Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
TRHC010003782022
2026:THC:704
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P(C) No.196 of 2022
W.P(C) No.250 of 2022
W.P.(C) No.298 of 2022
W.P.(C) No.832 of 2022
W.P.(C) No.92 of 2025
W.P.(C) No.206 of 2025
W.P.(C) No.536 of 2025
In W.P(C) No.196 of 2022
1. Sri Priyankar Biswas
son of Sri Santiranjan Biswas, resident of village-Kalshi Mura,
P.O- Boxanagar, P.S- Sonamura, Sub-Division- Sonamura,
District- Sepahijala, PIN- 799102, aged about 23 years.
2. Sri Biswajit Sarkar,
son of Sri Jadu sarkar, resident of village- Bajal Ghat, P.OFatick Charra, P.S- Fatick Charra, District- West Tripura, PIN799210, aged about 21 years.
3. Smt Soudamani Debnath,
daughter of Late Nani Gopal Debnath, resident of villageNorth Maharani, P.O- Maharani, P.S- Udaipur, DistrictGomati Tripura, PIN- 799013, aged about 24 years.
4. Sri Kusijoy Reang,
son of Sri Rosa Kumar Reang, resident of village- Shivnagar
Para Piplacherra, P.O- Piplacherra, P.S- Dam Cherra, DistrictNorth Tripura, PIN- 799256, aged about 22 years.
5. Sri Suken Debnath,
son of Sri Swapan Debnath,
resident of villageLaxmandhepa, P.O- Laxmandhepa, P.S- Melaghar, DistrictSepahijala, PIN- 799102, aged about 24 years.
6. Smt Priya Reang,
daughter of Sri Pran Kumar Reang, resident of villageTuisama, G.P- Ghilatali, P.O- Kanchanpur, P.S- Kanchanpur,
District- North Tripura, PIN- 799271, aged about 22 years.
7. Smt Puja Sen,
daughter of Sri Pijush Sen, resident of village- Mayachhari, P.ORamdurlavpur, P.S- Kamalpur, District- Dhalai Tripura, PIN- 799285, aged
about 21 years.
[2]
8. Sri Subhankar Pashi,
son of Sri Ramdeo Pashi, resident of village- Mayachari, P.OMayachari, P.S- Kamalpur, District- Dhalai Tripura, PIN799285, aged about 22 years.
9. Sri Birajit Sarkar,
son of Sri Narayan Sarkar, resident of village- Pecharthal,
P.O- Pecharthal, P.S- Pecharthal, District- Unakoti Tripura,
PIN- 799263, aged about 21 years.
10. Sri Sourab Srakar,
son of Sri Sudhangsu Sarkar, resident of village- Gatacharra,
P.O- Pecharthal, P.S- Pecharthal, District- Unakoti Tripua,
PIN- 799263, aged about 22 years.
11. Sri Swarajit Rudra Paul,
son of Sri Bimal Rudra Paul, resident of village- East
Howaibari, P.O- Howaibari, P.S-Howaibari, District- Khowai
Tripura, PIN- 799205, aged about 22 years.
12. Sri Jainal Uddin,
son of Sri Muhir Uddin, resident of village- Halahali, P.OHalahali, P.S- Halahali, District- Dhalai Tripura, PIN- 799003,
aged about 24 years.
13. Sri Subrata Mandal,
son of Sri Matilal Mandal, resident of village- Baluchara, P.OBaluchara, P.S- Teliamura, District- Khowai Tripura, PIN799205, aged about 22 years.
14. Sri Sukanta Pal,
son of Sri Jawahar Lal Pal, resident of village- Jashmura, P.OAbhoyganj Bazar, P.S- Rajnagar, District- South Tripura, PIN799155, aged about 23 years.
15. Sri Prasanta Sarkar,
son of Sri Santosh Sarkar, resident of village- South
Badharghat, P.O- Charipara, P.S- Amtalai, District- West
Tripura, PIN- 799003, aged about 23 years
16. Sri Sujit Sarkar,
son of Sri Ranjit Sarkar, resident of village- Damdamia, P.OLembucherra, P.S- Lefunga, District- West Tripura, PIN799210, aged about 20 years.
[3]
17. Sri Subrata Rudra Paul,
son of Sri Subhash Rudra Paul, resident of village- Belabor,
P.O- S.D. Mission, P.S- Amtali, District- West Tripura, PIN799003, aged about 22 years.
18. Sri Partha Bhowmik,
son of Sri Dilip Bhowmik, resident of village- Gopinagar, P.OKalkalia, P.S- Bishalgarh, District- Sepahijala, PIN- 799102,
aged about 24 years.
19. Sri Bipul Tripura,
son of Sri Rabindra Tripura, resident of village- Paschim
Kalabaria, P.O- Belonia, P.S- Maichara, District- South
Tripura, PIN- 799155, aged about 22 years.
20. Sri Manish Banik,
son of Sri Nitai Banik, resident of village- Santirbazar, P.OSantirbazar, P.S- Santirbazar, District- South Tripura, PIN799144, aged about 21 years.
21. Smt Suravi Dey,
daughter of Sri Samir Ranjan Dey, resident of villageChampamura, P.O- Champamura, P.S- Bishalagarh, DistrictSepahijala, PIN- 799130, aged about 24 years.
22. Sri Sagar Chandra Datta,
son of Sri Khokan Datta, resident of village- Ishan Chandra
Nagar, P.O- Ishan Chandra Nagar, P.S- Belonia, DistrictSouth Tripura, PIN- 799155, aged about 25 years.
23. Sri Karuna Rupini,
son of Sri Ananta Rupini, resident of village- Nitainagar, P.ONarendranagar, P.S- Damcherra, District- North Tripura, PIN799256, aged about 28 years.
24. Sri Kshirud Rudra Paul,
son of Sri Kshitish Rudra Paul, resident of village- Tuichindrai,
P.O- Howaibari, P.S- Tuichindrai, District- Khowai Tripura,
PIN- 799205, aged about 23 years.
25. Sri Surajit Debbarma,
son of Sri Mohan Debbarma, resident of village- Bidhya Manik
Para, P.O- Salimar, P.S- Kachuchara, District- Dhalai Tripura,
PIN- 799278, aged about 26 years.
