Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRANAY VERMA
ON THE 13th OF DECEMBER, 2023
WRIT APPEAL No. 2263 of 2023
BETWEEN:1.
SHAMBHUDAYAL AGRAWAL THROUGH LRS.
RAJKUMAR
AGRAWAL
S/O
LATE
SHRI
SHAMBHUDAYAL AGRAWAL, AGED ABOUT 73
YEAR S , OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 131 SHANTI
NIKETAN COLONY, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
SMT. VIMLA BAI AGRAWAL W/O SHRI
SHAMBHUDAYAL AGRAWAL, AGED ABOUT 70
YEAR S, OCCUPATION: HOUSEWIFE 131 SHANTI
NIKETAN COLONY, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
SMT. EKTA W/O SHRI RAJKUMAR AGRAWAL,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION:
HOUSEWIFE 131 SHANTI NIKETAN COLONY,
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
(SHRI YOGESH HEMNANI, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANTS)
AND
1.
INDORE MUNICIPAL CORPORATION THROUGH
THE COMMISSIONER INDORE MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
THE
COMMISSIONER INDORE MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(NONE)
This appeal coming on for admission this day, Justice Sushrut Arvind
Dharmadhikari passed the following:
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 20-12-2023
04:40:27
ORDER
Heard on the question of admission.
The present writ appeal under Section 2(1) of the Madhya Pradesh
Uchcha Nyayalaya(Khand Nyayapeeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 has been
filed assailing
the order dated 21.11.2023, passed in W.P. No.5007/2021
wherein, the appellants had
challenged the validity of the order dated
24.07.2020, passed by the respondent No.2 whereby the renewal of the lease
and mutation of their names have been rejected.
2. The brief facts of the case are that the land admeasuring 13440 Sq, ft.
situated at 40/1, Pardeshipura, Indore was originally granted on lease for 30
years by the respondent IMC to one Madanlal S/o Shivbaksh. Later on, the
said land was transferred to one V.V. Deshpande and it was further transferred
to one Baldev Prasad S/o Shivlal. Baldev Prasad transferred the said land
alognwith the superstructure to Dwarkadas Agrawal i.e. father of appellant
No.1. Respondent No.1, thereafter, transferred the lease dated 10.12.1979 in the
name of Dwarkadas Agrawal for the remaining period of lease up to 28.03.2009.
3. In pursuance to the Will dated 12.04.1980 bequeathing the land and the
superstructure in favour of his grandson - Ajay son of Shankarlal, son
Bholaram, and grandsons - Prakash and Manoj in the ratio of 50%, 20%, 20%
and 10% respectively. Dwarkadas Agrawal had died on 12.01.1981. Thereafter,
the legal representatives of Dwarkadas became owners of the land and the
superstructure by virtue of the Will transferred the rights in the name of
appellant no.1 vide gift-deed in the year 2016.
4. In pursuance to the aforesaid gift deed, the appellants applied before
the IMC for renewal of the lease and mutation of their names in the municipal
record. However, the application was rejected on the ground that the lease has
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 20-12-2023
04:40:27
already expired on 28.03.2009 and after expiry of the lease, the lesseee had no
right to execute the Will, therefore, the gift-deed is prima facie illegal for want of
authority and legal right. Being aggrieved, the writ petition was filed. The learned
Single Judge dismissed the writ petition as the appellants had become
encroachers after expiry of the lease period.
5. Learned counsel for the appellants contended that the order passed by
the learned Single Judge is illegal, contrary to law, and, therefore, deserves to be
set aside.
6. It is an admitted position that the mutation of the names cannot be
done on the basis of Will/gift-deed in a proceedings before the
revenue
authorities. The remedy available to the appellants is to approach the Civil Court
seeking declaration then only mutation can be done. In the present case, as per
the gift-deed, the appellants were required to seek permission from the
competent authority to alienate the property in question which has admittedly
not been taken. The learned Single Judge held that the relief of quashment of
the order dated 24.07.2020 passed by the respondent No.2, Commissioner and
a direction to the respondents to renew of the lease and to mutate the names of
the appellants in the municipal record cannot be done on the basis of gift-deed
executed after expiry of the lease-deed and dismissed the writ petition. As per
settled legal position, mutation in the revenue record cannot be done on the
basis of Will/gift-deed directly without even seeking a declaration from the
Competent Civil Court having jurisdiction.
7. The Supreme Court in the case of Jitendra Singh v. State of
Madhya Pradesh by order dated 06.09.2021 passed in SLP (civil)
No.13146/2021 has held as under:
“6. Right from 1997, the law is very clear. In the case of Balwant Singh
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 20-12-2023
04:40:27
v. Daulat Singh (D) By Lrs., 8 MP No.38/2023 reported in (1997) 7
SCC 137, this Court had an occasion to consider the effect of mutation
and it is observed and held that mutation of property in revenue records
neither creates nor extinguishes title to the property nor has it any
presumptive value on title.Such entries are relevant only for the purpose
of collecting land revenue. Similar view has been expressed in the series
of decisions thereafter.
