Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
TRHC010019232025
2026:THC:642
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.660 of 2025
Dr. Reema Saha, Age 45 years,
W/O-Sri Uttam Kumar Debnath,
R/O- Pragati Road, Krishnanagar,
P.O.- Agartala, P.S.- West Agartala,
Agartala, District- West Tripura,
PIN-799001.
…. Petitioner(s).
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Secretary,
Department of Industries & Commerce,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN-799010.
2. The Chairman (Principal Secretary),
Dept. of Forests,
Govt. of Tripura, NRMST, Aranya Bhavan,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN-799006.
3. The Director,
Directorate of Industries & Commerce,
Shilpa Udyog Bhavan, Khejurbagan,
Agartala, Tripura, PIN-799006.
4. The Manager,
Directorate of Industries & Commerce,
Shilpa Udyog Bhavan, Khejurbagan, Agartala,
Tripura, PIN-799006.
5. The CEO & P.D.,
IGDC, CRFLAT Project,
PMA, Hatipara, Gandhigram,
West Tripura, PIN-799012.
6. The Member Secretary,
Society for Entrepreneurship Development (SOFED),
ITI Road, Indranagar, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN-799006.
7. Shri S. Prabhu,
CEO & PD, IGDC, CRFLAT Project,
PMA, Hatipara, Gandhigram,
West Tripura, PIN-799012.
8. Dr. Biplab Brahma (STO-MIS),
Posted in the O/o of the CEO & P.D,
IHDC, CRFLAT Project,
PMA, Hatipara, Gandhipara,
West Tripura, PIN-799012.
…….Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Adv.
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of Hearing
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
11.05.2026
:
18.05.2026
:
NO
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. P. Roy Barman
assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr. K. Nath appearing on behalf of
the petitioner and also heard Learned Addl. G.A., Mr. D. Sarma
appearing on behalf of the State-respondents.
02.
The petitioner has filed this writ petition seeking the
following relief/reliefs:(i)
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like nature
shall not be issued whereby directing the Respondents to
re-appoint/ re-engage the Petitioner in the post of Project
Implementing Officer (PIO) for the Indo German
Development Corporation Project (CREFLAT) under the
Respondents, during the life of Indo German Development
Corporation Project (CREFLAT).
(ii)
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like nature
shall not be issued whereby directing the Respondents to
renew/extend the tenure of the appointment of the
Petitioner w.e.f 25.09.2025 to till the regularization of her
service or during the life of Indo German Development
Corporation Project (CREFLAT), whichever is earlier, as
the Petitioner‟s engagement is coterminous with the
Scheme.
(iii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like nature
shall not be issued whereby quashing & cancelling the
Recruitment
Notification
No.05/2025-26,
dated
05.11.2025, issued by the Member Secretary, SoFED, so
far the post of Project Implementing Officer (PIO) is
concerned.
(iv) Make the rules absolute.
(v)
Call for records.
(vi)
Pass any further Order/Orders as this Hon‟ble High
Court considered fit and proper.
03.
At the time of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. P.
Roy Barman appearing for the petitioner first of all drawn the
attention of the Court [Annexure-1] i.e. the certificate issued by
Director, NTFP Centre of Excellence, Tripura JICA Project and
submitted considering the performance of the petitioner the
Director, JICA had issued said certificate to her.
04.
Thereafter, Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
petitioner drawn the attention of the Court referring Annexure-2
and
submitted
that
by
the
said
appointment
letter
dated
10.02.2021 she was engaged as project Implementing Officer for
the Indo-German Development Cooperation Project (CREFLAT) on
contract basis for a period of 11 (eleven) months and accordingly
the CEO & PD, IGDC CREFLAT Project issued another certificate of
accreditation to her [Annexure-3].
05.
was
After that, the period of engagement of the petitioner
further
extended
w.e.f.
04.12.2024
by
the
authority
[Annexure-4].
06.
It was also submitted by Learned Senior Counsel that
the authority of IGDC CREFLAT Project, PMA by Office Order dated
14.05.2025 allocated the job of the petitioner to the respective
department [Annexure-5].
07.
By
another
Office
Order
dated
14.05.2025
the
petitioner was assigned the job to monitor the works of 5 (five)
Sub-Division. But by Office Order dated 28.08.2025 the job of the
petitioner assigned to Dr. Biplab Brahma (STO-MIS) [Annexure7].
08.
Thereafter, most arbitrarily on 25.09.2025 the SOFED
extended the period of service of the petitioner w.e.f. 08.09.2025
to 25.09.2025 [Annexure-8].
09.
