Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
BENCH AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE AVANINDRA KUMAR SINGH
CIVIL REVISION No. 674 OF 2023
BETWEEN:SMT. SHARDA RAJENDRA PRASAD SOLANKI W/O
SHRI RAJENDRA PRASAD SOLANKI, AGED
YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS, R/O HIG 849
OLD
HOUSING
BOARD
COLONY
DISTRICT-
MORENA (MADHYA PRADESH)
-----APPLICANT/DEFENDANT
(BY SHRI VIVEK TANKHA – LEARNED SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH SHRI
PRATIP VISORIYA- LEARNED ADVOCATE)
AND
1. SMT MEENA MUKESH JATAV W/O SHRI MUKESH
JATAV, AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
HOMEMAKER RUI KI MANDI JEEN GALI NO 2
NAGAR MORENA DISTRICT- MORENA (MADHYA
PRADESH)
-----RESPONDENT/PETITIONER
2. ADVOCATE
MAMTA
MOURYA
W/O
SHRI
RAMAKANT PIPPAL, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: ADVOCATE BABU JMADAR ROAD
UTTAM PURA HAL M -10 NEW HOUSING BOARD
COLONY MORENA (MADHYA PRADESH)
3. SMT. LALITA PAWAN AJIT JATAV W/O SHRI
PAWAN AJIT JATAV, AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: HOMEMAKER NAYA AAMPURA
WARD KRAMANK 42 NAGAR MORENA (MADHYA
PRADESH)
4. ANITA
CHOUDHARY
HITENDRA
W/O
LATE
SHRI
DR.
CHOUDHARY,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOMEMAKER WARD NO.
47 PREMNAGAY MORENA (MADHYA PRADESH)
5. KU. RITIKA SOLANKI D/O SHRI RAJENDRA
PRASAD SOLANKI, AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: BUSINESS HIG 849 OLD HOUSING
BOARD COLONY DISTRICT MORENA (MADHYA
PRADESH)
6. COLLECTOR
CUM
ELECTION
RETURNING
OFFICER MUNICIPAL CORPORATION ELECTION
MORENA (MADHYA PRADESH)
------ PROFORMA RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SANGAM JAIN - ADVOCATE AND SHRI S.N. SETH – LEARNED
ADVOCATE
FOR
RESPONDENT
NO.1)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Reserved on
Delivered on
:
:
20/12/2023
05/01/2024
This revision having been heard and reserved for orders, coming on
for pronouncement this day, this court passed the following:
ORDER
This Civil Revision under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure
read with Section 19 of Madhya Pradesh Municipal Corporation Act has
been filed by the applicant arising out of the order dated 25/07/2023 passed
by VI District Judge, Morena in Case No.EP 1/2022, whereby the application
filed by the revisioner/applicant/defendant under Section 441(3)(ii) read with
Section 441 (5)(a)(b)(c) of M.P. Municipal Corporation Act, 1956 read with
Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC have been dismissed vide order dated
25.07.2023 and review application has also been dismissed vide order dated
18/08/2023.
2.
In brief, applicant and respondent No.1 alongwith other candidates
contested the election of Mayor of Municipal Corporation, District- Morena
(M.P.) in which the applicant-Smt.Sharda Solanki won the election against
which respondent No.1- Smt. Meena Mukesh Jatav filed the election petition
as mentioned above.
3.
Applicant/defendant No.1 filed an application under Order VII Rule 11
of CPC in which it was submitted that on 24/11/2022, non-applicant No.1
came to know that applicant in election petition Smt.Meena has not
deposited the security deposit, therefore, mandatory provisions of Section
441(3)(II) of Municipal Corporation Act has not been complied with,
therefore, as security deposit of Rs.250/- was not deposited, election petition
was not maintainable. Other grounds were that non-applicant- Smt. Meena
Mukesh Jatav has not disclosed the source of information under Section 441
(5) of the Municipal Corporation Act that how she came to know that before
1950, family of the applicant herein was living at Pinahat, District- Agra
(U.P.), therefore, affidavits are not proper. Petition has not been verified
under Order VI Rule 15 of CPC. It was further submitted that Hon'ble
Supreme Court has allowed non-applicant No.1 to raise point of jurisdiction
whereas regarding validity of caste certificate jurisdiction is with High
Power Committee.
4.
Petitioner-Smt.Meena replied to the application submitting that she
has filed proper security deposit and court fee. Earlier also, this objection
was taken which was decided by the Hon'ble High Court. All information
have been verified under signature of the applicant. Applicant has also
submitted that non-applicant No.1-Smt.Sharda has not stated that she was
born in M.P. and studied in M.P. but stated that after marriage she is living in
Madhya Pradesh.
5.
Learned Election Tribunal has observed in its order dated 25/07/2023
that earlier also an application under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC was filed on
28/10/2022 which was decided on 16/11/2022 against that order of rejection,
revision was filed before this Court which was disposed observing that Ku.
