Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. A(J) 9 of 2024
Sanjoy Munda
……Appellant(s)
Versus
State of Tripura
.......Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. Sankar Bhattacharjee, Legal Aid Counsel.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. Raju Datta, PP
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. P.P.
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
: 25.06.2025.
Whether fit for reporting
: Yes._____________________________
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
[Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J]
Heard Mr. Sankar Bhattacharjee, learned Legal Aid
Counsel for the appellant. Also heard Mr. Rajib Saha, learned Addl.
P.P. appearing for the State-respondent.
[2]
This present appeal is filed under Section 374 of Code of
Criminal Procedure 1973 against the judgment of conviction and
order of sentence dated 11-08-2023 passed in S.T (T-1) 32 of 2019
by the learned Sessions Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar,
convicting and sentencing the appellant to suffer imprisonment for
life under Section 302 of IPC. The convict has also been sentenced
to pay fine of Rs.5000/-(Rupees five thousand) under Section 302
of IPC and in default of payment of fine, to suffer imprisonment for
a further period of five months.
[3]
The brief facts of this case are that on 12-03-2019 at
about 1600 hours, accused Sanjoy Munda, appellant herein and the
victim Laxmi Munda visited Mundatilla under Dharmanagar PS for
Ayurvedic
treatment
and
they
met
one
Budram
Lohar
and
requested him to show a place where liquor would be available.
Budram Lohar showed both of them the house where liquor was
available. Thereafter, in the evening both of them came to the
house of Budram Lohar and asked him to give them shelter for the
night but Budram Lohar refused as there was no sufficient space in
his house. Budram Lohar during that time was working as tractor
driver at Jubarajnagar OM Brick Field and the accused and the
victim were also working there as labourer. It was alleged that, on
the intervening night of 12-03-2019 and 13-03-2019, the accused
and the victim indulged in a quarrel under the influence of liquor
and accused committed the murder of the victim by strangulating
her and also by causing injuries with a sharp weapon and fled away
from the spot. On 13-03-2019 in the morning time, the body of the
victim was found in front of the shop of one Sailen Lohar with
visible injuries on her neck and other parts of the body and one
Pramila Lohar lodged an ejahar with Dharmanagar PS regarding the
incident.
[4]
The O/C Dharmanagar PS on receipt of the ejahar
registered Dharmanagar PS case No.23 of 2019 under Section 302
of IPC and endorsed the case to an SI for investigation. The I.O. on
completion of the investigation, submitted charge-sheet under
Section 302 of the IPC against the accused Sanjoy Munda. The
charge-sheet
was filed
before the
Court
of
learned
Judicial
Magistrate, North Tripura and prosecution papers were supplied to
the accused and thereafter the record was committed to the Court
of the Sessions Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar for trial.
[5]
Thereafter, charge was framed against the accused
under Section 302 of IPC and the same was read over and
explained to him to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be
tried.
[6]
The prosecution to establish the charge of murder
against the accused adduced as many as 27 witnesses. After
closure of the prosecution evidence the accused was examined
under Section 313 of Cr.P.C wherein he stated that the prosecution
case is false and declined to adduce any witness from his side.
Thereafter, the prosecution side submitted a prayer under Section
311 of Cr.P.C to examine Dr Dipak Ch. Haldar and the I.O. Ratan
Deb as witnesses in the case and the prayer was allowed and both
the witnesses were adduced by the prosecution.
[7]
Thereafter, upon hearing the arguments of both sides
and on perusal of the material evidence on record, learned trial
Court on 11.08.2023 in case No. ST (T-1) 32 of 2019, sentenced
the accused person, appellant herein in the following manner:
“......55.
ORDER
In the result, the prosecution has proved this case beyond all
reasonable doubt against the accused Sanjoy Munda.
The accused is accordingly convicted under Section 302 of the IPC.
I have heard the convict on the question of sentence and he
claimed himself as innocent and prayed for mercy.
I have also considered on the quantum of sentence.
The convict is found guilty for commission of offence of murder
and the punishment prescribed for the offence is either death or
imprisonment for life. The convict is found to have committed the murder
of the victim. However, the act of the convict in commission of the offence
does not come within the category of the rarest of the rare case.
Therefore, this Court is of the view that sentence for imprisonment of life
along with fine will suffice to render justice in this case.
