Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3s00 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO: 16547 OF 2025
Between:
Sri.A.Rajender, S/o.Rajaiah, Aged about 40 years, Occ; Business,
R/o.H.No.1 -1-249, Weekly Bazar, Jagtiyal,Karimnagar District, Telangana
State-S05451
Sri.M.Dayanandam, S/o.Narsaiah, Aged about 39 years, Occ ; Business,
R/o.H.No.4-1-13012, Vani Nagar, Jagtiyal,Karimnagar District, Telangana
State-505451.
.....PETITIONERS
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Transport
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad, Telangana State
2. Telangana State Road Transport Corporation, Rep by its Vice Chairman, Bus
Bhavan, Musheerabad, Hyderabad.
3. Telangana State Road Transport Corporation, Rep by its [Vlanaging
Director,Bus Bhavan, [Vusheerabad, Hyderabad.
4. Executive Director (REV. and lT) and Secretary to Corporation, Bus
Bhavan,OPD (Mktg. and Corn)wing, Musheerabad, Hyderabad.
5. The Divisional N4anager, TGRTC, Karimnagar Division, Karimnagar District,
Telangana State-505 001 .
6. The Regional Manager, TGRTC, Karimnagar Region, Karimnagar
District,Telangana State-505 001 .
7. The Depot fi/anager, TGRTC, Jagtiyal Bus Station, Karimnagar District,
Telangana State-505 001.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of
writ of mandamLls declaring the action of the 6th Respondent issued proceedings
Nos. 011122(4)/201 5-JGTL and 01t122(5)/201 5-JGTL, dated. 03.03. 2o2s
enclosed Calculation sheet from 23-09-2023 to 3'1 -O1-2025 is contrary to the
Advocate-Comrnissioners Report dated. 06.02.2024 also the Hon'ble Court
passed commcn order dated. 21.10.2024. in w.p.No.330g7 of 2023 and
W.P.No.19737 <tf 2024 is highly unwarranted, highly arbitrary, unfair, unjust,
irrational, unlaMul and against the Principles of Natural Justice and consequenly
set aside the sarne.
|.A.NO:1 OF 202[
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filecl in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant interim s,uspension of Proceedings Nos. 011122(4)/201 s-JGTL and
011122(5) 12015-JGTL, dated. 03.03. 2025 enclosed Calculation sheet from 2309-2023 to 31-01 -2025 pending disposal of the main writ petition.
|.A.NO:2 OF 202ti
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant inteiim sta'/ of all further proceedings in respect of Shops/Stalls No.16,17
and 18 of Jagitial Bus station pending disposal of the main writ petition.
Counsel for the lretitioners : MISS. VLADIMEER KHATOON
Counsel for the flespondent No.l : Gp FOR TRANSPORT
counsel for the Flespondent Nos.2 to I : sRl N.CHANDRA SHEKAR
The Court made rlhe following ORDER
i
!
I
I
/--t
?f
IIT THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAI(A
WRIT PETITION No. I 65,47 0F 20.25,
o,9.aL.20.26
EI!
A.Rajender & another
..... Petitioners
And
The State of Telangana,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Transport Department,
& others.
Respondents
ORDER:
This Writ Petition is filed aggrieved by the action of
Respondent No.6 in issuing proceedings dated 02.06.2025,
whereby the request of Petitioners for exemption from payment
of license fee and encroached portion rents for the period from
23.09.2023 till restoration of possession of DOT Shop Nos. 16,
17 and 18 at Jagitial Bus Station was rejected, and Petitioners
were directed to pay license fee and encroachment charges from
O2.O9.2O21 till restoration of possession. Petitioners atrso assail
the consequential action of Respondents in proceeding with E-
Tender Notification dated 11.O4.2O25 and letter dated
14.05 2025, despite pendency of representations and subsisting
orders of this Court, alleging that the impugned proceedings are
arbitraly, contrary to the Advocate Commissioner,s report
06-02.2024, viorative of the common order dated
passed in writ petitions No. 3309T of 2023
dated
2r.r0.2o24
and 19732 of 2024,
and in trreach of the principles o[ naturaljustice.
