Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH: BENCH AT INDORE
Writ Appeal No.122/2019
Nana Bhau v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.133/2019
Asha Rahtore v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.136/2019
Santosh Barde v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.137/2019
Lalita Sharma v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.140/2019
Kailash Choudhary v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.141/2019
Sadaram Kanoje v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.142/2019
Madhukar Khernar v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.143/2019
Tulsi Bai v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.144/2019
Puni Bai Gangele v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.145/2019
Nirmala Bai v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.146/2019
Roop Singh Vaskale v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.147/2019
Nahar Singh v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.148/2019
Nirmal Giri v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.151/2019
Sunil Kumar v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.164/2019
Sukhdev Vaskale v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.173/2019
Dinesh Rawal v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.175/2019
Mukesh Aatya v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.176/2019
Navin Niamdey v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
Writ Appeal No.177/2019
Mukesh Rahtore v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.188/2019
Rajendra Soni v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.189/2019
Janadi Bai v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.190/2019
Babulal Kagle v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.197/2019
Jambi Bai v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.209/2019
Jagat Narayan v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.212/2019
Kamlesh Joshi v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.217/2019
Fazal Rehman v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.218/2019
Tukaram Goyal v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.219/2019
Jagdish Goyal v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.278/2019
Laxman Chouhan v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.319/2019
Ramesh Oswal v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.328/2019
Jakir Khan v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.599/2019
Darbar Singh v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.672/2019
Jagdish Yadav v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Writ Appeal No.1103/2019
Gajanand v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Indore, dated 02.08.2019
Shri Rahul Sethi, learned counsel for the appellant.
Shri Abhishek
Tugnawat,
learned
Government
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
Advocate for the respondents / State.
Regard being had to the similitude in the controversy
involved in the present cases, the writ appeals were
analogously heard and by a common order, they are being
disposed of by this Court. Facts of the Writ Appeal
No.122/2019 are narrated hereunder.
The present Writ Appeal is arsing out of the order
dated 01.10.2018 passed by the learned Single Judge in
W.P. No.4964/2018 (Nanabhau Patil v/s Tirbal Welfare
Department & Others). The order dated 01.10.2018 has
been passed in a batch of writ petitions involving similar
controversy, and therefore, a common order is being passed
in the connected writ appeals.
The facts of the case reveal that the appellant is a
daily rated employee has filed the writ petition i.e. W.P.
No.4964/2018 being aggrieved by the order dated
19.06.2017 passed by the respondents. The respondents, by
the aforesaid order, have held that the appellant, who is a
daily wager, is not entitled for a regular pay-scale.
The
order
passed
by
the
respondents
dated
19.06.2017 reads as under:“@@vkns'k@@
Jh UkkukHkkm ikVhy fnukad 25-10-1999 dks nSfud osru Hkksxh
ds in ij fu;qDr gq, Fks rFkk muds }kjk izLrqr ;kfpdk dzekad
9606@2012 ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; [k.MihB bUnkSj ds le{k izLrqr