6.1 In the case of Suraj Bhan v. Financial Commissioner, (2007) 6
SCC 186, it is observed and held by this Court that an entry in revenue
records does not confer title on a person whose name appears in recordof-rights. Entries in the revenue records or jamabandi have only “fiscal
purpose”, i.e., payment of land revenue, and no ownership is conferred on
the basis of such entries. It is further observed that so far as the title of
the property is concerned, it can only be decided by a competent civil
court. Similar view has been expressed in the cases of Suman Verma v.
Union of India, (2004) 12 SCC 58; Faqruddin v. Tajuddin (2008) 8 SCC
12; Rajinder Singh v. State of J&K, (2008) 9 SCC 368; Municipal
Corporation, Aurangabad v. State of Maharashtra, (2015) 16 SCC 689; T.
Ravi v. B. Chinna Narasimha, (2017) 7 SCC 342; Bhimabai Mahadeo
Kambekar v. Arthur Import & Export Co., (2019) 3 SCC 191; Prahlad
Pradhan v. Sonu Kumhar, (201 9) 10 SCC 259; and Ajit Kaur v. Darshan
Singh, (2019) 13 SCC 70.”
8. The Supreme Court in the case of H. Lakshmaiah Reddy v.
L.Venkatesh Reddy, reported in (2015) 14 SCC 784 has held as under:
“8. As rightly contended by the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
appellants, the first defendant did not relinquish or release his right in
respect of the half-share in the suit property at any point of time and that
is also not the case pleaded by the plaintiff. The assumption on the part of
the High Court that as a result of the mutation, the first defendant
divested himself of the title and possession of half-share in suit property
is wrong. The mutation entries do not convey or extinguish any title and
those entries are relevant only for the purpose of collection of land
revenue. The observations of this Court in Balwant Singh case are
relevant and are extracted below: (SCC p. 142, paras 21-22)
“21. We have considered the rival submissions and we are of the view that
Mr Sanyal is right in his contention that the courts were not correct in
assuming that as a result of Mutation No. 1311 dated 19-7-1954, Durga
Devi lost her title from that date and possession also was given to the
persons in whose favour mutation was effected. In Sawarni v. Inder
Kaur, Pattanaik, J. , speaking for the Bench has clearly held as follows:
(SCC p. 227, para 7)
‘7. … Mutation of a property in the revenue record does not create or
extinguish title nor has it any presumptive value on title. It only enables
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 20-12-2023
04:40:27
the person in whose favour mutation is ordered to pay the land revenue in
question. The learned Additional District Judge was wholly in error in
coming to a conclusion that mutation in favour of Inder Kaur conveys
title in her favour. This erroneous conclusion has vitiated the entire
judgment.’
22. Applying the above legal position, we hold that the widow had not
divested herself of the title in the suit property as a result of Mutation
No. 1311 dated 19-7-1954. The assumption on the part of the courts
below that as a result of the mutation, the widow divested herself of the
title and possession was wrong. If that be so, legally, she was in
possession on the date of coming into force of the Hindu Succession Act
and she, as a full owner, had every right to deal with the suit properties in
any manner she desired.”
9. The Supreme Court in the case of Suraj Bhan v. Financial Commr.,
reported in (2007) 6 SCC 186 has held as under :
“9. There is an additional reason as to why we need not interfere with that
order under Article 136 of the Constitution. It is well settled that an entry
in revenue records does not confer title on a person whose name appears
in record-of-rights. It is settled law that entries in the revenue records or
jamabandi have only “fiscal purpose” i.e. payment of land revenue, and
no ownership is conferred on the basis of such entries. So far as title to
the property is concerned, it can only be decided by a competent civil
court (vide Jattu Ram v. Hakam Singh). As already noted earlier, civil
proceedings in regard to genuineness of will are pending with the High
Court of Delhi. In the circumstances, we see no reason to interfere with
the order passed by the High Court in the writ petition.”
10. Thus, it is clear that mutation of name of a person on the basis of
Will is not permissible and the Revenue Authorities have no jurisdiction to do
so. If the preponder of the Will wants to take advantage of the Will, then he has
to approach Civil Court for declaration of his title. The petitioners have already
approached the Civil Court for declaration of their title. Therefore, in the light of
the judgment passed by the Supreme Court in the case of Jitendra Singh
(supra), it is held that the order of mutation on the basis of Will was per se
illegal.
11. In view of the aforesaid, no illegality or irregularity has been
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 20-12-2023
04:40:27
committed by the learned Single Judge in passing the impugned order dated
21.11.2023.
12. The writ appeal being bereft of merit and substance is hereby
dismissed.
(S. A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
pn
Signed by: PREETHA HARI
NAIR
Signing time: 20-12-2023
04:40:27
(PRANAY VERMA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review