2-
Petitioners state that petitioner No. t is ricensees
of
Dor sh':p Nos. 16 and 1T and, petitioner No.2 is the ricensee
of
Dor Sh,rp No. 1g situated within the premises of Jagtiyal Bus
station- It is stated, the Respondent corporation, with
utilise vzrcant land available in Jagtial Bus Station,
a view to
invited bids
from int':ndipg business persons under the Deposit,
operate
and Tra'sfer (Dor) scheme for construction and operation
of
shops and stalrs within the bus station premises. pursuant
to
the said Notification, petitioners submitted bids for the
above
Dpr Shocs, offering to pay a monthry license fee o[ Rs.5,00o/-
per shop' and a non-refundabre deposit of Rs.2,40,0 oo
towards r:onstruction and allotment of the said
shops. The
corporation accepted the bids submitted by petitioners
communic:ated the acceptance uid"eretters dated
/-
and
0g.o1.2o15, on
receipt ol' which, Petitioners deposited the non-refundable
amount ol'Rs.2,4o,ooo/-. A ricense was thereafter,
granted in
favour of Petitioners for a fixed period of twenty
(2o) years
commenci,g from og.o2.2o1s and ending
specific stipulation that upon expiry of
""
on og.02.203s, with a
the ricense period, they
J
/1
tY
should vacate and hand over possession of the shops to the
Corporation and that no extension of license period would be
permitted beyond the said term.
2.1.
It is contended, after several years of uninterrupted
operation of the shops, Respondent No.S issued Notice-Il dated
15.Og.2021 alleging that Petitioners encroached upon additional
area measuring 232.75 square feet, 23L.16 square feet and
23L.t6 square feet respectively in front of the allotted shops,
purportedly based on the inspection report dated 31.08.2O2I.It
is the specific case of Petitioners that the said inspection report
was never furnished to them, despite repeated demands,
thereby depriving them of an opportunity to verify or contest the
alleged measurements. Subsequent notices dated O5.O7.2022'
2*,11.2022, 06.01.2023 and 05.06.2023 reiterated the very
same allegations of encroachment without supplying any
supporting material or report. It is stated, the Regional Tender
Committee convened a meeting on 22.06.2022 in connection
with the alleged encroachment, during the course of which,
Petitioners, without admitting the allegations, expressed their
willingness to pay additional license fee of Rs.2,OOO/- in respect
of the alleged encroached area in order to resolve the matter
amicably. However, the said offer was not accepted by the
Regional Tender Committee. Thereafter, by notices dated
25.Lr.rl,o22 and 06.01 .2023, the corporation demanded
monthly amounts of Rs.2S,32tl_, Rs.25,2 16/_ and Rs.20,7g3/_
respectively with effect from o2.og.2o2l towards license fee and
charges, for utitisation of additional space, coupled with a
threat
of terrrrination of the license and forfeiture of the security
deposit in the event of non-payment.
2.2.
Petitioners contend that the Regional Tender
committee lacked jurisdiction to unilaterally determine disputes
relating to terms and conditions of the license or to impose
additional financiat liability. According to them, clause 32 of the
License Agreement specifically provides that any dispute
arising
out of t,:rms and conditions of the license shall be decided by
the Managing Director of the corporation and that the decision
of the lVlanaging Director alone would be final and binding on
the parries. Petitioners further contend that similar notices
alleging encroachment were issued to all 21 Dor shops located
in Jagirjal Bus station, demonstrating arbitrariness and
mechanical action on the part of the Respondents. Aggrieved
by
the shovr cause notice dated 21.or.2023, petitioners f,rled writ
Petition l,lo. 2o696 of 2023, wherein, by order dated o3.og.2o23,
directed them to submit expranation within two weeks and
directed the Regionar Manager to consider the same
affording.b{€asonable opportunity of hearing, whire
after
restraining
2-r
l1\.,
Respondents from taking any coercive steps till completion of
the said exercise. It is stated, due to oversight, they failed to
submit explanation within the time stipulated. Consequently,
Respondent No.6 issued a'f-rnal order terminating the license of
Petitioners uid"e proceedings dated 19.09.2023. Immediately
thereafter, Petitioners submitted the representation dated
21.O9.2023 requesting reconsideration of termination. Despite
the same, Respondents closed the DOT shops on 23.09.2023 by
removing Petitioners' belongings and locking the premises.
Petitioners challenged the termination order in Writ
2.3.
petition No. 27244 of 2023 which was disposed of on
18.LO.2023, directing Respondents to
consider the
representation dated 21.O9.2023 and pass appropriate orders.