dj ikap o"kZ dh lsok iw.kZ gksus ds fnukad ls fu;fer osrueku fn;s
tkus gsrq ;kfpdk nk;j dh xbZ cM+okuh ftys es ;kfpdkdrkZ ds izdj.k
ds leku vU; izdj.k cgqrk;r esa gksus ls dysDVj ftyk cM+okuh ds
vkns'k vuqlkj 4 lnL;h; desVh xfBr dh xbZ rFkk bl desVh }kjk
viuh dk;Zokgh fooj.k fnukad 30-06-2014 }kjk ;kfpdkdrkZ ds i{k
esa ;kfpdk nk;j djus ds fnukad ls fu;fer osrueku nsus dh vuq'kalk
dh xbZA mDr desVh dh vuq'kalk ds ikyu esa vkns'k
dzekad@5680&81@vkfne@U;k0iz0@2014 cM+okuh] fnukad 10-07-2014
}kjk Jh UkkukHkkÅ ikVhy nSfud osruHkksxh deZpkjh orZeku esa 'kkldh;
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
ek/;fed fo|ky; [ksfr;k fodkl[k.M ikulsey dks mldh ekax
vuqlkj vkdfLedrk fuf/k ds deZpkfj;ksa dks ns; fu;fer osrueku ds
leku osru Lohd`r fd;k x;k gS] ftldk Hkqxrku
dk;ZHkkfjr@vkdfLedrk fuf/k ls fd;k tk jgk gSA mDr Lohd`r fd;s
x;s fu;fer osrueku ij ,fj;j jkf'k dh x.kuk ;kfpdk izLrqr fd;s
tkus ds fnukad 01-10-2012 ls fn;s tkus gsrq vknsf'kr fd;k x;k FkkA
;kfpdkdrkZ }kjk iqu% fjV ;kfpdk dzekad 6116@2014
ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; [k.MihB bUnkSj es nk;j dh tkdj fu;fer
osrueku dk okLrfod ykHk lsok es 5 o"kZ iw.kZ djus ds fnukad 25-102004 ls fn;s tkus dh ekax dh xbZA fjV ;kfpdk dzekad 6116@2014
es ekuuh; mPp U;k;k;ky; [k.MihB bUnkSj }kjk ikfjr fu.kZ; fnukad
31-10-2014 es ;kfpdkdrkZ dks fjV vihy dzekad 359@2010 Jh
dSyk'kpUnz ryojs fo:) e0iz0 'kklu es ikfjr fu.kZ; fnukad 10-042014 es nh xbZ O;oLFkk vuqlkj lsok es ikap o"kZ iw.kZ fd;s tkus ds
mijkar fu;fer osrueku gsrq ;kfpdkdrkZ ds izdj.k es fopkj djrs gq,
l{ke vf/kdkjh dks fu.kZ; fy;s tkus gsrq funsZf'kr fd;k x;kA
fjV ;kfpdk dzekad 6116@2014 esa ikfjr fu.kZ; fnukad 31-102014 dk ikyu u gksus ls ;kfpdkdrkZ }kjk voekuuk ;kfpdk dzekad
464@2015 ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; [k.MihB bUnkSj es nk;j dh xbZ gS
tks orZeku es izpfyr gSA
cM+okuh ftys es ;kfpdkdrkZ dh vykok vU; nSosHkks deZpkfj;kss
ds yxHkx 81 vU; izdj.k gSa ftlesa rFkk muds }kjk lsok esa ikap o"kZ
iw.kZ gksus ds fnukad ls foRr foHkkx ds ifji= dzekad
Mh&302@95@fu&1@4@78 fnukad 17-03-1978 ds ifjizs{; es
dk;ZHkkfjr ,oa vkdfLedrk fuf/k es fu;fer osrueku fn;s tkus dh
ekax dh tk jgh gSA
foRr foHkkx }kjk tkjh mDr ifji= fnukad 17-03-1978 esa
Li"V mYYksf[kr gS fd dk;ZHkkfjr@vkdfLedrk fuf/k esa fu;qDr ,sls
deZpkjh ftudh fnukad 01-01-1974 dks ,d o"kZ dh lsok iw.kZ gks pqdh
gks vFkok 01-01-1974 ds i'pkr dk;ZHkkfjr ,oa vkdfLedrk fuf/k es
fu;qDr ,sls deZpkjh ftudh ikap o"kZ dh lsok iw.kZ gqbZ gks] mUgs fu;fer
osrueku ¼LFkkiuk½ fn;s tkus dk izko/kku gSA tcfd ;kfpdkdrkZ Jh
ukukHkkm ikVhy fnukad 25-10-1999 es nSfud osruHkksxh in ij fu;qDr
gq, gSa vkSj orZeku es Hkh nSfud osruHkksxh gh gSA ,slh fLFkfr esa
;kfpdkdrkZ ds izdj.k esa foRr foHkkx dk ifji= fnukad 17-03-1978
ykxw ugh gksrk gSA mYys[kuh; gS fd foRr foHkkx dk ifji=
dzekad ,Q&8&1@2014@fu;e@pkj Hkksiky fnukad 28-02-2014
vuqlkj fnukad 17-03-1978 orZeku esa vizklafxd gks tkus ls ykxw ugh
jg x;k gSA
vk;qDRk vkfnoklh fodkl Hkksiky ds vkns'k dzekad 13704&05
fnukad 19-06-2017 }kjk dysDVj ftyk cM+okuh }kjk xfBr iwoZ lfefr
dh vuq'kalk ds vk/kkj ij eku- mPp U;k;ky; es voekuuk izdj.kksa dk
tokc izLrqr djus gsrq Rofjr :i ls 5 o"kZ dh lsok iw.kZ djus ds
fnukad ls fu;fer osrueku fn, tkus rFkk jhV ;kfpdk izLrqr djus ds
fnukad ls fu;fer osrueku o ,fj;lZ jkf'k Hkqxrku gsrq fdlh Hkh izdkj
ls xq.k nks"kksa ij fopkj ugh fd, tkus ls ;g ik;k fd ;kfpdkdrkZ o
vU; leLr ;kfpdkdrkZ dk;ZHkkfjr@vkdfLedrk fuf/k ds varxZr
fu;qDRk ugh gq, gS rFkk nSfud osruHkksxh] prqFkZ Js.kh ds in ij j[ks
x, gS] fu;fer osrueku dh ik=rk ugh j[krs gSA vr% ;kfpdkdrkZ o
vU; leLr ;kfpdkdrkZvksa ds izdj.kksa ij e0iz0 'kklu }kjk izns'k es
dk;Zjr nSfud osru Hkksxh deZpkfj;ksa ds mRFkku o muds fgrksa ds
laj{k.k ds m}s'; ls e0iz0 'kklu lkekU; foHkkx Hkksiky ds i= fnukad
07-10-2016 }kjk nSfud osru Hkksxh@Jfedksa ds fy, LFkk;h dfeZ;ks dks
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
fofu;fer djus dh ;kstk ds rgr osru Js.kh dk ykHk nsus ds fy,
dk;Zokgh djus gsrq funsZf'kr fd;k x;k gSA
cM+okuh ftys esa le:i izdj.kksa cgqrk;r dks ns[krs gq, bu
lHkh nSfud osru Hkksfx;ksa }kjk pkgh xbZ lgk;rk dh lekurk dks
n`f"Vxr j[krs gq, ;kfpdkdrkZ lfgr lHkh nSfud osru Hkksfx;ks ds
izdj.kksa dh ijh{k.k desVh dk xBu dysDVj egksn; cM+okuh ds vkns'k