[4]
26. Sri Titan Pal,
son of Sri Dulal Pal, resident of village- Karaiyamura, P.OEast Bagabasha, P.S- Radha Kishore Pur, District- Gomati
Tripura, PIN- 799114, aged about 21 years.
27. Sri Matilal Debbarma,
son of Sri Bimal Debbarma, resident of village- Jamthum,
P.O- Jamthum, P.S- Kachucherra, District- Dhalai, PIN799286, aged about 27 years.
28. Sri Ajoy Roy,
son of Sri Ranjit Roy, resident of village- Kalachara, P.OBhuratali, P.S- Manubazar, District- South Tripura, PIN799143, aged about 21 years
29. Sri Rakesh Chandra Das,
son of Sri Dinesh Das, resident of village- Indira Nagar, P.OGabtali, P.S- Belonia, District- South Tripura, PIN- 799157,
aged about 23 years.
30. Sri Bitan Barman,
son of Sri Rabindra Barman, resident of village- Bejimara,
P.O- Bejimara, P.S- Sonamura, District- Sepahijala Tripura,
PIN- 799131, aged about 28 years.
31. Sri Rajib Nama Das,
son of Sri Rakhal Nama Das, resident of village- Kalaban,
P.O- Kalaban, P.S- Radha Kishore Pur, District- Gomati
Tripura, PIN- 799125, aged about 27 years.
32. Sri Rakesh Debnath,
son of Sri Narayan Chandra Debnath, resident of villageBhatilarma, P.O- Purba Laxmi Bill, P.S- Bishalagarh, DistrictSepahijala Tripura, PIN- 799131, aged about 25 years.
33. Smt Aparna Chowdhury,
daughter of Sri Adhir Chowdhury, resident of village- South
Maheshpur, P.O- Kathalia, P.S- Jatrapur, District- Sepahijala
Tripura, PIN- 799132, aged about 25 years.
34. Sri Debashis Bhuiya,
son of Sri Santi Bhuiya, resident of village- Bara Bhaiya, P.OBagma, P.S- Radha Kishore Pur, District- Gomati Tripura,
PIN- 799114, aged about 23 years.
[5]
35. Sri Bapan Debnath,
son of Sri Arjun Debnath, resident of village- Purba Laxmi Bill,
P.O- Purba Laxmi Bill, P.S- Bishalgarh, District- Sepahijala
Tripura, PIN- 799102, aged about 22 years.
36. Sri Md. Jahir Hossain,
son of Sri Abul kalam, resident of village- Sonapur, P.ORabindra Nagar, P.S- Sonamura, District- Sepahijala Tripura,
PIN- 799131, aged about 23 years.
37. Smt Minakshi Majumder,
daughter of Sri Dilip Chandra Majumder, resident of villageGangacharra, P.O- Gangacharra, P.S- Kakraban, DistrictGomati Tripura, PIN- 799125, aged about 24 years.
38. Smt Lebi Rong Reang,
daughter of Sri Upendra Reang, resident of village- Garjee
Along Bari Para, P.O- Garjee, P.S- Radha Kishore Pur,
District- Gomati Tripura, PIN- 799125, aged about 24 years.
39. Smt Tepali Tripura,
daughter of Sri Sudharam Tripura, resident of village- New
Gonjalima, P.O- Ghorakappa, P.S- Silachari, District- Gomati
Tripura, PIN- 799104, aged about 22 years.
40. Smt Rinadevi Jamatia,
daughter of Sri Bijoy Singha Jamatia, resident of villageDakshin Maharani, P.O- Dakshin Maharani, P.S- Radha
Kishore Pur, District- Gomati Tripura, PIN- 799116, aged
about 25 years.
41. Sri Salman Kha
son of Sri Rafik Miah, resident of village- Gajaria Muslim Para,
P.O- A.D. Nagar, P.S- A.D. Nagar, District- West Tripura, PIN799003, aged about 21 years.
42. Sri Akash Sarkar,
son of Sri Sumanta Sarkar, resident of village- Bajal Ghat,
P.O- Fatik Cherra, P.S- Fatik Cherra, District- West Tripura,
PIN- 799210, aged about 22 years.
43. Sri Ajit Jamatia,
son of Sri Uttam Kumar Jamatia, resident of village- Tuitham
Pui Para, P.O- Khasiamangal, P.S- Teliamura, DistrictKhowai Tripura, aged about 20 years.
[6]
44. Smt Ripa Paul,
daughter of Sri Uttam Paul, resident of village- Noagaon, P.OBamutia, P.S- Bamutia, District- West Tripura, PIN- 799211,
aged about 23 years.
45. Sri Sourav Sarkar,
son of Sri Rajkumar Sarkar, resident of village- Kalkalia, P.OKalkalia, District- West Tripura, PIN- 799211, aged about 20
years.
46. Sri Shyamal Debbarma,
son of Sri Rajesh Debbarma, resident of village- Govinda
Sardar Para, P.O- Khashia Mangal, P.S- Teliamura, DistrictKhowai Tripura, PIN- 799205, aged about 24 years.
47. Sri Prasenjit Biswas,
son of Sri Bivhu Biswas, resident of village-, P.O-, P.SKhowai, District- Khowai Tripura, PIN- 799205, aged about 28
years.
48. Sri Mantu Biswas,
son of Sri Chitta Biswas, resident of village- West Balucharai,
P.O- M.T. Para, P.S- Khowai, District- Khowai Tripura, PIN799205, aged about 28 years.
49. Sri Dwipan Ghosh,
son of Sri Dilip Ghosh, resident of village- Golabari, P.OGolabari, P.S- Khowai, District- Khowai Tripura, PIN- 799205,
aged about 21 years.
50. Sri Tadir Islam,
son of Sri Abu Taher, resident of village- Purba Chandigarh,
P.O- Chandigarh, P.S- Melaghar, District- Sepahijala Tripura,
PIN- 799115, aged about 25 years.
51. Sri Prasenjit Rudra Paul,
son of Sri Bimal Rudra Paul, resident of village- East
Howaibari, P.O- Howaibari, P.S- Khowai, District- Khowai
Tripura, PIN- 799205, aged about 23 years.