Pursuant thereto, proceedings dated 23.L1-2023 were issued.
According to Petitioners, the said proceedings failed to properly
consider their explanation and did not assign cogent reasons for
rejecting their contentions. They thereafter filed Writ Petition
No. 33097 0f 2023 wherein, an Advocate commissioner was
appointed to conduct local inspection of subject Shops who
submitted the report dated 06.02.2024 stating that the actual
encroachment, if any, was only to an extent of 5.95 square feet
in respect of Shop Nos.16 and 18 and 63.7 square feet in
respect of Shop No.17, which was substantially lesser than the
I
I
I
extent alleged in the earlier notices. It is specifically stated
that
no objr:ctions were filed by Respondents to the said report.
while the said writ petition was reserved for orders,
Respondents issued E-Tender Notification dated og.or.2024
re-allotment of the subject shops which was chailenged
for
in writ
Petition No-19737 of 2024. Both the writ petitions were
ultimat:ly disposed of by a common order dated 2L.Lo.2o24,
directing Petitioners to pay charges for the encroached
as per r-he rules in force and directing Respondents
portion
to consider
leasing of the shops thereafter
2.4-
petitioners state that despite
submitting
represe:rtations dated 01.1 1 .2024 and lo.o2.2o2s
seeking
implem,:ntation of the directions issued by this
court,
(esponrlent No.7 issued proceedings dated
03.03.2o25
calculating dues for the period from O2.Og.2O2l to
22.Og.2O23
but enctosed a carculation sheet reflecting outstanding
amounts
up to {}1.oL-2o2s. They submitted a detailed representation
dated o'7.o3.2025 specifically stating that they were
not liable to
pay an'/ charges for the period from 23.og.2o23
onwards,
during which the shops remained crosed. while the
said
represerrtation was pending consideration, Respondents
issued
fresh E'Tender Notification dated LL.o4.2o25 foilowed
by the
letter derted L4-os.2025 seeking implementation
of the tender-
G
Petitioners submitted another representation dated 17.O5.2O25
agreeing to pay the encroachment charges excluding the closed
period and requesting de-notification of the tender. Thereafter,
they liled Writ Petition No.15200 of 2025, wherein this Court, by
order dated 2L.O5.2O25, directed that tender process shall be
subject to the outcome of the Writ Petition. Despite subsistence
of the said order, Respondent No.6 issued the impugned
proceedings dated 02.06.2025 which necessitated {iling of the
present Writ Petition.
3.
By order dated 2L.O5.2O25, while issuing notice
before admission, this Court directed that tenders in respect of
subject stalls pursuant to the impugned e-tender notification
dated L1.o4.2o25 shall be subject to the outcome of the writ
Petition.
4.
Respondent Corporation filed counter-aflidavit
stating that Petitioners have repeatedly violated the terms and
conditions of the License Agreement, therefore, are not entitled
to invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution. Petitioners were allotted subject
shops; at the time of initial allotment, monthly license fee was
fixed at Rs.5,O00/- per shop; however, Respondents
categorically deny the contention of Petitioners that license fee
remained Rs.5,OOO/- throughout the license period. tt is
specificzrlly contended that Petitioners have deliberately
suppressed material facts relating to enhancement of license
fee. In 2017, Petitioners themselves approached the Corporation
seeking permission to change the nature of business carried on
in the allotted shops. Upon due consideration, the competent
authori'y permitted such change of business and approved
enhanc,:ment of license fee. In respect of DOT Shop Nos. 16
and 17, nature of business rfiras changed from 'Kirana and
Genera. Store' to 'Food Court & Snacks with Non-Veg Items'.
Pursuart thereto, an additional license fee of Rs.4,1OO/- was
levied, and the total monthly license fee was revised to
Rs.9,1C'0/- with effect from 15.02.2017. In respect of DOT Shop
No.18, Petitioner No.2 changed the nature of business from
Ueans Corner' to 'Super Market', and the license fee was
enhanced by Rs.2,SOOl-, making the total monthly license fee
Rs.7,500/- with effect from O l.06.20 17. Petitioners accepted the
revised license fees and paid the same regularly without any
protest or objection, therefore, the plea of Petitioners that
license fee continued to be Rs.S,0OO/- per month is false and
intendt:d to mislead this Court.
