Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. A(J) 44/2024
Sri Purbahari Jamatia, son of late Suresh Chandra Jamatia,
resident of Rajapada Para (Krishnabhaktabari), P.S. R.K. Pur,
District- Gomati, Tripura.
----Appellant
Versus
The State of Tripura
----Respondent
For the Appellant(s)
:
Ms. Varsha Poddar,
Legal Aid Counsel
For the Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing & delivery
of Judgment & Order
:
07.01.2026
Whether fit for reporting
Yes/No
:
Mr. R. Saha, Addl. PP
BEFORE
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT(ORAL)
(Dr.T.Amarnath Goud, J)
Heard Ms. Varsha Poddar, learned Legal Aid Counsel appearing
for the appellant. Also heard Mr. R. Saha, learned Additiional Public
Prosecutor, appearing for the respondent-State of Tripura.
2.
The appellant, by means of filing the present appeal has
challenged the judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated
25.07.2022 and 27.07.2022, respectively, passed by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur, in connection with case
No. Sessions Trial 09 of 2020, whereby the appellant has been convicted
under Section 302 IPC and sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for life
with default stipulation.
3.
Facts leading to the present appeal are that, on 20.04.2020 at
around 8.00 p.m. the mother of the complainant, Durgarani Jamatia, went to
the house of their neighbour Ramhari Jamatia to attend a kirtan and at around
9.00 p.m. while her mother was about to leave the courtyard of Ramhari
Jamatia for her house, at that time father of the informant, namely, Purbahari
Jamatia, came there and gave random dao blows on the neck of the mother of
the informant, as a result of which she died at the spot. A specific case was
registered against the accused-appellant. In course of investigation, the
Investigating Officer recorded the statement of the available witnesses, seized
the material articles, arranged for post mortem of the deceased and arrested
the appellant-accused. After completion of investigation, charge sheet was
submitted against the accused appellant under Section 302 IPC. After receipt
of the papers, learned CJM, Gomati, Udaipur, took cognizance of the offence
against the accused-appellant and thereby committed the case to the court of
learned Sessions Judge, Gomati. Learned Sessions Judge, after supplying the
prosecution papers, framed charge against the accused-appellant to which he
pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. Accordingly, trial commenced.
During trial, prosecution examined 25 witnesses and exhibited some
documents.
Subsequently, examination of the prosecution witnesses was
closed and the accused appellant was examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C.
wherein he denied all the incriminating materials brought against him and also
declined to adduce any defence witness. Having heard learned counsels
appearing for the parties, and after considering the oral and documentary
evidence, the learned trial Court passed the impugned judgment of conviction
and order of sentence. Being aggrieved, the appellant has filed the present
appeal challenging the impugned judgment and order of conviction and
sentence.
4.
Ms. Poddar, learned Legal Aid Counsel appearing for the
appellant has submitted that the conviction passed by the learned trial court is
not based on cogent evidence. Learned counsel has also submitted that the
deposition of the alleged eye-witness i.e. PW-1, has not been corroborated
with deposition of other witnesses. Learned counsel has further submitted that
the entire case is based on circumstantial evidence, but the prosecution has
miserably failed to prove the circumstance. Learned counsel for the appellant
has also submitted that there are many discrepancies in the deposition of the
witnesses and also the medical documents/reports do not support the
prosecution story. Thus, learned counsel has urged this court for clear
acquittal of the appellant. Another argument, which has been advanced by the
learned counsel for the appellant is that even if it is to be held that the accused
was responsible for the death of deceased i.e. his wife, and further that her
death was a culpable homicide, he would still not be guilty of the offence of
murder and at best it could be a case of culpable homicide, not amounting to
murder punishable under the second part of Section 304 IPC since it is well
established from the deposition of the prosecution witnesses that the relation
between the accused-appellant and his wife i.e. the victim was not cordial and
relating to resolve dispute between them, several village meetings were held,
and sought for interference of this Court.
5.
