Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
TRHC010010652025
2026:THC:651
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C)No.375 of 2025
Sri Subrata Reang
C/O- Lt Najar Kr Reang,
Resident of Arundhutinagar,
P.O and P.S- A.D Nagar, Tripura, Pin – 799003
……The Petitioner(s)
Versus
1.The Union of India
Represented by the Secretary to the Government of India,
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pension,
Department of Personnel and Training, Govt of India, Central
Secretariat, New Delhi- 110001.
2.The Union Public Service Commission
Dholpur House, Shajahan Road,
New Delhi- 110001, represented by its Secretary
3.The Chairman
Selection Committee for selection to the Indian Administrative
Service Constituted under Regulation 3 of the IAS (appointed by
promotion) Regulations, 1955, represented by its Chairman,
Union Public Commission Dholpur House, Shajahan Road, New
Delhi- 110069
4.The State of Tripura
Represented by the Secretary GA (P & T) Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat, Pin - 799010, Agartala,
Tripura.
5.Sri Dilip Kr Chakma (IAS)
District Magistrate and Collector, Unakoti Tripura,
Government of Tripura.
6.Sri Nagendra Debbarma,
Director, TRP and PGT, Government of Tripura.
7.Ratan Biswas
Director, General Administration (Printing and Stationary),
Government of Tripura,
8.Rakhi Biswas
Commissioner of Taxes,
Agartala, Tripura.
……The Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Pradyot Maishan, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, DSGI,
Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of Hearing
:
05.05.2026
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
18.05.2026
Whether fit for
Reporting
NO
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Heard
Learned
Counsel,
Mr.
Pradyot
Maishan
appearing on behalf of the petitioner and also heard Learned
Additional G.A., Mr. M. Debbarma appearing on behalf of the
respondents.
02.
The petitioner has filed the writ petition seeking the
following relief/reliefs:
I. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order or direction shall not be issued whereby
Quashing and cancelling the Notification, dated,
14/12/2023, & 15/03/2022, issued by the Under
Secretary to the Government of India.
II. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order or direction shall not be issued whereby
directing the Respondents to give promotion to the
Petitioner from the Tripura Civil Service Cadre (TCS)
to Indian Administrative Service (IAS) by restoring
the seniority of the petitioner with all other ancillary
& consequential service benefit with retrospective
effect.
III. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order or direction shall not be issued whereby
directing the Respondents to create a supernumery
post & give promotion to the petitioner from Tripura
Civil Service Cadre (TCS) to Indian Administrative
Service (IAS).
IV. Make the rules absolute.
V. Call for records,
VI. Pass any further order/orders as this Hon'ble
High Court considered fit and proper.
03.
At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the
petitioner submitted that the petitioner was appointed as TCS,
Grade-II in year 1997 in pursuance of Rule 16 of the Tripura
Civil Service Rules, 1967 read with Clause (b) of Sub-rule (1) of
rule 5 of the said rule (Annexure-1). Thereafter, vide memo
dated 04.05.2010 the G.A.(P&T) Department released the draft
seniority list of the TCS, Grade-II Officers wherein the name of
the petitioner was shown to be at serial No.12 and the name of
the private respondent Nos.7 and 8 was shown at serial No.26
and 30. After that the petitioner along with others filed writ
petitioner before the High Court vide W.P.(C) No.71 of 2019 on
the ground that they were promoted to the post of TCS, GradeII and they have successfully completed the period of probation
of two years but the respondents by one office notification dated
21.07.2008 extended the period of probation of the petitioner
for an uncertain period on the ground that they did not pass the
Departmental
Examination.
The
petitioner
challenged
the
notification dated 21.07.2008 on the ground that the said
notification was arbitrary, unconstitutional and violative of TCS
Service Rules, 1967.
It was also submitted that since the petitioners were
appointed by promotion as per the provision of Rule 5(b) of TCS
Rule, 1967 observing the procedure prescribed in Rule 14 and
15, so, they were exempted from the prescribed examination
during the probation period by virtue of the provision prescribed
in Rule 22 of the Rule 1967. Hence, the petitioner was entitled
to be confirmed as per Rule 23 on successful completion of the
provision period. According to the petitioner, the respondent
vide office order dated 16.03.2005 exempted 17 officers from
appearing in the Departmental Examination and vide order
dated 07.07.2008 also further exempted 31 officers from
appearing in the Departmental Examination in exercise of the
power conferred under Rule 35 of the TCS Rules, 1967. This
High Court vide judgment and order dated 19.07.2012 set aside
and quashed the notification dated 21.07.2008 and directed the
respondents to confirmed the petitioner in TCS Grade-II under
Rule-23 of 1967 but the other prayer was rejected. The
judgment was annexed as Annexure-3.
