Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(Crl.) No.03 of 2025
Sri Shibu Chakraborty,
S/o. Sasadhar Chakraborty,
Resident of Kathaltali, Ranirkhamar,
P.O. Madhupur, P.S. Amtali,
District- West Tripura, PIN- 799003.
……..Petitioner(s)
For and on behalf of
Sri Rajesh Acharjee,
S/o. Lt. Chanu Acharjee,
Aged about 38 years,
Resident of Vill- Shibjoy Jamadar Para,
P.S. Budhjungnagar, Dist- West Tripura.
……..Accused Person
–Versus–
1. The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary, Home Department, Government of
Tripura, New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura.
2. The Investigation Officer of Agartala GRPS Case No.34 of 2025,
Agartala GRPS Police Station, Agartala Railway Station, Agartala,
West Tripura.
…….. Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Abhimanshu Dhyani, Advocate.
Mr. Kundan Pandey, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. P.P.
Date of hearing and delivery :
of Judgment & Order
15th May, 2025.
Whether fit for reporting
YES
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (Oral)
Heard Mr. Abhimanshu Dhyani, learned counsel and Mr.
Kundan Pandey, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr.
Rajib Saha, learned Addl. P.P. appearing for the State.
The Case Diary (for short, CD) has been produced by
learned Addl. P.P.
[2]
The petition is filed by the petitioner on behalf of Sri Rajesh
Acharjee, who was arrested on 1.4.2025 in connection with GRPS case
No.34 of 2025, registered under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C)/25/29 of the
NDPS Act and since then he has been in custody. The allegations as
borne in the FIR lodged by Sri Bishnu Pada Das, SIPF under GRPS is that
on 1.4.2025 at around 08.55 hours, he received specific secret
information regarding bringing of some contraband items by some
unknown persons for loading the same inside the PARCEL VAN at
Agartala Station. Then accordingly after obtaining permission from
IPF/Agartala, he alongwith other officers and staffs of GRP Agartala, set
on an ambush at Agartala Railway station and at around 11.45 hours,
one goods carrier truck bearing No-AS 01 JC 4571 was found coming
through the approaching road of unloading point Line No.13 of Agartala
Railway Station yard. On arrival at Agartala Railway Station, 3 persons
got down from the said vehicle and hurriedly unloaded some cartoon
boxes from the said vehicle. Thereafter, the informant detained those 3
persons for verification. On spot interrogation, they disclosed their
names as Prasenjit Nag, Rajat Debbarma and Rajesh Acharjee.
According to the informant, on asking they offered contradictory and
dissatisfactory statements regarding their presence there and finally
admitted that they were carrying some contraband goods by said
vehicle. It is also noted by the informant in the FIR that after complying
necessary legal formalities, a search was conducted and ultimately they
recovered total 58.535 kg of contraband Ganja from 28 Nos. of packets
and then those persons were also arrested.
[3]
Challenging the said arrest of Rajesh Acharjee, the present
writ petition has been filed under Section 226 of the Constitution of
India, to declare said arrest to be illegal, ultra vires and in violation of
Article 22(1) of the Constitution of India.
[4]
Mr. Dhyani, learned counsel, challenged the arrest of the
petitioner, mainly on two points: firstly, that written communication
regarding grounds of such arrest was not made available to the
arrestee; and secondly, that he was kept in detention for more than 24
hours, in violation of Article 22(2) of the Constitution of India. Learned
counsel, referring to the arrest memo as submitted by the Investigating
Officer in the Court below, submits that against the column for ‘grounds
of arrest’, it was written as- "information was given to his" and nothing
more. According to learned counsel, the ground of arrest ought to have
been specifically mentioned in the said arrest memo, as it touches the
very fundamental right of the arrestee to take his proper defence
against such arrest and detention. In support of his submission, Mr.
Dhyani, learned counsel also relies on a decision of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in the case of Prabir Purkayastha vs. State (NCT OF DELHI),
(2024) 8 SCC 254, wherein the relevant paragraphs as relied on are
extracted hereunder:
“19. Resultantly, there is no doubt in the mind of the
court that any person arrested for allegation of
commission of offences under the provisions of UAPA
or for that matter any other offence(s) has a
fundamental and a statutory right to be informed about
the grounds of arrest in writing and a copy of such
written grounds of arrest have to be furnished to the
arrested person as a matter of course and without
exception at the earliest. The purpose of informing to
the arrested person the grounds of arrest is salutary
and sacrosanct inasmuch as this information would be
the only effective means for the arrested person to
consult his advocate; oppose the police custody remand
and to seek bail. Any other interpretation would
tantamount to diluting the sanctity of the fundamental
right
guaranteed
under
Article
22(1)
of
the
Constitution of India.
……..
