Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
t 3300I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
wRr T PETITION NO: 15200 OF 2025
Between:
1. Sri.A.Rajender, S/o.Rajaiah, Aged about 40 years, Occ; €usiness,
R/o.H.No.'l-1-249,Weekly Bazar, Jagliyal,Karimnagar District, Telangana
State-505451.
2. Sri.M.Dayanandam, S/o.Narsaiah, Aged about 39 yeals, Occ ;Business,
Fyo.H.No.4-1-13Ol2,Yani Nagar, Jagtiyal,Karimnagar District, Telangana
State-505451.
...,.PETITIONERS
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Transport
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad, Telangana State.
2. Telangana State Road Transport Corporation, Rep by its Vice Chairman, Bus
Bhavan, Musheerabad, Hyderabad.
3. Telangana State Road Transport Corporation, Rep by its Managing
Director,Bus Bhavan, Musheerabad, Hyderabad.
4. Executive Director, (REV. and lT) and Secretary to Corporation, Bus
Bhavan,OPD (Mktg. and Corn)wing, Musheerabad, Hyderabad.
5. The Divisional lVlanager, TGRTC, Karimnagar Division, Karimnagar District,
Telangana State-505 00'l .
6. The Regional Manager, TGRTC,Karimnagar Region, Karimnagar
Diskict,Telangana State-So5 001 .
7. The Depot Manager, TGRTC, Jagtiyal Bus Station, Karimnagar District,
Telangana State-505 001.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may {e
pleased to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of
writ of mandamlts declaring the action of the 6th Respondent issued a Letter
dated.14losl202li to
implement the E-Tender Notification
No.E5/437(02)l2D2.RIV.KR,dated.11.O4.2025 is highly, unwarranted, highly
arbitrary, unfair, unjust, irrational, unlawful and against the Principles of Natural
Justice and consequently set aside the same.
l.A.NO:1OF 2025
Petition Urder Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filetl in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant interim suspension of Letter dated.14.05.2025 to implement the E-Tender
Notification No.E:S/ 437(02) I 202.RIV.KR,dated. 11.04.2025 pending disposal of
the main writ pe':ition.
I.A.NO:2 OF 20?5
Petition Lnder Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the Respondents No.6 85 7 to consider the representation date.17.O5.2O2S
pending disposzrl of the main writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioners : MISS VLADIMEER KHATOON
Counsel for the, Respondent No.1 : GP FOR TRANSPORT
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 to 7 : SRI N.CHANDRA SHEKAR
The Court made the following ORDER
t
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT
No. 152OO or'2025
o,9.oL.20/26
Between:
A.Rajender & another
Petitioners
And
The State of Telangana,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Transport Department,
& others.
... .. Respondents
ORD ER:
This writ Petition is fited aggrieved by the action of
the 6fr Respondent in issuing Letter dated 14.05.2025 seeking
to implement e-Tender Notification dated 11.04.2025 in respect
of DOT Shops/Stalls No 16, 17 and 18 situated in Jagtiyal Bus
Station, Karimnagar District, despite subsistence of a valid and
unexpired Deed of License granted in favour of Petitioners for a
fixed period of twenty years and despite pendency and
culmination of earlier rounds of litigation between the same
parties concerning the very same subject matter. Petitioners
seek a writ of mand.amus declaring the said action as illegal,
arbitrary, unjust, violative of the principles of natural justice
and contrary to the terms of the Deed of License,
and for
consequential reliefs.
2'
petitioners state that petitioner
No.
individual engaged in lawful commercial activity
successf,l licensee under the Deposit, operate
Petitione. No-2 is similarly praced and jointry
and is the
and rransfer
(Dor) Scheme in respect of shops/Stalls No.16,
situated at Jagtiyal Bus Station, Karimnagar
i is an
1,T and 1g
District, and
holds the said
license along with petitioner No.l.
2'l-
It is stated that corporation, in furtherance of its
statutory functions, invited bids for construction
and operation
of shops/stalls in the vacant rand availabre at Jagtiyal
station under the Deposit, operate and Transfer (Dor)
by. collec'-ing non-refundable deposits
Bus
scheme,
from intending business
persons ztnd stipulating payment of a fixed
monthly license fee,
subject t,r the terms and conditions contained
License. ?ursuant to the said notification,
in the Deed of
they submitted bids
for DOT lihops/Stalls No. L6, 17 and 1g located
at Jagtiyal Bus
Station, .ffering to pay a monthly license fee of
Rs.S,0OO/_ per
stall in addition to a non-refundabre deposit of
Rs.2,40,ooo/-.