The convict Sanjoy Munda is accordingly sentenced to suffer
imprisonment for life under Section 302 of IPC. The convict is also
sentenced to pay fine of Rs.5000/-(Rupees five thousand) under Section
302 of IPC and in default of payment of fine to suffer imprisonment for a
further period of five months. .....................”
[8]
Aggrieved by the above-quoted sentence passed by the
learned Court below, the appellant side has preferred this present
appeal seeking the following reliefs:
“I. Admit this appeal.
II. Call for the record of case no. S.T (T-1) 32 of 2019 by the Ld.
Sessions Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar.
III. After hearing the parties may be pleased allow this appeal by
quashing/setting aside the impugned judgment of conviction and
order of sentence dated 11/08/2023 passed in S.T (T-1) 32 of
2019 by the Ld. Sessions Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar and
may please set the appellant at liberty...............”
[9]
Mr. Sankar Bhattacharjee, learned Legal Aid Counsel
submits that learned trial Court has erred in law and came to a
wrong conclusion. He submits that learned Court below has failed to
appreciate that the case is based on circumstantial evidence and
there was no eye witness to the occurrence. He further submits that
the
material
witness
was
not
examined
nor
cited
by
the
prosecution. P.W.3 stated that he came to know that the appellant
was detained by Sanju Bhowmik but he said Sanju Bhowmik was
not examined.
[10]
Mr. Bhattacharjee contends that from the evidence of
PW- 1 it is clear that in front of their house the appellant and the
deceased were engaged in quarrel. Now, PW 11 has stated in his
examination in chief that in the night of incident he was sleeping
with his family member in his dwelling hut, at about 11.00 PM he
heard cry of a women from a nearby place of his house and he
called Manglu Karmakar (PW-15) who is his relative to see the
matter and allegedly found the women lying in the Varanda of shop
of Sailen Lohar and allegedly found the appellant cleaning blood
from a knife with a cloth. PW-15 also in similar tune stated the said
fact but, he deposed before the trial Court that the male person i.e.
the accused was found to have been cleaning blood from a dao with
a cloth. He submits that „knife‟ and „dao‟ are two different things
having different shape and size and thus, there was a clear
contradiction between the said two depositions. It is also contended
that PW-1 or PW-4 never stated that they ever heard crying of a
woman in front of her house. According to Mr. Bhattacharjee,
learned Legal Aid Counsel for the appellant, the learned Trial Court
has failed to appreciate the evidence on record in its proper
perspective and also has failed to appreciate that the prosecution
could not prove the chain of circumstances in the present case. He
further submits that the learned trial Court has failed to appreciate
that while the appellant was examined under section 313 of Cr.P.C.
to the question no. 92, he has specifically denied that deceased was
his wife, but, the learned Trial Court did not discuss the said
fact. Learned Legal Aid Counsel for the appellant, therefore, urges
this Court to set aside the impugned order dated 11.08.2023
passed by the learned Court below and to support his contention,
he has placed reliance on the judgment of the Hon‟ble Apex Court
passed in Karakkattu Muhammed Basheer Vs. State of Kerala
reported in 2024 STPL 11721 SC.
[11]
On the contrary, Mr. Rajib Saha, learned Addl. P.P.
appearing on behalf of the respondent-State submits that though
the P.W. 11 and P.W. 15 deposed that the accused was cleaning
blood from „knife‟ and „dao‟ respectively, but the same was seized
and as per the seizure list the weapon which was recovered was
mentioned as „dao‟ without handle measuring 10‟‟ (inch) in length.
Now, a 10‟‟ sized weapon may have appeared to someone as knife
as the size of the weapon was very similar to a knife and locally, the
weapon recovered may be known as something else. He further
contends that the present case is based on circumstantial evidence
and the circumstances in this case are vivid to state that the
murder of the victim was caused by no other person but, only the
accused person. To support his contention learned Addl. P.P. placed
reliance on the following judgments of the Hon‟ble Apex Court:
1.
State of Rajasthan v. Teja Ram and others reported in
(1999) 3 SCC 507.
2.
Barku Bhavrao Bhaskar v. State of Maharashtra reported
in (2013) 14 SCC 745.