24. A Constitution Bench of this Court examined in
detail the scheme of Article 22(5) of the Constitution of
India in Harikisan v. State of Maharashtra [1962 SCC
OnLine SC 117] and held that the communication of the
grounds of detention to the detenu in writing and in a
language which he understands is imperative and
essential to provide an opportunity to detenu of making
an effective representation against the detention and in
case, such communication is not made, the order of
detention would stand vitiated as the guarantee under
Article 22(5) of the Constitution was violated. The
relevant para is extracted hereinbelow: (SCC OnLine SC
para 7)
“7. … clause (5) of Article 22 requires that the
grounds of his detention should be made
available to the detenu as soon as may be, and
that the earliest opportunity of making a
representation against the Order should also be
afforded to him. In order that the detenu should
have that opportunity, it is not sufficient that he
has been physically delivered the means of
knowledge
with
which
to
make
his
representation. In order that the detenu should
be in a position effectively to make his
representation against the Order, he should have
knowledge of the grounds of detention, which are
in the nature of the charge against him setting
out the kinds of prejudicial acts which the
authorities attribute to him. Communication, in
this context, must, therefore, mean imparting to
the detenu sufficient knowledge of all the
grounds on which the Order of Detention is
based. In this case the grounds are several, and
are based on numerous speeches said to have
been made by the appellant himself on different
occasions
and
different
dates.
Naturally,
therefore, any oral translation or explanation
given by the police officer serving those on the
detenu would not amount to communicating the
grounds. Communication, in this context, must
mean bringing home to the detenu effective
knowledge of the facts and circumstances on
which the Order of Detention is based.”
(emphasis supplied)
…………………..
25. Further, this Court in Lallubhai Jogibhai Patel v.
Union of India, [(1981) 2 SCC 427 : 1981 SCC (Cri)
463], laid down that the grounds of detention must be
communicated to the detenu in writing in a language
which he understands and if the grounds are only
verbally explained, the constitutional mandate of
Article 22(5) is infringed. The relevant para is
extracted hereunder: (SCC p.436, para 20)
“20. … “Communicate” is a strong word. It means
that sufficient knowledge of the basic facts
constituting the “grounds” should be imparted
effectively and fully to the detenu in writing in a
language which he understands. The whole
purpose of communicating the “ground” to the
detenu is to enable him to make a purposeful and
effective representation. If the “grounds” are
only verbally explained to the detenu and nothing
in writing is left with him, in a language which he
understands, then that purpose is not served, and
the constitutional mandate in Article 22(5) is
infringed.”
(emphasis supplied)
[5]
Mr. Dhyani, learned counsel also relies on another decision
of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Ashish Kakkar vs. UT of
Chandigarh,
(Criminal
Appeal
No.1518/2025),
decided
on
25.3.2025, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court reiterated the ratio laid
down in Prabir Purkayastha (supra). In that case also it was held
that the arrest of the concerned accused was illegal
for non-
communicating the grounds of arrest.
[6]
Regarding the allegation of detention of more than 24 hours
of the said arrested person, Mr. Dhyani, learned counsel also brought to
the notice of the Court the paragraph No.16 of the counter affidavit
submitted by the State, wherein it was mentioned that the accused
person was intercepted on 1.4.2025 at about 11.30 hours. But in the
arrest memo, learned counsel, submits, the arrest of said Rajesh
Acharjee, was shown to be at 14.00 hours. In the order dated 2.4.2025
passed by Learned Special Judge in said case, it is mentioned that the
Investigating Police Officer produced all the 4 accused persons before
the Court Inspector, Sadar Police Court, Agartala for their production
before the Court of law before 2 p.m. on 2.4.2025. Learned counsel
relying on such observations, submits that in view of the above
observation made by the Learned Special Judge, it is apparent that
Rajesh Acharjee was produced before the Ld. Special Judge at 2 p.m. on
that day, and therefore, such over detention of the arrested person has
rendered the arrest illegal. Learned counsel on that point relies on
another decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Directorate of Enforcement vs. Subhash Sharma, 2025 SCC
OnLine SC 240. In that case, it appeared on factual aspects of the
case, that the related arrested person was detained and taken into
custody at 18.00 hours (6 p.m.) on 4.3.2022 at IGI Airport, New Delhi
by the Bureau of Immigration, on execution of one LOC issued against
said person by the ED and took him into custody. Thereafter, the ED
took said person in their own custody on the following day, i.e., on
5.3.2022 at 11.00 hours (11 a.m.) at IGI Airport and brought him to
Raipur and on the following day, i.e., on 6.3 2022, they produced him
before the remand Court. The ED showed that person to be arrested at
1.15 hours on 6.3.2022, despite the fact that the said person was into
their custody on the previous day at around 11.00 hours. The Hon'ble
Supreme Court in that situation observed the following at paragraph
No.6:
“6. This argument cannot be accepted. Admittedly, the
LOC was issued at the instance of the appellantDirectorate of Enforcement. By executing the LOC, the
Bureau of Immigration detained the respondent at IGI
Airport from 4th March 2022 on behalf of the Appellant.
The finding of fact recorded in paragraph 10 is that
undisputedly, the physical custody of the respondent
was taken over by the appellant from the Bureau of
Immigration at 11.00 hours on 5th March, 2022.
