Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page - 1 of 15
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Sri Litan Paul,
Son of Sri Bakul Paul,
Resident of Kasihpur, Reshambagan,
P.S-East Agartala, District-West Tripura.
-----Petitioner(s).
On behalf of :
Sri Mithan Paul @Buttu @ Mithun Paul,
Son of Sri Bakul Paul,
Vill- Netajinagar Coloney (Uricherra)
P.S-Kanchanpur, District-North Tripura.
-----Custody Accused Person.
Versus
1.
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Chief Secretary, Government of
Tripura, New Secretariat Building, Kunjaban, Agartala,
Agartala.
2.
The Secretary,
Department of Home, Government of Tripura, New
Secretariat Building, Kunjaban, Agartala.
3.
The Director General of Police,
Government of Tripura, Fire Brigade Chowmuhani,
Agartala.
4.
The Assistant Inspector General of Police,
Government of Tripura, Fire Brigade Chowmuhani,
Agartala.
5.
The Superintendent of Police,
North Tripura District, Dharmanagar,
North Tripura District.
6.
The Sub-Divisional Police Officer (SDPO),
Kanchanpur, North Tripura District.
7.
The Officer-in-Charge,
Kanchanpur Police Station, Kanchanpur, North Tripura.
8.
The Chairman,
Advisory Board, PIT NDPS Act, 1988,
Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura.
----- Respondent(s)
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 2 of 15
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. INDRAJIT MAHANTY
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. G. CHATTOPADHYAY
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. A. K. Pal, Advocate,
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
: 1st June, 2022.
Mr. Ratan Datta, Public Prosecutor.
Mr. Biswanath Majumder, CGC.
Date of Judgment & Order : 22nd June, 2022.
Whether fit for reporting
: Yes.
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(S.G. Chattopadhyay, J)
We have heard Mr. A. K. Pal, learned counsel appearing for
the detenue as well as Mr. Ratan Datta, learned public Prosecutor
appearing for the State-respondents. Mr. Biswanath Majumder, learned
CGC has appeared for the Union of India who submits that the Union of
India has received copy of the detention order in due course.
[2]
Detenue Mithan Paul @ Buttu @ Mithun Paul was detained
under Section 3(1) of the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs &
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988 (PITNDPS Act, hereunder) by an order
dated 13.10.2021 issued by the Secretary to the Government of Tripura in
the Home Department. The grounds of his detention are stated to be as
under:
“Grounds for detention Mithan Paul @ Butto @ Mitun S/o
Shri Bakul Paul of Netajinagar, PS-Kanchanpur, North
Tripura.
Following are the grounds for detention Mithan
Paul @Butto @ Mitun, S/o Shri Bakul Paul of Netaji
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 3 of 15
Nagar, P.S-Kanchanpur, North Tripura under Section 3(1)
of the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs &
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988.
[1]
As per report of Director General of Police,
Tripura, the aforesaid Mithan Paul @Butto @ Mitun, S/o
Shri Bakul Paul was involved in the following cases:(i)
Kanchanpur PS Case No. 2018KCP033
dated 23.04.2018 U/S 21(c) of NDPS Act,1985.
(ii)
Kanchanpur PS Case No. 2019KCP036
dated 21.05.2019 U/S 21(c)/25/29 of NDPS
Act,1985.
(iii) Kanchanpur PS Case No. 2020KCP009
dated 27.02.2020 U/S 21(b)/29 of NDPS Act,1985.
[2]
Mithan Paul @Butto @ Mitun, S/o Shri Bakul Paul
of Netaji Nagar, PS-Kanchanpur, North Tripura has
association with the smugglers of NDPS articles and illicit
drug traffickers in connection with Kanchanpur PS case
No. Kanchanpur PS Case No. 2018KCP033 dated
23.04.2018 U/S 21(c) of NDPS Act,1985, Kanchanpur PS
Case No. 2019KCP036 dated 21.05.2019 U/S 21(c)/25/29
of NDPS Act,1985 and Kanchanpur PS Case No.
2020KCP009 dated 27.02.2020 U/S 21(b)/29 of NDPS
Act,1985.