52. Sri Ainur Uddin,
son of Sri Baja Uddin, resident of village- Kuchainala, P.OKamalpur, P.S- Kamalpur, District- Dhalai Tripura, PIN799285, aged about 23 years.
[7]
53. Smt Menaka Jamatia,
daughter of Sri Bijoy Pada Jamatia, resident of villageDarjeeling Tilla, P.O- Karailong, P.S- Teliamura, DistrictKhowai Tripura, PIN- 799205, aged about 28 years.
54. Sri Pranab Das,
son of Sri Pradip Das, resident of village- South Ghilatali near
Rambabu Sampadak Para High School, G.P- Ghilatali, P.OGhilatali Bazar, District- Khowai Tripura, PIN- 799203, aged
about 23 years.
55. Sri Nayan Debnath,
son of Sri Bijoykrishna Debnath, resident of villageJumerdhepa, P.O- Jumerdhepa, P.S- Melaghar, DistrictSepahijala Tripura, PIN- 799115, aged about 22 years.
56. Sri Sushanta Das,
son of Late Dinesh Das, resident of village- Kalshimura, P.OBoxanagar, P.S- Sonamura, District- Sepahijala Tripura, PIN799102, aged about 28 years.
57. Sri Ananta Kumar Laskar,
son of Sri Ratan Kumar Laskar, resident of villageChampamura, P.O- Champamura, P.S- Bishalgarh, DistrictSepahijala Tripura, PIN- 799130, aged about 23 years.
58. Sri Chiranjit Shil,
son of Sri Mantu Chandra Shil, resident of villageChampamura, P.O- Champamura, P.S- Bishalgarh, DistrictSepahijala Tripura, PIN- 799130, aged about 22 years.
59. Sri Gourav Sarkar,
son of Sri Subrata Sarkar, resident of village- Kashi Nath Pur,
P.O- Khashia Mangal, P.S- Teliamura, District- Khowai
Tripura, PIN- 799205, aged about 22 years.
… Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1. The State of Tripura
represented by the Commissioner and Secretary, Home
Department, Government of Tripura, having his office at
Secretariat Building, P.O- Kunjaban, P.S- New Capital
Complex, District - West Tripura, Pin - 799006.
2. The Commissioner and Secretary, Home
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat
Building, P.O- Kunjaban, P.S- New Capital Complex, District West Tripura, Pin- 799006.
[8]
3. The Director General of Police,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Fire Service
Chowmuhani, P.O- Agartala, P.S- West Agartala, District West Tripura, Pin – 799001
4. The Commandant, SAF,
Member of TSR Recruitment Board, Government of Tripura,
having his office at Fire Service Chowmuhani, P.O- Agartala,
P.S- West Agartala, District - West Tripura, Pin – 799001
5.Smt. Manisa Das,
daughter of Asish Kumar Das
6.Smt. Mwtai Jamatia,
daughter of Pran Mohan Jamatia
….. Respondent (s)
In W.P.(C) No.250 of 2022
Sri Dipankar Bhowmik
S/O- Sri. Swapan Bhowmik, Presently residing at C/O Mr.
Tinu Debbarma, Lake Chowmuhani, Krishnanagar, Supari
Bagan, Agartala, Tripura, PIN – 799001
Permanent Resident of Village and PO - Srinagar, P.SManubazar, District - South Tripura, Tripura, PIN - 799143
….. Petitioner (s)
-V e r s u s1. The State of Tripura
represented by the Secretary, Department of Home Affairs,
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.OKunjaban, P.S New Capital Complex, District - West Tripura.
2. The Department of Police
represented by its Director General of Police, Police
Headquarter, Fire Brigade Chowmuhani, Agartala, West
Tripura.
3. The Director General of Police Tripura
Police Head Quarters, Fire Brigade Chowmuhani, P.OAgartala, Tripura, West PIN – 799001
[9]
4.The Recruitment Board (Inside) of Enrolled Followers
Tripura State Rifles
represented by its Chairman, having their Office at 11th BN,
TSR, Gokulnagar, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala.
5. The Chairman
The Recruitment Board (Inside) of Enrolled Followers, Tripura
State Rifles, having his office at 11th BN, TSR , Gokulnagar,
Bishalgarh, Sepahijala.
6. Sri. Jayanta Sarkar,
Son of Sri. Jhutan Sarkar
7. Sri. Asikh Das
Son of Nandan Das
8. Sri. Tutan Das
son of Narayan Das
9. Sri. Sanjoy Malakar,
Son of Nikhil Malakar.
