Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.659 of 2021
Shri Kamalesh Datta,
son of late Kanu Bhusan Datta,
resident of Village-Madhya Nayapara,
P.O. & P.S. Dharmanagar, District – North Tripura,
vendor of Dharmanagar F.L. Shop No.3
----Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
represented by the Commissioner & Secretary
to the Finance Department (Excise & Taxation),
Government of Tripura, having his office at New
Secretariat Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala,
P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District – West Tripura
2. The Commissioner & Secretary
to the Finance Department, Government of Tripura,
having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar,
District – West Tripura
3. The Commissioner & Secretary
to the Revenue Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at
New Secretariat Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar,
District – West Tripura
4. The Commissioner of Excise,
Government of Tripura, Office of the
Commissioner of Excise, having his Office
at P.N. Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala,
P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District – West Tripura
5. The Collector of Excise,
Government of Tripura,
Office of the Collector of Excise,
having his Office at North Tripura
District, Dharmanagar
---- Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s):
Date of hearing
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Majumder, Adv.
Mr. K. De, Addl. G.A.
:
05.04.2022
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order :
27.05.2022
Whether fit for
reporting
NO
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Judgment & Order
By means of this writ petition, the petitioner has urged this court for
commanding the respondents to exempt and refund the licence fee at
Rs.13,61,130/- paid by the petitioner vis-a-vis the closure period of his foreign
liquor shop. That apart, the petitioner has urged to direct the respondents to
compensate him at 10% of the said licence fee i.e. Rs.1,36,113/- for the loss he
has suffered during the compulsory Lockdown. Thus, the petitioner has urged this
court for directing the respondents to pay him Rs.14,97,243/- in total or
alternatively, to adjust the said amount with the licence fee for the proportionate
period.
2.
The facts are mostly admitted. The petitioner holds the licence
bearing No.01/2017 dated 07.04.2017 to run the foreign liquor shop namely
Dharmanagar F.L. Shop No.3 at Dharmanagar for sale of foreign liquor by retail
vend for the period stretching from 01.04.2017 to 31.03.2020. During the entire
licence period, the petitioner was obliged to pay a sum of Rs.91,25,525/- as the
licence fee and the petitioner had been paying the said licence fee quarterly part or
as directed by the respondents.
3.
By the letter dated 20.03.2020 [Annexure-2 to the writ petition]
issued by the Collector of Excise, North Tripura, the said licence has been extended
for another three years till 31.03.2023, subject to submission of the Security
Deposit amounting to Rs.33,17,515/- and further licence fee amounting to
Rs.13,82,298/- on each quarter. The petitioner has got the said licence extended
with the conditions as laid by the respondents. Now for a new licence, the
petitioner has to pay a sum of Rs.13,82,298/- on each quarter.
4.
The grievance of the petitioner is that from 25.03.2020 to
14.04.2020 there had been a nationwide lockdown as would be evident from the
order dated 24.03.2020 [Annexure-5 to the writ petition]. Thereafter, the said
lockdown was extended till 03.05.2020 to 04.05.2020. Some relaxation was given
vis-à-vis the opening of the liquor shops. During the period from 11.06.2020 to
16.07.2020, the petitioner and the other vendors of the foreign liquor shops were
permitted to get their shops open for a limited period from 1 a.m. to 2 p.m. Again,
the total lockdown was imposed from 27.07.2020 to 03.08.2020 and the foreign
liquor shops of the petitioner was totally closed during the said period. It has been
stated that during the period from 26.05.2021 to 06.06.2021, again the foreign
liquor shops were closed in terms of the order dated 25.05.2021 [Annexure-10 to
the writ petition]. The said closure/lockdown was extended from 06.06.2021 to
10.06.2021 vide the order dated 04.06.2021 [Annexure-11 to the writ petition].
Thereafter, the weekend curfew and closure of foreign liquor shops for the period
stretching from 10 p.m. of 10.07.2021 to 6 a.m. of 12.07.2021 was issued. By the
order dated 16.07.2021 [Annexure-13 to the writ petition], the foreign liquor shops
including that of the petitioner was completely closed w.e.f.17.07.2021 to
18.07.2021. The petitioner was restrained from opening his liquor shops which was
under valid licence and, as a result, he could not run his shop but he had to pay the
licence fee. The petitioner has provided a table to show the period of closure and
the proportionate licence fee. For purpose of reference, the said table is reproduced
hereunder:
Sl.