fnukad 06-02-2017 }kjk fd;k x;kA
U;k;ky;hu izdj.kksa ds fujkdj.k gsrq xfBr ftyk Lrjh;
lfefr }kjk fnukad 06-05-2017] 16-05-2017] 25-05-2017] 30-052017 ,oa 12-06-2017 dks cSBdksa dk vk;kstu fd;k x;kA lfefr }kjk
U;k;ky;hu izdj.kksa ds laca/k esa ijh{k.k djrs gq, lkekU; iz'kklu
foHkkx ea=ky; Hkksiky ds ifji= fnukad 07-10-2016 vuqlkj ftykUrxZr
dk;Zjr nSfud osru Hkksxh deZpkfj;ksa@Jfedksa ds fy, ykxw ^^LFkk;h
dehZ^^ ;kstuk ds rgr fu;fefrdj.k ls oafpr nSfud osru Hkksxh
deZpkfj;ksa dks LFkk;h dehZ ;kstuk rgr Js.kh@osrueku dk ykHk fn;s
tkus ds laca/k es dk;Zokgh dk fu.kZ; fy;k x;kA bl gsrq dk;kZy; Lrj
ij lfefr xfBr dj LFkk;h dehZ ;kstuk ds fdz;kUo;u gsrq nSfud
osru Hkksxh deZpkfj;ksa dks lwpuk i= tkjh djrs gql le{k es lquokbZ
dk volj iznku fd;k tkdj izdj.kksa dk ijh{k.k fd;k x;k %&
1&
Jh ukukHkkm ikfVy nSfud osru Hkksxh deZpkjh dks le{k es
lquk x;k rFkk muds izdj.k ds lexz ijh{k.k mijkar ;g ik;k dh os
nSfud osruHkksxh deZpkjh dysDVj ij fu;qDr gq, Fks vkt fnukad rd
mudks fu;fer ugh fd;k x;k gS ,slh ifjfLFkfr es vr% vk;qDr
vkfnoklh fodkl Hkksiky ds vkns'k dz- 13704&05 fnukad 19-06-2017
ds ifjikyu esa mUgs fu;fer osru dk;ZHkkfjr vkdfLedrk fuf/k ls
fu;fer osrueku ds cjkcj osru dh ik=rk ugh vkus ls Jh ukukHkkm
ikVhy nSfud osruHkksxh deZpkjh dks yafcr osru ,sfj;j Hkqxrku dk
iz'u gh ugh mBrk gSaA vr% ;kfpdkdrkZ dh yafcr ,sfj;j dh ekax
vLohdkj dh tkrh gSA lquokbZ ds nkSjku lacaf/kr }kjk 'kklu dh LFkk;h
dehZ ;kstuk ds rgr osru Js.kh izkIr djus ds laca/k esa vlgefr iznku
dh gSA Jh ikfVy dk i{k lquus ,oa ;kstuk fu;ekuqlkj ijh{k.k djus
ij ftu nSfud osru Hkksfx;ks }kjk vlgefr nh xbZ mUgs iwokZuqlkj
dysDVj nj ij ekuns; dk Hkqxrku djus dh dk;Zokgh djus gsrq
dk;Zokgh lqfuf'pr djsaA
2&
lfefr us ,sls nSfud osruHkksxh deZpkfj;ksa dks le{k esa
mifLFkr gksus ij lquk x;k ftUgksus 'kklu dh uohu LFkk;h dehZ
;kstuk esa lfEEkfyr gksus gsrq lgefr iznku dh xbZ gSA vr% ftu nSfud
osru Hkksfx;ks }kjk LFkk;h dehZ ;kstuk esa lfEefyr gksus dh lgefr
iznku dh xbZ mUgsa LFkkiuk 'kk[kk LFkk;h dehZ ;kstuk ds rgr i`Fkd ls
ijh{k.k dj vkns'k tkjh djus dh dk;Zokgh lqfuf'pr djsaA
vRk% vk;qDr vkfnoklh fodkl Hkksiky ds vkns'k dz 13704&05
fnukad 19-06-2017 ds ifjikyu es rFkk ftyk Lrjh; lfefr }kjk fd;s
x;s ijh{k.k mijkar ftyk cM+okuh vUrxZr dysDVj nj ij dk;Zjr
;kfpdkdrkZ dks dk;ZHkkfjr vkdfLedrk fuf/k ls fu;fer osrueku ds
cjkcj osru dh ik=rk ugh vkus ls nSfud osru Hkksxh Jh ukukHkkÅ
ikVhy nSfud osruHkksxh deZpkjh 'kkldh; ek/;fed fo|ky; [ksfr;k
fodkl[k.M ikulsey ,oa vU; leku izdj.kksa esa iwoZ esa fu/kkZfjr ,sfj;j
jkf'k fd ik=rk ugh vkrh gSA lfefr }kjk ;kfpdkdrkZ ,oa ;kfpdkdrkZ
ds leku vU; deZpkfj;ksa dks Hkh le{k lquk x;k vr% 'kklu }kjk tkjh
fu;e funsZ'kks ij iw.kZ fopkj mijkar nk;j voekuuk izdj.k rFkk vU;
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
leku izdj.kksa es iwoZor dysDVj nj ij osru Hkqxrku djus dh vuqefr
iznku dh tkdj bUgsa iwoZ es fu/kkZfjr ,fj;lZ jkf'k dh Lohd`fr fujLr
dh tkrh gSA ”
Another important aspect of the case is that earlier
also the appellant has approached this Court and an order
was passed on 31.10.2014 in W.P. No.6116/2014 in the case
of Nana Bhau Patil v/s The State of Madhya Pradesh &
Others and as the order passed by this Court was not
complied with, a contempt petition was preferred i.e. Conc
(Civil) No.464/2015 and the same has been dismissed by an
order dated 03.07.2017, however, liberty was granted to the
appellant to challenge the order passed by the respondents
dated 19.06.2017.
The undisputed fact makes it very clear that the
appellant is daily wager and he has not been regularized.
The order passed in Conc (Civil) No.464/2015 dated
03.07.2017 reads as under:“The present case is having a chequered history.
The petitioner before this Court, a daily wager, has filed
Writ Petition ie., W.P.No. 9608/2012 claiming
regularisation as well as regular pay scale on the basis of
some earlier judgments delivered by this Court, to be
more specific Writ Petition No. 3593/2012 (Ravindra
Choudhary Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh and others).
Reliance was also placed upon the judgment delivered by
the apex Court in the case of State of Karnataka Vs. M.
L. Kesari reported in 2010 (9) SCC 247 and in the case
of State of Karnataka Vs. Uma Devi reported in (2006) 4
SCC 1.