10. Sri. Abhijit Biswas
Son of Sishu Ranjan Biswas
11. Sri Dipak Das
Son of Girindra Das
12. Sri. Biswajit Das
Son of Bibhishan Das
13. Sri. Asish Das
Son of Arjun Das
14. Sri. Dip Das
Son of Lt. Dipankar Das
15. Sri. Rubal Das
Son of Sunil Das
16. Sri Sagar Das
Son of Subrata Das
17. Sri Rakesh Das
Son of Nilesh Chandra Das
[10]
18. Sri. Bijoy Das
Son of Babul Das
19. Sri Zomawia Darlong
Son of Darhminga Darlong
20. Sri Pankaj Das
Son of Dipal Das
21. Sri Swagatam Das
Son of Paban Das
22. Sri Bapan Chandra Das
Son of Bishu Chandra Das
23. Sri Amal Das
Son of Bhulu Das
24. Sri Newtan Das
Son of Nipendra Das
25. Sri Palash Das
Son of Animesh Das
26. Sri Papu Sukla Das
Son of Narayan Sukla Das
27. Sri Litan Das
Son of Jaharlal Das
28. Sri Pritam Das
Son of Prahalad Das
29. Sri Chinmoy Das
Son of Sri Chitta Ranjan Das
30. Sri Pranesh Podder
Son of Mantu Poddar
31. Sri Bijoy Sarkar
Son of Lt. Sanjit Sarkar
32. Santosh Das
Son of Dulal Das
[11]
33. Sri Ajoy Marak
Son of Raju Marak
34. Sri Jagannath Das
Son of Nimai Das
35. Sri Sanjoy Das
son of Satya Ranjan Das
36. Sri Pulak Mallik
Son of Partha Ranjan Mallik
37. Sri Sagar Das
Son of Subhash Ch Das
38. Sri Biplab Mitra
Son of Gopal Mitra
39. Sri Ranjit Sarkar
Son of Haripada Sarkar
40. Sri Deep Das
Son of Krishna Kumar Das
41. Sri Sagar Chandra Das
Son of Mantu Chandra Das
42. Sri Rajesh Das
Son of Lt. Basudeb Das
43. Sri Shantu Das
Son of Sukumar Das
44. Sri Surajit Halder
Son of Pratikul Halder
45. Sri Bapan Das
Son of Tapan Das
46. Sri Aniket Jamatia
Son of Bhuban Mohan Jamatia
47. Sri Rowhan Biswas
Son of Lt Santosh Biswas
48. Sri Sukanta Mali,
Son of Chandan Mali
[12]
49. Sri Sukanta Das,
Son of Lt. Jahar Lal Das
50. Sri Subrata Das
Son of Premjit Das
51. Sri Alok Malakar,
Son of Ranjit Malakar
52. Sri Jhutan Das
Son of Ranjit Das
53. Sri Jyotimoy Chakma
Son of Moni Chakma
54. Sri Rajib Das
Son of Amarendra Das
55. Sri Babul Sarkar
Son of Lt. Nipesh Sarkar
56. Sri.. Sourav Das
Son of Phani Bhusan Das
57. Sri Chiranjit Das
Son of Debal Chandra Das
58. Sri Raju Tripura
Son of Shib Charan Tripura
[
59. Sri Milton Malakar
Son of Gopiranjan Malakar.
Respondent Nos.6 to 59 are to be served through the Office
of Director General of Police, Police headquarter, Fire Brigade
Chowmuhani, Agartala, West Tripura.
….. Respondent(s)
In W.P.(C) No.298 of 2022
1. Sri Kalyanbrata Bhadra
son of Sri. Sujit Bhadra, resident of village - Nehal Chandra
Nagar, P.O- Nehal Chandra Nagar, P.S - Bishalgarh, SubDivision - Bishalgarh, District - Sepahijala, PIN - 799102, aged
about 23 years
[13]
2. Sri. Dipankar Roy,
son of Sri Ashish Kumar Roy, resident of village Raghunathpur, P.O - Bishalgarh, P.S - Bishalgarh, SubDivision - Bishalgarh, District - Sepahijala, PIN - 799102, aged
about 23 years.
….. Petitioner (s)
–Versus–
1. The State of Tripura
represented by the Commissioner and Secretary, Home
Department, Government of Tripura, having his office at
Secretariat Building, P.O- Kunjaban, P.S - New Capital
Complex, District - West Tripura, Pin – 799006
2. The Commissioner and Secretary, Home
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat
Building, P.O- Kunjaban, P.S - New Capital Complex, District
West Tripura, Pin – 799006
3. The Director General of Police
Government of Tripura, having his office at Fire Service
Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura, Pin-799001
4. The Commandant, SAF
Member of TSR Recruitment Board, Government of Tripura,
having his office at Fire Service Chowmuhani, P.O- Agartala,
P.S - West Agartala, District - West Tripura, Pin – 799001
5. Sourav Das
son of Subal Das
6. Amit Kumar Das
son of Gopal Chandra Das
7. Ratan Das
son of Swadesh Das
8. Santanu Das
son of Sunil Das
9. Jayanta Das
son of Mintu Das
[14]
10. Sankar Nama
son of Lt. Subal Ch Nama
11. Mitan Das
Son of Sasanka Das
12. Ashis Das
son of Khitish Das
13. Avijit Biswas
son of Biplab Biswas
14. Miltan Das
Son of Lt. Manoranjan Das,
Addresses of the said respondents No.5 to 14 are not known
to the petitioners, and hence, Notices upon them may be
served, through the Director General of Police, Government of
Tripura, having hid office at Fire Services Chowmuhani, P.OAgartala, P.S - West Agartala, District - West Tripura, Pin –
799001
….. Respondent(s)
In W.P.(C) No.832 of 2022
Sri Partha Baidya
son of Sri Ratan Baidya, resident of village and P.O- Uttar
Sonaichari, P.S- Belonia, Sub-Division- Belonia, DistrictSouth Tripura, PIN- 799155, aged about 25 years.
….. Petitioner (s)
–Versus–
1. The State of Tripura
represented by the Commissioner and Secretary, Home
Department, Government of Tripura, having his office at
Secretariat Building, P.O- Kunjaban, P.S- New Capital
Complex, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799006
2. The Commissioner and Secretary, Home
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat
Building, P.O- Kunjaban, P.S- New Capital Complex, DistrictWest Tripura, Pin- 799006.
[15]
3. The Director General of Police
Government of Tripura, having is office at Fire Service
Chowmuhani, P.O- Agartala, P.S- West Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura, Pin- 799001
4. The Commandant, SAF,
Member of TSR Recruitment Board Government of Tripura,
having his office at Fire Service Chowmuhani, P.O- Agartala,
P.S- West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001
5. Sourav Das
son of Subal Das
6. Amit Kumar Das
son of Gopal Chandra Das
7. Ratan Das
son of Swadesh Das
8. Santanu Das
son of Sunil Das
9. Jayanta Das
son of Mintu Das
10. Sankar Nama
son of Lt. Subal Ch Nama
11. Mitan Das
son of Sasanka Das
12. Ashis Das
son of Khitish Das
13. Avijit Biswas
son of Lt. Biplab Biswas
14. Miltan Das
son of Lt. Manoranjan Das,
Address of the said respondent Nos. 5 to 14 are not known to
the petitioner, and hence, Notices upon them may be served,
through the Director General of Police, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Fire Service Chowmuhani, P.OAgartala, P.S- West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin799001
….. Respondent(s)
[16]
In W.P.(C) No.92 of 2025
Sri Rana Nath
S/O- Sri Krishna Nath, Presently residing at Village and P.OSrinagar, P.S- Manubazar, District- South Tripura, Tripura,
PIN – 799143
….. Petitioner (s)
–Versus–
1. The State of Tripura
represented by the Secretary, Department of Home Affairs,
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.OKunjaban, P.S New Capital Complex, District - West Tripura.
