Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANG
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT
N NO: 15648 oF 2025
Between:
. Sri.A.Rajender, S/o.Rajaiah, Aged about 40 years, Occ.Business, Ri/o.H.No.11-249,W-eekly Bazar, Jbgtiyal,Karimnagar District, Telangana State-505451 .
2. Sri.M.Dayanandam, S/o.Narsaiah. Aged about 39 yegrs,. Occ3usiness'
R/o.H.No.4-1-130l2,Vani Nagar, Jagtiyal,Karimnagar District, Telangana
State-S05451.
.....PETITIONERS
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Transport
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad, Telangana State.
2. Telangana State Road Transport Corporation, Rep by its Vice Chairman, Bus
$havan, Musheerabad, Hyderabad.
3. Telangana State Road Transport Corporation, Rep by its Managing
Director,Bus Bhavan, Musheerabad, Hyderabad.
4. Executive Director, (REV. and lT) and Secretary to Corporation, Bus
Bhavan,OPD (Mktg. and Corn)wing, Musheerabad, Hyderabad.
5. The Divisional Manager, TGRTC, Karimnagar Division' Karimnagar District,
Telangana State-505 001 .
6. The Regional Manager, TGRTC,Karimnagar Region, Karimnagar
District,Telangana State-505 001.
7. The Depot Manager, TGRTC, Jagtiyal Bus Station, Karimnagar District,
Telangana State-505 001.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 of lhe Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be
pleased to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ
of mandamus declaring the action of the 6th Respondent issued Proceedings No.
LClffP1785(3O)12024-RM.KR,dated.02l0612025 is highly, unwarranted, highty
arbitrary, unfair, unjust, irrational, unlawful and against the principles of Natural
Justice and consequently set aside the same.
|.A.NO:1 OF 2:025
Petition UnderSection 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Courl may be pleased please
to grant interim suspension of Proceedings No. Lclwplzgs(30y 2024-RIu.KR,
dated. 0210612025 pending disposal of the main writ petiilon.
!.A.NO:2 OF 2125
Petition UnderSection 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
permit the petitioners to pay the encroached portion determined by Respondent
No.7,dated.03.(13. 2025 excluding the period from 23lOgl2123 to date of restoring
possession of DOT Shops No.16,17 and 18 pending disposal of the main writ
petition.
l.A.NO:3 OF 20.21
Petition Llnder Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filecl in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the Respondent No.6 not to finalize the E-Tender Notification No.E Sl43T(O2)]ZO2S,
dated.11.04-2025 in respect of DOT Shops Nos.16,11,18 pending disposal of the
main writ petition.
counsel for the Petitioners : Mlss VLADIMEER KHATOON
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 : Gp FOR TRANSPORT
counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 to7 : sRt N.CHANDRA SHEKAR
The Court made the following ORDER
(\o
.,).
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAI(A
WRIT PETITION No. 15648 OF 2O2S
09.o1.20/26
Between:
A.Rajender & another
..... Petitioners
And
The State of Telangana,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Transport Department,
& others.
..... Respondents
ORDER:
The present writ petition is filed aggriqved by the
proceedings dated 02.06.2025 issued by Respondent No.6.
whereby representation dated 17.O5.2025 of Petitioners was
rejected and consequential steps were initiated in furtherance of
e-Tender Notification dated LL.O4.2O25 in respect of DOT Shop
Nos. 16, 17 and 18 situated at Jagtial Bus Station. Petitioners
seek a declaration that the impugned proceedings dated
02.06.2025 are arbitrary, illegal, violative of the principles of
natural justice and contrary to the orders passed by this Court
in the earlier rounds of litigation, and consequently seek setting
aside of the said proceedings and protection of their license
rights in respect of the subject DOT Shops.
2-
Petitioners are licensees of Dor shop/Stall Nos. 16,
17 arul 18 situated at Jagitial Bus Station, Jagitial District and
they are carrying on business in the said stalls. Respondent
corporation, with a view to utilise vacant land available in
Jagtial Bus Station, invited bids from intending business
persons under the Deposit operate and Transfer (Dor) scheme
for corLstruction and operation of shops/stalls within the bus
station premises. Pursuant to the said notification, they
submitted bids for subject shops offering to pay a monthly
license fee of Rs.5,o00/- per stall and a non-refundable deposit
of Rs.2,4o,oool- for construction and arlotment of the said
stalls. 'fhe corporation communicated acceptance uide letters
dated o8.o1.2o15, on receipt of which, petitioners deposited
non-refundable amount of Rs.2,4o,o00/- and were thereafter,
granted license in respect of the Dor shops for twentJr years
commerrcing from 09.o2.2o15 and ending on og.o2.2o3s, with a
clear and unequivocal stipulation that upon completion of the
license lreriod, they should vacate and hand over possession of
the stalls to the corporation and that no extension of the license
period would be granted beyond the said term.