[3]
The person is still active in illicit trafficking of
NDPS articles as revealed from field information but could
not be arrested red-handed again and issue of detention
order under PITNDPS will also help Police in initiating
financial investigation laid down under Chapter-V(A) of
NDPS Act.
[4]
He is a habitual offender and he is continuously
involved in illegal business of NDPS especially in
Kanchanpur Sub-Divisional areas. Action for prosecution
u/s 110 Cr. PC is being initiated him. As a result, his illegal
activities there is a serious threat to the health and welfare
of the people of Kanchanpur areas specially the youths in
particular. Mithan Paul is a dreaded and hard-core
criminal and despite being arrested for similar cases on
several occasions, he has not restrained himself from
illegal trade of NDPS. Even the local publics are presently
aggrieved for his illegal activities.
Such kind of criminals are dangerous and
detrimental for the society where several youths are falling
pray to drug addiction without being aware of the evil
consequences. If this type of clandestine but organised
illegal business is carried on by Mithan Paul in this part of
the State, there is very possibility of further deleterious
effect to the youth group in adjoining areas and the whole
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 4 of 15
State in general too in a larger magnitude. Drug addiction
is a menace which completely destroy the individual
mentally and physically which usually lead the drug user to
resort to other crime like burglary, theft, crime against
Women etc.”
[3]
The detenue was served with the order of detention along with
the grounds thereof on 20.10.2021. Pursuant to the order, he was detained
in Kanchanpur sub-jail on the same day i.e. on 20.10.2021. Copies of the
documents relied on by the detaining authority were also served on the
detenue. He also acknowledged the receipt of those documents. The
detenue was apprised of his right to make representation to the
Central/State Government, the detaining authority as well as to the
Advisory Board.
[4]
The detenue had submitted representation on 20.11.2021 to
the detaining authority claiming that he was falsely implicated in all the
three NDPS cases in which charge sheet was laid without application of
mind. He claimed that in none of those cases, any contraband was
recovered from his possession. As a result, he was granted bail in all those
cases by the learned Trial Court but the detaining authority issued the
detention order without even considering the bail orders passed in those
cases. The detenue further claimed that since he did not commit any
offence under NDPS Act, the question of his being a repeated offender did
not arise. According to the detenue, the detaining authority issued the
detention order without application of mind and, therefore, the said order
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 5 of 15
should be quashed. His representation was rejected by the detaining
authority by an order issued on 09.12.2021 which reads as under:
“O-R-D-E-R
WHEREAS, a detention order vide No.15(9)PD/2021(P-V) dated 12.10.2021 under PITNDPS Act, 1988
was issued by the Home Department, Government of
Tripura against Shri Mithan Paul @Butto @ Mitun, S/o
Shri Bakul Paul of Netajinagar, PS-Kanchanpur, North
Tripura District on the basis of a proposal received from
the Director General of Police, Tripura.
AND
WHEREAS, Shri Mithan Paul was detained on
20.10.2021 under PITNDPS Act, 1988 in pursuance to the
aforesaid order of the Home Department dated 12.10.2021.
AND
WHEREAS, Shri Mithan Paul at present under
detention at Kanchanpur Sub-Jail, North Tripura has
submitted a representation to the Secretary, Home
Department, Government of Tripura 20.11.2021 for
releasing him from the present detention.
AND
WHEREAS, the representation filed by Shri Mithan
Paul and the parawise comments submitted by
Superintendent of Police, North Tripura have been
carefully examined and found that he is a repeated offender
and he continuously involved in illicit trafficking of NDPS
and that his claim of being falsely implicated by police does
not stand.
NOW, THEREFORE, the State Government after
careful examination of the records available is pleased to
reject the prayer/representation of Shri Mithan Paul for his
release from detention under the PITNDPS Act, 1988.”
[5]
We have been taken through the official records maintained
by the department. It has appeared to us that in due course the matter was
referred to the Advisory Board in terms of Section 9(b) of the PITNDPS
Act along with necessary documents. To provide an opportunity of
personal hearing, the Advisory Board asked the detaining authority to
produce the detenue before the Board if the detenue so desired.