2. The Department of Police
represented by its Director General of Police, Police
Headquarter, Fire Brigade Chowmuhani, Agartala, West
Tripura.
3. The Director General of Police Tripura
Police Head Quarters, Fire Brigade Chowmuhani, P.O- Agartala, Tripura,
West, PIN – 799001
4. The Recruitment Board (Inside) of Enrolled Followers
Tripura State Rifles
represented by its Chairman, having their Office at 11th BN, TSR,
Gokulnagar, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala.
5. The Chairman
The Recruitment Board (Inside) of Enrolled Followers, Tripura
State Rifles, having his office at 11th BN, TSR , Gokulnagar,
Bishalgarh, Sepahijala.
….. Respondent(s)
In W.P.(C) No.206 of 2025
Sri Sourav Majumder
Son of Sri Jiban Majumder, Presently residing at VillageKrishnanagar, P.O- Srinagar, P.S- Manubazar, District- South
Tripura, Tripura, PIN- 799143
….. Petitioner (s)
–Versus–
1. The State of Tripura
represented by the Secretary, Department of Home Affairs,
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.OKunjaban, P.S New Capital Complex, District - West Tripura.
2. The Department of Police
represented by its Director General of Police, Police
Headquarter, Fire Brigade Chowmuhani, Agartala, West
Tripura.
[17]
3. The Director General of Police Tripura
Police Head Quarters, Fire Brigade Chowmuhani, P.OAgartala, Tripura, West PIN – 799001
4. The Recruitment Board (Inside) of Enrolled Followers Tripura State
Rifles
represented by its Chairman, having their Office at 11th BN,
TSR, Gokulnagar, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala.
5. The Chairman
The Recruitment Board (Inside) of Enrolled Followers, Tripura
State Rifles, having his office at 11th BN, TSR , Gokulnagar,
Bishalgarh, Sepahijala.
….. Respondent(s)
In W.P.(C) No.536 of 2025
Sri Chiranjit Nath,
Son of Sri Jadu Gopal Nath, presently residing at villageDukhini Para, NCC Road, Dakshin Srinagar, P.O. Srinagar,
P.S. Manubazar, District- South Tripura, PIN-799143
….. Petitioner (s)
–Versus–
1. The State of Tripura
represented by the Secretary, Department of Home Affairs,
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O- Kunjaban,
P.S New Capital Complex, District - West Tripura.
2. The Department of Police
represented by its Director General of Police, Police
Headquarter, Fire Brigade Chowmuhani, Agartala, West
Tripura.
3. The Director General of Police Tripura
Police Head Quarters, Fire Brigade Chowmuhani, P.OAgartala, Tripura, West PIN – 799001
4.The Recruitment Board (Inside) of Enrolled Followers
Tripura State Rifles
represented by its Chairman, having their Office at 11th BN,
TSR, Gokulnagar, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala.
5. The Chairman
The Recruitment Board (Inside) of Enrolled Followers, Tripura
State Rifles, having his office at 11th BN, TSR , Gokulnagar,
Bishalgarh, Sepahijala.
….. Respondent(s)
[18]
For the petitioner(s)
: Mr. S. Deb, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Abir Baran, Adv.
Ms. R. Guha, Adv.
Mr. M. Debnath, Adv.
Mr. S. Bhowmik, Adv.
Ms. D. Chakraborty, Adv.
For the respondent(s)
: Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Advocate General
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. K. De, Addl. G.A.
Mr. R. Saha, Adv.
Ms. P. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of hearing
: 03.04.2026
Date of delivery of
judgment and order
: 22.05.2026
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
✔
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Common facts and issues being involved, all these writ
petitions were heard together and are being disposed of by this common
judgment.
[2]
An advertisement dated 07.03.2019 [Annexure-1 of W.P.(C)
196 of 2022] was issued by the Assistant Inspector General of Police(TSR)
for Director General of Police, Tripura for filling up of the posts of Riflemen
(GD) and Rifleman (Tradesmen), both for male and female, for raising of 2
IR Battalions for both „Inside State quota‟ and „Outside State quota‟. Inside
State quota is meant for the candidates who are residents of Tripura and
Outside State quota is meant for candidates other than the residents of
Tripura.
[3]
The number of vacancies to be filled through the said selection
process was 1013 against the post of Riflemen (GD) for inside State quota
and 337 for said post against outside State quota. The relevant portion of
[19]
said advertisement indicating the posts for reserved category of candidates
are as follows:
Number of vacancies of Riflemen (General Duty (Male &
Female) inside State quota:
Name of posts
Category wise vacancy position
Riflemen(General Duty)
SC
ST
UR
Total
Number of vacancies of Riflemen (General Duty)(Male &
Female) inside State quota:
Name of Posts
Riflemen (General Duty)
[4]
Vacancy against UR category
The main challenges of the writ petitioners are two-folds as
submitted by the learned counsel of the petitioners. Learned senior counsel,
Mr. Somik Deb and learned counsel, Ms. R. Guha for the petitioners first
raise the issue that 17% cap of reservation for the Scheduled Castes
candidates and 31% cap of reservation for the Scheduled Tribe candidates
were not scrupulously maintained in respect of the posts earmarked under
inside State quota, which violates the provisions of Section 4(1) of Tripura
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1991 (for shortthe Reservation Act). According to them, where against the total vacant
posts under the said quota as shown in the advertisement is 1013, 230
numbers of posts (22%) are kept reserved for SC candidates and 418 posts
(41%) are kept reserved for ST candidates, total of which comes to 63% or
so, and therefore, same has exceeded the upper limit of total 48% (17% for
SC candidates and 31% for ST candidates to the maximum extent) as
envisaged in Section 4 of the Reservation Act. These posts were created,
submits Mr. Deb, for 2 newly created battalions of TSR and therefore, the
rule of carry forward method cannot be applied here and moreover, the
respondents also did not claim that carry forward method was applied in this
[20]
selection process. Therefore, according to learned counsel, Section 4(1) of
the said Act of 1991 has been blatantly violated by the recruiting authority by
extending the benefit of reservation beyond the upper ceiling limit, which
ultimately has violated the Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
[5]
The next point, the learned senior counsel argues, is that
against Sl. No.4 in the said advertisement, a stipulation has been made that
the candidates those who are permanent residents of Tripura can only apply
for such post only through a particular centre/venue as stipulated in the
advertisement in the following manner:
VENUES FOR RECRUITMENT FROM INSIDE STATE(MALE & FEMALE)
Sl.No.