Madhuri Patil Vs. Additional Commissioner, 1994 SCC (6) 241, citation
principles do not apply in this case and this is question of fact which can be
decided after evidence is recorded and against that order, Special Leave to
Appeal (C) No.6122/2023 was filed which was dismissed by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court vide order dated 05/04/2023 mentioning that we do not find
any reason to interfere with the order impugned in this petition and also
permitted to raise disputed issues which were raised in this SLP before
Election Tribunal.
6.
Learned trial Court also observed that applicant-Smt.Sharda who has
filed new application under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC has submitted that he
had filed this application as per direction of Hon'ble Supreme Court and
what issues were raised before the Hon'ble Supreme Court that copy of
petitioner has not been filed, therefore, Court observed that application is not
maintainable either way and regarding security deposit of Rs.250/- receipt
has been filed and under which head it been deposited this is question of fact
requiring evidence, similarly where ancestral of the non-applicant No.1Smt.Sharda were living is not important but important point is whether nonapplicant No.1 is a domicile of Madhya Pradesh or not and besides copy of
Gazette notification has been filed. Learned Court also rejected the objection
about verification of pleadings submitting that they have been verified
specifying which para of verification are from personal knowledge of the
applicant and which para are on the information given by his Advocate and
rejected the application.
7.
On 18/08/2023, application for review filed by the applicant has been
rejected by Election Tribunal at Morena which also rejected the application
under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC filed by the non-applicant No.1- Smt. Sharda
Solanki. On 18/08/2023 learned Tribunal also observed that attempt is being
made to delay the election petition and imposed the cost of Rs.1000/- on
non-applicant No.1-Smt.Sharda.
8.
Against above order, this revision has been filed on the ground that
order of learned trial Court/Election Tribunal is incorrect regarding
depositing of security deposit. Similarly, regarding domicile of non-applicant
No.1-Smt.Sharda or her forefather in the year 1950 is wrong. Verification in
election petition by Smt.Meena in this regard is not as per rules, therefore,
order is bad in law. Inquiry in respect of migration is required to be
conducted by Caste Scrutiny Committee, therefore, prayer for setting-aside
the orders dated 25/07/2023 (Annexure P/1) and 18/08/2023 (Annexure P/2)
is made.
9.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
10.
In the considered view of this Court, this civil revision cannot be
allowed for the simple reason that when original order (Annexure-A/9) of
Tribunal dated 16.11.2022 rejecting the application under Order 7 Rule 11
CPC filed by Smt. Sharda was challenged before the Single Bench of this
Court in C.R.No.733/2022 (Smt. Sharda Vs Smt.Meena) who rejected the
revision (Annexure-A/10) which was affirmed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in SLP No.6122/2023 (Annexure-A/11) but permission was granted to raise
grounds before the Tribunal as in SLP that would mean that when petition
was finally decided by the Election Tribunal after the trial and not in
piecemeal. Learned Single Bench passed the order dated 23/01/2023 in Civil
Revision No.733/2022 has held thus;
“This civil revision under Section 115 of the CPC
read with Section 441F of Madhya Pradesh Municipal
Corporation Act, is directed against the order dated
16/11/2022 passed by VI District Judge, Morena (M.P.) in
Case No. EP 1/2022 dismissing an application filed under
Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC in a proceeding initiated by
respondent No.1 under Section 441 of the M.P. Municipal
Corporation Act.
In the said proceedings, election of the applicant as
Mayor has been challenged primarily on the ground that
even though the applicant is Jatav by caste but can not
claim to have SC status in Madhya Pradesh to contest the
election of Mayor from Morena reserved for SC woman,
as according to counsel for respondent No.1, she is
resident of Uttar Pradesh.
It appears that applicant filed an application under
Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC to contend that the nature of
enquiry sought for is related to residence of the applicant
and can not be gone into the election petition as same can
only be addressed by the High Level Committee
constituted under the order of Hon'ble Supreme Court in
the case of Ku. Madhuri Patil Vs Additional
Commissioner, 1994 SCC (6) 241.
The Trial Judge has rejected the application with
the reasoning that caste certificate of Jatav community is
not in dispute. The sole question raised is as to whether
the applicant is the resident of Uttar Pradesh or Madhya
Pradesh. Hence, under the circumstances, the nature of
the enquiry by way of trial in pending proceedings is
different from the nature and scope of enquiry by the High
Level Committee in the matter of caste verification
certificate. Therefore, the proceedings pending can not be
said to be either barred in the law or excluded by force of
judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Ku.
Madhuri Patil (Supra).
Upon hearing learned counsels for the parties and
perusal of the impugned order, this court is of the view
that the Trial Judge did not commit any error of law while
passing the impugned order. The mandate contained under
Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC by way of sub clauses are
clear and unambiguous. The instant proceeding neither
can be said to be barred by law nor prohibited by the
force of judgment of Supreme Court. Hence, contentions
advanced in the context of Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC are
found to be misdirected.