Mr. Saha, learned Additional PP defending the judgment of
conviction and order of sentence has submitted that the case is well-proved as
there are three eye- witnesses to the incident, namely, Ramhari Jamatia (PW1), Smt. Indrabhakti Jamatia (PW-16) and Smt. Renubala Jamatia (PW-17).
Mr. Saha, has further submitted that the medical report has established the fact
that the deceased was killed due to deadly hit by a dao inflicted by the
appellant at her neck. Learned Additional PP has further submitted that the
depositions of the other witnesses are consistent. In fine, learned Additional
PP has urged this court that the finding of the learned trial Court requires no
interference.
6.
Taking the aforesaid submissions into consideration, this Court
would proceed to decide the appeal at hand to examine whether there is any
manifest error or illegality and whether any miscarriage of justice on account
of misreading or ignoring material evidence has occurred in the present case.
This invariably would require a proper examination of the facts and context of
the case, for which we must revisit the background facts of the case and
evidence adduced.
7.
In course of trial, prosecution has examined as many as 25
witnesses, out of which PW-1, PW-16, and PW-17, are the eye-witnesses to
the alleged incident. PW-1, in his deposition has categorically stated that one
year back at night at around 8/8.30 p.m., Durga Rani Jamatia visited his house
for the purpose of Gariya Puja and at that time he alongwith four others were
present having some homely made cakes. PW-1 further deposed that, when
the victim (Durga Rani), was about to leave his house and on the way between
the courtyard and road, she was brutally attacked with a ‘dao’ on her neck by
her husband, namely, Purbahari Jamatia and then Durga Rani fell down on the
ground and died on the spot. PW-1, further deposed that thereafter Purbahari
fled away. PW-16, in her deposition stated that about one and half year back
at around 9.00 p.m. after completion of kirtan she alongwith Durga Rani
Jamatia (the victim) was sitting in the house of PW-1, for taking homely made
cake and at that time the husband of Durga Rani Jamatia, namely, Purbahari
Jamatia came there and gave her a dao blow on her neck resulting which
Durga Rani fell down on the ground. PW-16 further deposed that thereafter
Purbahari Jamatia left the place of occurrence. The deposition of PW-17 was a
replica to the deposition adduced by PW-16.
PWs-2, 3, 4, 5, 6 (complainant herein), 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14,15, are
the local inhabitants of Rajapadapara, and all these witnesses are hearsay
witnesses, but they have collectively deposed that the appellant has killed his
wife by a sharp cutting dao in the courtyard of Ramahari Jamatia. These
witnesses have further stated that the relation between the appellant and the
victim was not cordial and the appellant used to torture the victim after
consuming alcohol.
PW-6 and PW-12, are the sons of the victim and the appellant. PW-6
and 12 conjointly have stated that from their childhood they used to see that
their father i.e. the appellant, used to assault their mother i.e. the victim, and
on that issue, both the witnesses used to intervene. PW-6, also stated that his
mother brought the matter of torture to the village Panchayat and several
meetings were convened to settle their dispute and finally in one village
baithak held on 16.04.2020 it was decided that the victim will stay with her
sons and the appellant will reside separately.
PW-11, is the Village Chowdhury (Sardar) of Rajapadapara village.
This witness deposed that the victim, Durga Rani Jamatia used to pray for
village baithak about causing assault upon her by her husband i.e. the
appellant herein, and PW-11 being the Village Sardar settled their dispute on
several occasions. PW-11, further deposed that the victim prior to the alleged
incident filed a written complaint to him against her husband to settle their
dispute and finally the same was settled after which the appellant and the
victim started to reside separately.
PW-8 and 9 in their deposition stated that on 20.04.2020 at about 1.00
p.m., the appellant was detained by police nearby their house in the rubber
plantation with the offending weapon i.e. the dao, which was then seized by
the I.O. by preparing a seizure list marked as Exhibit-M.O. 6, and PW-8 and 9
put their signatures on the seizure list marked as Exhibit-10 and 10/1.
Thus, from the entire deposition of the prosecution witnesses, as stated
above, it is evident that the testimony of the witnesses is corroborative in
nature. The witnesses also identified the accused in the dock. Further, the
appellant in his examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C. also declined to
adduce any evidence on his behalf.