No.
1.
2.
3.
Closure period
No. of days
25.03.2020 to 31.03.2020
01.04.2020 to 03.05.2020
11.06.2020 to 16.07.2020
4.
5.
6.
7.
27.07.2020 to 03.08.2020
26.05.2021 to 10.06.2021
11.07.2021
17.07.2021 to 18.07.2021
36(9 hours
close)
8 days
Financial
year
2019-2020
2020-2021
2020-2021
Amount of
licence fee paid
Rs.58,337/Rs.4,99,900/Rs.4,09,032/-
2020-2021
2021-2022
2021-2022
2021-2022
Total :
Rs.1,21,188/Rs.2,27,227/Rs.15,149/Rs.30,297/Rs.13,61,130/-
Thus, the petitioner had to pay the licence fee at Rs.13,61,130/- without
being allowed to open his shop. Faced with such disadvantage, the petitioner made
several representations on 26.08.2020, 24.02.2021, 06.03.2021, 22.06.2021 &
29.06.2021 [Annexure-14 to the writ petition collectively].
5.
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner
has contended that Corona Virus Pandemic is assumed to be an instance of force
majeure, within the meaning of Section 55 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. Even
the reference has been made by Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel to Sections 51 and
54 of the said Act. He has argued that if the Sections 51, 54 and 55 of the Indian
Contract Act are read together, it would lead to an irresistible inference that when
the parties to the contract owe reciprocal obligations, and one party fails to perform
its obligation, such defaulting party cannot claim any benefit. The respondents in
the present case have failed to perform their obligations that are saddled under the
contract and now they cannot turn back or seek to recover the licence fee from the
petitioner.
6.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has also referred to the principle of
quid pro quo as the licence fee is determined on the basis of the service as would
be provided by the respondents. Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has contended
that a fee is a charge for special services rendered to individuals by some
Government agency, and such a charge has an element in it of quid pro quo.
Therefore, without allowing the petitioner to run the foreign liquor shop [under the
valid licence] is nothing but severing the benefit.
7.
At this juncture, Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has referred to
Section 24 of the Tripura Excise Act, 1987 which lays down that the District
Magistrate or a Sub-Divisional Magistrate, may by notice to the licencee require that
any shop in which any intoxicant is sold, shall be closed at such time or for such
period as the Magistrate may think necessary for the preservation of the public
peace and maintenance of law and order. Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has
contended that the said closure has adversely affected the petitioner in the similar
manner as would have occurred under the order under Section 24 of the Tripura
Excise Act, 1987. But in the instant case, no formal order under Section 24 of the
Tripura Excise Act, 1987 had been issued.
8.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has further submitted that Rule 193
of the Tripura Excise Rules, 1990 provides that when any shop for the vend of any
intoxicant is closed, under Section 24 of the Act, for the preservation of the public
peace or under Rule 173 on account of the march of troops, compensation for such
closure may be paid in cash to the licencee, in the mode as stated below:
(1) The compensation will be paid by the Collector with the
previous sanction of the Excise Commissioner.
(2) No compensation shall be paid when a shop remains
closed for less than six hours. Closure for six hours or more
shall be held to be closure for the whole day.
By reading the provisions of Section 24 of the Tripura Excise Act and Rule
193 of the Tripura Excise Rules together, Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has
sought to build up an argument that the petitioner is entitled to exemption from
payment of the licence fee and the compensation for the damage that the
petitioner has suffered during the said period as shown in the table above.