Venues
Regional
Institute,
Physical Education centre
Panisagar ground, North
District
Kulai School Ground,
Ambassa, Dhalai District
A.D. Nagar Police ground,
Agartala, West Tripura
K.B.I. Ground,
Gomati District.
Udaipur,
For candidates residing under jurisdiction of Police
Station
Dharmanagar, Churaibari, Damcherra, Khedacherra,
Kanchanpur, Kadamtala, Panisagr, Vangmun, Ananda
bazaar, Kailashahar, Kumarghat, Pecharthal, Fatikroy,
Irani PS.
Ambassa, Chawmanu, Dhumacherra, Gandacherra,
Ganganagar, Kamalpur, Kachucherra, Chailengta,
Manu, Nepal tilla, Raisyabari, Salema Manikpur
East Agt, West Agt Airport, Amtali, Bodhjang nagar,
Jirania, Lefunga, Mandai, Ranirbazar, Radhapur,
Sidhai, Srinagar, Bishalgarh, Bisramganj, Takarjala,
Khowai, Champahaour, Kalyanpur, Mungiakami,
Teliamura, Jampuijala, Madhupur , A.D.Nagar, New
Capital Complex.
Birganj, Korbook, Kakraban, Killa, Nutan Bazaar,
R.K.Pur, Taidu, Ompi, Belonia, Baikhora, Manubazar,
P.R.Bari, Sabroom, Silachari, Kalamcherra, Melaghar,
Jatrapur, Sonamura, Santirbazar.
”
[6]
According to learned senior counsel, Mr. Deb, imposing such
stipulation regarding centre/venue limiting a candidate of his choice in
respect of place of submission of his application form has curtailed his right
of choice to apply from any other place. According to learned senior
counsel, there are many candidates who for different purposes are residing
in different parts of state of Tripura and it is their right to apply from any such
place as per their own convenience and comfort and such rights cannot be
restricted in this way.
[21]
[7]
Regarding the first point of his challenge, learned senior
counsel also relies on a decision of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of
Indra Sawhney and Others vs. Union of India and Others; (1992) Supp.
(3) SCC 217, and relevant portion of paragraph no. 860, as relied on, is
extracted hereunder:
“860. For the sake of ready reference, we also record our
answers to questions as framed by the counsel for the parties
and set out in para 681. Our answers question-wise are:
(1) ………….
(2) …………..
(3) …………….
(4) The reservations contemplated in Clause (4)
of Article 16 should not exceed 50%. While 50%
shall be the rule, it is necessary not to put out of
consideration certain extraordinary situations
inherent in the great diversity of this country and
the people. It might happen that in far-flung and
remote areas the population inhabiting those
areas might, on account of their being out of the
main-stream of national life and in view of the
conditions peculiar to and characteristic of them
need to be treated in a different way, some
relaxation in this strict rule may become
imperative. In doing so, extreme caution is to be
exercised and a special case made out.
For applying this rule, the reservations should not
exceed 50% of the appointments in a grade, cadre
or service in any given year. Reservation can be
made in a service or category only when the State
is satisfied that representation of backward class
of citizens therein is not adequate.
To the extent, T. Devadasan vs. Union of India,
(1964) 4 SCR 680 is inconsistent herewith, it is
over-ruled.
(5) ………………….
(6) …………………….
(7) ………………………
(8) …………………………..”
[8]
Learned senior counsel also relies on another decision of
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of Tripurari Sharan and Another vs.
Ranjit Kumar Yadav and Others; (2018) 2 SCC 656, wherein at
[22]
paragraph no.11 also said principle regarding maximum cap was reiterated
in the following manner:
“11. This court has repeatedly, including the judgment in the
case of Indra Sawhney (supra), concluded that the
aggregate reservation should not exceed 50%.
Therefore,
even when a MRC opts for a seat reserved for reserved
category candidates, caution has to be exercised to maintain
the reservation to 50%. So also it is not open for the
authorities to deny a MRC a seat in the college of his
preference based on his merit, if such seat is available at the
relevant point of time and the same is reserved for candidates
of the reserved category to which the MRC belongs…...”
[9]
Learned senior counsel further relies on another Constitution
Bench decision of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of Dr. Jaishri
Laxmanrao Patil vs. Chief Minister and Others; (2021) 8 SCC 1 wherein
at Paragraph no.409, Hon‟ble Supreme Court observes that Judgment of
Indra Sawhney (supra) was being followed for more than a quarter century
without there being any doubt raised in any of the judgments about the 50%
cap and the said rule has been repeatedly followed. Further, in the
concluding part of the judgment, at paragraph No.688.1.1, it is observed
that reservation under Article 16(4) should not exceed 50% and at
paragraph No.688.1.2 it is further observed that for exceeding reservation
beyond 50%, extraordinary circumstances as indicated in para 810 of Indra
Sawhney (supra) should exist for which extreme caution is to be exercised.
At paragraph No. 688.9 it is again observed that the Constitution (Eightyfirst Amendment) Act, 2000 by which clause (4-B) was inserted in Article 16
makes it clear that ceiling of 50% “has now received constitutional
recognition”.