Now, if we go through the medical evidence, it is found that PW-24,
Medical Officer, has conducted PM examination over the dead body of the
deceased. As per his examination a chop wound measuring 8cm x 4cm x bone
deep was found in the left side of the neck of the victim and the same was
sharp directing above downwards. As per his opinion, the cause of death was
haemorrhagic shock due to sharp force trauma to the neck in association with
injury to the vital organs of neck, and all the injuries were ante mortem in
nature.
Further, from the Surathal/Inquest report, it is revealed that some
portion of the throat of the victim on its left side is lacerated which is caused
by the hacking blows with sharp-edged weapon.
If the post mortem examination report, surathal/inquest report and the
deposition of PWs 1, 16 and 17 are read unanimously, it would conclusively
be seen that the PWs 1, 16 and 17 deposed that the appellant gave a dao blow
on the neck of the victim wherein the PM examination report and the inquest
report also speak that the cause of death was due to haemorrhagic shock due
to sharp force trauma to the neck in association with injury to the vital organs
of neck and the left side of the neck is lacerated caused by sharp-edged
weapon.
Thus, the evidence of PWs 1, 16 and 17, who are eye-witnesses to the
alleged incident, are trustworthy, consistent and reliable.
Consequently, the evidence of PWs-2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13,
14,15, falls under the same line to that of PWs 1, 16 and 17.
8.
Upon scrutiny of the depositions of the material witnesses as well
as the exhibits produced by the prosecution, predominantly, it is evident that
on the alleged date, time and place, the deceased died due to the injuries
caused due to a dao blow on her neck inflicted by her husband, the appellant
herein, which has been clearly demonstrated in their deposition that the
accused was having a sharp cutting weapon and all on a sudden the appellant
inflicted dao blow upon the neck of the deceased. Further, from the line of the
evidence of the prosecution witness it is revealed that the appellant prior to
commission of the alleged crime used to assault the victim i.e.his wife under
the influence of liquor and the same happened to be a regular phenomenon.
Thus, it can be presumed that there was no sudden provocation or in a heat of
moment he had committed the alleged offence rather the same was
predetermined.
9.
Though learned counsel for the appellant pointed out certain
inconsistencies/contradictions in the evidence let in by the prosecution, they
being minor in nature, cannot be considered as remissness in the investigation
enabling the appellant’s acquittal when the presence and act of the appellant
was well proved through the prosecution witnesses, more particularly, PWs 1,
16 and 17, and also through the medical papers. It is settled proposition of law
that even if there are some omissions, contradictions and discrepancies, the
entire evidence cannot be discarded. Thus, it can be held that there is nothing
which could shatter the veracity of the prosecution witnesses or falsify the
claim of the prosecution. All the prosecution witnesses have materially
supported the prosecution case and, the testimonies of the prosecution
witnesses do not suffer from any material infirmity or contradiction and are
consistent and corroborative. The evidence of the prosecution witnesses is
natural and trustworthy and corroborated by medical evidence. The
prosecution witnesses have been able to build up a continuous link. Therefore,
it is established beyond reasonable doubt that the accused-appellant
committed the murder of his wife.
10.
In fine, taking into consideration all these circumstances
cumulatively, we find that the trial Court was justified in arriving at the
conclusion that it was the accused-appellant who committed the crime in
question. On re-appreciation of the entire oral and documentary evidence, we
find that the conclusion arrived at by the learned trial Court is neither illegal
nor perverse. Hence, we find no reason to disturb with the judgment and order
of conviction and sentence dated 25.07.2022 and 27.07.2022 respectively
passed by the learned trial Court. Hence, the appeal stands dismissed.
Consequently, the finding of conviction and sentence as returned by the
learned trial Court is confirmed.
S.DATTA PURKAYASTHA,J
SAIKAT KAR
DR.T. AMARNATH GOUD,J
KAR
Date: 2026.01.16 21:35:43
-08'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review