Learned Senior Counsel also drawn the attention of the
Court that as per Project Operation Manual in Column No.2.7.2, it
was observed that the following guideline has been prescribed:“2.7.2. Terms and Conditions of contractual staff or the
staff deployed through outsourcing
****
Continuity of Project staff until completion of
project period would be a very crucial
requirement for successful implementation of
the project, especially for critical positions like
Project Implementation Officer and certain
Technical
Officers/Technical
Assistants.
Provisions of certain stage-wise incentives
would be made to ensure their retention
throughout the entire project period.
Long unauthorized absence during the contract
period or indulgence in serious misconduct
would render a contractual employee liable for
disengagement
by
the
CREFLAT
project
authority, following principles of natural justice.
The expression serious misconduct would mean
improper or unprofessional act considered
detrimental for the functioning. Whether an act
is misconduct or not would be decided by the
Appointing Authority whose decision will be final
and binding.
In the case of Outsourced employees, if the
average cumulative performance score of an
outsourced employee falls below Five (5), out of
Ten (10), for two consecutive years, the service
provider may be asked to provide his/her
replacement.”
10.
Thus,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
appearing
for
the
petitioner also drawn the attention of the Court that in discharging
duties the petitioner suffered some harassment and for that she
submitted representation to the authority of the Department
[Annexure-10].
11.
But surprisingly the SOFED by recruitment Notification
No.05/2025-26 dated 05.11.2025 [Annexure-11] has give an
advertisement for filling of the post of Project Implementing
Officer (PIO) which compelled the petitioner to file this writ
petition.
12.
In this regard reliance was placed by Learned Senior
Counsel a judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Mohd.
Abdul Kadir and Another Vs. Director General of Police,
Assam reported in (2009) 6 SCC 611, wherein in Para Nos.5, 6,
10 and 17, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:“5. The Inspector General of Police (Border), Assam
issued a Circular dated 17-3-1995 laying down the
following procedure for appointment/continuation of exservicemen as ad hoc border staff:
(i) All appointments shall be for a contract period
of one year.
(ii) Termination notice should be issued to every
ad hoc employee at least 45 days before the date
of expiry of one year from the date of appointment.
(iii) The ad hoc employee, on receiving information
regarding termination from service, shall, if he
desires to continue, send an application seeking
fresh appointment for a further term of one year.
The application should reach the Office of IGB (B),
Assam at least 30 days before the date of expiry of
one year.
(iv) The DIGP (Range)/Superintendent of Police
concerned shall send a performance report and
medical certificate in respect of each ad hoc
employee to whom such termination notice has
been issued at least 30 days before the date of
such termination while forwarding the applications
for fresh appointment.
(v) The applications for fresh appointment shall be
considered with reference to the respective
performance report and medical certificate, and
those found fit and suitable will be reappointed at
least 20 days before the date of expiry of the
contract period of one year.
(vi) Such fresh appointment letters shall be issued
by the Superintendent of Police (Border), Assam
and the ad hoc employees cleared for fresh
appointment shall sign an agreement and submit
their joining report.
(vii) If application for fresh appointment is not
received in due time, it will be taken that the ad
hoc employee has not sought fresh appointment
and he will not be considered for fresh
appointment.
6. Aggrieved by the process of termination and
reappointment introduced by the said Circular dated 17-31995 and the consequences thereof, Appellants 1 and 2
filed Civil Rules Nos. 2065 and 1698 of 1995 in the Gauhati
High Court.
10. A learned Single Judge of the High Court allowed the
writ petition by order dated 29-2-1996. He held that the
appellants should be allowed to continue as long as the
Scheme was continued by the Government of India and
they shall be entitled to all service benefits as regular
employees so long as the Scheme continued. He also held
that the appellants shall be entitled to the benefits
extended under the State Government Scheme for
enrolment of ex-service personnel in Assam Special Peace
Keeping Force, vide Official Memorandum dated 14-61984. Feeling aggrieved the Director General of Police,
Inspector General of Police (Border) and Superintendent
of Police (Border), Assam, filed a writ appeal (WA No. 154
of 1996).
17. When the ad hoc appointment is under a scheme and is
in accordance with the selection process prescribed by the
scheme, there is no reason why those appointed under the
scheme should not be continued as long as the scheme
continues. Ad hoc appointments under schemes are
normally coterminous with the scheme (subject of course
to earlier termination either on medical or disciplinary
grounds, or for unsatisfactory service or on attainment of
normal age of retirement). Irrespective of the length of
their ad hoc service or the scheme, they will not be
entitled to regularisation nor to the security of tenure and
service benefits available to the regular employees. In this
background, particularly in view of the continuing Scheme,
the ex-serviceman employed after undergoing the
selection process, need not be subjected to the agony,
anxiety, humiliation and vicissitudes of annual termination
and re-engagement, merely because their appointment is
termed as ad hoc appointments.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel drawn the
attention of the Court in view of the observation of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the aforenoted case, there was no scope to
discontinue the service of the petitioner.