The learned Single Judge on 24/6/2013 has
directed the authorities to decide the petitioner's
representation keeping in view the order passed in the
case of Ravindra Choudhary (supra) and also taking into
account the judgment delivered by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in the case of M. L. Kesari (supra). The case of the
petitioner was scrutinised by the respondents and a
Committee was constituted and as many as 70 employees
were given regular pay scale. In the case of the petitioner,
by order dated 10/7/2014 he was also granted regular pay
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
scale. The order has been filed by the respondent as
Annexure R/3 and the same reflects that the petitioner is
a Daily Wager and he has been granted regular pay scale.
After an order was passed granting regular pay scale on
10/7/2014 to the petitioner who was never regularised by
the respondent by passing any order, came up before this
court for grant of regular pay scale on completion of 5
years of service. The second Writ Petition was registered
as W.P.No. 6116/2014 and this Court by order dated
31/10/2014 has directed the respondents to decide the
case of the petitioner keeping in view the judgment
delivered in the case of Kailash Chandra Talware (ie.,
W.A.No. 359/2010 – Kailash Chandra Talware Vs. State
of Madhya Pradesh). It is true that the Division Bench of
this Court in the case of Kailash Chandra (supra) has held
that Kailash Chandra will be entitled for regular pay scale
on completion of 5 years of service. Said Kailash
Chandra has been granted benefit of regular pay scale on
completion of 5 years of service. The judgment delivered
in the case of Kailash Chandra is under review.
The respondents have now decided the case of the
petitioner by passing a speaking order and they have
stated that the petitioner being daily wager who has not
been regularised, is not entitled for regular pay scale after
completion of 5 years service.
This Court has carefully gone through the order
passed by the respondents. It is true that in large number
of cases, regular pay scale has been granted by the
respondents. It is also true that the respondents in the
case of Kailash Chandra who was also a daily wager,
have granted regular pay scale on completion of 5 years
of service.
The judgment delivered by this Court in such
cases are arising out of only two Districts ie., Khargone
and Barwani out of 51 Districts in the State of Madhya
Pradesh. In the State of Madhya Pradesh people are
languishing as daily wages for 20 – 30 years and they are
still getting wages fixed by the Collector on daily wages
basis. They have not been granted permanent status in
other Districts and only in two Districts, on account of
the judgment delivered in one particular case that the
employees are receiving regular pay scale. The petitioner
was also granted regular pay scale, but the petitioner
wanted regular pay scale after completion of 5 years of
service.
It is really strange that in two Districts employees
want regular pay scale after completion of 5 years of
service and in other Districts the circular dated 16/5/07,
8/2/08 and 6/9/08 issued by the State Government
pursuant to the judgment delivered by the Hon'ble apex
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
Court in the case of Uma Devi (supra), are applicable,
meaning thereby, their cases have been scrutinised for
regularisation after completion of minimum 10 years of
service that too subject to various terms and conditions
and they are being granted a sum of Rs.500/- and
Rs.1000/- respectively (now enhanced to Rs.1000/- and
Rs.2000/- respectively) on completion of 10 years and 20
years of service.
The apex Court in a recent case ie., Ram Naresh
Rawat Vs. Shri Ashwini Ray and Ors., Contempt
Petition (Civil) No. 771/2015 while dealing with the
issue of employees who have been conferred permanent
status has arrived at a conclusion that the employees who
have been designated as permanent employees will be
entitled for minimum of the pay scale only. The cases of
the employees before the Hon'ble Supreme Court were
on better footings. They were designated as permanent
employees and they were claiming regular pay scale. In
the case of the petitioner at no point of time they have
been designated as permanent employees. The fact
remains that they are daily wagers. The apex Court in the
case of Ram Naresh Rawat (supra) in paragraphs 10 to 24
has held as under :
Before we consider the respective submissions,
we want to make two observations which are
crucial to the issue involved. These are:
(i) The matter is being examined in the contempt
jurisdiction of this Court. From the chronology of
events given, it would be clear that initially these
petitioners had claimed their classification as
'permanent' to the respective posts. They
succeeded in this attempt and the orders passed
therein in their favour was that they would be
classified as 'permanent' and that they would also
be entitled to pay-scale of permanent posts from
the dates specified in the award given by the
labour court.
In the second round of litigation, out of which
present contempt petitions arise, direction of the
High Court is to grant them pay- scales attached to
the posts to which they are working.
This order has been upheld by this Court as well
inasmuch as Special Leave Petitions filed by the
State Government have been dismissed by
common orders dated 21st January, 2015.
However, there is no specific direction for grant of
increments.
(ii) In order to implement the directions of High
Court, against which special Leave Petitions have
been dismissed, the State Government has passed
order dated 11th March, 2016 vide which the pay-
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
scale of the petitioners has been fixed in the payscale attached to these posts. This has also been
given from the dates to which these petitioners are
held entitled to and on that basis arrears of pay
have also been paid. However, the pay is fixed at
the minimum of the said pay-scales and there is
also stipulation in the said orders dated 11th
March, 2016 that these employees would not be
entitled to increment of salary.
It is clear from the above that the petitioners have
been given pay in the regular pay-scale.
Petitioners, however, have joined issue by
contending that orders dated 11th March, 2016 do
not carry out the complete compliance of the
directions given by the High court that on fixation
of pay in the regular pay-scale the petitioners are
also entitled to increments of salary, as is given to
the regular employees, on annual basis.
Therefore, the question that arise for consideration
is as to whether the petitioners are also entitled to
the increments.
It is not in dispute that the petitioners were
initially engaged on daily wage basis. Their
engagement was also done without following any
selection procedure. It also does not emerge from
record that the initial engagement of these
petitioners was against regular vacancies.
