented
the writ petition
N
OF
oF2
P
at Bachupaily, eutbulapur
for registration, pending disposal of
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the circumstances stated
the High court may be pteased to
stay of all further proceedings including auction
of the immovable properties plot
Nos.68,69,70.21,73,7s,76 and 17 in Sy Nos 311
and 312, rDAat Batchuparem,
Qutbullapur Mandal, R.R.District, pending disposal
of the writ petition.
t.A.
NO
F20
Petition under section 151 cPC praying that in
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the circumstances stated
the High court may be pleased to
permit the petitioner to take the aforesaid grounds
in support of the above writ
Petition' in addition to the grounds that were
taken in the affidavit filed in support
of the writ Petition, pending disposar
of the writ petition.
Counsel for the petitioner: Ms. ASVARI.C, REp.
SRI K.V.SUBRAHMANYA NARUSU
counsel for the Respondent No.1 & 2: AGp FoR
TAXES
counsel for the Respondent No.3: cp FoR srAMps
The Court made the following: ORDER
& REGrsrRATroN
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHATAPATHI RAO
WP.No. 2675 of 2OO4
Dt. 05 .02.2026
Between:
State Bank of India
Petitioner
and
The Commercial Tax Officer and two others.
...Respondents
O R D E R: Per the Hon'ble Sri Justice Suddata Chalapathi Rao)
1.
The instant writ petition has been filed by the State Bank of
India (formerly State Bank of Hyderabad) challenging the notice of sale
issued.in Form No.7 under Section 36 of the Revenue Recovery Act,
L864, dt.30.01.2004, by the 2',d respondent-Deputy Commissioner
(Tax Officer), as being illegal, without jurisdiction, and violative of the
principles of natural justice and also consequently prayed to stay of all
further proceedings, including the auction of immovable properties
bearing Plot Nos.68 to 77 to an extent of 25OO sq. yards with RCC
shed to the extent of 3022 sq. ft with two industrial sheds bearing
Nos.8-66 ,8-66/L(3O22 sq. ft each) in Survey No.311 and 312 of IDA,
Bachupalli, Quthbullapur Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, and for
,1
issuance of a clearance certificate in respect of the said properties to
the petitioner-Bank.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner-Bank is a
statutory corporation and in pursuance of the state policy, to promote
industriahzatron of the states, it had advanced loan facilities to M/s
Universal Packaging Industry, a partnership firm with Syed Ishak
Hussain, as Managing Partner, and Smt Parwin Taj, as other partner
and to M/s Amaran Packets Pvt. Ltd., a private limited company, with
Syed Anwar Hussain as Managing Director and Smt Zikera Sultan, as
other Director, by mortgaging immorrable properties comprising Plot
Nos.68 to 77 to an extent of 2500 sq. yards with RCC shed to the
extent of 3022 sq. ft with two industriai sheds bearing Nos.B-66, 8-
66/l(3O22 sq. ft each) in Survey No.311 and 312 of [DA, Bachupatli,
Quthbullapur Mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
3.
The petitioner further contends that as the said loanees failed to
clear the loan dues, their accounts \ rere classified as Non-Performing
Assets (NPAs), consequently by invoking the provisions of SARFAESI
Act,2oo2, the petitioner took possession of the mortgaged properties
on ll.l2.2oo2. Pursuant thereto, sale notices were issued to the
borrowers on 26.07.2003, and after following due process, the
\\r
properties were sold in a public auction held on 22.12.2003 for a sum
of Rs.3B,L},ooo/-, and the said amount was adjusted tourards the
outstanding dues of the aforesaid two loanees.
4.
It is further contended by the petitioner-Bank that the 1.t
respondent, by letter, dt.06. 12.2oo3, claimed that the borrowers were
in arrears of sales tax dues and, placing reliance on the judgments of
the Hon'ble supreme court of India in state Bank of Bikaner &
Jaipur a. Nationq.l Iron & Steet Rolting corporation & Otherst
and state of Mad.hga prad,esh and. Another a. stqte Bq.nk of
Indore & Othersz claimed that the Commercial Tax Department had
a first charge over the properties of the dealer in respect of amounts
payable under the Act and requested to remit the sales tax arrears for
the assessment years lggg-2ooo and 2ool-o2 out of the sale
proceeds of the properties belonging to M/s universal packaging
Industries and M/s Amaran packaging. Further, the l"t respondent
also alleged to have addressed a letter to the 3.d respondent not to
register the subject properties situated at Bachupally, Ranga Reddy
District. while so, the 2nd respondent got published notices in Form
No.S in the Ranga Reddy District Gazette Extraordinary,
CivilAppeal No.916j,/1994 , dt.t4.t2.Lgg4
CivilAppeal No.11528 of 1996, dt.15.03.2001
dt.26.12.2OO3, attaching the properties of the borrowers for recovery
of the said amounts and in the event of failure to pay the dues within
fifteen days, the attached properties rvould be put to sale by
conducting auction. Thereafter, the 2"cl respondent issued impugned
auction notice in Form 7, dt.30.01.2}04 under Section 36 of the
Revenue Recovery Act, L864, seeking to attach and sell the
aforementioned properties in public auction and the said notice was
challenged in the instant Writ Petition.
5.
Heard Ms. Asvari.C, learned counsel representing Sri K.V.
Subramanva Narsu, learned counsel for petitioner and learned
Assistant Government Pleader for Taxes appearing for respondent
Nos.1 and 2, and none appeared for the 3.d respondent.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner-Bank contends that the
subject plots belonged to the individual directors and not to the
borrowing firms and that, despite a reply sent to the lsr respondent,
the properties were nonthless attached and sold in terms of the
notices issued under Section 27 of the Act for recovery of the sales tax
dues from the dealers.