./^
e,-"4
2.1.
Petitioners contend that after several years of
peaceful operation of the stalls, Respondents issued notice
dated L5.O9.2021 alleging that Petitioners had encroached upon
additional area measuring 232.75 square feet, 231.16 square
feet and 231.76 square feet respectively in front of their allotted
stalls. It is the specific and consistent case of Petitioners that
the inspection report dated 31.08.2021, on the basis of which
such allegations were made, was never furnished to them,
thereby depriving them of an opportunity to verify or contest the
measurements. Petitioners state that subsequent notices dated
O5.O7.2022, 25.11.2022, 06.0 1 .2023 and 05.O6.2023 reiterated
the very same allegations without supplying any supporting
material or report.
2.2.
Petitioners further state that they participated in a
meeting convened by the Regional Tender Committee on
22-06.2022 in connection with the alleged encroachment,
during which, ft"y, without admitting the allegations, expressed
their willingness to pay additional license fee of Rs.2,OOO/-for
the alleged encroached area in order to resolve the issue
amicably. However, the said offer was not accepted by the
Regional Tender Committee. Thereafter, by notices dated
25.11.2022 and 06.01.2023, Respondents demanded monthly
amounts of Rs.2s,32rf-, Rs.2s,2r6/- and Rs.20,7g3/respe<:tively with effect from o2-o9.2o21 towards license fee
and
charg:s for alleged utilisation of additional space, coupled with
a thrr:at of termination of license and forfeiture of security
deposit in the event of non-payment.
2.3.
It is the specific contention of petitioners that
Regional Tender committee had no authority or jurisdiction
to
unilaterally alter or enhance the license terms or determine
additio;ral financial liability. According to petitioners, clause 32
of the L.icense Agreement categorically provides that any dispute
arising out of the terms and conditions of the license shall be
decided by the Managing Director of the corporation and that
the decision of the Managing Director alone would. be final and
binding. They further contend that similar allegations of
encroachment were levelled against all2l Dor shops in Jagitial
Bus stertion, thereby demonstrating arbitrariness and non_
application of mind on the part of the Respondents.
2.4.
Aggrieved by
the notice dated 2L.or.2023,
Petitione;:s filed writ petition No. 20696 o,f 2023, wherein this
court, blr order dated os.og.2o23, declined to set aside the
shor,r, carrse notice but directed petitioners to submit their
detailed t:xplanation within two weeks and directed Regional
-t
Manager to consider explanation and pass
appropriate orders
after affording reasonabre opportunity of hearing,
restraining the Respondents from taking any
completion of the said exercise. petitioners
while
coercive steps till
candidly admit that
due to oversight, they failed to submit their explanation
the time stipulated by this court. consequentry,
corporation issued a final order terminating
within
Respondent
the license of
Petitioners uide proceedings dated Lg.og.2o23.
Immediately
thereafter, petitioners submitted representation
dated
2l'o9'2023 requesting reconsideration and seeking
opportunity to explain their case. Notwithstanding
representation, Respondents closed the Dor
an
the pending
shops with effect
from 23-og.2o2a, thereby depriving petitioners of
their
livelihood.
2-5.
petitioners thereafter filed
writ petition No. 22244
of 2023 which was disposed of on 18. Lo.2o23
with a direction to
Respondent authorities to consider the representation
dated
2l'o9'2023 in accordance with law. pursuant
thereto,
proceedings dated 29.Lr.2o23 were issued
which, according to
Petitioners, did not properly consider their
explanation and did
not assign cogent reasons for rejecting their contentions.
Petitioners again approached this court in writ petition
No.
i
j
I
i
I
I
33097 0f 2023 wherein an
appoir ted for local inspection
submitted report stating that
feet each in respect of
the earlier notices issued
While the said Writ petition
adjudicarion, Respondents
the same, petitioners liled
charges for the encroached
seeking cornpliance with
of by a common order dated
portion as per the rules
in force and
to consider the petitioners,
of the shops thereafter. Despite
dated 01.11 .2024 and, 10.02.2025
the directions of this court,
corporation issued proceedings
amounts carculated up to
.2024.Both
court directed petitioners to pay
further directed Respondents
representation for leasing
the
dated o3.o3.2025 demanding
31 -or.2a25, which incruded
even for the period during
dated
of the subject sta,s. charenging
the writ l)etitions were disposed
submitting representations
was pending
writ petition No. 19737 0f
21'LO'202'+, whereby this
by the
issued e-Tender Notification
08'O7 '20t)4 for re-a,otment
which
rower than the extent of
Respondents.