Normally, in such a situation even if these
persons, because of their long service and also on
the assumption that they are discharging the same
duties as discharged by regular employees, such
employees can claim the salary which is being
paid to regular employees holding similar posts on
the principles of 'equal pay for equal work'. This
aspect has exhaustively and authoritatively being
dealt with by this Court in a recent judgment dated
26th October, 2016 in Civil Appeal No. 213 of
2013, titled State of Punjab and Ors. vs. Jagjit
Singh and Ors.[3] and other connected appeals,
though, there is one distinguished factor, viz. the
petitioners herein have been conferred the status
of 'permanent' employees. However, an important
question which arises is as to whether such
'permanent' employees are same as employees
appointed on 'regular' basis or their services stand
regularized. This aspect shall be touched upon and
dealt with a little later. At this stage, reference is
made to the aforesaid judgment in the case of
Jagjit Singh3 for the purpose that even if principle
of 'equal pay for equal work' is applicable and the
pay in the regular pay-scale is admissible to such
employees, these employees would be entitled to
minimum of the regular pay- scale and not the
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
increments. This case is taken note of and
discussed in Jagjit Singh3 in the following
manner:
“36. Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi
[(2006) 4 SCC 1], decided by a five-Judge
Constitution Bench: Needless to mention, that the
main proposition canvassed in the instant
judgment, pertained to regularization of
government servants, based on the employees
having rendered long years of service, as
temporary, contractual, casual, daily-wage or on
ad-hoc basis. It is, however relevant to mention,
that the Constitution Bench did examine the
question of wages, which such employees were
entitled to draw. In paragraph 8 of the judgment, a
reference was made to civil appeal nos. 3595-612
of 1999, wherein, the respondent-employees were
temporarily engaged on daily-wages in the
Commercial Taxes Department. As they had
rendered service for more than 10 years, they
claimed permanent employment
in the
department. They also claimed benefits as were
extended to regular employees of their cadre,
including wages (equal to their salary and
allowances) with effect from the dates from which
they were appointed. Even though the
administrative tribunal had rejected their claim, by
returning a finding, that they had not made out a
case for payment of wages, equal to those engaged
on regular basis, the High Court held that they
were entitled to wages, equal to the salary of
regular employees of their cadre, with effect from
the date from which they were appointed. The
direction issued by the High Court resulted in
payment of higher wages retrospectively, for a
period of 10 and more years. It would also be
relevant to mention, that in passing the above
direction, the High Court had relied on the
decision rendered by a three-Judge bench of this
Court in Dharwad District PWD Literate DailyWage Employees Association v. State of
Karnataka[(1990) 2 SCC 396]. The Constitution
Bench, having noticed the contentions of the rival
parties, on the subject of wages payable to dailywagers, recorded its conclusions as under:“55. In cases relating to service in the commercial
taxes department, the High Court has directed that
those engaged on daily wages, be paid wages
equal to the salary and allowances that are being
paid to the regular employees of their cadre in
government service, with effect from the dates
from which they were respectively appointed. The
objection taken was to the direction for payment
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
from the dates of engagement. We find that the
High Court had clearly gone wrong in directing
that these employees be paid salary equal to the
salary and allowances that are being paid to the
regular employees of their cadre in government
service, with effect from the dates from which
they were respectively engaged or appointed. It
was not open to the High Court to impose such an
obligation on the State when the very question
before the High Court in the case was whether
these employees were entitled to have equal pay
for equal work so called and were entitled to any
other benefit. They had also been engaged in the
teeth of directions not to do so. We are, therefore,
of the view that, at best, the Division Bench of the
High Court should have directed that wages equal
to the salary that is being paid to regular
employees be paid to these daily- wage employees
with effect from the date of its judgment. Hence,
that part of the direction of the Division Bench is
modified and it is directed that these daily-wage
earners be paid wages equal to the salary at the
lowest grade of employees of their cadre in the
Commercial Taxes Department in government
service, from the date of the judgment of the
Division Bench of the High Court. Since, they are
only daily-wage earners, there would be no
question of other allowances being paid to them.
In view of our conclusion, that Courts are not
expected to issue directions for making such
persons permanent in service, we set aside that
part of the direction of the High Court directing
the Government to consider their cases for
regularization. We also notice that the High Court
has not adverted to the aspect as to whether it was
regularization or it was giving permanency that
was being directed by the High Court. In such a
situation, the direction in that regard will stand
deleted and the appeals filed by the State would
stand allowed to that extent. If sanctioned posts
are vacant (they are said to be vacant) the State
will take immediate steps for filling those posts by
a regular process of selection. But when regular
recruitment is undertaken, the respondents in C.A.
Nos. 3595-3612 and those in the Commercial
Taxes Department similarly situated, will be
allowed to compete, waiving the age restriction
imposed for the recruitment and giving some
weightage for their having been engaged for work
in the Department for a significant period of time.
That would be the extent of the exercise of power
by this Court under Article 142 of the Constitution
to do justice to them.” We have extracted the
aforesaid paragraph, so as not to make any
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
inference on our own, but to project the
determination rendered by the Constitution Bench,
as was expressed by the Bench. We have no
hesitation in concluding, that the Constitution
Bench consciously distinguished the issue of pay
parity, from the issue of absorption/regularization
in service. It was held, that on the issue of pay
parity, the High Court ought to have directed, that
the daily-wage workers be paid wages equal to the
salary at the lowest grade of their cadre. The
Constitution Bench expressed the view, that the
concept of equality would not be applicable to the
issue of absorption/regularization in service. And
conversely, on the subject of pay parity, it was
unambiguously held, that daily-wage earners
should be paid wages equal to the salary at the
lowest grade (without any allowances). ” Another
significant reason for referring to the judgment of
Jagjit Singh3 is that the Court culled out the
principles of 'equal pay for equal work' from the
earlier judgments on the subject and collated them
at one place. Further, the Court also drew an
important distinction between the grant of benefit
of 'equal pay for equal work' to temporary
employees on the one hand and the status of
regular employees on the other hand. Insofar as
parameters of principles of 'equal pay for equal
work' deduced by the Court are concerned (para
42), our purpose of deduction stated in sub-para vi
thereof is important, which is reproduced below:
“(vi) For placement in a regular pay-scale, the
claimant has to be a regular appointee. The
claimant should have been selected, on the basis
of a regular process of recruitment. An employee
appointed on a temporary basis, cannot claim to
be placed in the regular pay-scale (see – Orissa
University of Agriculture & Technology Vs.