It
was
further
submitted
that
the
petitioner
thereafter, preferred writ appeal before this High Court vide writ
appeal No.60 of 2012 and during the pendency of the writ
appeal
the
G.A.(P&T)
Department
vide
notification
dated
03.04.2013 confirmed the petitioner in TCS, Grade-II post on
satisfactory
completion
of
their
probation
period
w.e.f.
03.11.1999 (Annexure-4). The petitioner also relied upon the
judgment of writ appeal as Annexure-5 and after that the
petitioner preferred SLP bearing No.3287 of 2014 before the
Supreme Court against the impugned judgment and order dated
02.09.2013 passed in W.A. No.60 of 2012 and as per direction
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India by a notification dated
17.04.2017 the petitioner was exempted from passing the
Departmental
Examination
(Annexure-7).
After
that
vide
notification dated 03.07.2021 issued by the Deputy Secretary to
the Government of Tripura, in pursuance of Rule 30 of the
Tripura Civil Service Rules, 1967 the Government appointed the
petitioner to the post of TCS, Grade-I, Selection Grade on Adhoc
basis as one time measure (Annexure-8). After that the
petitioner
made
a
representation
on
06.06.2025
to
the
Government, i.e. to the Secretary G.A.(P&T) Department,
seeking his promotion to the higher post (Annexure-9). In the
meantime, the under Secretary, Government of India by a
notification dated 14.12.2023 appointed Ratan Biswas and Rakhi
Biswas in the Indian Administrative Service and by the said
notification
dated
14.12.2023,
Dilip
Kumar
Chakma
was
promoted to the Indian Administrative Service and by another
notification dated 15.03.2022, Nagendra Debbarma was also
given promotion to the post of IAS. It was further submitted by
Learned Counsel for the petitioner that said Ratan Biswas and
Rakhi Biswas were junior to him and in the seniority list of 2011
both were also junior to him because both of them joined in the
Civil Service, Grade-II on 01.09.1998 but he was joined in the
State Civil Service on 03.11.1997. Similarly, other respondents
Dilip Kumar Chakma and Nagendra Debbarma were also given
promotion to the post of IAS depriving him. The petitioner relied
upon those notifications dated 15.03.2022 and the notification
dated 14.12.2023 as Annexure-10.
Learned Counsel
further submitted that as the
representation submitted by the petitioner was not addressed
by the respondent-Department, so, he has filed this writ petition
seeking the relief as stated above.
04.
The State has contested the case by filing counter-
affidavit. In para Nos.8 to 11 the State-respondents have
asserted the following facts:
“8. That, in reply of the contents of paragraphs-6 &
7 of the writ petition, I humbly submit that it is a
matter of records. The petitioner (Shri Subrata
Reang) alongwith other filed a writ appeal in the
Hon'ble High Court of Tripura bearing No. WA No.60
of 2012 (Divisional Bench) against the judgment
and order passed by the Hon'ble Gauhati High
Court's dated 19-July, 2012. The Hon'ble High Court
of Tripura passed an order dated 02-09-2013. The
relevant portion of the judgment is as follows:
"the Court cannot direct that relaxation be
granted; all it can direct is that the case for
relaxation be considered. But here in view of the
clear-cut provision of the Rules, 1975, no such
direction can be issued.
the appeal is only allowed to the limited extent
that the appellant-petitions shall be considered
for promotion for any of the promotional posts
which were filled up between 11-07-1999 to 1402-2001. All other prayers are rejected".