[12]
Mr. Saha, learned Addl. P.P. further submits that the
concept of „last seen together‟ is also applicable in this case as the
witnesses deposed categorically that before the death of the victim,
the accused and the victim were seen together. He, therefore,
urges this Court that the present appeal filed by the appellant be
dismissed and the impugned order dated 11.08.2023 passed by the
learned trial Court should not be interfered with. To support his
contention, learned Addl. P.P. further placed reliance on the
following judgments of the Hon‟ble Apex Court:
1.
Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of Maharashtra reported
in (2006) 10 SCC 681.
2.
Ashok v. State of Maharashtra reported in (2015) 4 SCC
393.
[13]
Heard the submissions made at the Bar. Perused the
material evidence on record.
[14]
It is seen from record that P.W. 10, Pramila Gour, the
informant deposed that on 13-03-2019 in the early morning, she
received an information that last night at about 8 p.m two unknown
male and female were found quarrelling in the veranda of the shop
of Salien Lohar and Swapan Tanti of the locality intervened and
separated them and Sailen Lohar asked them to leave the place by
Samika Lohar and thereafter, he closed the shop. She deposed that
she also came to know in the early morning that the woman who
was quarrelling on the previous night is found dead with some
bleeding injuries on the veranda of the shop of Sailen Lohar. She
also deposed that she is the sardar of cha bagan panchayet and she
informed the matter to the police. She identified her signature on
the ejahar as Exhibit.5/2.
[15]
From the deposition of the informant P.W.10 as evident
from her testimony, she did not witness the incident of quarrel
between the unknown male and female on the previous night. She
merely heard about the quarrel on the next day when the dead
body of a female was found lying in the veranda of the shop of
Sailen Lohar.
[16]
P.W. 1, Samika Lohar deposed that one night about one
year back at about 10 p.m she heard about a quarrel in front of her
house and she came out and found accused Sanjoy Munda and his
wife Laxmi Munda engaged in a quarrel. She further deposed that
she warned both of them and asked them to leave the place. She
also deposed that she had seen both of them leaving that place with
a bag and then she returned back home. She stated that on the
next morning she saw a gathering of people in front of the shop of
Sailen Lohar and she also saw the body of Laxmı Munda lying there
with some cut injury on her neck and other parts of her body.
[17]
P.W. 7 Swapna Tanti
deposed similarly as P.W.1 that
one night about one year back at about 8 p.m she heard some hue
and cry outside the house and she came out and found an unknown
person and a lady engaged in quarrel in front of a shop near to her
house. She deposed that she returned back home thereafter and on
the next morning she found that the lady who was engaged in a
quarrel on the previous night was found lying dead in front of the
shop.
[18]
From the deposition of P.W.1 & P.W. 7, it is assumed
that they identified the accused Sanjoy Munda as the person who
was engaged in a quarrel on that night with a lady who was found
dead on the next morning. So far identity of that deceased lady is
concerned, P.W.1 in her testimony stated that the lady was Laxmi
Munda whom she found quarrelling with the accused on the
previous night. Before the learned trial Court, the accused side
while examining both the witnesses failed to draw any contradiction
so far identity of the accused and the victim is concerned.
[19]
It is also seen from record that P.W.11, Rabi Tanti
deposed before the learned trial Court that on 12-03-2019 at about
10 p.m he was returning from the work site and saw hue and cry in
front of the shop of Sailen Lohar and he noticed that a quarrel was
going on between a male and a female who were unknown to him.
He further deposed that the local people warned both of them not
to cause any nuisance in the locality and asked them to leave that
place. He further stated that on that night he was sleeping with his
family members in his house and it was around 11 p.m and he
heard cry of a woman from a place nearby to his house. He deposed
that he woke up and went out of his dwelling hut and called Manglu
Karmakar who is his relative to see the matter and he also went in
front of the shop of Sailen Lohar and found a person engaged in
cleaning blood from a knife with a cloth and the body of the woman
who was found engaged in quarrel with that person earlier on that
night in front of the shop of Sailen Lohar was lying in the veranda of
the shop with a neck cut injury and the lady was alive and
groaning. He also deposed that the person who was cleaning blood
from a knife with a cloth threatened him and others to leave the
place immediately. It was also deposed by the said P.W.11 that he
suspected that the person has killed that woman with a knife from
which he was cleaning blood with a cloth. He also deposed that the
police subsequently arrested that person and he came to know that
the name of said person is Sanjoy Munda and he was drunk on the
night of incident.