Manoj K. Mohanty[4]). ” Insofar as distinction
between pay parity and regularisation of service is
concerned, referring to the Constitution Bench
judgment in Uma Devi2, the Court made the
following observations:
“We are of the considered view, that in paragraph
44 extracted above, the Constitution Bench clearly
distinguished the issues of pay parity, and
regularization in service. It was held, that on the
issue of pay parity, the concept of ‘equality’
would be applicable (as had indeed been applied
by the Court, in various decisions), but the
principle of ‘equality’ could not be invoked for
absorbing temporary employees in Government
service, or for making temporary employees
regular/permanent. All the observations made in
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
the above extracted paragraphs, relate to the
subject of regularization/permanence, and not, to
the principle of ‘equal pay for equal work’. As we
have already noticed above, the Constitution
Bench unambiguously held, that on the issue of
pay parity, the High Court ought to have directed,
that the daily-wage workers be paid wages equal
to the salary, at the lowest grade of their cadre.
This deficiency was made good, by making such a
direction. ” Thus, it follows that even if principle
of 'equal pay for equal work' is applicable,
temporary employee shall be entitled to minimum
of the pay-scale which is attached to the post, but
without any increments.
Insofar as petitioners before us are concerned they
have been classified as 'permanent'. For this
reason, we advert to the core issue, which would
determine the fate of these cases, viz., whether
these employees can be treated as 'regular'
employees in view of the aforesaid classification?
In other words, with their classification as
'permanent', do they stand regularized in service?
For this purpose, we would first like to refer to the
provisions of the Madhya Pradesh Industrial
Employment (Standing Orders) Act, 1961 and the
Rules made thereunder known as the Madhya
Pradesh Industrial Employment (Standing Orders)
Rules, 1963. Section 3(c) of the Act defines
“Standing Orders” and as per Section 6, the State
Government may, by notification, apply Standard
Standing Orders to such class of undertakings and
from such date as may be specified therein.
Section 21 empowers the State Government to
make rules to carry out the purposes of the said
Act which are required to be notified. It empowers
the State Government to frame Standard Standing
Orders as well. It is in exercise of powers under
Section 21(1) of the Act that the State
Government has framed Madhya Pradesh
Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Rules,
1963 (hereinafter referred to as the 'Rules').
Annexure to these Rules contains standard
Standing Orders for all undertakings in the State.
Standing Order No. 2 of this Order enumerates
classification of employees which has already
been reproduced above. As per this classification,
an employee would be known as 'permanent
employee' who has completed six months'
satisfactory service in a clear vacancy in one or
more posts whether on probation or otherwise or a
person whose name has been entered in the muster
roll and who is given a ticket of 'permanent
employee'. It follows from the above that merely
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
by putting in six months' satisfactory service, an
employee can be treated as 'permanent employee'.
Rights which would flow to different categories of
employees including 'permanent employee' are not
stipulated in these Rules or even in the parent Act.
It can be gathered from Rule 11 of the said Rules,
which relates to termination of employment, that
in case of a 'permanent employee' one month's
notice or wages for one month in lieu of notice is
required when the employment of a 'permanent
employee' is to be terminated. On the other hand,
no such notice or wages in lieu thereof is needed
to be given to any other category of employees.
Additional obligation casts on the employer is to
record reasons for termination of service in
writing and communicate the same to the
employee.
With this, we advert to the question posed above.
In the first blush, this question appears to be
somewhat puzzling, as to how such a question can
arise because normally an employee who is given
the designation of 'permanent employee' should be
treated as 'regular employee' as well. However,
this puzzle vanishes when we examine the
standing orders, acts and rules in question under
which designation of 'permanent employee' is
acquired. Fortunately for us, we are not trading on
a virgin territory.
This Court has already examine the issue in the
context of these very standing orders of Madhya
Pradesh. In the case of Mahendra L. Jain & Ors. v.
Indore Development Authority & Ors.[5], this
Court analyzed the Standard Standing Order in
question and held that permanent classification
does not amount to regularization, inasmuch as it
was noted that the matter relating to the
recruitment is governed by a separate statute, as
can be seen from the following discussion therein:
“28. The 1961 Act provides for classification of
employees in five categories. The 1973 Act, as
noticed hereinbefore, clearly mandates that all
posts should be sanctioned by the State
Government and all appointments to the said
cadre must be made by the State Government
alone. Even the appointments to the local cadre
must be made by the Authority. The said
provisions were not complied with. It is accepted
that no appointment letter was issued in favour of
the appellants. Had the appointments of the
appellants been made in terms of the provisions of
the Adhiniyam and the Rules framed thereunder,
the respondent Authority was statutorily enjoined
to make an offer of appointment in writing which
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
was to be accepted by the appellants herein. Who
made the appointments of the appellants to the
project or other works carried on by the Authority
is not known. Whether the person making an
appointment had the requisite jurisdiction or not is
also not clear. We have noticed hereinbefore that
in the case of Om Prakash Mondloi, the CEO
made an endorsement to the effect that he may be
tried in daily wages and should be entrusted with
the work of progress collection of ODA work. The
said order is not an “offer of appointment” by any
sense of the term.
xxx xxx xxx
31. The Standing Orders governing the terms and
conditions of service must be read subject to the
constitutional limitations wherever applicable.