Reference was placed upon another judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Hargurpratap Singh Vs.
State of Punjab and Others reported in (2007) 13 SCC 292,
wherein in Para No.3, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:-
“3. We have carefully looked into the judgment of the
High Court and other pleadings that have been put forth
before this Court. It is clear that though the appellants
may not be entitled to regular appointment as such it
cannot be said that they will not be entitled to the
minimum of the pay scale nor that they should not be
continued till regular incumbents are appointed. The
course adopted by the High Court is to displace one ad hoc
arrangement by another ad hoc arrangement which is not
at all appropriate for these persons who have gained
experience which will be more beneficial and useful to the
colleges concerned rather than to appoint persons afresh
on ad hoc basis. Therefore, we set aside the orders made
by the High Court to the extent the same deny the claim of
the appellants of minimum pay scale and continuation in
service till regular incumbents are appointed. We direct
that they shall be continued in service till regular
appointments are made on minimum of the pay scale. The
appeals shall stand allowed in part accordingly.”
Further, reference was placed upon another judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in U.P. Junior High
School Council Instructor Welfare Association v. State of
Uttar Pradesh & Ors. along with other connected matters
reported in 2026 SCC OnLine SC 147, wherein in para Nos.39
and 44, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“39. The part time contractual instructors/teachers
appointed in Primary Schools of the State of Uttar
Pradesh, in the first place, ceases to be contractual
teachers as soon as the contract period of eleven months
initially entered into or the renewed period, if any, comes
to an end. It is noticed from the counter affidavit that the
original contracts were last renewed in 2017-18 and in
these renewed contracts the honorarium agreed upon is
Rs. 8,470/- per month. There is no renewed contract
thereafter. The contract having once expired and not
having been renewed specifically and reduced to writing
after 2017-18 would not actually be a contract so as to
recognize the instructors/teachers so appointed to be
contract teachers on the expiry of the above contract.
They would rather be treated as teachers simpliciter after
2017-18.
44. The appointment of these instructors/teachers, even if
held to be contractual, part time or even temporary in
nature, there is hardly any scope to replace these
instructors/teachers by a fresh contractual, part time or
temporary instructor/teacher inasmuch as these are the
persons who are not only qualified but have acquired some
experience of working and are definitely more suitable
than the freshers. It goes without saying that an ad hoc
employee cannot be replaced by another ad hoc employee,
a temporary employee cannot be replaced by another
temporary employee, a contractual employee cannot be
replaced by another contractual employee and the guest
employee by another guest employee. The incumbents
working as aforesaid are entitled to preference in
comparison to the new candidates, unless of course there
is anything against them. In fact, practice of engaging
employees on ad hoc, temporary, part time, contractual or
as guest ought to be avoided and the Government should
strictly
adhere
to
proper
procedure
for
regular
recruitment.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel submitted
that in this case inspite of having requisite qualification the
respondents illegally discontinued the job of the petitioner which
compelled the petitioner to approach this Court. So, Learned
Senior Counsel urged before the Court to issue appropriate rule in
this regard and to allow the writ petition.
13.
The respondents have filed separate counter-affidavits
denying the assertions of the petitioner. However, the respondent
Nos.5, 7 and 8 in their counter-affidavit in Para Nos. 13, 14, 15,
17 and 20 observed as under:“13. That, in regard to the statements made in
paragraph 6 of the writ petition it is stated that, by
appointment letter dated 10.02.2021 issued by SoFED
the Petitioner was engaged purely as an outsourced
contractual personnel for 11 months for deployment in
the IGDC CREFLAT Project. The appointment was
neither made by the Respondent no.5 nor did it create
any employer-employee relationship with the CEO &
PD, IGDC. Her contractual engagement was entirely
governed by the terms issued by the outsourcing
agency.
14. That, in regards to the statement made in
paragraph 7 of the writ Petition it is stated that the
Petitioner‟s joining on 15.02.2021 is a matter of
record. However, it is denied that her service has been
continuous without issues. In 2022, based on
complaints received from members of the Project
Management
Agency
regarding
the
Petitioner‟s
misbehavior, SoFED granted only a three-month
extension beyond the initial 11-month tenure.