[20]
P.W.15,
Mangra
Karmakar
while
corroborating
the
statement made by P.W.11 Rabi Tanti stated that on 12-03-2019 at
about 9 p.m in the night there was a quarrel in between a male and
a female in front of the shop of Sailen Lohar and both were
intoxicated. He also deposed that he and other people asked both of
them to stop quarrel and to leave that place. It was further deposed
by him that he returned back home and after sometime heard cry
from outside and he went out of his dwelling hut. He also deposed
that he was called by P.W. 11 Rabi Tanti and both went in front of
the shop of Sailen Lohar and found that the woman who was
engaged in a quarrel with a male person earlier in the night was
lying in the veranda of the shop of Sailen Lohar with neck cut injury
and she was in a pool of blood and was groaning. He also stated
that he found that male person cleaning blood from a dao with a
cloth and he started shouting towards them and also threatened
them to leave the place otherwise they have to face the same
consequences like the lady. P.W.15 also identified that person as
accused Sanjoy Munda.
[21]
In the deposition of P.W.11 and P.W.15, in their
testimony, it is clearly stated that they found the accused Sanjoy
Munda quarreling with a woman on that night and after sometime
they heard the hue and cry of a woman and they went out and
found that the woman was lying in the veranda of the shop of
Sailen Lohar with injuries. The P.W. 11 deposed that he found that
the accused Sanjoy Munda was cleaning blood from a knife with a
cloth. The accused side while cross-examining PW11 had drawn
attention to his earlier statement recorded by I.O. and it was found
that the witness did not state specifically that he found the accused
cleaning blood from a knife. However P.W.11 in his statement to
I.O. stated that he found that the person was cleaning blood with a
cloth. The accused side at that juncture contended that PW11 in his
testimony before the court stated that he saw the accused cleaning
blood from a knife but in his statement to I.O. the witness did not
say anything regarding the knife. The accused side on this issue
raised question that PW11 was not a reliable witness since
contradiction was found in the testimony of PW11 regarding the use
of the knife.
[22]
During the course of argument before this Court, Mr. S.
Bhattacharjee, learned Legal Aid Counsel, submits that there is
contradictions between the deposition of statements between
P.W.11 & P.W.15. P.W.11 deposed that he saw the appellant
cleaning blood from a knife with a cloth whereas, P.W.15 deposed
that he saw the appellant cleaning blood from a dao with a cloth.
However, there has been clear evidence that the accused was found
cleaning blood with a cloth near to the body of that woman. On
perusal of record, it is seen that the weapon found was seized and
as per the seizure list the weapon which was recovered was
mentioned as „dao‟ without handle measuring 10‟‟ (inch) in length.
Learned Addl. P.P. during the course of argument, rightly pointed
out that a 10‟‟ sized weapon may have appeared to someone as
knife as the size of the weapon was very similar to a knife and
locally, the weapon recovered may be known as something else. In
view of the same, it is opined that the aforesaid contradiction is
minor in nature and it is not a material contradiction to discard the
entire testimony of P.W.11 & 15.
[23]
P.W. 22, Tulsi Prasad Munda deposed that the deceased
Laxmi Munda was his wife and about 13 years back he had got
himself married with Lami Munda. After three years of their
marriage, his wife left his residence for ever. He also deposed that
subsequently, he came to learn that his wife deceased Laxmi Munda
married to another person but he did not know that person.
[24]
P.W.20, Budhram Lohar deposed before the trial court
that one day about 3 years back at about 3 p.m, he was going
home to take lunch and he met Laxmi Munda and her husband on
the road where both of them requested him to accompany them to
the house of one Bhuvan Tanti. He deposed that he accompanied
both of them to the house of Bhuvan Tanti where both of them
consumed country made liquor and thereafter, P.W. 20 went to his
place of work after taking lunch. He deposed that after returning
home he came to know from his wife and other family members
that Laxmi Munda and her husband visited his residence in the
afternoon with intent to stay in his house but his family members
did not give them shelter in the house. It was also deposed by the
P.W. 20 that on the following morning he came to know that the
dead body of Laxmi Munda was found lying in front of the shop of
Sailen Lohar. And in his cross-examination, P.W. 20 stated that he
knew the victim and the accused while working at OM Brick Field.