9.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has placed reliance on a series of
precedents. In P.K. Kalasami Nadar versus K. Ponnuswami Mudaliar and
Others reported in AIR 1962 Madras 44, the apex court has observed as
follows:
“It is often the case, however, that the same wrong is both a breach of
contract and a tort. There are many instances in which a person
voluntarily binds himself by a contract to perform some duty which
already lies upon him independently of any contract. The breach of such
a contract is also a tort, in as much as liability would equally have
existed in such a case had there been no contract at all; for example,
when a passenger whilst travelling with a ticket is injured owing to the
railway company's negligence, the company is guilty of a wrong which is
both a breach of contract and a tort. Similarly, a bailee who wrongfully
refuses to restore the property lent to him is liable both in contract and
in tort; in contract because no one has a right to detain another's
property without some justification. Such concurrent liability in tort and
contract is found in the case of bailees, carriers and probably other
persons recognized at common law as exercising a common calling and
thereby owing duties to the public such as smiths and innkeepers. It
seems that a doctor or surgeon is in this position, but not an architect, or
stock broker, or solicitor, or a window cleaner. In other cases it depends
on the existence of a duty in tort independent of the contract.”
The said observation leads to an inference that the liability can be inferred
based on the nature of relation that exists between two parties which involves the
performance of certain duties by the vendor and the payment of reward to him by
the other, the law will imply or the jury [in the reported case] may infer a promise
by each party to what is to be done by him.
10.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has made a robust statement by
referring the said decision of the Madras High Court to contend that the failure of
keeping the shops open during the lockdown cannot be solely borne by the
licencee. An act of God will be an extraordinary occurrence due to natural causes,
which is not the result of any human intervention which could not be avoided by
any amount of foresight and care e.g. a fire caused by lightening. But an accidental
fire as in the present case, though it might not have resulted from any act of or
omission of the appellant, could not be said to be an act of God. [see para-3 of
P.K. Kalasami Nadar versus K. Ponnuswami Mudaliar and Others].
11.
Reference has been made to M/s Army Welfare Housing
Organisation versus Sumangal Services (P) Ltd. reported in (2004) 9 SCC
619. In order to buttress the arguments reference has been made to Section 56 of
the Indian Contract Act which deals with the agreement to do impossible act Mr.
Deb, learned senior counsel has made reference to Sections 53, 54 and even
Section 55 of the Indian Contract Act but in the present circumstances, this court
does not find that those provisions can be applied in the case of licencee, for retail
vend of foreign liquor. In M/s Army Welfare Housing Organisation versus
Sumangal Services (P) Ltd.(supra), the apex court has observed that:
“Risk and cost clause cannot be invoked on failure of the party to
respond to its self-imposed obligation. Damages are to be paid for willful
breach of the terms or conditions of the contract. Such a breach must be
in relation to an express agreement entered into by and between the
parties.”
Therefore, hardly this decision can support the extreme plea as raised by
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel.
12.
However, Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has also referred a
decision of the apex court in State of U.P. and Others versus Jagjeet Singh
and Others reported in (2003) 8 SCC 270 where the apex court had occasion to
observe that there is no blanket prohibition against any claim of damages or
remission on account of closure. In Jagjeet Singh(supra) it has been observed
that there would be no remission in case of curtailment of time of a shop, but the
position in respect of total closure of a shop in place of mere curtailment of time
has been left open for the respondents. It has been observed in Jagjeet Singh
(supra) thus:
“We may say there is no provision either way and the prohibition is only
in respect of partial closure in a day. Similarly, the first part of the subrule (ii) talks about the auction of shops in group. Out of the group of the
shops if some shops are closed or a shop is closed there would be no
claim for any remission. It leaves a situation where all shops of a group
are closed. Therefore, the language used for negating the claim in
respect of partial closure in relation to time or a group of shops leads to
the conclusion that cases of total closure would not be covered by Rule
34. We may hasten to say that no such inference can be drawn that in
case of total closure of a group of shops or for whole time in a day, would
necessarily entitle a licencee for remission or damages. All that can be
said is that it is not impermissible. It may or may not be allowed, is liable
to be decided on its own merits. But it would not be possible to say that
no such application for remission/damages would be maintainable as in
the case of curtailment of time of a shop or closure of one or some of the
shops in a group of shops. The interpretation as made by the Bench in
the case of Harpal Singh cannot be faulted with.”
13.