7. It is further contended by the counsel for petitioner-Bank that
Section 16C of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957 (for
short the APGST Act'), provides that, notwithstanding anything to the
contrary contained in any law for the time being in force, any amount
of tax, penaity, interest or other sum payable under the Act shall be
the first charge on the properties of the dealer or such person, the lst
and. 2"d respondents lacked jurisdiction to attach and sell the subject
properties, which were under mortgage to the petitioner-Bank and the
possession thereof had been taken by the Bank by invoking the
provisions of SARFAESI Act, 2OO2. In the instant writ petition, the
petitioner has also challenged the uires of Section 16C of the APGST
Act as being unconstitutional being violative of Article 254 of the
Constitution of India and is repugnant to the provisions of the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882, a central enactment and also
contended that SARFAESI Act, 2OO2,being central enactment cannot
be superseded by the State enactment.
8.
Per contra., the learned Assistant Government Pleader appearing
for respondent Nos.l & 2 would contend that Section 16C of the
Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957, unequivocally empowers
the sales tax,dues as a first charge on the assets of the dealer. [n view
of such statutory first charge, the l.t and 2"d respondents are fulIy
empowered to proceed against the subject properties by effecting
attachment and bringing them to sale, in accordance with due process
of law.
9.
It is further contended by the learned Assistant Government
Pleader that although the petitioner has chalienged the constitutional
vatidity of Section 16C of the APGST Act, no material or substantive
grounds have been placed on record to demonstrate that the said
provision is violative of any ccnstitutional mandate. As such, it is
subrnitted that the rvrit petition is devoid of merits and is liable to be
dismissed.
10. We havr: giverr earnest consideration to the submissions of the
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and tkre learned Assistant
Governmen[ Pleader for respondent Nos. L and, 2 and perused the
material on record
1i. From the facts stated it is evident that the petitioner-Bank hact
extencled loan facilities to the borrowers i.e., M/s Universal Packaging
lndustry and M/s Amaran Packets pv-t. Ltd., and the said bor-rowers
defaulted in repaynrent. It is equally true that the borrowers were in
arrears of sales tax dues for the relevant assessment years. Though
ttre petitioner has challenged tlte uire.s of Section 16C of the ApGST
Act, no cogent material or substantive grounds have been placed on
record to demonstrate as to how the said provision is unconstitutional
or repugnant to any Central enactment.
12. The Honble Apex court in state of A.p.& others a. McDoutell
& Co. & Otherss held as under:
"43-...
.A law made by Parliament or the
legislature can be struck down bg courts on two ground.s and.
two grounds alone, ui"z,., (1) lack of legislatiue competence and
(2) uiolation of any of the fundamental rights guaranteed. in
Part III of the constitution or of ang other constitutional
proui.sion. There is no third ground.'
13. In the present case, the challenge to the constitutional validity of
Section 16C of the APGST Act, 1957 was made on mere assertions,
unsupported by any material on record. In the absence of any
supporting material establishing such infirmities, the challenge to the
constitutional validity cannot be sustained and is, accordingly,
rejected.
74. Further, a plain reading of Section 16c of the APGST Act makes
it clear that the sales tax dues constitute a first charge on the
properties of the dealer. The respondents, therefore, were well within
'atR tggo sct62t
e
their jurisdiction to initiate recovery proceedings in accordance with
law.
15. Apparently, neither thc defaulting borro',vers nor the alleged
auction purchasers have been impleaded by the petitioner as parties
to the present u,rit petition or the affected parties have choose to
participate in these proceedings, though much tirne has elapsecl from
the filing of the rrrit petition in 2OO4 and also both the counsel for
petitioner as well as the respondent-State are unable to give the status
of the property as on toda_v. Thus, in our considered opinion, their
presence was necessary for an effective and complete adjudication of
the issues involved.
16. Moreover, the clispute essentially pertains to inter se claims
between the secured creditor and the statutory authority, while the
persons directly affected b), the proceedings or any beneficiaries have
not approached this Court, even after a lapse of more than 21 years
since the filing of the writ petition. on this ground also, the writ
petition is liable to be dismissed.
17. In vieu, of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, vue find no
merit in the writ pe[ition as no strbstantial grounds are placed by the
\\
petitioner for interference by this court and accordingly the writ
petition is dismissed. No order as to costs.
18. However, it is made clear that the affected parties, if so advised
and if otherwise entitled in law and if their grievance still survives, are
at liberty to challenge the auction proceedings or any other orders
affecting their rights before the competent court of law.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall stand
closed.
/TRUE COPY//
. OSMAN ALI BAIG
TANT REGIST
SECTION OFFICER
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble SRI
KOSHY
(For His Lordships Kind
r)
and
one Fair copy to.the Hon'ble sRl JUST|CE SUDDALA cHALApATHt RAo
(For His Lordships Kind Perusal)
To,
I
I
t
1. one cc to sRl K.V.SUBRAHMANYA NARUSU, Advocate topucl
2. 11 LR Copies
3. The Under secretary, Union of lndia, Ministry of Law, Justice and company
Affairs, New Delhi
4. Ing..secretary, Telangana
Advocates Association, Library, High court
Buildings, Hyderabad.
5. Two ccs to G.l- FoR TAXES, High court for the State of relangana at
Hyderabad [OUT]
6. Two CCs to GP FOR STAIVIPS & REGISTRATION, High Court for the State
of Telangana at Hyderabad TOUTI
7. Two CD Copies
BSR
BS
HIGH COURT
DATED: 06/0212026
'ir-,lI t'
()
(J
ORDER
WP.No.2675 of 2004
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION,
WITHOUT COSTS
3 3 a
(.
2 5 l'1,liB 2i]2$
*
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review