He also stated in his cross-examination that the accused was the
husband of the deceased and he could not say whether one Tulsi
Munda was the husband of the deceased or not. It was also stated
that he was arrested by police in connection with the murder of
Laxmi Munda and was in the custody for three days.
[25]
The deposition of P.W. 20 also indicates the presence of
the accused and the victim together on the date of incident. It also
indicates that he knew the accused and the deceased as husbandwife since earlier they were co-workers in the OM Brick Field.
[26]
Dr. Dipak Ch. Haldar, P.W.23 deposed that he was
posted in the Dharmanagar hospital as medical officer since 2015
and he had worked with Dr. Abhishek Paul Majumder and knew his
signature and handwriting. He also stated that on 13-03-2019, Dr.
Majumder conducted post mortem examination over the body of an
unknown female in connection with Dharmanagar P.S Case No.23 of
2019 and opined that it is a case of asphyxia due to strangulation.
P.W.23 identified the P.M. Report as Exhibit.8 and also stated that
during the examination laceration were found on the body of the
victim. P.W.23 although failed to state the name of the unknown
woman but he stated that the post mortem examination was done
in connection with Dharmanagar PS Case No.23 of 2019. In view of
the same, it is clear that the unknown woman was none but Laxmi
Munda. It is also clear from the P.M. Report that although there
were laceration on the body of the victim but, she died due to
asphyxia as a result of strangulation.
[27]
P.W.24, Sri Ratan Debnath i.e. the Investigating Officer
deposed in course of investigation that he seized the wearing
apparels of the victim and arranged for sending them to SFSL,
Narsingarh for examination and later he collected the report. He
also deposed that he arranged for collection of samples from the
body of the deceased and also forwarded them to SFSL for
examination and report.
[28]
From the testimony of P.W.8 i.e. Dr. Subhankar Nath,
Deputy Director, SFSL Tripura, it is found that on 13.05.2019 he
was endorsed to examine certain exhibits received in connection
with Dharmanagar PS Case No.23 of 2019 and those exhibits were
one yellow-white coloured printed saree marked as Exhibit.A,
black/white/red coloured printed saree marked as Exhibit.B, one
yellow coloured full sleeve sweater marked as Exhibit.C and sky
coloured half jeans pant marked as Exhibit.D and he examined all
those exhibits and he found blood stained in all the four exhibits
and he subjected them for DNA isolation by organic extracting
method and after examination found that the blood stain detected
in all the four exhibits was female blood and it originated from the
single/same source.
[29]
It is seen from record that so far the aforesaid exhibits A
& B are concerned these are the wearing apparels of the victim and
Exhibits. C and D are the wearing apparels of the accused. During
the examination blood stains were found in all the four exhibits and
those were female blood and originated from a single source. Then
the question arises, how the blood stain of the victim was found on
the wearing apparels of the accused marked as Exhibit.C & D. At
this juncture, as discussed earlier on the testimony of P.W.23, the
victim had laceration on some parts of her body and it indicates
that blood came out from such laceration and that blood left some
stain on the wearing apparels of the accused. The accused has
miserably failed to explain in his defence, the presence of those
blood stains of the deceased on his wearing apparels.
[30]
In view of the failure of the accused in explaining his
case in his defence and on perusal of the material evidences as
dealt by the learned trial Court, this Court is of the view that all the
evidences clearly indicate that the lacerated injuries to the victim
could have been caused by the accused since he was present at the
time of the death of the victim and there was every possibility that
he strangulated the victim to death and while doing so blood stain
originated from the lacerated wounds of the victim and these were
found on the wearing apparels of the accused. The testimony of
PW11 and 15, also categorically indicates that they found the
accused cleaning blood just near to the body of the victim.