The said offer was accepted and communicated
vide lette':s dated 0g.o1.20rs. pursuant
to petitioners
to the said acceptance,
l
d
petitioners deposited Rs.2,40,OOO/ - towards non'refundable
deposit, which, as per the terms of the scheme, does not carry
any interest.
2.2.
It is further stated that a Deed of License was
thereafter executed in favour of Petitioners granting them
license to construct, operate and conduct business in the said
DOT Shops/Stalls for a fixed and non-extendable period of
twenty (2Ol years commencing from o9.o2.2o15 and ending on
O8.O2.2O35. The Deed of License specifically stipulates that
upon expiry of the said license period, the Petitioners shall
vacate the shops and hand over vacant possession to the
Respondent Corporation and that no extension of the license
period shatl be granted beyond the stipulated term.
2.3.
Petitioners state that while they were carrying on
their business strictly in accordance with the terms of the Deed
of License, the 5th Respondent issued Notice-ll dated
15.Og.2O21 alleging that a committee comprising the 6th
Respondent, the Deputy Executive Engineer (C), Karimnagar
and the Assistant Manager (Traffic), Jagtiyal, had inspected
stalls and found that Petitioners had allegedly encroached
additional areas measuring 232.75 sq.ft, 231.16 sq.ft and
23L.16 sq.ft respectively. Petitioners specifically contended that
l
i
lnspectio' report dated 3r.0g.2o21, which formed the basis
the said notice, \rras never furnished to them. The said
of
notice
directed Petitioners to vacate the alleged encroached
area
forthwith or to pay additional license fee, failing which
terminati,:n of license and forfeiture of the non-refundabre
deposit was threatened.
2-4-
It is stated that thereafter, another notice dated
o5.o7.20'.12 was issued reiterating the very same
allegations.
The Regional Tender committee convened a meeting
22-06-20'.12 and held negotiations with petitioners
in relation to
the alieg':d encroachment, during the course of which,
expresse(l readiness / willingness to pay additional
on
they
license fee of
Rs.2,ooo,t- for the alleged additional area, without prejudice
their con:ention that there was no encroachment. However,
to
the
said proposal was not accepted by the Regional Tender
committr:e. Petitioners further state that notices
dated
25.1L.2o'22 :rnd 06.0r.2o23 were issued alleging
vioration of
Item No 2 of the Deed of License, stating that Tender
committt:e, Karimnagar had decided to collect
enhanced
monthly ,rmounts of Rs.25,32I/_, Rs.25,216/_
and Rs.2O,7g3/_
respectivt:ly from 02.09.2021 towards license
fee and charges
for utlliztttion of the aileged additionar
space. petitioners were
r)
,o
called upon to pay the said amounts along with arrears within
fifteen days from the date of receipt of the notice, failing which
termination of license and forfeiture of deposit was threatened.
A further notice dated 05.06.2023 reiterating the same demands
was also issued.
It is stated that a show cause notice dated
2.5.
21.07.2023 was thereafter issued, making reference to all the
earlier notices dated I5.O9.2O2L, O5.O7 -2022, 25.11.2022,
06.01 .2023 and. 05.06.2023, and calling upon Petitioners to
submit their explanation within seven days. It is asserted, from
the inception of license, there was no encroachment whatsoever
in front of DOT Shops/Stalls No.16 and 17 and that the front
tin roof provided for shelter does not amount to encroachment.
Regional Tender Committee has no authority or jurisdiction to
alter or re-determine the terms and conditions of the Deed of
License and that in terms of Clause 32 of the Deed of License,
any dispute arising out of the terms and conditions of the
license can only be decided by the Managing Director of
APSRTC/TSRTC, whose decision alone is final and binding on
the parties. It is also stated, there are twenty-one (2ll DOT
Shops/Stalls in Jagtiyal Bus Station and that similar notices
were issued to all such stall holders.
r^-
.\\\
.. i.
d
2.6.
Aggrieved by the show cause notice dated
21.O7.2O23, Petitioners filed Writ Petition No. 20696 of 2023. By
order datr:d 03.O8.2023, this Court declined to quash the show
cause notice but directed Petitioners to submit their explanation
within tu'o weeks from the date of receipt of the order and
further drrected the Regional Manager, Karimnagar to consider
the explanation, afford reasonable opportunity of hearing and
pass appropriate orders within four weeks, while restraining the
Respondr:nts flrom initiating any coercive steps in the
interregnum. Petitioners however, due to oversight, could not
submit r:xplanation within the time stipulated. Thereafter, the
6th Respondent issued Final Order dated 19.O9.2023
terminating the license granted in favour of Petitioners;
irhmediately thereafter, Petitioners submitted representation
dated t.L.O9.2023 requesting permission to submit their
explanar-ion and seeking reconsideration of the matter. However,
the DO'l Shops/Stalls were closed by the Respondents from
23.O9-2r)23 onwards.