9. That, in reply of the contents of paragraphs-8 to
10 of the writ petition, I humbly submit that being
aggrieved, the petitioners filed SLP(C) No.3287 of
2014 before the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India
against the judgment passed by the Hon'ble High
Court of Tripura. The Hon'ble Supreme Court of
India in its order dated 08-07-2015 has disposed of
the said SLP. The relevant portion of the said
judgment is as follows: "Be that as it may we are only inclined to direct
the Govt. to consider the case of the petitioners
under Rule, 35 of 1967 Rules as the said Rule
would be applicable to the case at hand. While
considering the issue of relaxation, the State
Govt. shall keep in mind the expediency and
other factors that had weighed with it while
passing the orders dated 16th March, 2005 and
7th July, 2005. Needless to emphasize, the order
shall contain reasons.
With the aforesaid modification in the order
passed by the High Court, the special leave
petition stands disposed of, without any order as
to cost".
In compliance with order passed by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court of India dated 08-07-2015, the
matter was placed before the Council of Ministers.
The Council of Ministers in its meeting held on 11th
April, 2017 approved to give one time relaxation as
on exemption from appearing at the Departmental
Examination to all the 6(six) petitioners (including
Shri Subrata Reang, Petitioner). As per decision of
Council of Ministers, the notification for exemption
of 6(six) TCS officers from passing the Departmental
Examination had been issued vide No.F.30(1)GA(P&T)/2009 dated 17th April, 2017.
It is pertinent to mention that as per Proviso under
Rule 30 of the TCS Rules, 1967 no person subject to
provision of Rule, 20 of the TCS (Training &
Departmental Examination) Rule, 1975 shall be
considered for appointment to the next higher
scale/
Selection
Grade
unless
he
passes
Examination in full. However, in view of the
exemption from the Departmental appearing before
the Departmental Examination, above 6(six) TCS Grll officers including the petitioner (Shri Subrata
Reang) had become eligible for promotion to the
post of TCS Gr-I(Selection Grade). But, at that
material period due to pendency of SLP before the
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in connection with
the Reservation Policy of State Govt. all kinds of
promotion of the State Govt. employees remained
withheld. In this regard a Memo was also issued on
1st April, 2017.
Thereafter, the State Govt. had introduced ad-hoc
Promotion Policy, 2021 on 22-06-2021 to allow
promotion to the State Govt. employees on ad-hoc
basis as one time measure on prospective effect
basis subject to the final outcome of the SLP
pending before the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India.
Following the provision of above ad-hoc Promotion
Policy, the petitioner (Shri Subrata Reang) has been
promoted to the post of TCS Gr-1 (Selection Grade)
on ad-hoc basis with prospective effect and there
was no discrimination meted out to him viz-a-viz
other similarly situated colleagues of him.
10. That, in reply of the contents of paragraph-11 of
the writ petition, I humbly submit that this is a
matter of records that as per Promotion Policy,
2021, Shri Subrata Reang, TCS Gr-ll has been
promoted to the post of TCS Gr-I (Selection Grade)
on ad-hoc basis on prospective date as one time
measure. Therefore, as per promotion Policy Shri
Reang did not get any promotion to the next higher
grade from his present ad-hoc post.
11. That, in reply of the contents of paragraph-12 of
the writ petition, I humbly submit that it is
completely denied.
It is fact that by the Notification dated 1412-2023 of the Department of Personnel & Training,
Govt. of India Shri Ratan Biswas and Smt. Rakhi
Biswas [Respondents No.7 & 8 respectively] have
been appointed to IAS on the basis of Select List of
2018. It is also fact that by the said Notification
dated 14-12-2023, Shri Dilip Kumar Chakma
[Respondent No.5] has been appointed to IAS on
the basis of Select List of 2018. For promotion /
induction to IAS for the Select List of 2018, the
Selection Committee Meeting was held on the basis
of finally published seniority list of Tripura Civil
Service Officers Gr-l (Selection Grade) as on 01-012015. In the said finally published seniority list, Shri
Subrata Reang [Petitioner] did not figure. As such,
all the aforesaid Respondents [No.5, 7 & 8] are
senior to the Petitioner. Moreover, by the
Notification dated 15-03-2022 of the Govt. of India,
Department of Personnel & Training, New Delhi, Shri
Nagendra Debbarma [Respondent No. 6] has been
appointed on the basis of Select List of 2017. For
promotion / induction to IAS for the Select List of
2017, the Selection Committee Meeting was held on
the basis of finally published seniority list of Tripura
Civil Service Officers (Senior Selection Grade) and
Tripura Civil Service Officers [Gr-1 (Selection
Grade)] as on 01-01-2015. In the said finally
published seniority lists, Shri Subrata Reang
[Petitioner] is also not figured. The Petitioner has
only been promoted to TCS Gr-1 (Selection Grade)
on 03-07-2021 on ad-hoc basis because the
petitioner
did
not
pass
the
Departmental
Examination in full as required under TCS Rules,
1967 for granting higher grade/promotion to the
post of TCS Gr-I(Selection Grade). But, the above
private respondents cleared their Departmental
Examination in full and they got promotion to the
higher post earlier to the petitioner. Further it is
stated that both the Respondents No.5 & 6 are
senior to the Petitioner.