2.6.
was
stalr Nos.
feet in respect of stall No.17,
was substantiaily and drastica[y
encroac'1ment alreged in
was
of the subject DoT stalls who
actual encroachment, if any,
only to an extent of 5.g5 square
16 and 18 and 63-7 square
Advocate commissioner
charges
which the shops were admittedry-
ft
('-l
closed by the Respondents from 23.09.2023 onwards.
Petitioners submitted a detailed representation dated
O7.O3.2O25 specifically stating that they were not liable to pay
any charges for the closed period and expressed their readiness
to pay charges for the encroached portion only up to the date of
termination.
2.7.
While the said representation was pending
consideration, Respondent Corporation issued a fresh e-Tender
Notification dated 11.04.2025 followed by a consequential letter
dated L4.O5.2O25 seeking implementation of the tender.
Petitioners submitted another representation dated 17.O5.2O25
agreeing to pay the encroached portion charges excluding the
closed period and requesting de-notification of the tender
insofar as their stalls were concerned. Aggrieved thereby, they
filed Writ Petition No. 15200 of 2025, wherein this Court, by
order dated 21.05.2025, directed that any tender process in
respect of DOT Shop Nos. 16, LT and 18 pursuant to the e-
Tender Notification dated L1.O4.2O25 shall be subject to the
outcome of the writ petition. Despite the subsistence of the said
judicial order, Respondent No.6 issued the impugned
proceedings dated 02.06.2025 rejecting Petitioners'
representation dated L7.O5-2O25 without affording arry
opporrunity of hearing and without even adverting
passe<l by this court, which has necessitated
to the order
a-\
the filing of the
present writ petition.
3'
Respondent corporation, through their
affidavjt, vehemently opposed the Writ petition
counter
and contends
that th: same is misconceived, devoid of merit and
constitutes
an abuse of the process of raw. It is asserted that petitioners,
having repeatedry violated the terms and concritions
License Agreement, are not entitred to invoke
jurisdiction of this court under Articre
the extraordinary
226 of the constitution
and writ petition is liabre to be dismissed at the
3.1.
of the
threshold.
Respondents state that subject stails were
to Petitioners under a License Agreement dated
allotted
og.o2.2o15 for
20 years ending on og.02.2o3s, subject to strict
compliance
with the terms and conditions contained therein, particularly
clause 2 of the License Agreement, which mandates
licensee shall confine business operations
strictly within the
allotted area and sha, not encroach upon
or ut,ise any
additional government land. In 2oLT, petitioners
approacherl the corporation seeking permission
nature of t'usiness carried on in the respective
considerati'rn and negotiations, the
I:,.-
,
that
themselves
to change the
stalls. After due
competent authorit5r
'Ii
:::,
1-r:
-
.:.,l:r:;.:R:*i::
- :.--.:i::.-i-:.:.
' - ^t
ii
iI
I
I
I
i
!
I
:
i'1
permitted the change of business. Pursuaqt thereto, license fee
was revised and enhanced. In respect of Stalls 16 and 17,
license fee was enhanced with effect from l5-O2.2O17, and in
respect of DOT Stalt No.18, fee was enhanced with effect from
OL.O6.2OL7. Petitioners accepted the revised license fee and
paid the same without any demur or protest, thereby
acquiescing to the revised contractual terms. It is asserted that
Petitioners' claim that license fee remained unchanged at
Rs.S,OOO/- per month is factually incorrect and misLeading.
3.2.
Respondents assert that during inspections
conducted in 2O2L, it was noticed that Petitioners had
unauthorisedly encroached upon additional area beyond the
allotted stall premises, which formed part of government land
within the bus station. Such encroachment was in clear
violation of Clause 2 and other material conditions of the
License Agreement. Accordingly, notices were issued to
Petitioners starting from O2.O9.2O21, followed by notices dated
L5.O9.2021 and O5.O7.2022, calling upon them either to vacate
the encroached area or to pay additional license fee for
unauthorised utilisation of the said space. Despite repeated
notices and opportunities, Petitioners neither vacated the
encroached portion nor complied with the demands raised by
the C,rrporation. It is contended that Petitioners continued to
enjoy unauthorised occupation of public property while deriving
comm,lrcial benefit therefrom, thereby causing hnancial loss to
the Corporation.