Indeed, in the context of caste or caste verification
certificate, High Level Committee has been constituted
under the order of Hon'ble Supreme Court in Madhuri
Patil (Supra) and procedure is prescribed but in the
instant case, the issue raised is as regard to resident of the
applicant. Such question is pure question of fact and can
only be addressed by the Trial Judge after the parties lead
evidence.
Of course, either party shall have right to raise all
questions of law and facts available to them at the
appropriate stage of the proceedings before the Trial
Judge.
With the aforesaid observations, civil revision
stands disposed of.”
And Hon'ble Supreme Court in Special Leave to Appeal (C)
No.6122/2023 vide order dated 05/04/2023 has held as under:“Heard learned counsel for the petitioner.
We do not fine any reason to interfere with the order
impugned in this petition.
The special leave petition is, accordingly, dismissed
but the issues which were raised for adjudication by this
Court in this petition may be raised by the petitioner
before the Tribunal.
Pending application (s), if any, shall stand disposed
of.”
11.
Again the same objection regarding competent forum to decide the
issue of candidate's caste certificate is being raised by using different words.
12.
Regarding second ground of depositing security deposit in wrong
head, on this aspect it is seen that Division Bench in para 11 in the case of
Renu Shah Vs. Kant Shirh Dev Singh [2010 (4) M.P.L.J.] has held as
under:“11. So far as second objection in the petition that the
security was deposited in wrong head is concerned, the
Tribunal has deferred the aforesaid issue by order dated
15-4-2010 on the ground that it was subject-matter of the
evidence and the relevant documents were not before the
Election Tribunal. It is not disputed before us that the
amount of security was deposited before the Tribunal.
Merely it was deposited in the wrong head, will not be a
ground to dismiss the election petition. The election
petitioner deposited the amount of security to the Election
Tribunal and merely it was deposited in a wrong head,
will not be a ground to dismiss the election petition. See
Budhinath vs. Nanilal Jatav, 22 ELR 86 and Kaushlendra
Prasad vs. Nand Kishore, 22 ELR 484. In spite of this,
Election Tribunal decided to defer the issue to ascertain
the factual position, in which no fault is found.”
13.
Incidentally, the above matter Renu Shah (Supra) before the Division
Bench also arose under in election petition under Section 441 of M.P.
Municipal Corporation, Act, 1956, therefore, when a Division Bench
judgment is there about depositing the security deposit in wrong head then
the judgment relied by the applicant/revisioner in the case of Kanchan
Khattar Vs. Rakesh Dardwanshi [2016 (1) M.P.L.J. 509] passed by the
Single Bench will not be applicable in the facts and circumstances of this
case as in which the case of Renu Shah (supra) was not considered,
therefore, ground regarding depositing of security deposit of Rs.250/- does
have any merit at this stage as it has been deposited by respondent No.1-Smt.
Meena Mukesh Jatav on 24/07/2022 that is date of presentation of election
petition which was not disputed by the learned counsel for the applicant. His
only contention was that the deposit in wrong head is no head and is no
compliance of the provision of Section 441 (3)(ii) and Section 441 (5)(a)(b)
(c) of the M.P. Municipal Corporation Act but in the light of judgment of
Renu Shah (supra) this contention does not have any force as of now at this
stage but applicant shall have right to raise this issue during trial as
concerned court in its order dated 25/07/2023 has observed that deposit was
made in the wrong head or not is matter of the evidence and this Revisional
Court cannot interfere in this matter at this stage because in the deposit by
online mode, there are multiple heads and only by proper evidence of proper
authority it can be held that what was the major head and minor head on
depositing etc.
14.
The last issue is regarding verification on which trial Court has
rejected the objection but again this issue is also directly related to the
evidence to be recorded by the Tribunal regarding domicile of wining
candidate and her matrimonial and maternal home etc. Therefore, what
information is personally known and what information has been received by
the other person can be considered during trial itself. Accordingly, this
revision petition stands dismissed.
15.
Let a copy of this order be sent to the concerned Court to decide the
election petition as expeditiously as possible as per law as election is under
challenge which was held on 20/07/2022 and result was declared on
26/07/2022.
(AVANINDRA KUMAR SINGH)
JUDGE
(05/01/2024)
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH BENCH
GWALIOR, ou=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH BENCH
GWALIOR,
2.5.4.20=eac942476567cd1b39b3da46068403462fdf82ab67
6d0cde4dee473fe77953f5, postalCode=474001, st=Madhya
Pradesh,
serialNumber=0275C4F803F94C47998BE5C534E21BDED91
0FD4AB9D159B55575E814D05B2EED, cn=RAHUL SINGH
PARIHAR
Date: 2024.01.09 12:39:35 +05'30'
RAHUL SINGH
rahul
PARIHAR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review