Constitution being the suprema lex, shall prevail
over all other statutes. The only provision as
regards recruitment of the employees is contained
in Order 4 which merely provides that the
manager shall within a period of six months, lay
down the procedure for recruitment of employees
and notify it on the notice board on which
Standing Orders are exhibited and shall send copy
thereof to the Labour Commissioner. The matter
relating to recruitment is governed by the 1973
Act and the 1987 Rules. In the absence of any
specific directions contained in the Schedule
appended to the Standing Orders, the statute and
the statutory rules applicable to the employees of
the respondent shall prevail.” The issue came up
again in the case of M.P. State Agro Industries
Development Corporation Ltd. & Anr. v. S.C.
Pandey[6] wherein this Court held that only
because a temporary employee has completed 240
days of work, he would not be entitled to be
regularized in service. The Court also reiterated
that the Standing Orders categorize the nature of
employment and do not classify individual
employees in different post according to the
hierarchy created in the Department and thus
proviso to Rule 2 does not apply to promotions or
regularization in higher grade. We would like to
reproduce following paras from the said
judgment:
“17. The question raised in this appeal is now
covered by a decision of this Court in M.P.
Housing Board v. Manoj Shrivastava [(2006) 2
SCC 702] wherein this Court clearly opined that:
(1) when the conditions of service are governed
by two statutes; one relating to selection and
appointment and the other relating to the terms
and conditions of service, an endeavour should be
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
made to give effect to both of the statutes; (2) a
daily-wager does not hold a post as he is not
appointed in terms of the provisions of the Act
and the Rules framed thereunder and in that view
of the matter he does not derive any legal right;
(3) only because an employee had been working
for more than 240 days that by itself would not
confer any legal right upon him to be regularised
in service; (4) if an appointment has been made
contrary to the provisions of the statute the same
would be void and the effect thereof would be that
no legal right was derived by the employee by
reason thereof.
18. The said decision applies on all fours to the
facts of this case. In Mahendra L. Jain [(2005) 1
SCC 639 : 2005 SCC (L&S) 154] this Court has
categorically held that the Standing Orders
governing the terms and conditions of service
must be read subject to the constitutional and
statutory limitations for the purpose of
appointment both as a permanent employee or as a
temporary employee. An appointment to the post
of a temporary employee can be made where the
work is essentially of temporary nature. In a case
where there existed a vacancy, the same was
required to be filled up by resorting to the
procedures known to law i.e. upon fulfilling the
constitutional requirements as also the provisions
contained in the 1976 Regulations. No finding of
fact has been arrived at that before the respondent
was appointed, the constitutional and statutory
requirements were complied with.
xx xx xx
22. Such appointments, in our opinion, having
regard to the decisions in Mahendra L. Jain
[(2005) 1 SCC 639 : 2005 SCC (L&S) 154] and
Manoj Shrivastava [(2006) 2 SCC 702] must be
made in accordance with extant rules and
regulations. It is also a well-settled legal position
that only because a temporary employee has
completed 240 days of work, he would not be
entitled to be regularised in service. Otherwise
also the legal position in this behalf is clear as
would appear from the decision of this Court
inDhampur Sugar Mills Ltd. v. Bhola Singh
[(2005) 2 SCC 470 : 2005 SCC (L&S) 292] apart
from Mahendra L. Jain [(2005) 1 SCC 639 : 2005
SCC (L&S) 154].” A direct judgment on the
subject is State of M.P. & Ors. v. Lalit Kumar
Verma[7] wherein it was held that a workman
would be entitled to classification as permanent or
temporary employee if the conditions precedent
are satisfied. It was held that the respondent was
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
not appointed against the clear vacancy, he was
not appointed in a permanent post or placed on
probation. This Court, thus, held that working on
daily wages alone would not entitle him to the
status of permanent employee. Para 7 of this
judgment needs to be looked into.
“7. A workman, therefore, would be entitled to
classification of permanent or temporary
employee, if the conditions precedent therefor are
satisfied. The respondent was not appointed
against a clear vacancy. He was not appointed in a
permanent post or placed on probation. He had
also not been given a ticket of permanent
employee. Working on daily wages alone would
not entitle him to the status of a permanent
employee.” It is, thus, somewhat puzzling as to
whether the employee, on getting the designation
of 'permanent employee' can be treated as 'regular'
employee. This answer does not flow from the
reading of the Standing Orders Act and Rules. In
common parlance, normally, a person who is
known as 'permanent employee' would be treated
as a regular employee but it does not appear to be
exactly that kind of situation in the instant case
when we find that merely after completing six
months' service an employee gets right to be
treated as 'permanent employee'. Moreover, this
Court has, as would be noticed now, drawn a
distinction between 'permanent employee' and
'regular employee'.
We may mention, at this stage that this aspect has
come up for consideration, in another context, in
State of Madhya Pradesh and Others vs. Dilip
Singh Patel and Others[8]. That was a case where
similarly situated employees, who were classified
as 'permanent employees' under the Standing
Orders Act, were given minimum of the pay-scale
attached to their posts. However, after the
implementation of Sixth Pay Commission,
benefits thereof were not extended to these
employees. High Court held that they would be
entitled to have their pay fixed as per the revised
scales in accordance with the recommendations of
Sixth Pay Commission which were accepted qua
regular employees. This Court, though, upheld the
orders of the High Court giving them the benefit
of revision of pay-scale pertained to Sixth Pay
Commission, but at the same time made it clear
that they would be entitled to minimum salary and
allowances as per the said revised scales and
would not be entitled to any increments. It was
further held that such increments would be
admissible only after regularisation of their
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
services which regularisation was to take place as
per the seniority list with due procedure.