Further, it is stated that the Petitioner was not in
TCS Gr-I (Selection Grade) as on 01.01.2015 and he
has only been promoted to TCS Gr-I (Selection
Grade) on 03.07.2021, on ad-hoc basis. As such,
contention of the Petitioner is completely denied.”
At the time of hearing, Learned Addl. G.A. for
the State-respondents submitted that the other private official
respondents were confirmed in their service much earlier as
because the official private respondents were appointed to the
post of IAS on the basis of select list of 2018 and the Selection
Committee considered the finally published seniority list of TCS
Officers, Grade-I as on 01.01.2015 but in the said finally
published seniority list the name of the present petitioner was
not there, so, his name was not considered. Further, the
petitioner was not in TCS, Grade-I as on 01.01.2015 and he has
been promoted to the post of TCS, Grade-I, Selection Grade-I
on 03.07.2021 on Adhoc basis. So, there was no question to
promote the petitioner to the post of Indian Administrative
Service.
Learned Addl. G.A. also submitted that the petitioner
in this writ petition did not challenge the final seniority list dated
01.01.2015 and until and unless the said final seniority list is
challenged, there is/was no any scope on the part of the State
Government to recommend the name of the petitioner, nor
there is any scope on the part of this Court to issue any rule in
this regard.
Union of India also filed counter-affidavit. In their
counter-affidavit they only asserted that as per recommendation
of the Selection Committee the respondents were appointed to
the post of IAS and they had no direct role on it.
05.
I have heard both the sides at length and perused
the writ petition and the documents annexed as well as the
counter-affidavit filed by the respondents. The petitioner in this
case prayed for certain reliefs including the prayer for directing
the respondents to consider the name of the petitioner for
promotion to the post of Indian Administrative Service.
Admittedly, the petitioner joined in TCS in 1997 but
as he could not qualify the Departmental Examination, so, his
service was not confirmed but prior to his confirmation the other
private official respondents could qualify the Departmental
Examination and they were accordingly confirmed in their
service and promoted. The petitioner approached to the Court
and finally as per direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court he was
exempted from appearing in the Departmental Examination and
later on by notification dated 17.04.2017 (Annexure-7) issued
by the Government of Tripura he was exempted from passing
the Departmental Examination and thereafter, the petitioner
was promoted to the post of TCS Grade-I (Selection Grade) on
adhoc
basis
by
another
memorandum
dated
03.07.2021
(Annexure-8). But in the given case, the private official
respondents on the basis of seniority list of 2015 were promoted
to the post of IAS but the petitioner did not challenge the said
seniority list of 2015 before this Court or any other forum and
unless and until the seniority list of 2015 is challenged and the
seniority of the petitioner is restored in that case there was no
scope on the part of the respondent-State to consider the name
of the petitioner in the selection list of IAS.
06.
At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the
petitioner could not give any explanation as to why the
petitioner has not challenged the said selection list rather
Learned Counsel only submitted that since the petitioner was
pursuing his case before the Supreme Court, so, no steps could
be taken by him in this regard. But this plea cannot be taken as
a genuine ground for issuing any rule in this writ petition. Thus,
it appears that the petitioner has failed to satisfy the Court by
showing any cogent materials on record to issue any rule
against the State-respondents. As such the petitioner is not
entitled to get any relief in this writ petition.
07.
In the result, the writ petition filed by the petitioner
is found to be bereft of merit.
Accordingly, the same stands dismissed/rejected.
With
this
observation
this
writ
petition
stands
disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed
of.
JUDGE
PURNITA
DEB
Purnita
PURNITA DEB
Date: 2026.05.19
18:23:44 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review