On remission, another decision of the apex court has been relied by
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel to nourish the case of the petitioner for
compensation for total closure or for curtailment of time. In Secretary,
Department of Excise & Commercial Taxes and Others versus Sun Bright
Marketing (P) Ltd., Chhattisgarh and Another reported in (2004) 3 SCC 185
it has been observed that the General Licence Conditions and the conditions
contained in the Sale Memo postulate that, in the event, the licencee is required to
close a shop in terms of an order passed by the statutory authority or otherwise, he
would be entitled to claim remission in licence fee unless the same is expressly
barred. Section 24 of the Act is in two parts. Sub-section (1) of Section 24
empowers the District Magistrate to direct closure of any shop in which any
intoxicant is sold for such time or for such period as he may think necessary for
preservation of the public peace. Sub-section (2) of Section 24, however, deals with
a specific situation in terms whereof in the event of apprehension or occurrence of
a riot or unlawful assembly in the vicinity of a shop, a Magistrate of any class may
require such shops to keep closed for such period as he may think necessary. In the
event, however, no magistrate is available, the proviso appended thereto mandates
that the licencee shall close the said shop without any order.
In the said Act, there is a clause that if during the period of contract, the
contractor suffers from any loss or damage whatsoever as a result of natural
calamity, celestial problem or political demonstrations, public demonstration,
movements, law and order problems, the contractor shall not be entitled to any
compensation whatsoever.
According to the apex Court, the said provision does not put an embargo on
remission in payment of licence fees in the event the closure of shop due to any
reason authorized by law. [see para-25 of the Secretary, Department of Excise
& Commercial Taxes and Others versus Sun Bright Marketing (P) Ltd.,
Chhattisgarh and Another].
14.
As referred by the petitioner in Bharat Petroleum Corporation
Ltd. versus Maddula Ratnavalli and Others reported in (2007) 6 SCC 81 the
apex court while dwelling on reasonable action has observed that reasonableness
and non-arbitrariness are the hallmarks of an action by the State. This is very
unequivocal that the action against the appellant does not satisfy the test of
fairness or reasonableness. It being wholly arbitrary, cannot be sustained.
In this case, the decision of curtailment in the hour or the closure during
the lockdown has not been levelled as unreasonable or arbitrary. Therefore, this
court rephrases the said decision by holding that it may be very relevant to judge a
state in action in their case. But in the case in hand its ratio is far remote.
15.
Finally, Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has relied on a recent
decision of the apex court in South East Asia Marine Engineering and
Constructions Limited versus Oil India Limited reported in (2020) 5 SCC
164. But the context of the said case is entirely different. However, some
propositions have been sought to be drawn for nourishment of the contention as
raised in this petition. It is again in relation to Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act.
The apex court while examining the various clauses of the contract has found that
Clause 23 is akin to a force majeure clause. We need to understand the utility and
implications of a force majeure clause. Under Indian contract law, the
consequences of a force majeure event are provided for under Section 56 of the
Contract Act, which states that on the occurrence of an event which renders the
performance impossible, the contract becomes void.
This observation emanates from interpretation of Section 56 of the Indian
Contract Act. For purpose of applying Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act, the
apex court has unequivocally laid down that it can only be done in the event for
such occurrence which renders the performance impossible. The temporary
suspension is not imposed for the period of contract. Therefore, the said
proposition of law has no relevance for our present purpose. Even though, Mr. Deb,
learned senior counsel has strenuously argued that Corona Virus is a widespread
pandemic and assumed to be an instance of force majeure.
16.
Mr. K. De, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the respondents has
quite categorically stated that the petitioner cannot get any compensation inasmuch
as the lockdown was imposed by the Disaster Management Authority and no order
was issued by the District Collector purely in terms of Section 24 of the Tripura
Excise Act. In the response filed by the respondents, it has been stated that
Collector of Excise, North Tripura District had taken necessary steps time to time for
reopening of the foreign liquor shops under North Tripura District. It has been
categorically stated that in view of the prohibitory orders issued under Section 144
of the Cr.P.C. to check the spread of COVID-19 pandemic, there had been
temporary closure or curtailment of time during the period from 16.03.2020 to
16.07.2021, but no order was issued by the District Magistrate and Collector for
closure of the foreign liquor shops. The petitioner was given extension of the
licence so that they can continue their business more robustly in the succeeding
business period, but not on adjustment of licence fees.