2.7.
Petitioners thereafter, fiIed Writ Petition No. 27244
of 2023' seeking a direction to Respondents to consider their
representation dated 21.09.2023. The said Writ Petition was
disposed of by this Court on 18.10.2023 directing the 6th
r)
,o
Respondent to consider the representation and pass appropriate
orders in accordance with law. Pursuant thereto, proceedings
dated 23.11.2023 were issued by the 6th Respondent, which
according to Petitioners did not properly consider their
explanation and failed to assign cogent or sustainable reasons.
Aggrieved thereby, Petitioners challenged the said proceedings
in Writ Petition No.33097 of 2023. Pursuant to directions of this
Court, an Advocate Commissioner was appointed to conduct
local inspection of DOT Shops/Stalls No.16, 17 and 18. The
Advocate Commissioner submitted the report stating that
alleged encroachment was only 5.95 sq.ft in respect of DOT
Shops/Stalls No.16 and 18 and 63.7 sq.ft in respect of DOT
Stall No.17, which is wholly contrary to the alleged
eneroachment of 232.75 sq.ft and 231.16 sq.ft mentioned in the
show cause notice dated 21.07.2023 and earlier notices.
2.8.
While Writ Petition No. 33097 of 2023 was pending
adjudication before this Court, Respondents issued e-Tender
Notification dated 08.O7.2024 calling for fresh bids in respect of
the very same shops. Petitioners immediately submitted
representation dated 18.07.2024 bringing to the notice of
Respondents that subject matter was pending before this Court
and thereafter, fited Writ Petition No.19737 of 2024 challenging
the said ,:-Tender Notification.
By a common order dated
21.10.2024 in Writ Petitions No. 33O97 of 2023 and 19737 of
2024, this Court directed Petitioners to pay the requisite
charges as per the rules in force for the encroached portion as
indicaterl in the Advocate commissioner's report and further
directed that upon such payment, Respondent corporation shall
consider leasing the shops in favour of the petitioners.
2.9.
Petitioners state that in compliance vyith the said
directiorrs, they submitted representations dated 01. 1 1 .2024
and 1o.o2.2025. However, Respondent corporation issued
proceed'ngs dated 03.03.2025 demanding payment for the
period liom O2.O9.2O21 to 3L.OL.2O2S, including the period
during which the shops were admittedly closed by the
Respon<lents from 23.o9.2023 onwards. petitioners submitted a
further representation dated 07.o3.2o25 specifically stating that
they arr: not liable to pay license fee for the period during which
they were dispossessed and expressed readiness to pay charges
up to 23.09.2023.
2.1O.
While the said representation was stilt pending
consideration, Respondents issued a fresh e-Tender Notification
dated 11.o4.2o25 and issued Letter dated 14.os.2o25 seeking
to implement the same. petitioners immediately submitted
i
:
.,i-"
.,:_:: ,..::i
n
n
representation dated 17.O5.2O25 agreeing to pay the
encroachment charges determined by the authorities excluding
the period from 23.09.2023 till restoration of possession and
requesting de-notification of the tender. The said representation
has not been considered till date. Petitioners contend that the
license granted in their favour is valid and subsisting till
08.02.2035 and that issuance of a fresh tender during the
subsistence of the license, without lawfully terminating the
same and without complying with the binding orders passed by
this Court, is arbitrary, illegal and violative of Articles 14 and
19(1)(g) of the Constitution of lndia, apart from being contrary to
the principles of natural justice.
No counter affidavit has been {iled by the
3.
Respondents. There is no denial on record of the factual
assertions made by the Petitioners.
4.
Heard Ms. Vladimeer Khatoon, learned counsel for
petitioners as well as Sri N. Chandra Shaker, learned Standing
Counsel for the Corporation.
5.
Petitioners' case is that they are entitled to
exemption from payment of license fee and encroachment
charges for the period commencing from 23.09.2023 till
restoration of possession and that issuance of e-Tender
ft\
_\
l0
Notilicatic,n dated 11.O4.2O25 is arbitrary. This Court is unable
to accept the said contention.
6.