3.3.
Respondents further submit that Petitioners
challerrged the show cause notice dated 2L.O7.2O23 in Writ
Petitiorr No. 20696 of 2023, wherein this Court, by order dated,
O3.O8.r1023, declined to interfere with the show cause notice
and inr;tead granted Petitioners an opportunity to submit their
explanzrtion within two weeks. The Court further directed the
Regionzil Manager to consider the explanation and pass
appropriate orders in accordance with law. Respondents
contend that Petitioners wilfully failed to comply with the said
drder and did not submit any explanation within the stipulated
time, compelling the Corporation to issue a final order
terminar-ing the license on 19.O9.2023.
3.4.
It is further contended that even after termination
of the license, Petitioners continued to pursue litigation and
prevented the Corporation from taking possession of the stalls
or proceoding with fresh allotment. Petitioners filed writ Petition
No. 272+4 of 2023, pursuant to which proceedings dated
23.L1.2O23 were issued after considering their representation.
t\
l1
o
Thereafter, they once again filed Writ Petition No. 33O97 of
2023 and Writ Petition No.19737 of 2024, thereby prolonging
the dispute. During the proceedings in writ Petition No. 33097
of 2023, an Advocate commissioner was appointed who, on
physical inspection, confirmed encroachment to an extent of
5.95 square feet in respect of DoT stalt Nos.16 and 18 and
63.07 square feet in respect of DoT Stall No. L7, aggtegating to a
total encroachment of 74.92 square feet. Petitioners never
challenged the Advocate Commissioner's report and have thus
accepted the findings relating to encroachment'
3.5.
It is contended that by common order dated
2L.1O.2024 in writ Petitions No. 33097 0f 2023 and' 19737 0f
2024, this Court granted one final opportunity to Petitioners to
clear the dues relating to the encroached area within one week
and directed the Corporation to consider their representation
thereafter. According to Respondents, they failed to comply with
the said directions and instead disputed liability beyond
23.Og.2O23. Respondents justify the calculation of .dues up to
January 2025 by contending that although the license was
terminated on lg.Og.2o23, Petitioners continued to assert
possessory rights over the subject stalls by filing successive Writ
Petitions, thereby preventing the Corporation from taking
t2
physical possession or issuing fresh tenders. Due to pendency
\
of Writ Petitions No. 27244 and 33097 of 2023 and, L9737 of
2024, the Corporation was effectively restrained from exercising
its rigtrts as lessor, and consequently, the Petitioners remained
in de facto possession. In such circumstances, Respondents
contenl that they were justified in computing differential license
fee for -he period from O2.O9.2O2\ to 31.O1.2O25.
3.6.
Respondents further submit that calculation of
additional license fee for encroached area was made in a
transparent, rational and standardised manner. The formula
adoptec involved deriving the per square foot rate by dividing
the applicable monthly license fee by the allotted area and
applyinli the same proportionately to the encroached area as
confirmt:d by physical inspection and the
Advocate
Commissioner's report. It is contended that the method adopted
ensures proportionality and uniformity and cannot be termed
arbitrarl'. It is further asserted that as there was no subsisting
license agreement after termination and the petitioners failed to
comply rvith the directions issued by this court, corporation
was constrained to issue e-Tender Notification dated Ll.o4.2o2s
for re-all,ttment of the subject stalls. Petitioners challenged the
said tencler by fiting Writ Petition No.152OO of 2025, wherein
{
l3
i(7
this Court directed that tender outcome would be subject to the
result of the writ petition.
3.7.
Respondents contend that in view of Petitioners'
continued non-compliance, absence of any subsisting license,
and persistent default in clearing dues, the Corporation lawfully
issued proceedings dated 02.06.2025 rejecting Petitioners'
representation dated 17.05.2025. It is asserted that the said
proceedings were passed in accordance with law, do not suffer
from arbitrariness, and do not violate any statutory or
constitutional right of the Petitioners. Respondents finatly stated
that once a transparent tender process has been initiated and
no enforceable or subsisting right exists in favour of the
Petitioners, they cannot seek cancellation or de-notification of
the tender. Such a course, according to Respondents, would be
contrary to public interest and the principles governing fair
allotment of public property.
4.
Heard Ms. Vladimeer Khatoon, learned counsel for
petitioners as well as Sri N. Chandra Shaker, learned Standing
Counsel for the Corporation.
5.