[10]
Learned senior counsel, Mr. Deb also relies on the decision of
this Court in the case of Kinkar Bhowmik vs. State of Tripura and Ors.,
WP(C) 264 of 2024 decided on 12.8.2025, wherein at Para No.23, the
following were observed:
[23]
“[23] On plain reading of sub-section(1) of Section 4 of the
said Act, it appears that reservation for the Scheduled Castes
and the Scheduled Tribes in any vacancy in services or posts
in an establishment (emphasis laid) which are to be filled up
by direct recruitment shall be regulated in the manner as
prescribed in the said provision and also as set out in the
schedule of the Act. Further Section 2(e) defines the word
„establishment‟ to be any office (emphasis laid), a local or
statutory authority constituted under the Constitution of India
or any other law for the time being in force or a Corporation in
which not less than fifty one percent of the paid-up share
capital is held by the State Government etc.”
Same principle was further followed by this Bench in its
Judgment dated 20.08.2025 in the case of Shri Abhijit Das vs. State of
Tripura and Ors., WP(C) No.77 of 2025.
[11]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel to give stress in the matter of
50% reservation to the maximum extent, also relies on a decision of the
High Court of Orissa in the case of Dr. Arabinda Panda & Ors. vs. State of
Odisha & Ors., WP(C) No.13778 of 2025, decided on 17.03.2026, wherein
the High Court found fault with an advertisement issued for filling up the
posts of Medical Officers and it was noticed by the High Court that the
number of vacancies kept reserved for SC & ST category of candidates
were in violation of Article 16(4-B) of the Constitution of India by exceeding
the maximum cap to be maintained for reserved category of candidates.
Ultimately, the High Court allowed the writ petition, and it was directed that
only 411 posts were advertised for the UR category, so from the reserved
category also maximum 411 number of candidates may be proportionately
absorbed, considering the serious crunch or dearth of Medical Officers.
[12]
Learned counsel, Ms. R. Guha, in addition to what Mr. Deb,
learned senior counsel has submitted and further taking note of excess
reservation for ST and SC category of candidates, submits that apart from
violation of Articles 14 and 16, such procedure, as adopted by the selection
[24]
committee, has also violated Article 19(1)(g) and Article 21 of the
Constitution.
[13]
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned Advocate General appearing for
the state-respondents, however, submits that the petitioners are trying to
create a division between the same category of posts, i.e., Riflemen (GD),
by creating and artificial differentiation of said post between „within-State
quota‟ category an „outside-State quota‟ category, though, according him,
both the categories are to be taken into consideration as a single unit and
as a common post of Riflemen (GD). Learned Advocate General, also
referring to sub-clauses No.2 & 3 of the advertisement, submits that the total
numbers of posts of Riflemen (General Duty) were 1350, out of which
against inside-State quota, there were total 1013 posts and against outsideState quota, there were 337 posts which were required to be filled up. If the
total vacant posts both under inside-State quota and outside-State quota
are taken into consideration as a single unit, it will be found that the total
number of posts of Riflemen (General Duty) (Male and Female) was 1350,
out of which 702 posts were kept for UR category, 229.5 say 230 (17%)
were kept for SC category and 418 (31%) posts were kept for ST category.
Therefore, there was no violation of Section 4 of the Reservation Act of
1991, by the recruiting authority.
[14]
Learned Advocate General further submits that the petitioners
participated throughout in the selection process and only at the viva-voce
stage, they were unsuccessful. When they participated in said process
without challenging the advertisement at that time, they cannot now raise
any question regarding said advertisement just because they could not
qualify themselves in the selection process.
[25]
[15]
Learned Advocate General also relies on a decision of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in case of R.K. Sabharwal & Ors. vs. State of
Punjab & Ors., (1995) 2 SCC 745, wherein, at paragraph No.6, it has been
explained by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court that „Vacancy‟ means an
unoccupied post or office and the plain meaning of the two expressions
makes it clear that there must be a „post‟ in existence to enable the
„vacancy‟ to occur. According to Learned Advocate General, there was only
one single identifiable post which was Riflemen (General Duty) which may
further be evident from clause No.8 of the advertisement which envisaged a
common test for selection of the said category of post. Therefore, the
related law of reservation was completely followed by the department while
issuing the advertisement and going for selection process of filling up said
post. Learned Advocate General further submits that already many persons
are selected and they have also joined the service and, therefore, reversal
or quashing of the entire selection process will have a disastrous effect in
their selection.
[16]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel in reply, submits that
exceeding maximum cap for reserved category candidates itself violates
Articles 14 & 16 of the Constitution which is a fundamental right of the
petitioners and, therefore, in case of such violation, the principle of estoppel
will not be applicable. Learned senior counsel on this point also relies on a
decision of the Honble Supreme Court (3 Judges Bench) in the case of Raj
Kumar & Ors. vs. Shakti Raj & Ors., (1997) 9 SCC 527, and in paragraph
No.16, the followings were observed by the Apex Court:
16. Yet another circumstance is that the Government had not
taken out the posts form the purview of the Board, but after
the examinations were conducted under the 1955 Rules and
after the results were announced, it exercised the power
[26]
under the proviso to para 6 of 1970 Notification and the posts
were taken out from the purview thereof. Thereafter the
Selection Committee was constituted for selection of the
candidates. The entire procedure is also obviously illegal. It is
true, as contended by Shri Madhava Reddy, that this Court in
Madan Lal v. State of J&K, (1995) 3 SCC 486, and other
decisions referred therein had held that a candidate having
taken a chance to appear in an interview and having remained
unsuccessful, cannot turn round and challenge either the
constitution of the Selection Board or the method of selection
as being illegal; he is estopped to question the correctness of
the selection. But in his case, the Government have
committed glaring illegalities in the procedure to get the
candidates for examination under the 1955 Rules, so also in
the method of selection and exercise of the power in taking
out from the purview of the Board and also conduct of the
selection in accordance with the Rules. Therefore, the
principle of estoppels by conduct or acquiescence has no
application to the facts in this case. Thus, we consider that
the procedure offered under the 1955 Rules adopted by the
Government or the Committee as well as the action taken by
the Government are not correct in law.
[17]
Learned senior counsel also submits that the Riflemen (General
Duty) (Male & Female) under inside-State quota and Riflemen (General
Duty) (Male & Female) under outside-State quota cannot be treated as a
single unit or single cadre inasmuch as the residents of Tripura cannot
contest for the said post from outside-state quota.