[31]
In view of the above discussion, this Court has no
hesitation to say that the present case is based on circumstantial
evidence. In this regard, the relevant contents of the judgment of
Hon‟ble Apex Court as referred earlier by the learned Addl. P.P. on
behalf of the State, are quoted as under:
Barku Bhavrao Bhaskar v. State of Maharashtra reported in
(2013) 14 SCC 745:
“.......14. As far as the other circumstance, namely, about the bloodstains
found on the clothes of the appellant was concerned, it was contended that
though the blood group found on the clothes of the appellant was "A" and
that the blood group of the deceased was also "A", it was submitted on
behalf of the appellant that the blood group of the appellant was not
tested. While examining the said contention, the High Court has taken
pains to note that when at the instance of the appellant, his shirt was
recovered under Exts. 16 and 17 and when the appellant was physically
examined, it was found that there were absolutely no injuries on the body
of the appellant and, therefore, the question of the bloodstains from the
body of the appellant to get transmitted to his shirt was ruled out. It was,
therefore, held that the bloodstains found on the appellant's shirt,
considered along with the factum of the appellant having led the
prosecution to discover his bloodstained clothes and the body of the
deceased put together, the bloodstains found on the shirt of the appellant
could have been only that of the deceased and none else. The said
conclusion arrived at by the High Court was fully justified and no fault can
be found with the said conclusion. As regards the bloodstains found on the
shirt of the appellant, except the ipse dixit submission made on this
aspect, no other submission was made and there was no valid explanation
offered on behalf of the appellant as to how the bloodstains came to be
found on his shirt, which was recovered at his instance, in the presence of
the panch witnesses..........”
[32]
This Court is further of the opinion that the concept of
„last seen together‟ is also applicable in the present case as the
witnesses as discussed above, deposed categorically that before the
death of the victim, the accused and the victim were seen together.
In this regard, the relevant contents of the judgment of Hon‟ble
Apex Court as referred earlier by the learned Addl. P.P. on behalf of
the State, are quoted as under:
Ashok v. State of Maharashtra reported in (2015) 4 SCC 393:
“8. The "last seen together" theory has been elucidated by this Court in
Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of Maharashtra [(2006) 10 SCC 681], in
the following words: (SCC p. 694, para 22)
"22. Where an accused is alleged to have committed the murder of
his wife and the prosecution succeeds in leading evidence to show
that shortly before the commission of crime they were seen
together or the offence takes place in the dwelling home where the
husband also normally resided, it has been consistently held that if
the accused does not offer any explanation how the wife received
injuries or offers an explanation which is found to be false, it is a
strong circumstance which indicates that he is responsible for
commission of the crime. Thus, the doctrine of last seen together
shifts the burden of proof onto the accused, requiring him to
explain how the incident had occurred. Failure on the part of the
accused to furnish any explanation in this regard, would give rise
to a very strong presumption against him.*"
9. In Ram Gulam Chaudhary v. State of Bihar[(2001) 8 SCC 311], the
accused after brutally assaulting a boy carried him away and thereafter
the boy was not seen alive nor was his body found. The accused, however,
offered no explanation as to what they did after they took away the boy. It
was held that for absence of any explanation from the side of the accused
about the boy, there was every justification for drawing an inference that
they had murdered the boy.*****************
12. From the study of abovestated judgments and many others delivered
by this Court over a period of years, the rule can be summarised as that
the initial burden of proof is on the prosecution to bring sufficient evidence
pointing towards guilt of the accused. However, in case of last seen
together, the prosecution is exempted to prove exact happening of the
incident as the accused himself would have special knowledge of the
incident and thus, would have burden of proof as per Section 106 of the
Evidence Act. Therefore, last seen together itself is not a conclusive proof
but along with other circumstances surrounding the incident, like relations
between the accused and the deceased, enmity between them, previous
history of hostility, recovery of weapon from the accused, etc. nonexplanation of death of the deceased, may lead to a presumption of
guilt.............”
[33]
In
view
of
the
above
discussions,
following
the
judgments of Hon‟ble Apex Court cited supra, we are of the opinion
that there is no scope for taking any lenient view or extending
benefit of doubts in favour of the accused-appellant. We find no
infirmity in the impugned order dated 11.08.2023 passed in S.T (T1) 32 of 2019 by the learned Sessions Judge, North Tripura,
Dharmanagar, convicting and sentencing the appellant to suffer
imprisonment for life under Section 302 of IPC with default
stipulations.
Accordingly,
the
said
impugned
order
dated
11.08.2023 passed by the learned Court below is hereby affirmed.
We are also of the opinion that the judgment referred by the
learned Legal Aid Counsel on behalf of the appellant, is not
applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present case.
With the above observations, the instant appeal is
hereby
dismissed.
As
a
sequel,
miscellaneous
application(s),
pending if any, shall also stand closed.
Send down the LCRs.
B. PALIT, J
Sabyasachi G.
SABYASACHI GHOSH GHOSH
Date: 2025.07.04 15:40:15 +05'30'
DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review