Subsequently, upon the Petitioner‟s own request, the
then CEO & Project Director of IGDC CREFLAT
recommended to SoFED for a further one-year
extension. The Petitioner continued only as an
outsourced contractual personnel, with no employeremployee relationship with the IGDC CREFLAT project.
15. That, in regards to the statement made in
paragraph 8 of the writ Petition it is stated that the
certificate dated 16.08.2022 does not create any legal
or contractual right in favour of the Petitioner. It is
well
settled
that
satisfactory
performance
or
appreciation notes cannot confer entitlement to
continuation or renewal of a contractual engagement.
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in State of Karnataka v.
Uma Devi (2006) 4 SCC 1 and in Punjab State
Warehousing Corporation v. Manmohan Singh (2007) 9
SCC 337 has held that temporary or contractual
employees have no right to extension merely on the
basis of past performance. Similarly, in Grideo Ltd. V.
Sadananda Doloi (2011) 15 SCC 16 the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court reiterated that fixed-term contractual
appointments automatically expire and cannot be
continued on the strength of favourable certificates.
Hence, the certificate relied upon by the Petitioner is
merely a factual acknowledgment and does not create
any enforceable right against the Respondents.
17. That, in regards to the statement made in
paragraph 10 of the writ Petition, it is stated that the
Memorandum dated 04.12.2024 issued by SoFED is a
matter of record. It is submitted that the said
Memorandum pertains solely to the internal extension
of
outsourced
contractual
manpower
by
the
outsourcing agency, and not by the Respondent No.5.
The Petitioner‟s name appearing at Sl. No.29 with
extension from 07.10.2024 to 06.09.2025 reflects only
SoFED‟s administrative decision for continuation of
deployment and does not create any employeremployee relationship or service rights against the CEO
& Project Director of IGDC CREFLAT or the State. All
such extensions remained purely contractual and
subject to SoFED‟s terms and project requirements.
20. That, in regards to the statement made in
paragraph 13 of the writ Petition, it is stated that the
Respondent denies the allegations of the Petitioner
except those which are matters of record. It is
submitted that by Office Order dated 28.08.2025,
issued by the CEO & Project Director, IGDC-CREFLAT
Project, in partial modification of the earlier office
order dated 14.05.2024, the duties of the Petitioner as
Project Implementing Officer (PIO) were re-assigned
to Dr. Biplab Brahma, STO-MIS, with immediate effect.
The Petitioner was accordingly directed to hand over
all related hard files and e-office files to the said
officer.
The Respondent respectfully submits that the CREFLAT
Project is an externally aided development programme
with clearly defined outputs, outcomes, and strict
timelines. The project management authority has the
administrative responsibility to ensure that all
activities are executed effectively and that the project
achieves its mandated results within the approved
project period.
However, it became evident from the Petitioner's
conduct and performance pattern that she was not
discharging her responsibilities with the diligence and
regularity required for a senior position such as PIO.
The Petitioner:
did not submit monthly work reports;
did not regularly visit the field despite being
assigned monitoring duties across multiple subdivisions;
did not produce activity monitoring reports; and
follow up on the regular monthly review meeting
by the CEO & PD with the field staffs.
failed to demonstrate measurable progress or
deliverables against the ToR.
Such persistent non-performance by an officer holding
a key operational position posed a serious risk to the
progress of the project. Therefore, in order to ensure
continuity of work, timely completion of activities, and
achievement of project outputs, the competent
authority took a bonafide administrative decision to
reassign certain duties to another officer-Dr. Biplab
Brahma
(STO-MIS)-who
possesses
equivalent
knowledge, experience, and demonstrated capability in
project implementation.
This administrative action was taken not against the
Petitioner personally, but in the larger interest of the
project, to prevent further delay or stagnation. The
project authority is under obligation to ensure
efficiency and cannot allow critical tasks to remain
unattended due to the negligence or non-performance
of any individual Project Management Agency Member.
Accordingly, the reassignment of duties under the
office order dated 28.08.2025 was a necessary and
justified decision taken in good faith to safeguard the
objectives of the externally aided project.
In view of the above, the Respondent submits that
Annexure-7 does not advance the Petitioner's case,
and the administrative order was issued wholly in
accordance with project requirements and managerial
prudence.”
14.
Learned Addl. G.A., Mr. D. Sarma appearing for the
respondents submitted that the performance of the petitioner was
not at all satisfactory and there were lot of allegations against her
and referring Annexure-R/4 drawn the attention of the Court
that she polluted the environment at the time of discharging her
job.