[18]
This Court has considered the submissions of both sides and
the materials placed by them. As per Tripura State Rifles Recruitment
Rules, 1984 there are mentions of several categories of post in Tripura
State Rifles, Inspector General being on the top and Enrolled Follower
being on the bottom of the rank. Riflemen, Naib Subedar, Havildar, Naik,
Lance Naik and Riflemen are shown as Non-Gazetted, Class-III post. The
recruitment procedure for the post of Riflemen is contained in Rule 25 of the
said rules and no separate division has been made therein in respect of the
recruitment against „Inside State quota‟ and „Outside State quota‟. Nothing
could be shown from that Rules that selected candidates under „Inside
State quota‟ and „Outside State‟ quota form different cadres or different
[27]
posts. It appears that the post of „Riflemen‟ is a common and a single cadre
though selection of candidates may be made either from the State or from
outside the State. It makes no difference as to where is the residence of the
candidates. Ultimately, after selection all the successful candidates are to
be appointed as Riflemen (GD). As per Rule 8 of the said Rules, the earlier
provision was that 75% of direct recruitment in all ranks shall be made from
within Tripura and the remaining 25% of such recruitment shall be made
from States and Union Territories outside Tripura. Said provision was
further amended vide Eighth Amendment Rules of 2010 envisaging that
85% of direct recruitment in all ranks shall be made from within Tripura and
the remaining 15% of such direct recruitment shall be made from States
and Union Territories outside Tripura.
[19]
When the advertisement was issued, two separate charts were
reflected therein, as indicated earlier, showing the number of vacancies of
the post of Riflemen GD [Male & Female] inside the State quota and the
number of vacancies of Riflemen GD [Male & Female] outside the State
quota. If both the charts are taken into consideration together, it is seen that
total vacancy for the post of Riflemen (GD) (Male & Female) as mentioned
therein is 1350 [1013+337]. Inside the State quota the recruitment authority
divided 1013 number of posts in vertical reservation for UR, SC & ST
category but the vacancy meant for outside State quota was only kept for
UR category candidates. Whether such provision for SC & ST category
candidates only against the vacancy of inside State quota is proper or not,
is not under challenged in these writ petitions and therefore, same does not
require any scrutiny. Now, what appears is that if only the vacancy position
as shown for inside State quota is taken into consideration, the submission
made from the side of the petitioners regarding violation of Section 4 of the
[28]
Act of, 1991 appears to be attractive, but if the vacancy position as shown
both for inside State quota and outside State quota are taken into
consideration together, it appears that out of total 1350 posts, 230 posts i.e.
17.3% were kept reserved for SC candidates. Similarly, 418 posts i.e.
30.96% (say 31%) were kept reserved for ST category of candidates. As
per Section 4(1) (a) of the Act of 1991, maximum 17% posts may be
reserved for SC candidates and 31% posts may be reserved for ST
candidates. Thus, if the vacancies meant for inside State quota and outside
State quota are taken into consideration together, Section 4 of the said Act
of 1991 appears to have been properly maintained by the Selection
Committee. For better appreciation, sub Section 1 of Section 4 of the said
Act of 1991 is also extracted hereunder:
“4. [(1) Reservation for the Scheduled Castes and the
Scheduled Tribes in any vacancy or vacancies in services or
posts in an establishment which are to be filled up by direct
recruitment] shall be regulated in the following manner,
namely –
[(a) There shall be seventeen percent reservation for the
Scheduled Castes and thirty one percent reservation for
the Scheduled Tribes in the manner as set out in the
schedule;] [Provided that the State Government may from
time to time review the implementation of the reservation
policy and take adequate measures including increase of
percentage mentioned in sub-section (a) above]
(b) The candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes
and the Scheduled Tribes who qualify for selection on
merit shall be included in the general list and not against
reserved quota;
(c) Fees, if any, prescribed for any examination for
selection to any service or post shall be reduced to onefourth in the case of candidates belonging to the
Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes;
(d) The members of the Scheduled Castes and the
Scheduled Tribes shall be entitled to a concession of five
years over the prescribed maximum age limit for
appointment to any service or post. [and also for
admission to educational institutions and undergoing any
kind of training]”
(emphasis underscored)
[20]
Sub section 1 of Section 4 of Act of 1991 as reproduced
hereinabove clearly envisages that such percentage of reservation for SC &
ST candidates are to be determined in respect of any vacancy or vacancies
[29]
in any service or post in any establishment. Therefore, such quota for
reserved category of candidates is to be counted against the total vacancy
of a particular post or service and not by making any further division in
respect of any particular post by referring to inside State quota and outside
State quota. Thus, according to this Court, no illegality or error is found
committed by the recruiting authority in respect of computing of vacancies
meant for reserved category candidates. Therefore, the challenge as made
by the petitioners about alleged exceeding of maximum cap of 17% and
31% in the said advertisement against the post of Riflemen (GD) (Male &
Female) is, therefore, not sustainable.
[21]
In W.P.(C) No.250 of 2022 and some other writ petitions such
as W.P.(C) 92 of 2025, W.P.(C) 206 of 2025 and W.P.(C) 536 of 2025,
another plea is also taken by the petitioners that in the final merit list, 54
numbers of reserved category candidates were recommended illegally
against UR category but such challenge is also not sustainable in view of
provision of Clause (b) of sub Section 1 of Section 4 of the said Reservation
Act of 1991 as cited earlier. Though it was also argued by Mr. Deb, learned
senior counsel that specifying of venue for candidates of a particular area
was illegal on the ground that the right of choice to apply from any other
venue by a candidate, was curtailed, but such contention is also not
acceptable inasmuch as it is for the selection committee to devise their own
procedure for determining the venue for collection of application and also
for holding examination or test for a group or a class of candidates as per
their own convenience and a candidate cannot grieve for that. Moreover,
already the petitioners filed their applications through the respected venue
as specified by the recruiting authority and participated in the selection
process, therefore, they are also estopped from challenging the same now.
[30]
[22]
Considering all theses aspects, this Court finds no merit in
these writ petitions. Accordingly, the same are dismissed.
No order as to costs.
Interim application(s), if any, also stands disposed of
accordingly.
JUDGE
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2026.05.25 14:57:16 +05'30'
Sujay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review