Following passage from the said judgment, which
captures the aforesaid directions, is quoted
hereunder:
“We have heard learned counsel for the parties
and perused the records. It appears that the
respondents
earlier
moved
before
the
Administrative Tribunal, Gwalior by filing
original applications such as O.A. No. 648 of
1995, O.A. No. 293 of 1991 etc. In compliance of
the orders passed in such original applications, the
Chief Engineer, Yamuna Kachhar, Water
Resources Department, Gwalior (M.P.)( by orders
issued in between April,. 2004 and June, 2004
provided the mi8nimum wages and allowances to
the respondents without increment as per the
Schedule of the pay scale from the date of the
order of the Tribunal. It was further ordered that
the regularization of the daily wages employees
shall be made as per the seniority list with due
procedure and the benefit of increment and other
benefits can only be granted after the
regularisation as per the Rules. It was ordered that
the order of the Court for benefit of minimum
wages and allowances shall be …..........
From the aforesaid facts, it is clear that the
respondents are entitled for minimum wages and
allowance as per the fixed Schedule of the pay
scale but without any increment. In such case, if
the pay scale is revised from time to time
including the pay-scale as revised pursuant to
Sixth Pay Commission, the respondents will be
entitled to minimum wages and allowance as per
the said revised scale without increment. Only
after regularisation of their service, as per
seniority and rules, they can claim the benefit of
increment and other benefits.” From the aforesaid,
it follows that though a 'permanent employee' has
right to receive pay in the graded pay-scale, at the
same time, he would be getting only minimum of
the said pay-scale with no increments. It is only
the regularisation in service which would entail
grant of increments etc. in the pay-scale.
In view of the aforesaid, we do not find any
substance in the contentions raised by the
petitioners in these contempt petitions. We are
conscious of the fact that in some cases, on earlier
occasions, the State Government while fixing the
pay scale, granted increments as well. However, if
some persons are given the benefit wrongly, that
cannot form the basis of claiming the same relief.
It is trite that right to equality under Article 14 is
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
not in negative terms (See Indian Council of
Agricultural Research & Anr. v. T.K.
Suryanarayan & Ors.[9]).
Keeping in view the judgment of the apex Court,
this Court is of the opinion that the respondents were
justified in passing the impugned order. The petitioner is
still a daily wager. There is no order brought on record
by either side regularising the petitioner on the post he is
working and, therefore, this Court is of the considered
opinion that no contempt is made out in the matter.
However, liberty is granted to the petitioner to challenge
the order passed by the respondents dt. 19/6/2017, if so
advised. The repercussions of the order passed by this
Court will affect large number of employees in the entire
State of Madhya Pradesh and, therefore, a uniform
policy should be followed in respect of daily wagers
working in the State of Madhya Pradesh by the State
Government Departments. The Departments shall ensure
that the policy framed by the State Government are
strictly adhered to.
The present contempt petition and the connected
contempt stand dismissed.”
The aforesaid order passed in the contempt petition
makes it very clear that in the State of Madhya Pradesh
only in respect of two districts, there is some order in
respect of some daily wager for granting pay-scale. The
daily wager employees are claiming regular pay-scale,
which has not been granted to any other individual in the
entire State of Madhya Pradesh. Merely because some
persons have been granted regular pay-scale, on the ground
of negative equality, the question of grant of regular payscale to backdoor entrants, keeping in view the the
judgment delivered in the case of State of Karnataka v/s
Uma Devi reported in (2006) 4 SCC 1, does not arise.
The State Government has issued various executive
instructions pursuant to the judgment delivered in the case
of Uma Devi (supra) and after completion of ten years and
20 years of service, extra emoluments are given to the daily
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
wager.
The State Government has also issued executive
instruction for granting them permanent status and in light
of the judgment delivered in the case of Ram Naresh
Rawat v/s Shri Ashwini Ray & Others (Conc (Civil)
No.771/2015) and in case, they are conferred permanent
status, they shall be entitled for only minimum of the payscale. In those circumstances, the learned Single Judge has
dismissed the writ petition.
No statutory provision of law has been brought to the
notice of this Court by the appellant, which entitles him for
grant of regular pay-scale even though he is not the regular
employee. For appointment to the regular post, there is a
prescribed procedure under the law, there are circulars
issued by the State Government and the process has to be
followed. The appellant's case was certainly considered by
the department for regularization and the order passed by
the learned Single reveals that the State Government in the
counter affidavit has categorically stated that as and when,
vacancies are available, the case of the appellant shall be
considered for regularization and in those circumstances,
the learned Single Judge, as the appellant was not the
regular employee, has dismissed the writ petition.
In the considered opinion of this Court, as no
statutory provision of law has been pointed by the appellant
and as the appellant is not a regular employee who is
entitled for grant of regular pay-scale, the question of
granting him relief and setting the order passed by the
learned Single Judge dated 01.10.2018 does not arise.
Writ Appeal Nos.122/2019 & Other Identical Matters
The appellant does not enjoy special status merely
because, he posted in a particular district. All daily wager in
the State of Madhya Pradesh are to be treated at par and the
judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court delivered in the cases
of Uma Devi (supra) and Ram Naresh Rawat (supra) is
applicable in respect of all daily wager.
In the considered opinion of this Court, the learned
Single Judge was justified in dismissing the writ petition.
No case for interference is made out in the matter.
Resultantly, the admission is declined.
The order passed by this Court in the present case
shall govern the connected writ appeal also, and therefore,
the connected writ appeals also stand dismissed.
Let a copy of this order be kept in the connected writ
appeals also.
Certified copy as per rules.
(S.C. SHARMA)
JUDGE
Ravi
Date: 2019.08.21 17:52:27 +05'30'
(SHAILENDRA SHUKLA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review