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 6 of 15
Accordingly, the detenue was produced before the Advisory Board on
23.11.2021. He was heard by the Advisory Board and his statement was
also recorded by the Advisory Board where he stated that he was shocked
to know that even after being granted bail in all the three cases registered
against him under NDPS Act, he was again detained under a preventive
detention order. The detenue stated before the Advisory Board that he was
maintaining his family with the income generated from his grocery
business. All the three cases were planted against him and he had no
connection with the alleged illegal activities. The Advisory Board
however, opined that the detention order was based on adequate materials
and the detaining authority issued the order after proper application of
mind. The Advisory Board communicated its opinion dated 21.12.2021 to
the detaining authority.
[6]
Pursuant to the report received from the Advisory Board, the
detaining authority by order dated 27.12.2021 confirmed the detention
order in terms of Clause (f) of Section 9 of the PITNDPS Act for a period
of one year from the date of his detention i.e. from 20.11.2021. The said
confirmation order was also served on the detenue at Kendriya
Sansodhanagar, Bishalgarh on 01.02.2022 in presence of the witnesses.
[7]
Aggrieved by his detention, the petitioner has challenged the
detention order by making this application under Article 226 of the
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 7 of 15
Constitution seeking issuance of a writ of a habeas corpus, commanding
the respondents to release him from detention.
[8]
The petitioner has challenged the detention order mainly on
the following grounds:
(i)
The order of detention is vitiated by non-application of
mind of the detaining authority.
(ii)
The detaining authority did not consider the fact that
the detenue was granted bail in the 03 NDPS cases lodged
against him. The detaining authority should have considered
the bail orders to arrive at a subjective satisfaction about the
need of preventive detention of the detenue.
(iii)
The last case was registered against him under NDPS
Act in 2020. There was no complaint against him that he was
likely to commit further offence. In these circumstances, the
detaining authority should not have passed a preventive
detention order against the detenue.
[9]
Counter affidavit was filed by the State-respondents on
27.04.2022 in which it was asserted that the detenue was engaged in
nefarious activities in trafficking of NDPS and forming of illegal business
ring for proliferation of such activities over a quite long period of time. He
was booked in as many as three cases for violation of the various
provisions of the NDPS Act and after collecting adequate materials against
him charge sheet was laid in the following three cases:
(i)
Kanchanpur PS Case No. 2018KCP033
dated 23.04.2018 U/S 21(c) of NDPS Act,1985.
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 8 of 15
(ii) Kanchanpur PS Case No. 2019KCP036
dated 21.05.2019 U/S 21(c)/25/29 of NDPS
Act,1985.
(iii) Kanchanpur PS Case No. 2020KCP009
dated 27.02.2020 U/S 21(b)/29 of NDPS Act,1985.
[10]
It was further asserted by the State-respondents that he was a
repeated offender under the NDPS Act and, therefore, with a view to
preventing him from engaging in illegal traffic and narcotic drugs and
psychotropic substances, it was necessary to make an order directing his
preventive detention.
[11]
Mr. A. K. Pal, learned counsel appearing for the detenue has
submitted that the detaining authority did not consider the fact that no
contraband was seized from the possession of the detenue in any of the
NDPS cases registered against him and moreover, the detaining authority
did not also consider the fact that he was granted bail in all the three cases
registered against him and there was no report that he further engaged
himself in trafficking NDPS. Counsel contends that non-consideration of
these essential facts has vitiated the detention order due to non application
of mind. It is contended by Mr. A. K. Pal, learned counsel that petitioner is
a poor man who is the only breadwinner of his family consisting of his old
and ailing parents. According to learned counsel, the petitioner runs a
grocery shop and he has no connection with trafficking in NDPS. Counsel
therefore, urges the Court for quashing the preventive detention order.
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 9 of 15
[12]
Mr. Ratan Datta, learned Pubic Prosecutor has contended
that in the detention order, the grounds of the detention of the petitioner
have been indicated. Moreover, the grounds of his detention more
elaborately discussed in a separate sheet of paper have also been
communicated to the petitioner along with the documents at the time of
service of the detention order on the detenue. Detenue was also informed
about his right to make a representation against the detention order. Mr.