4-L.
Respondents further state that during inspections
in 2021, it was noticed that petitioners had unauthorisedly
encroached upon additional area beyond the allotted shop
{
:
I
I
I
I
tr
premises, which constituted government property within the
bus station. Accordingly, notices were issued, despite the same,
Petitioners neither vacated the encroached portion nor complied
with the payment demands. Consequently, a show cause notice
dated 21.07.2023 was issued, granting an opportunity to
submit explanation. The Petitioners challenged the said show
cause notice by filing writ Petition No. 20696 of 2023. This
Court, by order dated O3.O8.2O23, directed them to submit
explanation within two weeks. Since Petitioners failed to comply
with the said directions license was validly terminated by final
order dated lg.Og.2023. Even thereafter, Petitioners continued
to assert possessory rights over the subject shops and preVented
Corporation from taking physical possession or proceeding with
re-allotment by filing successive writ petitions. Due to pendency
of the said writ petitions, the corporation was effectively
restrained from exercising its rights as lessor and from issuing
fresh tender notifications in respect of the subject shops.
4.2.
It is therefore, contended that Respondents were
justified in calculating arrears and differential license fee up to
31.01.2025, as Petitioners themselves prevented re-allotment
and continued to assert rights over public properry. No benefit
or income accrued to the Corporation during this period, as the
stalls remained locked due to the ongoing litigation initiated by
:
l0
I
Petitioners. Respondents place reliance on the Advocate
Commisisioner's report dated 06.02.2024, which quantified the
encroached area as 5.95 square feet in respect of DOT Shop
Nos. 16 and 18 and 63.7 square feet in respect of DOT Shop
No.17. it is asserted that Petitioners never challenged the said
report rrnd, therefore, findings regarding encroachment have
attainecl finality.
4.g.
It is further submitted that calculation of
encroachment charges was carried out in a transparent and
standardised manner, strictly in accordance with the norms
adopteci b), the Corporation. The formula adopted involved
derivinE; the rate per square foot by dividing the applicable
monthhr license fee by the allotted area and multiplying the
same vrith the extent of encroached area confirmed during
inspection and as per the Advocate Commissioner's report. The
said method ensures proportionality and uniformity and cannot
be terrred arbitrary or illegal. Respondents contend that
proceedings dated O3-O3.2O25 were issued in compliance with
the corrLmon order dated 21.1O.2024 passed by this Court, and
that thr: subsequent proceedings dated 02.06.2025 were issued
after aflording personal hearing to Petitioners on 24.05.2025.
The all:gation that the impugned proceedings were passed
without opportunity of hearing is denied. Respondents further
ll
r\
state that representations dated O7.O3.2O25 and 17.05.2025
submitted by Petitioners were considered but rejected as
untenable, as they sought exemption from payment for a period
during which they continued to assert possessory rights.
4.4.
It is finally contended that Petitioners are habitual
defaulters and they approached this Court with unclean hands
by suppressing material facts; they repeatedly failed to comply
with contractual obligations and judicial directions. Therefore,
Petitioners are not entitled to any equitable relief and the Writ
Petition is liable to be dismissed with costs.
5.
Heard Ms. Vladimeer Khatoon, learned counsel for
petitioners and Sri N. Chandra Shaker, learned Standing
Counsel for the Corporation.
6. .
At the outset, it is not in dispute that Petitioners
were granted license in respect of DOT Shop Nos. 16, 17 and 18
situated at Jagitial Bus Station for a fixed period of twent$ years
commencing from O9.O2.2O15 and ending on 08.O2.2035. It is
also an admitted position that pursuant to acceptance of their
bids, Petitioners deposited. a non-refundable amount of
Rs.2,4O,OOOl- and entered into a license arrangement governed
by the terms and conditions. These foundational facts are not in
controversy between the Parties
t
t2
i,
7.