Learned Addl. G.A. also submitted allegation which has
been duly inquired by the authority but the allegation found to be
baseless and since her job was for a certain period contractual
employment so there was no scope to continue her job and
referring the citations referred by Learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioner, Learned Addl. G.A. submitted that those citations are
not applicable in this case because those were relating to regular
employees and ad-hoc employees and referring those judgments
the petitioner cannot take advantage in this case and urged for
dismissal of this writ petition as she has failed to satisfy the Court
by showing any materials on record for interference.
15.
Heard both the sides.
It is not the case of the petitioner that due to
misconduct or misbehavior her service has been discontinued
rather it was the case of the petitioner that inspite of having
requisite qualification the respondents authority discontinued her
job.
16.
Admittedly, the petitioner was engaged by SOFED and
she was initially engaged for a period of 11 (eleven) months which
was extended on difference interference.
The petitioner relied
upon some accreditation by the superior authority.
17.
However,
by
Memorandum
dated
25.09.2025
her
period was extended w.e.f. 08.09.2025 to 25.09.2025 which she
has challenged in this writ petition although no reason was
assigned. It was further submitted that the respondents authority
proceed for further recruitment by issuing another notification
dated
05.11.2025
[Anenxure-11]
which
also
has
been
challenged in this writ petition. Now, it is to be seen, whether the
petitioner
being
a
contractual
employee
can
claim
for
regularization and whether this Court can direct the respondents
authority to absorb the petitioner.
18.
Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India in a judgment the
Municipal Council represented by The Municipal Council, Rep.
by its Commissioner Nandyal Municipality, Kurnool District,
A.P. Vs. K. Jayaram and Others Etc. Etc. in Special Leave
Petition (Civil) Nos.17711-17713 of 2019, wherein in Para Nos.3,
4, 7, 8, 10,11, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:“3. The appellant had engaged the respondents not
directly, but through a third-party contractor starting
from the year 1994. However, upon the change of
contractors also, they continued to perform their duties
and work for the appellant. They approached the A.P.
Administrative
Tribunal,
Hyderabad
seeking
regularization and for payment of the minimum of the
scale of that post which was given to the regular
employees. The Tribunal ruled against them and they
approached the High Court. The High Court vide the
impugned order has reversed the order of the Tribunal
and has directed the appellant in the terms as
indicated above.
4. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the
High Court has failed to consider the basic issue
involved in the present case, which is that the
respondents were never the direct employees of the
appellant, inasmuch as, there was no such relationship
created by the appellant. The only connection which
the appellant had with the respondents is that the
contractor who had been given the contract of
providing manpower to the appellant had engaged
them and on that basis they were assigned various
works to be performed by the appellant, for which,
payment was made directly to the contractor and the
contractor in turn used to pay to the respondents. It
was submitted that the contract was given with
sufficient safeguards regarding the basic rights of an
employee, inasmuch as, it was stipulated that the
payment should not be below the minimum wages
prescribed by the Government from time to time and
further, that statutory deductions/contributions would
be made by the contractor with regard to such
employees, including the respondents. Thus, it was
contended that since the respondents were faceless
before the appellant, any claim by such persons, i.e.,
the respondents, would only lie against the contractor
but definitely not against the appellant. In support of
her contention, learned counsel referred to and relied
upon a decision of this Court in “Bharat Heavy
Electricals Limited vs. Mahendra Prasad Jakhmola and
others (2019) 13 SCC 82, the relevant being at
paragraphs no. 21, 22 and 24. She also relied upon a
judgment of a Bench of this Court, to which, one of us
(Ahsanuddin Amanullah, J.) was a party, dated
17.09.2025 in Civil Appeal No.4014 of 2025, titled
„Joint Secretary, Central Board of Secondary Education
and Another Vs. Raj Kumar Mishra and Another‟, the
relevant being at paragraphs No.6 & 9.
7. Having considered the matter, we find substance in
the contention of learned counsel for the appellant. The
moot point on which the issue revolves is the nature of
employment/ relationship of the appellant with the
respondents. It is not in dispute that the appellant had
engaged the respondents and other similarly situated
persons through a contractor, which also had changed
periodically. However, at the same time, the
respondents may have continued to work for the
appellant, though through some other contractor.
Further, the respondents may have also continued for
long periods. Thus, at first blush the reasoning may
seem to be attractive that there was discrimination as
they were also performing the duties as was being
performed by other regular employees and were
required to be suitably paid and, at least, the minimum
time scale of the pay attached to the regular post,
however, a deeper probe would reveal that the matter
cannot be dealt with in such a simplistic way. The test
which would actually throw light and would be relevant
in the facts and circumstances of the present case is to
whether the relationship, which is direct between two
parties in whatever manner, can be differentiated with
a relationship which had no direct connection with the
two parties who are contesting, but rather the
relationship is through a third-party which in the
present case is the contractor.