Thereafter, at 1.15 hours on 6th March 2022, an arrest
memo was prepared by ED at Raipur. He was produced
before the Court at 3 p.m. on 6th March, 2024. The
perusal of the arrest order(Annexure p-1) shows that
the typed order was kept ready. The date and time of
arrest were kept blank which appear to have been filled
in by hand. Admittedly, the respondent was not
produced before the nearest learned Magistrate within
24 hours from 11.00 a.m. on 5th March, 2022.
Therefore, the arrest of the respondent is rendered
completely illegal as a result of the violation of clause 2
of Article 22 of the Constitution of India. Thus, the
continuation of the respondent in custody without
producing him before the nearest Magistrate within the
stipulated time of 24 hours is completely illegal and it
infringes fundamental rights under clause 2 of Article
22 of the Constitution of India. Therefore, his arrest
gets vitiated on completion of 24 hours in custody.
Since there is a violation of Article 22(2) of the
Constitution, even his fundamental right to liberty
guaranteed under Article 21 has been violated.”
[7]
Learned Addl. P.P., however, opposes the prayer submitting
that the written communication regarding the grounds of arrest was
duly made to the arrested person just after his arrest and same was
received by him under his own signature. Learned Addl. P.P. also refers
to the said copy of the written communication as available in the CD.
Regarding the second point of challenge, learned Addl. P.P. submits
that, as per the entry made in the CD, on 2.4.2025 at around 12.30
hours, the arrested person was forwarded to the Court of Learned
Special Judge seeking police remand of the accused and the CD was also
available before the Learned Special Judge at the time of hearing of the
bail application of the petitioner as well as the petition of the IO for
police remand.
[8]
I have given due consideration to the submissions of learned
counsel of both sides and have also perused the record and relevant
portion of the CD as placed before this Court. It is found that in the
arrest memo the grounds of arrest, was not mentioned but there is
another copy of letter issued by the informant on the same day of arrest
of said Rajesh Acharjee, showing the grounds of arrest and said Rajesh
Acharjee appears to have received the same under his own signature.
[9]
Mr. Dhyani, learned counsel, on that point submitted that no
such copy was ever served upon the arrested person. Moreover, in the
forwarding report while producing the said person before the Learned
Special Judge, no such specific averments were made by the IO that
such written letter was communicated to the accused person, and
therefore, according to learned counsel, said document cannot be given
much reliance.
[10]
Keeping in mind the submissions of both the parties, this
Court has also further perused the record and it is found that after such
alleged recovery and arrest of the accused person, a letter was sent by
the informant to the IPF, Agartala, wherein it was specifically mentioned
that the grounds of arrest was duly intimated to the arrested persons
and their family members. In the forwarding report, dated 2.4.2025 also
the IO mentioned that grounds of arrest was duly informed to the
arrested person as well as their family members after the arrest. The
only non-mentioning of the fact specifically that such communication
was made in writing itself, in the said forwarding letter to this Court, is
not sufficient enough to hold that no such communication was ever
made. Another accused, namely Sri Prasenjit Nag, filed one bail
application, in this Court bearing B.A.No.25 of 2025, wherein also
similar plea of non-communication of grounds of arrest was made on his
behalf. While disposing of the said bail application, a Coordinate Bench
of this Court, vide order dated 17.4.2024, observed that it appeared
that the grounds of arrest were duly communicated to the accused on
the same day by supplying a copy of the same to him.
[11]
Considering the above discussions, thus it cannot be held at
this stage that no such communication of grounds of arrest was made to
the accused person. Now, coming to the second point of challenge i.e.,
detention of the accused person beyond 24 hours without producing
before the Court, it appears from the record that initially the arrested
person was detained for verification at around 11.45 hours on 1.4.2025.
As per the counter affidavit of the respondents in one paragraph, he was
detained for such verification at 11.30 hours on that day (though in
another paragraph of the counter affidavit, said time is mentioned as
11.45 hours). Be as it may, as per the arrest memo, the time of formal
arrest of said Rajesh Acharjee after taking him into custody is reflected
to be 2 p.m. and as per the note made in the CD, at around 12.30 hours
on the following day, he was forwarded by the Investigating Officer for
production before the Court, and therefore, it can also not be said that
the accused person was produced before the Court beyond 24 hours. In
Subhash Sharma’s case as mentioned above, though the arrested
persons were detained by Bureau of Immigration on 4.3.2022 at around
6 p.m., but ultimately in paragraph No.6 of the judgment as extracted
hereinabove observation was made that, the respondent was not
produced before the nearest Magistrate within 24 hours from 11 a.m. of
5.3.2022, and therefore, practically his arrest was treated to be at 11
a.m. of 5.3.2022. Here according to the police, though for formal
verification they detained him at 11.30 or 11.45 a.m., as the case may
be, but actual arrest was effected at 2 p.m. Considering above said
discussions, the second point of challenge also does not deserve
consideration in favour of the petitioner.
[12]
Considering all these aspects, and also in view of the above
said discussions, this Court does not find merit in the petition, and
accordingly, the same is dismissed.
With such observations, the writ petition stands disposed of.
Return the Case Diary to the learned Addl. P.P.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
SATABD Digitally
SATABDI DUTTA
2025.05.17
I DUTTA Date:
13:26:04 +05'30'
Dinashree
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review