It is not in dispute that Petitioners were granted
license trnder the Deposit, Operate and Transfer scheme
pursuant to proceedings dated O8.01.2OL5 which commenced
from O9.O2.2O15, governed by the terms and conditions of the
Deed of l,icense and the applicable rules and regulations of the
Respondt:nt Corporation. The license, though for a fixed period,
is not urrconditional and does not confer an absolute right to
continue irrespective of violations. The material on record
reveals teat inspections conducted by Respondents in August,
2o2l dir;closed unauthorised occupation of additional area
beyond l-he sanctioned shop limits. Therefore, notices dated
15.09.202t, O5.O7.2022, 25.Lt.2022, 06.01 .2023 and
o5.o6.2a23 were issued alleging encroachment and demanding
payment of charges, however, Petitioners did not vacate the
encroactred area nor did they comply with the demands raised.
Their contention that inspection report was not supplied does
not absolve them of the obligation to respond substantively or
comply provisionally, particularly when repeated notices were
issued over a period exceeding two years
n
..-jr---.:.,-1-:---::-.::::.-'.,.'-:::::il__:j::
:j ::1:::a_::-:t::::-_,:::
ll
n
7.
The plea that the Regional Tender Committee lacked
jurisdiction is also devoid of merit. Notices issued were
preliminary in nature and culminated in a show cause notice
dated 21.07.2023, which was subjected to judiqial scrutiny in
Writ Petition No. 20696 of 2023.ln the said case, by order dated
O3.O8.2O23, this Court granted Petitioners liberty to submit
explanation within two weeks and restrained coercive action till
consideration of such explanation. It is an admitted fact that
Petitioners failed to submit any explanation within the time
granted by this Court. Having failed to avail a judicially-granted
opportunity, they cannot later contend violation of principles of
natural justice.
8.
The termination proceedings dated 19.09.2023 thus
flowed directly from Petitioners' non-compliance with the
directions of this Court and cannot be characterised as
arbitrary. Even after termination, Respondents acted with
restraint and considered Petitioners' representation dated
2L.O9.2O23 pursuant to directions issued in Writ Petition
No.27244 of 2023. Subsequently, in W.P.No.33O9T of 2023, an
Advocate Commissioner was appointed and the report dated
06.02.2024 quantified the extent of encroach*.rri. Though
petitioners rely heavily on the said report which states that
\
..-:-.:.
.
=-
-..-l
t2
encroacflment is very meagre and not as stated by respondents
in the notices, the same does not advance their case unless they
discharge the corresponding {-rnancial liability arising therefrom.
The conlmon order dated 21.10.2024 in Writ petitions No.
33097 of 2023 and 19737 of 2024 did not grant unconditional
restoration of possession. on the contrary, it clearly directed
Petitionr:rs to pay charges for the encroached portion as per the
rules in force, and only thereafter directed the Respondents to
consider leasing of the shops.
9.
Further, this Court also finds substance in
Responrlents' contention that fresh e-Tender Notification dated
ll.o4.2t)25 was issued only after Petitioners failed to clear the
dues de spite repeated demands and despite clear directions of
this Court. The tender was not issued during pendency of
represerrtations arbitrarily, but only after it became evident that
Petitioners were unwilling to comply with the conditions
precedent imposed by judicial orders. The plea that issuance of
tender violates the subsisting license also cannot be accepted.
Once t.he license stood terminated on lg.Og.2}23 and
Petitioners failed to secure restoration by complying with
conditi<lns imposed by this court, they cannot claim a vested
right to continue till 2O35.
:
I\
i:._;::.J_--i:__,.::_.
_- ..t
j'l-:.: ,-
.
,-, -,.
,. .,:-'.,,.-:-,-.:-, -l ':::::.+i;" tr.
.il.
t
_ 't
I
I
I
10.
f'r
It is a settled principle that a writ court does not act
as an appellate authority over contractual disputes, particularly
where petitioner is in breach of contractual and statutory
obligations. Petitioners seek equitable relief while remaining in
default of admitted dues, which disentitles them to discretionary
relief under Article 226. This Court therefore, finds no merit in
'the
Writ Petition and holds that Petitioners failed to establish
.
" any enforceable legal right warranting interference.
1 1.
The Writ . Petition is accordingly, dismissed. No
costs.
12.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
2-
SD/. C. DEEPIKA
ASSISTANT
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To
1. Two CCs to GP FOR TRANSPORT' High Co
Hvderabad. IOUTI
the State of Telangana at
Advocate-[OP.UC]
2. Ohe CC to tvllSS. VLADI tvl E ER KHATOON,
(oPUC)
Advocate
3. One CC to SRI N.CHAN tinn sHrKAR,
4. Two CD CoPies
SA
GJP
HIGH COIJRT
DATED:0!)/0112026
( q'3
{ HES
3 ?t JAtt
*
WP.No.1 5200 of 2025
DISMISSING THE W.P
WITHOUIT COSTS.
,:-
a
:'!
ORDER
,.1 t ,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review