8. From the facts discussed above, it is clear that the
appellant had no direct connection with the actual
persons who were employed by the contractor, i.e., the
respondents. The obligation and responsibility of the
appellant was to pay to the contractor the amount
which had been contracted and agreed to between the
appellant and the contractor, and the responsibility
then was that of the contractor to ensure payment of
wages and other emoluments as per the terms of the
contract to the persons who were actually sent by the
contractor to the appellant for performing various
types of job.
10. In view of the discussions made hereinabove and
for the reasons aforesaid, the appeals are allowed. The
impugned order dated 23.08.2018 passed by the High
Court is set aside and the orders of the Tribunal stand
restored.
11. Having passed the order, we feel that sometimes
justice is required to be tempered with mercy as
human factors cannot be totally lost sight of. In such
view of the matter, we would require the appellant to
look into whether the jobs which were being done by
the respondents, in the background that they have not
been disengaged or returned to the contractor on the
ground of being unsatisfactory, having uninterrupted
service under the appellant for decades can be
regularized on posts, which prima facie appears to be
perpetual in nature. We make it clear that this
direction is limited for the purposes of the present case
only as it has been passed in the special facts and
circumstances of the present case and shall not be
treated as a precedent in any other case. We expect
the appellant to take a compassionate and sympathetic
view in the matter.”
19.
Similarly, in another judgment in Sunil Kumar Yadav
and Others Vs. State of Jharkhand and Others reported in
2026 SCC OnLine SC 818 wherein in Para Nos. 7, 8.1, 8.2, 13,
17, 19, 20, 21 and 23, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as
under:“7. The Respondents, in unison, resisted the Writ
Prayers. The gist of the case of the Respondents is
stated thus:
• Para-teachers were initially engaged as
education volunteers (Sahyogi Shikshak) on a
fixed honorarium under community school
schemes. These centres were later subsumed
into the centrally sponsored SSA. The parateachers were engaged by local School
Management Committees and the Village
Education Committees, but not by district
authorities. Their honorarium was paid from
SSA funds provided by the Government of India
and the State of Jharkhand in a 60:40 ratio.
Following the Girinath Singh Committee's
recommendation, the State of Jharkhand
amended its recruitment rules in 2009 to
provide a 50 per cent reservation for eligible
para-teachers in direct appointments to regular
teacher posts. Furthermore, para-teachers
have been granted a relaxation of the upper
age limit to 50 years. Under Article 309 of the
Constitution
of
India,
the
framing
of
recruitment policies and the identification of
sources of appointment are strictly matters of
State policy.
• The para-teachers‟ terms of engagement
stated that the appointment was purely
contractual and co-terminus with the SSA. This
engagement does not confer any right to
absorption,
permanency,
or
parity
with
government teachers.
• The Appellants are not being denied the
opportunity to become regular Assistant
Teachers. The 2012 Rules, as amended in 2014,
already provide a specific 50 per cent quota for
the direct recruitment of TET-qualified para
teachers with two or more years' experience.
• The remaining 50 per cent of the quota under
the 2012 Rules is strictly reserved for
unemployed candidates in the open market.
The Appellants, relying on their subsequent
TET qualifications and years of service, are
essentially seeking accommodation within the
50 per cent open market quota. Regularising
them against this quota would consume the
seats reserved for open-market candidates,
thereby violating the statutory balance and the
rights guaranteed under Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution of India.
• The framing of recruitment rules, service
conditions, and the actual hiring of teachers is
entirely the jurisdiction and prerogative of the
State
Government/Union
Territories'
Administrations. The Government of India has
no role in the policy of service conditions of
para-teachers engaged by the States.
• The TET is strictly an eligibility-qualifying
test, not a teacher recruitment test that
guarantees employment.
• Teacher recruitment is the prerogative of the
State Government, and the Government of
India submits that it has no role in it.
• The SSA or similarly designated schemes are
an additional support program for States and
Union Territories, and there are no plans to
close them.
• The schemes support the States in hiring
additional teachers to maintain the mandated
pupil-teacher ratio in the schools.
Simultaneously, the Union of India restricts its
role
to
providing
funds
to
meet
the
proportionate salary requirements of these
para teachers in accordance with the norms of
the Samagra Shiksha Scheme.
• While systemic issues such as vacancies,
poor teacher-student ratios, and single-teacher
schools are real, the legal and administrative
responsibility
to
address
them
and
to
determine the employment fate of the para-
teachers lies squarely with the State of
Jharkhand.