The dispute essentially emanates from allegations of
encroachment of additional area beyond the allotted shop
premises and the consequential financial demands raised by the
Respon<lents on that basis. The record discloses that such
allegaticns led to a series of notices, representations,
termina-ion proceedings, and multiple rounds of litigation
before t.ris court. tt is evident from the record that on earlier
occasior s, this court directed Respondents to consider the
explanalions and representations submitted by petitioners in
accordance with law and restrained Respondents from initiating
coercive action pending such consideration. In the course of
writ Per-ition No. 33ogr of 2023, this court, in order to
objectively ascertain the extent of alleged encroachment,
appointed an Advocate commissioner to conduct a local
inspection of Dor Shops who submitted the report dated
06.02.2024, wherein the extent of encroachment was quantified
as 5.95 siquare feet each in respect of Shop Nos.16 and 1g and
63-7 sqLrare feet in respect of Shop No.17. The said report
demonstu'ated that the extent of encroachment was
substant.ally lesser than what was originally alleged by the
Respondt:nts in the earlier notices. It is significant to note that
no object ons were filed by the Respondents to the said report.
s'
l3
i\
8.
Taking into consideration the
Advocate
Commissioner's report and the submissions of both the sides,
this Court disposed of Writ Petition Nos. 33097 of 2OQ3 and
L9737 of 2024 by a common order dated 21.10.2024 directing
Petitioners to pay charges for the encroached portion as per the
rules in force and further directed Respondents to consifler the
Petitioners' representation for leasing of the shops thereafter.
The said order attained finality and continues to bind the
parties. Pursuant to the said directions, Respondent No.7
issued proceedings dated 03.03.2025, wherein charges were
calculated for the period from O2.Og.2021 to 22.Og.2023
towards unauthorised utilisation of additional space. Hqwever,
the calculation sheet enclosed to the said proceedings reflected
outstanding amounts up to 31.OL.2O25, including the period
during which the DOT shops were admittedly closed by
Respondents from 23.Og.2A23 onwards. Aggrieved thereby, the
Petitioners submitted a detailed representation dated
07.O3.2O25 specifically raising an objection tJ:at they could not
be fastened with Iinancial liability for the period from
23.O9.2023 onwards, during which they were dispossessed and
the shops remained closed.
9.
The stand of petitioner is the said representation
.-:
dated 07 -O3.2O25 was not conside/red by the Corporation,
,t.(^
howeve::, the latter proceeded to issue e-tender notification
dated LL.O4.2O25 and a consequential letter dated 14.05.2025.
Challenging the same, Petitioners filed Writ Petition No. 1S2OO
of 2025. By order dated 21.05.2025, this Court directed that
any tender process in respect of DOT Shop Nos. 16, L7 and i8
pursuarrt to the dated L1.O4.2O25 shall be subject to the
outcomr: of the Writ Petition.
10.
However, it is to be seen from the counter of the
Corporation that the impugned proceedings dated 03.03.2025
were issued in strict compliance with the directions of this
Court and based on the Advocate-Commissioners' report and
inclusion of the period 23.09.2023 to 31.01.2025 in the
calculation sheet is justified as petitioners had not surrendered
\t
possessLon and the encroached space remained occupied. It is
also stated, petitioners subsequent representations dated
07.03.21)25 and 17.05.2025 were not acceptable since they
sought to exclude the period for which they were tiable for
paymen[ as per Court directions and the further proceedings
dated 0'.2.06.2025 were issued after providing personal hearing
to petitioners on 24.o5.2025, hence the allegation of violation of
principlt:s of natural justice is denied
1.
From the above and from the conduct of petitioners
in approaching this court, as stated earlier, this court finds
I
I
some force in the contention of the Corporation that petitioners
are habitual defaulters and they approached this court with
unclean hands by suppressing material facts and they failed to
comply with contractual obligations and judicial"directions. This
court therefore, is of the opinion that respondent - corporation
acted lawfully and in public interest to prevent unauthorised
occupation of public property. The Writ petition, in the
circumstances, is liable to be dismissed.
$
12.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is dismissed. No
costs.
13.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
SD/- C. DEEP
SISTANT
//TRUE COPY/
\
SECTION OFFICER
To
1. Two CCs to GP FOR TRANSPORT, High Court fo
Hyderabad. [OUT]
2. One CC to t\tllSS. VLAD IMEER KHATOON, Advocate
3. One CC to SRI N.CHANDRA SHEKAR, Advocate (O
4. Two CD Copies
SA
GJP
of Telangana at
PUCI
I
HIGH COURT
DATED:09/0112026
t
o
t
t Jrtt 2026 ii:
)';
SE;'.r{ _,1 1. - .2,
ORDER
WP.No.16547 of 2025
DISMISSING THE W. n
WITHOU]r COSTS.
bh
.'/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review