Datta, learned Public Prosecutor has contended that the detenue exercised
his right to representation by submitting a written representation to the
detaining authority and it would appear from the said written
representation that there is no complaint of any infraction of the provisions
of Sub-Section (1), (2) and (3) of Section 3 of the PITNDPS Act and
Clause (5) of Article 22 of the Constitution. Counsel contends that as many
as three cases under NDPS Act has already been registered against the
detenue and still he is pursuing his illegal activities in the trafficking of
NDPS. Therefore, his preventive detention was absolutely necessary to
maintain law and order in the society by preventing the detenue from
further engaging in illicit trafficking in NDPS. Counsel has therefore,
urged the Court for dismissing the petition.
[13]
In Sub-Section (3) of Section 3 of PITNDPS Act it is
provided that for the purpose of Clause (5) of Article 22 of the
Constitution, the communication, to a person detained in pursuance of
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 10 of 15
detention order, of the grounds on which the order has been made shall be
made as soon as may be after the detention, but ordinarily not later than
five days, and in exceptional cases and for reasons to be recorded in
writing, not later than 15 days, from the date of detention.
[14]
On bare reading of Section 3(1) of the NDPS Act, it would
emerge that a detention order under Section 3(1) can be issued on the
subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority that, with a view to
preventing a person from engaging in illicit trafficking in narcotic drugs
and psychotropic substances, preventive detention of such person is
necessary. In a catena of decisions, the Apex Court has made it absolutely
unambiguous that the documents and all other materials including police
report, if any, proposing such detention are to be supplied to the detenue
so as to enable him to make an appropriate and effective representation
challenging the grounds of detention.
[15]
In Sub-Section (3) of Section 3 of the PITNDPS Act it has
been provided as under:
―3. Power to make orders detaining certain persons.—
(3) For the purposes of clause (5) of Article 22 of the
Constitution, the communication to a person detained in
pursuance of a detention order of the grounds on which
the order has been made shall be made as soon as may be
after the detention, but ordinarily not later than five days,
and in exceptional circumstances and for reasons to be
recorded in writing, not later than fifteen days, from the
date of detention.‖
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 11 of 15
[16]
Clause (5) of Article 22 provides that when any person is
detained in pursuance of an order made under any order providing for
preventive detention, the authority making the order shall, as soon as may
be, communicate to such person the grounds on which the order has been
made and shall afford him the earliest opportunity of making a
representation against the order.
[17]
Clause (4) of Article 22 of the Constitution provides as under:
―22. Protection against arrest and detention in certain
cases.—
(4) No law providing for preventive detention shall
authorise the detention of a person for a longer period
than three months unless –
(a)
an Advisory Board consisting of persons
who are, or have been, or are qualified to be
appointed as, Judges of a High Court has reported
before the expiration of the said period of three
months that there is in its opinion sufficient cause
for such detention:
Provided that nothing in this sub-clause shall
authorise the detention of any person beyond the
maximum period prescribed by any law made by
Parliament under sub-clause (b) or clause (7); or.
(b)
such person is detained in accordance with
the provisions of any law made by Parliament
under sub-clauses (a) and (b) of clause (7).‖
[18]
As discussed, the detention order along with the grounds of
detention and all other material documents were served on the detenue
within the stipulated time and he was thus afforded the earliest opportunity
of making a representation against such order. Undisputedly, the detenue
made a written representation on 20.11.2021 which was rejected by the
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 12 of 15
detaining authority by an order dated 09.12.2021 after consideration of the
representation on merit.
[19]
It is on record that the detaining authority referred the matter
to the Advisory Board within the stipulated period of time. The Advisory
Board heard the detenue in person and recorded his elaborate statement
and sent a written report to the detaining authority approving the detention
order. Thereafter, the detaining authority confirmed the detention order for
a period of one year w.e.f the date of detention i.e. from 13.10.2021.
Nowhere, in his written representation the detenue has made any complaint
of any violation of Sub-Sections (2) and (3) of Section 3 of the NDPS Act
or Clauses (4) and (5) of Article 22 of the Constitution. The only challenge
of the detenue to the detention order is that the detaining authority did not
consider the material documents to arrive at a subjective satisfaction about
the need of preventive detention of the petitioner (detenue). For this
purpose, this Court in the judgment dated 01.06.2022 in the case of Sri
Sushanta Kumar Banik Vrs. The State of Tripura and others has
elaborately discussed the law. On the issue of subjective satisfaction of the
detaining authority, the decision of the Apex Court in Shalini Soni Vrs.