8.1 The High Court held that since the writ
petitioners voluntarily accepted appointments on a
contractual/engagement basis as para teachers under
the SSA scheme, they cannot later claim regularization
as a matter of right. It reasoned that by accepting
contractual
employment,
the
Writ
Petitioners
acquiesced in the terms of their engagement, which did
not, by itself, confer any right of absorption or
regularisation of services as Assistant Teachers.
8.2 Para-teachers were not selected through a
process comparable to the competitive selection
process prescribed for Assistant Teachers, and
therefore, regularisation is not permissible. It is stated
that Village Education/Local School Management
Committees have appointed the para-teachers, not the
District Authorities.
13. The State of Jharkhand asserts that the
employment of para teachers in SSA could, at best, be
a temporary arrangement. The Union of India has
stated that it is for the respective State Governments
to make policy decisions regarding para-teachers‟
services. The policy, now implemented for recruitment
or regularisation, conforms to the constitutional
mandate under Articles 14, 16 and 309 of the
Constitution of India. In furtherance of the policy
decision of the State, a slew of statutory frameworks is
put in place, which includes the following:
• Community Teacher Service Condition Rules, 2008
• Jharkhand Primary School Recruitment Rules, 2012
• Jharkhand Regularisation of Rules, 2015
• Jharkhand Assistant Teacher Service Conditions
Rules, 2021
• Jharkhand Elementary School Sahayak Acharya Cadre
(Appointment, Promotion and Service Conditions)
Rules, 2022
The prayer for the regularisation of para-teachers as
Assistant Teachers or Sahayak Acharyas does not
conform to the constitutional mandate. Any direction
for blanket regularisation would be contrary to this
Court's binding precedents. The subsequent line of
decisions in which this Court issued directions for
regularisation are case-specific and are distinguishable
on one or more key parameters.
17. The High Court, on the mode of appointment of
Appellants, held that the posts occupied by them were
not sanctioned posts under the State of Jharkhand's
establishment but were posts sanctioned under the
SSA scheme, a Centrally Sponsored Scheme funded
jointly by the Union and the State. Accordingly, it is an
admitted case that the Appellants are not appointed
against sanctioned posts; rather, they are contractual
engagees under a scheme. Once an appointee is
appointed under a scheme, there is no question of
considering them to be appointed against sanctioned
posts.
19. The prayer for regularisation is a prayer for
direct absorption from a scheme post of para-teachers
to a State cadre post of Assistant Teacher/Sahayak
Acharya. This would change the character of the
appointment. A scheme post under the SSA is jointly
funded by the Union of India and the State of
Jharkhand, is governed by the SSA guidelines, and
continues until the scheme ceases to exist. A cadre
post under the State of Jharkhand is governed by
Article 309 of the Constitution of India, which creates
public employment, and the State must follow a
constitutionally aligned recruitment process. The direct
leap from one to the other, bypassing the statutory
rules, would create a new mode of recruitment not
sanctioned
by
law.
This
is
prohibited
by
Umadevi(supra) and the line of precedents. In an
attempt to cure the purported irregularity in
appointment, if para-teachers are regularised under
Articles 226 or 142, it would change the source of
appointment altogether.
20. On the issue of equal pay for equal work, we
note that it is not an automatic entitlement, but rather,
the claimant must demonstrate that their duties,
responsibilities,
qualifications,
accountability
and
conditions of service are qualitatively identical to those
of regular employees. Para-teachers, though they
perform similar classroom functions, are not assigned
the full range of responsibilities of an Assistant
Teacher. Further, the UP Junior High School case
(supra) directed pay parity under Rule 20(3) of the
RTE Rules for scheme teachers who are prohibited
from other employment. In the instant case, the
teachers claim pay parity with Assistant Teachers,
which is inherently distinct from a revision of the
honorarium.
21. In the Additional Affidavit filed by the State, it is
brought on record that, in the recruitment of Assistant
Teachers held in the year 2023, 1637 para-teachers
were appointed after successfully participating in the
extant appointment process for Assistant Teachers.
The ratio laid down in the above judgments notes that
the direction for regularisation cannot be contrary to
the statutory rules made by the competent authority.