Having considered the pleadings and rival
contentions, this Court finds that the relationship between the
parties is governed by a License Agreement dated Og.O2.2Ol5,
which clearly stipulates that license is subject to strict
compliance with the terms and conditions therein. petitioners
themsr:lves admit issuance of multiple notices alleging
€ncro?,rhment and do not dispute the fact that they failed to
submit an explanation within the time granted by this court in
writ P,:tition No.2o696 of 2023. Therefore, the termination
dated '..g.og.2o23 which was issued for non-compliance with
the dire'ction given by this court cannot be termed arbitrary or
violativr: of natural justice.
6.
The Advocate Commissioner's report was not
questiorred by petitioners which establishes that they
encroached some extent. This Court in its common order dated
2L.Lo.2(t24 in writ Petitions No. 33097 of 2023 and r9T3T of
2024 dirl not restore the license unconditionally but granted a
conditional opportunity to Petitioners to pay charges for the
encroached portion as per the rules in force and directed the
corporation to consider leasing of the shops thereafter. The
conditional nature of the relief is evident from the language of
the order. compliance with the condition was a sine qua non for
any further consideration. Petitioners, however, instead of
complyinll with the same, raised disputes regarding
computat:on of dues and liability for the period after
.rl
(")
23.09.2023. Such conduct clearly demonstrates noncompliance with the spirit and letter of the directions issued by
this Court. During the pendency of Writ Petition Nos.27244 of
2023, 33097 of 2023 and 19737 ol 2024, the Corporation was
effectively restrained from exercising its rights over the subject
stalls. In such circumstances, computation of differential license
fee for the period during which Petitioners continued to assert
control cannot be termed arbitrary or illegal.
7.
It is also to be seen, as on the date of issuance of
the impugned proceedings dated 02.06.2025, there was no
subsisting license in favour of Petitioners. The termination
dated 19.09.2023 continued to operate. [n the absence of any
enforceable right, they could not have sought de-notification of
e-Tender Notification dated 11.04.2025 or continuation of
occupation of public property. Rejection of their representation,
therefore, cannot be faulted.
8.
Yet another contention that impugned proceedings
violate principles of natural justice is devoid of merit inasmuch
as Petitioners were afforded repeated opportunities over several
years including a specific opportunity granted by this Court,
which they faited to utilise. The explanation offered by
Respond.ents for computing charges up to January 2025 is on
accourlt of the fact that petitioners did not surrender the
possession and they continued in the premises in view of the
successive litigation and the said explanation is reasonable and
cannot be termed arbitrary. Hence, initiation of a transparent
tender process for re-allotment of public property in the absence
Ofrry subsisting license cannot be interdicted at the instance of
Petitioners.
9.
Furthermore, it is a settled legal position that a writ
of mand.a,ztus cannot be issued to enforce purely contractual
rights e.riSing out of a non-statutory license, particularly when
dispute,l questions of fact and computation of dues are
involvec.. It is eqqally well settled that public propert5r must be
dealt with in a fair, transparent and revenue-oriented manner,
and that no individual can claim a vested right to continue in
occupat on of such property contrary to contractual terms and
public interest. Once the license stood terminated and no
subsisting right existed, the Corporation was fully justified in
initiating; a transparent tender process through e-Tender
Notification dated | 1.O4.2O25.
10.
In the totality of circumstances, this Court linds
that PeLtioners have not approached the Court with clean
hands, have repeatedly failed to comply with contractual
\i;
t7
obligations and judicial directions, and are attempting to
perpetuate their occupation of public properW by invoking the
extraordinary jurisdiction of this court. No arbitrariness,
illegality, mala ftdes or violation of statutory or constitutional
provisions is made out to warrant interference. For all the
aforesaid reasons, this court holds that writ petition is devoid
of merit and is liable to be dismissed.
1.1'.' ,.,
tlq
' i' " Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. No
costs.
t2.
t
Consequentl5r, the miscellaneous Applications, if
/
any'shall stand closed.
I
i
SD/. C. DEEPI
ANT REG
I
l
//TRUE COPY//
OFFICER
To
Court for
of Telangana at
1. Two CCs to GP FOR TRANSPORT' High
Hyderabad . tourl
KHATOON, Advocate IOPUCI
MEER
2. One CC to tvttSS VLADI
Ad vocate (OPUC)
3. One CC to SRI N.CHAN DRA S I{EKAR,
4. Two CD CoPies
SA
GJP
t:
li
ll
il
ii
HIGH COURT
DATED:l)9/0112026
STA
(-
?.1 JAil 2$26
(J
t
*
ORDER
t
WP.No.15648 ot 2025
DISMISSINTG THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS.
TI,
&
a
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review