Union of India: reported in (1980) 4 SCC 544 was referred to in which the
Apex Court held that whenever a decision making function is entrusted to
the subjective satisfaction of a statutory functionary, there is an implicit
obligation of such authority to apply its mind to pertinent and proximate
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 13 of 15
matters only eschewing the irrelevant and the remote. Observation of the
Apex Court in the said judgment is as under:
―7..........Communication of the grounds pre-supposes the
formulation of the grounds and formulation of the
grounds requires and ensures the application of the mind
of the detaining authority to the facts and materials
before it, that is to say to pertinent and proximate matters
in regard to each individual case and excludes the
elements of arbitrariness and automatism (if one may be
permitted to use the word to describe a mechanical
reaction without a conscious application of the mind). It
is an unwritten rule of the law, constitutional and
administrative, that whenever a decision making function
is entrusted to the subjective satisfaction of a statutory
functionary, there is an implicit obligation to apply his
mind to pertinent and proximate matters only eschewing
the irrelevant and the remote. Where there is further an
express statutory obligation to communicate not merely
the decision but the grounds on which the decision is
founded, it is a necessary corollary that the grounds
communicated, that is, the grounds so made known,
should be seen to pertain to pertinent and proximate
matters and should comprise all the constituent facts and
materials that went in to make up the mind of the
statutory functionary and not merely the inferential
conclusions. Now, the decision to detain a person depends
on the subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority.
The Constitution and the statute cast a duty on the
detaining authority to communicate the grounds of
detention to the detenue. From what we have said above,
it follows that the grounds communicated to the detenu
must reveal the whole of the factual material considered
by the detaining authority and not merely the inferences
of fact arrived at by the detaining authority. The matter
may also be looked at from the point of view of the second
fact of Art. 22(5). An opportunity to make a
representation against the order of detention necessarily
implies that the detenue is informed of all that has been
taken into account against him in arriving at the decision
to detain him. It means that the detenue is to be informed
not merely, as we said, of the inferences of fact but of all
the factual material which have led to the inferences of
fact. If the detenue is not to be so informed the
opportunity so solemnly guaranteed by the Constitution
becomes reduced to an exercise in futility. Whatever angle
from which the question is looked at, it is clear that
"grounds" in Art. 22(5) do not mean mere factual
inferences but mean factual inferences plus factual
material which led to such factual inferences. The
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 14 of 15
'grounds' must be self- sufficient and self explanatory. In
our view copies of documents to which reference is made
in the `grounds' must be supplied to the detenue as part of
the `grounds'.‖
[Emphasis added]
[20]
Among the 03 cases pending against the detenue, the last case
was registered in 2020 which cannot be said to be an irrelevant and remote
mater for the purpose of arriving at a subjective satisfaction about the need
of the preventive detention of the petitioner.
[21]
It is apparent from the record that repeated involvement of the
petitioner in NDPS cases and the police report available against him made
the detaining authority apprehensive that unless prevented by a detention
order he would further engage himself in illicit trafficking in narcotic
drugs and psychotropic substances. The detaining authority therefore,
issued the impugned order of preventive detention. All the documents on
the basis of which the detaining authority formed its opinion were supplied
to the detenue. In his written representation detenue did not make any
complaint that he could not submit an effective representation for want of
any particular document. There is no complaint of any violation of the
safeguards provided under Clauses (4) and (5) of Article 22 of the
Constitution.
[22]
In these circumstances, we are of the considered view that
there is no ground to interfere with the impugned detention order.
Resultantly, the petition stands dismissed.
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
Page - 15 of 15
[23]
In terms of the above, the matter is disposed of. Department’s
file and the case diary be returned to the learned Public Prosecutor
forthwith.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY), J
Dipankar
W.P(Crl.) No.11 of 2021
(INDRAJIT MAHANTY), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review