17.
Mr. De, learned Addl. G.A. has submitted that it needs to be
mentioned that no order has been issued by the Collector of Excise during the said
period under Sub-Section (1) of Section 24 of the Tripura Excise Act, 1987 with
regard to the closure of the foreign liquor shops under North Tripura District.
Therefore, the matter for granting compensation during such closure or curtailment
of time cannot be brought under purview of Rule 193 of the Tripura Excise Rules,
1990. The said rule will apply only when the concerned Authority will exercise
power under Section 24 of the Tripura Excise Act, 1987. If no power is exercised
under Section 24 of the Tripura Excise Act, 1987, then no claim can be raised under
Rule 193 of the Tripura Excise Rules, 1990.
18.
In support of his contention, Mr. De, learned Addl. G.A. has referred
a decision of this court in Sri Abhishek Dahiya versus State of Tripura and
Others reported in (2021) 2 TLR 498 where it has been culled out that the
period during which the liquor shops had to remain closed on account of orders
passed by the District Collectors under Section 24 of the Tripura Excise Act,
compensation as envisaged under Rule 193 of the rules is payable. However, if the
shops had remained closed for any periods beyond the period covered by the
orders under Section 24 of the Tripura Excise Act, in absence of any statutory
provision, such compensation cannot be claimed. Even if the order is passed by the
Collector under Section 24 of the Act merely recorded the restrictions imposed by
the State Disaster Management Committee under the Disaster Management Act
and, therefore, no compensation would be payable for the period covered under
the said order. For better reference, the following passages from Sri Abhishek
Dahiya(supra) is reproduced hereunder:
“17. Our conclusion, therefore, is that the period during which the liquor
shops of the petitioners had to remain shut on account of orders passed
by the District Collectors under Section 24 of the Tripura Excise Act,
compensation as envisaged under Rule 193 of the rules is payable.
However, if the shops had remained closed for any periods beyond the
periods covered by the orders under Section 24 of the Tripura Excise Act,
in absence of any statutory provision, such compensation cannot be
claimed. We may clarify that the order dated 4.7.2020 passed by the
Collector Shipaijala was not under Section 24 of the Act but merely
recorded the restrictions imposed by the State Disaster Management
Committee under the Disaster Management Act and therefore, no
compensation would be payable for the period covered under the said
order.
18. The petitioners have produced orders passed by the District
Collector, Sepahijala under Section 24 of the Tripura Excise Act. It is not
clear whether the District Collector, West Tripura had passed similar
orders. However, our conclusion will remain the same namely that for
the period during which the District Collector be it of Sepahijala or West
Tripura, had ordered under Section 24 of the Tripura Excise Act that the
liquor shops within the district shall remain closed, the petitioners would
be entitled to compensation as specified in Rule 193 of the rules.”
19.
On appreciation of the submissions as advanced by the learned
counsel for the parties, this court is of the view that the petitioner will not be
entitled to any compensation for the closure or curtailment of time for the period
from 16.03.2021 to 16.07.2021. Even the remission cannot be directly granted
inasmuch as from the scrutiny of the orders it appears that the closure or the
lockdown was the outcome of the orders passed by the competent authority under
Section 10(2)(I) of the Disaster Management Act, 2005. No single order has been
produced by the petitioner to show that the order was passed under Section 24 of
the Act to entitle him to get the compensation or remission in the usual course. In
this regard, the provisions of Rule 193 of Tripura Excise Rules, 1990 has been taken
into consideration and the said Rules is structured on closure of shops for vendor of
any intoxicant by the order passed under Section 24 of the Tripura Excise Act,
1987.
Hence, the reliefs sought in this writ petition are bereft of merit and
hence, the writ petition stands dismissed, subject to following observation.
However, the petitioner may represent to the appropriate authority
[The Collector of Excise, North Tripura] for taking special consideration so far the
remission of the licence fee, proportionate to the closure or curtailment of time, as
noted above, is concerned. The competent authority may consider, even going
beyond the ambit of Rule 193 of the Tripura Excise Rules, 1990.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review