The para-teachers, assuming that they have been
appointed under the scheme, make a prayer for
regularisation, which takes them into the service of the
State Government. For the said purpose, adherence to
Statutory Rules must be insisted upon. In the extant
case, the State, in furtherance of its policy, has framed
rules and kept in perspective the principles laid down
in Umadevi(supra). We are of the view that the claim
of para-teachers for regularisation does not rest on
sound legal and constitutional principles. But, the
statutory scheme made by the State has recognised a
right of participation and consideration of the claims of
para-teachers, subject to the respective statutory
framework. This Court is conscious of a diabolical
situation in the category of the then para-teachers,
namely those who participated in the selection
process, on being meritorious, are appointed by the
State Government, and the para-teachers who could
not be meritorious would be appointed through a
mandamus for regularisation of their services as
Assistant Teachers. In the circumstances of the case
and having regard to the statutory rules in force, the
prayer for a blanket direction for regularisation as an
Assistant Teacher or Sahayak Acharya would be
contrary to the binding precedent in Umadevi(supra).
The para-teachers, in fact, have a right to participation
and consideration under the extant rules, but do not
have a right to regularisation. The argument of parateachers is that the State has hardly issued any
notifications over the past ten to fifteen years, and the
delay in issuing notifications for available vacancies
would defeat the rights of para teachers. The
comparison of similarities of duties, etc., is to be
subjected to the statutory framework and may not
ripen into an absolute right for regularisation of the
services as prayed for. The above discussion leads to
the next point for consideration, whether the para
teachers are entitled to a timely recruitment and
selection process under the extant procedure.
21.1 Umadevi(supra) does two things: (i) it bars
blanket regularisation by mandamus contrary to
statutory rules; and (ii) in Para 53, it carves a one-time
exception for irregularly appointed employees working
against sanctioned posts for over 10 years, directing
the executive to frame a regularisation scheme. The
directions in the following paragraphs implement the
ratio of Umadevi(supra) by directing the State to
periodically implement its own statutory mechanism.
We do not wish to create a right to regularisation, but
rather to ensure that the State carries out its selfimposed statutory obligation by appointing parateachers to regular posts.
23. The complete answer to the enduring swing of
judicial consideration between irregular and illegal
appointments is resolved by Umadevi(supra). It is
noted that the distinction between illegal and irregular
appointments determines the relief available to a
party. In the case on hand, we find it unnecessary to
determine whether the initial entry of the parateachers into service under the SSA was irregular or
illegal, and we expressly decline to do so for the
following reason: the question has been rendered
academic by the State's own legislative conduct. By
setting aside 50 per cent of all marked vacancies for
Assistant Teachers/Sahayak Acharyas exclusively for
para-teachers under both the 2012 Rules and the 2022
Rules, the State of Jharkhand has itself recognized
para-teachers as a distinct and legitimate class,
possessing a right to participation and consideration
for regular cadre appointments. To ensure security of
employment to the para-teachers and simultaneously
give full effect to the statutory rules made under
Article 309 of the Constitution of India, we find it
appropriate to mould the relief by directing the State to
activate, implement, and periodically honour the very
statutory mechanism it has itself created.”
20.
From
contractual
the
based
aforesaid
employees
judgments,
have
no
it
appears
automatic
right
that
for
regularization absorption permanency of pay parity, only they
have a right to participate and be considered under the applicable
statutory recruitment rules participate in the process.
21.
It was further observed that an outsourced worker
cannot claim the status of regular employee and regularization or
equal service benefits against the Government body unless direct
employment or sham contract is proved.
22.
Here in the case at hand, the petitioner was initially
engaged on contractual basis for a period of 11 (eleven) months
by SOFED an outsourced agency w.e.f. 10.02.2021 and thereafter
her service was extended time to time and finally it was extended
up to 25.09.2025. In the meantime, the said agency gave further
advertisement for appointment of persons against the said post
along with other posts.
23.
However, at the time of hearing, Learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioner although referred some citations but
could not place any material before the Court to justify that there
was no such scope on the part of the outsourced agency i.e.
SOFED to discontinue the service of the present petitioner because
the appointment of the petitioner was purely contractual.
Furthermore, from the counter-affidavit submitted by
the respondents it appears that her performance was not at all
satisfactory although the respondents engaged her till 25.09.2025.
Thereafter, advertisement was issued for fresh engagement. As
such I do not find any irregularity or illegality in the proceedings of
the respondents authority. Since the petitioner has failed to satisfy
the Court by showing any extent rule so, that appropriate
direction may be given to the respondents to absorb the petitioner
to the post which she was possessing prior to her discontinuance,
as such in the considered opinion of this Court the present
petitioner is not entitled to get any relief. The citations as already
stated cannot be applied in this case.
24.
In the result, the writ petition filed by the petitioner is
found to be bereft of merit.
This writ petition accordingly stands dismissed.
Interim order passed earlier, if any, thus stands
vacated.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Amrita
AMRITA
DEB
AMRITA DEB
Date: 2026.05.19
12:34:17 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review